Karyotype similarity between two sympatric Schizodon fish species (Anostomidae, Characiformes) from the Paraguay River basin

Karyotype similarity between two sympatric Schizodon fish species (Anostomidae, Characiformes) from the Paraguay River basin

Cesar Martins and Pedro Manoel Galetti Jr.

Departamento de Genética e Evolução, Universidade Federal de São Carlos, Via Washington Luiz, km 235, 13565-905 São Carlos, SP, Brasil. Fax: [phone]. E-mail: [e-mail] Send correspondence to P.M.G.Jr.

ABSTRACT

Fish of the neotropical family Anostomidae generally show low karyotype variability. Nevertheless, karyotype variants have been identified within some genera, providing information about their evolutionary history. Species of the genus Schizodon show a high degree of morphological and ecological similarity compared to other anostomids. In the present study, karyotype characteristics of Schizodon borelli (40 individuals) and S. isognathum (one individual), two sympatric species found in the Paraguay River basin, were studied. C-banding, GC-specific fluorochrome Mitramycin (MM) and Ag staining as well as in situ hybridization (FISH) with rDNA probes were used. The karyotypes of these species were found to be very similar. Only two NORs were detected in a common chromosome pair of both species under Ag, MM and FISH treatments. Similar heterochromatin distribution patterns were also observed. A parallelism between the small karyotype variation and low morphological and ecological divergence observed for this genus is discussed. Their karyotype homogeneity might be related to populational features or, alternatively, might indicate that the maintenance of a symmetric and conserved karyotype structure represents optimal genomic organization among these fish.

INTRODUCTION

The neotropical freshwater fish family Anostomidae has been considered a monophyletic unit among Characiformes (Vari, 1983), although there is some disagreement regarding interrelationships between genera (Géry, 1977; Winterbottom, 1980). Cytogenetic analyses have set the basis for the phylogenetic studies within and between genera of this family (Galetti Jr. et al., 1984, 1991b, 1995a).

In contrast to other fish groups, the Anostomidae generally have showed a very conserved karyotypic structure. However, variations in the location of NORs (Galetti Jr. et al., 1984, 1991b), heterochromatin patterns (Galetti Jr. et al., 1991a,b) and sex chromosomes (Galetti Jr. et al., 1981b, 1995a; Galetti Jr. and Foresti, 1986, 1987; Koehler et al., 1997) have been observed in Leporinus species, the most extensively studied genus of Anostomidae. Chromosome studies are important to address taxonomy and evolutionary biology in these fishes. Leporinus obtusidens and L. elongatus, for example, are sympatric in the Alto Paraná River system, with negligible morphological differences between species. Although there is high karyotype macrostructure similarity, NOR studies have revealed large differences between them. This fact proves the usefulness of NORs as a decisive cytotaxonomic character (Galetti Jr. et al., 1984, 1991b).

Among the anostomid genera, Schizodon represents a taxonomically well-defined clade, composed of 14 species residing in all large neotropical hydrographic basins. Cytogenetic data of this genus, however, are restricted to only two species, Schizodon nasutus, from the Mogi-Guaçu River/Alto Paraná basin (Galetti Jr. et al., 1981a, 1984, 1991a), and Schizodon fasciatus, from the Solimões and Madeira Rivers in the Amazon basin (Galetti Jr. et al., 1991a).

In the present study, the chromosomes of S. borelli and S. isognathum, sympatric species in the Paraguay River basin, were analyzed using Giemsa, C- banding, silver nitrate and fluorochrome staining and rDNA in situ hybridization.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Specimens

Forty Schizodon borelli specimens (15 females, 15 males and 10 of unidentified sex) taken from the following four locations along the Paraguay River basin were analyzed: Cuiabá River (Santo Antônio do Laverger/MT), Bento Gomes River (Poconé/MT), Miranda and Vermelho Rivers (Passo do Lontra, Corumbá/MS). Only one young S. isognathum specimen of unidentified sex was collected in syntopy with S. borelli in the Vermelho River.

Chromosome preparation and banding

Metaphase chromosomes obtained from cephalic kidney cell suspensions were submitted to silver (Ag) staining (Howell and Black, 1980), C-banding using barium hydroxide (Sumner, 1972) and fluorescent staining with the GC-specific fluorochrome Mitramycin (MM), counterstained by Distamycin A (Schmid, 1980).

Non-isotopic in situ hybridization (FISH)

Ribosomal DNA probes (HM123 and HM456) which contain 18S and 28S genes of Xenopus laevis were labeled with biotin by nick translation according to manufacturer's instructions (Nick Translation kit, Boehringer-Mannheim, Germany). The metaphase chromosome slides were incubated with RNase (40 µg/ml) for 1.5 h in a moist chamber at 37^oC. After denaturation of chromosomal DNA in 70% formamide/2 x SSC for 5 min at 70^oC, 40 µl of hybridization mixture (1 µg of denatured probe, 50% formamide, 10 mg/ml dextran sulfate, 2 x SSC) was dropped on the slides. Hybridization was performed overnight at 37^oC in a moist chamber. The probes were detected by avidin-FITC conjugate (Sigma). The signal was then enhanced by biotinylated anti-avidin and avidin-FITC. The chromosomes were counterstained with 70 µl propidium iodide (100 µg/ml), and the slides were mounted with 25 µl Vectashield antifade (Vector).

RESULTS

The karyotypes of Schizodon borelli and Schizodon isognathum had 54 meta-submetacentric chromosomes (Figure 1). Ag-NOR⁺ sites were found in the terminal region of the long arm of one medium-sized metacentric chromosome pair (Figure 2), corresponding to the 20th pair of the complement of both species. C⁺ band heterochromatin blocks were strongly stained in the centromeres and less intensely stained at the telomeres in the majority of chromosomes in the complement of both species (Figure 3). The Ag-NOR⁺ regions were found to be heterochromatic (C⁺ band). Fluorescent MM⁺ bands were detected in the Ag-NOR sites of chromosome 20 in both species (Figure 4) and interstitially in the short arm of chromosome pair 23. FISH revealed signals corresponding to rDNA units located exclusively in the Ag-NOR⁺ regions (Figure 5). In S. borelli, the homologous NORs, demonstrated by Ag and MM staining and FISH, were found to be heteromorphic. No variation in karyotype was observed for the different S. borelli populations analyzed.

Figure 1
- Giemsa-stained karyotypes of Schizodon borelli (A) and S. isognathum (B) showing 54 meta-submetacentric chromosomes.

Figure 2
- Karyotypes of Schizodon borelli (A) and S. isognathum (B) arranged from Ag-stained chromosomes.

Figure 3
- C-banded karyotypes of Schizodon borelli (A) and S. isognathum (B).

Figure 4
- MM-stained karyotypes of Schizodon borelli (A) and S. isognathum (B).

Figure 5
- Metaphases of Schizodon borelli (A and B) and S. isognathum (C and D) after in situ hybridization with 18S + 28S rDNA genes, showing NOR sites (arrows).

DISCUSSION

Arrangement of nucleolar ribosomal DNA in Schizodon chromosomes

Chromosomal NOR phenotypes have been useful to systematic relationships among fish species (Gold, 1984; Venere and Galetti Jr., 1989; Amemiya and Gold, 1990; Gold and Zoch, 1990, among others). In neotropical fishes, NORs appear as a heterogeneous trait, occurring in a single chromosome pair in some groups or in several pairs in others (Bertollo, 1995). In Leporinus, the most extensively studied Anostomidae group, NOR phenotypes have demonstrated to be important as systematic markers for cryptic species (Galetti Jr. et al., 1984, 1991b). In Schizodon, NORs are located in a homologous chromosome pair of different species and might suggest a close relationship among them.

As often reported for fishes in general (Amemiya and Gold, 1986; Phillips et al., 1989; Sola et al., 1997, among others), S. borelli and S. isognathum had conspicuous MM⁺ bands, corresponding to the Ag-NOR⁺ regions. MM and other GC-specific fluorochromes have been frequently used in fish due to the role they play in NOR identification (Galetti Jr. and Rasch, 1993a,b; Mestriner et al., 1995; Margarido and Galetti Jr., 1996; Sola et al., 1997, among others) supplying interesting results that have helped to identify polymorphisms and to understand the rDNA structural organization in these organisms (Galetti Jr. et al., 1995b; Castro et al., 1996). However, there are still doubts if fluorochromes stain ribosome cistrons (Schmid et al., 1987) or interspersed heterochromatin (nontranscriber spacer DNA) in rDNA (Pendás et al., 1993). Additional fluorescent MM⁺ bands were detected in at least one other chromosome pair (No. 23) of both species. GC-rich bands not corresponding to Ag-NOR⁺ segments have already been identified in other fishes (Phillips et al., 1988; Mestriner, 1993; Artoni, 1996) and may be associated with inactive ribosomal DNA segments (Amemiya and Gold, 1986). It appears, however, that this is not the case in Schizodon. FISH, using rDNA probes (18 and 28S), gave positive signals only in the terminal region of the long arm of the chromosome pair comparable to the Ag-NOR bearing pair, and suggests the lack of rDNA in the additional MM⁺ bands observed in chromosome 23. NOR heteromorphism between homologous chromosomes, more clearly visible in S. borelli under Ag and MM staining and FISH, indicates that this situation is related to variation in the number of copies of 18S + 28S rDNA genes (Goodpasture and Bloom, 1975) instead of genetic regulation of these cistrons (Miller et al., 1976).

Chromosome homogeneity in the genus Schizodon

Previous studies have provided information (based on conventional Giemsa and Ag-NOR staining and C-banding) on karyotypes of S. nasutus (Alto Paraná) and S. fasciatus (Amazônia) (Galetti Jr. et al., 1981a, 1984, 1991a). Although these species belong to different hydrographic basins, differences in their karyotype patterns were not found. In fact, cytogenetic data available for Schizodon (including the present study) indicate that karyotype homogeneity, already reported for the family Anostomidae in general (Galetti Jr. et al., 1981a, among others), is well evidenced in this genus.

Anostomidae, as well as other non-Anostomidae groups (Chilodontidae, Prochilodontidae, Curimatidae and Parodontidae), have a very similar karyotype pattern, consisting of 54 biarmed chromosomes. However, even fish groups with high chromosome homogeneity may experience different chromosome evolutionary trends. Among anostomids, the large genus Leporinus shows wide morphological and ecological diversity of forms and considerable chromosome variability associated with the sex chromosomes (Galetti Jr. et al., 1981b; Galetti Jr. and Foresti, 1986, 1987), NOR sites (Galetti Jr. et al., 1984, 1991b, 1995b) and patterns of constitutive heterochromatin (Galetti Jr. et al., 1991a,b). On the other hand, Schizodon shows higher ecological and morphological similarity among the species. S. borelli and S. isognathum, for instance, occur sympatrically and were collected in syntopy in the Vermelho River. They share similar ecological and behavioral characteristics. Therefore, a parallelism between ecological and morphological diversity and the low rate of chromosomal evolution observed in Schizodon may exist.

Models of chromosome evolution invoke the primacy of chromosome change in speciation (King, 1993; Sites and Reed, 1994; Qumsiyeh, 1994). White´s principle of karyotype orthoselection might explain the similarity of chromosome in shape and size observed in the karyotype of Schizodon (White, 1969). In this case, particular types of rearrangements occurred several times during karyotype differentiation, leading to a very uniform karyotype. Moreover, chromosomal mechanisms of speciation seem to be more prevalent in organisms of restricted mobility (White, 1978), which is not the case for Schizodon. Species of this genus are fast swimmers and can spread throughout an entire hydrographic system, and their karyotype homogeneity might be due to these populational features. Karyotypic stability might be reached after a canalization to an optimal karyotypic configuration and further rearrangements are mal-adaptive (Bickham and Baker, 1979). Alternatively, symmetric and homogeneous karyotypes may find a homeostatic balance between selective forces of genome diversity and pressure for cellular constancy during the mitotic process, preventing changes in karyotypes macrostructure, though the minor and cryptic chromosome rearrangements occur (Venere and Galetti Jr., 1989). Thus, once a symmetric and homogeneous karyotype pattern is reached, as observed in Schizodon, major changes in the chromosome complement appear to be selected against.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The authors thank Orílio Leoncini for providing HM123 and HM456 rDNA probes, and Maria C. Navarrete and Otávio Fröelick for specimen collecting facilities. This work was supported by Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq). Publication supported by FAPESP.

RESUMO

Peixes neotropicais da família Anostomidae apresentam, de uma forma geral, pouca variação na sua estrutura cariotípica. Mesmo assim, em alguns grupos, foi possível identificar variantes cariotípicas que forneceram informações tanto sobre sua sistemática quanto sobre sua história evolutiva. As espécies do gênero Schizodon apresentam um alto grau de similaridades ecológicas e morfológicas comparado com outros anostomídeos. No presente trabalho, foram estudadas características cariotípicas de S. borelli (40 indivíduos analisados) e S. isognathum (somente um indivíduo analisado), duas espécies simpátricas do rio Paraguai, utilizando bandamento C, coloração com nitrato de prata, aplicação do fluorocromo GC-específico mitramicina e hibridação in situ (FISH) com sonda de DNAr. Os cariótipos destas espécies mostraram-se muito similares. Somente duas NORs foram detectadas sob os tratamentos com Ag, MM e FISH em um par cromossômico comum a ambas as espécies e um padrão similar de distribuição da heterocromatina também foi observado. Estes dados sugerem a existência de um paralelismo entre a pouca variação cromossômica e a baixa divergência ecológica e morfológica observada neste gênero. A homogeneidade cariotípica observada pode estar relacionada a fatores populacionais ou pode indicar que a manutenção de uma estrutura cariotípica conservada e simétrica representa a melhor forma para a organização do genoma destes peixes.

(Received August 14, 1997)

• Amemiya, C.T. and Gold, J.R. (1986). Chromomycin A₃ stains nucleolar organizer regions of fish chromosomes. Copeia 1986(1): 226-231.
• Amemiya, C.T. and Gold, J.R. (1990). Chromosomal NOR phenotypes of seven species of North American Cyprinidae, with comments on cytosystematic relationships of the Notropis volucellus species-group, Opsopoeodus emiliae, and the genus Pteronotropis Copeia 1990(1): 68-78.
• Artoni, R.F. (1996). Estudos citogenéticos na família Loricariidae, com ęnfase no gęnero Hypostomus Lacépčde (1803) (Pisces, Siluriformes). Master's thesis, Universidade Federal de Săo Carlos, Săo Carlos.
• Bertollo, L.A.C. (1995). The nucleolar organizer regions of Erythrinidae fish. An uncommon situation in the genus Hoplias Cytologia 61: 75-81.
• Bickham, J.W. and Baker, R.J. (1979). Canalization model of chromosome evolution. Bull. Carnegie Mus. Nat. Hist. 13: 70-84.
• Castro, J., Vińas, A., Sánchez, L. and Martínez, P. (1996). Characterization of an atypical NOR site polymorphism in brown trout (Salmo trutta) with Ag- and CMA₃-staining, and fluorescent in situ hybridization. Cytogen. Cell Genet. 75: 234-239.
• Galetti Jr., P.M. and Foresti, F. (1986). Evolution of the ZZ/ZW system in Leporinus (Pisces, Anostomidae). Cytogenet. Cell Genet. 43: 43-46.
• Galetti Jr., P.M. and Foresti, F. (1987). Two new cases of ZZ/ZW heterogamety in Leporinus (Anostomidae, Characiformes) and their relationships in the phylogeny of the group. Bras. J. Genet. 10: 135-140.
• Galetti Jr., P.M. and Rasch, E.M. (1993a). Chromosome studies in Poecilia latipunctata with NORs polymorphism as shown by silver nitrate and chromomycin A₃ (Teleostei: Poecilidae). Ichthyol. Explor. Freshwaters, 4: 269-277.
• Galetti Jr., P.M. and Rasch, E.M. (1993b). NOR variability in diploid and triploid forms of the Amazon molly fish Poecilia formosa as shown by silver nitrate and chromomycin A₃ staining. Braz. J. Genet. 16: 927-938.
• Galetti Jr., P.M., Foresti, F., Bertollo, L.A.C. and Moreira-Filho, O. (1981a). Karyotypic similarity in three genera (Leporinus, Leporellus and Schizodon) of the family Anostomidae (Pisces, Teleostei). Braz. J. Genet. 4: 11-15.
• Galetti Jr., P.M., Foresti, F., Bertollo, L.A.C. and Moreira-Filho, O. (1981b). Heteromorphic sex chromosomes in three species of the genus Leporinus (Pisces, Anostomidae). Cytogenet. Cell Genet. 29: 138-142.
• Galetti Jr., P.M., Foresti, F., Bertollo, L.A.C. and Moreira-Filho, O. (1984). Characterization of eight species of Anostomidae (Cypriniformes) fish on the basis of the nucleolar organizing region. Caryologia, 37: 401-406.
• Galetti Jr., P.M., Mestriner, C.A. and Foresti, F. (1991a). Heterochromatin and karyotype reorganization in fish of the family Anostomidae (Characiformes). Cytogenet. Cell Genet. 56: 116-121.
• Galetti Jr., P.M., Cesar, A.C.G. and Venere, P.C. (1991b). Heterochromatin and NORs variability in Leporinus fish (Anostomidae, Characiformes). Caryologia 44: 287-292.
• Galetti Jr., P.M., Lima, N.R.W. and Venere, P.C. (1995a). A monophyletic ZW chromosome system in Leporinus (Anostomidae, Characiformes). Cytologia 60: 375-382.
• Galetti Jr., P.M., Mestriner, C.A., Monaco, P.J. and Rasch, E.M. (1995b). Post-zygotic modifications and intra- and inter-individual nucleolar organizing region variations in fish: report of a case involving Leporinus friderici Chromosome Res. 3: 285-290.
• Géry, J. (1977). Characoids of the World T.F.H. Publications, Neptune City.
• Gold, J.R. (1984). Silver-staining and heteromorphism of chromosomal nucleolus organizer regions in North American cyprinid fishes. Copeia 1984(1): 133-139.
• Gold, J.R. and Zoch, P.K. (1990). Intraspecific variation in chromosomal nucleolus organizer regions in Notropis chrysocephalus (Pisces: Cyprinidae). Southwest. Nat. 35: 211-215.
• Goodpasture, C. and Bloom, S.E. (1975). Visualization of nucleolar organizer regions in mammalian chromosomes using silver staining. Chromosoma 53: 37-50.
• Howell, W.M. and Black, D.A. (1980). Controlled silver-staining of nucleolus organizer regions with a protective colloidal developer: a 1-step method. Experientia 36: 1014-1015.
• King, M. (1993). Species Evolution: The Role of Chromosome Change Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
• Koehler, M.R., Dehm, D., Guttenbach, M., Nanda, I., Haaf, T., Molina, W.F., Galetti Jr., P.M. and Schmid, M. (1997). Cytogenetics of the genus Leporinus (Pisces, Anostomidae). 1. Karyotype analysis, heterochromatin distribution and sex chromosomes. Chromosome Res. 5: 12-22.
• Margarido, V.P. and Galetti Jr., P.M. (1996). Chromosome studies in fish of the genus Brycon (Characiformes, Bryconinae). Cytobios 85: 219-228.
• Mestriner, c.a. (1993). Análise das regiőes organizadoras de nucléolos e investigaçăo do sistema XX/XY descrito para Leporinus lacustris (Pisces, Anostomidae). Master's thesis, Universidade Federal de Săo Carlos, Săo Carlos.
• Mestriner, C.A., Bertollo, L.A.C. and Galetti Jr., P.M. (1995). Chromosome banding and synaptonemal complexes in Leporinus lacustris (Pisces, Anostomidae): Analysis of a sex system. Chromosome Res. 3: 440-443.
• Miller, E.A., Dev, V.G., Tantravahi, R. and Miller, O.J. (1976). Suppression of human nucleolus organizer activity in mouse human somatic hybrid cells. Exp. Cell Res. 101: 235-243.
• Pendás, A.M., Morán, P. and Garcia-Vásquez, S. (1993). Ribossomal RNA genes are interspersed throughout a heterochromatic chromosome arm in Atlantic salmon. Cytogenet. Cell Genet. 63: 128-130.
• Phillips, R.B., Pleyte, K.A. and Hartley, S.E. (1988). Stock-specific differences in the number and chromosome positions of nucleolar organizer regions in arctic char (Salvelinus alpinus). Cytogenet. Cell Genet. 48: 9-12.
• Phillips, R.B., Pleyte, K.A. and Ihssen, P.E. (1989). Patterns of chromosomal nucleolar organizer region (NOR) variation in fishes of the genus Salvelinus Copeia 1989(1): 47-53.
• Qumsiyeh, M.B. (1994). Evolution of number and morphology of mammalian chromosomes. J. Hered. 85: 455-465.
• Schmid, M. (1980). Chromosome banding in Amphibia. IV. Differentiation of GC- and AT-rich chromosome regions in Anura. Chromosoma 77: 83-103.
• Schmid, M., Vitelli, L. and Batistoni, R. (1987). Chromosome banding in Amphibia. IV. Constitutive heterochromatin, nucleolus organizers, 18S+28S and 5S ribossomal RNA genes in Ascaphidae, Pipidae, Discoglossidae and Pelobatidae. Chromosoma 95: 271-284.
• Sites, J.W. and Reed, K.M. (1994). Chromosomal evolution, speciation, and systematics: some relevant issues. Herpetologica 50: 237-249.
• Sola, L., Galetti, P.M., Monaco, P.J. and Rasch, C.M. (1997). Cytogenetics of bisexual/unisexual species of Poecilia VI. Additional nucleolus organizer region chromosomal clones of Poecilia formosa (Amazon molly) from Texas, with a survey of chromosomal clones detected in Amazon molly. Heredity 78: 612-619.
• Sumner, A.T. (1972). A simple technique for demonstrating centromeric heterochromatin. Expt. Cell Res. 75: 304-305.
• Vari, R.P. (1983). Phylogenetic relationships of the families Curimatidae, Prochilodontidae, Anostomidae and Chilodontidae (Pisces, Characiformes). Smithson. Contrib. Zool. 378: 1-60.
• Venere, P.C. and Galetti Jr., P.M. (1989). Chromosome relationships of some Neotropical Characiformes of the family Curimatidae. Braz. J. Genet. 12: 17-25.
• White, M.J.D. (1969). Chromosomal rearrangements and speciation in animals. Annu. Rev. Genet. 3: 75-90.
• White, M.J.D. (1978). Chain processes in chromosomal speciation. Syst. Zool. 27: 285-298.
• Winterbottom, R. (1980). Systematics, osteology and phylogenetic relationships of fishes of the ostarionphysian subfamily Anostominae (Characoidei, Anostomidae). Royal Ontario Museum, Life Sci. Contrib. 123: 1-112.

Publication Dates

• Publication in this collection
  23 Feb 1999
• Date of issue
  Sept 1998

History

• Received
  14 Aug 1997