Abstract Previous reports of Gilvossius setimanus (De Kay, 1844) from the Gulf of Mexico have been based on a population of small specimens from deep offshore continental shelf waters off Texas and larger specimens from shorelines and shallow embayments of western Florida. The offshore population, herein designated Gilvossius fredericqae n. sp., reaches sexual maturity at much smaller size than does Gilvossius setimanus s.s. from the U.S. Atlantic seaboard, a species from which it differs in a number of morphological characters. While maturing at a similar size to G. setimanus s.s., a western Florida population, herein designated Gilvossius howellorum n. sp., differs from it in the 16S mt gene sequence, and from both it and the offshore species in morphology. An updated synonymy and rediagnosis of G. setimanus s.s. herein accompany descriptions of the two new species.