A1-Improving handoff communications in critical care: utilizing simulation-based training toward process improvement in managing patient risk13
2008/Israel Evidence: III |
Phase 1: retrospective, analysis of the causes of an adverse event Phase 2: prospective, intervention, quantitative N=390 handoffs (224 pre- and 166 post-intervention) |
To describe common flaws in the handoff process based on a retrospective analysis of an event, creating a handoff protocol and nursing team training-based simulations. |
After the intervention, the incidence of nurses communicating relevant information during handoffs increased, including patient name, events occurred in the last shift and treatment objectives for the following shift. No changes were found in the incidence of checking monitor alarms and mechanical ventilators. |
A2-A prospective observational study of physician handoff for intensive-care-unit-to-ward patient transfers14
2011/Canada Evidence: IV |
Observational, prospective and quantitative N=112 intensive-care-unit-to-ward patient transfers |
To understand the methods and quality of communication in handoffs between physicians in the ICU. |
Poor communication resulted in 13 medical errors and chaperone dissatisfaction relative to lack of knowledge about the patient’s clinical condition. |
A3-Falling through the cracks: information breakdowns in critical care handoff communication15
2011/USA Evidence: IV |
Qualitative, multi method Audio recordings of 80 handoffs; monitoring work flow of 30-40 professionals; |
To investigate communication flaws during handoffs |
Two factors contributed to information breakdown: lack of standardized communication during handoffs; inadequate preparation for handoff in the pre-handoff phase. |
A4-Standardized multidisciplinary protocol improves handover of cardiac surgery patients to the intensive care unit16
2011/USA Evidence: III |
Prospective, interventionist, and quantitative N=69 handoffs |
To assess pre- and post-intervention handoffs through direct observation based on a standardized instrument. |
Technical errors during handoffs decreased from 6.23 to 1.52; omission of critical information during handoffs fell from 6.33 to 2.38. Teamwork and handoff content improved. |
A5-Bridging gaps in handoff: A continuity of care based approach17
USA/2012 Evidence: IV |
Qualitative, multi method N=80 handoffs 30-40 ICU professionals |
To identify the nature and intrinsic characteristics of handoff phases and develop a framework for handoff communication in critical care. |
Three independent phases of the handoff process were identified: before, during, and after, which can result in the acceptance or rejection of information, or in the need for more information requested by information recipients. 52% of the information was accepted without any discussion, 4% was rejected. The remaining 44% required additional information, and of these, 33% was resolved when one of the team members complemented the information, whereas 11% was not immediately resolved and went into a team-based collaborative problem-solving cycle. |
A6-In search of common ground in handoff documentation in an Intensive Care Unit18
2012/USA Evidence: IV |
Observational, qualitative and documental N=22 instruments used by nurses and physicians |
To understand the structure, functionality, and content of handoff documentation used by nurses and physicians in an intensive care unit setting. |
There were overlaps in the documentation used by nurses and physicians. A user-centered semi-structured tool can help communication among professionals and improve patient safety. |
A7-Handover patterns: an observational study of critical care physicians19
2012/Canada Evidence: IV |
Observational, prospective and quantitative N=21 handoffs |
To describe handoff communication patterns used by the participating physicians in an ICU and compare them to widely promoted standardized handoff communication schemes. |
Intensive care physicians did not follow the commonly recommended communication standards; i.e., they did not use the same schemes and some elements were scattered and others absent during handoff. |
A8-Pilot implementation of a perioperative protocol to guide operating room-to-intensive care unit patient handoffs20
2012/USA Evidence: III |
Prospective, interventionist, and quantitative N=238 health professionals during 60 patient handoffs. |
To assess the impact of implementing a standardized handoff protocol in patient care and team satisfaction. |
After the intervention, the presence of all group members at the bedside increased from 0% to 68%. The percentage of lost information on surgery reports fell from 26% to 16%. The protocol reduced the risk of losing information and promoted satisfaction among the perioperative team. |
A9-Understanding current intensive care unit nursing handover practices9
2013/Australia Evidence: IV |
Observational, prospective and quantitative N=20 handoffs involving 40 nurses (20 transferring and 20 receiving) |
To assess the content and completeness of the intensive care unit nursing shift-to-shift handoff. |
Flaws in communication included: absence of current clinical condition at handoff; discharge and long-term plans were present in 40% of handoffs; reading over charts together with professionals receiving handoffs occurred in 35% of the cases, and cross-referencing data occurred in 40% of the analyzed handoffs. |
A10-Failures in transition: learning from incidents relating to clinical handover in acute care21
2013/Australia Evidence: IV |
Observational, cross-sectional, quantitative, descriptive N=459 events occurred between 2004-2008 in acute care units. |
To analyze the characteristics, contributing factors and detection mechanisms of failures associated with handoffs in acute care settings. |
The most common failures were: inadequate handoff (28%); omission of critical information about the patient’s condition (19%); and omission of critical information about patient care plan (14%). |
A11-Differences in the handover process and perception between nurses and residents in a critical care setting22
2014/Singapore Evidence: IV |
Quantitative, descriptive N=580 (290 resident physicians and 290 nurses. |
To identify differences in handoff practices and perceptions between nurses and residents in critical care units. |
Among the providers, nurses were more concerned with the complexity of the patient’s health condition than residents. Among recipients, nurses considered medical history the most useful information (12%), while among residents, the 48-hour care management plan was perceived as the most useful. |
A12-Are attendings different? intensivists explain their handoff ideals, perceptions, and practices23
2014/USA Evidence: IV |
Qualitative, descriptive N=30 intensivists |
To characterize attending intensivists handoff practices and determine the ideal aspects of handoffs from the perspective of attending physicians. |
Standardized practices were rare. Handoff practices included: telephone conversations, in-person communications, e-mail or text messages. The “ideal handoff”: succinct and organized, face to face, including verbal and written communication about patient trajectory. |
A13-Comparative evaluation of the content and structure of communication using two handoff tool: Implications for patient safety24
2014/USA Evidence: III |
Interventionist, prospective, quanti-qualitative N=82 handoffs (41 with each tool) |
To compare two handoff tools: SOAP and HAND-IT. Groups of five professionals worked with one of the tools for 1 month and then switched. |
Comparative assessment between the two handoff tools: SOAP and HAND-IT, showed that HAND-IT generated fewer communication errors. |
A14-Transferring patient care: patterns of synchronous bidisciplinary communication between physicians and nurses during handoffs in a critical care unit25
2015/Canada Evidence: IV |
Qualitative, descriptive, observational N=40 handoffs |
To characterize the flow of information during handoffs and identify patterns of communication between anesthesiologists and nurses in a postoperative critical care unit. |
The presence of patient history (42%) and intraoperative events (39%) was more frequent, while patient condition (8%) and care plan (9%) were less so. Searching for information by asking questions was more common regarding patient condition (46%) and care plan (29%). |
A15-Face-to-face handoff: improving transfer to the pediatric intensive care unit after cardiac surgery26
2015/USA Evidence: III |
Prospective, interventionist and quantitative N=79 handoffs |
To develop and implement a handoff process, improving forms of communication, which begins in the operating room and ends at the ICU bedside. |
Before the handoff instrument, 58% of the professionals believed the process was efficient; 53% felt comfortable asking questions; 19% believed the process improved care. After the intervention, these percentages were 69%, 75%, and 94%, respectively. |