Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

Otoneurological screening of civil construction workers performing work at height

ABSTRACT

Purpose:

to investigate the prevalence of otoneurological signs and symptoms in construction workers at the health campus of Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG) that perform their functions at height.

Methods:

the cross-sectional observational study consisted of 33 construction workers. The Protocolo Ofício de Gestão de Diagnóstico Otoneurológico (Otoneurological Diagnosis Management Service Protocol) was used, which is composed of medical case history, vestibular tests including Dix Hallpike test and Positional Nystagmus, vestibular dynamics evaluation using Head Shaking Nystagmus test, static and dynamic balance tests, cerebellar exam, complementary investigation of the cranial nerves, completion/conduct and orientation. The data were entered into a SPSS 13.0 spreadsheet, considering significant the differences up to the level of 5%.

Results:

all participants were male. The average age was 38.1 years, ranging from 21 to 65 years. One third of the participants showed changes in screening due to complaints about imbalance and/or tinnitus. Chi-square test revealed a statistically significant difference in the group with complaints of imbalance in relation to the variables of circulatory dysfunctions, headache and use of medicines; the last was also statistically significant in the group with tinnitus.

Conclusion:

one third of the construction workers who perform work at height presented otoneurological screening results that indicate alteration.

Keywords:
Speech, Language and Hearing Sciences; Postural Balance; Occupational Groups; Construction Industry

RESUMO

Objetivo:

avaliar a prevalência de sinais e sintomas otoneurológicos em operários da construção civil do campus saúde da Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG) que trabalham expostos à altura.

Métodos:

estudo observacional transversal constituído por 33 trabalhadores da construção civil. Foi utilizado o Protocolo Ofício de Gestão de Diagnóstico Otoneurológico composto por anamnese, provas vestibulares realizadas por meio de Dix-Hallpike e nistagmo de posição, avaliação da dinâmica vestibular utilizando a prova de Head Shaking, provas de equilíbrio estático, dinâmico, cerebelares, investigação complementar dos pares cranianos, conclusão/conduta e orientação. Os dados foram lançados em planilha do programa SPSS versão 13.0, sendo consideradas significantes as diferenças que apresentaram nível de significância de até 5%.

Resultados:

todos os participantes eram do gênero masculino. A média de idade foi de 38,1 anos, variando de 21 a 65 anos. Um terço dos participantes apresentaram alteração na triagem devido a queixa de equilíbrio e/ou zumbido. Por meio do teste Qui-Quadrado foi possível observar diferença estatisticamente significante entre o grupo com queixa de equilíbrio para as variáveis de distúrbios circulatórios, cefaleia e uso de medicamentos, sendo que este último estatisticamente significante também no grupo com queixa de zumbido.

Conclusão:

um terço dos trabalhadores da construção civil que executam trabalho em altura apresentou triagem otoneurológica sugestiva de alteração.

Descritores:
Fonoaudiologia; Equilíbrio Postural; Categorias de Trabalhadores; Indústria da Construção

Introduction

Body balance is essential to practice postural reactions that allow the performance of movements with harmony, physical and mental comfort, maintaining an upright posture and avoiding falls11. Flores FT, Rossi AG, Schmidt PS. Avaliação do equilíbrio corporal na doença de Parkinson. Arq Int Otorrinolaringol. 2011;15(2):142-50.. To maintain balance, an interaction among the vestibular, visual and proprioceptive systems22. Kleiner AFR, Schlitter DXC, Arias MDRS. O papel dos sistemas visual, vestibular, somatossensorial e auditivo para o controle postural. Rev Neurocienc. 2011;19(2):349-57. is required. A dysfunction among these three systems may be manifested through dizziness33. Hueb MM, Feliciano CP. Avaliação vertiginosa das síndromes vertiginosas. Rev Hosp Univ Pad Ern. 2012;11(3):23-35..

Dizziness is the feeling of disturbance in body balance and it can be defined as a misleading perception, illusion or hallucination of movement, sensation of spatial disorientation, including the rotating type (vertigo) or non-rotating type (instability, fluctuation, oscillations)44. Ganança FF, Gazzola JM, Aratani MC, Perracini MR, Ganança MM. Circunstâncias e consequências de quedas em idosos com vestibulopatias crônicas. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol. 2006;72(3):388-93.. It can occur in individuals of any age, but it is more common among adults and the elderly over age 4055. Scherer S, Lisboa HRK, Psqualotti A. Tontura em idosos: diagnostic otoneurológico e interferência na qualidade de vida. Rev Soc Bras Fonoaudiol. 2012;17(2):142-50..

Patients with dizziness usually report having difficulty with concentration, memory lapses, fatigue, insomnia or drowsiness, insecurity, irritability, anxiety and depression66. Vieira AAU, Aprile MR, Paulino CA. Exercício físico, envelhecimento e queda em idosos: Revisão Narrativa. Rev Equi Corp Saú. 2014;6(1):25-33.. Constant imbalance, either in a slight or intense degree, may lead an individual to a certain disability in several aspects of life, such as work, carrying the risk of falling at his/her workplace77. Teixeira CS, Korbes D, Rossi AG. Ruído e equilíbrio: aplicação da posturografia dinâmica em indústria gráfica. Rev CEFAC. 2011;13(1):92-101..

Falls from heights is the occupational factor that presents the highest mortality risk in this environment, representing approximately 40% of the cases88. Firetti VL. Trabalho em altura: legislação, soluções e análise [monografia] Curitiba (Paraná): Universidade Tecnológica Federal do Paraná; 2013.. This percentage is relevant mainly in relation to the civil construction industry, which presents poor work conditions and it is one of the economy sectors that has been developing the most over the past years, increasing the number of workers and, consequently, increasing the number of work accidents99. Lima JL. Avaliação em trabalho com andaime suspenso da conformidade com a NR 35 em obra de construção civil vertical [monografia]. Curitiba (Paraná): Universidade Tecnológica Federal do Paraná; 2013..

According to the Regulatory Norm (NR) 35 of the Ministry of Labor and Employment1010. MTe: Ministério do Trabalho. NR-35 Trabalho em Altura. [citado em 27 de março de 2012]. Disponível em: http://portal.mte.gov.br/data/files/8A7C816A3D63C1A0013DAB8EA3975DDA/NR-35%20(Trabalho%20em%20Altura).pdf.
http://portal.mte.gov.br/data/files/8A7C...
, every activity performed above two meters in relation to the inferior level, when there is risk of falling, is considered work at heights. Causes of falls can be countless, such as dizziness, and other otoneurologic alterations, balance disorders and postural stability deficiency1111. Manual de auxílio na interpretação e aplicação da Norma Regulamentadora 35 Trabalhos em Altura - NR 35 Comentada. Disponível em http://www.sfiec.org.br/palestras/saude/sst-4jornada/1NR35comentada.pdf
http://www.sfiec.org.br/palestras/saude/...
. There may be other symptoms, associated with the aforementioned symptoms, that, directly or indirectly, tend to aggravate the worker's clinical condition, such as headache, darkened vision, nystagmus, sleep disorders, tinnitus, hearing loss, instability, deviation of the walk trajectory, difficulty with visual fixation, nausea and vomit1212. Gorski LP, Andrade MS, Canto JD. Proposta de triagem do equilíbrio corporal aplicada a um grupo da terceira idade. Rev Salus. 2008;2(1):37-45..

In order to assess the frequency of signs and symptoms related to balance alterations in workers that need adequate balance to perform their activities safely at height and/or those presenting complaints about dizziness, the Protocolo Ofício de Gestão de Diagnósticos Otonoeurológicos (Otoneurological Diagnosis Management Service Protocol)1313. Meira AL, Silva CB, Lorentz D, Barbosa KR, Almeida KN, Miranda LS. Verificação da aplicabilidade do Protocolo Ofício de Gestão de Diagnósticos Otoneurológicos. 27° Encontro Internacional de Audiologia; 14 a 17 de abril de 2012, Bauru; 2012 . was created. This protocol is composed of medical case history, equilibriometric tests, complementary investigation of the cranial nerves, completion/conduct and orientation.

The purpose of this study is to analyze, through otoneurological screening, the frequency of otoneurological signs and symptoms in civil construction workers at the health campus of Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG) that perform their functions at height.

Methods

There was an analytical cross-sectional observational study composed of 33 civil construction workers that perform their tasks at settings above two meters in relation to the inferior level, approved by the Research Ethics Committee of UFMG under the protocol number 719.442.

Initially, the workers were invited to attend a lecture called "Otoneurological screening of civil construction workers performing work at height", in which pieces of information about the research were given, the procedures used in it, its risks and benefits. After the lecture, all workers were invited to take part in the research. The evaluations were scheduled and every participant that voluntarily attended the lecture signed an Informed Consent Form. The appointments took place in the Speech, Language and Hearing Sciences Laboratory of Medical School at UFMG.

Each individual was asked questions to formulate a medical case history. They were related to metabolic alterations, hormonal, circulatory dysfunctions, cervical alterations, regular use of medicine, caffeine, alcohol and nicotine consumption, family medical history of labyrinth diseases and complaints about balance alterations and tinnitus. In relation to balance, if the patient confirmed having a symptom related to it, this individual was asked questions about the type, when it began, its duration, intensity, frequency, factors that make the dizziness become better or worse, if there was a relation to the movement of the head and during ambulation or not. In relation to tinnitus, if the patient confirmed feeling it, this individual was asked questions about which ear the tinnitus occurred in, its intensity, frequency, and factors that make the tinnitus become better or worse.

After that, the Protocolo Ofício de Gestão de Diagnóstico Otoneurológico1313. Meira AL, Silva CB, Lorentz D, Barbosa KR, Almeida KN, Miranda LS. Verificação da aplicabilidade do Protocolo Ofício de Gestão de Diagnósticos Otoneurológicos. 27° Encontro Internacional de Audiologia; 14 a 17 de abril de 2012, Bauru; 2012 . - Otoneurological Diagnosis Management Service Protocol (Appendix 1 Appendix 1 - OTONEUROLOGICAL SCREENING ) was used to assess all participants. This protocol was developed to be applied in an occupational environment and it consists of a practical and fast screening of the systems that are responsible for balance, identifying individuals that present signs and symptoms of alterations in corporal balance in order to prevent work accidents and the risk of falling from heights. The individuals that present alteration in the screening should be referred to a complete otoneurological assessment. The screening initially aims to determine if there are signs indicating peripheral or central lesions in the systems responsible for corporal balance, so that adequate measures and treatments decisions can be made. Constant vestibular tests in the screening protocol (Appendix 1 Appendix 1 - OTONEUROLOGICAL SCREENING ) were selected in a way so that they did not demand any special equipment and due to the fact that they are easily applied in an occupational environment. To use a protocol, only a room with a stretcher and a fixed chair is necessary, and it needs to be in a space with a free area equivalent to one square meter approximately, so that the worker is able to take static and dynamic balance tests.

The standard form used in the otoneurological screening of civil construction workers performing work at height is composed of the following sessions: I. Complement of Clinic-Occupational Medical Case History; II. Balance Tests; III. Complementary Investigation of the Cranial Nerves; IV. Completion and Conduct, and V. Orientation (Appendix 1 Appendix 1 - OTONEUROLOGICAL SCREENING ).

Among the balance tests that were taken, the first test was the vertigo and Positional Nystagmus research through Dix Hallpike test. This test assesses labyrinth mechanics, making it possible to identify the presence of otoconia in the semicircular canals1414. Zuma e Maia FC, Carmona S, Costa SS. Avaliação clínica do paciente vertiginoso. In: Zuma e Maia FC, Albernaz PLM, Carmona S. Otoneurologia Atual. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2014. p.25-51.. Each patient was placed on a stretcher, using sitting position, and was given instructions to look attentively upon a predetermined point during each head movement. With the head turned 45 degrees to the side, the patient rapidly changes from a sitting position to a pendant head position, considering that this inclination is maintained during 40 seconds, while eye movements related to occasional nystagmus are observed, turning back to the sitting position afterwards. The same procedure was used on the other side. The test was considered positive in cases of benign paroxysmal positional vertigo, which is the most common cause of peripheral vertigo1414. Zuma e Maia FC, Carmona S, Costa SS. Avaliação clínica do paciente vertiginoso. In: Zuma e Maia FC, Albernaz PLM, Carmona S. Otoneurologia Atual. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2014. p.25-51.. Then the vertigo and Positional Nystagmus research was conducted, in which, still with the patient placed on a stretcher, head and body movements are made in the following positions: supine, right and left lateral, dorsal with head hanging, dorsal with head hanging to the right and to the left and sitting position. In each position the presence of nystagmus and its direction were observed. It is known that horizontal nystagmus is more evident in peripheral vertibular lesions, while vertical nystagmus can be found in central lesions1414. Zuma e Maia FC, Carmona S, Costa SS. Avaliação clínica do paciente vertiginoso. In: Zuma e Maia FC, Albernaz PLM, Carmona S. Otoneurologia Atual. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2014. p.25-51.. The presence of nystagmus or vertigo indicated alterations in these tests33. Hueb MM, Feliciano CP. Avaliação vertiginosa das síndromes vertiginosas. Rev Hosp Univ Pad Ern. 2012;11(3):23-35..

Thereafter, the vestibular dynamics was assessed through Head Shaking test. This test is used to evaluate vestibular dynamics, which is useful when determining central disorders. Patients were given instructions to close their eyes and their heads were placed 30 degrees downwards to make the lateral semicircular canals horizontal. After that, their heads were under rotation to the right and to the left alternately, approximately 45 degrees on each side, as fast as possible, during 30 seconds. After undergoing those oscillations, patients open their eyes and the examiner observes if there was nystagmus or not. In cases of unilateral peripheral lesion, it is possible to notice horizontal nystagmus, and in central lesions there is evidence of vertical nystagmus after horizontal Head Shaking1414. Zuma e Maia FC, Carmona S, Costa SS. Avaliação clínica do paciente vertiginoso. In: Zuma e Maia FC, Albernaz PLM, Carmona S. Otoneurologia Atual. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2014. p.25-51.. The test was considered altered when it was observed nystagmus after patients opened their eyes.

The cerebellum plays an important role in programming motor system actions and in coordinating response reflexes to maintain balance1414. Zuma e Maia FC, Carmona S, Costa SS. Avaliação clínica do paciente vertiginoso. In: Zuma e Maia FC, Albernaz PLM, Carmona S. Otoneurologia Atual. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2014. p.25-51.. To evaluate it, some tests were selected: the finger to finger test, in which patients keep their arms extended and in parallel at shoulder height, with their index fingers pointing to the front with their eyes closed; the finger to nose test, in which the individual must touch their nose tip with their index finger, alternating their arms; and the diadochokinesia, in which patients alternate movements with their palm and back of the hand rapidly. The lack of coordination when performing those movements was considered as an alteration11. Flores FT, Rossi AG, Schmidt PS. Avaliação do equilíbrio corporal na doença de Parkinson. Arq Int Otorrinolaringol. 2011;15(2):142-50..

The static balance analysis was done using Romberg's test. Patients are given instructions to stand up, with their arms close to the body, initially with their eyes open, closing them a few seconds later. The difference between the oscillation with their eyes open and closed is observed. Sideways falls are noticed in peripheral labyrinth lesions, while other types of falls, specially to the back, are noticed in central lesions1414. Zuma e Maia FC, Carmona S, Costa SS. Avaliação clínica do paciente vertiginoso. In: Zuma e Maia FC, Albernaz PLM, Carmona S. Otoneurologia Atual. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2014. p.25-51.. In relation to dynamic balance, analyzed though Unterberger test, patients were asked to walk in place, initially with their eyes open and then with them closed. If there was a rotation to one side of the body, specially rotations above 45 degrees, it was considered as an evidence of peripheral vestibular disorder1414. Zuma e Maia FC, Carmona S, Costa SS. Avaliação clínica do paciente vertiginoso. In: Zuma e Maia FC, Albernaz PLM, Carmona S. Otoneurologia Atual. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2014. p.25-51..

In relation to the complementary investigation of the cranial nerves, in order to evaluate the cranial nerves III, IV and VI (the oculomotor, trochlear and abducens nerves), a pen was placed in different directions (upwards, downwards, right, left, right and left inferior oblique and circular positions). Patients were asked to follow the pen's movement with their eyes, without moving their heads. Cranial nerve V (trigeminal nerve) was evaluated by touching each third of their faces with a piece of cotton wool and, with their eyes closed, patients should tell which part of their faces was being touched. Cranial nerve VII (facial nerve) was evaluated through the perception of gustatory stimulus (sweet and salty).

The screening was classified as "pass" when individuals did not report complaints about balance alteration and tinnitus, and they have not presented alterations in balance tests yet. In this case, the participants only received instructions to suspend their work activities and search for the nearest health care service in case they feel any sign and/or symptom related to balance.

In the screening, it was considered as "failure" those individuals that presented complaints or medical case history of balance alteration and/or alterations in any of the balance tests. It is important to emphasize the fact that the screening itself does not allow specialists to establish an otoneurological diagnosis, however, it allows to identify cases in which there is an evidence of alteration that should be referred to a complete otoneurological evaluation. The participants that failed the screening also received medical orientations about a healthy diet and tips of good daily habits related to body balance.

After analyzing the results, the participants were distributed into four groups, according to their results. Group 1 (G1) was composed of individuals that did not present complaints and/or alteration, that is, that passed the screening. The other groups were composed of participants that failed the screening. Group 2 (G2) was composed of individuals that presented complaints of imbalance. In Group 3 (G3) were included all individuals that reported complaints of tinnitus. Group 4 (G4) was composed of individuals that reported complaints of imbalance and tinnitus. The last three groups were compared to the first one in order to relate the data found in the medical case history/evaluation in individuals with and without complaints/alterations of balance and tinnitus. The data were entered into a SPSS 13.0 spreadsheet.

The frequencies among the groups in relation to the analyzed variables were compared using the Chi-square test. The differences that presented a significance level up to 5% were considered significant.

Results

100% of the 33 participants were male. The average age was 38,1 years (± 11,37), ranging from 21 to 65 years, considering that the largest group was composed of individuals from age 21 to 39 years (54,5%), followed by a group of individuals from age 40 and 59 years (42,4%). Table 1 presents the data related to the age of the participants.

Table 1:
Distribution in relation to age

All vestibular tests in this study did not present alterations, however, one third of the workers presented an indication of alteration in the otoneurological screening due to the presence of complaints of imbalance and/or tinnitus. Table 2 presents the data related to altered screenings.

Table 2:
Individuals with and without alteration

In relation to the participants' function in the civil construction, 21,2% of them were bricklayers, 18,2% of them were painters, 12,1% of them were electricians and 9,1% of them were fitters, among other functions. Table 3 contains the data related to the participants' function.

Table 3:
Data related to function

In relation to the data found in the medical case history, 6,1% of the participants reported having metabolic alterations, 3% of them reported having hormonal dysfunction, 27,3% of them reported having circulatory dysfunctions and/or heart diseases, 24,2% of them reported having alterations in the spinal column, 15,2% of them reported having headaches or migraines and 21,2% of them had medical case history of labyrinth diseases. Table 4 contains the data related to alterations found in the medical case history.

Table 4:
Data related to alterations found in the medical case history

Considering caffeine, alcohol and nicotine consumption, 31 (91%) individuals reported constant use of caffeine, 16 (48,5%) individuals reported drinking alcohol and nine (27,3%) individuals reported using nicotine. Only one individual reported using none of such substances. In relation to the use of medicines, eight individuals (24,2%) reported their constant use and, among them, there are Atenolol, Losartan, Clorana, Hydrochlorothiazide, Simvastatin, Vitamin D and Nifedipine. Among these eight individuals, three of them use more than one of those medicines. Table 5 shows the data related to caffeine, alcohol, nicotine and medicine consumption.

Table 5:
Caffeine, alcohol, nicotine and medicine consumption

In relation to the alteration of balance, six (18,2%) out of the 33 participants reported imbalance and, in relation to tinnitus, seven (21,2%) of them reported feeling such symptom. No individual presented alteration in balance tests and in complementary investigation of the cranial nerves.

The comparisons among G1 and all the other groups were made through Chi-square test, evidencing significant statistical differences in relation to circulatory dysfunctions and/or heart diseases, regular use of medicines, headache/migraine and caffeine consumption associated with alcohol consumption in G2. In G3, a significant statistical difference in relation to regular use of medicines was noticed. No significant statistical difference was found when comparing to G4. Table 6 contains the data related to the comparisons among groups.

Table 6:
Descriptive statistics and comparisons among groups

Discussion

In relation to gender, 100% of the sample was composed of male individuals. The same result was found in other study, which asserts that most part of male workers are concentrated in civil construction1515. Ogido R, Costa EA, Machado HC. Prevalência de sintomas auditivos e vestibulares em trabalhadores expostos a ruído ocupacional. Rev Saúde Pública. 2009;43(2):377-80..

The average age was 38,1 years and the largest group was composed of individuals between ages of 21 and 39. This result corroborates other study that reports there is a decrease in age in this sector related to the loss of physical ability or characteristics that are important when performing this activity1616. Silva ARP. Perfil dos operários da construção civil na cidade do Rio de Janeiro (Avaliação do nível de satisfação dos operários). IV Congresso Nacional em Gestão; 31 de julho a 02 de agosto de 2008, Rio de Janeiro.. However, other studies claim that the Brazilian civil construction labor force exhibits workers that belong to older age groups1717. DIEESE: Departamento Intersindical de estatística e estudos socioeconômicos. O trabalho por conta própria na construção civil. [citado fevereiro 2011]. Disponível em: http://www.dieese.org.br/boletimtrabalhoeconstrucao/2011/2011boletimConstrucaoCivil5.pdf.
http://www.dieese.org.br/boletimtrabalho...
),(1818. DIEESE: Departamento Intersindical de estatística e estudos socioeconômicos. Perfil da construção civil no estado da Bahia. [citado em setembro 2012]. Disponível em: http://www.dieese.org.br/projetos/informalidade/perfilConstrucaoCivilBA.pdf.
http://www.dieese.org.br/projetos/inform...
. Due to the expansion of the civil construction industry, it is possible to assert that young people enter into this field searching for their first job opportunity and, progressively, they are conquering this activity, which demands their strength, agility and physical effort. In this study, one third of the workers reported complaints of balance and/or tinnitus and, therefore, the result in the otoneurological screening was altered. Other studies in the literature that could relate working at height to otoneurological screening were not found. Therefore, it is important to know the most prevailing kind of alteration, its intensity, and if the complaint jeopardize the individual during working hours.

In relation to function, 21,2% of the workers were bricklayers and 18,2% of them were painters. Together, they represented 39,4% of the sample, considering that one third of these workers reported complaints about balance and tinnitus. A study done in 2005 highlighted the fact that bricklayers represent 55,2% of the accidents to civil construction professionals and painters represent 7,5% of these accidents1919. Moreira MD, Costa VSP, Melo JJ, Marchiori LLM. Prevalência e associações da vertigem posicional paroxística benigna em idosos. Rev CEFAC. 2014;16(5):1533-40.. This finding makes one need even more evident: the need of using preventive measures in civil construction in order to decrease its risks.

Studies that compare metabolic and cervical alterations, hormonal dysfunctions, and circulatory disorders in workers that perform work height were not found in the literature. However, it is known that several non-vestibular problems can affect the balance of an individual1717. DIEESE: Departamento Intersindical de estatística e estudos socioeconômicos. O trabalho por conta própria na construção civil. [citado fevereiro 2011]. Disponível em: http://www.dieese.org.br/boletimtrabalhoeconstrucao/2011/2011boletimConstrucaoCivil5.pdf.
http://www.dieese.org.br/boletimtrabalho...
. In this study, there was only one (3%) report about this alteration from a workman.

In relation to circulatory disorders and/or diseases, nine (27,3%) workers reported having these disorders. Such finding corroborates another study found in the literature that mentions cardiovascular disorders as the main causes of vertigo or dizziness2020. Cal R, Junior FB. Enxaqueca associada a disfunção auditivo-vestibular. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol. 2008;74(4):606-12.. The occurrence of cervical alteration was noticed in eight (24,2%) workers. This finding was also noticed in other studies that mention this alteration when dealing with an otoneurological clinical condition1919. Moreira MD, Costa VSP, Melo JJ, Marchiori LLM. Prevalência e associações da vertigem posicional paroxística benigna em idosos. Rev CEFAC. 2014;16(5):1533-40..

In relation to headaches or migraines, it was noticed that five (15,2%) individuals reported having one of these symptoms. However, in other studies headaches and/or migraines were prevailing symptoms, mainly in the condition in which dizziness and vertigo are associated2020. Cal R, Junior FB. Enxaqueca associada a disfunção auditivo-vestibular. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol. 2008;74(4):606-12.. Therefore, it is extremely important to distinguish if a worker presents complaints about headache and/or migraine associated with a condition of auditory-vestibular dysfunction, because if such situation is confirmed, it is possible that this individual feels loss of balance and nausea, mainly jeopardizing the professional who needs to work at height.

In relation to family medical history of labyrinth diseases, it is known that there might be a relation between familial predisposition and the presence of metabolic alterations, headache or migraine, circulatory dysfunctions and hormonal dysfunctions1212. Gorski LP, Andrade MS, Canto JD. Proposta de triagem do equilíbrio corporal aplicada a um grupo da terceira idade. Rev Salus. 2008;2(1):37-45., corroborating the findings in this study, in which seven (21,2%) of the 33 individuals that were analyzed reported having family history of these alterations.

In this study, it was noticed that eight (24,2%) workers use one or more medicines daily. This result corroborates the findings in other studies, which describe that collateral effects and the amount of medicine taken can contribute to and/or trigger dizziness2121. Maarsingh OR, Dros J, Schellevis FG, Weert HC van, Windt DA van der, Riet G, et al. Causes of Persistent Dizziness in Elderly Patients in Primary Care. Ann Fam Med. 2010;8(3):196-205.),(2222. Paulino CA, Doná F, Aprile MR. Ocorrência de queixas vestibulares e uso de medicamentos em adultos. Rev Equi Corp Saú. 2013;5(2):43-52..

In relation to caffeine, alcohol and nicotine consumption, it was noticed that 94% of the individuals reported using caffeine, 48,5% of them reported drinking alcohol and 27,3% of them reported using nicotine. According to other studies, caffeine has a diuretic effect and stimulant properties, making vertigo and tinnitus symptoms worse. Whereas alcohol affects the inner ear, altering the volume and concentration of its fluid, causing vestibulocochlear symptoms2323. Silva DF, Guimarães LC. Utilização da cafeína como ergogênico nutricional no exercício físico. Rev Cient UNIFOR. 2013;8(1):59-74.),(2424. Tavares C, Sakata RK. Cafeína para tratamento de dor. Rev Bras Anestesiol. 2012;62:387-401.. Studies show that nicotine has systemic effects, measured by nicotinic receptors, found in the central nervous system (CNS) (2525. Oliveira CB, Kniess CT, Dias LB, Bacaicoa MH. Estudo da nicotina através da quimioprevenção. Rev Ibirapuera. 2011;1(1):26-30., and it also has peripheral effects, ranging from headaches to diziness2626. Prezotto AO, Paulino CA, Aprile MR. Hábitos de vida, comobirdades e uso de medicamentos em idosas vestibulopatas. Rev Equil Corp Saú. 2010;2(2):2-15..

It is important to highlight that all altered screenings were only related to complaints of dizziness or tinnitus that were reported by the participants, and that alterations in vestibular tests were not found. No study was encountered in the literature on construction workers that took the same tests used in this research.

The workers were divided into four groups according to their complaints. Group 1 was composed of workers with no complaints about balance alteration and/or tinnitus. The individuals that only reported complaints of imbalance were included in group 2. Group 3 was composed of workers that only reported complaints about tinnitus. Group 4 gathered the individuals that reported complaints of balance alteration and tinnitus. The statistical analysis revealed significant statistical differences in G2 in relation to the variables of circulatory dysfunctions and/or heart diseases, regular use of medicines, caffeine consumption associated with alcohol consumption and headache/migraine. In G3, only the regular use of medicines was statistically significant. In G4, no significant statistical difference was found in none of the variables. Circulatory dysfunctions may cause peripheral and/or central damage in the auditory and/or vestibular systems44. Ganança FF, Gazzola JM, Aratani MC, Perracini MR, Ganança MM. Circunstâncias e consequências de quedas em idosos com vestibulopatias crônicas. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol. 2006;72(3):388-93., but it was not possible to find studies that relate such alteration with civil construction professionals. In this study, eight (24,2%) individuals use medicines to treat blood pressure, hypertension and cholesterol, similarly to other study that deals with an elderly population, and not with civil construction workers2626. Prezotto AO, Paulino CA, Aprile MR. Hábitos de vida, comobirdades e uso de medicamentos em idosas vestibulopatas. Rev Equil Corp Saú. 2010;2(2):2-15.. However, researches reporting the types of medicine most used by workers with complaints of balance and/tinnitus were not found in the literature. In relation to caffeine and alcohol consumption, it was observed that half (50%) of the workers with complaints of imbalance confirmed having such consumption. Studies that investigate the consumption of those substances in civil construction workers were not found, however, one study confirms the association between the presence of vestibular symptoms and regular caffeine ingestion2727. Felipe L, Simões LC, Gonçalves DU, Mancini PC. Avaliação do efeito da cafeína no teste vestibular. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol. 2005;71(6):758-62.. The prevalence of 50% of the individuals with headache or migraine corroborates other studies, which confirm the report of headache crisis in individuals with balance disorders, mainly during the most productive phase of life, between the ages of 30 and 392020. Cal R, Junior FB. Enxaqueca associada a disfunção auditivo-vestibular. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol. 2008;74(4):606-12.. Due to the fact that this situation is dealing with a young population that is entering the job market prematurely, it is very important to implement screening programs to detect individuals with balance disorders and, when necessary, to establish a diagnosis in order to refer individuals with complaints and altered results in their exams to an efficient treatment, decreasing the risks of serious accidents in civil construction.

It must be highlighted the fact that this research had a limited number of individuals and it lacked studies in this field to support it, considering that it is necessary to do new researches with a larger number of civil construction workers.

Conclusion

Alterations in positional and positioning nystagmus, static and dynamic balance tests, cerebellar exams, vestibular dynamics evaluation and in complementary investigation of the cranial nerves of civil construction workers that perform work at height were not found, nevertheless, the number of complaints related to balance and tinnitus was high, representing one third of the workers. It is recommended an otoneurological screening during periodic and entrance exams in these workers, in order to prevent risks of falls from heights and work accidents.

Acknowledgment

To the engineer Vinicius Milleo and the civil construction workers at the health campus of UFMG.

Appendix 1 - OTONEUROLOGICAL SCREENING

Referências

  • 1
    Flores FT, Rossi AG, Schmidt PS. Avaliação do equilíbrio corporal na doença de Parkinson. Arq Int Otorrinolaringol. 2011;15(2):142-50.
  • 2
    Kleiner AFR, Schlitter DXC, Arias MDRS. O papel dos sistemas visual, vestibular, somatossensorial e auditivo para o controle postural. Rev Neurocienc. 2011;19(2):349-57.
  • 3
    Hueb MM, Feliciano CP. Avaliação vertiginosa das síndromes vertiginosas. Rev Hosp Univ Pad Ern. 2012;11(3):23-35.
  • 4
    Ganança FF, Gazzola JM, Aratani MC, Perracini MR, Ganança MM. Circunstâncias e consequências de quedas em idosos com vestibulopatias crônicas. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol. 2006;72(3):388-93.
  • 5
    Scherer S, Lisboa HRK, Psqualotti A. Tontura em idosos: diagnostic otoneurológico e interferência na qualidade de vida. Rev Soc Bras Fonoaudiol. 2012;17(2):142-50.
  • 6
    Vieira AAU, Aprile MR, Paulino CA. Exercício físico, envelhecimento e queda em idosos: Revisão Narrativa. Rev Equi Corp Saú. 2014;6(1):25-33.
  • 7
    Teixeira CS, Korbes D, Rossi AG. Ruído e equilíbrio: aplicação da posturografia dinâmica em indústria gráfica. Rev CEFAC. 2011;13(1):92-101.
  • 8
    Firetti VL. Trabalho em altura: legislação, soluções e análise [monografia] Curitiba (Paraná): Universidade Tecnológica Federal do Paraná; 2013.
  • 9
    Lima JL. Avaliação em trabalho com andaime suspenso da conformidade com a NR 35 em obra de construção civil vertical [monografia]. Curitiba (Paraná): Universidade Tecnológica Federal do Paraná; 2013.
  • 10
    MTe: Ministério do Trabalho. NR-35 Trabalho em Altura. [citado em 27 de março de 2012]. Disponível em: http://portal.mte.gov.br/data/files/8A7C816A3D63C1A0013DAB8EA3975DDA/NR-35%20(Trabalho%20em%20Altura).pdf
    » http://portal.mte.gov.br/data/files/8A7C816A3D63C1A0013DAB8EA3975DDA/NR-35%20(Trabalho%20em%20Altura).pdf
  • 11
    Manual de auxílio na interpretação e aplicação da Norma Regulamentadora 35 Trabalhos em Altura - NR 35 Comentada. Disponível em http://www.sfiec.org.br/palestras/saude/sst-4jornada/1NR35comentada.pdf
    » http://www.sfiec.org.br/palestras/saude/sst-4jornada/1NR35comentada.pdf
  • 12
    Gorski LP, Andrade MS, Canto JD. Proposta de triagem do equilíbrio corporal aplicada a um grupo da terceira idade. Rev Salus. 2008;2(1):37-45.
  • 13
    Meira AL, Silva CB, Lorentz D, Barbosa KR, Almeida KN, Miranda LS. Verificação da aplicabilidade do Protocolo Ofício de Gestão de Diagnósticos Otoneurológicos. 27° Encontro Internacional de Audiologia; 14 a 17 de abril de 2012, Bauru; 2012 .
  • 14
    Zuma e Maia FC, Carmona S, Costa SS. Avaliação clínica do paciente vertiginoso. In: Zuma e Maia FC, Albernaz PLM, Carmona S. Otoneurologia Atual. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2014. p.25-51.
  • 15
    Ogido R, Costa EA, Machado HC. Prevalência de sintomas auditivos e vestibulares em trabalhadores expostos a ruído ocupacional. Rev Saúde Pública. 2009;43(2):377-80.
  • 16
    Silva ARP. Perfil dos operários da construção civil na cidade do Rio de Janeiro (Avaliação do nível de satisfação dos operários). IV Congresso Nacional em Gestão; 31 de julho a 02 de agosto de 2008, Rio de Janeiro.
  • 17
    DIEESE: Departamento Intersindical de estatística e estudos socioeconômicos. O trabalho por conta própria na construção civil. [citado fevereiro 2011]. Disponível em: http://www.dieese.org.br/boletimtrabalhoeconstrucao/2011/2011boletimConstrucaoCivil5.pdf
    » http://www.dieese.org.br/boletimtrabalhoeconstrucao/2011/2011boletimConstrucaoCivil5.pdf
  • 18
    DIEESE: Departamento Intersindical de estatística e estudos socioeconômicos. Perfil da construção civil no estado da Bahia. [citado em setembro 2012]. Disponível em: http://www.dieese.org.br/projetos/informalidade/perfilConstrucaoCivilBA.pdf
    » http://www.dieese.org.br/projetos/informalidade/perfilConstrucaoCivilBA.pdf
  • 19
    Moreira MD, Costa VSP, Melo JJ, Marchiori LLM. Prevalência e associações da vertigem posicional paroxística benigna em idosos. Rev CEFAC. 2014;16(5):1533-40.
  • 20
    Cal R, Junior FB. Enxaqueca associada a disfunção auditivo-vestibular. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol. 2008;74(4):606-12.
  • 21
    Maarsingh OR, Dros J, Schellevis FG, Weert HC van, Windt DA van der, Riet G, et al. Causes of Persistent Dizziness in Elderly Patients in Primary Care. Ann Fam Med. 2010;8(3):196-205.
  • 22
    Paulino CA, Doná F, Aprile MR. Ocorrência de queixas vestibulares e uso de medicamentos em adultos. Rev Equi Corp Saú. 2013;5(2):43-52.
  • 23
    Silva DF, Guimarães LC. Utilização da cafeína como ergogênico nutricional no exercício físico. Rev Cient UNIFOR. 2013;8(1):59-74.
  • 24
    Tavares C, Sakata RK. Cafeína para tratamento de dor. Rev Bras Anestesiol. 2012;62:387-401.
  • 25
    Oliveira CB, Kniess CT, Dias LB, Bacaicoa MH. Estudo da nicotina através da quimioprevenção. Rev Ibirapuera. 2011;1(1):26-30.
  • 26
    Prezotto AO, Paulino CA, Aprile MR. Hábitos de vida, comobirdades e uso de medicamentos em idosas vestibulopatas. Rev Equil Corp Saú. 2010;2(2):2-15.
  • 27
    Felipe L, Simões LC, Gonçalves DU, Mancini PC. Avaliação do efeito da cafeína no teste vestibular. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol. 2005;71(6):758-62.
  • Funding: Pró-reitoria de Pesquisa of Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    Jan-Feb 2016

History

  • Received
    14 Apr 2015
  • Accepted
    02 Nov 2015
ABRAMO Associação Brasileira de Motricidade Orofacial Rua Uruguaiana, 516, Cep 13026-001 Campinas SP Brasil, Tel.: +55 19 3254-0342 - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
E-mail: revistacefac@cefac.br