Record of cleaning behavior by Platydoras costatus (Siluriformes: Doradidae) in the Amazon Basin, Brazil

SCIENTIFIC NOTES

Record of cleaning behavior by Platydoras costatus (Siluriformes: Doradidae) in the Amazon Basin, Brazil

Lucélia Nobre Carvalho^I; Rafael Arruda^II; Jansen Zuanon^III

^IInstituto de Biologia, Caixa Postal 593, Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, 38400-902 Uberlândia, Minas Gerais, Brazil

^IIPrograma de Pós-Graduação em Ecologia e Conservação de Recursos Naturais, Caixa Postal 593, Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, 38400-902 Uberlândia, Minas Gerais, Brazil

^IIIInstituto Nacional de Pesquisas da Amazônia (INPA), Caixa Postal 478, 69011-970 Manaus, AM, Brazil. e-mail: [e-mail]

ABSTRACT

Records of cleaning symbiosis between freshwater fish are scarce. Here we report on juvenile catfish, Platydoras costatus, cleaning the piscivorous characin Hoplias cf. malabaricus in a stream of the rio Araguaia drainage in the Brazilian Amazon. The scarcity of records on cleaning behavior in freshwater systems seems to be in part a consequence of the few observational studies under natural conditions in the Neotropics. Otherwise, the rareness of this behavior in freshwaters is possibly related to the short evolutionary time available to the fish fauna to develop these complex interactions, when compared to the ocean environment.

Key words: Erythrinidae, Hoplias cf. malabaricus, piscivorous client, juvenile cleaner, rio Araguaia.

RESUMO

Registros de simbiose de limpeza entre peixes dulcícolas são raros. No presente trabalho registramos um juvenil de Platydoras costatus, limpando uma traíra, Hoplias cf. malabaricus em um riacho do rio Araguaia, Bacia Amazônica. A escassez de registros de comportamento de limpeza em peixes de água doce parece ser uma conseqüência dos poucos estudos subaquáticos nos Neotrópicos. Por outro lado, a raridade deste comportamento em ambientes dulcícolas está possivelmente relacionada ao curto tempo evolutivo disponível para o desenvolvimento de interações complexas, quando comparada ao ambiente marinho.

Cleaning symbiosis is defined as an interspecific cooperative interaction, in which a micro-carnivore (cleaner) forage on the body of other fishes (clients), the latter thus getting rid of ectoparasites and diseased tissue, and receives tactile stimulation (Losey, 1971, 1987; Côté, 2000). This type of complex interspecific interaction is widespread in the marine environment, especially coral reefs (Limbaugh, 1961; Losey, 1987; Côté, 2000). Although most records came from the Pacific, recent studies have shown that this interaction is well diversified in southwestern Atlantic (Sazima et al., 2000, and references therein). On the other hand, records on cleaning activity in freshwaters are relatively rare, and include cleaners in several families, such as Callichthyidae (Wickler, 1956), Cyprinidae and Percidae (Abel, 1971), Centrarchidae (Sulak, 1975) Cichlidae (Ward & Wyman, 1977; Konings, 1989) and even Serrasalmidae, the piranhas (Sazima & Machado, 1990).

Here we report on an instance of a possible cleaning symbiosis between two freshwater fishes a juvenile catfish, Platydoras costatus (Doradidae) and Hoplias cf. malabaricus (Erythrinidae) in a tributary of the rio Araguaia, Amazon basin, Brazil. Additionally, we comment on some possible reasons for the apparent rareness of cleaning records in freshwaters and predict that additional instances of this interaction will be found with further studies in environments amenable to underwater observation.

Field work was done in São José dos Bandeirantes (13°41’S 50°47’W), Nova Crixá, Goiás, western Brazil, in a clearwater stream tributary of the rio Araguaia, Amazon basin, in May 2002. The study site was a still water stretch of the stream 20 m wide and 35 cm deep. The bottom was sandy, with submersed logs and trunks. We recorded the behavioral sequences from the stream bank at about 1.5 m from the fishes using "all occurrences" and "focal animal" sampling in 25 min of direct observation (Lehner, 1996). Size of fishes throughout the text refers to total length (TL).

Two juvenile Raphael catfishes, Platydoras costatus, about The strongly contrasting black and white coloration of 7 cm TL were recorded foraging on the surface of a young P. costatus may be regarded as a signal that allows for periphyton-covered submerged log. On the bottom near the its recognition as a cleaner. Contrasting color pattern is log two traíras, Hoplias cf. malabaricus, about 30 cm TL recurrent among specialized marine cleaners, which attend were resting. After about 15 min of the observation session, potentially dangerous clients (Potts, 1973; Sazima et al., one Raphael catfish moved directly to the nearest traíra, 1999; Côté, 2000). The contrasting coloration of P. costatus positioning itself on the flank of the larger fish. It stayed (confer picture of juvenile in www.fishbase.org) fades as it there for about 40 sec foraging in a way similar to that grows, the white lines becoming more yellowish and blurred observed on the trunk. Afterwards, it moved towards the head (www.fishbase.org, see picture of adult). This ontogenetic of the traíra close to its mouth (Fig. 1), where it remained for change indicates that the cleaning behavior is probably another 15 sec probing the surface with its barbels and restricted to the juvenile phase. Platydoras costatus is an mouthing. Then the catfish returned to the back of the traíra omnivore tending towards carnivory (J. Zuanon, pers. obs.). for another 30 sec, moving along the fish body while touching The adult diet strengthens the view that P. costatus is a it with its mouth and barbels. After this supposed cleaning facultative cleaner, and that this catfish shifts its diet as it session, the catfish left the traíra and returned to the log and resumed its foraging on it.

We observed no further interactions between P. costatus and H. cf. malabaricus, and the latter eventually drifted away. During our observation session, the traíras remained in the same position recorded initially {although a traíra chased an individual of Hoplerythrinus unitaeniatus about 12 cm TL that approached the resting couple}.

Although we observed a single event, this seems to be the first record of a freshwater catfish acting as a cleaner under natural conditions (but see Wickler, 1956, for a record of Corydoras as a cleaner under aquarium conditions). The cleaning behavior of this doradid catfish differs from that of some conspicuously patterned marine cleaners such as the labrids Thalassoma bifasciatum and T. noronhanum (Darcy et al., 1974; Francini-Filho et al., 2000). Both cleaners show clear preference for non-dangerous clients, and the latter one approach potentially dangerous clients mostly from behind and uses the "hit and run" cleaning behavior (Francini-Filho et al., 2000). However, we observed that the doradid P. costatus does not seem to adopt any behavior that would indicate that it perceives its piscivorous client as a threat, which may indicate a specialized relation between the two fishes.

The strongly contrasting black and white coloration of young P. costatus may be regarded as a signal that allows for its recognition as a cleaner. Contrasting color pattern is recurrent among specialized marine cleaners, which attend potentially dangerous clients (Potts, 1973; Sazima et al., 1999; Côté, 2000). The contrasting coloration of P. costatus (confer picture of juvenile in www.fishbase.org) fades as it grows, the white lines becoming more yellowish and blurred (www.fishbase.org, see picture of adult). This ontogenetic change indicates that the cleaning behavior is probably restricted to the juvenile phase. Platydoras costatus is an omnivore tending towards carnivory (J. Zuanon, pers. obs.). The adult diet strengthens the view that P. costatus is a facultative cleaner, and that this catfish shifts its diet as it grows, as often observed in several marine fish species (see review in Côté, 2000). Hoplias is an ambush predator that forages mainly at twilight, and during daytime it mostly remains stationary in shallow marginal areas, camouflaged among plant detritus on the bottom (Sabino & Zuanon, 1998). The diurnal inactivity of this predator may have facilitated the cleaning interaction, in a way similar to that described for the possible evolution of cleaning symbiosis between cleaning gobies and some sharks and rays (Sazima & Moura, 2000).

The two species recorded here interacting are nocturnal (P. costatus) or crepuscular to nocturnal (Hoplias cf. malabaricus) (Burgess, 1989; Sabino & Zuanon, 1998). Our daytime record of cleaning activity strengthens the view that this interaction type is visually mediated, at least at its beginning (Côté, 2000). Additionally, the armor of lateral bony plates with hooks, as well as pectoral and dorsal spines, may provide additional protection for P. costatus, and may have facilitated the first steps in the evolution of a cleaning interaction with a potentially dangerous client.

The rareness of cleaning behavior among freshwater fishes is possibly related to the short evolutionary time available to the fish fauna to develop these complex interactions, when compared to the ocean environment. Also, we believe that the relatively low number of records on complex interactions in freshwaters, including cleaning and mimicry, is due to the still few observational studies under natural conditions in the Neotropics (Sazima, 1986; Sabino & Zuanon, 1998; Sabino, 1999). Thus, we anticipate that new instances will be reported as additional studies, particularly underwater ones, proceed. The evidence that visual contact is of utmost importance for these interspecific interactions also indicates that these records are to be expected in clear waters (see Sazima, 1986, for this view). Additionally, local species richness will likely increase the occurrence of this type of interactions. In the Amazon area, clear waters and high fish species richness occur in the Xingu, Tapajós, Trombetas, and Tocantins drainages, and the lesser watersheds are promising candidates for the occurrence of additional instances of cleaning and other complex interactions between fishes.

Acknowledgements

We thank André L. Q. Santos for logistic assistance; Christian Westerkamp for improving the English and for critical comments on the manuscript; Ivan Sazima and Andréa Araujo for critically reviewing the manuscript, and Rubem S. Ávila Jr. for the drawing.

Literature Cited

Received June 17, 2003

Accepted October 31, 2003

• Abel, E. F. 1971. Zur Ethologie von Putzsymbiosen einheimischer Süßwasserfische im natürlichen Biotop. Oecologia, 6: 133-151.
• Burgess, W. E. 1989. An atlas of freshwater and marine catfishes: a preliminary survey of the Siluriformes. T.F.H. Publications, Neptune City. 784 p.
• Côté, I. M. 2000. Evolution and ecology of cleaning symbiosis in the sea. Pp. 311-355. In: Gibson, R. N. & M. Barnes (Eds.). Oceanography and Marine Biology: An Annual Review. Vol. 38. Taylor and Francis, London.
• Darcy, G., E. H. Maisel & T. C. Ogden. 1974. Cleaning preferences of the gobies Gobiosoma evelynae and G. prochilos and the juvenile wrasse Thalassoma bifascia tum Copeia, 1974: 375-379.
• Francini-Filho, R. B., R. L. Moura & I. Sazima. 2000. Cleaning by the wrasse Thalassoma noronhanum, with two records of predation by its grouper client Cephalopholis fulva Journal of Fish Biology, 56(4): 802-809.
• Konings, A. 1989. Malawi cichlids in their natural habitat. Verduijn Cichlids & Lake Fish Movies, Zevenhuizen, Holland. 303 p.
• Lehner, P. N. 1996. Handbook of ethological methods. 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 672 p.
• Limbaugh, C. 1961. Cleaning symbiosis. Scientific American, 205(2): 42-49.
• Losey, G. S. 1971. Communication between fishes in cleaning symbiosis. Pp. 45-76. In: Cheng, T.C. (Ed). Aspects of the biology of symbiosis. University Park Press. Baltimore.
• Losey, G. S. 1987. Cleaning symbiosis. Symbiosis, 4: 229-258.
• Potts, G. W. 1973. The ethology of Labroides dimidiatus (Cuv. & Val.) (Labridae) on Aldabra. Animal Behaviour, 21(2): 250-291.
• Sabino, J. 1999. Behavior of stream fishes: methods for a naturalistic approach. Pp. 183-208. In: Caramaschi, E.P., Mazzoni, R. & Peres-Neto, P.R. (Eds.). Oecologia Brasiliensis: Stream Fishes Ecology. Vol 6. PPG-UFRJ, Rio de Janeiro.
• Sabino, J. & J. Zuanon. 1998. A stream fish assemblage in central Amazonia: distribution, activity patterns and feeding behavior. Ichthyological Exploration of Freshwaters, 8(3): 201-210.
• Sazima, I. 1986. Similarities in feeding behaviour between some marine and freshwater fishes in two tropical communities. Journal of Fish Biology, 29(1): 53-65.
• Sazima, I. & F. A. Machado. 1990. Underwater observations of piranhas in Western Brazil. Environmental Biology of Fishes, 28: 17-31.
• Sazima, I. & R. L. Moura. 2000. Shark (Carcharhinus perezi), cleaned by the goby (Elacatinus randalli), at Fernando de Noronha Archipelago, Western South Atlantic. Copeia, 2000(1): 297-299.
• Sazima, I., R. L. Moura & C. Sazima. 1999. Cleaning activity of juvenile angelfish, Pomacanthus paru, on the reefs of the Abrolhos Archipelago, western South Atlantic. Environmental Biology of Fishes, 56(4): 399-407.
• Sazima, I., C. Sazima, R. B. Francini-Filho & R. L. Moura. 2000. Daily cleaning activity and diversity of clients of the barber goby, Elacatinus figaro, on rocky reefs in southeastern Brazil. Environmental Biology of Fishes, 59(1): 69-77.
• Sulak, K. J. 1975. Cleaning behaviour in the centrarchid fishes, Lepomis macrochirus and Micropterus salmoides Animal Behaviour, 23(2): 331-334.
• Ward, J. A. & Wyman, R. L. 1977. Ethology and ecology of cichlid fishes of the genus Etroplus in Sri Lanka: preliminary findings. Environmental Biology of Fishes, 2(2): 137-145.
• Wickler, V. W. 1956. Eine Putzsymbiose zwischen Corydoras und Trichogaster Zugleich ein Beitrag zur Klärung der Frage, wie Ausdrucksbewegungen entstehen. Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie, 13(1): 46-49.

Publication Dates

• Publication in this collection
  02 Jan 2008
• Date of issue
  Dec 2003

History

• Accepted
  31 Oct 2003
• Received
  17 July 2003