Services on Demand
On-line version ISSN 1678-9946
Rev. Inst. Med. trop. S. Paulo vol.42 n.3 São Paulo May/June 2000
PERSISTENT INFECTIONS IN CHRONIC CHAGAS' DISEASE PATIENTS TREATED WITH ANTI-Trypanosoma cruzi NITRODERIVATIVES
M. Socorro BRAGA, Liana LAURIA-PIRES, Enrique R. ARGAÑARAZ, Rubens J. NASCIMENTO & Antonio R. L. TEIXEIRA
We used a molecular method and demonstrated that treatment of the chronic human Trypanosoma cruzi infections with nitroderivatives did not lead to parasitological cure. Seventeen treated and 17 untreated chronic Chagas' disease patients, with at least two out of three positive serologic assays for the infection, and 17 control subjects formed the study groups. PCR assays with nested sets of T. cruzi DNA primers monitored the efficacy of treatment. The amplification products were hybridized to their complementary internal sequences. Untreated and treated Chagas' disease patients yielded PCR amplification products with T. cruzi nuclear DNA primers. Competitive PCR was conducted to determine the quantity of parasites in the blood and revealed < 1 to 75 T. cruzi/ml in untreated (means 25.83 ± 26.32) and < 1 to 36 T. cruzi/ml in treated (means 6.45 ± 9.28) Chagas' disease patients. The difference between the means was not statistically significant. These findings reveal a need for precise definition of the role of treatment of chronic Chagas' disease patients with nitrofuran and nitroimidazole compounds.
KEYWORDS: Trypanosoma cruzi; Chagas' disease; Treatment; Nifurtimox; Benznidazole.
Recent publications have described notable advances in experimental chemotherapy of the T. cruzi infections, and results obtained with specific therapeutic regimes have been considered satisfactory6,27,28. The sterol and phospholipid synthesis inhibitors, which have been synthesized as anti-fungal drugs, and produced 70 to 90% cure of the experimental murine infections, did not prove to be effective in the treatment of human Chagas' disease28. In addition, synthesis of a novel chemical class of 60 nitrobenzofurans designed for advantageous activity against the murine T. cruzi infections yielded a single compound 1.6 times as effective than the reference drug nifurtimox13. However, several authors have shown the nitrobenzofurans and related compounds bear high potential for mutagenesis, carcinogenesis, teratogenesis and sterility4,18,21-23,25.
Itraconazol used as an anti-fungal drug for 20 years, produced parasitologic cure in 53% of chronic Chagas' disease patients (6mg/kg/day, for 60 days) whereas allopurinol (8.5 mg/kg/day) yielded parasitologic cure in 44% of treated Chagas' disease patients2. The treatment of acute T. cruzi-infected patients with benznidazole resulted in conversion of serologic assays, which was considered equivalent to parasitological cure in 60% to 20% of treated cases1,15. However, the dichotomy between responders and non-responders of the specific drug therapy needs to be explained, since treatment did not appear to influence the clinical features of the acute infection12,15. Broad discrepancies in percentage of parasitological cure of chronic infections have been reported but they were explained by sectional observations, conducted on different occasions after treatment, in which the patients were not protected against the reduvid insect-vector and, therefore, the possibility of superinfection can not be ruled out8-11,14-16,29.
In the absence of new drugs, nitroimidazol and nitrofuran are the compounds used to treat human Chagas' disease8,9,29. Here we present results of a study of chronic Chagas patients treated with benznidazole (N-benzyl-2-nitro-1-imidazolacetamide) or nifurtimox (4-[5-nitro-3-methyl-furfurylideneanimo]-tetrahydro-4-H-1,4-thiazine-1-1-dioxide). This study conducted in an insect-vector transmission-free urban area shows persistence of the T. cruzi infection in each Chagas patient, regardless of treatment.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study was conducted at the Medical Offices of the Brasília Refuse Department, and at the Chagas' Disease Multidisciplinary Research Laboratory, University of Brasília. The study protocol was approved by the Institutional Ethical Committee in Human Research. The street-cleaners enrolled in the programme gave written consent to participate in the study.
Each street-cleaner was subjected to immunological assays to determine specific antibodies for the T. cruzi infection. Patients showing at least two out of three positive tests (ELISA, indirect immunofluorescence [IF] and indirect hemagglutination [IH]26 were considered T. cruzi infected30. The results of the serological study in this series were validated by ELISA, IF and IH assays run in parallel with a panel of sera from 94 Chagas' disease patients with parasitological demonstration of T. cruzi24.
This test was performed in each patient with positive immunological tests for the infection, essentially as described22.
The street-cleaners enrolled in this programme were subjected to immunological assays and 18.5% of them showed serological evidence of T. cruzi infections26. A cohort of these Chagas patients were treated with anti-trypanosomal nitrofuran or nitroimidazole (10 mg/kg/day, per os), because they showed severe electrocardiographic alterations. Among treated Chagas patients we selected 17 who had completed full treatment for 30 days or above. These treated patients were matched by gender and age with 17 untreated Chagas patients and with 17 control, non-Chagas individuals. As a result, three study groups were formed comprising 51 male street-cleaners: i) treated; ii) untreated; iii) control, with serologic tests negative for the T. cruzi infection.
Polimerase chain reaction (PCR) and hybridization
DNA samples extracted from 10 ml of peripheral blood from each street-cleaner were analysed by PCR with specific primers for the constant regions of minicircles of kinetoplast DNA (kDNA) and to highly repetitive sequences of nuclear DNA (nDNA) of T. cruzi 3, 17, 19 . The kDNA primer set (S35, 5'-ATAATGTACGGG(T/G)GAGATGC-3' and S36, 5'-GGTTCGATTGGGGTTGGTG-3') annealing to the constant region of minicircles yields a 330 bp product and its catamer of 660 bp19. The nDNA primer set (PON1, 5'-TGGCTTGGAGGAGTTATTGT-3' and PON2, 5'-AGGAGTGACGGTTGATCAGT-3') amplifies a 250 bp fragment17. A DNA thermal cycler (MJ Research, Watertown, MA) was used for 30-32 cycles, as described7. Negative controls (water and P388D1-IL1 DNA) and positive control (T. cruzi DNA) were always included to detect DNA contamination and ensure that the PCR worked efficiently. The PCR amplification products were transferred by capillarity to a nylon membrane. Prehybridization and hybridization were performed as described7. For S35/36 products, the sequence was S67 5'-GGTTTTGGGAGGGG(CG)-(G/C)-(T/G)TC-3'19 . For PON1/2 products, the sequence was PON3 5'-CCGGCCTGTGTCTGCGGC-3'17. These oligonucleotides were radiolabelled with [(a 32P]-dATP (3000 CimMol) using the polynucleotide kinase method following the manufacturer's recommendation (Life Technologies).
These assays were conducted in blood samples of 17 untreated and of 17 treated Chagas patients who had received full treatment with nitroderivatives for 30 days and above. DNA samples from all these serologically positive patients that yielded positive PCR amplification products of the size expected with specific kDNA and nDNA primers were used for quantification of the parasitemia, as described7.
The results are presented as means and standard deviation. The Student t test was used for group analysis.
Regardless of chemotherapeutic regime used, all Chagas' disease patients showed at least two out of three positive tests (ELISA, IF and IH) for the T. cruzi infections. Furthermore, the quantitative serological assays showed antibody titers in the treated Chagas group to be as high as those for the untreated Chagas patients (data not shown). No subject in the control group showed positive serology. Furthermore, we took advantage of results of xenodiagnosis showing parasitological demonstration of T. cruzi infections in chronic Chagas patients and used blood samples from these patients for covalidation of data obtained with serological and PCR assays. Results of these experiments are shown in Table 1.
Each Chagas patient yielded PCR amplification products with specific primers that annealed to T. cruzi nDNA (Figure 1). All these Chagas patients had shown PCR amplification product that formed a predictable size band in agarose gels, when specific kDNA primers were used. This product was hybridized with its complementary internal sequence. In contrast, none of the 17 control subjects, showing negative serological assays, yielded PCR amplification products with specific kDNA and nDNA primers.
The quantitative PCR was used to detect parasitemias in the blood of 34 patients with chronic Chagas' disease (Table 2). Among 17 Chagas patients treated with nitroderivatives, 41% received the drug for 30 days and 59% for 60 days. Citrated blood was collected from these patients 10 years after treatment. The competitive PCR assays showed T. cruzi kDNA bands at various points of equivalency with the competitor DNA bands, regardless of whether the template DNA was originated from treated or untreated Chagas patients. The competitive PCR quantification of T. cruzi in treated and untreated Chagas patients is shown in Table 2 and Figure 2. Seventeen untreated Chagas patients showed bands whose intensity was compared to that of DNA from a known quantity of T. cruzi showing equivalency in a range of < 1-to-75 parasites/ml of blood. The average means of T. cruzi/ml in this group was 25.83 ± 26.32. In addition, 16 treated Chagas patients showed bands whose equivalency ranged from < 1-to-36 parasites/ml of blood. The average means in this group was 6.45 ± 9.28. The statistical analysis demonstrated that the differences of means of parasitemias between treated and untreated Chagas patients are not significant. One treated Chagas patient (no 201) showed exquisitely high number of parasites in the blood and was not considered for statistical analysis.
The prescription of nitroderivatives to treat the T. cruzi infections of street-cleaners with clinical and serological evidence of Chagas' disease was made by physicians at the Medical Offices of the Brasília Refuse Department, Federal District of Brazil. The Federal District is insect-vector transmission-free of the T. cruzi infections and, therefore the possibility of superinfections was ruled out in this study.
Records in the files of all individuals in the study groups have shown that nitrofuran nifurtimox (10 mg/kg/day) was prescribed for 62% of Chagas patients. Nitroimidazole benznidazole (10 mg/kg/day) was prescribed to treat 38% of the remaining chagasic patients. In this series we report only those cases of chronic Chagas' disease undergoing full treatment for at least 30 days and showing PCR amplifications with specific kDNA and nDNA primers. In order to determine the efficacy of nitroderivative chemotherapy of the T. cruzi infections therefore, we used a quantitative PCR assay for detecting subclinical parasitemias in treated and untreated chronic Chagas patients. In this regard, previously we had run serological and quantitative PCR testings of blood samples from patients with positive xenodiagnosis, which showed consistently positive results. Essentially, the methods used were covalidated by these results.
Here we report that phenotypic and genotypic markers of the T. cruzi infections, which were used to evalutate the efficacy of nitroderivative therapy, did not shown significant differences in groups of treated and untreated Chagas' disease patients. In the first category, high titers of specific antibodies were observed in treated as well as in untreated Chagas patients. The lack of alteration of the serologic profile suggests that the specific chemotherapy did not affect the humoral immune responses to the parasitic antigens (data not shown). The discrepancy between these observations and those reported in the literature1,9,11,12,15,29 might be explained by the fact that we used a highly sensitive molecular method to detect very low levels of parasitemias in treated and untreated chronic Chagas' disease patients. The persistence of T. cruzi shown in treated Chagas patients in this series may not be considered as resulting of reinfections, because our patients lived in an insect-vector transmission-free area.
Genotypic markers of T. cruzi infections were present in the treated as well as in the untreated chronic Chagas' disease patients in this series. We obtained PCR amplification products from Chagas' disease patients template DNA with nested sets of primers of nuclear DNA and kinetoplast DNA of T. cruzi, regardless of the patient belonging to the treated or the untreated group. In view of the observation that sequences of minicircles of T. cruzi may integrate in the genome of the host cell, we suggested that the nuclear DNA is the only genotypic marker that confers evidence of the living T. cruzi infection in treated and in untreated Chagas' disease patients20. In this regard, we used template DNA from both groups of Chagas' disease patients who had shown PCR amplification products with the primer set PON1/2, in order to quantify the parasitemia by competitive PCR7,17.
The tests of competitive PCR were run with template DNA from 34 Chagas patients, treated and untreated, which have shown the 330 bp band amplified with the S35/36 kDNA primers. This criteria secured optimal amplification reactions and allowed comparison between the 280 bp band (amplification of the competitor DNA) and the 330 bp (amplification of the sequence of the minicircle kDNA of T. cruzi). The quantification of the minicircle DNA was determined at the tube of equivalency with known concentration of the competitor DNA. Considering that each parasite contains 15 fg of the 330 bp minicircle sequence, the quantity of parasite in each ml of blood was determined7. To our knowledge, this study shows, for the first time with a molecular method, that the treatment of chronic Chagas' disease patients with nitrofuran and nitroimidazole compounds do not lead to the parasitological cure of the T. cruzi infections.
The demonstration of persisting phenotypic and genotypic markers of the living T. cruzi infections in patients treated with anti-trypanosomal drugs indicates these drugs have limited efficacy. The results discussed here show that assessment of cure after treatment of acute and chronic Chagas' disease requires a highly sensitive molecular method for detecting subclinical parasitemias. Moreover, treatment of chronic Chagas' disease remains controversial10, therefore requiring further research evaluation of benefits resulting from nitroderivative therapy5. In this regard, new drugs without undesirable side effects are needed, and that hopefuly promoting a true parasitological cure of the infection would halt the progression of the chronic disease.
Persistência das infecções em pacientes chagásicos crônicos tratados com nitroderivados anti-Trypanosoma cruzi
Usamos um método molecular e demonstramos que o tratamento de infecções crônicas pelo Trypanosoma cruzi com nitroderivados, que se mostraram eficientes em diminuir parasitemias nas infecções agudas, não produziu cura parasitológica. Trinta e quatro chagásicos crônicos, com pelo menos dois entre três testes sorológicos positivos para a infecção, e 17 controles com testes sorológicos negativos formaram os grupos de estudo. Os testes de PCR com primers de DNA de T. cruzi monitoraram a eficácia do tratamento. Foram obtidos produtos de PCR a partir de DNA de pacientes chagásicos tratados e não-tratados, com primers de DNA nuclear de T. cruzi. Os produtos amplificados hibridizaram com suas sequências internas e complementares. A técnica de PCR competitiva foi usada para quantificar o número de parasitos no sangue e revelou < 1 a 75 T. cruzi/ml em chagásicos não-tratados (média 25,83 ± 26,32) e < 1 a 36 T. cruzi/ml em chagásicos tratados (média 6,45 ± 9,28). A diferença entre as médias não foi estatisticamente significativa. O resultado mostra que o tratamento da doença de Chagas crônica com drogas nitroderivadas é insatisfatório.
We are greatful to Dr. Wesley Van Voorhis, Division of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, SJ-10, Dept. of Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, for donation of the competitor DNA. We are thankful to Dr. Marcio Maurmo, head of the Medical Office, Brasília Refuse Department, for giving us permission to enroll his patients in this Chagas' disease follow-up programme. This work was supported by Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Distrito Federal and by Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa, Brasil.
1. ANDRADE, A.L.; ZICKER, F. & OLIVEIRA, R.M. - Randomised trial of efficacy of benznidazole in treatment of early Trypanosoma cruzi infection. Lancet, 348: 1407-1413, 1996. [ Links ]
2. APT, W.; AGUILERA, A.A.; ARRIBADA, A. et al. - Treatment of chronic Chagas' disease with itraconazole and allopurinol. Amer. J. trop. Med. Hyg., 59: 133-138, 1998. [ Links ]
3. AVILA, H.A.; SIGMAN, D.S.; COOHEN, L.M.; MILLIKAN, R.C. & SIMPSON, L. - Polymerase chain reaction amplification of Trypanosoma cruzi kinetoplast minicircle DNA isolated from whole blood lysates: diagnosis of chronic Chagas' disease. Molec. Biochem. Parasit., 48: 211-222, 1991. [ Links ]
4. BOCCHI, E.A.; HIGUCHI, M.L.; VIEIRA, M.L. et al. - Higher incidence of malignant neoplasms after heart transplantation for treatment of chronic Chagas' heart disease. J. Heart Lung Transplant., 17: 399-405, 1998. [ Links ]
5. CANÇADO, J.R. - Criteria of Chagas' disease cure. Mem. Inst. Oswaldo Cruz, 94: 331-335, 1999. [ Links ]
6. CASTRO, S.L. - The challenge of Chagas' disease chemotherapy: an update of drugs assayed against Trypanosoma cruzi. Acta trop. (Basel), 53: 83-98, 1993. [ Links ]
7. CENTURION-LARA, A.; BARRETT, L. & VAN VOORHIS, W.C. - Quantitation of parasitemia by competitive polymerase chain reaction amplification of parasite kDNA minicircles during chronic infection with Trypanosoma cruzi. J. infect. Dis., 170: 1334-1339, 1994. [ Links ]
8. COURA, J.R.; ABREU, L.L.; WILLCOX, H.P.F. & PETANA, W. - Estudo comparativo controlado com emprego de benznidazole, nifurtimox e placebo, na forma crônica da doença de Chagas, em uma área de campo com transmissão interrompida. 1. Avaliação preliminar. Rev. Soc. bras. Med. trop., 30: 139-144, 1997. [ Links ]
9. FERREIRA, H.O. - Tratamento da forma indeterminada da doença de Chagas com nifurtimox e benzonidazol. Rev. Soc. bras. Med. trop., 23: 209-211, 1990. [ Links ]
10. FRAGATA-FILHO, A.A.; LUQUETTI, A.O.; PRATA, A. et al. - Etiological treatment for Chagas' disease. Parasit. today, 13: 127-128, 1997. [ Links ]
11. GALVÃO, L.M.C.; NUNES, R.M.B.; CANÇADO, J.R.; BRENER, Z. & KRETTLI, A.U. - Lytic antibody titre as a mean of assessing cure after treatment of Chagas' disease: a 10 years follow-up study. Trans. roy. Soc. trop. Med. Hyg., 87: 220-223, 1993. [ Links ]
12. INGLESIS, I.; CARRASCO, H.A.; ANEZ, N. et al. - Clinical, parasitological and histopathologic follow-up studies of acute Chagas patients treated with benznidazole. Arch. Inst. Cardiol. Méx., 68: 405-410, 1998. [ Links ]
13. KINNAMON, K.E.; POON, B.T.; HANSON, W. & WAITS, V.B. - Trypanosoma cruzi: a novel chemical class (nitrobenzofurans) active against infections of mice (Mus musculus). Exp. Parasit., 89: 251-256, 1998. [ Links ]
14. MACÊDO, V. & SILVEIRA, C.A. - Perspectiva da terapêutica específica da doença de Chagas. Experiências na forma indeterminada. Rev. Soc. bras. Med. trop., 20 (supl. 2): M24-M26, 1987. [ Links ]
15. PARADA, H.; CARRASCO, H.A.; ANEZ, N.; FUENMAYOR, C. & INGLESSIS, I. - Cardiac involvement is a constant finding in acute Chagas' disease: a clinical, parasitological and histopathological study. Int. J. Cardiol., 60: 49-54, 1997. [ Links ]
16. RASSI, A. & LUQUETTI, A.O. - Therapy of Chagas' disease. In: WENDEL, S.; BRENER, Z.; CAMARGO, M.E. & RASSI, A., ed. Chagas' disease (American Trypanosomiasis): its impact on transfusion and clinical medicine. São Paulo, Cartgraf; ISBT, 1992. p. 237-247. [ Links ]
17. REQUENA, J.M.; JIMENEZ-RUIZ, A.; SOTO, R.M.; LOPEZ, M.C. & ALONSO, C. - Characterization of a highly repeated interspersed DNA sequence of Trypanosoma cruzi. Its potential use in the diagnosis and strain classification. Molec. Biochem. Parasit., 51: 271-280, 1992. [ Links ]
18. SERA, N.K.; FUKUHARA, N.; MYIATA, K.; HORIKAWA, K. & TOKIWA, H. - Mutagenicity of nitro-azabenzeno[a]pyrene and its related compounds. Mutat. Res., 280: 81-85, 1992. [ Links ]
19. STURM, N.R.; DEGRAVE, W.; MOREL, C.M. & SIMPSON, L. - Sensitive detection and schizodeme classification of Trypanosoma cruzi by amplification of kinetoplast minicircle DNA sequences: use in the diagnosis of Chagas' disease. Molec. Biochem. Parasit., 33: 205-214, 1984. [ Links ]
20. TEIXEIRA, A.R.L.; ARGAÑARAZ, E.R.; FREITAS JR., L.H. et al. - Possible integration of Trypanosoma cruzi kDNA minicircles into host cell genome by infection. Mutat. Res., 305: 197-209, 1994. [ Links ]
21. TEIXEIRA, A.R.L.; CALIXTO, M.A. & TEIXEIRA, M.L. - Chagas' disease: carcinogenic activity of the antitrypanosomal nitroarenes in mice. Mutat. Res., 305: 189-196, 1994. [ Links ]
22. TEIXEIRA, A.R.L.; CORDOBA, J.C.; SOUTO-MAIOR, I.C. & SOLORZANO, E. - Chagas' disease: lymphoma growth in rabbits treated with benznidazole. Amer. J. trop. Med. Hyg., 43: 146-158, 1990. [ Links ]
23. TEIXEIRA, A.R.L.; CUNHA-NETO, E.; RIZZO, L.V. & SILVA, R. - Trypanocidal nitroarene treatment of experimental Trypanosoma cruzi infection does not prevent progression of chronic phase heart lesions in rabbits. J. infect. Dis., 162: 1420, 1990. [ Links ]
24. TEIXEIRA, A.R.L.; FIGUEIREDO, F. & REZENDE FILHO, J. - Delayed hypersensitivity to Trypanosoma cruzi antigens. II. The use of the skin testing with the T12E antigen for diagnosis of Chagas' disease. Rev. Soc. bras. Med. trop., 28: 259-265, 1995. [ Links ]
25. TEIXEIRA, A.R.L.; SILVA, R.; CUNHA-NETO, E.; SANTANA, J.M. & RIZZO, L.V. - Malignant, non-Hodgkin' s lymphomas in Trypanosoma cruzi-infected rabbits treated with nitroarenes. J. comp. Path., 103: 37-48, 1990. [ Links ]
26. TINOCO, D.L.; GARCIA, M.P.; LAURIA-PIRES, L.; SANTANA, J.M. & TEIXEIRA, A.R.L. - The use of four immunologic assays for diagnosis of Chagas' disease in street-sweepers of the Federal District, Brazil. Rev. Soc. bras. Med. trop., 29: 33-40, 1996. [ Links ]
27. URBINA, J.A. - Lipid biosynthesis pathways as chemotherapeutic targets in kinetoplast parasites. Parasitology, 114: 591-599, 1997. [ Links ]
28. URBINA, J.A.; PAYARES, G.; MOLINA, J. et al. - Cure of short- and long-term experimental Chagas' disease using D0870. Science, 273: 969-971, 1996. [ Links ]
29. VIOTTI, R.; VIGLIANO, C.; ARMENTI, H. & SEGURA, E. - Treatment of chronic Chagas' disease with benznidazole: clinical and serologic evolution of patients with long term follow-up. Amer. Heart J., 127: 151-162, 1994. [ Links ]
30. WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION - Control of Chagas' disease: report of a WHO expert committee. Wld. Hlth. Org. techn. Rep. Ser., 811: 1-42, 1991. [ Links ]
Received: 27 September 1999
Accepted: 17 April 2000
Chagas' Disease Multidisciplinary Research Laboratory, University of Brasília, Federal District, Brazil.
Correspondence to: Antonio R. L. Teixeira, Chagas' Disease Multidisciplinary Research Laboratory, University of Brasília, P.O. Box 04536, 70919-970 Brasília, DF, Brasil. e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org