Services on Demand
On-line version ISSN 1806-3756
J. bras. pneumol. vol.30 no.1 São Paulo Jan./Feb. 2004
Role of the fiberoptic bronchoscopy in the diagnosis of patients with suspected pulmonary*
Anna Luiza Summers Caymmi(TE SBPT); Marco Antônio Santos Silveira; Guilherme Montal(TE SBPT); Antônio Carlos Moreira Lemos(TE SBPT)
BACKGROUND: Pulmonary tuberculosis is
an infectious disease of high prevalence and incidence. The use of sputum bacilloscopy
is a sure and speedy way of reaching a diagnosis. However as30% to 50% of the
bearers of pulmonary tuberculosis have a negative sputum smear or have no sputum
the fiber bronchoscopy acquires a special importance.
OBJECTIVES:To evaluate the sensitivity of the specimens collected by means of the fiber bronchoscopy (bronchoalveolar lavage and transbronchial biopsy) for the diagnosis of patients suspected of having pulmonary tuberculosis, without confirmation by sputum bacilloscopy.
METHOD: By review of the ledgers of fiber bronchoscopies carried out from March 1997 to March 2001, we identified and included in the study patients over 18 years of age and referred with suspicion of tuberculosis and at least three negative sputum smears. Data regarding age, gender, changes detected at thorax imaging and endoscopy were collected.
RESULTS: Fifty-two patients ranging from 19 to 77 years of age (median of 39), were included, 58% were of male and 37% were patients from the Official Health System. Prevailing finding at chest X-ray was the alveolar infiltrate (80%). In 35 patients tuberculosis was the final diagnosis (one with associated neoplasia); in 28 patients (80%) diagnosis was achieved by bronchoscopy. Other diagnoses disclosed by bronchoscopy were neoplasias, histoplasmosis, chronic eosinophil alveolitis, pneumonia by Pneumocystis carinii and pulmonary fibrosis.
CONCLUSION: results of this study point to the use of fiber bronchoscopy in patients suspect of tuberculosis, not diagnosed thorough sputum bacilloscopy, not only for pulmonary tuberculosis but also of those that represent differential diagnoses.
Key Words: Tuberculosis, pulmonary/diagnosis. Bronchoscopy/methods.
Abbreviations used in this paper:
AFB Acid-fast bacilli
BAL Bronchoalveolar lavage
TBB Transbronchial biopsy
In the late 1800s and early 1900s, after the discovery of radiology and effective chemotherapy, it was expected that a cure for Mycobacterium tuberculosis would be found. This would have been a significant advance in public health.(1,2-25) In the beginning of the 1980s, there was an increase in the incidence of pulmonary tuberculosis. This occurred as a result of various factors, including the advent of AIDS, increased migration from areas of high tuberculosis prevalence to areas in which the disease was under control, increased poverty, greater life expectancy and disorganization within tuberculosis control centers. It is believed that, during the 1990s, 1.7 billion people (one-third of the global population) were infected by M. tuberculosis and that 30 million died from this disease.(1, 4,3-22)
Direct examination of sputum is a fast, simple, and inexpensive way to diagnose pulmonary tuberculosis. However, from 30% to 50% of patients infected with pulmonary tuberculosis are not diagnosed through sputum culture.(1,25,23,5-24) In the literature, there is much controversy over what is the best method for investigating suspected cases of tuberculosis.(1,25,23,6,7,8,9,26,27,10,12,28-29) Fiber bronchoscopy has been evaluated for this purpose. This study was carried out in order to evaluate the sensitivity of methods used in the detection of bacillus in specimens collected by means of fiberoptic bronchoscopy for the diagnosis of tuberculosis and of other diseases with similar clinical manifestations.
Patients suspected of having pulmonary tuberculosis and presenting negative sputum cultures (in at least 3 samples) were evaluated using fiberoptic bronchoscopy. Only patients above the age of 18 were included. The study was carried out at the Hospital Universitário Prof Edgard Santos (HUPES) and at the Hospital São Rafael (HSR). The records of all (940) fiberoptic bronchoscopies performed at the HUPES and at the HSR from March 1997 to March 2002 were reviewed, and 52 were found to have been performed based on suspicion of tuberculosis. Clinical demographic data were collected from the files of the HUPES and HSR respiratory endoscopy clinics or from patient medical charts. Data on the clinical evolution of tuberculosis patients in whom fiberoptic bronchoscopy failed to identify the disease were also collected (at least 6 months after the exam). Fiberoptic bronchoscopies were always performed by the same (2) clinicians, using Fujinon or Pentax 4.8-mm flexible bronchoscopes. Prior to the procedure, patients were sedated with 20 mL of intravenous 2% xylocaine, and no vasoconstrictors were administered during the exam. Thorough inspection of the tracheobronchial tree was always performed, followed by the collection of bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid, bronchial biopsy (when endobronchial lesions were found) and transbronchial biopsy (TBB) when necessary. The BAL and TBB were performed at sites where radiological changes, according to standard criteria, were previously found. The BAL consisted of 5 samples of 20 mL of saline solution each, manually aspirated and stored in sterile containers. Samples were sent to the microbiology laboratory and submitted to direct examination and culture for BK viruses and fungi, Gram stain and quantitative culture for pyogenic microorganisms. The same samples were then sent to the pathology laboratory. The TBB procedure was performed through a channel of the bronchoscope using forceps to reach the lung parenchyma with no visual access, and approximately 6 tissue samples were collected. Samples were stored in a formaldehyde solution and sent to the pathology laboratory for anatomopathological examination and specific staining for acid-fast bacilli (AFB) and fungi.
Continuous variables are expressed as mean ± standard deviation (SD), median and limits. Categorical variables are expressed as percentages. The calculation of the sensitivity of fiberoptic bronchoscopy using Ziehl-Nielsen staining, BAL culture, and TBB anatomopathological examination was performed taking into consideration all criteria for the diagnosis of tuberculosis. The 95% confidence interval (95% CI) was used for the estimation of sample variability. Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS 7.5 and Epi Info 6.04 software. Criteria for diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis included positive bacilloscopy (in the BAL culture, or in the TBB or open-lung biopsy), M. tuberculosis-positive culture, granuloma with caseous necrosis (with negative findings for fungi in TBB or open-lung biopsy) and positive response to the use of regimen I, according to standards of the national tuberculosis control plan.
Of a total of 940 patients submitted to fiberoptic bronchoscopy, 52 presented suspected tuberculosis and negative sputum smears (from at least 3 samples). Ages ranged from 19 to 77 (median, 39). The most common radiographic finding was alveolar infiltrate (in 78.8%). A final diagnosis of tuberculosis was made in 35 patients. Table 1 shows the results.
Diagnostic and therapeutic methods used to define diagnosis are shown in Table 2. The methods found to have the best diagnostic potential were BAL bacilloscopy, BAL culture and TBB. Bronchoscopy helped determine a final diagnosis of tuberculosis in 28 patients. Table 3 shows the diagnostic methods used.
The sensitivity of bronchoscopy for the diagnosis of tuberculosis was 80% when compared with all other sampling methods, although the percentage was lower when compared to only some of the other methods, as can be seen in Table 4. The specificity of bronchoscopy was 100%, there were no false-positive results, 20% of the exams yielded false-negative results, the positive predictive value was 100% and the negative predictive value was 70%.
Of the 17 patients whose diagnosis was not tuberculosis, 11 were diagnosed through bronchoscopy, 3 through open-lung biopsy and 3 on the basis of clinical evidence (Table 5). For these patients, the sensitivity of bronchoscopy was 77%, there were no false-positive results and 25% false-negative results.
Bronchoscopic sampling, as a diagnostic tool for use in suspected cases of tuberculosis or other diseases, demonstrated a sensitivity of 78% (95% CI = 63.7 to 88) and a specificity of 100%. There were no false-positive results and the negative predictive value was 15.4% (95% CI = 2.7 to 46.3).
When there is suspicion of active tuberculosis, patients in whom direct examination of sputum is inconclusive represent a diagnostic and therapeutic challenge. When there are no other diagnostic resources, analysis of clinical data in together with chest radiograph findings has proven to be inappropriate in determining treatment regimens, especially when diseases for which there is no specific treatment progress.(15-17, 24-25) Our study confirms this observation since other infectious, neoplastic and immunologic diseases were diagnosed in these patients who were originally though to be suffering from pulmonary tuberculosis.
The most common radiological finding in pulmonary tuberculosis in adults is alveolar infiltrate in the upper lobes (right or left).(25) In this study, radiographs of all the patients diagnosed with neoplasia revealed alveolar infiltrate in the upper lobe of a lung, whereas alveolar infiltrate was observed in other areas of the lungs of some patients diagnosed with tuberculosis. Although we did not study some factors, such as diabetes, AIDS, and other causes of immunosuppression, any of which could masquerade as tuberculosis with atypical radiological findings, we reassert the lack of specificity of chest radiographs in the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis.(20, 24-25)
The Mycobacterium tuberculosis culture process, despite its 80% sensitivity, is time consuming, and thereby delays diagnosis. The use of DNA amplification techniques is mainly restricted to laboratory research and does not determine the viability of the bacillus.(2) Tuberculosis is a pathology with one of the highest diagnostic sensitivities for transbronchial biopsy,(26,27) a method of sample collection that uses a fiberoptic bronchoscope and has a low incidence of complications (pneumothorax in less than 5% of cases and less than 1% requiring drainage). Anatomopathological study of biopsy fragments may immediately indicate a diagnosis of tuberculosis, as well as helping define the diagnosis of other diseases with varying etiologies.(27) In this group of patients, the sensitivity of bronchoscopy for diagnosis of tuberculosis was 80% when we studied the results of the direct examination of BAL fluid, BAL culture and the anatomopathological examination of the transbronchial biopsy together. When we analyzed only the results of the direct examination of BAL fluid and BAL culture, sensitivity was 60%. The sensitivity of the direct examination of BAL fluid alone was 48.6%.
The study of the sensitivity of different sample collection methods using bronchoscopy in this group of patients reinforces the idea that, whenever there are no contraindications (for example, in patients who suffer from coagulopathy), transbronchial biopsy should be used in concert with other collection methods (direct examination and BAL culture).
A study comparing HIV-positive (HIV+) and HIV-negative (HIV) patients was performed in the city of São Paulo between January 1994 and June 1998.(20) The objective of the study was to evaluate the contribution of bronchoscopy to the diagnosis of tuberculosis in patients with no expectoration or with negative bacilloscopy. The conclusion was that the overall sensitivity of BAL culture and direct examination of BAL fluid were similar: 30% and 50%, respectively. The sensitivity of transbronchial biopsy was found to be 89% in the HIV group and 67% in the HIV+ group, quite similar (regarding the HIV group) to our results, and the authors suggested that this could be attributed to the lower tendency for granuloma formation in the HIV+ group. Lung neoplasia was diagnosed in 10 HIV+ patients and in 4 HIV patients. Inconclusive results were found in only 17/214 HIV+ patients and 4/105 HIV patients. Similar to our results, the authors found the contribution of bronchoscopy to diagnosis confirmation to be significant and emphasized the use of transbronchial biopsy for the immediate diagnosis of tuberculosis and other diseases of varying etiologies, such as infectious diseases and neoplasias.
In the present study, bronchoscopy was useful not only for the diagnosis of tuberculosis but also for the identification of other pathologies, especially neoplasias, whose delayed diagnosis may exclude the possibility of a surgical cure. Some authors even suggest that the higher the possibility of neoplasia, the sooner bronchoscopy should be performed.(26-27) Other infectious diseases (Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia and histoplasmosis) were also diagnosed through bronchoscopy during this study. The initial method of diagnostic investigation for these pathologies is also sputum culture(3) and the consequent delay in diagnosis may cause progressive pulmonary deterioration, which can lead to respiratory insufficiency. Another type of lesion that may occur in patients with histoplasmosis is fibrosing mediastinitis, creating a risk of chronic deterioration of respiratory mechanics.
Endobronchial changes detected by bronchoscopy are not always predicted prior to the examination, and must be investigated through bronchial biopsy. Anatomopathological findings from this type of biopsy show a higher sensitivity when neoplasia is diagnosed, ranging from 90% to 95%. In a study that evaluated 280 patients diagnosed with neoplasia, Castella detected changes ranging from 65% to 95% during the endoscopic examination, with varied histological types, the most common of which was the small-cell subtype and the least common was the alveolar bronchiole subtype.(26) Some authors believe that false-negative results in bronchial biopsies from patients diagnosed with neoplasia are caused by areas of necrosis within the tumor tissue.(27) Of the 52 patients evaluated in the present study, endobronchial lesions were found in 4 patients, 3 of them diagnosed with neoplasia (28% of the patients with neoplasia) and 1 with tuberculosis (3% of the total number of patients with tuberculosis). Endobronchial lesions were present in about 20% of patients diagnosed with tuberculosis, and it was quite common that no evidence of those lesions appeared in chest radiographs. This is consistent with the smaller percentage of endobronchial lesions expected in patients with pulmonary tuberculosis and negative sputum bacilloscopy.(26-27)
Cytopathological analysis was not performed on sputum cultures from patients with a final diagnosis of neoplasia. This method has low sensitivity for the diagnosis of neoplasia and, even in sputum culture confirmed cases, endoscopic evaluation must be performed in patients diagnosed with neoplasia in order to determine the exact location (which could include the oropharynx or the larynx) and endobronchial extension of the neoplasm, as well as the staging and whether surgical treatment will be necessary.(25-27)
In this study, no investigative method other than bronchoscopy was used for detection of tuberculosis. Therefore, no comparative study was possible. However, Since more than 15% of the patients studied were diagnosed with neoplasia, no other method could replace bronchoscopy in the endoscopic evaluation of these patients.
The sensitivity of bronchoscopy for tuberculosis (80%) and the determination of the diagnosis of other pathologies (neoplasia, infectious diseases or diseases mediated by the hypersensitivity mechanism) reinforce data in the literature indicating this type of examination when there is suspicion of tuberculosis but no confirmation in the sputum bacilloscopy. This is especially true if we consider the fact that immediate results are obtained through anatomopathological examination of the transbronchial biopsy.
1. Lauzardo M, Ashkin D. A review of tuberculosis and the prospects for its elimination. Chest 2000;117:1455-73. [ Links ]
2. Small PM, Fujiwara PI. Management of tuberculosis in the United States. N Eng J Med 2001;345:189-200. [ Links ]
3. Styblo K. The relationship between the risk of tuberculosis infection and the risk of developing infectious tuberculosis. Bull Int Union Tuberc Lung Dis 1986;60:117-9. [ Links ]
4. Chin DP, Osmond D, Page-Shafer K, Glassroth J, Rosen MJ, Reichman LB, et al. Reliability of anergy skin testing in persons with HIV infection. The pulmonary complications of HIV Infection Study Group. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1996;153:1982-4. [ Links ]
5. Smith LS, Schillaci RF, Sarlin RF. Endobronchial tuberculosis. Chest 1987;91:644-7. [ Links ]
6. TB and Airbone Disease Weekly, Sept. 1998, 28. [ Links ]
7. Hnizdo E, Singh T, Churchyard G. Chronic pulmonary function impairment caused by initial and recurrent pulmonary tuberculosis following treatment. Thorax 2000;55:32-6. [ Links ]
8. Strump IJ, Tsand Ay, Sehork MA, Weg JG.The reliability of gastric smears by auramine rhodamine staining technique for the diagnosis of tuberculosis. Am Rev Respir Dis 1976;114:971-6. [ Links ]
9. Anderson C, Inhaber N, Menzies D. Comparison of sputum induction with fiber-optic bronchoscopy in the diagnosis of Tuberculosis. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1995;152:1570-7. [ Links ]
10. Broto J. Acts. Tuberculosis y broncoscopia. ORL Iberamer 1971;1:71-5. [ Links ]
11. del Martin ML, Leon Grande M, Leon Ceruelo L, J Garcia Hortelano J. Broncoscopia en la tuberculosis pulmonar del ninõ. An Esp Pediatr 992;36:133-5. [ Links ]
12. Blib J, Scheinman P. The value of flexible bronchoscopy in childhood pulmonary tuberculosis. Chest 1991;100:688-92. [ Links ]
13. Kvale PA. Conscious sedation for bronchoscopy. J Bronchol 1999;6:67-8. [ Links ]
14. Diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis by flexible fiberoptic bronchoscopy. Am Rev Respir Dis 1979;119. [ Links ]
15. Anderson C, Inhaber N, Menzies D. Comparasion of sputum induction with fiber-optic bronchoscopy in the diagnosis of tuberculosis. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1995;152:1570-4. [ Links ]
16. Khoo KK, Meadway J. Fibreoptic bronchoscopy in rapid diagnosis of sputum smear negative pulmonary tuberculosis. Respir Med 1989;83:335-8. [ Links ]
17. Willcox PA, Benatar SR. Use of the flexible fibreoptic bronchoscope in diagnosis of sputum-negative pulmonary tuberculosis. Thorax 1982;37:598-601. [ Links ]
18. Wallace JM, Deutsch AL, Harrell JH, Moser KM. Bronchoscopy and transbronchial biopsy in evaluation of patients with suspected active tuberculosis. Am J Med 1981;70:1189-94. [ Links ]
19. Bammann RH, Fernandez A, Vázquez C, Leite K. Broncoscopia no diagnóstico de tiberculose: papel da biópsia transbrônquica em imunocompetentes e em HIVpositivo. J Pneumol 1999;25:207-12. [ Links ]
20. Cantwell MF, Snider DE Jr, Cauthen GM, Onorato IM. Epidemiology of tuberculosis in the United States, 1985 through 1992. JAMA 1994;272:535-9. [ Links ]
21. Sudre P, Tem Dam G, Kochi A. Tuberculosis: a global overview of the situation today. Bull World Health Organ 1992;70:149-59. [ Links ]
22. Iseman MD, Huitt GA, Tuberculosis. Clin Chest Med 1997;18. [ Links ]
23. I Consenso Brasileiro de Tuberculose -1997. J Pneumol 1997;23.: [ Links ]
24. Corrêa LC. Condutas em pneumologia. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2001. [ Links ]
25. Castella. Broncologia. Local: Editora Savage; 1982. [ Links ]
26. Prakash. Bronchoscopy. New York: Raven Press; 1994. [ Links ]
27. Kuhl IA. Laringologia prática ilustrada. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 1996. [ Links ]
28. Kleinsasser O. Microlaringoscopia e microcirurgia da laringe. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 1997. [ Links ]
Anna Luiza Summers Caymmi
Avenida Santa Luzia, 379, Condomínio Chácara Suíça ed. Otto Billian, apt. 702 Horto Florestal
SSA-BA. CEP 40295-50 Tel (71) 2765977
Accepted, after revision: 05/10/2003.
Masters Thesis. Research Advisor: Professor Antônio
Carlos Lemos, thesis defended on the 28th of November 2002 in Salvador Bahia.
Grant source: scholarship from CNPq.
* Study carried out in the Respiratory Endoscopy Clinics of the Hospital Universitário Professor Edgard Santos and of The Hospital São Rafael in Salvador (BA)