Services on Demand
- Cited by SciELO
- Access statistics
Print version ISSN 0066-782X
On-line version ISSN 1678-4170
Arq. Bras. Cardiol. vol.86 no.5 São Paulo May 2006
Clínica Dr. Edmar Atik - São Paulo, SP - Brazil
To determine the long-term natural history of patients with
mild pulmonary valve stenosis
METHODS: Throughout a 24-year evolutive period (1980 a 2004), 83 patients with pulmonary valve stenosis were evaluated, with 29 of them presenting a mild form of the defect. Of these 29, 13 patients had a long-term follow up. The mean age at the first and last follow-up visits was 34 months (1 month to 15 years) and 10.5 years (3 to 24 years), respectively. In addition to evolutive elements, those regarding clinical, electrocardiographic and echocardiographic aspects were also assessed.
RESULTS: All patients remained assymptomatic throughout the study. Regarding the pulmonary valve pressure gradient, 5 (38.4%) presented a decrease, 3 (23%) remained unchanged, 4 (30.7%) presented elimination and 1 (7.6%) presented accentuation to a moderate degree of involvement. The mean initial and final gradient was 24.2 mmHg (15-30) and 13.6 mmHg (0-54), respectively. The initial gradients of the 4 patients who achieved spontaneous cure were 30, 19, 30 and 20 mmHg. The systolic murmur and right ventricular overload had a direct correlation to the gradient pressure degree, subdivided at each 10 mmHg.
CONCLUSION: The spontaneous cure of the mild pulmonary valve stenosis is possible to achieve, similarly to other acyanogenic anomalies.
Key words: Pulmonary valve stenosis, congenital cardiopathy, natural history.
The mean longevity according to the natural history of pulmonary valve stenosis was estimated by Campbell1 as being 24 ± 4.5 years. At this evaluation, performed in 1969, regarding the moderate and severe degrees of the defect, 19 ± 7% survived up to 40 years of age. It is thus demonstrated that these defects with a higher impact tend to worsen with age, and are responsible for an adverse evolution in case they are not subsequently improved by interventionist techniques, by balloon-catheter or even surgery itself2,3.
Dissimilarly, Samanek4 subsequently stated in 1992, also by studying the natural history of congenital cardiopathies, that pulmonary stenosis is the most benign anomaly of all, with a survival rate of 94% up to 15 years of age.
On the other hand, when the defect has a mild impact, its natural history tends to be even more favorable2-13, although the "spontaneous cure" is a rare occurrence8.
This study reports the natural history of mild pulmonary stenosis in a small series of patients followed by the author, with some of them presenting a complete transvalvular pressure gradient reduction.
Eighty-three patients with pulmonary valve stenosis were followed from November 1980 to December 2004, by only one observer at the author's private clinic. Among them, 29 presented mild stenosis (pressure gradient lower than 41 mmHg), 27 had moderate stenosis (pressure gradient between 41 and 80 mmHg) and 27 presented severe stenosis (pressure gradient above 80 mmHg).
Of the 29 patients with mild pulmonary stenosis, 13 of them, all with gradient pressure < 30 mmHg, had a long-term follow-up and comprise the series in this study. These patients were followed and evaluated regarding the natural history with emphasis on the presence/absence of symptoms, clinical complications, cardiac murmur type and intensity, always correlated with electrocardiographic findings, such as the electrical axis of the QRS complex and right ventricle overload, and mainly the pressure gradient between the right ventricle and the pulmonary trunk, evaluated by echocardiography.
Regarding the cardiac murmur, it was characterized as the ejection type, with the intensity varying from + to ++++ according to the degree, with + being mild, ++ moderate, and > +++, severe. The +/++ intensity refers from mild to moderate intensity. The echocardiography study was carried out by a skilled professional with broad experience in the specialty in hospital services and/or specialized clinics; the study was carried out randomly, regardless of the evolutive phase of the defect. The pressure gradient between the right ventricle and the pulmonary trunk was evaluated by transthoracic Doppler echocardiographic study, in a parasternal short axis view, or subcostal view. The size of the right ventricle was disregarded, as all patients showed normal sized ventricles due to the mild obstruction effect at the pulmonary valve level.
The fact that the echocardiographic study was randomly performed by several examiners was not considered a limitation, given the professionals' experience in acquiring diagnostic images as well as the accurate evaluation of the defect, which was carried out homogeneous and consistently. In addition, this is a simple defect, which does not bring any difficulty for its routine diagnosis as well as its outcome analysis.
Patients' mean ages at the initial phase ranged from 1 month to 15 years, with a mean of 34 months and a mean weight of 15.1 kg, ranging from 3.6 to 60 kg. At the last evaluation, mean age was 10.5 years, ranging from 3 to 24 years and a mean weight of 41.1 kg, ranging from 14 to 93 kg. Six patients were females and 7 patients were male. None of the patients presented another associated cardiac defect, even at the interatrial communication. Four of them presented a pervious foramen ovale (PFO).
Regarding the natural history of the pressure gradient, a decrease was observed in 5 patients (38.4%), corresponding to cases 4, 6, 8, 9, and 10; 3 patients remained unaltered (23%), corresponding to cases 3, 7 and 13; 4 patients (30.7%) presented elimination, corresponding to cases 1, 2, 5 and 12, and accentuation to a moderate degree was observed in just one patient (7.6%), case 11.
The mean pressure gradients between the right ventricle and the pulmonary trunk at the initial and final phases were 24.2 mmHg and 13.6 mmHg, respectively. Eliminating case 11, the only one that showed accentuation of the defect during the natural history of the disease, the mean initial and final gradients of the other 12 cases corresponded to 24.4 mmHg and 10.25 mmHg, respectively. The "spontaneous cure" of the cardiopathy occurred in patients with previous pressure gradients of 30, 19, 30 and 20 mmHg, corresponding to cases 1, 2, 5 and 12, respectively (Table 1).
All patients remained assymptomatic from the initial phase up to the last clinical consult. During follow-up, 4 patients presented intercurrences such as bronchial asthma, bronchopneumonia, urinary infection, and renal lithiasis. No patient showed neuropsychomotor development alterations.
The intensity of the cardiac murmur and the presence or not of mild right ventricular overload had a clear correlation with the degree of pressure gradient at the pulmonary valve level. Thus, considering the initial and final periods and totaling 26 cardiovascular assessments, at the 13 occasions in which pressure gradients were below 19 mmHg, the systolic murmur was absent in 4 (30.7%), and had a mild intensity (+) in 8 (61.5%); at the 13 occasions in which pressure gradients were above 20 mmHg, the murmur had a +/++ intensity in 11 (84.6%) of them. The right ventricular overload evaluated by electrocardiogram, did not occur in 12 (93.3%) at the 13 occasions with pressure gradients below 19 mmHg, and was mild in 9 (69.2%) at the 13 occasions with pressure gradients above 20 mmHg. The electrical axis of the QRS complex was situated, among the 13 patients with gradients below 19 mmHg, between 0 and 90º. Among the 13 with gradients above 20 mmHg, 2 presented the QRS complex axis above 90º, 10 between 0 and 90º, and 1 at 20º. The latter was the only patient in the series with a higher orientation of the electrical axis of the QRS complex (Table 2).
The knowledge of the natural history of pulmonary valve stenosis allows us to state that moderate and accentuated defects tend to undergo the intensifying of their effects2,3 and the mild defects, their decrease2-13. The mean longevity of this defect, when presenting its more accentuated effects, is 24.5±4.5 years, given the concurrent adverse events in the evolution responsible for the deterioration of the ventricular function, represented mainly by hypertrophy, fibrosis, cardiac failure and arrhythmias1.
However, Samanek4 stresses that, during the study of the natural history of several congenital cardiopathies, pulmonary stenosis presents the most favorable evolutive course among all of them, with a survival rate of 97%, 96% and 94% at 1, 2 and 15 years of age, respectively. In this series, 3% of the patients died in the first year, with the safest evolutive period corresponding from the 3rd to the 10th year4.
Most of the publications also mention a favorable evolution in pulmonary valve stenosis when they present a mild degree of severity2-13. Few of these5,7 show an unfavorable evolution of the mild defect, due to the rapid worsening of the condition, similar to what is observed in more severe defects, mainly when exteriorizing occurs early in life. Mody5 observed that the increase of defect severity was noticed in patients younger than 1 year, even those who presented mild effects, at a faster progression rate than in patients older than 1 year of age. The same type of evolution was observed by Anand and Mehta7 in 6 (15%) of 40 infants, with a fast worsening of the mild defect at this age range. It is thought that such evolution is due to two reasons. The first, by the presence of a physiological pulmonary hypertension in the neonatal period, causing an initial underestimated gradient; and the second, due to the child's rapid growth in the first months of life, which would not be proportional to the pulmonary ring and the valvular elements. Tomita et al6, however, have contested such reports by observing a favorable evolution in patients with mild pulmonary valve stenosis younger than 1 one year of age.
On the other hand, no study in literature except that by Gielen et al8, has mentioned the total elimination of the pulmonary valvular pressure gradient. According to these authors8, this normalization occurred in 9 (28.1%) of 32 patients with pulmonary stenosis characterized as minor, with pressure gradients < 20 mmHg. These authors8, however, do not report, concomitantly with the elimination of the defect, on the other clinical events of this "cure", such as cardiac murmur elimination, electrocardiographic normalization, along with the total elimination of the pressure gradient between the right ventricle and the pulmonary trunk, as observed in 4 (30.7%) of our 13 patients.
Our remaining findings are in accordance to most of the other findings in literature, which show that 5 (38.4%) patients presented a gradient decrease, 3 (23%) remained unchanged and only 1 (7.6%) presented worsening of the defect to a moderate degree.
Regarding this aspect, Anand and Mehta7 observed a gradient worsening in 15% (6 of 40) of assymptomatic infants, who needed surgical intervention or percutaneous valvuloplasty. The same type of evolution was observed by Gielen et al8, who noticed worsening in 3 and 10% of minor and mild defects, respectively. Wennevold and Jacobsen2 observed worsening in 1 (14.2%) of 7 patients with pressure gradient < 50 mmHg. Lueker et al12 observed a mild worsening in 1 (12.5%) of 8 patients with pressure gradient < 50 mmHg during a mean period of 7.8 years, in children. Nugent et al9 had also noticed worsening of the pulmonary transvalvular gradient in 14% of the patients evaluated by a hemodynamic study, during a period of 4 to 8 years.
Finally, it can stated that, in mild cases of pulmonary stenosis with a pressure gradient < 30 mmHg, diagnosed and evaluated at any age range, except neonatal and first months of life5,7, the evolution is usually favorable up to the spontaneous cure of the defect, and complications that would necessitate some type of intervention are rarely observed in this group of patients in the course of the natural history.
Despite the favorable evolutive perspective, these patients must undergo the prophylaxis of infectious endocarditis, although it seldom occurs in patients with pulmonary stenosis, even in those cases with more severe defects, according to the current guidelines of the American Heart Association.
Thus, the pulmonary stenosis can be grouped with other congenital anomalies that can evolve to spontaneous cure, similarly to what occurs with other acyanogenic defects such as left-to-right blood flow, mainly represented by interventricular communication, but also by the arterial canal and interatrial communication.
This knowledge becomes fundamental when providing adequate assistance to these patients' families during daily clinical practice, allowing an early outline of a more appropriate perspective for mild pulmonary valve stenosis.
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
1. Campbell M. Natural history of congenital pulmonary stenosis. Br Heart J .1969; 31: 394. [ Links ]
2. Wennevold A, Jacobsen JR. Natural history of valvular pulmonary stenosis in children below the age of two years. Long-term follow-up with serial heart catheterizations. Eur J Cardiol .1978; 8: 371-8. [ Links ]
3. Lange PE, Onnasch DG, Heintzen PH. Valvular pulmonary stenosis: natural history and right ventricular function in infants and children. Eur Heart J .1985; 6: 706-9. [ Links ]
4. Samanek M. Children with congenital heart disease: probability of natural survival. Pediatr Cardiol .1992; 13 :152-8. [ Links ]
5. Mody MR. The natural history of uncomplicated valvular pulmonic stenosis. Am Heart J .1975; 90: 317-21. [ Links ]
6. Tomita H, Ikeda K, Iida K, Chiba S. Mild to moderate pulmonary valvular stenosis in infant sometimes improves to the condition unnecessary to do PTPV: Doppler echocardiographic observation. Tohoku J Exp Med .995; 176: 155-62. [ Links ]
7. Anand R, Mehta AV. Natural history of asymptomatic valvar pulmonary stenosis diagnosed in infancy. Clin Cardiol .1997; 20: 377-80. [ Links ]
8. Gielen H, Daniels O, van Lier H. Natural history of congenital pulmonary valvar stenosis: an echo and Doppler cardiographic study. Cardiol Young .1999; 9: 129-35. [ Links ]
9. Nugent EW, Freedom RM, Nora JJ, Ellison RC, Rowe RD, Nadas AS. Clinical course in pulmonary stenosis. Circulation .1977; 56(Suppl I): 38-47. [ Links ]
10. Freedom RM, Benson L. Congenital pulmonary stenosis and isolated congenital pulmonary insufficiency. In: Freedom RM, Yoo SJ, Mikailian H, William WG, editors. The natural and modified history of congenital heart disease. Toronto: Futura 2004; 107-18 [ Links ]
11. Kirk CR, Wilkinson JL, Qureshi SA. Regression of pulmonary valve stenosis due to a dysplastic valve presenting in the neonatal period. Eur Heart J .1988; 9: 1027-9. [ Links ]
12. Lueker RD, Vogel JH, Blount SG Jr. Regression of valvular pulmonary stenosis. Br Heart J .1970; 32: 779-82. [ Links ]
13. Ardura J, Gonzalez C, Andres J. Does mild pulmonary stenosis progress during chilhood?: a study of its natural couse. Clin . 2004; 27: 519-22. [ Links ]
Rua 13 de Maio, 1954 Cj. 71
01327-002 - São Paulo, SP - Brazil
Received on 02/16/05
Accepted on 04/22/05