versión impresa ISSN 0100-8455
Braz. J. Genet. v.20 n.3 Ribeirão Preto sep. 1997
Genetic variability in salt tolerance during germination of Stylosanthes humilis H.B.K. and association between salt tolerance and isozymes
Maria Bernadete Lovato1 and Paulo Sodero Martins 2
1Departamento de Biologia Geral, Instituto de Ciências Biológicas,
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Caixa Postal 486,
31270-010 Belo Horizonte, MG, Brasil. Send correspondence to M.B.L.
2Departamento de Genética, Escola Superior de Agricultura "Luiz de Queiroz",
Caixa Postal 83 , 13418-900 Piracicaba, SP, Brasil.
Variation in salt tolerance of six natural populations of Stylosanthes humilis from three ecogeographic regions, Mata (wet tropical climate), Agreste and Sertão (semi-arid tropical climate) of Pernambuco State, Northeast Brazil, was evaluated on germination in 201 mM NaCl. There were significant differences among families of all populations for germination percentage and of five populations (except Tamandaré, from Mata) for germination rate. Populations from semi-arid regions presented high coefficients of genetic variation, those from Agreste being higher than those from Sertão. Populations from Mata showed low coefficients of genetic variation. The coefficients of genotypic determination were high for five populations, except Tamandaré, both for germination percentage (³ 0.89) and for germination rate (³ 0.79), indicating the possibility of selection for salt tolerance in these populations. An electrophoretic analysis of esterase and peroxidase isozymes was also performed in the six populations, and correlations were estimated between salt tolerance and allelic frequencies. The analysis of salt tolerant and salt sensitive families of populations from Agreste suggested an association of alleles of a peroxidase locus with salt tolerance during germination in the Caruaru population.
Salinity is a serious problem in many parts of the world, decreasing crop productivity and it is an important edaphic factor, affecting the natural distribution of plants in natural habitats (Tal, 1985). The semi-arid regions are characterized by drought, and commonly by saline soils, thus the plants from these regions must be adapted to the adverse situations of these habitats (Epstein, 1972).
Stylosanthes humilis is an annual herbaceous legume endemic to Central and South America, presenting a wide geographic and ecological distribution. In Brazil it is found in semi-arid regions, as well as in areas with an annual rainfall of up to 3000 mm (Williams et al., 1984). Apart from these characteristics, which make it an interesting species for genetic/ecological studies, it is considered as an important pasture legume for the tropics.
S. humilis presents hard or water-impermeable seeds. Dormancy is broken by high surface soil temperatures as the growing season approaches, which ensures that seeds only germinate during the rainy season (Mott et al., 1981), and thus avoid drought (Fisher and Ludlow, 1984). The response of S. humilis to saline stress is stage-specific with high tolerance during germination (Lovato et al., 1994), and greater sensitivity during growth (Russell, 1976; Lovato, 1991). However, a significant variation in salt tolerance has been found among natural populations both during germination (Lovato et al., 1994) and during the growth stage (Lovato, 1991), although it was not determined how much of this variation is due to genetic components. Intraspecific genetic variation is important to develop cultivars with a higher salt tolerance.
Salt tolerance has been reported in various species as a quantitative trait, e.g., tomato (Fooland and Jones, 1991), alfafa (Allen et al., 1985) and sorghum (Igartua et al., 1994). A method for understanding the inheritance of quantitative traits is the detection of linkage between molecular and biochemical markers. Associations between biochemical marker loci and quantitative traits suggest a functional significance for the extensive enzymatic polymorphism frequently found in natural populations (Price et al., 1984).
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Six populations of S. humilis from Pernambuco State (Northeast Brazil), two from each of three ecogeographic regions, Mata, Agreste, and Sertão, were analyzed. Mata is the coastal region (originally forested) with small annual temperature variation and high rainfall. Agreste and Sertão are characterized by semi-arid tropical climates, with a predominance of thorny shrubs. The populations analyzed and their respective locations were: 1) Janga and 2) Tamandaré, from Mata; 3) São Caetano and 4) Caruaru, from Agreste; 5) Sertânia and 6) Flores, from Sertão (see Lovato et al., 1994).
Seeds collected from each plant (18 to 24 plants for each population) were kept separately. In order to prevent the effects of different habitats during the development of seeds and to increase the number of available seeds, one seed from each collected plant was planted in an experimental field located at the Genetics Department of the Escola Superior de Agricultura "Luiz de Queiroz", Universidade de São Paulo, in Piracicaba, SP, and their seed progenies were used in this work. Seeds taken from 18 families (seed progeny from single maternal parents) of each population were used to assess the genetic variation for salt tolerance and for electrophoretic analysis.
Variation in salt tolerance
Seeds stored for eight months at room temperature were mechanically scarified and treated with fungicide, and incubated in plastic boxes Gerbox type (50 seeds in each) with 12 ml of 201 mM NaCl. This salt concentration discriminates well between these populations (Lovato et al., 1994). After 5 h of incubation at 25oC in darkness, the temperature was decreased to 16oC for 2 h, to break the embryo dormancy that could exist in some families. The seeds were then incubated at 25oC in darkness. Germinated seeds, based on the emergence of the radicle, were counted every 24 h, over a period of 14 days. The experimental design was a completely randomized one, with 18 treatments (families) for each population, and three replications of 50 seeds each. Germination rates were calculated according to Popinigs (1977) as S(ni/ti), where ni = number of germinated seeds on day i and ti = time (days) to germination. Data for percentage of germination were transformed into arcsin Ö% prior to the statistical analysis, in order to achieve variance homogeneity.
The statistics consisted of an analysis of variance for each population (Steel and Torrie, 1980). The genetic variance among families () and the phenotypic variance () were estimated by the following equations: = (Q1 - Q2)/r and = Q1/r, where Q1 = mean square of families, Q2 = mean square of error and r = number of replications. The coefficient of genetic variation (CVg) and the coefficient of genotypic determination (b) were obtained from these estimates for each population, as follows: CVg = (Ö/m)100 and b =/, where m = general mean. These parameters were estimated for both germination rate and germination percentage.
Isozyme electrophoresis and analysis of association with salt tolerance
Seedlings 2 cm in length (36 to 48 h after incubation in distilled water) were used for analyzing peroxidases (PER, EC 22.214.171.124) and seeds which were soaked for 14 h in distilled water were used for esterase analysis (EST, EC 126.96.36.199). Enzymes were extracted in a buffer composed of 0.1 M Tris, pH 7.5, 0.2 M sucrose, 0.6% polyvinylpyrrolidone, 0.1% bovine serum albumine and 20 ml 0.6% 2-mercaptoethanol in 15 ml buffer. Electrophoresis was performed in 12% Sigma starch gel in Tris-citrate/lithium-borate buffer (Scandalios, 1969).
First, the electrophoresis was performed on one seed or seedling of each of 18 families of each population. Then, peroxidases were analyzed for five to 10 seedlings of each of the five most salt tolerant and five most sensitive families of the populations São Caetano and Caruaru. Allelic frequencies, determined by direct allele counting, were established for each population and for each of the 10 families of populations from São Caetano and Caruaru. For those staining zones which were difficult to interpret, the presence or absence of a specific band was recorded and its frequency for each population was obtained by dividing the number of seedlings with the band by the total number of seedlings analyzed. Linear correlations were used to analyze the association of salt tolerance with frequencies of bands or alleles, both for populations and for families within São Caetano and Caruaru populations. For this statistical study the allelic or band frequencies were transformed into arcsin Ö frequency. For the analysis of the association of salt tolerance during germination with isozymes, linear correlations of band or allele frequencies with rate and percentage germination on 201 mM NaCl were calculated. The relationship of isozymes with salt tolerance during growth was analyzed using the number of necrotic leaves and the shoot dry weight of plants grown in 80 mM NaCl , established in another experiment (Lovato, 1991).
Genetic variation for salt tolerance
There was a significant variation (P < 0.01) within all populations in relation to the germination percentage (Tables I and III) and within five populations (except Tamandaré) for germination rate (Table II and IV) screened on 201 mM NaCl. The populations from São Caetano, one of the most sensitive (mean 44% germination), and Caruaru, one of the most tolerant (mean 70% germination), both from the Agreste region, presented the greatest variation among families, where the differences between the highest and the lowest percentage of germination were 90% and 75.4%, respectively. Populations from Mata (Janga and Tamandaré) were the least phenotypically variable, these values being 46.3 in Janga and 50.7 in Tamandaré (Table I).
The values in each column followed by the same letter do not differ from each other at the 5% level (Tukey test).
The values in each column followed by the same letter do not differ from each other at the 5% level (Tukey test).
|Source ofvariation||Means squares|
*, Significant at 1% level.
1CV, CVg, b represent coefficients of variation, genetic variation and genotypic determination, respectively.
Table IV - Summary of variance analysis of germination rate, and respective coefficients of variation (CV), genetic variation (CVg) and genotypic determination of seeds of six populations of Stylosanthes humilis sown in 201 mM NaCl.
|Source of variation||Means squares|
*, Significant at the 1% level.
The coefficients of genetic variation for germination percentage (Table III) were also higher for both populations from Agreste (Caruaru and São Caetano), followed by populations from Sertão. The populations from Mata presented the lowest coefficients of genetic variation. Five populations, with the exception of Tamandaré, showed high coefficients of genotypic determination, indicating that a high proportion of observed phenotypic variation was genetic, and therefore allowing selection for saline tolerance, even in populations with intermediate values of variation, as in the population from Janga.
Populations from Agreste also had the highest variation in germination rate and Tamandaré the lowest phenotypic variation, although other population from Mata (Janga) had a high variation (Table II). However, considering the genetic variation (Table IV), the values of coefficients of genetic variation, although higher than those for germination percentage, maintained the same relation between populations, i.e., populations from Agreste had the highest variation, followed by populations from Sertão, and the populations from Mata presented the lowest coefficients of genetic variation among families. The coefficients of genotypic determination for germination rate were of the same magnitude as those for germination percentage, being relatively low for Tamandaré and high for all other populations.
Salt tolerance and isozymes
The esterase system exhibited two staining zones consistent with a monomeric subunit structure. The two zones were interpreted as two loci, each with two alleles. The peroxidases showed three staining zones, one anodic with only one band in all populations, that was interpreted as a monomorphic locus (Per1), and two cathodic zones. The fast cathodic zone presented two bands, and was interpreted as a locus (Per2) with two alleles. The slow cathodic zone was difficult to be interpret, exhibiting in all populations two bands, assigned as bands 3 and 4.
The analysis of the association of salt tolerance of populations during germination and during growth, with the allele or band frequencies of locus or staining polymorphic zones showed significant correlations (P < 0.05) only between the allele frequency in the Per2 locus with germination rate and with the number of leaves with necrosis (Table V). This preliminary analysis (based on electrophoresis of one seed for each family) showed that in the Caruaru population all the tolerant families presented only the allele Per2S, and the sensitive ones only the alternative allele, Per2F. In the São Caetano population, the sensitive families also had only the Per2F allele, but the tolerant ones presented one or the other allele.
|Alleles or |
|No. of necrotic |
*, Significant at the 5% level.
Considering that within both populations from Agreste region (Caruaru and São Caetano) there were families that were very different in relation to salt tolerance (Tables I and II), a more detailed study was made, analyzing the peroxidases of five to 10 seedlings within each of five tolerant and five sensitive families of each of these populations. S. humilis presents an intermediate mating system (Marcon, 1988), and thus segregation within families can occur. All the tolerant families of Caruaru population presented only homozygote seedlings for the Per2S allele, and the seedlings of sensitive families presented only the alternative allele, Per2F (Table VI). In the São Caetano population, all the seedlings of sensitive families were also homozygotic for the Per2F allele, however the tolerant families were homozygotic for this or for the alternative allele, or segregated for both (Table VI). The high correlation coefficients between the frequencies of allele Per2S of the families and the rate and percentage germination of families of Caruaru population confirmed the association of this allele with salt tolerance during germination in this population (Table VII).
|Families||Per2S frequencies||Families||Per2S frequencies|
|2 (T)1||1.00||4 (T)||0.00|
|5 (T)||1.00||7 (T)||1.00|
|10 (T)||1.00||11 (T)||1.00|
|14 (T)||1.00||14 (T)||0.00|
|16 (T)||1.00||18 (T)||0.11|
|3 (S)||0.00||2 (S)||0.00|
|8 (S)||0.00||3 (S)||0.00|
|9 (S)||0.00||6 (S)||0.00|
|13 (S)||0.00||9 (S)||0.00|
|15 (S)||0.00||15 (S)||0.00|
|Population||Number of |
|No. of necrotic |
*, **, Significant at 5% and 1% levels, respectively.
It appears that there was no association between alleles of the Per2 locus and salt tolerance during growth, since a significant correlation was observed only for the number of leaves with necrosis for São Caetano population, and none for the other character used to assess salt tolerance during growth, the shoot weight (Table VII).
Genetic variation for salt tolerance during seed germination has been shown in several species, for example, in alfafa the estimated broad sense heritability is 50% (Allen et al., 1985), and in the cultivated tomato, 74% (Fooland and Jones, 1991).
The populations from Agreste presented the highest genetic variation, followed by those from Sertão. The populations Janga and Tamandaré from Mata region showed lower genetic variation. Marcon (1988) also found lower variation in isozymes in populations from Mata than those from Agreste and Sertão, and the variation within populations was correlated with environmental heterogeneity (climatic, topographic and edaphic conditions). The Agreste region is the most variable in relation to environmental conditions. The two populations from Agreste besides having shown great intrapopulational variation presented different levels of saline tolerance, Caruaru being one of the most tolerant and São Caetano one of the most sensitive. The spatial environmental heterogeneity in relation to soil salinity and rainfall between and within habitats of these populations could, through disruptive selection mechanisms, contribute to the maintenance of high genetic variation on salt tolerance in these populations. It is known that in many salt affected soils there is extreme variability in salinity both spatially (Richards,1983) and temporally (Ungar, 1987). According to Hedrick (1995), when an unfavorable environment can be avoided by either delayed germination or diapause, the conditions for genetic polymorphism are greatly broadened in a temporally varying environment. S. humilis presents dormancy and this could maintain variation in salt tolerance. The patterns of spacial and temporal variation had different effects on the maintenance of polymorphism (Hedrick, 1986, 1995). Although in the present study the patterns of environment variation were not characterized, it is known that there are great temporal fluctuations in rainfall in Agreste and Sertão regions, which could lead to temporal variations in soil salinity.
Marcon (1988), based on levels of genetic variation, on genetic distances between populations, and on historical evidence that populations from Mata are recent and have been introduced by migrants from Sertão region, suggested that populations from Mata have a marginal distribution, and their relative genetic uniformity is due to a founder effect. The low levels of genetic variation in salt tolerance of these populations favor this hypothesis.
Our results showed an association of salt tolerance during germination with alleles of one locus of peroxidase only in the population from Caruaru. The fact that a relation between saline tolerance and allozymes of peroxidases was found only in one population suggests that even if peroxidases have some functional relation with saline stress in S. humilis, the two allozymes do not confer differences in salt tolerance during germination.
The association found in this study could be due to a physical association (linkage) between the peroxidase locus and the saline response loci. The putative gametic disequilibrium found only in Caruaru population could be explained by historical events, such as founder effect or bottleneck, both leading to genetic drift (Hedrick et al., 1978).
The populations from Janga and Tamandaré, both from Mata region, are from an environment that was altered by man, and probably are recent (Marcon, 1988). The presence of allele Per2S in Janga suggests that this population was founded by seeds from São Caetano and/or Caruaru populations, since it is common to bring goats into the Mata region (Marcon, 1988). The dispersal of Stylosanthes humilis seeds is facilitated by the presence of a hooked beak (hardened style which remains after anthesis) that adheres readily to fur, clothing, hay, etc (McKeon and Mott, 1984).
A variação na tolerância salina na germinação dentro de seis populações naturais de Stylosanthes humilis, provenientes de três regiões ecogeográficas do Estado de Pernambuco, Mata (clima tropical úmido), Agreste e Sertão (clima tropical semiárido), foi determinada submetendo-se sementes para germinar em NaCl 201 mM. Os resultados mostraram diferenças significativas entre famílias de todas as populações para porcentagem de germinação e de cinco populações para velocidade de germinação, com exceção da população Tamandaré (Mata). As populações das regiões semiáridas mostraram altos coeficientes de variação genética, sendo as do Agreste maiores que as do Sertão. As populações da Mata apresentaram baixos coeficientes de variação genética. Os coeficientes de determinação genotípica foram altos para todas as populações, com exceção de Tamandaré, tanto para porcentagem de germinação (³ 0,89), como para velocidade de germinação (³ 0,79), indicando a possibilidade de seleção para tolerância salina na germinação nessas populações. Foram também realizadas análises de isoenzimas de esterases e peroxidases e estabelecidas correlações entre tolerância salina e freqüências alélicas dessas populações. A análise de famílias sensíveis e tolerantes ao sal de populações do Agreste mostrou uma associação de alelos de um loco de peroxidase com a tolerância salina durante a germinação na população proveniente de Caruaru.
Allen, S.G., Dobrenz, A.K., Schonhorst, M. and Storner, J.E. (1985). Heritability of NaCl tolerance in germinating alfafa seed. Agron. J. 77: 99-101. [ Links ]
Epstein, E. (1972). Mineral Nutrition of Plants: Principles and Perspectives. Wiley, New York. [ Links ]
Fisher, M.J. and Ludlow, M.M. (1984). Adaptation to water deficits in Stylosanthes. In: The Biology and Agronomy of Stylosanthes (Stace, H.M. and Edye, L.A., eds.). Academic Press, Sydney, pp. 163-180. [ Links ]
Fooland, M.R. and Jones, R.A. (1991). Genetics analysis of salt tolerance during germination in Licopersicum. Theor. Appl. Genet. 81: 321-326. [ Links ]
Hedrick, P.W. (1986). Genetic polymorphism in heterogeneous environments: a decade later. Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 17: 535-566. [ Links ]
Hedrick, P.W. (1995). Genetic polymorphism in a temporally varying environment: effects of delayed germination or diapause. Heredity 75: 164-170. [ Links ]
Hedrick, P.W., Jain, S. and Holden, L. (1978). Multilocus systems in evolution. Evol. Biol. 11: 101-184. [ Links ]
Igartua, E., Gracia, M.P. and Lasa, J.M. (1994). Characterization and genetic control of germination-emergence responses of grain sorghum to salinity. Euphytica 76: 185-193. [ Links ]
Lovato, M.B. (1991). Variabilidade genética da tolerância salina em populações de Stylosanthes humilis H.B.K. de diferentes regiões ecogeográficas do Estado de Pernambuco. Doctoral thesis, ESALQ/USP, Piracicaba. [ Links ]
Lovato, M.B., Martins, P.S. and Lemos Filho, de J.P. (1994). Germination in Stylosanthes humilis populations in the presence of NaCl. Aust. J. Bot. 42: 717-723. [ Links ]
Marcon, G. (1988). Estrutura genética de populações de Stylosanthes humilis H.B.K. (Leguminosae) de diferentes regiões ecogeográficas do Estado de Pernambuco. Doctoral thesis, ESALQ/USP, Piracicaba. [ Links ]
McKeon, G.M. and Mott, J.J. (1984). Seed biology of Stylosanthes. In: The Biology and Agronomy of Stylosanthes (Stace, H.M. and Edye, L.A., eds.). Academic Press, Sydney, pp. 311-332. [ Links ]
Mott, J.J., McKeon, G.M., Gardner, C.J. and Mannetje, L. (1981). Geographic variation in the reduction of hard seed content of Stylosanthes seeds in the tropics and subtropics on northern Australia. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 32: 861-869. [ Links ]
Popinigs, F. (1977). Fisiologia da Semente. AGIPLAN, Brasília. [ Links ]
Price, S.C., Shumaker, K.M., Kahler, A.L., Allard, R.W. and Hill, J.E. (1984). Estimatives of population differentiation obtained from enzyme polymorphisms and quantitative characters. J. Hered. 75: 141-142. [ Links ]
Richards, R.A. (1983). Should selection for yield in saline regions be made on saline or non-saline soils? Euphytica 32: 431-438. [ Links ]
Russell, J.S. (1976). Comparative salt tolerance of some tropical and temperate legumes and tropical grasses. Aust. J. Exp. Agric. Anim. Husb. 16: 103-109. [ Links ]
Scandalios, J.B. (1969). Genetic control of multiple molecular forms of enzymes in plants. Biochem. Genet. 3: 37-79. [ Links ]
Steel, R.G.D. and Torrie, J.H. (1980). Principles and Procedures of Statistics. 2nd edn. McGraw-Hill, New York. [ Links ]
Tal, M. (1985). Genetics of salt tolerance in higher plants: theoretical and practical considerations. Plant Soil 89: 199-226. [ Links ]
Ungar, I.A. (1987). Population ecology of halophyte seeds. Bot. Rev. 53: 301-334. [ Links ]
Williams, R.J., Reid, R., Schultze-Kraft, R., Souza Costa, N.M. and Thomas, B.D. (1984). Natural distribution of Stylosanthes. In: The Biology and Agronomy of Stylosanthes (Stace, H.M. and Edye, L.A., eds.). Academic Press, Sydney, pp. 71-101. [ Links ]
(Received September 9, 1996)