Corrosion resistance enhancement of SAE 1020 steel after Chromium implantation by nitrogen ion recoil

Corrosion resistance enhancement of SAE 1020 steel after Chromium implantation by nitrogen ion recoil

Geraldo Francisco GomesI, ^*; Mario Ueda^II; Antonio Fernando Beloto^III; Roberto Zenhei Nakazato^IV; Helfried Reuther^V

^IScience and Technology Analyst, Laboratório de Combustão e Propulsão - LCP, Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas Espaciais, LCP - INPE, Rodovia Pres. Dutra, km 40, 12630-000 Cachoeira Paulista - SP, Brazil

^IILaboratório Associado de Plasma - LAP/INPE, Brazil

^IIILaboratório Associado de Sensores e Materiais - LAS/INPE, Brazil

^IVDepto. de Física e Química, UNESP/FEG, Guaratinguetá - SP, Brazil

VForschungszentrum Rossendorf, FZR, Dresden, Germany

ABSTRACT

SAE 1020 construction steel is widely used as mortar reinforcement and small machine parts, but aside good surface properties as high ductility, hardness and wear resistance, its surface is prone to severe corrosion. As it is known, Chromium in amount over 12%-13% in the Fe alloys renders them resistance to several corrosive attacks. SAE 1020 samples were recovered with Chromium film and then bombarded either by nitrogen Ion Beam (IB) or Plasma Immersion Ion Implantation (PIII) to recoil implant Cr atoms in the Fe matrix. Samples treated by 100 keV N⁺ IB showed irregular, thin Cr profile, remaining a part of the film on the surface, to about 10 nm. Samples treated by 40 kV N PIII presented Cr layer of about 18% at., ranging to around 90 nm. Cr of the film was implanted in the Fe matrix in an almost flat profile. Results of corrosion test showed good performance of the PIII treated sample. The IB treated sample showed some enhancement over the non-treated reference and the only Cr film deposited sample showed no modification on the corrosion behavior as compared to the non-treated reference sample.

Keywords: corrosion, plasma immersion ion implantation, SAE 1020

1. Introduction

SAE 1020 construction steel (SAE/AISI 1020 grade) is most used as concrete reinforcement and small machine parts^1-3. But aside good surface properties as ductility, hardness and wear resistance, it is prone to severe corrosion. As the presence of Chromium (Cr), in excess of 12%-13% in Fe alloys, turns them resistant to several corrosive attacks, we tried to introduce Cr into the surface of this steel in such amounts. Cr films were deposited by electron beam on SAE 1020 surface and then bombarding either by nitrogen Plasma Immersion Ion Implantation (PIII) or ion beam (IB), Cr atoms are recoil introduced into the steel matrix^4,5.

Numerical simulations were performed using 2000.40 version of SRIM⁶ code, Stop and Range of Ions in Matter, from J.F. Ziegler and J.P. Biersack, of IBM Co., that showed the range of Cr and N atoms in Cr/Fe region, where the presence of Cr film was taken into account. Simulations showed that Cr atoms can be introduced in the steel surface by nitrogen ion recoil. Corrosion analysis was performed to compare the treated sample behavior with that of the non-treated reference sample⁷.

2. Experimental

SAE 1020 steel samples were polished to 1 µm with alumina powder and covered with Cr film of several thicknesses, Figure 1, in a 5 keV electron beam device prior to ion bombardment. Ion bombardment was performed using a 100 keV N⁺ beam to doses of 2 x 10¹⁷ N/cm² and 5 x 10¹⁷ N/cm² . In the case of nitrogen Plasma Immersion Ion Implantation, PIII, samples were bombarded using high voltage pulses at 40 kV and 8 x 10^-2 mbar in a nitrogen plasma, to doses around 5 x 10¹⁷ N/cm².

SRIM simulation showed Cr atoms introduced into steel surface after N recoil, at several ion energies. For the AES (Auger Electron Spectroscopy) measurements applied for determination of the elemental concentration in the samples, a spectrometer from FISONS Instruments Surface Science, model MICROLAB 310-F was used. Corrosion properties were measured in a PAR-EG&G 283 apparatus, using saline NaCl at 0.66 M, pH 6.0, aerated solution, RT SCE, KCl saturated, 0.333 mVs^-1 polarization.

3. Results

The SRIM simulation, of nitrogen ion bombardment on Cr film, showing Cr range into the iron matrix, as can be seen in the Figure 2, were confirmed by AES results. Figure 3 presents AES profile of samples treated by nitrogen ion beam at 100 keV energy. It seems to be large enough to make the N⁺ cross the Cr film, and despite of a 30% Cr content measured in the region just beneath the interface between the Cr film and the steel, Cr atoms lie in a very thin layer, less than 9 nm. The best Cr implantation was attained using Cr film of 50 nm and PIII at 40 kV, with percentages over 13% Cr at the surface in a layer ranging for more than 90 nm, Figure 4. Oxygen appears like impurities in the modified layer, coming from the pumping system.

Corrosion tests indicated remarkable increase in SAE 1020 resistance under corrosive medium attack, even in the case of IB, that produced a modest Cr enriched layer in treated samples, where a great amount of the Cr remains in the original film, as can be seen in Figure 5. For IB treated samples, there is a gain in the current density, which was the smallest result. For PIII treated samples, there is a gain in the corrosion potential, towards a more noble potential. For comparison purposes, Figure 6 depicts the corrosion profile of SAE 304 stainless steel under the same corrosion environment.

4. Conclusion

The computer simulations showed that a Cr film on the surface of mild steel, if bombarded with energetic nitrogen ions, can implant some Cr atoms by recoil process.

Thus, to produce a Cr-rich layer on the surface of mild steel, aiming to enhance its corrosion resistance, we deposited Cr films of several thicknesses on SAE 1020 steel surface. Then, we proceed to bombardment of the films, either by Nitrogen PIII, at 40 kV or by IB, at 100 keV.

Experimental results showed that Cr atoms penetrated deeply in the iron matrix, beyond the theoretical ranges. IB implantation presented an irregular profile, with a maximum of 30% at., going into the surface for only about 10 nm, with a large part of the original film remaining on the steel surface. In the case of PIII, the modified layer showed good uniformity, with a maximum of 17% at., ranging to about 90 nm, in an almost Gaussian profile, following the nitrogen profile. All the Cr atoms from the film were implanted in the steel surface, except those lost by sputtering.

Corrosion test showed good performance of the PIII treated sample. The IB treated sample showed some enhancement over the non-treated reference and the only Cr film treated sample showed no modification on the corrosion character as compared to the non-treated reference.

Acknowledgments

This work is partially funded by FAPESP, to whom G.F. Gomes thanks a post-doctoral fellowship.

Received: July 19, 2004; Revised: October 10, 2005

• 1. Capozucca R. Damage to reinforced concrete due to reinforcement corrosion. Construction and Building Materials 1995; 9(5):295-303.
• 2. Andrade C, Alonso C. On-site measurements of corrosion rate of reinforcements. Construction and Building Materials. 2001; 15(2-3): 141145.
• 3. Agerskov H. Fatigue in steel structures under random loading. Journal of Constructional Steel Research 2000; 53(3):283-305.
• 4. Anders A, Anders S, Brown I.G, Yu K.M. Increasing the retained dose by plasma immersion ion implantation and deposition. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 1995; 102(1-4):132-135.
• 5. Wu ZC, Liu Y-L, Chen M-C. Passivation of copper films with magnesium doping using recoil ion implantation. Thin Solid Films 2000; 358(1-2):180-186.
• 6. Ziegler JF, Biersack JP, Littmark U. The stopping and range of ions in matter, v.1. New York: Pergamon Press, 1985.
• 7. Saremi M. Mahallati E. A study on chloride-induced depassivation of mild steel in simulated concrete pore solution. Cement and Concrete Research 2002; 32(12):1915-1921.

Publication Dates

• Publication in this collection
  31 Jan 2006
• Date of issue
  Dec 2005

History

• Received
  19 July 2004
• Accepted
  10 Oct 2005