Effect of Experimental Parameters on Wear Response of Thermally Sprayed Carbide Based Coatings

Friction and abrasive wear response of WC-12 Co and Cr3C2-25 NiCr coatings was studied. Abrasive wear experiments were conducted with SiC abrasive particles with varying load and sliding speeds. The results were analyzed using SEM, XRD and XPS observations of worn surfaces, wear debris and worn out abrasive paper. Friction coefficient diminished with rise in sliding speed and increased for increase in load while wear rates decreased for increasing sliding speed for both coatings. WC-12 Co coating had better wear resistance than Cr3C2-25 NiCr coating while Cr3C2-25 NiCr coating displayed lower friction coefficient. The variation in wear rate and friction response of coatings was due to combined effects of adhesion, abrasion and tribo oxidation effects. The composition of tribo films was strongly influenced by load and sliding velocity and altered friction and wear response of the coatings.


Introduction
Thermally sprayed cermet coatings based on hard carbide phases like WC, and Cr 3 C 2 are increasingly used for mitigation against high temperature, wear and corrosion to increase life of engineering components. High Velocity Oxy Fuel (HVOF) sprayed WC-Co and Cr 3 C 2 -NiCr coatings are suitable for different wear conditions due to higher hardness and good toughness. The major applications of carbide based coatings are in automobile, aerospace, power generation, hydraulic, steel, mining and paper industries. Typical abrasive wear applications include landing gears of aircrafts, fans used in cement industries, sand pumps and tool bits etc. [1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9] . Coating composition, microstructure and mechanical properties are crucial factors influencing their tribological behaviour.
Carbide dissolution and formation of brittle carbides during thermal spraying process had significant influence on wear tribological behaviour of coatings 1,[10][11][12][13][14] . HVOF process is the best method to deposit WC-Co and Cr 3 C 2 -NiCr type coatings as compared to other thermally sprayed techniques (e.g. plasma spray, detonation gun, flame spray etc.) [15][16][17][18][19] . High particle velocity and low flame temperature in HVOF process leads to low decomposition of WC and Cr 3 C 2 particles, which has been reported beneficial for wear resistance of WC-Co and Cr 3 C 2 -NiCr coatings 16,20,21 . The initial coating powder morphology, carbide particle size, volume fraction of carbide, binder phase and coating spray parameters (e.g. velocity, temperature, pressure, fuel type) affect structure and properties of the coating 4,5,20,[22][23][24][25][26][27][28] . WC-17Co coatings with fine carbide grain size distribution had lower abrasive wear resistance due to more decomposition of WC into W 2 C which is detrimental for abrasive wear resistance, as reported earlier 24 . Yang et al. reported that wear rate was more sensitive to carbide size rather than the hardness and toughness of the coating 29 . Cr 3 C 2 -NiCr coating having nano crystalline grains (CNG) exhibited lower friction coefficient around than conventional grains coating (CGC) which was due to different material removal mechanisms 30 .
The assessment of performance of thermally sprayed coatings is complicated due to different response shown by hard particles and soft matrix phase, under wear situations involving solid particles 31 . The important factors which influence abrasive wear behaviour of carbide based coatings are carbide particle size, hardness of carbide phase, nature of binder apart from abrasive particle properties; size, shape and hardness. The important abrasive wear mechanisms in WC and Cr 3 C 2 based coatings involve fatigue, binder extrusion, carbide pull out, carbide fracture, intergranular cracking and splat fracture severity of which depends on abrasive wear situations 9,19,32,33 . Tribo film formation during abrasive wear process also alters wear and friction response of thermally sprayed cermet coating as influenced by sliding speed, load, nature, composition and thermodynamic stability of oxides 19,34,35 . The formation of WO 3 , dense CoWO 4 tribo films due to tribo oxidation phenomenon helped in reducing friction coefficient and wear rate of WC-Co coating, whereas spinel phase NiCrO 4 formation in abrasive wear of Cr 3 C 2 -NiCr coatings resulted in improved friction and wear response 19 Abrasive wear rate increased with abrasive particle size up to a critical particle size of 100-150 µm and then remained more or less constant [40][41][42] . The wear and friction behaviour of stainless steel, ferritic and martensitic steel was explained in terms of particle size effect; i.e., clogging, capping, attrition and shelling of abrasive particle during abrasive wear [43][44][45] . The increased wear rate of WC-Co -Cr coating with increasing abrasive size was due to change in wear mechanism from plastic grooving to fracture 5 . Using factorial design approach it was concluded that effect of load rather than abrasive size on wear rate of Co-CrC coating was dominating 8 . Pirso et al. found that abrasive wear performance of TiC-NiMo and Cr 3 C 2 -Ni coatings was inferior to WC-Co coating due to different binder hardness and its effect on wear mechanisms 46 . TiC-Ni based coating showed increased abrasive wear loss of around seven times for increase in abrasive size from 30 µm to 200 µm 47 .
In the previous study 19 , friction and wear behaviour of WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings were studied with 150 µm SiC particles, in which friction behaviour of coating was predominantly influenced by abrasion. The particle size effect is established in the literature however, the effect of tribo oxidation in modifying adhesion and abrasion component of friction with decrease in abrasive particles size has not been studied previously. This has been the impetus for the present investigation. The present work is aimed at studying abrasive wear and friction and response of WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings for different loads and sliding speeds using 50 µm SiC particles. The Tribo oxidation effects were analyzed comprehensively. SEM, XRD and XPS analyses of worn surfaces provided an insight into tribo mechanisms and formation of tribo chemical reaction films.

Coating powders, deposition and Characterisation
Two commercial powders WC-12%Co (WOKA 3102) and Cr 3 C 2 -25%NiCr (WOKA 7202) manufactured by sintering and agglomeration route by Sulzer Metco, Germany were used in this study. The powders were in size range of -45 µm + 15 µm with spherical shape. Both the coatings were deposited on 316 stainless steel substrate. The coating deposition parameters, substrate preparation and other details regarding structural characterization and mechanical property measurement are described in previous publication 9,19 .

Wear experiments
Wear testing was performed using Pin on Disc setup with SiC (50 µm) abrasive paper, at room temperature. Wear test conditions were; 15 , 30 , 45 , and 60 N load with sliding speeds of 0.25, 0.5, 1.0 and 1.5 m s -1 and sliding distance was 1271 m. The specimens were in cylindrical form of 25 mm length and diameter 10 mm. The details regarding specimen preparation for wear testing and method of wear testing is detailed in previous publication 19 . Frictional force during abrasive wear testing was continuously recorded to determine coefficient of friction (COF). The morphology of worn surfaces and wear debris was examined and analyzed by using SEM, EDS, XRD and XPS. Carbon peak corresponding to 284.6 eV binding energy was used as the reference. XPS peak 4.1 software was used to fit XPS peaks. The binding energies of various phases were revealed by Standard Reference Database 20, (NIST), Version 4.1.

Properties of coatings
Fig. 1a and 1b shows the lamellar microstructure of WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings, respectively. WC and Cr 3 C 2 particles were uniformly disperse in cobalt and nickel-chrome binder, respectively in WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings were forming a dense coating structure with lower porosity. EDS spectra revealed the W, Co were the main elements in WC-12Co coating (Fig.  1c) while Cr, Ni were the main element in Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating (Fig. 1d). WC particles (bright regions) were surrounded by Co binder in WC-12Co coating (Fig. 1a). In Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating, Cr 3 C 2 particle observed as grey regions which were surrounded by dark grey NiCr binder (Fig. 1b). No microcracking was seen on the both coating surfaces. Cross-sectional micrographs were used for measuring porosity, carbide size by image analysis. The average size of WC and Cr 3 C 2 particle size was 1.5 ± 0.5 µm and 2.5 ± 0.5 µm, respectively. The calculated area percentage porosity was 1.2 % and 1.5 % for WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings, respectively. WC-12Co coating showed higher microhardness (1270 ± 100 HV) than Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating (825 ± 80 HV). The indentation fracture toughness measured on cross-section was 4.5 ± 1.0 M Pa√m and 3.7 ± 0.9 M Pa√m for WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings, respectively 9 .

COF and wear rate
Typical coefficient of friction curves of both the coatings at different sliding speeds (0.25-1.5 m s -1 and load (15-60 N) are shown in Fig. 2(a-d). In the running in period, COFs increased initially then decreased and then increased to reach a steady state region, after sliding distance of 400-500 meters. Initially the contact between the coating surface and abrasive particle occur at a few asperities, which results in increased contact stress at the asperity junction. When wear proceeds further, real contact area increased leading to reduction in stress at  the asperity junction and COF. With further sliding, wear debris generated due to plastic deformation covers the coating surface, causing an increase in adhesion, resulting in rise in friction force and COF. The fluctuations in COF curve can be attributed to formation and delamination of tribolayer and formation of tribo chemical reaction films on the worn surface, which is discussed in section 4. With increasing sliding distance more and more wear debris is generated due to plastic deformation and fracture depending upon load. Similarly, more and more abrasive particle fracture and fragmentation occur with increase in sliding distance and load. With increasing sliding speed and load both oxidative wear and mechanical wear prevail leading to removal of tribo oxide film by delamination cracking and fracture which generates oxide debris. The wear debris, fractured abrasive particles and oxide debris results in material removal by three body abrasion and tend to increase friction force and COF with increasing sliding distance particularly at higher loads, which is discussed in detail in section 4.
COF values were plotted vs. load and sliding velocities for both coatings, as displayed in Fig. 3(a-d), respectively. Friction coefficients for WC-12 Co coating were observed to be 0.29-0.38, 0.28-0.35, 0.27-0.33 and 0.24-0.30 for velocities of 0.25, 0.5, 1.0 and 1.5 m s -1 , and for load range of 15-60 N, respectively. While the respective COF values were 0.26-0.35, 0.25-0.32, 0.24-0.29 and 0.21-0.28 for Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating. COF showed decreasing trend with increasing sliding speed (0.25 -1.5 m s -1 ), for both the coatings. For both coatings, lowest friction coefficient was noted at 1.5 m s -1 velocity, irrespective of the load. It was seen from graphs that the decrease in COF was not more than 20 % for increase in sliding speed, for both coatings. For both coatings, COF displayed an increasing trend, for entire range of sliding speeds with an increase in load from 15 to 30 N followed by a decrease to 45 N and further increased when the load is reached to 60 N. It can be noted that COF values at 30 N and 60 N were nearly similar or slightly higher at 60 N, as shown in Fig. 3(c-d). The rise in COF was in the range of 21-31 % in case of WC-12 Co coating while for Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating, the increase in COF was 23-34 % when the load is increased from 15-60 N. Fig. 2 also showed that depending on sliding speed and load, COF values were 7-15% lower for Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating than WC-12 Co coating. The wear rates for change in load and sliding speed for coatings are displayed in Fig. 4(a-d). Wear rate of both coatings showed decreasing trend for increase in sliding velocity (0.25 to 1.5 m s -1 ). With WC-12 Co coating, the wear rates diminished by 31-42% while this decrease was in the range of 22-36 % for Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating within 15-60N load range. Within the load range of 15-60 N load, increase in wear rate was 2.68, 2.79, 2.63 and 2.72 times for sliding velocities of 0.25, 0.5, 1.0 and 1.5 m s -1 , respectively for WC-12 Co coating while corresponding increase was 3.09, 3.42, 2.74 and 2.58 times for Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating. Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating showed 2.2-2.8 times higher abrasive wear rates, than WC-12 Co coating, within the range of load and sliding speed.

Wear mechanisms
SEM micrographs of worn surfaces for both the coatings, at different sliding speeds and loads are shown in Figs. 5(a-h) and 6(a-h), respectively. From the worn surfaces it was observed that the severity of abrasion increased for rise in load from 15 to 60 N. At lower sliding speeds of less than 1 m s -1 (0.25 -0.5 m s -1 ) and up to load of 30 N for WC-12Co coating, the abrasive wear mechanism involved displacement of carbide grains, plastic grooving and binder extrusion, which can be seen in Fig. 5a. Compressive stresses exerted by hard abrasive SiC particles results in binder extrusion and removal of cobalt binder phase, which leads to loss in mechanical strength and subsequent decrease in the support to WC carbide. This resulted in displacement of mechanically loosed WC particles and their bodily removal from the coating matrix by the action of repeated cyclic fatigue with increasing load 9,33 . At 45-60 N load, rise in wear rates were associated with increased depth of grooving, fracture of carbides, carbide pull out and inter granular cracking as seen in Fig. 5(b-c). The propensity of carbide pull out increased with load, as fractured abrasive particle can effectively undermine the binder phase. The material removal mechanisms from the Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating under abrasive wear conditions were similar to the WC-12Co coating. In Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating relatively high percentage of binder content resulted in more binder phase extrusion, which can be seen in Fig. 6(a) at 30 N load and 0.25 m s -1 sliding speed. At higher loads, worn surface showed fracture and pull out of carbide grains (Fig. 6b-c). Carbide pull out, inter granular cracking and inter splat fracture leads to higher abrasive rates 11,19 .  Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating showed higher abrasive rates than WC-12 Co coating, which were due to lower fracture toughness of Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating than WC-12 Co coating 9 . With rise in sliding speed, oxidative wear mechanism also played an important role in altering friction and wear response of coatings. As the sliding velocity is increased from 0.25-1.5 m s -1 , the propensity of tribo oxidation increased which is evident from morphology worn surfaces of both coatings, as shown in Fig. 5(c-h) and 6(c-h). During wear, some of the debris particle get swept away while some retained in wear tracks are subjected to oxidation due to frictional heating. The fragmentation, oxidation, agglomeration and subsequent compaction forms a tribo-film separating contact between the abrasive particles and the worn surface and prevents further damage, as summarized previously 19 .
As the flash temperature is increased, the adhesive forces between individual oxide wear debris became stronger and enhances the compaction of tribo film to the coating surface.
This tribo layer having lower shear strength serves as solid lubricant and prevents further damage to the worn surface reducing not only wear rate but also COF 19,34,48 . At higher sliding velocity of 1.0 and 1.5 m s -1 , intense frictional heating caused oxidation of worn surface and resulted in covering of worn surface with tribo film (Fig. 5d-h and 6d-h). Wear tracks filled with oxide debris and number of hot spot patches confirming the localized heating, which can be observed in Fig. 5e-h and 6e-h. tribo film effectiveness in reduction of COF and wear rate is affected by its thermodynamic stability, adherence with the substrate, nature and its composition 19,49 . The tribo film is expected to be removed by shearing process at lower loads rather than by delamination cracking at higher loads as shown in Fig. 5(e,g,h) and Fig. 6(e,g,h), which also indicates fractured tribo film. With the removal of tribo film the contact conditions are modified, fresh contact occur between abrasive particle and the surface, and wear rate increases at higher loads. The extent of tribo-oxidation with varying sliding speed and load and can be assessed by rise in flash temperature, EDS, XRD, XPS analyses of worn surface, which is discussed in subsequent sections.
Frictional heat developed during abrasive wear leads to rise in flash temperature, at real contact area, which accelerates tribo-oxidation reactions resulting in tribo-oxide film formation. The increase in flash temperature with varying load and sliding speed provides useful information which can be used to predict different oxidation regimes from mild to severe. Flash temperatures increased for increase in both, load (15-60 N) and speed (0.25-1.5 m s -1 ), as shown in Fig. 7. The calculated flash temperature were in the range of 197-2496ºC and 179-2306ºC in case of WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings, respectively. It is also noted that rise in flash temperatures were much higher than the actual surface temperature of the coating surface i.e. bulk temperature 52 . The estimated flash temperatures are approximate, because the thermal conductivity of oxide was not taken into account.

Characterization of worn surface
EDS spectrum of worn surfaces of WC-12 Co coating showed peaks of oxygen (O) along with tungsten (W) and cobalt (Co) as shown Fig. 5(i-k). In Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating, EDS also revealed the peaks of O along with the chromium (Cr) and nickel (Ni) elements (Fig. 6i-k), suggesting formation of various oxide of Co, W, Cr and Ni. The concentration of oxygen increased for an increase in sliding speed and load, for both coatings, which was in the range of 19-41 % in case of WC-12Co coating while in case of Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating this range was 22-36 %, depending upon the load and sliding velocity, thus suggesting increased tribo oxidation. XRD analyses of worn surface of WC-12Co coating (Fig. 8a-d) (Fig. 8e-h). The number of oxide peaks and increased intensity of oxide peaks for rise in both, load and sliding velocity confirmed the prevalence of oxidative wear.
XPS analyses was performed to assess composition of different products of tribo chemical reaction, during abrasive of both the coatings. Fig. 9(a-b) showed XPS surface survey worn surface of both coatings, at 1.5 m s -1 and 0.25 m s -1 velocities at 60 N load. XPS spectra of W4f and Co2p of worn surface of WC-Co coating were shown in Fig. 10(a-d). The high resolution spectra of Cr2p and Ni2p of worn surface of Cr 3 C 2 -NiCr coating were displayed in Fig. 10(e-h). The XPS peaks were identified as WO 3 , CoO and Co(OH) 2 in case of WC-12Co coating and for Cr 3 C 2 -NiCr coating, XPS spectra displayed peak of Cr 2 O 3 , CrO 2 , Cr(OH) 2 and NiO. The binding energies of various phases is also indicated in XPS spectra.

Worn surface analysis
The occurrence and composition of tribo-oxide and hydroxide films on worn surface of both the coatings, was confirmed by analyses of worn surfaces. At 1.5 m s -1 sliding speed , the intensity of WO 3 peak was relatively more strong as than that at 0.25 ms -1 sliding speed for WC-12 Co coating surface, as seen in XPS spectra of Fig. 10(a and b). CoO peaks along with peak of Co(OH) 2 , due to tribo-chemical reaction with humidity were also recorded at higher sliding speed. It can also be noted that the intensity of CoO peak was weak at lower speed of 0.25 m s -1 and peak of Co with strong intensity were also observed, indicating that temperature rise at lower velocity was not sufficient for oxidation of Co. The tribo oxidation reaction of WC with oxygen can be expressed as per the following equations; 2 and 3 53 ; . .

WC O WO C G
KJmole 533 87 Where ΔG 298K is the standard Gibbs free energy of reaction formation.
Magneli phase oxides like, WO 3 which has layered structure, helps in decreasing COF depending on whether it is crystalline or amorphous. Spinel phase, CoWO 4 was considered beneficial in enhancing wear resistance and reducing COF due to its high deformity and good lubrication properties 35,[54][55][56] The metastable oxide, CoO as observed on worn surface aids in reduction of wear rate but Co 3 O 4 was reported to be more thermodynamically stable than CoO, and effectual to reduction of wear rate and COF. 35 . In case of Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating, Cr 2 O 3 , CrO 3 , CrO 2 and NiO were main oxide phases identified by XRD and XPS analyses of worn surface. A strong intensity Cr and Ni peaks were observed at 0.25 m s -1 as compared to that at 1.5 m s -1 , whereas the intensity of NiO peak was strong at higher velocity, indicating relatively greater extent of oxidation of binder phase for Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating, at higher velocity (Fig. 10e-h). Cr 2 O 3 film with more passivity and lower negative Gibbs free energy, indicates beneficial effect of Cr 2 O 3 film in decrease of wear rate and COF than CrO 3 . Chromium oxide formation can be given by following reactions as mentioned in equations in 7 and 8 59 ; . . . . .
It has been also reported that the oxidation of Cr 3 C 2 leads to the generation of secondary carbides like Cr 7 C 3 and Cr 23 C 6 61 . Cr 23 C 6 phase was noted in the XRD spectra of worn surfaces. The hardness of Cr 23 C 6 and Cr 7 C 3 is lower than the Cr 3 C 2 , which can also cause increase in wear rates of Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating 62 . Nickel oxide (NiO) and spinel oxide (NiCr 2 O 4 ) peaks were noted in XRD and XPS spectra of worn surfaces (Fig. 8e-h  and Fig. 10g-h) " + (12)

Analyses of debris and worn abrasive paper
SEM photographs of wear debris particle were shown in Fig. 11(a-f) for both the coatings. Expectedly, at lower load, the wear debris removal rate was lower as compared to that at higher load and for increase in load, relatively coarser wear debris was observed. Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating showed more amount of wear debris than WC-12Co coating, as revealed in Figs 11(d, e, f), which also supports higher wear rate shown by Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating than WC-12Co coating (Fig. 4) Fig. 12(a-g). It was also observed that intensity of peaks and number of various oxide phases were influenced by sliding velocity and the load, due to difference in the frictional heat generation and associated rise in flash temperatures as discussed earlier. XRD analyses of wear debris particles, further supported the observation regarding varying degree of tribo-oxidation and tribofilm composition with change in abrasive wear test parameters. SiC peaks were attributed to fracture of SiC abrasive particles during wear.  Fig. 13(a-h), for both the coatings. Fragmentation of SiC abrasive particles was relatively greater at higher loads (45-60 N) as compared to lower load (15-30 N). Low magnification SEM images as shown in Fig. 13(a & e) reveals the greater extent of capping (covering of tip of abrasive particles with wear debris) and clogging (accumulation of wear debris in the spaces of abrasive particle) in case of Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating than that WC-12Co coating. Oxygen peaks revealed by EDS spectra of worn paper confirmed accumulation of wear debris on abrasive paper (Fig. 13i-j). The other features observed on worn papers were attrition of abrasive, edge rounding, fracture and fragmentation, removal (shelling) of abrasive particle, severity of these depends upon load.

Wear and friction of coatings
Friction and wear data for both the coatings with 50 µm SiC abrasive particle size, obtained in present work, were compared with those obtained under similar test conditions with 150 µm SiC abrasive particle size 19 . Friction coefficients and wear rates were significantly affected by change in abrasive particle size. Both COF and wear showed decreasing trend with decrease in abrasive particle from 150 to 50 µm, although the extent of the decrease was influenced by load and sliding velocity. With 150 µm particle size, the friction coefficients were 0.32-0.44 and 0.27-0.38 for WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings, respectively. With increasing sliding speed (0.25 to 1.5 m s -1 ), the reduction in COF was at the most 20 % for WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings, for both abrasive particle sizes. For both the particle sizes of   50 and 150 µm, the COF displayed increasing trend when the load was increased from 15 to 60 N. The maximum rise in COF was 14 % and 31% for WC-12 Co coating for 150 and 50 µm particle size, respectively whereas respective values for Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating were 17 % and 34 %. Both coatings showed lower friction coefficients with 50 µm abrasive particle size as compared to that with 150 µm particle, the magnitude of which was governed by load and sliding speed. The maximum decrease in COF of around 20-26 % was noted at lower load of 15 N, for both the coatings over sliding velocities in the range of 0.25-1.5 m s -1 . At higher loads (45-60 N), the decrease was 10-20 % for both coatings, depending on sliding speed and load. Abrasive wear rate showed diminishing trend for increasing sliding speed while with increasing load abrasive wear rate increased for both coatings. Abrasive wear rates were in the range of 2.61 x 10 -4 -14.2 x 10 -4 mm 3 m -1 and 11 x 10 -4 -35.36 x 10 -4 mm 3 m -1 with 150 µm particle size in case of WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings, respectively. With reduction in abrasive particle size to 50 µm, wear rates reduced by around two times and more than three times for WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings, respectively. Wear rate increased for increase in load (15 N-60 N) which was around 2.5-3 and 2.6-3.4 times for both coatings, for abrasive particle size of 150 µm and 50 µm, respectively.
The frictional behaviour of WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating can be explained on the basis of contribution of abrasion and adhesion components of friction, tribo-oxidation and mechanical and oxidative wear, with change in wear test conditions. The reduction in COF and wear rate for increase in sliding velocity for both the coatings can be attributed to tribo oxide films. Tribo-films have lower shear strength and protects the worn surface by acting as solid lubricant, as discussed earlier. However, change in composition of oxides and the extent of tribo-oxidation altered friction response of both the coatings. In case of WC-12Co coating, at lowest velocity, the intensity of peak of oxides W and Co was relatively weak as compared to those at highest velocity, as revealed by phase analyses of worn surface. Similarly, in case of Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating, strong peaks of oxide of Cr and Ni were noted at highest sliding speed, indicating an increase in severity of oxidative wear, which is also supported by increased flash temperatures with rise in sliding velocity, as discussed earlier. Relatively lower COF exhibited by Cr 3 C 2 -25NiCr coating can be attributed to Cr 2 O 3 film with greater thermodynamic stability and spinel phase NiCr 2 O 4 , which help in reduction of COF.
Adhesion and ploughing are two important components which contributes to friction between two surfaces. The adhesion between two surfaces is influenced by real area of contact whereas angle of attack posed by asperities decide ploughing component. With decrease in abrasive size, capping and clogging of abrasive paper result in agglomeration of wear debris particle on paper and adhesion mechanism becomes dominant and for increased abrasive particle size, abrasion mechanism become prevalent 43,45,50 . The contribution of abrasion and adhesion to friction coefficient is also governed by ratio of abrasive hardness to surface hardness (Ha/Hs) during abrasive wear, apart from the contact pressure and the deterioration of abrasive particles. The degradation of abrasives can modify attack angle and material removal rate and generation of wear debris. With higher Ha/Hs ratio, a minimum in friction coefficient was observed for abrasive particle size of 35 µm; adhesion became prominent below this particle size and abrasion component was increased above this particle size 44 . In cermets with high volume fraction of carbides, contribution to total material removal rate arises from hard phase (carbide) and soft phase (binder). Considering Ha/Hc ratio (abrasive hardness to carbide hardness), it can be observed that silicon carbide particle has comparable hardness to tungsten carbide in case of WC-12Co coating, whereas Ha/Hc ratio in case of Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating was more than 1.3. However, in two phase materials like cermets, the material removal rate from carbides is also augmented by removal of binder i.e. bodily removal and carbide pull out, propensity of which increases with an increase in load, as pointed earlier. Thus, the wear debris generation rate in these coating is strongly influenced by microstructural features like difference in carbide size, binder content and Ha/Hc and varying fracture toughness 11,66 . The other aspect which needs attention and which has not been addressed by previous researchers is tribo oxidation effects with change in load, sliding velocity abrasive size. In the present work, friction coefficient increased when the load was increased from 15 N to 45 N, which can be attributed to combined effect of adhesion and abrasion. SEM image of wear debris particle, as shown in Fig. 10, demonstrate the differences in amount and size of wear debris particles for variation in load and sliding speed, for both coatings. It is expected that during abrasive wear, abrasion predominantly contributes to friction between two surfaces.
With relatively finer abrasive particles, with increase in load, contribution of both adhesion and abrasion components increased, which is supported by SEM images of worn abrasive papers, as shown in Fig. 13. Similarly, with increase in load, due to rise in flash temperature (Fig. 7) tribo oxidation led to formation of tribo films, which also decreases real contact area and helps in reduction in COF, as discussed in section 3.3. Thus, reduction in friction coefficient at 45 N load can be justified as following; firstly, by balance of abrasion and adhesion to friction coefficient, secondly the rate of formation of tribo film and its removal reaching to an equilibrium and thirdly, because of increased load, fragmentation and fracture of abrasive particles increases and fractured particles have reduced cutting efficiency due to decrease in attack angle. Further increase in COF to 60 N was due to delamination of agglomerated wear debris on worn abrasive paper which also acted as a third body and contributes to abrasion and easy removal of tribo film due to enhanced contribution of mechanical wear, which has resulted in increased COF at higher load of 60 N for both coatings.
The correlation between flash temperature, abrasive wear rate and COF as a function of sliding velocity is shown in Fig. 14(a-b), for WC-12 Co and Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coatings. The reduction in wear rate for increase in velocity was observed and increased flash temperatures were noted for increase in sliding speed. However, no consistent correlation between wear rate and COF of coatings was observed. The friction and wear behaviour of any material depends upon chemical, physical, and mechanical interaction between two surfaces and with the environment. Wear and friction are therefore regarded not as intrinsic properties but as system properties. The decrease in abrasive wear rate of carbide based coatings for increase in sliding speed and rise in COF for rise in load was also observed previously 37,67-69 whereas contradictory observations have also been reported 35 . The variation in COF and wear rate of coatings with decreasing abrasive particle size was also associated with the change in their attack angle. In generally, abrasive particle attack angle decreases with decreasing particle size leading to lower wear rates 43 . A change in abrasive particle attack angle also results in the transition in material removal mechanisms which effectuate abrasive particle size effect on wear and friction response. Abrasive particle fragmentation was more predominant with lower particle size and deterioration abrasive particle was more severe with increasing load while coarser abrasive particles show less fragmentation due to their partial participation in abrasion process 45 . Finer SiC abrasive particles due to fragmentation can aid in easily removal of binder by undermining process, which resulted binder rich tribo-layer formation, as confirmed by phase analysis of worn surfaces in the present work. With coarser abrasive, predominant material removal mechanisms were plastic grooving of binder phase, carbide pullout, carbide fracture, delamination cracking and fracture of splats 19 . With finer abrasive particles the mechanism showed transition from plastic deformation to fracture with an increase in load as observed in the present work. The worn surfaces were covered by tribo oxide layer which was up to 60 % with coarser abrasive particles 19 while tribo oxides covering worn surface was around 40% with finer abrasive particle size due to relatively lower rise in flash temperatures, as noted in present investigation. The combined effect of adhesion and abrasion to friction, variation in tribo oxidation, change in wear mechanisms and varying contribution of oxidative and mechanical wear as influenced by load and sliding velocity, could explain the differences in tribological behaviour of coatings.

Conclusions
The abrasive experiments were carried using 50 µm SiC abrasive particles with varying load and sliding speeds. The detailed study of abraded surfaces, wear debris, worn abrasive papers has contributed in understanding of wear mechanisms, tribo oxidation effects and phase composition of tribo chemical reaction films. The conclusions of present work can be summarized as follows.
1. The better wear resistance of WC-12 Co coating was attributed to its relatively higher fracture toughness than Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating.The tribo mechanisms exhibited transition from plastic grooving to fracture with increasing load. 2. The lower friction coefficient of Cr 3 C 2 -25 NiCr coating was due to tribo oxide films of Cr 2 O 3 and NiCr 2 O 4 . 3. The difference in magnitude of decrease in wear rate and COF of coatings with reduction in sliding speed was attributed to varying degree of tribo-oxidation, stability and phase composition of tribo-chemical reaction film. 4. The change in COF with increase in load for both the coatings was due to combined effect of adhesion, abrasion and tribo oxidation.