Silicone resin to improve corrosion resistance of Zn and ZnFe coated steel

Silicone resin to improve corrosion resistance of Zn and ZnFe coated steel

M.E.P.Souza^I,II; E.Ariza^II, M.Ballester^III; I.V.P.Yoshida^IV; L.A. Rocha^II,V; C.M.A.Freire^I

^IDepartment of Materials Engineering, Faculty Mechanical Engineering, UNICAMP, C.P. 6122, 13083-970, Campinas, São Paulo, Brasil. Tel: [phone], e-mail: [e-mail], [e-mail] ^IIResearch Centre on Interfaces and Surfaces Performance, Campus de Azurém, 4800-058, Guimarães, Portugal. Tel: [phone]. E-mail: [e-mail] ^IIIApplied Physics Department, Physics Institute, UNICAMP, C.P. 6039, Campinas, São Paulo, Brasil. Tel: [phone], e-mail: [e-mail]

^IVChemistry Institute, UNICAMP, C.P. 6154, 13083-970, Campinas, São Paulo, Brasil. Tel: [phone], e-mail: [e-mail]

^VDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, University of Minho, Campus de Azurém, 4800-058, Guimarães, Portugal. Tel: [phone], e-mail: [e-mail]

ABSTRACT

Chromatation pre-treatments have been widely used to improve galvanized steel corrosion resistance. However, due to the high toxicity of chromate ions, chromatation pre-treatments tend to be banned and, in last years, alternative coating systems are under investigation. Recently, polysiloxanes have been developed for application as coatings. Among them, and due to their specific properties, such as hardness, chemical resistance and hydrophobicity, silicone resins may be considered as promising substitutes for chromatation pre-treatments.

In this work silicone films, obtained from the hydrolysis of a methoxy functional silicone reactive intermediate, were applied on galvanized steel and on steel electroplated with a ZnFe alloy. Electrochemical techniques were used to characterize the degradation behavior of the samples. These consisted on the monitoring of the open circuit potential (OCP), and on the potentiodynamic polarization of the samples, which was performed in a 3% NaCl aqueous solution. Additionally, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) was used as a complementary technique for the evaluation of the corrosion mechanisms of the coating system. SEM and EDS were employed to inspect the surface of the samples before and after the electrochemical tests. EIS data was fitted to an equivalent circuit from which the electrochemical parameters were obtained.

Results show the protective character of the resin films, when compared with uncovered specimens. The capacitance of the films increased with the immersion time, in accordance to the behavior expected for an organic film. The overall performance of the coating systems appears to be highly dependent on the type of metallic coating applied to the steel. During the first three days of immersion the coatings applied upon galvanized steel showed larger |Z| values when compared with those applied to the electroplated steel, indicating a superior corrosion resistance of the former. However, after that time, an abrupt drop of |Z| is observed in the film applied on galvanized steel. In comparison, the coating system involving ZnFe alloy evidences a better stability throughout the immersion time.

Palavras chaves: Silicone Resin; Zinc Alloy Coatings; Electrochemical Behaviour

1 INTRODUCTION

Painting of metallic surfaces constitutes an efficient way to provide protection and corrosive prevention for these surfaces. An industrial coating system may consist of several layers each one having different functions. A chemical-conversion coating of chromate or phosphate is often applied initially to provide a substrate of superior adherence. A primer coating of good surface adherence and inhibitive properties may be required; these improve the durability of the final topcoats, which have maximum resistance to weather [1-2].

Nowadays, because of toxicity of chromate ions, environmentally legislation has pressured for to prohibit the pre-treatment with chromates. As a consequence alternative pre-treatments have been researched. Thus, polysiloxanes, materials that own Si-O groups, were developed as a viable alternative [3-4]. Polysiloxanes are inorganic polymers that contain silicon and oxygen atoms at the principal chain and are characterized for three-dimensional siloxanes net with organic substitutes constituting the units that form the net. At this group the silicone resins can be included. The term "silicone resin" refers to a class of nonlinear, largely silsesquioxane, containing polyorganosiloxanes and formulation there from. Commercial silicone resins can be classified into a DT type, which mainly consist of D and T units, and a MQ type, which comprise M and Q units, see figure 1 [5-6]. The application of silicone chemistry has permitted the development of a simple mechanical treatment for metal surface, these chemicals are easy to handle and non-toxic. Furthermore they provide a better adhesive surface for paints [7].

The present paper focused on the valuation of commercial silicone resin (R-3074 – Dow Corning) used to cover Zn (galvanized) and ZnFe coated steel without chromate pre-treatments. This resin is a methoxy-functional low-molecular weight, silicone-reactive intermediate. Electrochemical techniques, EIS and potentiodynamic polarization, were used to monitor the behaviour of coating system in a corrosive electrolytic medium. Results were confronted with samples without resin coating to verify the effectiveness of this material.

2 EXPERIMENTAL

The experimental procedure can be divided in three parts: Preparation of silicone resins films, application of resin upon the Zn and ZnFe coated steel and analysis.

2.1 Preparation of silicone resins

Sol-gel process was used in the resin films preparation. The intermediate R-3074 was mixed with Dibutylthin diacetate, catalytic, in the proportion of 0.2% mass. This mixture was agitated for about 15 minutes, until getting an ideal viscosity for application on the substrates.

2.1.1 Application

Two substrates were utilised and their characteristics are presented in table 1, none post-plating passivation treatments was made on the substrates.

Before coat application the substrates were cleaned in order to remove any kind of grease. The application was done by a baton that spread the resin upon the plates. A box specially designed and dimensioned was used to obtain resin coating 25mm thick. The curing temperature was 200ºC for 12 hours. Samples are referred as Zn and ZnFe, corresponding to the galvanized and electroplated ZnFe specimens and as Zn/R and ZnFe/R when they are coated with resin.

2.1.2 Analyses

A PGZ 100 Voltalab potentiostat (Radiometer, Denmark), controlled by the Volta Master-4 software, was used in the Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) experiments. A three-electrode cell arrangement was used in the experiments. The exposed area was 1,86cm². The reference electrode was a saturated calomel electrode and the counter electrode was platinum. The electrolyte was a 3% NaCl solution and the impedance spectra were ranged from 10⁵ to 10^-2Hz. The amplitude of a.c. signal imposed was 10mV. Measurements were made at different exposure times, until 3 days of exposure. The impedance spectra were analysed using ZView software and equivalent electrical circuits model had been used to evaluation the behaviour of coatings in corrosive environments.

The open circuit potential (OCP) and the electrochemical polarisation were measured in a Potentiostat PGP 201 (Radiometer, Copenhagen) controlled by the Voltamaster-1 software. The OCP was registered during 60 min and the potentiodynamic polarisation was determined in a range of -1700 to 0 mV at a scan rate of 2mV/s. All tests were carried out at ambient temperature in a 3% NaC1 solution.

The morphology of coatings was determined using a Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM). In the same way, the chemical composition was evaluated by an energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS). Surfaces of resin coatings were analysed at initial conditions and after EIS tests.

3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

In figure 2a) the open circuit potential (OCP) representative of the behaviour of the samples is presented. As it can be observed, after one hour of immersion, the Zn-coated samples exhibit a corrosion potential ca. 200 mV higher than that of the ZnFe-coated samples, this being an indication of a lower tendency for corrosion evidenced by the Zn-coated sample. However, considering the resin coated samples, one can observe that after one hour the corrosion potential is of the same order of magnitude for both the Zn- and the ZnFe-coated samples. Both samples tend to a stable corrosion potential, which is, however, lower than that of the Zn-coated samples. Nevertheless, it should be referred the dissimilar evolution of the potential curves for the ZnFe/R and the Zn/R curves. In fact, for the Zn/R sample the corrosion tendency appears to increase with the immersion time, as shown by the decrease in potential, while for the ZnFe/R sample a slight increase in corrosion potential is observed.

Representative potentiodynamic polarization curves expressing the behaviour of the samples are presented in fig. 2b. A first remark to be made refers to the Zn/R and ZnFe/R curves, both displaying a passive plateau characterised by a corrosion current density ranging from 10^-7 to 10^{-6 A.cm-2}. As it can be seen, the passive plateau for the Zn/R sample is present for a larger potential range than that of the ZnFe/R sample. Also, the passive current densities for the resin coated samples are 2 and 5 decades lower than that of the Zn and ZnFe samples, respectively, this being a strong indication of the protective character of the resin.

The monitoring of the time dependence of the electrochemical impedance of the coated samples, exposed to NaCl solution, allowed the evolution of the corrosion protection character of each coating system to be compared. It is well known that equivalent electrical circuits can be used to explain the electrochemical impedance data obtained by the EIS tests. These models use a combination of resistance, capacitance and other elements which have a clear physical meaning, related with the response of the electrochemical system [8]. In this work a general equivalent electrical circuit model for coating systems was used, as illustrated in fig. 3. This circuit was used by some authors to describe the behaviour of a polymer coated metal [8-10], where R_e is the electrolyte resistance, R_p is the coating pore resistance, C_c is the coating capacitance, R_ct is the charge-transfer resistance and C_DL is the double-layer capacitance at the coating/solution interface. All the capacitances shown in the equivalent electrical circuit are mathematically modelled using a constant phase element (cpe); this element represents all the frequency dependent electrochemical phenomena. The results from EIS was successful adjusted to this circuit, with the exception of the data obtained in the Zn/R samples immersed for one hour of sample, where a simple electrical circuit just with a R_e, C_c and R_p was fitted to the experimental data.

Figure 4 shows results obtained in samples Zn and ZnFe in the EIS experiments. As shown in fig 4a, the values of |Z| for both samples at different times of immersion are in the range 10²-10³W. A relaxation time observed at the low frequency region, for the third day of exposure, denotes the presence of a degradation process occurring on the samples surfaces caused by the time of immersion, fig. 4b. Sample Zn presents a better behaviour in the first hour of immersion, as shown both by the high |Z| value and the high phase angle, but the EIS results suggests a degradation of the protective characteristics of the films after 3 days of immersion. In contrast, the ZnFe sample increases the value of |Z| after three days of immersion, indicating an increase of the protective characteristics of the coating. This behaviour may perhaps be attributed to the blockade of surface pores with corrosion products.

Figure 5 shows the evolution with immersion time of the Bode plots resulting from the EIS tests carried out in the resin coated samples. The first remark to be done refers to the barrier against corrosion provided by these resin coatings. In fact, as it can be seen in fig 5 a) and c), |Z| values at low frequencies, are several decades higher than that found on the resin uncoated sample (10^-9 W for the Zn/R sample, and 10^-7 W to ZnFe/R sample), after one hour of immersion. Additionally, as seen in fig 5 b) and d), phase angles approaching 90⁰, at high frequencies, are indicative of a capacitive behaviour to coatings.

It should be referred a distinctive behaviour of the resin-coated samples, depending on the nature of the substrate. In fact, in the Zn/R sample the impedance spectra changed from a capacitive nature after one hour of immersion, which is typical of intact coatings, to a spectrum containing two time constants [11]. On the order hand, sample ZnFe/R exhibited two time constants since the first hour of immersion, indicating the influence of the ZnFe/resin interface on the corrosion process. By other words, it might represent an indication of some permeability of the resin from the first moments of immersion. A decrease of |Z| with immersion time can be observed for the two samples. However for the Zn/R sample this fall is more accentuated, mainly after the second day of immersion.

According to some authors, the evaluation of C_c can be associated to water uptake or the entry of electrolyte into the coating [9, 11]. In fig 6 a) the dependence of the coating capacitance (C_c) and of the double-layer capacitance (C_DL), with the immersion time is presented. Firstly, the C_c values for the Zn/R and ZnFe/R are always lower than the values calculated for the samples without resin, indicating a good protective character of the resin over the substrate. Also, as it can be observed, C_c for the two resin-coated samples maintains very stable, maybe with a slight tendency to increase, throughout the immersion time, this being an indication of the maintenance of good protective properties of the resin coating. The continuous raise of the double-layer capacitance C_DL, presented in figure 6 b), is representative of the increase of the area at which delamination or corrosion occurs [10]. This increase was largest for sample Zn/R, which indicate this coating system provide the least corrosion protection

Figure 7 a) shows the variation of the R_p at function of immersion time for all samples. In the first moments of immersion R_p for the Zn/R sample is substantially higher than that calculated for the ZnFe/R sample. However, the decrease of R_p with the immersion time was found to be more abrupt for the Zn/R sample. For both samples the pore resistance stabilizes at a value near 10⁶ W.cm^{-2. In comparison with the systems without resin, the values of R}_p are bigger until the end of experiments showing that the resin continues protecting the substrate.

The evaluation of the evolution of R_ct with the immersion time shows that, although the higher R_ct shown by the Zn/R sample during the first hours of immersion when compared with the ZnFe/R sample, after 3 days the Zn/R sample displays a charge transfer resistance more than one decade lower than the ZnFe/R sample. Nevertheless, for both resin-coated systems, R_ct is much higher for the resin-coated samples than for the samples without the resin coatings.

As referred above, EIS data indicates that absorption of the electrolyte by the resin is likely to occur after some time of immersion. In figure 8, representative SEM micrographs of the surface of the Zn/R samples before and after the EIS test are presented. As it can be seen, the surface of the samples appears to be very smooth, and no signs of significant defects are observed before the immersion of the samples in the saline solution. However, after the EIS test, some white spots are observed in the surface, which appears to be due to a slight swell of the resin coating, this being an indication of penetration of the electrolyte into the resin at dispersed spots, resulting in lack of adhesion at those regions, probably due to the de-cohesion of the coating. By EDS it was not possible to identify the presence of any corrosion products at those spots. Consequently, any corrosion products resulting from the reaction of the Zn substrate with the solution at those spots, are apparently kept at the Zn/resin interface, explaining the de-cohesion of the resin coat.

In fact, both the potentiodynamic polarization and EIS results indicates that the behaviour of the resin-coated samples results from the events happening at the resin/substrate interface. In this aspect, as referred above, the Zn/R samples, although presenting a superior corrosion resistance in the beginning of the tests, presents a higher tendency to degradation during immersion. In figure 9 cross-sections representative of both resin-coated systems are presented. As it can be seen, in both systems the resin coating appears to be very compact, and no open pores can be detected. However, the observation of the resin/substrate interface reveals a defective adhesion of the resin to the Zn sample, which might lead to accumulation of electrolyte, in case of its penetration through the coating.

4 CONCLUSIONS

Zn coated steel showed a superior corrosion resistance when compared with the ZnFe coated steel. Additionally, silicone films have shown the ability of providing supplemental corrosion protection to Zn and ZnFe coated steel. However, in contrast with the behaviour of the resin-uncoated samples, the performance of the ZnFe resin-coated samples in contact with a sodium chloride solution becomes better than that of the Zn resin-coated samples. Penetration of the solution through the resin coating and a defective adhesion of the silicone to the galvanized steel might explain this behaviour.

5 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The authors gratefully acknowledge Capes and CNPq for the financial support.

6 REFERENCES

• [1] CABRAL, E.R., MANNHEIMEN, W.A., Galvanização, sua aplicação em equipamentos elétricos, 1ed, Ao livro técnico S/A, Indústria e comércio, Rio de Janeiro, pp.37, 1979.
• [2] JONES, D. A., Principles and prevention of corrosion, 2nd ed., Prentice-Hall Inc, USA, pp.477, 1996.
• [3] CHILD, T.F., van OOIJ, W.J, "Application of Silane Technology to Prevent Corrosion of Metals and Improve Paint Adhesion", Trans IMF, v. 77, n.2, pp. 64-70, 1999.
• [4] BECCARIA, A. M., PADELETTI, G., MONTESPERELLI, G., CHIARUTTINI, L., "The Effect of Pretreatments with Siloxanes on the Corrosion Resistance of Aluminium in NaCl Solution", Surface & Coatings Technology, v. 111, pp. 240-246, 1999.
• [5] BANEY, R. H., ITOH,  M., SAKAKIBARA, A., SUSUKI, T., "Silsesquioxanes", Chemical Reviews, v. 95, pp. 1409 1430, 1995.
• [6] ARKLES, B., "Commercial Applications of Sol-Gel-Derived Hybrid Materials", MRS Bulletins, May, pp. 402-407, 2001.
• [7] PETRUNIN, M. A., NAZAROV, A. P., ZAITSEV, R. M., MIKLAILOVSKI, YU. N., "Phase interactions in a system composed of a metal and an anticorrosive siloxanes coating", Protection of Metals (English translation of Zaschita Metallov), v 26, n 5 (May), pp. 587-592, 1991,
• [8] BONORA, P., DEFLORIAN, F., FEDRIZZI, L., "Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy as a tool for investigation underpaint corrosion", Electrochimica ACTA, v. 41, n. 7-8 (May-Jun) pp. 1073-1082, 1996.
• [9] BAJAT, J. B., MISKOVIC-STANKOVIC, V. B., KACAREVIC-POPOVIC, Z., "The influence of steel surface modification by electrodeposited Zn-Fe alloys on the protective behaviour of an epoxy coating", Progress in Organic Coatings, v. 47, pp. 49-54, 2003.
• [10] McINTYRE, J. M., PHAN, H. Q., "Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy; a tool for organic coatings optimisations", Progress in Organic coatings, v. 27, n. 1-4 (Jan-Apr), pp. 201-207, 1996.
• [11] TSAI, C. H., MANSFELD, F., "Determination of coating deterioration with EIS: Part II. Development of a method for field testing of protective coatings", Corrosion, v. 49, n. 9 (Sep), pp. 726-737, 1993.

Publication Dates

• Publication in this collection
  06 Feb 2013
• Date of issue
  2006