SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.34 número1MATHEMATICAL MODELING OF THE ELECTRIC CURRENT GENERATION IN A MICROBIAL FUEL CELL INOCULATED WITH MARINE SEDIMENTEFFECTS OF NANOPARTICLES AND SURFACTANT CHARGE GROUPS ON THE PROPERTIES OF VES GEL índice de autoresíndice de assuntospesquisa de artigos
Home Pagelista alfabética de periódicos  

Serviços Personalizados

Journal

Artigo

Indicadores

Links relacionados

Compartilhar


Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering

versão impressa ISSN 0104-6632versão On-line ISSN 1678-4383

Braz. J. Chem. Eng. vol.34 no.1 São Paulo jan./mar. 2017

http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/0104-6632.20170341s20150231 

KINETICS AND CATALYSIS; REACTION ENGINEERING; AND MATERIALS SCIENCE

INVESTIGATING THE LONG-TERM STABILITY AND KINETICS OF SUPEROXIDE ION IN DIMETHYL SULFOXIDE CONTAINING IONIC LIQUIDS AND THE APPLICATION OF THIOPHENE DESTRUCTION

M. Hayyan1  2  *  * 

M. H. Ibrahim1  3 

A. Hayyan1  2 

M. Ali Hashim1  3 

1University of Malaya Centre for Ionic Liquids (UMCiL), University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur 50603, Malaysia.

2Institute of Halal Research University of Malaya (IHRUM), Academy of Islamic Studies, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur 50603, Malaysia. Phone/Fax: + 6-03-7967-5311

3Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur 50603, Malaysia.

Abstract

The long-term stability of superoxide ion (O2•−) with four ionic liquids (ILs), namely 1-(2-methoxyethyl)-1-methylpiperidinium tris(pentafluoroethyl)trifluorophosphate [MOEMPip][TPTP], 1-(3-methoxypropyl)-1-methylpiperidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [MOPMPip][TFSI], N-ethyl-N,N-dimethyl-2-methoxyethylammonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [N112,1O2][TFSI], and ethyl-dimethyl-propylammonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EDMPAmm][TFSI], was studied for up to 24 h using two-second intervals. This was achieved by chemical generation of O2•− by dissolution of potassium superoxide salt in dimethyl sulfoxide and the subsequent addition of the IL. The decrease in the concentration of O2•− after the introduction of the IL was monitored using a UV-vis spectrophotometer. The ammonium-based ILs were found to be more stable than piperidinium-based ILs. To the best of our knowledge, this was the first time that O2•− stability with ILs has been monitored continuously for up to 24 h. This should provide a better insight into the stability and kinetics of O2•− for industrial applications and its role in energy-storage devices. The most appropriate IL as a medium was [EDMPAmm][TFSI], and O2•− generated in this IL was used to destroy nearly 90% of thiophene.

Keywords: Reactive oxygen species; Kinetics; Deep eutectic solvents; Green solvents; Desulfurization; Potassium superoxide; Hazardous material

INTRODUCTION

Superoxide ion has garnered interest mostly for its role in biological applications due to its involvement in diseases, such as Parkinson's disease and cancer. Other sources of interest for O2•− are its role in fuel cells, batteries, and other electrochemical devices, as well as many other applications (Afanas'ev et al., 1974; Yuan et al., 2014). However, the main problem associated with implementing O2•− is the selection of a solvent in which O2•− is stable. It is well established that O2•− is a highly nucleophilic ion that initiates further reactions with any proton source that may be present in the medium (Tanner et al., 2014). This instability makes it impractical for industrial use. Furthermore, the instability of O2•− is a major issue for the performance of energy-storage devices, because O2•− cannot participate in the subsequent reduction reactions, thereby reducing the specific capacity of the device (Pozo-Gonzalo et al., 2013). However, O2•− is stable in the absence of a proton source, as is the case in aprotic solvents, including dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), acetonitrile, and dimethylformamide (Sawyer and Valentine, 1981; Sawyer, 1991; Sawyer et al., 1995; Hayyan et al., 2016a). However, these solvents are hazardous due to their high volatility and negative ecological effects. Since 2001, O2•− has been shown to be stable in some ILs (AlNashef et al., 2001), providing a potentially green alternative to volatile organic solvents due to their low volatility and potential to be benign if selected carefully.

Many studies have been dedicated to investigating the stability of O2•− in ILs and to identifying the products that result from the reaction of O2•− with some ILs (Hayyan et al., 2012c; Hayyan et al., 2012a; Pozo-Gonzalo et al., 2013; Switzer et al., 2013; Frith et al., 2014).

The generation of O2•− in ILs and its short-term stability can be determined accurately by cyclic voltammetry (CV). However, to confidently confirm its long-term stability in ILs, the stability of O2•− must be monitored for a greater length of time, because the short timescale of voltammetry may not detect reactions that occur after the analysis has been completed. For example, imidazolium-based ILs produce O2•− that is stable in the short-term (AlNashef et al., 2001; Islam et al., 2009), but it was found later that the O2•− was stable only in the short-term, after which the cation reacted with O2•− (Islam et al., 2009; Hayyan et al., 2015a). Thus, it can reasonably be concluded that, from a practical perspective, the O2•− species is not stable in imidazolium-based ILs, although the reversible cyclic voltammetric redox reaction of the O2/O2•− couple was observed (Islam et al., 2009; Hayyan et al., 2013a). Another example to illustrate the need to confirm cyclic voltammetry by other techniques is work that was published recently by Xiong et al. (2014). The authors reported that an additional reaction has more impact at a slower sweep rate since a longer voltammetric timescale allows the reaction to be detected. Furthermore, long-term monitoring of the O2•− concentration allows the reaction kinetics to be studied. Several studies have reported the long-term stability of O2•− with ILs (AlNashef et al., 2010; Hayyan et al., 2012d; Hayyan et al., 2012f) and other electrolytes, such as glyme (Schwenke et al., 2013). Recently, Schwenke et al. (2015) monitored O2•− with 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide for 18 h.

Increasingly stringent sulfur limits in fuels have driven intense research efforts to find a more efficient means of desulfurization to replace the conventional hydrodesulfurization method (Yahaya et al., 2013; Ibrahim et al., 2016). ILs have attracted attention due to their many desirable properties, such as low volatility, high conductivity, and their tuneability. Hence, they have been used to desulfurize fuels by various methods, including extraction (Ferreira et al., 2014; Lu et al., 2014) and oxidative desulfurization (Jiang et al., 2014; et al., 2014). Recently, our group reported the possibility of using O2•− generated in ILs to destroy chlorinated hydrocarbons and sulfur compounds (Hayyan et al., 2012f; Hayyan et al., 2012e; Hayyan et al., 2015b; Hayyan et al., 2016b; AlNashef et al., 2013). Therefore, it also was worthwhile to explore using O2•− to destroy sulfur compounds in one of the studied ILs.

In this work, we studied the stability of O2•− with four ILs for the long timespan of 24 h, using two-second intervals. The concentration of O2•− was monitored for up to 24 h by monitoring the concentration of O2•− in DMSO with the IL every 2 s, using the timedrive of a UV-vis spectrophotometer. Interestingly, O2•− generated in the ILs destroyed thiophene, which we used as a model sulfur compound.

EXPERIMENTAL SECTION

In this study, we used synthesis grade ILs provided by Merck (Table 1). Scheme 1 shows the chemical structure of the ILs used. DMSO (Fisher, 99.98%), potassium superoxide (KO2) (Sigma Aldrich, 99.9%), acetonitrile (AcN) (UNICHROM, HPLC grade 99.9%), and thiophene (TH) (Merck) were used without any further purification.

Table 1 Formulae and molecular weights for ILs. 

IL Abbreviation Formula Molecular wt
1-(2-Methoxyethyl)-1-methylpiperidinium tris(pentafluoroethyl)trifluorophosphate [MOEMPip][TPTP] C15H20F18NOP 603.27
1-(3-Methoxypropyl)-1-methylpiperidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [MOPMPip][TFSI] C12H22F6N2O5S2 452.44
N-Ethyl-N,N-dimethyl-2-methoxyethylammonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [N112,1O2][TFSI] C8H18F6N2O5S2 412.37
Ethyl-dimethyl-propylammonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide [EDMPAmm][TFSI] C9H18F6N2O4S2 396.37

Figure 4 Structures of ions comprising the ILs. 

Electrochemical Generation of Superoxide Ion

CV tests were performed as the electrochemical analysis technique, since this method is extremely powerful and is among the most extensively practiced of all electrochemical methods. Protic impurities can have a dramatic effect on the stability of O2•− (AlNashef et al., 2001; Evans et al., 2004). Hence, the ILs were dried overnight at 50 ºC under vacuum. It should be noted that some of the ILs used were acidic without pre-treatment, with pH values in the range of 4-6. AlNashef et al. (2001) reported that O2•− was unstable in some ILs due to their acidity and due to the reaction of O2•− with protons. Therefore, the pH of the ILs was measured using pH strips (Merck), and a very small quantity of KO2 was added to the acidic ILs until their pH became neutral.

The electrochemistry experiment was performed using an EG&G 263A potentiostat/galvanostat (PAR) connected to a computer with data acquisition software. CVs were conducted in a one-compartment cell because the time required to affect the ILs was relatively short. The cell was a jacketed vessel (10-ml volume) with a Teflon cap with four holes for the three electrochemical electrodes and a gas sparging tube. A glassy carbon (GC) macroelectrode (BASi, 3-mm diameter) was used as working electrode for CV. A platinum electrode was used as a counter electrode, and an aqueous Ag/AgCl electrode (BASi) was used as the reference electrode. The macroelectrodes were polished using alumina solution (BASi) and sonicated in distilled water for 10 min before each experiment. This was done to ensure that there were no impurities on the surface of the working electrode.

Due to the sensitivity of O2•− to water, all experiments were performed in a dry glove box, with tight humidity control of less than 1 ppm water, under either an argon or helium atmosphere. Prior to the formation of O2•−, a background voltammogram was obtained after removal of O2, using a scan rate of 100 mV/s. O2 removal was achieved by purging the IL with dry N2. This particular method was quite simple and effective. Purging a solution with an inert gas can reduce the partial pressure of O2 above the solution, and consequently, the solubility of O2 in the solution is decreased. Then, O2 was bubbled into the IL for at least 30 min to ensure that equilibrium was achieved. Between consecutive CV runs, O2 was bubbled into the solution briefly to refresh the system and to remove any concentration gradients. N2 or O2 sparging was discontinued during the CV runs.

Long-Term Stability of O2•−

Spectroscopic grade DMSO was dried overnight in a vacuum oven at 50 ºC and vacuum pressure. KO2 was stored in a sealed vial filled with molecular sieves. The chemical generation of O2•− was performed by dissolving about 0.001 to 0.003 g of KO2 in 20 to 30 ml of DMSO while stirring with a magnetic stirrer. Subsequently, 0.05 g of IL was added to 5 ml of the DMSO in which O2•− had been produced to investigate the stability of O2•− with time. A computer-controlled UV-vis spectrophotometer (PerkinElmer-Lambda 35) was used to measure the absorption spectra of O2•− every 2 s for up to 24 h. Quartz cuvettes were used (Perkin Elmer, 10-mm path length). The reference solution for the spectral measurements was DMSO or DMSO solution that contained an appropriate amount of IL. It is known from previous studies that the absorbance band of O2•− is in the range of 250-270 nm (Hayyan et al., 2015a). The UV-vis experiments were conducted in a dry area. The cuvettes were sealed, and the necessary precautions were considered to prevent any external effects. This was verified by simultaneously measuring the O2•− absorbance in a cuvette containing IL and in a cuvette containing a blank solution without IL.

Destruction of Thiophene Using Potassium Superoxide

About 0.01 g of the thiophene was added to a labeled vial, after which 5 g of dried IL were added. The mixture was stirred for 30 min. After reaching equilibrium, a sample was withdrawn and diluted in AcN and then analyzed using HPLC. The HPLC specifications and analysis conditions are shown in Table 2. Then, during vigorous stirring, KO2 was added gradually to the vial that contained the IL mixture. Samples were taken before and after the addition of KO2 by dissolving 0.1 g of the IL-sulfur mixture in 1 g of AcN. This procedure was repeated, and more KO2 was added until the thiophene peak was no longer detected or did not change.

Table 2 HPLC specifications and analysis conditions. 

Analytical Instruments
Shimadzu HPLC System Liquid chromatograph LC-10AD VP
System controller SCL-10A VP
UV/Vis Detector SPD-10A VP
Auto injector SIL-10AD VP
Column oven CTO-10AS VP
Degasser DGU-14AShimadzu LC solution software
Column Size: 4.6 x 150 mm, 5 µm Description: Eclipse Plus C18 Agilent
Guard column Agilent Zorbax reliance cartridge
Analytical Conditions
Mobile phase AcN:Deionized Water (75:25%),
HPLC grade
Flow rate 1 ml/min, low pressure gradient
Wavelength 254 nm
Column Temperature 30 ºC
Injection Volume 5 µl

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Electrochemical Generation of O2•−

Figure 1 shows the CVs for the reduction of O2 to O2•− at sweep rates of 9 and 100 mV/s in [MOEMPip] [TPTP], [MOPMPip][TFSI], [N112,1O2][TFSI], and [EDMPAmm][TFSI]. The background voltammograms after N2 sparging indicated that all ILs were electrochemically stable in the range of potential for O2•− generation (i.e., ± -1 V). The reduction peak indicated the formation of O2•−. The presence of the oxidation peak in the backward scan indicated that the O2•− formed was stable in these ILs within the time limits of the experiment. In the CV shown in Figure 1(c) for [N112,1O2][TFSI], the slight hump seen at - 0.7 V indicates the presence of impurities in the IL that could react with O2•−. These impurities were not electrochemically active after nitrogen sparging, but they were activated after O2 reduction to produce electrochemically-active compounds. Another possible reason was the adsorption of cations on the surface of the GC working electrode (Hayyan et al., 2012b). Previous studies have suggested that the potential shifts to more positive values as the solvating properties of the solvent increase. The asymmetry of the forward and reverse peaks reflected the difference in the diffusion of O2 vs. O2•− (Buzzeo et al., 2003). The main impurities in ILs are water and halide ions. Electrochemically speaking, water impurities have been shown to decrease the viscosity (Widegren et al., 2005; Zhang et al., 2006), increase the conductivity (Fitchett et al., 2005) and shrink the electrochemical window significantly (Schröder et al., 2000; Fitchett et al., 2005). Although water is by far the major impurity affecting the ILs, O2 from air is also easily dissolved in the ILs and often accompanies water; since this molecule is electroactive, its removal is required before any electrochemical measurement (Ohno, 2005). Mostly, water is present in every IL as an adventitious impurity. The presence of a trace amount of water can significantly change the physicochemical properties of ILs (and their analogous deep eutectic solvents), such as conductivity, viscosity, diffusivity and consequently mass transport properties of electrochemical processes (Schröder et al., 2000; Zhao et al., 2010). It has been recognized that water has a very different structure when dissolved in ILs relative to that in pure water since the water molecules in ILs are structurally associated with the ions of the ILs (Cammarata et al., 2001; Köddermann et al., 2006), and therefore are difficult to be eliminated. Nevertheless, it was found that O2 removal by placing 1-n-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate in a nitrogen-filled glove box or in a vacuum cell also simultaneously leads to water removal and alteration of voltammetric data (Zhao et al., 2010). Halide impurities are also of main concern when interpreting voltammetric responses. These impurities are generally introduced during the preparation of the ILs, which commonly involves a halide precursor (Seddon et al., 2000). Earle et al. (2006) stated that the color of ILs is due to chromophoric impurities in ILs during the synthesis process, and they have suggested a methodology to decolorize the ILs. However, this method can be applied only for small volumes of ILs required for fundamental spectroscopic studies but not in industrial processes.

Figure 1 CVs in (a) [MOEMPip][TPTP] (b) [MOPMPip][TFSI] c) [N112,1O2][TFSI] and d) [EDMPAmm] [TFSI] after sparging with oxygen and nitrogen (background) at the GC macro-electrode for different sweep rates at 25 ºC. 

Figure 1 shows that the ILs produce stable O2•− for the analysis time. However, the short timespan of the voltammetry (less than 5 min) is insufficient to confirm the long-term stability of O2•− in these ILs. For instance, AlNashef et al. (2002) reported a stable generation of O2•− in 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate [BMIm][HFP]. Conversely, it has been shown in diverse studies that O2•- was unstable in imidazolium-based ILs (Katayama et al., 2004; Islam et al., 2005; Barnes et al., 2008; Islam et al., 2009; Rogers et al., 2009). AlNashef et al. (2010) reported that imidazolium cations reacted with O2•− to produce the corresponding 2-imidazolones. Therefore, the long-term stability of the O2•− with these ILs was monitored using a UV-vis spectrophotometer.

Chemical Generation and Long-Term Stability of O2•−

Any consumption of the O2•− that is generated can be ascribed to the reaction of O2•− with the IL or with impurities that could not be removed by vacuum drying. Figure 2 shows the time course of the chemically-generated O2•− in DMSO that contained the corresponding IL for up to 24 h at 2-s intervals. The reaction time was divided into zones, as shown in Table 3 and Figure 2. The reaction kinetics for the zones and the overall reaction time were analyzed.

Figure 2 Absorbance of superoxide ion in DMSO with (a) [MOEMPip][TPTP] (b) [MOPMPip][TFSI] (c) [N112,1O2][TFSI] and (d) [EDMPAmm][TFSI] monitored every 2 s for up to 24 h. 

Table 3 Kinetic rate constants for O2 •− reaction with IL (k1= first order rate constant, k2= second order rate constant). 

[MOEMPip][TPTP]
Zone 1 Steady State Steady State Steady State Steady State Steady State
0-2 h 2-6 h 6-10 h 10-14 h 14-18 h 18-24 h Overall
k1(s–1) 5×10–5 5×10–5
R² = 0.958 - - - - R² = 0.958
(0-2 h)
k2(M–1s–1) 0.0365 0.0365
R2=0.971 - - - - - R2=0.971
(0-2 h)
[MOPMPip][TFSI]
Zone 1 Zone 2 Zone 3 Steady State Steady State Steady State
0-2 h 2-6 h 6-10 h 10-14 h 14-18 h 18-24 h Overall
k1(s–1) 5×10–5 2×10–5 6×10–6 2×10–5
R2= 0.997 R2= 0.979 R2= 0.978 - - - R2= 0.876
(0-10 h)
k2(M–1s–1) 0.0228 0.0126 0.0047 0.0109
R2= 0.999 R2= 0.988 R2= 0.979 - - - R2= 0.922
(1-10 h)
[N112,1O2][TFSI]
Zone 1 Zone 2 Zone 3 Zone 4 Zone 5 Steady State
0-2 h 2-6 h 6-10 h 10-14 h 14-18 h 18-24 h Overall
k1(s–1) 2×10–5 8×10–6 3×10–6 3×10–6 4×10–6 4×10–6
R2= 0.925 R2= 0.965 R2= 0.981 R2= 0.978 R2= 0.917 - R2=0.912
(0-18 h)
k2(M–1s–1) 0.0069 0.0034 0.0017 0.0013 0.002 0.002
R2= 0.933 R2= 0.969 R2= 0.981 R2= 0.978 R2= 0.914 R2=0.936
(0-18 h)
[EDMPAmm][TFSI]
Zone 1 Zone 2 Zone 3 Zone 4 Zone 5
0-2 h 2-6 h 6-10 h 10-14 h 14-18 h 18-24 h Overall
k1(s–1) 1×10–5 3×10–6 3×10–6 2×10–6 4×10–6 3×10–6
R2= 0.941 R2= 0.835 R2= 0.955 R2= 0.884 R2= 0.930 R2=0.959
(0-18 h)
k2(M–1s–1) 0.0055 0.0014 0.0014 0.001 0.0022 0.0014
R2= 0.943 R2= 0.836 R2= 0.955 R2= 0.884 R2= 0.928 R2=0.968
(0-18 h)

Assuming that the IL that was added to the DMSO was in large excess in comparison to O2•−, the IL concentration was negligible, and the reaction might follow the pseudo first-order kinetics, i.e., Eqs. (1) and (2):

r=kO21 (1)
O2·+AZ (2)

where k is the rate constant, [A] is the concentration of the cation, and Z is either the new product or the ion paring of the O2•−....cation.

The calculated rate constant was also based on the assumption of a second-order kinetic mechanism, assuming that either the involvement of the cations or the order of O2•− is two, Eqs. (3) and 4.

r=kO2·2 (3)
r=kA1O2·1 (4)

The total consumption of O2•− in the ILs was calculated by comparing the initial O2•− concentration with the concentration after 2 h, and the consumption rate of O2•− was determined by dividing the concentration of O2•− consumed by the time period of the measurement, Eqs. (5) and (6).

AverageRate=ΔO2·Δt (5)
AverageRate=O2finalO2initialΔt (6)

Table 3 lists the first- and second-order rate constants (k1 and k2) calculated for the respective ILs. As can be observed from the more gradual slope of these graphs and from the smaller values of k1 and k2 that were calculated, the O2•− was found to be more stable with the ammonium-based ILs than with the piperidinium-based ILs. This was in good agreement with the results of previous studies (Hayyan et al., 2012d; Hayyan et al., 2015a). This high stability of O2•− in the ILs consisting of ammonium cations was anticipated because O2•− is known to form the stable ionic salt of tetramethylammonium superoxide (Sawyer and Valentine, 1981). Furthermore, Laoire et al. (2010) attributed the stabilization of O2•− in tetrabutylammonium hexafluorophosphate [TBAmm][HFP] solutions in different solvents to Pearson's hard-soft acid-base (HSAB) theory through the formation of the TBA+---O2- complex. For the piperidinium-based ILs, the [TFSI]- showed greater stability than the [TPTP]-. This was expected since ILs that contain [TFSI]- are hydrophobic (Kato et al., 2008; O'Mahony et al., 2008; Hayyan et al., 2011; Hayyan et al., 2013b). The hydrophobicity of the IL increases as the length of the alkyl chain on the cation increases (Freire et al., 2007; Erdmenger et al., 2008; O'Mahony et al., 2008). This also could explain why O2•− in [MOPMPip] [TFSI] is more stable than in [MOEMPip][TPTP]. The rate constants determined were highest during the first 2 h. This may have been due to the consumption of impurities, which react with O2•− faster than the IL. Figure 2 shows that, in general, the rate constants of O2•− reactions with [MOEMPip] [TPTP], [MOPMPip][TFSI], [N112,1O2][TFSI], and [EDMPAmm][TFSI] follow those of second-order reactions rather than first-order reactions. This was in accordance with previous studies conducted by hin et al. (1982) and Hayyan et al. (2015a). Figure 2 shows that different zones provide different kinetics. This clearly shows that the O2•− reaction mechanism varied depending on the medium, substrate, and reaction time.

The IL was added in excess, so steady state was attributed to the complete O2•− consumption. O2•− lasted for 2 h in [MOEMPip][TPTP], 10 h in [MOPMPip][TFSI], 18 h in [N112,1O2][TFSI], and more than 21 h in [EDMPAmm][TFSI]. These findings were in accordance with our recently reported work in which we investigated the long-term stability of O2•− for only 2 h with 10-min time intervals of measurements (Hayyan et al., 2015a). In general, in both time intervals, the rate constants were the same order of magnitude. However, the 2-s intervals provided more useful results than the 10-min intervals. Table 4 illustrates the consumption percentage and consumption rate of O2•− in DMSO that contained ILs. The total percentage of O2•− that was consumed followed the order of [EDMPAmm] [TFSI] < [N112,1O2][TFSI] < [MOPMPip][TFSI] < [MOEMPip][TPTP]. This was in agreement with the order of the rate constants that were determined. This clearly showed that O2•− was more stable in ammonium-based ILs than in piperidinium-based ILs. However, the slight differences in the percentage of consumption can likely be attributed to the inability to remove all water or other impurities via the pre-preparation procedures.

Table 4 Total consumption percentage and consumption rate of O2 •− in DMSO containing ILs. 

IL Total consumption% of O2·−after 120 min Consumption rate of O2·−× 103 (mM/min)
[MOEMPip][TPTP] 28.3 3.71
[MOPMPip][TFSI] 26.0 5.12
[N112,1O2][TFSI] 10.0 2.30
[EDMPAmm][TFSI] 9.0 2.09

Destruction of Thiophene

The superoxide ion in [EDMPAmm][TFSI] was found to be most stable based on our kinetics studies; therefore, this IL was used as a medium to generate O2•− from the dissolution of KO2 for possible reaction with thiophene. Figure 3 shows the HPLC chromotogram of thiophene in the IL before and after the addition of KO2. Remarkably, it was found that O2•− destroyed close to 90% of the thiophene in [EDMPAmm][TFSI] at ambient conditions. This result was in good agreement with the findings of recent studies (Chan et al., 2008; Hayyan et al., 2015b; Hayyan et al., 2016b). Chan et al. (2008) used KO2 as an alternative oxidant for the oxidative-desulfurization process. It was shown that KO2 was comparable to or better than H2O2 for the ultrasound-assisted oxidative desulfurization or for the oxidative-desulfurization process. However, they used [BMIm][HFP] as the medium, which was reported later to be an inappropriate medium for producing O2•− in terms of the cation or the anion. This conclusion was based on the fact that the imidazolium cation reacts with O2•− to produce the corresponding 2-imidazolone (AlNashef et al., 2010), and [HFP] anion is undesired for such reactions because it produces HF when it is in contact with water.

Figure 3 HPLC chromatograms of TH in [EDMPAmm] [TFSI] (a) before KO2 addition (b) after KO2 addition. 

Nevertheless, it is important to conduct studies on the extraction of sulfur compounds from diesel fuel feed using the ILs in this work, since most published studies have used pyrrolidinium-based ILs (Zhao et al., 2007; Holbrey et al., 2008), imidazolium-based ILs (Bosmann et al., 2001; Zhang and Zhang, 2002; Lo et al., 2003; Huang et al., 2004; Wasserscheid and Jess, 2004; Planeta et al., 2006; Cassol et al., 2007; Li et al., 2009b), pyridinium-based ILs (Jian-long et al., 2007; Chu et al., 2008; Gao et al., 2008; Holbrey et al., 2008; Francisco et al., 2010), and quinolium-based ILs (Kumar and Banerjee, 2009).

Cheng and Yen (2008) stated that ILs can be used as phase-transfer catalysts for deep oxygenative desulfurization. Lu et al. (2006) found that the sulfur removal from dibenzothiophene-containing model oil can be in the range of 60-93%, depending on the reaction temperature, and this was superior to simple extraction with ILs, but they used H2O2 as the oxidant. Zhao et al. (2007) suggested that a coordination compound was generated between H2O2 and the cation of the IL and that it decomposed to produce hydroxyl radicals. The sulfur-containing compounds in the model oil or diesel fuel were extracted into the IL phase and oxidized to their corresponding sulfones by the hydroxyl radicals.

Thus, a combination of catalytic oxidation and extraction in the IL can remove sulfur compounds from the model oil effectively. This clearly shows the remarkable advantage of this process over desulfurization by mere solvent extraction with IL or catalytic oxidation without IL (Zhu et al., 2007; Li et al., 2009a).

CONCLUSIONS

The long-term stability of O2•− that was produced was investigated in piperidinium-based and ammonium-based ILs by the chemical generation of O2•− in DMSO in the presence of the corresponding IL. A UV-vis spectrophotometer was used in the absorbance range of 190−400 nm to determine the stability of O2•− with [MOEMPip][TPTP], [MOPMPip][TFSI], [N112,1O2][TFSI], and [EDMPAmm][TFSI]. The rate constants were calculated based on first- and second-order reactions. It was found that the values of k followed the order of [EDMPAmm][TFSI] < [N112,1O2][TFSI] < [MOPMPip][TFSI] < [MOEMPip][TPTP]. [EDMPAmm][TFSI] was found the best IL for O2•− stability. These ILs potentially can be used as media to investigate the possible applications of O2•−, such as the destruction of hazardous chemicals and the oxidative desulfurization of sulfur compounds. The O2•− kinetics varied depending on the medium, substrate, and reaction time. The reactions of O2•− and ILs require further study to isolate and analyze possible products.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The authors would like to express their thanks to the University of Malaya HIR-MOHE (D000003-16001) and UMRG (RP037B-15AET) for their support to this research.

REFERENCES

Afanas'ev, I. B., Prigoda, S. V., Mal'tseva, T. Y., Samokhvalov, G. I., Electron transfer reactions between the superoxide ion and quinones. Int. J. Chem. Kinet., 6, 643-661 (1974). [ Links ]

AlNashef, I. M., Hashim, M. A., Mjalli, F. S., Ali, M. Q., Hayyan, M., A novel method for the synthesis of 2-imidazolones. Tetrahedron Lett., 51, 1976-1978 (2010). [ Links ]

AlNashef, I. M., Hashim, M. A., Mjalli, F. S., Hayyan, M., Benign degradation of chlorinated benzene in ionic liquids. Int. J. Chem. Environ. Biol., 1, 201-206 (2013). [ Links ]

AlNashef, I. M., Leonard, M. L., Kittle, M. C., Matthews, M. A., Weidner, J. W., Electrochemical generation of superoxide in room-temperature ionic liquids. Electrochem. Solid-State Lett., 4, D16-D18 (2001). [ Links ]

AlNashef, I. M., Leonard, M. L., Matthews, M. A., Weidner, J. W., Superoxide electrochemistry in an ionic liquid. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 41, 4475-4478 (2002). [ Links ]

Barnes, A. S., Rogers, E. I., Streeter, I., Aldous, L., Hardacre, C., Wildgoose, G. G., Compton, R. G., Unusual voltammetry of the reduction of O2 in [C4dmim][N(Tf)2] reveals a strong interaction of O2•- with the [C4dmim]+ cation. J. Phys. Chem., C, 112, 13709-13715 (2008). [ Links ]

Bosmann, A., Datsevich, L., Jess, A., Lauter, A., Schmitz, C., Wasserscheid, P., Deep desulfurization of diesel fuel by extraction with ionic liquids. Chem. Commun., 2494-2495 (2001). [ Links ]

Buzzeo, M. C., Klymenko, O. V., Wadhawan, J. D., Hardacre, C., Seddon, K. R., Compton, R. G., Voltammetry of oxygen in the room-temperature ionic liquids 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis ((trifluoromethyl) sulfonyl) imide and hexyltriethylammonium bis ((trifluoromethyl) sulfonyl) imide: One-electron reduction to form superoxide. Steady-state and transient behavior in the same cyclic voltammogram resulting from widely different diffusion coefficients of oxygen and superoxide. J. Phys. Chem., A, 107, 8872-8878 (2003). [ Links ]

Cammarata, L., Kazarian, S. G., Salter, P. A., Welton, T., Molecular states of water in room temperature ionic liquids. PCCP, 3, 5192-5200 (2001). [ Links ]

Cassol, C., Umpierre, A., Ebeling, G., Ferrera, B., Chiaro, S., Dupont, J., On the extraction of aromatic compounds from hydrocarbons by imidazolium ionic liquids. Int. J. Mol. Sci., 8, 593-605 (2007). [ Links ]

Chan, N. Y., Lin, T. Y., Yen, T. F., Superoxides: Alternative oxidants for the oxidative desulfurization process. Energy Fuels, 22, 3326-3328 (2008). [ Links ]

Cheng, S.-S., Yen, T. F., Use of ionic liquids as phase-transfer catalysis for deep oxygenative desulfurization. Energy Fuels, 22, 1400-1401 (2008). [ Links ]

Chu, X., Hu, Y., Li, J., Liang, Q., Liu, Y., Zhang, X., Peng, X., Yue, W., Desulfurization of diesel fuel by extraction with [BF4]−-based ionic liquids. Chin. J. Chem. Eng., 16, 881-884 (2008). [ Links ]

Earle, M. J., Gordon, C. M., Plechkova, N. V., Seddon, K. R., Welton, T., Decolorization of ionic liquids for spectroscopy. Anal. Chem., 79, 758-764 (2006). [ Links ]

Erdmenger, T., Vitz, J., Wiesbrock, F., Schubert, U. S., Influence of different branched alkyl side chains on the properties of imidazolium-based ionic liquids. J. Mater. Chem., 18, 5267-5273 (2008). [ Links ]

Evans, R. G., Klymenko, O. V., Saddoughi, S. A., Hardacre, C., Compton, R. G., Electroreduction of oxygen in a series of room temperature ionic liquids composed of group 15-centered cations and anions. J. Phys. Chem., B, 108, 7878-7886 (2004). [ Links ]

Ferreira, A. R., Freire, M. G., Ribeiro, J. C., Lopes, F. M., Crespo, J. G., Coutinho, J. A. P., Ionic liquids for thiols desulfurization: Experimental liquid-liquid equilibrium and COSMO-RS description. Fuel, 128, 314-329 (2014). [ Links ]

Fitchett, B. D., Rollins, J. B., Conboy, J. C., 1-Alkyl-3-methylimidazolium Bis (perfluoroalkylsulfonyl) imide water-immiscible ionic liquids. J. Electrochem. Soc., 152, E251 (2005). [ Links ]

Francisco, M., Arce, A., Soto, A., Ionic liquids on desulfurization of fuel oils. Fluid Phase Equilib., 294, 39-48 (2010). [ Links ]

Freire, M. G., Santos, L. M., Fernandes, A. M., Coutinho, J. A., Marrucho, I. M., An overview of the mutual solubilities of water-imidazolium-based ionic liquids systems. Fluid Phase Equilib., 261, 449-454 (2007). [ Links ]

Frith, J. T., Russell, A. E., Garcia-Araez, N., Owen, J. R., An in-situ Raman study of the oxygen reduction reaction in ionic liquids. Electrochem. Commun., (2014). [ Links ]

Gao, H., Luo, M., Xing, J., Wu, Y., Li, Y., Li, W., Liu, Q., Liu, H., Desulfurization of fuel by extraction with pyridinium-based ionic liquids. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 47, 8384-8388 (2008). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Hashim, M. A., AlNashef, I. M., Superoxide ion: Generation and chemical implications. Chem. Rev., 116, 3029-3085 (2016a). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Alakrach, A. M., Hayyan, A., Hashim, M. A., Hizaddin, H. F., Superoxide ion as oxidative desulfurizing agent for aromatic sulfur compounds in ionic liquid media. ACS Sustainable Chem. Eng., DOI: 10.1021/acssuschemeng.6b02573 (2016b). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Hashim, M. A., AlNashef, I. M., Kinetics of superoxide ion in dimethyl sulfoxide containing ionic liquids. Ionics, 21, 719-728 (2015a). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Ibrahim, M. H., Hayyan, A., AlNashef, I. M., Alakrach, A. M., Hashim, M. A., Facile route for fuel desulfurization using generated superoxide ion in ionic liquids. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 54, 12263-12269 (2015b). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Mjalli, F. S., AlNashef, I. M., Hashim, M. A., Chemical and electrochemical generation of superoxide ion in 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide. Int. J. Electrochem. Sci., 7, 8116 - 8127 (2012a). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Mjalli, F. S., AlNashef, I. M., Hashim, M. A., Generation and stability of superoxide ion in tris(pentafluoroethyl)trifluorophosphate anion-based ionic liquids. J. Fluorine Chem., 142, 83-89 (2012b). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Mjalli, F. S., AlNashef, I. M., Hashim, M. A., Stability and kinetics of generated superoxide ion in trifluoromethanesulfonate anion-based ionic liquids. Int. J. Electrochem. Sci., 7, 9658 - 9667 (2012c). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Mjalli, F. S., Hashim, M. A., AlNashef, I. M., Generation of superoxide ion in pyridinium, morpholinium, ammonium, and sulfonium-based ionic liquids and the application in the destruction of toxic chlorinated phenols. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 51, 10546-10556 (2012d). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Mjalli, F. S., Hashim, M. A., AlNashef, I. M., An investigation of the reaction between 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate and superoxide ion. J. Mol. Liq., 181, 44-50 (2013a). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Mjalli, F. S., Hashim, M. A., AlNashef, I. M., Al-Zahrani, S. M., Chooi, K. L., Generation of superoxide ion in 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium trifluoroacetate and its application in the destruction of chloroethanes. J. Mol. Liq., 167, 28-33 (2012e). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Mjalli, F. S., Hashim, M. A., AlNashef, I. M., Al-Zahrani, S. M., Chooi, K. L., Long term stability of superoxide ion in piperidinium, pyrrolidinium and phosphonium cations-based ionic liquids and its utilization in the destruction of chlorobenzenes. J. Electroanal. Chem., 664, 26-32 (2012f). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Mjalli, F. S., Hashim, M. A., AlNashef, I. M., Mei, T. X., Investigating the electrochemical windows of ionic liquids. J. Ind. Eng. Chem., 19, 106-112 (2013b). [ Links ]

Hayyan, M., Mjalli, F. S., Hashim, M. A., AlNashef, I. M., Tan, X. M., Electrochemical reduction of dioxygen in Bis (trifluoromethylsulfonyl) imide based ionic liquids. J. Electroanal. Chem., 657, 150-157 (2011). [ Links ]

Holbrey, J. D., Lopez-Martin, I., Rothenberg, G., Seddon, K. R., Silvero, G., Zheng, X., Desulfurisation of oils using ionic liquids: Selection of cationic and anionic components to enhance extraction efficiency. Green Chem., 10, 87-92 (2008). [ Links ]

Huang, C., Chen, B., Zhang, J., Liu, Z., Li, Y., Desulfurization of gasoline by extraction with new ionic liquids. Energy Fuels, 18, 1862-1864 (2004). [ Links ]

Ibrahim, M. H., Hayyan, M., Hashim, M. A., Hayyan, A., The role of ionic liquids in desulfurization of fuels: A review. Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev., DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/ j.rser.2016.11.194 (2016). [ Links ]

Islam, M. M., Ferdousi, B. N., Okajima, T., Ohsaka, T., A catalytic activity of a mercury electrode towards dioxygen reduction in room-temperature ionic liquids. Electrochem. Commun., 7, 789-795 (2005). [ Links ]

Islam, M. M., Imase, T., Okajima, T., Takahashi, M., Niikura, Y., Kawashima, N., Nakamura, Y., Ohsaka, T., Stability of superoxide ion in imidazolium cation-based room-temperature ionic liquids. J. Phys. Chem., A, 113, 912-916 (2009). [ Links ]

Jian-long, W., Zhao, D.-s., Zhou, E.-p., Dong, Z., Desulfurization of gasoline by extraction with N-alkyl-pyridinium-based ionic liquids. J. Fuel Chem. Technol., 35, 293-296 (2007). [ Links ]

Jiang, W., Zhu, W., Li, H., Chao, Y., Xun, S., Chang, Y., Liu, H., Zhao, Z., Mechanism and optimization for oxidative desulfurization of fuels catalyzed by Fenton-like catalysts in hydrophobic ionic liquid. J. Mol. Catal. A, Chem., 382, 8-14 (2014). [ Links ]

Katayama, Y., Onodera, H., Yamagata, M., Miura, T., Electrochemical reduction of oxygen in some hydrophobic room-temperature molten salt systems. J. Electrochem. Soc., 151, A59-A63 (2004). [ Links ]

Kato, H., Nishikawa, K., Koga, Y., Relative hydrophobicity and hydrophilicity of some "ionic liquid" anions determined by the 1-propanol probing methodology: A differential thermodynamic approach. J. Phys. Chem., B, 112, 2655-2660 (2008). [ Links ]

Köddermann, T., Wertz, C., Heintz, A., Ludwig, R., The association of water in ionic liquids: A reliable measure of polarity. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 45, 3697-3702 (2006). [ Links ]

Kumar, A. A. P., Banerjee, T., Thiophene separation with ionic liquids for desulphurization: A quantum chemical approach. Fluid Phase Equilib., 278, 1-8 (2009). [ Links ]

Laoire, C. O., Mukerjee, S., Abraham, K., Plichta, E. J., Hendrickson, M. A., Influence of nonaqueous solvents on the electrochemistry of oxygen in the rechargeable lithium−air battery. J. Phys. Chem., C, 114, 9178-9186 (2010). [ Links ]

Li, F.-t., Liu, R.-h., Jin-hua, W., Zhao, D.-s., Sun, Z.-m., Liu, Y., Desulfurization of dibenzothiophene by chemical oxidation and solvent extraction with Me3NCH2C6H5Cl[middle dot]2ZnCl2 ionic liquid. Green Chem., 11, 883-888 (2009a). [ Links ]

Li, H., He, L., Lu, J., Zhu, W., Jiang, X., Wang, Y., Yan, Y., Deep oxidative desulfurization of fuels catalyzed by phosphotungstic acid in ionic liquids at room temperature. Energy Fuels, 23, 1354-1357 (2009b). [ Links ]

Lo, W.-H., Yang, H.-Y., Wei, G.-T., One-pot desulfurization of light oils by chemical oxidation and solvent extraction with room temperature ionic liquids. Green Chem., 5, 639-642 (2003). [ Links ]

Lu, L., Cheng, S., Gao, J., Gao, G., He, M.-y., Deep oxidative desulfurization of fuels catalyzed by ionic liquid in the presence of H2O2. Energy Fuels, 21, 383-384 (2006). [ Links ]

Lu, X., Yue, L., Hu, M., Cao, Q., Xu, L., Guo, Y., Hu, S., Fang, W., Piperazinium-based ionic liquids with lactate anion for extractive desulfurization of fuels. Energy Fuels (2014). [ Links ]

Lü, H., Deng, C., Ren, W., Yang, X., Oxidative desulfurization of model diesel using [(C4H9)4N]6Mo7O24 as a catalyst in ionic liquids. Fuel Process. Technol., 119, 87-91 (2014). [ Links ]

O'Mahony, A. M., Silvester, D. S., Aldous, L., Hardacre, C., Compton, R. G., Effect of water on the electrochemical window and potential limits of room-temperature ionic liquids. J. Chem. Eng. Data, 53, 2884-2891 (2008). [ Links ]

Ohno, H., Electrochemical Aspects of Ionic Liquids. Wiley, Hoboken (NJ) (2005). [ Links ]

Planeta, J., Karasek, P., Roth, M., Distribution of sulfur-containing aromatics between [hmim][Tf2N] and supercritical CO2: A case study for deep desulfurization of oil refinery streams by extraction with ionic liquids. Green Chem., 8, 70-77 (2006). [ Links ]

Pozo-Gonzalo, C., Torriero, A. A. J., Forsyth, M., MacFarlane, D. R., Howlett, P. C., Redox chemistry of the superoxide ion in a phosphonium-based ionic liquid in the presence of water. J. Phys. Chem. Lett., 4, 1834-1837 (2013). [ Links ]

Rogers, E. I., Huang, X. J., Dickinson, E. J. F., Hardacre, C., Compton, R. G., Investigating the mechanism and electrode kinetics of the oxygen| superoxide (O2|O2•-) couple in various room-temperature ionic liquids at gold and platinum electrodes in the temperature range 298-318 K. J. Phys. Chem. C., 113, 17811-17823 (2009). [ Links ]

Sawyer, D. T., Oxygen Chemistry. Oxford University Press, USA (1991). [ Links ]

Sawyer, D. T., Sobkowiak, A., Roberts, J. L., Electrochemistry for Chemists. Wiley (1995). [ Links ]

Sawyer, D. T., Valentine, J. S., How super is superoxide? Acc. Chem. Res., 14, 393-400 (1981). [ Links ]

Schröder, U., Wadhawan, J. D., Compton, R. G., Marken, F., Suarez, P. A. Z., Consorti, C. S., Souza, R. F., Dupont, J., Water-induced accelerated ion diffusion: voltammetric studies in 1-methyl-3-[2, 6-(S)-dimethylocten-2-yl] imidazolium tetrafluoroborate, 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate and hexafluorophosphate ionic liquids. New J. Chem., 24, 1009-1015 (2000). [ Links ]

Schwenke, K. U., Herranz, J., Gasteiger, H. A., Piana, M., Reactivity of the ionic liquid Pyr14TFSI with superoxide radicals generated from KO2 or by contact of O2 with Li7Ti5O12. J. Electrochem. Soc., 162, A905-A914 (2015). [ Links ]

Schwenke, K. U., Meini, S., Wu, X., Gasteiger, H. A., Piana, M., Stability of superoxide radicals in glyme solvents for non-aqueous Li-O2 battery electrolytes. PCCP, 15, 11830-11839 (2013). [ Links ]

Seddon, K. R., Stark, A., Torres, M. J., Influence of chloride, water, and organic solvents on the physical properties of ionic liquids. Pure Appl. Chem., 72, 2275-2287 (2000). [ Links ]

Switzer, E. E., Zeller, R., Chen, Q., Sieradzki, K., Buttry, D. A., Friesen, C., Oxygen reduction reaction in ionic liquids: The addition of protic species. J. Phys. Chem., C, 117, 8683-8690 (2013). [ Links ]

Tanner, E. E. L., Xiong, L., Barnes, E. O., Compton, R. G., One electron oxygen reduction in room temperature ionic liquids: A comparative study of Butler-Volmer and Symmetric Marcus-Hush theories using microdisc electrodes. J. Electroanal. Chem., 727, 59-68 (2014). [ Links ]

Wasserscheid, P., Jess, A., Deep desulfurization of oil refinery streams by extraction with ionic liquids. Green Chem., 6, 316-322 (2004). [ Links ]

Widegren, J. A., Laesecke, A., Magee, J. W., The effect of dissolved water on the viscosities of hydrophobic room-temperature ionic liquids. Chem. Commun., 1610-1612 (2005). [ Links ]

Xiong, L., Barnes, E. O., Compton, R. G., Amperometric detection of oxygen under humid conditions: The use of a chemically reactive room temperature ionic liquid to 'trap' superoxide ions and ensure a simple one electron reduction. Sens. Actuators, B, 200, 157-166 (2014). [ Links ]

Yahaya, G. O., Hamad, F., Bahamdan, A., Tammana, V. V. R., Hamad, E. Z., Supported ionic liquid membrane and liquid-liquid extraction using membrane for removal of sulfur compounds from diesel/crude oil. Fuel Process. Technol., 113, 123-129 (2013). [ Links ]

Yuan, X. -Z., Alzate, V., Xie, Z., Ivey, D. G., Qu, W., Oxygen reduction reaction in 1-butyl-1-methyl-pyrrolidinium bis (trifluoromethanesulfonyl) imide: Addition of water as a proton species. J. Electrochem. Soc., 161, A451-A457 (2014). [ Links ]

Zhang, S., Sun, N., He, X., Lu, X., Zhang, X., Physical properties of ionic liquids: Database and evaluation. J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, 35, 1475 (2006). [ Links ]

Zhang, S., Zhang, Z. C., Novel properties of ionic liquids in selective sulfur removal from fuels at room temperature. Green Chem., 4, 376-379 (2002). [ Links ]

Zhao, C., Bond, A. M., Compton, R. G., O'Mahony, A. M., Rogers, E. I., Modification and implications of changes in electrochemical responses encountered when undertaking deoxygenation in ionic liquids. Anal. Chem., 82, 3856-3861 (2010). [ Links ]

Zhao, D., Wang, J., Zhou, E., Oxidative desulfurization of diesel fuel using a Bronsted acid room temperature ionic liquid in the presence of H2O2. Green Chem., 9, 1219-1222 (2007). [ Links ]

Zhu, W., Li, H., Jiang, X., Yan, Y., Lu, J., Xia, J., Oxidative desulfurization of fuels catalyzed by peroxotungsten and peroxomolybdenum complexes in ionic liquids. Energy Fuels, 21, 2514-2516 (2007). [ Links ]

Received: April 15, 2015; Revised: September 20, 2015; Accepted: October 31, 2015

*E-mail: maan_hayyan@yahoo.com; maan.hayyan@gmail.com

*To whom correspondence should be addressed

Creative Commons License This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.