Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

Effects of Pilates Method on women's static body posture: a systematic review

ABSTRACT

The Pilates Method provides improvement in flexibility, coordination and muscle strength, which can reflect the postural alignment. In this sense, the objective of this study was to verify the level of scientific evidence from randomized controlled trials and nonrandomized that evaluated the influence of Pilates Method in postural alignment women when compared to a control group or other intervention based on a systematic review (CRD42015026518). A search was carried out between 25 and 29 September 2015 at BIREME, EMBASE, PEDro, PubMed, Scielo, Science Direct, Scopus and Web of Science, without language restriction and date. For selecting studies, two reviewers applied independently eligibility criteria: exclusive sample of women; intervention with Pilates Method in a group and presence of comparator; variable outcome static body posture; clinical trials. Reviewers obtained data about the studies (participants, intervention and outcomes), applied the methodological quality scale PEDro and determined the strength of the evidence through Best Evidence Synthesis. Four studies were included, three with high quality, but due to the divergence of results there is no scientific evidence about the effects of the Method in postural alignment. The results suggest that from 24 sessions of Pilates Method, applied twice a week, adjustments occur in the frontal alignment of the shoulders and sagittal of the pelvis in adults. And, after 48 sessions, adds to the improvement in the sagittal alignment of the head. In older, 60 sessions of Pilates Method appear to be effective in reducing the angle of kyphosis thoracic and cervical-thoracic distance, increasing height.

Keywords:
Exercise Therapy; Posture; Women; Review

RESUMO

O Método Pilates proporciona melhora na flexibilidade, coordenação e força muscular, podendo refletir no alinhamento postural. Nesse sentido, o objetivo desse estudo foi verificar o nível de evidência científica dos ensaios clínicos randomizados e não randomizados que avaliaram a influência desse Método no alinhamento postural de mulheres quando comparados a um grupo controle ou outra intervenção através de uma revisão sistemática (CRD42015026518). Foi realizada uma busca entre 25 e 29 de setembro de 2015 nas bases BIREME, EMBASE, PEDro, PubMed, SciELO, Science Direct, Scopus e Web of Science, sem restrição de idioma e data. Para seleção dos estudos, dois revisores aplicaram, independentemente, os critérios de elegibilidade: amostra exclusiva de mulheres; intervenção com o Método Pilates em um grupo e presença de comparador; variável de desfecho a postura corporal estática; ensaios clínicos. Os revisores obtiveram dados acerca dos estudos (participantes, intervenção e resultados), aplicaram a escala de qualidade metodológica PEDro e determinaram a força da evidência pela Melhor Síntese de Evidência. Quatro estudos foram incluídos, sendo três com elevada qualidade, porém devido à divergência de resultados não há evidências científicas acerca dos efeitos do Método Pilates no alinhamento postural. Os resultados sugerem que a partir de 24 sessões desse Método, praticadas duas vezes por semana, ocorrem ajustes nos alinhamentos frontal dos ombros e sagital da pelve, em mulheres adultas, e que após 48 sessões soma-se a melhora no alinhamento sagital da cabeça. Em idosas, sessenta sessões desse Método parecem ser efetivas na redução do ângulo da cifose torácica e da distância cérvico-torácica, aumentando a estatura.

Descritores:
Terapia por Exercício; Postura; Mulheres; Revisão

RESUMEN

El Método Pilates mejora la flexibilidad, coordinación y fuerza muscular, y puede traer como consecuencia la alienación postural. En este sentido, el propósito de este texto es verificar el nivel de evidencia científica de estudios clínicos aleatorios y no aleatorios, que evaluaron la influencia de este Método para la alienación postural de mujeres cuando comparados a un grupo control y otra intervención a través de una revisión sistemática (CRD42015026518). Se realizó una búsqueda entre 25 y 29 de septiembre de 2015 en las bases de datos BIREME, EMBASE, PEDro, PubMed, SciELO, Science Direct, Scopus y Web of Science, sin cualquier restricción de fecha e idioma. Para la recolección de datos, dos revisores aplicaron de manera independiente criterios de elegibilidad: muestras solo de mujeres; intervención con el Método Pilates en un grupo y presencia de comparador; variable de resultado, postura corporal estática; estudios clínicos. Los revisores tuvieron acceso a los datos sobre los estudios (participantes, intervención y resultados), aplicaron la escala de calidad metodológica PEDro y establecieron la fuerza de evidencia por la Mejor Síntesis de Evidencia. Se incluyeron cuatro estudios, siendo tres con alto nivel de calidad, sin embargo, debido a las divergencias de resultados no fueron encontradas evidencias científicas sobre los efectos de este Método en la alienación postural. Los resultados evidencian que la práctica de más de 24 sesiones, dos veces a la semana, puede posibilitar correcciones en las alienaciones frontal de los hombros y sagital de la pelvis, en mujeres adultas, y que tras 48 sesiones se añade la mejora en la alienación sagital de la cabeza. En adultos mayores son necesarias sesenta sesiones para reducir el ángulo de la cifosis torácica y de la distancia cervical y torácica, aumentando, así, la estatura.

Palabras clave:
Terapia por Ejercicio; Postura; Mujeres; Revisión

INTRODUCTION

Pilates Method uses the body as a mediator of physical and mental development, with emphasis on concentration, awareness, and quality of movements11. De Souza MCS, Vieira CB. Who are the people looking for the Pilates method? J Body Mov Ther. 2006;10(4):328-34.), (22. Di Lorenzo CE. Pilates: what is it? Should it be used in rehabilitation? Sports Health. 2011;3(4):352-61.. It includes muscle stretching and strengthening exercises33. Gallagher S, Kryzanowska R. Método pilates de condicionamento físico. São Paulo: The Pilates Studio do Brasil; 2000.), (44. Kolyniak I, Cavalcanti S, Aoki M. Avaliação isocinética da musculatura envolvida na flexão e extensão do tronco: efeito do método Pilates. Rev Bras Med Esporte. 2004;10(6):487-90. performed in specific equipment or on the floor; it involves concentric, eccentric and, mainly, isometric contractions, highlighting the recruitment of powerhouse muscles, which are responsible for stabilization of the body55. Marés G, Oliveira KB, Piazza MC, Preis C, Bertassoni Neto L. A importância da estabilização central no método Pilates: uma revisão sistemática. Fisioter Mov. 2012;25(2):445-51..

In the health sphere, Pilates Method has been used for the development of constraining physical abilities, therapeutic purposes, posture alignment, welfare, and mental discipline66. Emery K, De Serres SJ, McMillan A, Côté JN. The effects of a Pilates training program on arm-trunk posture and movement. Clin Biomech. 2010;25(2):124-30.), (77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.. Whereas Pilates Method prioritizes the activation of postural muscles, professionals believe that the systematic practice of Pilates Method may promote positive adjustments in posture alignment88. Latey P. The Pilates method: history and philosophy. J Body Mov Ther . 2001;5(4):275-82.. Posture alignment refers to a state of joint balance, being determined by the relationship between body segments and the force necessary to stabilize joints and promote symmetrical movements99. Kendall FP, McCreary EK, Provance PG, Rodgers MM, Romani WA. Músculos: provas e funções. 5ª ed. São Paulo: Manole; 2007..

On the other hand, postural imbalances arising from repeated kinetic patterns can cause a decrease in flexibility and muscle shortenings1010. Molinari B. Avaliação médica e física: para atletas e praticantesde atividade físicas. São Paulo: Roca; 2000., which bring consequences harmful to the support and mobility function of the body as a whole1111. Santos CIS, Cunha ABN, Braga VP, Saad IAB, Ribeiro MAGO, Conti PBM, et al. Ocorrência de desvios posturais em escolares do ensino público fundamental de Jaguariúna, São Paulo. Rev Paul Pediatr. 2009;27(1):74-80.. In view of the increased incidence of postural deviations and related problems in recent years1212. Fejer R, Kyvik KO, Hartvigsen J. The prevalence of neck pain in the world population: a systematic critical review of the literature. Eur Spine J. 2006;15(6):834-48.), (1313. Bispo Júnior JP. Fisioterapia e saúde coletiva: desafios e novas responsabilidades profissionais. Cien Saude Coletiva. 2010;15(Suppl 1):1627-36., using Pilates Method as a form of intervention in the development of postural balance is highlighted.

Despite the importance of intervention on postural deviations, Cruz-Ferreira et al. (1414. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Laranjo L, Bernardo LM, Silva A. A systematic review of the effects of Pilates method of exercise in healthy people. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2011;92(12):2071-81. mention in their review that there is no evidence about the effects of the Pilates Method on posture alignment, in such a way that health care professionals prescribe exercises of the Pilates Method based on practice. However, they included studies with heterogeneous samples and several methodologies, making unfeasible the specific conclusion of effects relate to gender and age group. Thus, the aim of this study was to verify the level of scientific evidence of randomized and nonrandomized clinical trials that evaluated the influence of Pilates Method on women's posture alignment when compared with a control group or with other intervention.

METHODOLOGY

Type of study and search strategies

This study comprised a systematic review of the literature, which was registered in PROSPERO under number CRD42015026518. Systematic searches were conducted between September 25 and 29, 2015, at BIREME, EMBASE, Physiotherapy Evidence Database (PEDro), PubMed, Scielo, Science Direct, SCOPUS, and Web of Science databases. Search terms used, with their respective Boolean operators, were "Women AND Exercise Movement Techniques OR Pilates AND Posture". The search strategy used at PubMed can be observed in Table 1. In addition, no language and publication date restrictions were used, and studies were identified from the references of included studies.

Table 1
PubMed search strategy

Selection of studies

Two researchers independently selected potentially relevant studies based on titles and abstracts. When the latter did not provide enough information to exclude the study, the complete text was verified. Then, the same reviewers independently evaluated complete studies and made the selection according to eligibility criteria, which were: (1) intervention based on the Pilates Method in at least one group, in addition to presenting control group (without intervention or submitted to another practice); (2) the outcome variable considered was the static body posture, assuming its equivalence with static posture alignment; (3) studies should be randomized or nonrandomized clinical trials; and (4) the sample should be composed only of women. The discordant cases were resolved by consensus or by a third researcher1515. Van Tulder MW, Koes BW, Bouter LM. Conservative treatment of acute and chronic nonspecific low back pain: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials of the most common interventions. Spine. 1997;22(18):2128-56..

Data extraction, quality analysis, and risk of bias

Only included studies were submitted to data extraction, quality analysis, and risk of bias. Extracted information included authors' name, publication year, participants (total and per group, age), intervention and evaluation protocol, and results of interest. Evaluation of quality and risk of bias was independently performed by two researchers through PEDro scale, which consists of 11 criteria, being the score of each criterion only assigned if the same was clearly satisfied1616. Costa C, Cabri J. Escala de PEDro. [Internet]. [citado 16 abr 2015]. Disponível em: http://www.pedro.org.au/portuguese/downloads/pedro-scale/
http://www.pedro.org.au/portuguese/downl...
. This scale score ranges from zero to 10, due to the fact that the participants' eligibility is not part of the total ammount1717. Shiwa SR, Costa LOP, Moser ADL, Aguiar ID, Oliveira LVF. PEDro: a base de dados de evidências em fisioterapia. Fisioter Mov . 2011;24(3):523-33.. It is worth mentioning that in studies involving physical activity oriented as a form of intervention, as in the case of this review, the maximum score to be obtained is eight, since it is not possible to blind subjects and therapists. As PEDro scale does not provide cutting values, we used as parameters the sum less than seven for low quality, and sum higher than or equal to seven for high quality1414. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Laranjo L, Bernardo LM, Silva A. A systematic review of the effects of Pilates method of exercise in healthy people. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2011;92(12):2071-81.), (1717. Shiwa SR, Costa LOP, Moser ADL, Aguiar ID, Oliveira LVF. PEDro: a base de dados de evidências em fisioterapia. Fisioter Mov . 2011;24(3):523-33..

Data synthesis and analysis

Due to insufficient data, the diversity of types of intervention and different outcomes, a statistical analysis could not be performed. Thus, a summary of the characteristics of studies and outcomes was presented in a chart (Chart 1). Descriptive analysis of the results was also presented in topics. The strength of the scientific evidence was analyzed qualitatively by the Best Evidence synthesis (BES), based on four levels1515. Van Tulder MW, Koes BW, Bouter LM. Conservative treatment of acute and chronic nonspecific low back pain: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials of the most common interventions. Spine. 1997;22(18):2128-56.: (1) strong evidence, consistent findings in multiple high-quality tests; (2) moderate evidence, consistent findings in a trial of high quality and/or one or more low-quality trials; (3) limited evidence, consistent findings in one or more low-quality trials; (4) no or insufficient evidence, if no trial was found, or if results are conflicting.

Chart 1
Descriptive characteristics of studies included

RESULTS

Selection of studies

The initial search identified 143 articles, of which six were detailed analyzed. Of these, two were excluded for not including women only. However, four were considered potentially relevant. Figure 1 demonstrates the flowchart of the included studies, and Chart 1 summarizes the characteristics of these studies.

Figure 1
Flowchart of studies included in the systematic review

Quality analysis and risk of bias

The score of PEDro scale (Table 2) varied between three and eight. The study that obtained the lowest value was considered of low quality1919. Donahoe-Fillmore B, Hanahan NM, Mescher ML, Clapp ED, Addison NR., Weston CR. The effects of a home Pilates program on muscle performance and posture in healthy females: a pilot study. J Womens Health Phys Therap. 2007;31(2):6-11.. Remaining studies77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.), (1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.), (2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33. were considered of high quality; the criteria more frequently met were the subject's distribution randomness, similarity and initial evaluation of the groups, blinding of the reviewers, acceptance of intervention, and analysis and presentation of results.

Table 2
Evaluation according to PEDro scale. We excluded criteria 5 and 6 concerning blind participation in the study

Based on the results reported in Chart 1 and Table 2, we may affirm that there is no scientific evidence to promote the use of Pilates Method for women's posture alignment benefits. Although, among the four studies reviewed, two high-quality studies have shown that the method is able to promote general effects on posture alignment1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.), (2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33.; and a high-quality study found no changes77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.. Hence, results are conflicting.

DISCUSSION

Research on the effects of Pilates Method practice on static posture alignment present methodological differences, but do not make their comparisons unfeasible. Regarding the sample, three studies were conducted predominantly with young adult women77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.), (1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.), (1919. Donahoe-Fillmore B, Hanahan NM, Mescher ML, Clapp ED, Addison NR., Weston CR. The effects of a home Pilates program on muscle performance and posture in healthy females: a pilot study. J Womens Health Phys Therap. 2007;31(2):6-11.. Regarding quality, three studies were highly rated, being these conducted with more than 30 individuals77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.), (1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.), (2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33., however, only one had exclusively chosen female older adults2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33.. Donahoe-Fillmore et al. (1919. Donahoe-Fillmore B, Hanahan NM, Mescher ML, Clapp ED, Addison NR., Weston CR. The effects of a home Pilates program on muscle performance and posture in healthy females: a pilot study. J Womens Health Phys Therap. 2007;31(2):6-11. also focused on the young adult age group, but conducted a low-quality study, with only 11 individuals, and we must be careful when interpreting the results of their study.

In the intervention, three studies adopted Pilates Method exercises on the floor77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.), (1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.), (1919. Donahoe-Fillmore B, Hanahan NM, Mescher ML, Clapp ED, Addison NR., Weston CR. The effects of a home Pilates program on muscle performance and posture in healthy females: a pilot study. J Womens Health Phys Therap. 2007;31(2):6-11. and only one study added equipment2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33.. The preference may be due to low cost, ease of performance regarding physical space, and the fact that the exercises can be taught in larger groups. In addition, overall, the exercises were instructed by trained professionals and performed under supervision; only Donahoe-Fillmore et al. (19 used videotapes and initial instructions in their intervention, being the practice performed individually at home.

The exercises performed by the experimental group are not clearly described in the studies77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.), (1919. Donahoe-Fillmore B, Hanahan NM, Mescher ML, Clapp ED, Addison NR., Weston CR. The effects of a home Pilates program on muscle performance and posture in healthy females: a pilot study. J Womens Health Phys Therap. 2007;31(2):6-11.), (2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33.. Only Cruz-Ferreira et al.1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611. briefly mention the performance of 34 floor-based exercises proposed by Joseph Pilates, focusing on pelvic and scapular stability, mobility of the spine, and stretching. The lack of information about the intervention makes it difficult to compare the results obtained by the studies, as well as the extrapolation for conducting other studies with the same protocol, or even, the guidance for clinical practice.

The frequency of sessions, mostly, consisted of two weekly interventions with duration of 60 minutes77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.), (1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.), (2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33.. Only one study1919. Donahoe-Fillmore B, Hanahan NM, Mescher ML, Clapp ED, Addison NR., Weston CR. The effects of a home Pilates program on muscle performance and posture in healthy females: a pilot study. J Womens Health Phys Therap. 2007;31(2):6-11. conducted three sessions per week, in addition to being the only one to include another therapy in the experimental group and to intervene with the control group with initial instructions for postural education.

Photogrammetry was the postural evaluation method consensually adopted77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.), (1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.)-(2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33., although it differs regarding anatomical points of interest and analysis. For instance, Donahoe-Fillmore et al. (1919. Donahoe-Fillmore B, Hanahan NM, Mescher ML, Clapp ED, Addison NR., Weston CR. The effects of a home Pilates program on muscle performance and posture in healthy females: a pilot study. J Womens Health Phys Therap. 2007;31(2):6-11. evaluated only the pelvic alignment in the sagittal plane, and did not observe any differences after 30 sessions of the Pilates Method.

Junges et al. (2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33. photographs of sagittal planes (right and left profiles) were acquired to investigate cervical-thoracic and front (back and front) distances to analyze the height of shoulders and shoulder blades, but they did not specify the anatomical points demarcated. After 60 intervention sessions, the group submitted to Pilates Method showed decreased cervical-thoracic distance in the sagittal plane, increased shoulder height and shoulder blades in the back posture, and stature gain. In addition, they used x-rays to measure Cobb angle of thoracic kyphosis, which significantly reduced after practicing the Pilates Method. However, it is worth noting that the average difference of eight Cobb degrees (pre 63.50 ± 9.78° and post 55.50 ± 11.97°) found by the authors, despite being statistically significant (p < 0.001), may present no clinical relevance if we consider the reference adopted by the authors - that a normal kyphosis presents Cobb angles between 20° and 40° -, being that all participants presented hyperkyphotic curvatures.

It is noteworthy, still regarding the Cobb method for thoracic kyphosis evaluation, that it presents limitations, for despite having good intra- and inter-researchers agreement values2222. Vrtovec T, Pernus F, Likar B. A review of methods for quantitative evaluation of spinal curvature. Eur Spine J . 2009;18(5):593-607., with error values ranging from 3 to 10°, it has MDC (Mininum Detectable Change) values ranging between 9 and 10°2323. Marchetti BV. Proposição de uma medida alternativa de interpretação radiológica das curvaturas sagitais da coluna vertebral de crianças [dissertação]. Porto Alegre: Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul; 2015.. Such MDC values reflect the amount of change in the evaluation required to determine that there was a true change and not just a measurement error2424. Hicks GE, George SZ, Nevitt MA, Cauley JA, Vogt MT. Measurement of lumbar lordosis, inter-rater reliability, minimum detectable change and longitudinal variation. J Spinal Disord Tech. 2006;19(7):501-6., i.e., the eight degrees of difference found in the study of Junges et al. (2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33. may be a measurement error and not clinical change one. In addition, Mac-Thiong et al. (2525. Mac-Thiong JM, Labelle H, Charlebois M, Huot MP, de Guise J. Sagittal plane analysis of the spine and pelvis in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis according to the coronal curve type. Spine. 2003;28(13):1404-9. reported that thoracic kyphosis angle values can be influenced mainly by deformities in the coronal plane and by the pelvis alignment, which may be erroneous clinical interpretations-generating factors.

Cruz-Ferreira et al. (1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611. also performed postural evaluations through photography, in frontal and sagittal planes. In the frontal plane, they evaluated the alignment of thoracic and lumbar spine, pelvis, and shoulders. However, in the sagittal plane, they investigated only the alignment of the head and pelvis. Researchers conducted three evaluations throughout the study (prior, after 24 and 48 sessions) comparing intra and intergroups in different evaluation times1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.. In the experimental group, changes were observed when comparing the pre-intervention with intermediate and final periods, in frontal alignment of the shoulders and sagittal pelvic alignment, and by comparing initial and intermediate with final evaluation moments, regarding the sagittal alignment of the head. In the control group, changes were not observed. In intergroups comparisons, there were only differences regarding frontal alignment of the shoulders and sagittal alignment of the head after the 48 sessions.

In the study conducted by Sinzato et al. (77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50., the method of image acquisition and analysis of the Posture Assessment Software - SAPO2626. Ferreira EAG, Duarte M, Maldonado EP, Burke TN, Marques AP. Postural assessment software (PAS/SAPO): validation and reliability. Clinics. 2010;65(7):675-81.) was used, in which, from predefined points, they calculated horizontal alignments of the head, acromia, pelvis and anterior superior iliac spine, horizontal asymmetry of the scapula in relation to T3, frontal angles of lower limbs, vertical alignment of the body, knee angle and Q angle, and asymmetries of the center of gravity in frontal and sagittal planes (based on the anthropometric model proposed by Zatsiorsky and Seluyanov adapted by Leva2727. De Leva P. Adjustments to Zatsiorsky-Seluyanov's segment inertia parameters. J Biomech. 1996;29(9):1223-30.)). When comparing pre- and post periods (after 20 sessions), intra- and intergroup, they did not observe any difference regarding the variables analyzed.

Considering that the studies did not use the same methodology and neither evaluated the same variables, some observations should be made. Specifically regarding female older adults, 60 sessions of the Pilates Method seem to be effective in reducing the angle of thoracic kyphosis and cervical-thoracic distance, consequently increasing stature2020. Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33.. Concerning the effects of the Pilates Method in young adult women, 20 sessions seem to be effective77. Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50., but 24 sessions would be able to promote improvements in frontal alignment of shoulders and sagittal pelvic alignment, and the latter seems to be observed if the intervention frequency is twice a week. After 48 sessions, these posture adjustments remain, and, in addition, changes in the sagittal alignment of the head are also perceived1818. Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.. These results need to be confirmed by other high-quality studies in such a way that evidences can be considered acceptable.

CONCLUSION

Based on the Best Evidence Synthesis criteria, the results of this systematic review indicates that there is no scientific evidence about the effects of the Pilates Method on posture alignment of healthy women.

REFERÊNCIAS

  • 1
    De Souza MCS, Vieira CB. Who are the people looking for the Pilates method? J Body Mov Ther. 2006;10(4):328-34.
  • 2
    Di Lorenzo CE. Pilates: what is it? Should it be used in rehabilitation? Sports Health. 2011;3(4):352-61.
  • 3
    Gallagher S, Kryzanowska R. Método pilates de condicionamento físico. São Paulo: The Pilates Studio do Brasil; 2000.
  • 4
    Kolyniak I, Cavalcanti S, Aoki M. Avaliação isocinética da musculatura envolvida na flexão e extensão do tronco: efeito do método Pilates. Rev Bras Med Esporte. 2004;10(6):487-90.
  • 5
    Marés G, Oliveira KB, Piazza MC, Preis C, Bertassoni Neto L. A importância da estabilização central no método Pilates: uma revisão sistemática. Fisioter Mov. 2012;25(2):445-51.
  • 6
    Emery K, De Serres SJ, McMillan A, Côté JN. The effects of a Pilates training program on arm-trunk posture and movement. Clin Biomech. 2010;25(2):124-30.
  • 7
    Sinzato CR, Taciro C, Pio CA, Toledo AM, Cardoso JR, Carregaro RL. Efeitos de 20 sessões do método Pilates no alinhamento postural e flexibilidade de mulheres jovens: estudo piloto. Fisioter Pesqui. 2013;20(2):143-50.
  • 8
    Latey P. The Pilates method: history and philosophy. J Body Mov Ther . 2001;5(4):275-82.
  • 9
    Kendall FP, McCreary EK, Provance PG, Rodgers MM, Romani WA. Músculos: provas e funções. 5ª ed. São Paulo: Manole; 2007.
  • 10
    Molinari B. Avaliação médica e física: para atletas e praticantesde atividade físicas. São Paulo: Roca; 2000.
  • 11
    Santos CIS, Cunha ABN, Braga VP, Saad IAB, Ribeiro MAGO, Conti PBM, et al. Ocorrência de desvios posturais em escolares do ensino público fundamental de Jaguariúna, São Paulo. Rev Paul Pediatr. 2009;27(1):74-80.
  • 12
    Fejer R, Kyvik KO, Hartvigsen J. The prevalence of neck pain in the world population: a systematic critical review of the literature. Eur Spine J. 2006;15(6):834-48.
  • 13
    Bispo Júnior JP. Fisioterapia e saúde coletiva: desafios e novas responsabilidades profissionais. Cien Saude Coletiva. 2010;15(Suppl 1):1627-36.
  • 14
    Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Laranjo L, Bernardo LM, Silva A. A systematic review of the effects of Pilates method of exercise in healthy people. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2011;92(12):2071-81.
  • 15
    Van Tulder MW, Koes BW, Bouter LM. Conservative treatment of acute and chronic nonspecific low back pain: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials of the most common interventions. Spine. 1997;22(18):2128-56.
  • 16
    Costa C, Cabri J. Escala de PEDro. [Internet]. [citado 16 abr 2015]. Disponível em: http://www.pedro.org.au/portuguese/downloads/pedro-scale/
    » http://www.pedro.org.au/portuguese/downloads/pedro-scale/
  • 17
    Shiwa SR, Costa LOP, Moser ADL, Aguiar ID, Oliveira LVF. PEDro: a base de dados de evidências em fisioterapia. Fisioter Mov . 2011;24(3):523-33.
  • 18
    Cruz-Ferreira A, Fernandes J, Kuo YL, Bernardo LM, Fernandes O, Laranjo L, et al. Does Pilates-based exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Health. 2013;53(6):597-611.
  • 19
    Donahoe-Fillmore B, Hanahan NM, Mescher ML, Clapp ED, Addison NR., Weston CR. The effects of a home Pilates program on muscle performance and posture in healthy females: a pilot study. J Womens Health Phys Therap. 2007;31(2):6-11.
  • 20
    Junges S, Gottlieb MG, Baptista RR, Quadros CB, Resende TL, Gomes I. Eficácia do método Pilates para a postura e flexibilidade em mulheres com hipercifose. R Bras Cienc Mov. 2012;20(1):21-33.
  • 21
    Willian DB, Sanders B. Exercícios terapêuticos: técnicas para a intervenção. Rio de Janeiro: Guanabara Koogan; 2003.
  • 22
    Vrtovec T, Pernus F, Likar B. A review of methods for quantitative evaluation of spinal curvature. Eur Spine J . 2009;18(5):593-607.
  • 23
    Marchetti BV. Proposição de uma medida alternativa de interpretação radiológica das curvaturas sagitais da coluna vertebral de crianças [dissertação]. Porto Alegre: Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul; 2015.
  • 24
    Hicks GE, George SZ, Nevitt MA, Cauley JA, Vogt MT. Measurement of lumbar lordosis, inter-rater reliability, minimum detectable change and longitudinal variation. J Spinal Disord Tech. 2006;19(7):501-6.
  • 25
    Mac-Thiong JM, Labelle H, Charlebois M, Huot MP, de Guise J. Sagittal plane analysis of the spine and pelvis in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis according to the coronal curve type. Spine. 2003;28(13):1404-9.
  • 26
    Ferreira EAG, Duarte M, Maldonado EP, Burke TN, Marques AP. Postural assessment software (PAS/SAPO): validation and reliability. Clinics. 2010;65(7):675-81.
  • 27
    De Leva P. Adjustments to Zatsiorsky-Seluyanov's segment inertia parameters. J Biomech. 1996;29(9):1223-30.
  • 3
    Funding source: Nothing to declare

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    Jul-Sep 2016

History

  • Received
    Nov 2015
  • Accepted
    Sept 2016
Universidade de São Paulo Rua Ovídio Pires de Campos, 225 2° andar. , 05403-010 São Paulo SP / Brasil, Tel: 55 11 2661-7703, Fax 55 11 3743-7462 - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
E-mail: revfisio@usp.br