Comparison of methods for quantification of nitrifying bacteria

ABSTRACT

The quantification of nitrifying bacteria is of utmost importance for monitoring biological treatment systems designed to promote nitrification. In this study, 15 activated sludge samples were analyzed in order to quantify nitrifying bacteria by two different methods: the most-probable number (MPN); and the fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). The results suggest that there was a tendency to obtain different values for ammonia-oxidizing bacteria by MPN compared to FISH. However, statistical analysis of these data revealed that the difference found between the two techniques was not significant, indicating that both can be used for quantification of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria. For nitrite-oxidizing bacteria it was not possible to make this comparison, since the bacterial genera that were being determined in each technique were likely different. Thus, MPN and FISH techniques proved to be relatively simple and suitable for quantification of nitrifying microorganisms in sludge samples, each of them with advantages and limitations.

Keywords:
ammonia-oxidizing bacteria; nitrite-oxidizing bacteria; fluorescence in situ hybridization; activated sludge; most probable number