Effect of Flame Spray Deposition Parameters on The Microstructure of Al 2 O 3-13 % TiO 2 Coatings Applied Onto 7075 Aluminum Alloy

In this work, the effect of flame spraying parameters on physical, structural and microstructural characteristics of Al2O3 13 wt.% TiO2 (AT-13) coatings were studied. NiCrAl and AT-13 feedstock powders were used for spraying a bond coat (BC) and a top coat (TC), respectively, onto a 7075 aluminum alloy substrate. The effect of acetylene-to-oxygen ratio and the spraying distance on surface roughness, crystalline phases, porosity and thickness of top coat were analyzed. The results showed that for the evaluated spraying conditions, the volumetric oxy-fuel ratio had significant effects on roughness, porosity and crystalline phases of the coating. On the other hand, the spraying distance affected the thickness of the coating and did not influence the formation of Al2TiO5 phase; no significant effect of spraying distance on roughness was observed. The results showed that an acetylene: oxygen volumetric ratio of 1:2.5 is preferable to obtain higher melting of the ceramic powders and therefore a denser coating with major content of γ-Al2O3 crystalline phase.


Introduction
The competitiveness of ceramic coatings has evolved over the years thanks to developments in thermal spraying coatings, processes and devices used for this purpose, as well as the increase in the number and variety of applications including thermal protection of components located in the hot gas path of gas turbines, improvement of wear resistance of automotive engine devices and medical implants, among others 1 .Regarding thermal spraying processes, flame spraying is the oldest and most used in industrial applications 2 .However, the development of new applications for ceramic coatings manufactured by Atmospheric Plasma Spraying (APS) has increased notably in recent years due to the higher temperature and speed of the particles achieved in this process, which allows manufacturing denser and most adhesive coatings 3 .Consequently, a reduction in the number of investigations carried out to develop new coatings and to improve the performance of coatings deposited by flame spraying is evident despite its lower operation cost, ease of use and flexibility for selecting a range of flame temperature profiles from the combustible/comburent ratio 4 ; all these, depending on the feedstock materials and feed rates.
Aluminum alloys are preferred as structural components due to their high strength-to-weight ratio.However, they have low wear resistance which limits their use 5 .Alloys such as the 7075-T6 are widely used for aeronautic applications, but depending of the environmental conditions, this material may suffer several types of corrosion damage.Consequently, surface protection of 7075-T6 alloy with the aid of thermal spraying processes has been increasingly studied, being Ti, Al 2 O 3 , ZrO 2 and TiO 2 some of the materials commonly chosen to provide protection against corrosion and wear 5,6 .
The thermally-sprayed AT-13 coatings are widely used in tribological applications given the variety of mechanical properties that can be obtained as a function of the stable and metastable phases present in the microstructure and the morphological features of the coatings 7 .Typical phases found in AT-coatings include α-Al 2 O 3 , γ-Al 2 O 3 , TiO 2 and Al 2 TiO 5 8 .Aluminum titanate (Al 2 TiO 5 ) is desirable for applications involving high temperature due to its low thermal expansion coefficient (1.5x10 -6 K -1 ), low thermal conductivity (0.9-1.5 Wm -1 K -1 ), low Young's modulus (10-20 GPa) and high melting point (1860 ± 10ºC) 9,10 .Additionally, Al 2 TiO 5 has been used by the industry because it has high thermal shock and corrosion resistances (10) .Rutile (TiO 2 ) also exhibits good corrosion resistance combined with excellent chemical stability in aqueous environments 11 while α-Al 2 O 3 is a good choice for wear and corrosion aplications due to its high hardness and chemical inertness 12 .For use in thermal spraying processes, the stability of aluminum titanates is improved by adding modifying agents such as SiO 2 , MgO and Fe 2 O 3 to the powder 13 , which hinders the decomposition of the phase at high temperature.Currently, highly improved AT-13 coatings are being manufactured from Materials Research nanoagglomerated feedstock powders in order to obtain a bimodal structure constituted by fully and partially melted splats, which notably improve the mechanical and tribological properties of the coating as reported by 14 and 15 .
Phase contents and porosity are determinant for the wear and corrosion resistances of AT-13 coatings as previously stated by Aruna et al 1 , Ibrahim 16 and Yussoff et al 17 , among others.Accordingly, establishing proper thermal spray deposition conditions is key to prevent premature failure of the coatings, which are commonly used to protect surfaces against elevated temperature and/or harsh environments.This work studied the effect of the spraying distance and the oxygen:acetylene volumetric ratio on the microstructure of coatings composed of NiCrAlY as Bond Coat (BC) and Al 2 O 3 -13%wt.TiO 2 as Top Coat (TC), with the purpose of improving the combined response of the surface to mechanical, thermal and chemical requirements.The characterization of the coatings included crystalline phase identification and quantification, surface texture assessment and detailed analysis of morphological features such as unmelted particles, splats/lamellae, pores and cracks.

Powders characterization
The particle size distribution of feedstock powders Metco 6221 (Al 2 O 3 -13 wt.% TiO 2 ) and Amdry 510 (NiCrAlY) was determined using a Malvern Master Sizer 2000 analyzer.Morphological characterization of feedstock powders was made in a JEOL 6701 SEM.Additionally, the identification of the crystalline phases was carried out by X-Ray diffraction (XRD) using a PANAlytical Empyrean III series Alpha 1 model 2012 diffractometer with CuKα radiation and X'Pert Pro MDPsoftware.

Flame spraying process
Prior to the spraying process, the AA7075 substrates were cleaned in ultrasonic bath with isopropyl alcohol then the surface was corundum blasted and finally cleaned again in the ultrasonic bath with isopropyl alcohol for removing impurities.This procedure allowed obtaining surfaces with Ra = 6.33 ± 0.84 µm, Rt = 53.86 ± 10.10 µm and Rpc = 72.42 ± 8.84 cm -1 .
The bond and top coatings were deposited with a Castolin-Eutectic TeroDyn® 2000 system torch, in which the powders were fed using a bowl feeder TUMAC CHTB-10 and nitrogen as carrier gas.The preheating temperature of substrates was measured using a RayTek MI infrared sensor.The spraying parameters controlled during thermal spraying processes carried out to manufacture the coatings are listed in Table 1.
In order to study the effect of standoff distance and acetylene:oxygen volumetric ratio on roughness, porosity, thickness, and formation of crystalline phases in the AT-13 top coatings, the spraying distance (110 and 140 mm), and the acetylene:oxygen volumetric ratios (1:1.7 and 1:2.5) were selected according to a factorial design of experiments 2 2 with three replicas per spraying condition and a central point at 125 mm of spraying distance and a flame gases ratio at 1:2.1, as shown in Table 2.A confidence level of 98% was taken for the statistical evaluation of the experiments.Thirteen experimental runs were executed randomly to verify the repeatability of the experiment and the uniform distribution of experimental error.The p-value was also considered to evaluate the significance of the effects on roughness and phases formation.Porosity and thickness of the coating were also studied by means of effects plots to estimate the tendencies of those characteristics in the coatings.

Coatings characterization
Surface roughness of the BC and TC layers was determined using a Mitutoyo Surftest SV-3000; six profiles of each sample were obtained.The measurements were made with five cut-off lengths of 2.5 mm for a total sampling length of 12.5 mm.The surface roughness parameters Ra, Rt, RSM, Rpc and power spectral density (PSD), whose definition can be found elsewhere 18 , were measured after all experiments.
X-ray diffraction of the coatings were carried out using an X'Pert Pro MPD.The diffractograms of the coatings manufactured according to each spraying condition were compared to confirm the repeatability of the experiments.Crystalline phases present in the coatings were quantified by Rietveld refinement using MAUD (Materials Analysis Using Diffraction) software, always verifying that Rwp < 10%.A seventh degree polynomial was used to model the background noise of the diffractograms while scale factor, crystal structure, parameters for texture, strain analysis, among other parameters, were refined using from 9 to 12 iterations for each one.Amorphous phase content was also computed through Le Bail approximation for the silica glass.The Rietveld method approximates the amorphous phase to a nanocrystalline solid where the long-range order is lost 19 and the Le Bail approximation has been used to analyze the semicrystalline pattern of several ceramics including α-Al 2 O 3 20 .
Structural characterization of the coatings were performed using SEM Jeol 5910LV.The cross section of the coatings was also analyzed from samples prepared according to ASTM E 1920-03(2014) standard; porosity of the BC and TC was measured in the cross section using digital image processing according to the ASTM E2109-01 standard.For the BC, oxides were quantified using the red histogram in the color thresholding process in order to exclude them of readings carried out to measure the porosity.The thickness of the coatings was measured through optical microscopy.

Feedstock powders
The Amdry 510 and Metco 6221 powders showed spheroidal morphology.Amdry 510 is compact as those produced by gas atomization, which is a process widely Al 2 TiO 5 and low quantities of TiO 2 -rutile were identified in Metco 6221 powder after XRD analyses.Metallic alloys containing the phases identified in Amdry 510 powder are normally used to apply the bond coat in components for stationary and aircraft gas turbines thanks to their high mechanical resistance despite their lower resistance to

Bond coat characterization
The XRD results of NiCrAlY coating and powders are shown in Figure 1.Rietveld analysis of as-sprayed BC with an Rwp of 6.54% showed 99.7% of phase γ'-Ni 3 Al and only 0.3% of β-AlNi.No γ phase was identified in the as-sprayed used to manufacture metal alloy powders 21 .In the Metco 6221, each particle is constituted by several agglomerated submicron-particles, which is consistent with manufacturing by agglomeration and sintering.The particle size distribution of the powders is shown in Table 3.
The phases identified in feedstock powders and their quantities are summarized in Table 4. γ-Ni,Cr, γ'-Ni 3 Al and β-AlNi were found in Amdry 510 powder while α-Al 2 O 3 , BC as reported previously by 24 .A slight peak shift was also observed, which can be related to quenching stresses produced when the particles reached the substrate and rapidly solidified.In flame spraying process, unlike HVOF process, aluminum gets oxidized extensively forming Al 2 O 3 during deposition, contributing also to the peaks shift as reported by Rana et al 24 .
The surface morphology of the bond coat exhibited splats produced from highly flattened particles and splashing as shown in Figure 2a (yellow enclosure), which indicates that in-flight particles were sufficiently heated and arrived well melted to the surface on which they were deposited.Despite the diffractograms did not show strong evidences of oxides likes Al 2 O 3 , the BC layer showed oxides content of 18 ± 1.90% and porosity of 6.73 ± 0.98%.Likewise, the cross-section of the BC layer Figure 2b exhibited oxidized areas around lamellae which were produced during the spraying process due to the slightly oxidizing combustion flame used for the deposition of this layer.The oxidation of some elements present in the thermally sprayed metallic powder NiCrAlY are reported by Rana et al 24,25 where alumina is the oxide predominantly produced, which increases the oxidation resistance of the coating.The arithmetic average roughness Ra of the bond coat was 9.4 ± 1.8 µm.

Analysis of crystalline phases in the microstructure
The X-Ray diffractograms of the AT-13 coatings obtained with different deposition parameters are shown in Figure 3.The assumptions of normality and constant variance of the phase contents data were verified through the normal probability and residuals plots.To check for the normality of the residuals (i.e. the fact that residuals follow a normal distribution), the normal probability plot is presented in figure 4a with the data obtained for γ-Al 2 O 3 .Residuals follow a straight line, which is a strong indication that the assumption of its normality is valid.Furthermore, the plot of residuals vs fitted values Figure 4b shows a random scattering of residuals around zero, which verifies the assumption of constant variance of the experiments.These facts were also observed in the evaluation of the assumptions of normality and constant variance for the other crystalline and amorphous phases found in the samples.
Quantitative phases analysis of the coatings evidenced a higher content of γ-Al 2 O 3 in coatings S3 and S4, while S1 and S2 coatings were constituted predominantly by α-Al 2 O 3 and some quantities of Al 2 TiO 5 which are residual phases that were present in feedstock powders.Coatings S3 and S4 sprayed with a combustion ratio of 1:2.5 showed amorphous content of 47.20% and 42.35% respectively, while the amorphous content of coatings S1 and S2 were 12.26% and 10.58% respectively (Figure 5d).These results show that when the particles absorb more energy in the flame, higher amorphous phases are obtained.However, the amorphous percentage estimated can be affected also by the presence of γ-Al 2 O 3 which is a nanosized crystalline phase 26 , whose volume fraction is higher in coatings S3 and S4.
The plots of the effects of spraying parameters vs phases present in the coatings are shown in Figure 5.A p-value < 0.02 was obtained for the effect of the combustion ratio on the α-Al 2 O 3 phase content in the coatings.It means that this parameter had an important effect in α-Al 2 O 3 phase transformation during the spraying process.Regarding the effect of spraying distance on α-Al 2 O 3 transformation, the p-value was 0.485; this means that this parameter did not have a significant impact on the α-Al 2 O 3 transformation; to show graphically this result, it can be seen in figure 5a that for a fixed combustion gases ratio, variations on spraying distance did not produce significant changes on the α-Al 2 O 3 phase transformation.For example, with a fixed combustion ratio 1:1.7, an increase of the spraying distance from 110 mm to 140 mm only produces a decrease of 5% in the mean content of α-Al 2 O 3 .It is important to note also in Figure 5a that the deviation bars of α-Al 2 O 3 content in both combustion ratio are overlapping for changes in spraying distance, this is the main graphically aspect that evidence why this parameter did not have a significant effect on this phase.
For the combined effect of the spraying distance and combustion ratio on α-Al 2 O 3 transformation, the p-value was 0.545; this means that it did not have a significant impact on this phase transformation.The combined effect indicates that when a variation of combustion ratio is made there is a relevant change in the amount of α-Al 2 O 3 with variations of spraying distance, same logic is applicated with the other phases analyzed.Figure 5 a shows that it does not matter the combustion ratio set, for both, 1:1.7 and 1:2.5, changes in spraying distance did not produce important variation in the α-Al 2 O 3 phase content.
Figure 5b shows that the coating deposited with a combustion gases ratio 1:2.5 exhibited a major formation of γ-Al 2 O 3 as a consequence of the transformation of α-Al 2 O 3 from the feedstock powders during the solidification at high cooling rates of the splats, as explained in detail by Góral et al 27 and Vargas et al 28 .This is consistent with the reduction of α-Al 2 O 3 phase content observed in figure 5a for the same combustion ratio.
With respect to the γ-Al 2 O 3 formation, a p-value < 0.02 for the effects of the combustion gases ratio was obtained while the spraying distance yielded a p-value = 0.080.This means that the combustion gases ratio had a significant effect on the γ-Al 2 O 3 formation and the spraying distance did not had effect on the formation of this phase; besides, for the combined effect of spraying parameters evaluated, a p-value=0.911evidencing that for both combustion ratios, variations in spraying distances did not have a significant effect on the formation of γ-Al 2 O 3 .
The increase in γ-Al 2 O 3 at ratio 1:2. 26.This can be verified in Figure 5c, where for a fixed distance, the Al 2 TiO 5 content is lower at combustion gases ratio 1:2.5 with respect to 1:1.7.The eutectoid reaction of Al 2 TiO 5 was facilitated because the particles had a higher dwelling time inside the flame during the spraying process, allowing them to absorb a higher energy to reach the temperatures of decomposition.For the Al 2 TiO 5 , p-value<0.02was obtained for the effect of the combustion gases ratio meaning that it had a significant effect on the eutectoid reaction of this phase during the spraying process; on the other hand, a p-value = 0.573 was obtained for both the spraying distance and its combined effect with combustion gases ratio, so it can be said that no important effect of such variables on the decomposition of this phase is expected.
With respect to the amorphous content in the coating, a p-value < 0.02 obtained for the effect of combustion on this phase indicated that it had an important effect on this variable response, while the spraying distance did not affect it according to the p-value=0.163obtained.The combined effect of spraying distance and combustion ratio did not have significand impact on the amorphous content as indicated by a p-value of 0.478.
Curvature analysis of the effect of spraying parameters on phase formation shows p-value of 0.392 and 0.019 for α-Al 2 O 3 and γ-Al 2 O 3 respectively, revealing that there is not curvature in the response of α-Al 2 O 3 , and a marginal curvature in the response for γ-Αl 2 O 3 phase; on the other hand, p-value for curvature of Al 2 TiO 5 was 0.001, this suggests that there is curvature in the response of this phase with respect to the spraying parameters inside the experimental region evaluated.

Roughness, morphology and porosity of the coatings
Normal probability plot and residuals vs fitted plots for the Rms roughness parameter are shown in Figure 6.It can be seen from Figure 6a that residuals follow a straight line while Figure 6b shows a random scattering of residuals about zero.This means that there is no evidence of non-normality and non-constant variance in the experiments; these facts were also observed for the other roughness parameters evaluated.
Roughness parameters of the TC are shown in the effects plots of flame spraying parameters onto surface roughness (Figure 7).A p-value = 0.008 (<0.02) for the effect of the combustion gases ratio on the surface roughness was obtained, while the p-values of spraying distance and the combined effect of the spraying distance and combustion gases ratio were 0.386 and 0.964 respectively (both >0.02).This means that only combustion gases ratio had a significant effect on the coatings surface roughness.On the other hand, curvature analysis shows p-values of 0.199, 0.030, 0.021 and 0.678 for RSm, Ra, Rt, and Rpc parameters respectively, this mean that there was not curvature in the response of the roughness parameters studied.Higher roughness values were obtained with a combustion gases ratio of 1:1.7, and this is because the coatings S1 and S2 had a higher number of unmelted particles than that of the coatings S3 and S4 sprayed with combustion gases ratio of 1:2.5 as verified by means of SEM analysis whose results are shown in Figure 8. Figure 7 also shows that with a fixed combustion gases ratio, variations of spraying distance had not a considerable impact onto surface roughness; On the other hand, when the spraying distance was fixed, variations of combustion gases ratio had a high impact onto surface roughness.According to the measured roughness parameters, a smoother surface can be obtained with the combustion gases ratio used for manufacturing S3 and S4 coatings.Figure 8 shows that effectively, coatings S3 and S4 presented a lower number of unmelted and partially-melted particles on their surfaces, this means that the AT-13 particles reached higher temperatures with a combustion gases ratio of 1:2.5 in their flying time during the spraying process.
Figure 9 shows the cross section of the applied coatings.The coatings sprayed with combustion ratio 1:2.5 (Figures 9a  and 9b) present a denser microstructure because the particles reach higher temperatures and consequently experience more softening and deformation when they strike the substrate's surface.This leads to the formation of flatter lamellae in comparison with the coatings sprayed with combustion ratio 1:1.7, whose cross section shows a larger porosity due to the presence of a greater number of unmelted and partially melted particles (figures 9c and 9d).Furthermore, microstructure defects such as pores and cracks reduce the bonding strength between splats, which in turn affects other properties including hardness and abrasion resistance 29 .
The size of unmelted and partially-molten particles was measured through SEM and the data were used to perform spectral analysis as shown in Figure 10 and Table 5.The increase of the minimum and maximum diameters of semimolten particles with respect to d(0.1) and d(0.9) of feedstock powders was due to the deformation of the particles during The effect of the spraying parameters on the thickness of the TC layer is shown in Figure 11.An important effect of the spraying distance on the thickness of the coating can be appreciated.The use of a spraying distance of 110 mm led to thinner coatings when compared to the coatings sprayed with 140 mm distance, this is due to higher deceleration and slight cooling of the particles in the latter case, which in turn causes less deformation of the particles when they impact the substrate.Consequently, slower particles produce thicker lamellae and the overall thickness of the coating is larger.Figure 9 illustrates this effect.Figures 9 and 9d show thicker lamellae than those observed in figures 9a and 9c.It can be seen also that with a fixed spraying distance, variations in the combustion gases ratio did not contribute strongly to changes in the thickness of the coatings.
The effect of the spraying parameters on the porosity of the coatings is reported in Figure 12.Coatings S3 and S4 had lower porosity values than S1 and S2 coatings and close to the values reported by 30 for an AT-13 coating deposited by APS, which is a process with higher enthalpy.Figure 11 shows that variations in spraying distance when the combustion gases ratio is fixed at 1:2.5 did not have and important effect on the porosity of the coatings; however, with a combustion gases ratio fixed at 1:1.7, distance variation affects the coatings porosity incrementing it in the coatings deposited with a spraying distance of 140 mm.This may the impact against the substrate.On the other hand, the minimum diameter of unmelted particles measured in the surface coating was 30.44 µm, which means that the heat produced in the flame is enough to melt particles smaller than approximately 30 µm.The Power Spectral Density (PSD) plot in Figure 9 shows a higher intensity in the frequency range from 17 to 23 mm -1 for the coatings sprayed with a combustion gases ratio of 1:1.7; this verifies that a higher quantity of semi-molten particles with sizes between 43 and 59 µm can be found along the roughness profile measured in the S1 and S2 coatings with respect to S3 and S4 coatings.In the frequency range between 25 and 33 mm -1 the intensity was lower in the spectra corresponding to coatings sprayed with combustion gases ratio of 1:2.5, which indicates that  also be related to the higher deceleration of the particles with the distance, which leads to poor piling and adhesion between particles in the coating.

Analysis of the quality of the flame
In general terms, it was observed that S3 and S4 coatings exhibited lower values of the roughness parameters and porosity; XRD analysis also showed highest formation of γ-Al 2 O 3 and also highest decomposition of Al 2 TiO 5 for those coatings.These results indicated that particles absorbed more heat during the spraying process at the flame produced from combustion gases ratio of 1:2.5, than that produced from 1:1.7 combustion gases ratio; despite the higher temperature of flame from 1:2.5 combustion gases ratio is lower than that produced from 1:1.7 combustion gases as demonstrated by Fauchais et al 2 .
Besides the temperature reached by the flame, which is shown in figure 13 for several oxy/acetylene ratios, the length of the hot zone of the flame obtained with different comburent/combustible ratios must be considered since it plays a key role in the heating of the particles.At atmospheric pressure, the stoichiometric chemical reaction of combustion is obtained by feeding the torch with a volumetric mixture of acetylene and oxygen in proportions around 1:1.7, producing a flame whose primary zone reaches the maximum possible temperature, which is close to 3170 ºC.When an additional quantity of oxygen is fed to the torch, part of the heat produced by the combustion is consumed in heating up the excess gas because it does not react in the process, then the temperature of flame decreases as it has been shown by Fauchais et al 2 .Also, Góral showed that the excess of oxygen in a combustion reaction contribute to dilute the combustion products and causes elongation of the primary zone of the flame and therefore a change of his temperature profile, providing the particles a longer dwelling time in the hottest zone of the flame when combustion gases ratio is 1:2.5 compared to when the combustion gases ratio is 1:1.7 31 .

Conclusions
The effect of the volumetric combustion gases ratio and spraying distance on structural and microstructural characteristics of the Al 2 O 3 -13 wt.%TiO 2 coatings manufactured by flame spraying process was studied.
The most significant effect over the formation of γ-Al 2 O 3 crystalline phase was given by the combustion gases ratio.Higher levels of crystalline phase formation were achieved when the combustion gases ratio was 1:2.5, which is due to the elongation of the hottest zone of the oxyacetylene flame produced by the excess of oxygen in the combustion reaction.On the other hand, Only combustion gases ratio had a significant effect on α-Al 2 O 3 formation and Al 2 TiO 5 dissolution.
Only the combustion gases ratio had a significant effect on the roughness parameters of the coating.Lower surface roughness values and lower porosities were obtained for the combustion gases ratio of 1:2.5 because of the longer dwelling time of the particles in the hottest zone of the flame.
The thickness of the coatings was not affected by the combustion gases ratio; however, thicker coatings were produced when the spraying distance was larger at a fixed combustion gases ratio.

Figure 1 .
Figure 1.XRD of NiCrAlY coating.a) As-sprayed BC, b) Feedstock powder For each spraying condition, the diffractograms of the three replicas are superimposed.The AT-13 coatings S3 and S4 (figures 3a and 3b) were composed of cubic γ-Al 2 O 3 and rhombohedral α-Al 2 O 3 .The coatings S1 and S2 (Figure 3c and Figure 3d) showed γ-Al 2 O 3 , α-Al 2 O 3 and orthorhombic Al 2 TiO 5 .TiO 2 -rutile, which was present in feedstock powder, was not found in any of the deposited coatings.

Figure 2 .
Figure 2. Microstructure of the Bond Coat.a) surface morphology in which an individual splat is shown within the yellow circle, b) cross section morphology in which an individual lamella is shown within the red oval

Figure 4 .Figure 5 .
Figure 4. Residual plots for γ-Al 2 O 3 .a) normal probability plot, b) residual vs fitted values 5 was affected also by Al 2 TiO 5 thermal instability in a range of temperatures between 800 and 1300°C where an eutectoid reaction occurs and decomposes it into α-Al 2 O 3 and TiO 2 as suggested by Papitha et al 9 and Sarkar et al 10 ; During the spraying process, α-Al 2 O 3 and TiO 2 melt together and rapidly solidify to form γ-Al 2 O 3 containing dissolved TiO 2

Figure 6 .
Figure 6.Residual plots for RSM roughness parameter.a) normal probability plot, b) residual vs fitted plot

Table 1 .
Spraying parameters used to manufacture the coatings

Table 2 .
Spraying parameters used to manufacture the Top Coats according to the factorial Design of Experiments.

Table 4 .
Phase analysis of feedstock powders 23lfidation when compared to the CoCrAlY bond coatings22.On the other hand, α-Al 2 O 3 -13 wt.% TiO 2 materials with phases as those constituting Metco 6221 powder provides good tribological properties due to their high hardness, which help withstanding severe abrasive wear conditions23.

Table 5 .
Attributes of interest after PSD analysis.