Services on Demand
Print version ISSN 0034-7094
Rev. Bras. Anestesiol. vol.57 no.2 Campinas Mar./Apr. 2007
Hematoma after epidural anesthesia: conservative treatment. Case report*
Hematoma posterior a la anestesia peridural: tratamiento conservador. Relato de caso
Edno Magalhães, TSAI; Cátia Sousa Govêia, TSAII; Luís Cláudio de Araújo Ladeira, TSAII; Laura Elisa Sócio de QueirozIII
Adjunto da Área de Clínica Cirúrgica da FM-UnB; Responsável
pelo CET do Centro de Anestesiologia da UnB
IIMédico Assistente da Clínica de Anestesiologia do HU de Brasília (UnB); Co-Responsável pelo CET do Centro de Anestesiologia da UnB
IIIMédica Assistente do Hospital Regional de Sobradinho
OBJECTIVES: Hematoma associated with spinal compression after epidural anesthesia
is a severe neurological complication, despite the reduced incidence reported
(1:150,000). It is an acute episode and the traditional treatment includes urgent
surgical decompression. More recently, treatment with corticosteroids has been
used as an alternative, in specific cases, with good neurological resolution.
The objective of this report was to present the case of an epidural hematoma
treated conservatively with complete neurological recovery.
CASE REPORT: Female patient, 34 years old, ASA physical status I, with no prior history of bleeding disorders or anticlotting treatment, underwent epidural anesthesia at the L2-L3 level for the surgical treatment of lower limb varicose veins. Eight hours after the regional anesthesia, the patient still presented complete motor blockade (Bromage scale), reduction of thermal and pain sensitivity below L3, hyperalgesia in the left plantar region, preserved tendon reflexes, and absence of lumbar pain. A CT scan showed an epidural hematoma in L2, with compression of the dural sac. Ten hours after the epidural puncture, there was no regression of neurological signs and symptoms. It was decided, then, to treat the patient with a continuous infusion of methylprednisolone (5.3 mg.kg-1 in the first hour and 1.4 mg.kg-1.h-1 in the following 23 hours). Eight hours after the beginning of the treatment, the patient recovered thermal and pain sensitivity and presented total regression of the motor blockade. On the 12th hour, she was walking and complained of pain in the surgical wound. The epidural hematoma was not visualized in a CT scan done 14 hours after the beginning of the treatment. The patient was discharged 86 hours after the beginning of the treatment without neurological deficits. A CT scan done after 7 months showed a completely normal spinal canal.
CONCLUSIONS: The efficacy of the conservative approach demonstrated that it is an important alternative to surgery in specific cases. The evaluation of the progression or stabilization of the neurological deficit, especially 8 hours after the epidural puncture, is essential in choosing the treatment.
Key Words: COMPLICATIONS: spinal cord compression, epidural hematoma; ANESTHETIC TECHNIQUES, Regional: epidural.
JUSTIFICATIVA Y OBJETIVOS:
O hematoma asociado a la compresión espinal después de la anestesia
peridural es una complicación neurológica grave, a pesar de la
pequeña incidencia relatada (1:150.000). Es un episodio agudo y el tratamiento
tradicionalmente aplicado es la descompresión quirúrgica de urgencia.
Recientemente, en casos específicos, el tratamiento con corticosteroide
ha sido aplicado como alternativa y con una buena recuperación neurológica.
El objetivo de este relato fue exponer un caso de hematoma peridural con tratamiento
conservador y recuperación neurológica completa.
RELATO DEL CASO: Paciente del sexo femenino, 34 años, estado físico ASA I, sin ningún historial de coagulopatía o terapia anticoagulante, sometida a la anestesia peridural con punción única, en L2-L3, para tratamiento quirúrgico de várices en los miembros inferiores. Ocho horas después de la anestesia regional, todavía presentaba bloqueo motor completo (escala de Bromage), reducción de las sensibilidades térmica y dolorosa por debajo del nivel L3, hiperalgesia en la región plantar izquierda, preservación de los reflejos tendinosos y ausencia de dolor lumbar. La tomografía computadorizada reveló hematoma peridural en L2 con compresión del saco dural. Diez horas después de la punción peridural no había progresión de las señales y síntomas neurológicos. Se optó entonces por el tratamiento con metilprednisolona en infusión venosa continua (5,3 mg.kg-1 en la primera hora y 1,4 mg.kg-1.h-1 en las 23 horas siguientes). Ocho horas después del inicio del tratamiento, la paciente recuperó las sensibilidades térmica y dolorosa y la regresión total del bloqueo motor. En la 12ª hora, deambulaba y refería dolor en la herida operada. El hematoma peridural no se visualizó en una nueva tomografía computadorizada en la 14ª hora después del inicio del tratamiento. La paciente recibió alta hospitalaria 86 horas después del inicio del tratamiento conservador, sin comprometimiento neurológico. Una tomografía computadorizada de control después de 7 meses, mostró el canal vertebral completamente normal.
CONCLUSIONES: La eficiencia del abordaje conservadora fue una alternativa importante para la intervención quirúrgica en casos específicos. La evaluación de la progresión o estabilización del comprometimiento neurológico, particularmente después de la 8ª hora posterior a la punción peridural, es esencial para la elección del tratamiento.
Epidural anesthesia is a good technique of regional anesthesia for several types of surgeries, including those in the inferior limbs. With this type of block it is possible to promote analgesia, variable degrees of motor blockade, and protection against surgical stress.
Similar to any other procedure in the neuroaxis, epidural anesthesia is also associated with neurological complications. Although described in the literature with a reduced incidence (1:150,000) 1, epidural hematoma with spinal compression after epidural anesthesia is a severe neurological complication, requiring short-term treatment. Traditionally, it has been treated with urgent surgical decompression. More recently, the treatment with corticosteroids in selected cases has been proposed as an alternative, with good neurological recovery. The objective of this report was to call attention to this type of conservative treatment in selected cases, in face of the reduced number of reports in the literature regarding the non-surgical treatment of epidural hematomas.
Female patient, 34 years old, ASA physical status I, with no history of bleeding disorders or anticoagulant treatment, underwent epidural anesthesia for the outpatient surgical treatment of varicose veins in the lower limbs. Epidural puncture in the L2-L3 space with a 16G Tuohy needle was done without complications; 0.5% bupivacaine (125 mg) and fentanyl without preservatives (100 µg) were administered.
Eight hours after the epidural puncture, the neurological exam showed suppression of thermal and pain sensitivity below L3, hyperalgesia in the left plantar region, and complete motor blockade (according to the Bromage scale). Tendon reflexes were preserved, the patient did not complain of lumbar pain, and vital signs were normal.
A CT scan (Figure 1) showed a collection with blood density in the vertebral canal at the level of L2, with compression of the dural sac.
Ten hours after the epidural puncture, neurological signs and symptoms did not evolve. Treatment with continuous intravenous infusion of methylprednisolone was initiated, 5.3 mg.kg-1 in the first hour and 1.4 mg.kg-1.h-1 in the remaining 23 hours.
Eight hours after the beginning of the treatment, the patient recovered thermal and pain sensitivity and showed complete regression of the motor blockade. In the 12th hour, the patient was able to walk and complained of pain in the surgical wound.
A CT scan done 14 hours after the beginning of the treatment did not show the epidural hematoma (Figure 2).
The patient was discharged from the hospital 86 hours after the beginning of the treatment without neurological deficits. The CT scan done after seven months showed a completely normal spinal canal.
Epidural hematoma secondary to anesthesia of the neuro- axis can be due to bleeding disorders, use of drugs, or traumatic punctures 2,3. Some cases, however, occur without any apparent risk factors 3. External compression of the epidural space, by the blood clot and the subsequent inflammatory reaction, can compromise arterial and venous blood flow to the spinal cord and spinal nerve roots. This causes ischemia and damage. Nonetheless, the compressive effect of the epidural hematoma can manifest only when compensatory mechanisms have been exhausted, with increased pressure in the vertebral canal 4. The case reported here showed a patient in which those mechanisms were probably exhausted. The importance of the neurological deficit for the prognosis, choice of treatment, and evolution, has been closely studied since World War II. Since 1970, several classifications of the severity of the spinal cord lesion, to define the degree of neurological involvement to better orient the treatment, have been created. Such classifications avoid the adoption of the empirical criterion for the diagnosis of "complete" or "incomplete" lesion. Currently, two classifications considered very useful to establish the presence of spinal cord lesions are being used; the oldest, the Frankel classification (decade of 1970), and the American Spinal Injury Association ASIA (decade of 1990).
The case presented here had a neurological clinical picture consistent with the B level of the Frankel classification and very close to the B level of the ASIA classification, since only sensitive function below the lesion was present (Charts I and II) 5. Those cases require treatment. Traditionally, surgical decompression was always indicated and, the sooner the treatment (within the first 12 to 36 hours), the better the prognosis 1,6,7. More recently, conservative treatment, monitored by imaging exams, with corticosteroids have been defended 2,6,8.
MRI is considered the best follow-up exam in those cases, but myelography or CT scan are valid alternatives 9.
The indication of conservative treatment must be based on neurological follow-up to confirm the absence of evolution or stabilization of the neurological symptoms, especially 8 hours after the puncture. The anesthesiology and neurology teams should follow-up the patient together. One should also consider that the surgical treatment could be instituted in the first 12 to 36 hours after the puncture. Thus, if the evolution of the neurological sings and symptoms do not show satisfactory regression in the first few hours of the conservative treatment, it is still possible to institute the surgical treatment. The results of this case demonstrate the efficiency of the conservative treatment as an alternative to the surgical treatment, which is not devoid of risks and is not 100% successful 6.
Follow-up with imaging exams is extremely important on deciding whether or not to continue with the conservative treatment. We can conclude that, based on adequate clinical and neurological observation and with the appropriate radiological support, the surgical treatment is not the only treatment option when the diagnosis of epidural hematoma is made.
01. Zink M, Rath M, Waltensdorfer A et al. Unilateral presentation of a large epidural hematoma. Anesthesiology, 2003;98:1032-1033. [ Links ]
02. Inoue K, Yokoyama M, Nakatsuka H et al. Spontaneous resolution of epidural hematoma after continuous epidural analgesia in a patient without bleeding tendency. Anesthesiology, 2002;97:735-737. [ Links ]
03. Gilbert A, Owens BD, Mulroy MF Epidural hematoma after outpatient epidural anesthesia. Anesth Analg, 2002;94:77-78. [ Links ]
04. Castillo D, Tsen LC Epidural blood patch placed in the presence of an unknown cervical epidural hematoma. Anesth Analg, 2003;97:885-887. [ Links ]
06. Torres A, Acebes JJ, Cabiol J et al. Spinal epidural hematomas proagnostic in a series of 22 cases and a proposal management. Neurocirugia (Asturias, Spain), 2004;15:353-359. [ Links ]
07. Groen RJ Non-operative treatment of spontaneous spinal epidural hematomas: a review of the literature and a comparison with operative cases. Acta Neurochir (Wien), 2004; 146:103-110. [ Links ]
08. Wagner S, Forsting M, Hacke W Spontaneous resolution of a large spinal epidural hematoma: case report. Neurosurgery, 1996;38:816-818. [ Links ]
09. Wulf H Epidural anaesthesia and spinal haematoma. Can J Anaesth, 1996;43:1260-1271. [ Links ]
Dr. Edno Magalhães
SQS 113, Bloco C/406
70736-030 Brasília, DF
Submitted em 24
de abril de 2006
Accepted para publicação em 27 de novembro de 2006
* Received from Hospital Universitário de Brasília Universidade de Brasília (UnB), Brasília, DF