Services on Demand
On-line version ISSN 1806-9940
Rev Bras Med Esporte vol.10 no.3 Niterói May/June 2004
Proposicion de un criterio antropometrico para el diagnostico presuntivo de la dismorfia muscular
Aldair José de OliveiraI; Claudio Gil Soares de AraújoI, II
Program in Physical Education - Gama Filho University
IIClinimex Exercise Medicine Clinic - Rio de Janeiro - RJ
The muscle dysmorphia (DYSMUS) is a psychiatric syndrome that occurs to both
genders with higher prevalence in men, in which the individual perceives his
body as small and weak when in fact it is strong and muscular. There are no
anthropometric approaches in literature about DYSMUS.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain data from a reference population in order to suggest an anthropometric criterion for the diagnosis of DYSMUS.
METHODS: The sample was composed of 1,825 individuals who participated in a medical-functional evaluation (1,108 men and 717 women) between years of 1994 and 2003, with ages higher or equal to 15 years, non-athletes and not presenting significant locomotive physical disorders or clinical diagnosis of DYSMUS. Two non-dimensional proportionality indexes B/P1 and B/P2 were individually calculated with and without correction through the measure of the skinfold thickness, respectively. The presence of a ratio above 1 between the contracted and inflected arm and leg perimeters associated to the inexistence of three other cut-off points of ectomorphy, åSKF (sum of measures of triceps and medial leg skinfold thickness) and abdominal perimeter variables; these last ones with the purpose of excluding individuals with high B/P1 and B/P2 values primarily due to the excess of body fat.
RESULTS: The ratio B/P1 > 1 was observed in 16 individuals, eight from each gender. Analyzing the other cut-off points, all women could be identified as obese and, therefore, not carrier of DYSMUS, while among men, seven out of eight individuals could be classified as suggestive DYSMUS cases.
CONCLUSIONS: Based on the wide and heterogeneous sample used in this study, it is possible to suggest an anthropometric criterion to identify DYSMUS. Other studies are being conducted in order to validate the DYSMUS anthropometric criterion proposed in the present study and to determine the sensibility and specificity used in samples willfully selected due to their high prevalence of DYSMUS.
Key words: Body image. Proportionality. Anthropometry. Muscle strengthening. Strength.
La dismorfia muscular (DISMUS) es un síndrome siquiátrico
que ataca a individuos de ambos sexos con mayor prevalencia entre los hombres,
donde cada individuo reconoce su cuerpo como pequeño y frágil
cuando en verdad es fuerte y musculoso. No existen en la literatura abordajes
antropometircas sobre DISMUS.
OBJETIVO: Obtener datos de una población de referencia para sugerir un criterio antropométrico para el diagnóstico de DISMUS.
MÉTODOS: La muestra fue compuesta por 1.825 individuos que participaron de una evaluación médico funcional (1.108 hombres y 717 mujeres) entre los años 1994 y 2003, con edad superior o igual a 15 años, no atletas y que no presentaban deficiencia física locomotora significativa ni diagnóstico clínico de DISMUS. Fueron calculados individualmente, dos indices de proporcionalidad dimensionadas, B/P1 e B/P2, con o sin corrección por la medida de grosor del pliegue cutáneo respectivamente. Se estableció como criterio antropométrico para DISMUS, la presencia de una razón superior a uno entre los perímetros de brazo contraido y flexionado y de pierna asociado a la inexistencia de otros puntos de corte de las variables de ectomorfia, åDC (sumatoria de las medidas de grosor de los pliegues cutáneos tricipital y pierna medial) y perímetro abdominal, estos últimos cuidando de excluir individuos con valores de B/P1 e B/P2 elevados primariamente debido al exceso de obesidad corporal.
RESULTADOS: Razón B/P1 > 1 fue observada en 16 individuos, ocho en cada género. Analizando los otros puntos de corte, todas las mujeres pudieron ser identificadas como obesas y, po lo tanto no portadoras del DISMUS en cuanto a los hombres, 7 de los 8 individuos pudieron ser encuadrados como casos sugestivos de DISMUS.
CONCLUSIONES: Con la base de la muestra amplia y heterogénea utilizada en el presente estudio, es posible sugerir un criterio antropométrico como señal del DISMUS. Otros estudios están siendo conducidos para validar el criterio antropométrico de DISMUS propuesto en el presente estudio y determinar la sensibilidad y la especificidad utilizando las muestras escogidas a propósito por su alta prevalencia de DISMUS.
Palabras-clave: Imagen corporal. Proporcionalidad. Antropometria. Fortalecimiento muscular. Fuerza.
Kinanthropometry, characterized as the knowledge branch dedicated to the study of anthropometrical measures in movement conditions, is applicable in several health areas(1), and its clinical interpretation is an important and relevant tool for epidemiological screening(2). Some anthropometrical variables may provide important aids for both the diagnosis and for the prognosis of some diseases(3). For instance, methods based on weight and height ratios such as the body mass index (IMC) have a strong association with chronic degenerative diseases, among which we could emphasize: ischemic disease(3), systemic arterial hypertension(4) and anxiety and depression symptoms(7), although this simple mathematic relation has several theoretical limitations(8). Other anthropometric characteristics also have clinical implications, such as the ligamentous hyperlaxity, whose prevalence is higher among adult women with mitral valve prolapse(9).
Morbid concerns with body image were exclusive of female gender until not long ago(10), being associated to the reverse anorexia and nervous bulimia conditions(11,12). More recently, these concerns have also been found in men, initially defined as reverse nervous anorexia and later renamed as muscle dysmorphia (DYSMUS). This syndrome, rarely found in the general population, involves individuals of both genders although far more prevalent in the male gender, whose main characteristic is a specific distortion of the body self-image. The individual with DYSMUS perceives his body as small and weak when in fact it is strong and muscular(13).
This distorted image trends to lead such individuals to seek in muscle strengthening exercises the "correction" for their problem(13). Thus, a remarkable aspect of this syndrome is the permanent search for the increase on the muscular mass through muscle strengthening exercises, besides the frequent and indiscriminate use of ergogenic substances and hyperprotein diets. This constant concern with body self-image has a negative effect on their social life, affecting significantly the quality of life of these individuals.
Furthermore, there are no precise laboratorial or clinical criteria for the clinical characterization of DYSMUS that allow an accurate and precise diagnosis. In late review, we observed that there are instruments that were developed to diagnose DYSMUS(14,15) by means of questionnaires that, at first, are distinguished from others with regard to the number of items. In that manner and considering a possible anthropometric expression of the DYSMUS syndrome, the proposition of an anthropometric criterion that could contribute for its characterization and clinical diagnosis would be important and suitable.
The objective of the present study is to propose an anthropometric criterion that could contribute for the DYSMUS characterization.
All individuals with more than 15 years of age who participated in a medical-functional evaluation were included in the study. Most times this evaluation included maximal exercise cardiopulmonary test, 4-seconds test for the evaluation of the cardiac vagal tonus and a wide kinanthropometric evaluation, performed by three specialized physicians, from January 1994 to August 2003. This convenient sample was composed of individuals who searched for the Exercise Medicine Clinic - Clinimex, as part of their routine medical evaluations or as orientation for the practice of physical exercises or even for the admission in supervised exercise programs. Individuals presenting one or more of the following conditions were excluded: a) clinical evidence of DYSMUS; b) participant of competitive sports; c) carrier of significant locomotive disorder; and d) absent or incomplete relevant anthropometric clinical data. Thus, a final sample of 1,825 individuals was obtained (1,108 men and 717 women). Almost all men were white with high socioeconomic level. All individuals evaluated signed a specific consent form allowing the anthropometric data collecting and the use these information in the research. The main anthropometric and demographic data are presented in table 1.
Among the several variables measured, the following measures were used for the present study: body weight, height, contracted and inflected arm and leg perimeters, triceps and medial leg skinfold thickness. For the assessment of the body weight measure, balances (Filizola) or Plenna Personal Line (Brazil) were used with the individuals bare-footed and wearing the lesser amount of clothes as possible. Following, the height was determined by means of clinical stadiometer especially produced for this purpose or steel estadiometers label WCS (United States); the individual should be positioned in standing position with trunk the most elongated as possible and head positioned at Frankfurt level(16). The body weight and height measures were performed at 0.1 kg and 0.1 cm, respectively, and the values used for the calculation of ectomorphy (ecto), according to specific equation. The contracted and flexed arm girth (BC) was determined with tape measure perpendicularly around the central region of the arm, aiming to reach the largest value. The individual in sitting position should maintain the shoulder joint at 90º of flexion in relation to the trunk and the elbow joint inflected as to form an angle of 90º between arm and forearm with hand at supine position. The left hand was used in such way that the palm region of hands touched each other in order to provide resistance on the performance of the static contraction. Still at sitting position, the calf girth was determined (P) with tape measure perpendicularly, aiming to reach the largest value. Abdominal girth was measured at the umbilical scar region, maintaining the measure tape fully parallel in relation to the floor. For the girth measurements, a flexible measure tape Gullick (United States) was used, which performs the measurements with accuracy of 0.1 cm and allows the tension performed to be controlled and standardized. The measure of the triceps skinfold thickness (T) was made with individual with relaxed and extended arms. This thickness should be measured at the arm medium point (between the acromial and radial anatomical point) at the posterior side with the arm fold vertical and parallel to the longitudinal axis with arm along the body. The measure of the medial leg skinfold thickness (PM) was determined with individual maintaining the knee articulation at 90º; the skinfold thickness assessment was performed at the leg medial region considering the largest perimeter. A digital skinfold caliper Skyindex II (United States) was used with accuracy of 0.1 cm and constant pressure of 10 g/mm2.
Two non-dimensional proportionality indexes were calculated for each individual (B/P), one of them with no correction and the other with correction through the skinfold thickness measures, which express the relation between perimeters BC and P. The first is the ratio between variables BC and P. The second is the ratio between BC subtracted from T and P subtracted from PM, adjusted for the respective measure units, in other words, centimeters and millimeters. Both indexes are exemplified in table 2. The values above 1 were hypothesized, in other words, the measure of the contracted and inflected arm perimeter higher than the leg perimeter would correspond to the anthropometric expression of DYSMUS in adult men and women.
Considering that individuals extremely obese may present atypical anthropometric proportions and eventually be classified as DYSMUS carriers, we intended to control the influence of the weight excess and the amount of fat on values found for the proportionality indexes by adopting other additional criteria. The variables ecto, åDC and abdominal perimetry were found with the following cut-off points: < 1.458, > 45 mm and > 100 cm, respectively; these last two variables presented values near to P90 in their respective distributions.
Data have been analyzed by gender separately. The descriptive analysis was used through the average, standard deviation and percentiles. In order to assess the association level between B/P1 and B/P2, the Pearson moment-product correlation was applied. All calculations were performed in the SPSS software version 10.0 (SPSS, Chicago, United States), where the significance level of 5% was adopted.
The descriptive statistics for the anthropometric variables was presented in table 2. The indexes B/P1 and B/P2 showed high association in both groups: male (r = 0.98; p < 0.001) and female (r = 0.98; p < 0.001), emphasizing the similarity between indexes.
The percentile values of the proportionality indexes presented in table 3 suggest that values above 1 compatible with DYSMUS would be extremely scarce. Indeed, we have found only 16 individuals with the mentioned values in B/P1, eight of each gender. The results of these individuals were tested for fat extreme excess using the criteria previously mentioned. In the female group, 100% of individuals presented valued below the cut-off point of the ecto and above the cut-off point proposed for åDC, while 75% presented values of abdominal perimetry above 100 cm, indicating that the B/P1 value, above 1, was caused by problems of fat excess. Unlike in the male group, no individual obtained values above 45 mm for åDC and only one of them exceeded the cut-off point adopted for the abdominal perimetry. However, it was observed that 75% presented values below 1.45 for the ecto.
In a later and more detailed analysis, two adult young men with ages ranging from 21 to 26 years were excluded from sample by reporting high dissatisfaction degree with muscular level during anamnesis, compatible with the clinical suspicion of DYSMUS and B/P values above 1. Table 4 presents some anthropometric data of these two individuals; it is worthy emphasizing that these two adult young men do not suit in none of the cut-off points proposed for the investigation of weight excess.
The anthropometric proportionality has been objective of several clinical and sportive studies(17,18). Among the several strategies, the most recommendable is the Phantom(2), based on a unisex and standard height model, from which all anthropometric measures are proportionally compared and the results expressed as how many standard deviations above or below the mentioned model a given individual measure is found. However, the authors of the original proposition limited themselves primarily to the model's description, without establishing or discussing more deeply the implication and potential cut-off points for the clinical utilization. In the present study, we intended to suggest a proportionality criterion that would represent an objective and potentially valid approach as an anthropometric evidence of the presence of DYSMUS.
Two features of our sample and methodology of data collecting must be previously discussed and more deeply understood. Firstly, the non-randomness of the sample that more likely represents a subgroup of the highest socioeconomic stratum, favoring the white-colored skin with higher prevalence of chronic-degenerative diseases, mainly cardiovascular diseases. One should, therefore, consider that the generalization of these results for the adult Brazilian population might not be suitable. On the other hand, the data collecting performed by only three specialized physicians in a large number of individuals during a long period of time represents a high point and a sufficiently high control level of possible sources of error in the measure.
A possible limitation of our study was the impossibility to test or to question the self-perception of the individuals tested in relation to their muscular development degree. However, in practice, it would have been difficult to identify an instrument or a valid protocol of such heterogeneous characteristic for the application in our sample.
The reason why we decided to propose an anthropometric analysis of DYSMUS based on a ratio between the contracted and inflected arm and leg perimeters based on the empiric observation that individuals who attend to academies aiming at the development of the muscular hypertrophy trend to emphasize the muscular strengthening of arms and thorax upper region, parts of the body more easily seen by the others and by themselves. Particularly, it is common that these individuals would dress T-shirts with no sleeves in order for their hypertrophied muscles to be easily seen.
The interpreted results show that the high magnitude of associations between indexes B/P1 and B/P2 presented no practical advantage of correcting the circumferences for the respective skinfolds, simplifying the analysis and data collecting and allowing adopting only the proportionality index B/P1 (without correction for the measures of the skinfold thickness) or just the index B/P for the diagnosis of DYSMUS. The rareness on the attainment of B/P1 values above 1 within a wide and heterogeneous sample of adult individuals showed to be this arbitrary and easy-assimilation value a practical and probably suitable cut-off point. Although participants of competitive sports have been excluded from the sample, values above 1 in the index B/P1 also seem to be unusual or absent in this group (data not published), except for elite bodybuilders(19).
When the strategy of Phantom was considered, we could simulate, with data from BC and P sufficient to generate indexes B/P equal to 1, that the difference between the proportionality scores for the respective measures was of 2.5 standard deviations, similar to the score found recently by Silva et al.(19) for elite bodybuilders, corroborating the idea that this type of result would be extremely improbable to be found in a general population.
While the female sample for all cases of false positive of DYSMUS could be properly classified through the skinfold or abdominal perimetry measures, the same was not verified for the male group, when only one individual had in the obesity the explanation of finding such values in B/P1. The other seven cases presented values non-compatible with obesity, what suggests that they could be carrier of DYSMUS not identified in the clinical approach or be compulsive participants of muscular strengthening exercises, or even representing some keyboarding or measure error.
Considering results as a whole, among the 16 individuals presenting results of B/P1 > 1, all but seven could be classified as extremely obese or carrier of important weight excess. Among these seven individuals, four presented severe reduction on the body linearity, compatible with large muscular mass and/or with severe mesomorph and endomorph combination. The other individuals presented severe anthropometric disproportion not clearly related to muscular strengthening exercises, self-image disturbances or perception of muscular underdevelopment.
Due to what has been previously presented, it is wise to suggest that the index B/P1 only be used to define DYSMUS in women who do not suit in at least two of the three following differential diagnosis criteria: ecto < 1.45, åDC > 45 mm, and abdominal perimetry > 100 cm.
Furthermore, it is important that experienced evaluators measure the perimeters, preferentially adopting the procedure used in the present study in order to avoid false interpretations of the values calculated of B/P1.
Based on the large sample of adult individuals without clinical DYSMUS evidences analyzed in this study, it is possible to propose a DYSMUS anthropometric criterion based on the result above 1 for the relation between the contracted and inflected arm and leg perimeters in men and women, and for these last individuals, after the exclusion of extreme obesity cases from the adoption of three other criteria previously discussed. The decisive and interpretative process is illustratively presented in table 5.
In the clinical practice, the presence of a ratio B/P > 1 should be understood as an evidence of DYSMUS, and the diagnosis should be confirmed based on the analysis of other clinical and psychological parameters. Other studies are in progress with the application of this simple anthropometric criterion for the suspicious or characterization of muscle dysmorphia, using a specific questionnaire and samples willfully selected due to their high DYSMUS prevalence.
All the authors declared there is not any potential conflict of interests regarding this article.
1. Ross W, De Rose E, Ward R. Anthropometry applied to sports medicine. In: Dirix AK, Tittel K, editors. Olympic book of sports medicine. London: Blackwell Publications, 1988;233-74. [ Links ]
2. Ross W, Wilson N. A stratagem for proportional growth assessment. Acta Paediatr Belg 1974;28:169-82. [ Links ]
3. Willett W, Dietz WH, Colditz GA. Guidelines for healthy weight. N Engl J Med 1999;341:427-34. [ Links ]
4. Krauss R, Eckel RH, Howard B, Appel LJ, Daniels SR, Deckelbaum RJ, et al. A statement for healthcare professionals from the Nutrition Committee of the American Heart Association. Circulation 2000;102:2284-99. [ Links ]
5. Eckel R. Obesity and heart disease: a statement for healthcare professionals from the Nutrition Committee, American Heart Association. Circulation 1997;96:3248-50. [ Links ]
6. Grundy SM, Benjamin IJ, Burke GL, Chait A, Eckel RH, Howard BV, et al. Diabetes and cardiovascular disease: a statement for healthcare professionals from the American Heart Association. Circulation 1999;100:1134-46. [ Links ]
7. Ahlberg A, Ljung T, Rosmond R, McEwen B, Holm G, Akesson HO, et al. Depression and anxiety symptoms in relation to anthropometry and metabolism in men. Psychiatry Res 2002;112:101-10. [ Links ]
8. Ricardo D, Araújo CGS. Índice de massa corporal: uma análise baseada em evidências. Arq Bras Cardiol 2002;79: 61-69. [ Links ]
9. Chaves CP, Araújo DSMS, Araújo CGS. Kinanthropometrical and clinical characteristics in adult women with mitral valve prolapse. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2001;33:S75. [ Links ]
10. Assunção S. Dismorfia muscular. Rev Bras Psiquiatr 2002;24:80-4. [ Links ]
11. Su JC BC. Anorexia nervosa: the cost of long-term disability. Eat Weight Disord 2003;8:76-9. [ Links ]
12. Mehler PS. Bulimia nervosa. N Engl J Med 2003;349:875-81. [ Links ]
13. Pope H, Gruber AJ, Choi P, Olivardia R, Phillips KA. Muscle dysmorphia. An underrecognized form of body dysmorphic disorder. Psychosomatics 1997;38:548-57. [ Links ]
14. Mayville S, Williamson DA, White MA, Netemeyer RG, Drab DL. Development of the Muscle Appearance Satisfaction Scale: a self-report measure for the assessment of muscle dysmorphia symptoms. Assessment 2002;9:351-60. [ Links ]
15. Lantz C, Rhea DJ, Cornelius AE. Muscle dysmorphia in elite-level power lifters and bodybuilders: a test of differences within a conceptual model. J Strength Cond Res 2002;16:649-55. [ Links ]
16. Gordon C, Chunlea WC, Roche AF. Stature, recumbent length, and weight. In: Lohman T, Roche AF, Martorell R, editors. Anthropometric standardization reference manual. Champaign: Human Kinetics, 1988;3-8. [ Links ]
17. Miller R, Ross WD, Rapp A, Roede M. Sex chromosome aneuploidy and anthropometry: a new proportionality assessment using the phantom stratagem. Am J Med Genet 1980;5:125-35. [ Links ]
18. Hebbelinck M, Ross WD, Carter JE, Borms J. Anthropometric characteristics of female Olympic rowers. Can J Appl Sport Sci 1980;5:255-62. [ Links ]
19. Silva P, Trindade RS, De Rose EH. Composição corporal, somatotipo e proporcionalidade de culturistas de elite do Brasil. Rev Bras Med Esporte 2003;9:403-7. [ Links ]
Received in 19/1/04. 2nd version received in 12/4/04. Approved in 13/4/04