Cobham et al., 2010 |
Anxiety disorder |
ADIS-C CBCL RCMA-S |
Anxiety − significant improvement maintained, compared to the
baseline |
No longer met the criteria for the Ads = 48 (80%) There was
significant difference between the interventions: GCBT − 23
(69%) without a diagnosis of ADs GCBT + family − 25 (92%)
without a diagnosis of ADs |
Saavedra et al., 2010 |
Social phobia Specific phobia Panic disorder/Agoraphobia
Depressive disorder |
ADIS-C & ADIS-P ADIS-IV RCMA-S MAS CDI BDI CBCL YASR |
Anxiety and depression symptoms − significant improvement after
1 year of follow-up, maintained up to 9 years after CBT |
62 (92.5%) no longer met the criteria for the ADs 61 (91%) did
not meet the criteria for depression 55 (82.1%) did not meet the
criteria for any disorder |
O’Leary; Barrett; Fjermestad, 2009 |
OCD |
ADIS –C & ADIS-P NIMH-GOCS Y-BOCS-SR MASC MASC-OC BDI-II FAD
DASS-21 |
Anxiety − no significant improvement. Depression symptoms –
significant improvement in individual CBT and in older
individuals |
No diagnosis of OCD after 7 years of CBT (87%) Individual CBT
(79%) GCBT (95%) |
Bernstein et al., 2008 |
Separation anxiety disorder GAD Social phobia |
ADIS MASC SCARED CGI |
Anxiety − significant improvement when compared to control group
in 6 months of follow-up, did not remain significant at 12
months |
No significant difference regarding the diagnosis of ADs. CBT
with training for parents appears to be more effective than CBT
only with the children |
Kendall et al., 2004 |
Primary Anxiety disorder |
ADIS–C & ADIS–P ADIS-IV-L CASI RCMAS CDI CQ-C APES CBCL CQ-P
STAIC |
Anxiety and depression symptoms − significant improvement
maintained, compared to the baseline |
No longer met the criteria for the ADs: After the CBT sessions =
51.2% At follow-up = 80.5% |
Manassis et al., 2004 |
GAD Others Anxiety Disorders |
DICA-R-P RCMAS |
Anxiety and depression symptoms − persisted at the follow-up,
did not require clinical care in 70% of the individuals
treated |
No significant difference regarding the diagnosis of ADs
Baseline (n = 63): GAD = 32 (52%) Other ADs = 21 (49%) Follow-up
(n = 43): GAD = 31 (48%) Other ADs = 22 (51%) |
Barrett et al., 2001 |
Separation anxiety disorder Social phobia Simple phobia
Depression Oppositional defiant disorder |
ADIS-C RCMAS FSSC-R CDI CBCL |
Anxiety and depression symptoms − significant improvement
maintained at 6-year follow up, compared to the baseline, but
greater than at the 12-month evaluation |
No longer met the criteria for the ADs: After 12 months = 79.6%
and after 6 years = 85,7% CBT and CBT+FAM interventions were
equally effective |
Cobham; Dadds; Spence, 1998 |
GAD Social phobia Agoraphobia Overanxious disorder Separation
anxiety disorder |
ADIS-C & ADIS-P RCMAS STAIC CBCL |
Anxiety − overall improvement observed in the four conditions of
treatment and significant difference maintained, compared to the
baseline |
No longer met the criteria for the ADs: CBT = 82% and CBT+PAM =
80% |
Barrett, 1998 |
Separation anxiety disorder Secondary diagnosis of simple phobia
Depression |
ADIS-C & ADIS-P FSSC-R CBCL |
Anxiety − significant improvement maintained at follow-up |
No longer met the criteria for the ADs: After CBT and CBT+FAM =
64.8% versus 25.2% waiting list After 12
months: GCBT = 64.5% versus GCBT+FAM = 84.8%
The intervention that included the family proved more effective
than GCBT only with the children |
Barrett; Dadds; Rapee, 1996 |
Overanxiety disorder Separation Anxiety disorder Social
phobia |
ADIS-C & ADIS-P RCMAS FSSC-R CDI CBCL DASS FEAR |
Anxiety and depression symptoms − overall improvement observed
in the three conditions of treatment and significant difference
maintained at follow-up, compared to the baseline |
No longer met the criteria for the ADs: After 12 months = 70.3%
of CBT versus 95.6% of CBT+FAM Both
interventions maintained long-term benefits, but there were
additional clinical benefits for CBT+FAM |