On-line version ISSN 1809-4341
Vibrant, Virtual Braz. Anthr. vol.8 no.2 Brasília July/Dec. 2011
Drawing the city: a proposal for an ethnographic study in Rio de Janeiro*
Drawing the city is a proposal for an ethnographic research project in Rio de Janeiro. I begin by mapping the production of an international group calling themselves urban sketchers,' whose collective project extols drawing as a form of looking, knowing and registering the experience of living in cities. Next I show the connections between art and anthropology, as well as their relation to cities and to Rio de Janeiro in particular. The sources and bibliography on the themes of the social history of art, drawing, visual anthropology and urban anthropology are also discussed. Setting out from the latter area, I present the possibilities for undertaking an ethnography that contributes to our comprehension of the graphic and symbolic narratives of urban life.
Keywords: drawing, art, city, urban anthropology, Rio de Janeiro
Desenhando a cidade é uma proposta de estudo etnográfico no Rio de Janeiro. Começo mapeando a produção de um grupo internacional que se autodenomina desenhadores urbanos (urban sketchers), cujo projeto valoriza o desenho como uma forma de olhar, conhecer e registrar a experiência de viver em cidades. Em seguida, mostro as aproximações entre arte e antropologia, bem como sua relação com as cidades e o Rio de Janeiro em particular. As fontes e as referências bibliográficas são discutidas em torno das temáticas da história social da arte, do desenho, da antropologia visual e da antropologia urbana. A partir desta última, apresento as possibilidades de realizar uma etnografia que contribua para a compreensão das narrativas gráficas e simbólicas da vida urbana.
Palavras-chave: desenho, arte, cidade, antropologia urbana, Rio de Janeiro
"Drawing to see" | Why draw?
The title of this section is taken from Joaquim Pais de Brito's catalogue for the exhibition "Drawing to see: the encounter of Bárbara Assis Pacheco with the galleries of Amazonia," organized by the National Museum of Ethnology in Lisbon in 2009. Brito's exuberant work as the museum's director has taught us, as anthropologists and spectators, that objects are always "open to new fields of signification," since "they exist before the eyes that look at them" and "each look has its own history, made from a mixture of intellectual construction, experience, sensibility and daydreaming in which it seeks out its own limits." It is the anthropologist who alerts us to the wealth of experimenting, interrogating and searching for knowledge through multiple languages, and thus allows us to attain new "levels of reading and understanding," since "there is no such thing as exclusive knowledge that allows the formulation of the infinity of questions and responses that objects carry within them." The title of the exhibition invites us to plunge into one of these multiple languages, produced in the artist-object encounter: "drawing to see," which we could also read as drawing to know, comprehend, appropriate, narrate and produce.1
In November 2007, Gabriel (Gabi) Campanario, a Spaniard now living and working in the USA as an illustrator and journalist for The Seattle Times, posted a set of drawings on Flickr entitled "urban sketches." A year later, the initiative led to a blog and, in December 2009, gave rise to the non-profit organization Urban Sketchers (USK) which is dedicated to organizing events, raising funds and providing grants to artists. Since then, as well as recruiting members in more than 50 countries, USK has also generated around 25 local affiliated blogs, like USK-Portugal, USK-Indonesia, USK-Argentina and so on. The first international symposium hosted by the NGO took place in 2010, in Portland, USA. A second event was held the following year in Lisbon, Portugal, attended by around 250 "urban sketchers," including researchers, professors, students and speakers.2 The "spirit" of USK is summarized in its manifesto:
We draw on location, indoors or out, capturing what we see from direct observation. Our drawings tell the story of our surroundings, the places we live and where we travel. Our drawings are a record of time and place. We are truthful to the scenes we witness. We use any kind of media and cherish our individual styles. We support each other and draw together. We share our drawings online. We show the world, one drawing at a time. 3
The final phrase of the manifesto became a slogan for the group. Displayed prominently on all its blogs, the phrase "We show the world, one drawing at a time" "calls attention to an interesting contemporary phenomenon: knowing the world through drawings.
The expression "show the world""not only means "showing the world" "but also exploring and knowing this world, as the many synonyms of the verb "to show" "make clear: "present, reveal, manifest, expose, mark, prove, highlight, attest, emphasize, allow to see, make understand, demonstrate, make visible."4
Teresa Carneiro explores these dimensions, presenting the drawings from the book Diários gráficos em Almada – which involves the participation of various members of the Portugal and Spain USK – as experiences that express a "more attentive look," "a "systematic investigation," "an "attitude of interrogating and rediscovering the mediations and ways of seeing the world" in order to, eventually, "(re)encounter the world through drawing."5
"We are not perfect sketchers" | Who draws?
The sub-title for this section comes from the title of Eduardo Salavisa's article in the above-cited book, which was published to accompany an exhibition of drawings of Almada, a city in Portugal. As Salavisa explains, the idea that someone can make drawings without calling him or herself an "artist""(or a professional illustrator) is central to this universe:
The authors of the displayed sketchbooks have no intention of being artists. While some are, and some will be, this was not why they took part in this exhibition. The fact they are all excellent sketchers, which they are, is likewise not the reason why they are here. They took part because they have a habit: they draw in sketchbooks systematically, daily, I would even say obsessively.
Among the universe of people who contribute to USK, one particular sketcher and blogger stands out: Danny Gregory, who is a New Yorker and the author of at least three books central to the sketchbook world and its online interface.6 It all began in 2003 with the publication of Everyday Matters: a memoir, an autobiography composed of texts and drawings, defined on its back cover as a "graphic memoir."7 In this book, Gregory tells how an accident left his wife Patty paraplegic, and how the couple tried to carry on with their lives, raising their son Jack, who was just a ten-month old baby at the time of the accident. The story's meaning is also summarized on the back cover:
In a world where nothing seemed to have much meaning, Danny decided to teach himself to draw, and what he learned stunned him. Suddenly things had color again, and value. The result is Everyday Matters, his journal of discovery, recovery, and daily life in New York City. It is as funny, insightful, and surprising as life itself.
On page 12 of the book Gregory narrates with an air of suspense: "Then one evening I decided to teach myself to draw." The pause ( "one evening"), the unusual ( "teach myself") and the magical ability ("draw") combine all the ingredients for a ritual of transformation in which the hero overcomes obstacles and discovers a new world. In his own words: "it didn't matter what I drew." All that mattered was drawing with that "slow, careful gaze," through which he learned to value each day ("everyday matters") and each object, however simple. Opened cans of food, old pairs of shoes, a corner of New York – everything can encounter its own space in his sketchbooks.8
Saul Steinberg, cited by Gregory as one of his main sources of inspiration, talks about drawing as a process of knowing: "You must manage to establish complicity with whatever you're drawing until you gain a deep knowledge of it." The observational drawing, the artist says, forces the sketcher "to find answers to questions that so far haven't been raised."9
A number of these elements appear in The Creative License – Gregory's most extensive book. The explicit objective of the work is to cultivate "a wild celebration of amateurism" (back cover) and turn drawing into a process, a means of self-discovery and self-recuperation, as the title and subtitle emphasize: "The Creative License: giving yourself permission to be the artist you truly are." The punning on the words license and permission suggests that learning to draw can be like learning to drive, accessible to everyone. This is the same principle found implicitly in the USK manifesto (which does not use the word "artist") and explicitly in Salavisa's text, cited above. Not by coincidence, the epilogue to Gregory's book reads: "Dedicated to you, the artist." In the introduction to An Illustrated Life, Gregory talks to his reader:
I hope they [the book's collaborators] will all encourage you to buy a little blank book and start recording the contents of your medicine cabinet, fellow passengers on your commute, the clutter on your desk. Whether you are an artist, a designer, a writer, a musician or a CPA [accountant], I hope you'll discover the richness, the adventure and the endless horizons of your own illustrated life. (Gregory 2008:7)
In this universe, becoming a sketcher is a journey of self-knowledge, which transforms the person and confers identity. These are drawings where the "objects" "do not exist in themselves, but as "objects drawn by somebody." As John Berger tells us, the drawing of a tree does not show a tree but "a tree-being-looked-at." Teresa Carneiro adds to this idea, writing that the drawings produced by sketchers tell us "something about the person drawing" and about the conditions "in which each drawing was made," as though they revealed "a consciousness of the experience of seeing itself."10
Drawing the city | Drawing what?
Drawing a city isn't just capturing it on paper, it's really about getting to know it, to feel it, to make it your own. (Nina Johansson, correspondent of the blog Urban Sketchers, in Stockholm, Sweden)11
In Danny Gregory's work, the themes covered by the drawings are broad in scope and contain a strong element of observing the private universe: personal objects, pets, friends, self-portraits. At the same time, since Everyday Matters, the city of New York has played a prominent role in his identity as a sketcher. Gregory calls he city one of the world's four "creative Meccas""(alongside Los Angeles, Paris and London); these are the places his readers should go in search of stimulating ideas and people. His own books, notebooks and online publications are full of drawings of New York, as well as dozens of sketches of other cities visited on trips.
As their name for themselves, urban sketchers, emphasizes, drawing urban space is a core value in their observational universe. The sketcher's relation to his or her own city or to the cities visited while travelling is one of the project's distinguishing features. The names of the observed cities are contained in the title of the blogs, webpages and books and in most of the captions to the drawings in the USK universe. The entire international symposium of the USK in Lisbon was organized around the idea of "drawing the city." "Its notebook featured a drawing of Lisbon on the cover, a map of the city on the back cover and a program in which all the workshops were named after the locations where the drawings had been made.
Gabi Campanario's newspaper column and blog are called "Seattle Sketcher" and are intended as an "illustrated diary" "of life in the region. As well as drawings made "in situ," "the journalist-illustrator writes about the drawn theme, provides a back history and interviews people related to the subject (public officials, city inhabitants, traders, etc.). The model is journalistic reporting in the image-text style, but with the added artisanal and creative dimension of the drawing process, including references to the choice of colours, materials and other elements from the world of the arts.
Dozens of other urban sketchers focus on the city as the main theme of their drawings. Paul Heaston, for example, became a prominent figure in the group on the basis of his project of drawing all the buildings along the Main Street of Bozeman, in the state of Montana, USA. Pete Scully, present at USK's two international symposia, has been drawing the main streets of the city of Davis, California, in a Moleskine sketchbook in a format known as "Japanese""(since its pages fold out accordion-style). Nina Johansson, whose quote is presented at the start of this section, was a workshop instructor at the USK symposium in Lisbon and one of her favorite themes is scenes of a city street in Stockholm, Sweden.
At the 2011 event in Portugal, the six lectures given were related to the theme of drawing in an urban environment. Ruth Rosengarten produced an in-depth analysis of the history and academic debates surrounding the issue (which I will discuss later). James Richards highlighted the renewed value attributed to hand-made observational drawing in communication projects, architecture and entertainment. Matthew Brehm discussed how to teach architectural students to draw "on location," "emphasizing various elements present in the USK manifesto. Antonio Jorge Gonçalves described a travel project that involved him drawing subway passengers in ten cities of the planet, leading to the book Subway Life. Tia Boom Sim, meanwhile, told how she and the group of sketchers from USK-Singapore ended up unleashing a process of "rediscovery" "and "revaluation" "of one of the city's neighbourhoods through drawing. Simonetta Capecchi showed drawings made from behind the scenes of the project "The L'Aquila Earthquake: a collective report." "Following delays with reconstruction work in the aftermath of the tragedy, which resulted in 300 deaths and 1,600 injured people, and led to the complete evacuation of the Italian city of L'Aquila for more than a year, a group decided to draw the location and, through these drawings, tell its history and that of its inhabitants.12
Draw how? | Devices
To draw the city, one of the trademarks of the USK universe is the use of sketchbooks. These may be small, with blank or grid paper, Japanese-style, made by famous brands (like Moleskine) or handmade. They may also be very specific, like old accounting books, which became a symbol readily identified with Lapin, the nickname of Julien Fassel, a French illustrator living in Barcelona, a member of the USK board and a figure admired by urban sketchers across the world.
A sketchbook with texts and drawings, writes Gregory (2008:2), can become the sketcher's "therapist," "his or her "crying towel," "but much more than this. In Creative License, he provides his readers with a list of at least ten reasons for drawing in diaries: they are compact, portable, cheap, personal, useful, accumulative, familiar, stimulate drawing with the "right-side of the brain," "provide an escape valve, comprise a form of art, a form of meditation, private or public, and enable your mistakes to be hidden. "Hate a drawing?" jokes Gregory, "Turn the page. Start again."13
Aside from the principles already cited – "drawing to see," "don't be a perfect sketcher," "draw the city" and use sketchbooks for their drawings – the universe of urban sketchers (delimited here through their manifesto, blogs and a selection of representative works) is full of "devices" "that establish rules and conditions for making drawings.
I use the concept of "device" "as found in the definition of the documentary cinema of João Salles, explained by Arbel Griner:
Salles uses the term device to describe the "rule,"" "prison" "or "limits" that the documentary maker imposes on himself when making a film. For him this is one of the fundamental questions of the documentary, since it translates the way in which the documentary maker organizes and informs/shapes the film – a reflection too of his way of framing the world. (Griner 2010:46)
Similarly the drawings of the urban sketchers are not "simply" drawings: they are "informed-shaped" by a particular "worldview." Drawings are defined by the locality surrounding the sketcher ("on location"), the use of direct observation (contrasting with drawing from memory), the search for a narrative (telling a story based on the observed world) and the providing of a context (time and place). There is a moral basis (be truthful to what is observed) and a philosophical basis ("show the world, drawing by drawing," which can be likened to the Chinese saying: "a thousand-mile journey begins with one step"). There is respect for diversity and individual styles, as well as the principle of not distinguishing between artists and non-artists, implicit in the defence of the sketchbook (rather than the art gallery) and their collective and non-commercial identity (we support each other, draw in a group and share our drawings online).
Based on these general devices, very often an individual sketcher establishes his or her own rules, such as drawing "every day" (various authors in Salavisa 2008); drawing for a month just the "clothes from your closet" (Gregory 2006); draw "always standing up," to avoid feeling "too comfortable" (M. Brehm);14 draw anything "in less than 30 minutes" (Steel 2010) or draw on very personal media, such as the aforementioned "old accounting books" used by Lapin.
As in the documentaries made by Salles, Gonçalves (2010) in his project Subway Life set a list of rules or "devices" for himself: draw people in the subway; draw people full-length, but not the surrounding environment; do not "select" a particular character for the drawing: he forces himself to draw the passenger in front of him (to get around the idea of the "desire" for the drawn object); draw only in "square notebooks" (a personal "passion," later abandoned, the author says, when he arrived in New York and discovered "passengers too big" for the format); draw in subways of ten different cities; and draw all the lines of the chosen subway system, at all times during the working day, in daily sessions of three to six hours.15
Deepening our understanding of these different devices, here no more than outlined, is perhaps a good way to comprehend how the urban sketchers relate with the city through drawings. Put otherwise, we could ask: how are the sketchers" drawings constructed through the ways in which they "frame" the city?
Designing a project | The research proposal
In 2012, a group affiliated to the Urban Sketchers organization will be created in Brazil, with representatives from Rio de Janeiro, São Paulo and other cities. This innovation, arising from the participation of Brazilians on the blog network and at the USK event in Lisbon, was one of the reasons that led me to formulate a research project about urban sketchers in Rio de Janeiro. The existence of this local social base made the idea of producing an ethnography much more concrete.
As a "sketcher" myself and an urban anthropologist – I have conducted research in this area for twenty years now – I glimpsed an ideal opportunity for a fieldwork project in which drawing and the city are densely interwoven. Rio de Janeiro indeed has a long history as a "drawn city."
The research proposal thus emerges from the convergence of these three domains: the "urban sketchers," the city of Rio de Janeiro and anthropological theory. We have a universe of (networked) social actors, a research locus (the city, the starting point extended through the networks) and a theoretical-methodological approach (taken from anthropology, but in dialogue with other traditions). The problem that emerges from this conjuncture can be compared to what Cornélia Eckert has identified as one of the main challenges facing urban anthropology today: conceiving the city through a "plurality of agencies" and the circulation of new forms of ethnographic knowledge, such as those from the online and audio-visual domains.16
Everything gained further substance when I read the text by Oscar Wilde, The Decay of Lying: an Observation.17 This small essay, written in the form of dialogues, contains one of the author's most famous phrases: "life imitates art far more than art imitates life." A maxim so familiar that it arouses little attention. However, when placed in its original context, that is, in the arguments of Wilde's characters, it reveals a profoundly anthropological approach to the relation between artistic production and social life:
Things are because we see them, and what we see, and how we see it, depends on the Arts that have influenced us. (…) People see fogs not because there are fogs but because poets and painters have taught them the mysterious loveliness of such effects. There may have been fogs for centuries in London. I dare say there were. But no one saw them, and so we do not know anything about them. They did not exist till Art had invented them.18
What do the forms produced by art teach us about the city of Rio de Janeiro and how to see it? Who draws which city? How are different gazes onto the city produced? Which areas, themes and elements of the city are selected, delimited and drawn? What relations are developed between sketchers and the city in the process of constructing their graphic "narratives"? What meanings emerge from these drawings? What are the continuities and ruptures of the graphic and symbolic constructions of the city over the course of its history?
These are some of the questions that the research project aims to answer.
Anthropology, city, drawing | The bibliographic illusion
What is drawing? How does one get there? It's working one's way through an invisible iron wall that seems to stand between what one feels and what one can do. (Vincent Van Gogh, Van Gogh Letters, n.274)
Van Gogh describes the difficulty of working one's way through the "invisible wall" separating what the artists sees (and feels) from what his or her drawing produces.
"Exactitude is not truth," says Matisse in his Writings and reflections on art [available only in French or Portuguese: Escritos e reflexões sobre arte]. We need to take into account the "profound feeling of the artist before the objects that he has chosen," without presuming that a "combination of exact details" that are "patiently assembled" can enable the recreation of nature in a drawing (p. 192, free translation).
Like Matisse and Van Gogh, Paul Klee also reflected on the need of the artist to feel, select and find his way:
Art does not reproduce the visible; rather it makes visible. (...) There has to be some region common to spectators and artists in which a mutual approximation is possible and where the artist does not need to appear as something apart, but a creator that, like the reader, was hurled without warning into a multiform world and, like the reader, has to find his own way, for good or ill. (Paul Klee, Sobre a arte moderna e outros ensaios, free translation, p. 52)
I would venture to say that Van Gogh's "invisible wall," Matisse's unproductive search for "exact details" or Klee's evocation of the drifting of the "multiform world" all provide useful analogies for the difficulty faced by the researcher confronted by the vast range of works referring to the themes of his or her research.
The more works we read and the more classes we teach about this literature, the more aware we become of its complexity and more conscious still of the huge amount of texts we have to "leave out." Faced with the profusion of already read works and other, almost infinite possibilities for our desires to pursue (through online bookstores), we feel like Jacinto de Tormes, a character in A cidade e as serras by Eça de Queirós, who became paralyzed staring at his library of more than 30,000 volumes, unsure which to read before going to sleep.
Here I glean a little comfort from the seven pages written by Luiz Fernando Duarte in his foreword to the collection Horizontes das ciências sociais: Antropologia. In this text, he discusses what could have been included in the work, but was not for a series of entirely understandable practical and theoretical motives. Obviously, the difficulties faced in organizing a work of this magnitude cannot be compared with those involved in a simple research project. In making the comparison, I simply wish to emphasize what Duarte defines as essential to the "objectivity" of the choices present in any scientific investigation:
Hence the classification presented in each article is objective only insofar as its author makes apparent, even if only implicitly, the bias informing it. (...) The only possible guarantee of the "scientificity" of our forms of knowledge is this: maintaining doubt and debate open always, submitting each statement to comparative, historical and empirical debate." (Duarte 2010:19-20)
Here I follow Duarte's lead, looking to avoid the production of a "bibliographic illusion" – to paraphrase Pierre Bourdieu's famous expression concerning autobiographic narratives and their tendency to present lived events as "coherent" wholes, animated by the "totalizing" and "artificial" production of meaning.19
Consequently I start by highlighting the areas I could investigate for a research project on drawing and the city, but shall be unable to cover sufficiently, due to the choices made, time demands and personal limitations. Some areas are present, such as the anthropology and sociology of art, as well as visual anthropology, but comprise vast fields of reflection with which I intend to dialogue in more depth in the future.20 Others, such as the universe of communication, new technologies, design and urban planning, are briefly mentioned only and will comprise bibliographic areas providing support as and when needed.21
Returning to the idea of the three main domains – urban sketchers, the city of Rio de Janeiro and anthropological theory – I present below some of the different sets of sources and bibliographic references that will help develop my ethnographic investigation.
I discovered the universe of urban sketchers through the internet and a little later through works published in the United States and Portugal. The two key authors who I would pick out as the core of this literary production are Danny Gregory (2003, 2006, 2008) and Eduardo Salavisa (2008, 2010a, 2010b, 2011). Both are not only authors, but also editors of books featuring samples of work by dozens of other sketchers of various backgrounds and styles.22 Gonçalves (2010) and Steel (2010) are two different examples of works that reproduce sketchbooks. The first is the outcome of a large project, the second is a booklet printed and sold by the author herself. These publications (always in interaction with their respective blogs) will comprise sources for the research, but they also dialogue with the academic field. An especially rich source here is the introduction by Salavisa (2008) on the world of sketchbooks, travel notebooks and graphic diaries throughout history by different kinds of artists, like Eugène Delacroix, Edward Hopper, Frida Kahlo, Pablo Picasso, Le Corbusier, among others.23 Both this text and the paper written by Ruth Rosengarten – an art historian, as well as an artist and urban sketcher herself – contain a selected academic bibliography and numerous questions that converge with the aims of the proposed research. The latter author highlights some of the central themes of the USK project: observational drawing "on location," drawing as a "witness" and drawings made during "urban walking." She concludes:
Historically, somewhere in the middle of the spectrum between apparent objectivity and declared subjectivity, sits the sketchbook as traveller's companion and ethnographer's tool, recording not only the urban and natural surroundings, but also the lives and customs of foreign people in far flung lands. (Rosengarten, 2011:4)
Rosengarten suggests a likeness between sketchers, historians and anthropologists, all of whom produce detailed observations of "everyday life" in the city. For the author Michel de Certeau, reflection is central: someone who wanders the streets may lose sight of the whole, but engages in a rich bodily and sensory exploration, absorbing the city's spaces in a new way.24
A sketcher too, the anthropologist Manoel João Ramos claims that drawing is an opportunity to "participate in a world" that is not one's own, creating "imaginary" orders and organizing "lived experiences" in memory. Moreover, the act of drawing, in contrast to taking photographs or filming, allows a more open dialogue with the "people with whom the traveller comes face-to-face." For Ramos, the gesture of drawing is especially important in the ethnographer's case since it becomes an invitation to the native "to look, to dialogue with him, to grant him the status of a human being."25
Returning to the idea of drawing as a means of knowing the city, we head to Brazil, more precisely São Paulo, and the words of the architect and illustrator Paula Caffé. She begins by emphasizing the value of drawing in the street, "being" and "living" in the city:
Remaining local makes a lot of difference to drawing: because of the bustle, the pedestrians, the climate. I think it's really important to let your mind wander in the location. (...) I also like to draw in a boteco (bar), a padoca (bakery),26 on any street corner. I draw much better than when in my studio. In the book Avenida Paulista I revived this methodology of drawing in the street.27
Here I would also highlight her appreciation of how this act of drawing "on location" becomes a new form of "seeing" (in the sense that we explored in the initial section of the project) and appropriating the city:
Another thing I noticed while making the book is: how important it is for us to draw our city, in the sense of putting it on the map. (...) I hope my drawing inspires people to draw their own city. Because I think drawing is a form of knowledge. By drawing, you end up knowing many things; you end up discovering many things. Not just inner things, your things, but things that are out there, to be drawn. (my italics)28
Contemporary projects like Avenida Paulista, dedicated exclusively to drawing in cities (or drawings of cities), are fairly rare in the international literature or in Brazil, even taking into account the rich fictional – and sometimes also documental – collection of graphic novels, which have led to volumes like New York: Life in the Big City (Eisner 2006). There is a recent book about sketchbooks, also published in São Paulo, though not specifically focused on drawing the city (Almeida & Bassetto 2010). In Rio de Janeiro, there are a few tourist guides that are illustrated entirely with drawings and one publication that stands out: Rio de Janeiro: les carnets de Voyage de Jano.29 There are also some publications produced to accompany exhibitions of humorous drawings, cartoons and illustrations, such as that by Caruso (2009). All these are important reference works for developing the idea of a "semantic landscape" in the city's recent history (1975-2011).
If we go back in time, the number of works becomes incalculable.30 Even if we focus on the city of Rio de Janeiro alone, it would be impossible to list everything that has been published. There are the worlds of maps (Castro 2000), travellers (Ermakoff 2011), postcards (Gerodetti & Cornejo 2004), the city's history (Sandroni 2010), magazines and the press (Lustosa 2010), illustrators (Simioni 2002), books (El Far 2004), and much more.
Among the works that can be cited here, O bonde e a linha: um perfil de J. Carlos (Loredano 2002) and O Rio de J. Carlos (Loredano & Ventura 1998) both stand out for their specific focus on the relation between a sketcher (illustrator) and the city of Rio de Janeiro. Through texts and images, the authors show us how the mutual influences evolved between the newly urbanized society and its expression in the drawings of J. Carlos. The different streets, public figures, neighbourhoods, automobiles, beach, football and the buildings... so many objects and themes drawn in a style very close to what Julia O'Donnell has called an "ethnographic temperament."31
This interpretation (of J. Carlos) would really need to be justified here through a careful analysis of the images in question. But postponing this work for now, given the time and space restrictions, I cite instead a series of works that will be important to the development of this type of approach. As well as Barthes (1990), Gombrich (1995 and 1999), Chipp (1988), Garner (2008), Ingold (2007) and Lagrou (2009), I consider the approach of the Italian historian Carlo Ginzburg (1989 and 2010) particularly fertile.
Inspired by anthropological theory and by the work of various authors from the intellectual circle of the art historian Aby Warburg (such as Saxl, Panofsky and Gombrich), Ginzburg proposes a relation between art and history that considers, on one hand, "works of art in the light of historical witnesses, (...) able to explain the genesis of their meaning." On the other hand, "the work of art itself and visual forms in general should be interpreted as a sui generis source for historical reconstruction" (1989:56). Cautious of the limits of a "purely stylistic" reading, Ginzburg looks to reconstruct "iconographic modules," as well as the "intricate networks of microscopic relations that every artistic product, even the most basic, presumes." For the author, this is the path towards a "social history of artistic expression" (2010:19).32
Returning to the theme of urban life, seen from the viewpoint of anthropological theory, brings us to another extensive series of works. In Antropologia da Cidade, Michel Agier produces a summary of the area, listing its vast repertoire of traditions, especially those originating in the so-called Chicago and Manchester schools.33 As Graça I. Cordeiro & Heitor Frúgoli Jr. emphasize in their foreword, the city that emerges from Agier's book is not a "theoretical abstraction," but a "relational and situational city" in which the creative dimension of its inhabitants is valued through ethnographic investigation. Seen in this light, we can recall the exemplary monographies of Whyte (2005) and Mitchell (2010) - studies that still influence urban anthropologists today.34 In Brazil urban anthropology developed in São Paulo through the work of Ruth Cardoso and Eunice Durham. In Rio de Janeiro the same development took place in the 1970s, principally through the work of Gilberto Velho and his students. Velho's work also formed the basis for a productive dialogue between urban studies carried out in Brazil and Portugal. From the generation of former students of Ruth Cardoso at USP, we can also highlight the work of Guilherme Magnani, founder of the Urban Anthropology Nucleus (NAU).35
It is also worth recalling Velho's text in the introduction to Antropologia urbana: Cultura e sociedade no Brasil e em Portugal, where he restates his concern to avoid "reifying the urban," with the risk of isolating it from its "socio-historical and cultural contexts." Urban anthropology, says Velho, is not only "the research that anthropologists undertake in cities." It also includes the investigation of broader ideological frameworks resulting from sociocultural diversity and complexity, as shown by Simmel, Park and Barth, among others.
Here I wish to emphasize just one of the themes raised by urban research and identified by Velho: the question of the city's moral regions, natural areas and social maps. This aspect is also explored in the article by Cordeiro & Costa (1999) about Lisbon's Bica and Alfama districts. By showing the intricate narratives of these localities, the authors reveal a complex "field of possibilities" in which individuals relate "in diverse ways with the different kinds of living conditions in which they are inserted," circulating "between social spheres and universes of meaning." In this way, they go about constructing their "everyday practices, their life projects and their frameworks of value." Analyzing the disputes surrounding these urban districts, the authors show "a variety of mythographs, images and narratives […] that each city chooses to adorn." Adopting much the same approach, Castro (1999) shows us, through the transformation of cartographic representations of Rio de Janeiro, different forms in which the tourist experiences the city, constructed from "narratives and images that very often clash and vie with each other," as if in distinct "provinces of meaning," in Alfred Schutz's terms.
I conclude this theoretical-bibliographic journey by returning to the theme of "drawing the city" and the words of Saul Steinberg, summarizing many of the points discussed here through his recollections of drawing New York's streets:
In 1950, I did drawings more or less from life of American landscapes, streets in America, things by now vanished. No one at the time took an interest on those things; American painters were looking for places, corners, that look like "real painting"; even on Main Street they looked for a little bit of English painting or something out of Rembrandt or Vermeer. There were a number of painters in New York — Reginald Marsh, for example — who look for Hogarths or Rubenses on 14th Street. (Steinberg 2002:74)
As I have described over the course of this text, the proposed research will employ an interdisciplinary approach, involving sources and knowledge from areas like anthropology, history, the arts, sociology and so on. The dialogue between these traditions leads to a deeper understanding of the actions, beliefs and values present in urban life.
However anthropological theory will comprise the central axis of the investigation. This implies a constant effort to reflect on our own representations, exploring to the limits the process of denaturalizing the linguistic and visual concepts involved. It also means taking ethnographic reflection as the main theoretical tool, both in the fieldwork itself, and in the investigation of sources and archives.36
For all these reasons, I conclude this text with a small autobiographical note: I was a student in the PUC-Rio Industrial Design course for a number of terms, and was also a student at the Parque Lage School of Visual Arts (Escola de Artes Visuais: EAV), where I took a course in observational drawing, run by Professor Manoel Fernandes, between March 2008 and March 2009. Since then I have frequented open drawing courses in places like the Botanical School and the EAV itself.37 In July 2011 I took part as a student in the II International Urban Sketching Symposium, in Lisbon, where workshops and lectures were given by more than thirty teachers who came from every continent.38 The experience played a decisive role in leading me to the present research theme since, beyond the explicit aims of teaching and encouraging the production of drawings, the Symposium generated a wide-ranging debate on the role of drawing in urban life. So I end this text by pressing the "pause" button. The research is just beginning.
Bibliography | Sources and readings Drawing | Sources and bibliography
Almeida, Cézar de; BASSETTO, Roger. 2010. Sketchbooks - As páginas desconhecidas do processo criativo. São Paulo: POP. [ Links ]
Brito, Joaquim Pais de (org.). 2009. Desenhar para ver. Catálogo da exposição "Desenhar para ver: o encontro de Bárbara Assis Pacheco com as galerias da Amazónia". Lisboa: Museu Nacional de Etnologia. [ Links ]
Caffé, Carla. 1991-1994. "Cidade nua" (Coluna semanal de desenhos da cidade). Folha de São Paulo, Revista da Folha. [ Links ]
Caffé, Carla. 2009. Av. Paulista (Coleção Ópera Urbana). São Paulo: Cosac & Naify; SESC-SP. [ Links ]
Caruso, Eliana (org.). 2009. 2º Festival Internacional de Humor do Rio de Janeiro: A arte de desdesenhar. Rio de Janeiro: Ministério da Cultura. [ Links ]
Cavalcante, Nathalia Sá. 2010. Ilustração: uma prática passível de teorização. Tese de doutorado, Departamento de Artes e Design, Rio de Janeiro, PUC-Rio. [ Links ]
Chipp, Herschel Browning. 1988. Teorias da arte moderna. São Paulo: Martins Fontes. [ Links ]
Debret, Jean-Baptiste. 2006. Caderno de viagem. Julio Bandeira (org.). Rio de Janeiro: Sextante. [ Links ]
Edwards, Betty. 2005. Desenhando com o lado direito do cérebro. Rio de Janeiro: Ediouro. [ Links ]
Eisner, Will. 1999. Quadrinhos e a arte sequencial. Rio de Janeiro: Martins Fontes. [ Links ]
Eisner, Will. 2006. New York: life in the big city. New York: W. W. Norton & Company. [ Links ] FRUZZETTI, Lina; ÖSTÖR, Ákos. 2007. Arte e performance das mulheres de Naya. Lisboa: Museu Nacional de Etnologia. [ Links ]
Johnson, Cathy. 2011. Artist's journal workshop: creating your life in words and pictures. New York: North Light Books. [ Links ]
Garner, Steve. 2008. Writing on drawing: essays on drawing practice and research. Chicago: Intellect; University of Chicago Press. [ Links ]
Gomes, Luiz Vidal Negreiros. 1996. Desenhismo. Santa Maria: Ed. Universidade Federal de Santa Maria. [ Links ]
Gonbrich, Ernst. 1999. A história da arte. Rio de Janeiro: LTC. [ Links ]
Gonbrich, Ernst. 1995. Arte e ilusão: um estudo da psicologia da representação pictórica. Rio de Janeiro: Martins Fontes. [ Links ]
Gonçalves, António Jorge. 2010. Subway life / Vida subterrânea. Lisboa: Assírio e Alvim. [ Links ]
Gregory, Danny. 2003. Everyday matters: a memoir. New York: Hyperion. [ Links ]
Gregory, Danny. 2006. The creative license: giving yourself permission to be the artist you truly are. New York: Hyperion. [ Links ]
Gregory, Danny. 2008. An illustrated life: drawing inspiration from the private sketchbooks of artists, illustrators and designers. Cincinnati, Ohio: How Books. [ Links ]
Klee, Paul. 2001. Sobre a arte moderna e outros ensaios. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Korzenik, Diana. 1985. Drawn to art: a nineteenth-century american dream. Hanover/London: University Press of New England. [ Links ]
Loredano, Cássio (org.); VENTURA, Zuenir (texto). 1998. O Rio de J. Carlos. Rio de Janeiro: Lacerda. [ Links ]
Loredano, Cássio. 2002. O bonde e a linha: um perfil de J. Carlos. São Paulo: Capivara. [ Links ]
Lustosa, Isabel (org.). 2011. Imprensa, humor e caricatura: a questão dos estereótipos culturais. Belo Horizonte: UFMG (Humanitas). [ Links ]
Matisse, Henri. 2007. Matisse: escritos e reflexões sobre arte. Dominique Fourcade (org.) São Paulo: Cosac & Naify. [ Links ]
Michel, Albin. 2001. Rio de Janeiro: les carnets de voyages de Jano. Paris: Sefam. [ Links ]
Rosengarten, Ruth. 2011. "Passing by, stopping, walking on: urban sketching in context". II International Urban Sketching Symposium. Lisboa. Download at http://ruthrosengarten.blogspot.com/2011/07/passing-by-stopping-walking-on-urban.html [ Links ]
Salavisa, Eduardo (coord.) 2008. Diários de viagem: desenhos do quotidiano – 35 autores contemporâneos. Lisboa: Quimera. [ Links ]
Salavisa, Eduardo (coord.) 2010a. Diário de viagem em Lisboa. Edição Bilíngüe. Lisboa: Quimera. [ Links ]
Salavisa, Eduardo . 2010b. Diário de viagem em Cabo Verde. Edição Bilíngüe. Lisboa: Quimera. [ Links ]
Salavisa, Eduardo (coord.) 2011. Diários gráficos em Almada – "Não somos desenhadores perfeitos". Almada: Câmara Municipal/ Museu da Cidade. [ Links ]
Simioni, Ana Paula Cavalcanti. 2002. Di Cavalcanti ilustrador: trajetória de um jovem artista gráfico na imprensa (1914-1922). São Paulo: Sumaré [ Links ].
Steel, Liz. 2010. From my sketchbooks. Impresso por Blurb.com. [ Links ]
Steinberg, Saul. 2002. Reflections and shadows. (Aldo Buzzi). London: Allen Lane. [ Links ]
Van gogh, Vincent. 1882. Van Gogh letters. Available at http://vangoghletters.org/vg/letters/let274/letter.html [ Links ]
Wilde, Oscar. 1889. "The decay of lying: an observation". Available at http://www. mnstate.edu/gracyk/courses/philofart/wildetext.htm. [ Links ]
Rio de Janeiro39 | Sources and bibliography
Abreu, Maurício. 1987. A evolução urbana no Rio de Janeiro. Rio de Janeiro: Instituto Pereira Passos. [ Links ]
Castro, Celso. 1999. "Narrativas e imagens do turismo no Rio de Janeiro". In: Gilberto Velho (org.), Antropologia urbana. Cultura e sociedade no Brasil e em Portugal. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. pp. 80-87. [ Links ]
Castro, Celso. 2000. "Uma viagem pelos mapas do Rio". In: Jorge Czajkowski (org.), Do cosmógrafo ao satélite. Mapas da cidade do Rio de Janeiro. Rio de Janeiro: Banco do Brasil/Prefeitura do Rio. pp. 8-15. [ Links ]
Castro, Celso. 2006. "Destino: Rio de Janeiro". Nossa História (São Paulo), 1(28): 70-75. [ Links ]
Ermakoff, George. 2011. A paisagem do Rio de Janeiro: aquarelas, desenhos e gravuras dos artistas viajantes (1790-1890). Rio de Janeiro: G. Ermakoff. [ Links ]
Ferreira, Marieta. 2000. Rio de Janeiro: uma cidade na história. Rio de Janeiro: FGV. [ Links ]
Freitag, Bárbara. 2009. Capitais migrantes e poderes peregrinos: o caso do Rio de Janeiro. Campinas: Papirus. [ Links ]
Gerodetti, João Emílio; CORNEJO, Carlos. 2004. "Rio de Janeiro". In: Lembranças do Brasil: as capitais brasileiras nos cartões-postais e álbuns de lembranças. São Paulo: Solaris Edições Culturais. pp. 14-39. [ Links ]
Goslin, Priscilla Ann; CARNEIRO, Carlos. 2010. How to be a carioca: the alternative guide for the tourist in Rio. Rio de Janeiro: TwoCan (3a edição). [ Links ]
Medeiros, Bianca Freire; CASTRO, Celso. 2007. "A cidade e seus souvenires: o Rio de Janeiro para turista ter". Revista Brasileira de Pesquisa em Turismo, 1(1): 34-53. [ Links ]
Oliveira, Márcio Piñon; FERNANDES, Nelson Nóbrega. 2010. 150 anos de subúrbio carioca. Rio de Janeiro: Lamparina, Faperj, EdUFF. [ Links ]
Pinheiro, Ivan de Freitas (org.) 2010. Rio de Janeiro: cinco séculos de história e transformações urbanas. Rio de Janeiro: Casa da Palavra. [ Links ]
Rebelo, Marques. 2007. Guia antiturístico do Rio de Janeiro (com ilustrações de Jaguar e prefácio de Millôr). Rio de Janeiro: Desiderata, Batel. [ Links ]
Sandroni, Luciana. 2010. História do Rio de Janeiro através da arte. Rio de Janeiro: Pinakotheke. [ Links ]
Anthropology, Social Sciences and History | Bibliography
Agier, Michel. 2011. Antropologia da cidade: lugares, situações, movimentos. (Prefácio à edição brasileira de Graças Índias Cordeiro e Heitor Frúgoli Jr. Coleção Antropologia Hoje.) São Paulo: Terceiro Nome. [ Links ]
Amin, Ash; THRIF, Nigel. 2002. Cities. Reimagining the urban. Cambridge: Polity Press. [ Links ]
Augé, Marc. 1997. Por uma antropologia dos mundos contemporâneos. Rio de Janeiro: Bertrand Brasil. [ Links ]
Bakhtin, Mikhail M. 1987. A cultura popular na Idade Média e no Renascimento: o contexto de François Rabelais. São Paulo: Hucitec/Edusp; Brasília: UnB. [ Links ]
Barbosa, Andréa; CUNHA, Edgar Teodoro da; HIKIJI, Rose Satiko Gitirana (orgs.). 2009. Imagem-conhecimento: antropologia, cinema e outros diálogos. Campinas: Papirus. [ Links ]
Barth, Fredrik. 2000. "A análise da cultura em sociedades complexas". In: O guru, o iniciador e outras variações antropológicas. Rio de Janeiro: Contra Capa. pp. 107-139. [ Links ]
Barthes, Roland. 1990. "A mensagem fotográfica". In: T. Adorno et alii. Teoria da comunicação de massa. Rio de Janeiro: Paz e Terra. 3a. ed. pp. 299-316. [ Links ]
Becker, Howard S.1982. Art worlds. Berkeley-Los Angeles-London: University of California Press. [ Links ]
Becker, Howard S.1999. Métodos de pesquisa em ciências sociais. São Paulo: Hucitec. [ Links ]
Becker, Howard S.2007. Segredos e truques da pesquisa. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Becker, Howard S.2009. Falando da sociedade. Ensaios sobre as diferentes maneiras de representar o social. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Bott, Elizabeth. 1976. Família e rede social: papéis, normas e relacionamentos externos em famílias urbanas comuns. Rio de Janeiro: Francisco Alves. [ Links ]
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1996a. "A ilusão biográfica". In: M. Ferreira; J. Amado (orgs.), Usos & abusos da história oral. Rio de Janeiro: FGV. pp. 183-91. [ Links ]
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1996b. As regras da arte: gênese e estrutura do campo literário. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras. [ Links ]
Cardoso, Ruth. 1986. A aventura antropológica: teoria e pesquisa. Rio de Janeiro: Paz e Terra. [ Links ]
Cavalcanti, Maria Laura V. C. 2006. Carnaval carioca: dos bastidores ao desfile. Rio de Janeiro: UFRJ (2ª edição). [ Links ]
Cavalcanti, Mariana. 2010. "Sem morro, varandão, salão, 3dorms: a construção social do valor em mercados imobiliários 'limiares'". In: "Dossiê: cidade, teoria, etnografia". Antropolítica, 28: 19-46. [ Links ]
Castro, Celso. 2008. Pesquisando em arquivos. (Coleção Passo-a-Passo) Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Certeau, Michel de. 2000. A invenção do cotidiano. Artes do fazer. vol. 1. Rio de Janeiro: Vozes. [ Links ]
Cordeiro, Graça Índias. 1997. Um lugar na cidade: quotidiano, memória e representação no bairro da Bica. Lisboa: D. Quixote. [ Links ]
Cordeiro, Graça Índias. 2003. "A antropologia urbana entre a tradição e a prática". In: G. Cordeiro; L. V. Baptista; A. F. Costa (orgs), Etnografias urbanas. Oeiras: Celta. pp. 3-34. [ Links ]
Cordeiro, Graça Índias; COSTA, António Firmino da. 1999. "Bairros, contexto e intersecção". In: G. Velho(org.), Antropologia urbana: cultura e sociedade no Brasil e em Portugal. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. pp. 58-79. [ Links ]
Costa, António Firmino. 2003. "Estilos de sociabilidade". In: G. Cordeiro; L. V. Baptista; A. F. Costa (orgs), Etnografias urbanas. Oeiras: Celta. pp. 121-31. [ Links ]
Dabul, Lígia. 2001. Um percurso da pintura: a produção de identidades de artista. Niterói: EdUFF. [ Links ]
Darnton, Robert. 1986. "Um burguês organiza seu mundo: a cidade como texto". In: O grande massacre de gatos e outros episódios da história cultural francesa. Rio de Janeiro: Graal. pp. 141-90. [ Links ]
Darnton, Robert. 1990. "História e antropologia". In: O beijo de Lamourette. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras. pp. 284-303. [ Links ]
Duarte, Luiz Fernando. 2010. "O campo atual da antropologia no Brasil". In: L. F. D. Duarte (org.), Horizontes das ciências sociais no Brasil: antropologia. São Paulo: Anpocs/Barcarolla/Discurso Editorial/ICH. pp. 13-23. [ Links ]
Duarte, Luiz Fernando; velho, Gilberto (orgs.) 2010. Culturas, gostos e carreiras na juventude contemporânea. Rio de Janeiro: 7Letras. [ Links ]
Durham, Eunice. 1973. A caminho da cidade. São Paulo: Perspectiva. [ Links ]
Durham, Eunice; cardoso, Ruth. 1973. "A investigação antropológica em áreas urbanas". Revista de Cultura Vozes, LXVII(2): 49-54. [ Links ]
Eckert, Cornélia. 2010. "Cidade e política: nas trilhas de uma antropologia da e na cidade no Brasil". In: Luiz Fernando Duarte (org.), Horizontes das ciências sociais no Brasil: antropologia. São Paulo: Anpocs/Barcarolla/Discurso Editorial/ICH. pp. 155-196. [ Links ]
Eckert, Cornélia; rocha, Ana Luiza C. 2005. O tempo e a cidade. Porto Alegre: Editora da Universidade. [ Links ]
El FAR, Alessandra. 2004. Páginas de sensação - Literatura popular e pornográfica no Rio de Janeiro (1870-1924). São Paulo: Companhia das Letras. [ Links ]
Elias, Norbert e scotson, John L. 2000. Os estabelecidos e os outsiders. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Eepstein, A. L. "The network and urban social organization". In: C. Mitchell (org.), Social networks in urban situations. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1969. pp. 117-127. [ Links ]
Feldman-bianco, Bela (org.) 2010. Antropologia das sociedades contemporâneas: métodos. São Paulo: Unesp (2ª edição). [ Links ]
Fortuna, Carlos e leite, Rogério Proença (orgs.). 2009. Plural de cidade: novos léxicos urbanos. Coimbra: Almedina/ CES. [ Links ]
Fox, Richard. 1977. Urban anthropology. Cities in their cultural settings. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall. [ Links ]
Frehse, Fraya e LEITE, Rogério Proença. 2010. "Espaço urbano no Brasil". In: Martins et alli (orgs.), Horizontes das ciências sociais: sociologia. São Paulo: Anpocs/Barcarolla/Discurso Editorial/ICH. pp. 203-51. [ Links ]
Freyre, Gilberto. 1933. Casa grande e senzala: formação da família brasileira sob o regime da economia patriarcal. Rio de Janeiro: José Olimpio. [ Links ]
Freyre, Gilberto. 1936. Sobrados e mucambos: decadência do patriarcado rural e desenvolvimento urbano. Rio de Janeiro: José Olimpio. [ Links ]
Frúgoli jr., Heitor. 2006. "Introdução – Inspirações iniciais: cidade moderna, modernista e 'pós-moderna'". In: Centralidade em São Paulo. São Paulo: Eudsp. pp. 19-24. [ Links ]
Frúgoli jr., Heitor. 2007. Sociabilidade urbana. (Coleção Passo-a-Passo). Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Frúgoli jr., Heitor; andrade, Luciana T.; peixoto, Fernanda A. (orgs.) 2006. As cidades e seus agentes: práticas e representações. São Paulo: PUC-Minas/Edusp. [ Links ]
Gans, Herbert J. 1962. The urban villagers: group and class in life of italian americans. New York: The Free Press. [ Links ]
Geertz, Clifford. 1997. "Como pensamos hoje: a caminho de uma etnografia do pensamento moderno". In: O saber local – novos ensaios em antropologia interpretativa. Petrópolis: Vozes. pp. 220-45. [ Links ]
Geertz, Clifford. 2001. Nova luz sobre a antropologia. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Giner, Josepa Cucó. 2004. "La naturaleza de la antropologia urbana". In: Antropologia urbana. Barcelona: Ariel. pp. 15-43. [ Links ]
Ginzburg, Carlo. 1989. Mitos, emblemas e sinais. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras. [ Links ]
Ginzburg, Carlo. 2010. Investigando Piero: o batismo, o ciclo de Arezzo, a flagelação de Urbino. São Paulo: Cosac & Naify. [ Links ]
Gluckman, Max. 1987. 2010. "Análise de uma situação social na Zululândia moderna". In: Bela Feldman-Bianco (org.), Antropologia das sociedades contemporâneas: métodos. São Paulo: Unesp. (2ª edição). pp. 227-344. [ Links ]
Gmelch, George; zenner, Walter P. (orgs.) 2002. "Urban fieldwork: anthropologists in cities". In: Urban life: readings in the anthropology of the city. Long Grove, Il.: Waveland. pp. 127-186. [ Links ]
Goffman, Erving. 1975 . A representação do eu na vida cotidiana. Petrópolis: Vozes. [ Links ]
Gomes, Laura Graziela; FRÚGOLI Jr., Heitor. 2010. "Apresentação". In: "Dossiê: cidade, teoria, etnografia". Antropolítica, 28: 11-18. [ Links ]
Gonçalves, Marco Antônio. 2008. O real imaginado – etnografia, cinema e surrealismo em Jean Rouch. Rio de Janeiro: Top Books. [ Links ]
Griner, Arbel. 2010. A estética da ética: uma análise do cinema documentário de Eduardo Coutinho, Eduardo Escorel. Dissertação de mestrado, PPGSA/IFCS/UFRJ. [ Links ]
Gutwirth, Jaqcues. 2007-2010. L'anthropologie urbaine en France: un regard rétrospectif , HAL – Sciences de L'Homme e de la Société (Download at: http://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00267536/fr/). [ Links ]
Hannerz, Ulf. 1980. Exploring the city: inquiries toward an urban anthropology. New York: Columbia University Press. [ Links ]
Hughes, Everett C. 1993. "The cultural aspects of urban research". In: The sociological eye. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers. pp. 106-17. [ Links ]
Ingold, Tim. 2007. Lines. London: Routledge. [ Links ]
Jankowski, Martin Sanchez. 1991. Islands in the street: gangs and american urban society. Berkeley: University of California Press. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina. 1993. "Bakhtin, Ginzburg e a cultura popular". Cadernos de Campo, 3: 76-88. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina. 1999. "Política, cultura e espaço urbano". In: G. Velho (org.), Antropologia urbana: cultura e sociedade no Brasil e em Portugal. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar. pp. 88-97. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina. 2000a. Eleições e representação no Rio de Janeiro. Rio de Janeiro: Relume-Dumará/NuAP (Coleção Antropologia da Política). [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina. 2000b. O cotidiano da política. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar (Coleção Antropologia Social). [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina. 2001. "Trajetória, projeto e mediação na política". In:G. Velho; K. Kuschnir (orgs.), Mediação, cultura e política. Rio de Janeiro: Aeroplano. pp. 137-64. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina. 2003a. "Política e comunicação de massa", Interseções, 5(2): 375-388. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina. 2003b. "Uma pesquisadora na metrópole: identidade e socialização no mundo da política". In: G. Velho; K. Kuschnir (orgs.), Pesquisas urbanas: desafios do trabalho antropológico. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. pp. 20-42. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina. 2008a. "Maternidade e amamentação: biografia e relações de gênero intergeracionais". Sociologia, problemas e práticas, 56, Lisboa: 85-103. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina. 2008b. "Cinema documentário e antropologia: a experiência com Vocação do Poder". In: Quando o campo é o arquivo (de imagens). Rio de Janeiro, Evento CPDOC/FGV – PPGAS/MN/UFRJ. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina; ALKMIM, Antônio C. 2001. "Mapas eleitorais fluminenses". In: Américo Freire; Carlos Eduardo Sarmento; Marly Motta (orgs.), Um estado em questão: os 25 anos do estado do Rio de Janeiro. Rio de Janeiro: FGV. pp. 103-13. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina; CARNEIRO, Leandro Piquet; SCHMITT, Rogério. 1998. "A campanha eleitoral na TV em eleições locais: estratégias e resultados". In: Irlys Barreira; Moacir Palmeira (orgs.), Candidatos e candidaturas: enredos da campanha eleitoral no Brasil. São Paulo: Annablume. pp. 58-90. [ Links ]
Kuschnir, Karina; CARNEIRO, Leandro Piquet; SCHMITT, Rogério. 1999. "Estratégias de campanha no Horário Gratuito de Propaganda Eleitoral em eleições proporcionais". Dados - Revista de Ciências Sociais, 42(2): 277-301. [ Links ]
Lagrou, Els. 2002. "O que nos diz a arte kaxinawa sobre a relação entre identidade e alteridade?". Mana. Estudos de Antropologia Social, 8(1): pp. 29-61 [ Links ]
Lagrou, Els. 2007. A fluidez da forma. Arte, alteridade e agência em uma sociedade amazônica (Kaxinawa, Acre). Rio de Janeiro: Topbooks. [ Links ]
Lagrou, Els. 2009. Arte indígena brasileira. Belo Horizonte: ComArte. [ Links ]
Le goff, Jacques. 1998. Por amor às cidades. São Paulo: Unesp. [ Links ]
Leach, Edmund R. 1982. "O meu tipo de antropologia". In: A diversidade da antropologia. Lisboa: Edições 70. pp. 117-141. [ Links ]
Lima, Antónia Pedroso; SARRÓ, Ramon (orgs.). 2006. Terrenos metropolitanos: ensaios sobre produção etnográfica. Lisboa: Imprensa de Ciências Sociais. [ Links ]
Low, Setha M. 2005. "Introduction: theorizing the city". In: Setha M. Low (ed.), Theorizing the city: the new urban anthropology reader. NB: Rutgers University Press. pp. 1-33. [ Links ]
Machado pais, José. 2009. Sociologia da vida quotidiana. Teorias, métodos e estudos de caso. Lisboa: Imprensa de Ciências Sociais. 4ª edição. [ Links ]
Magnani, José Guilherme Cantor. 1984. Festa no pedaço: lazer e cultura popular na cidade. São Paulo: Brasiliense. [ Links ]
Magnani, José Guilherme Cantor. 2000. "Quando o campo é a cidade: fazendo antropologia na metrópole". In: José G. C. Magnani; Lilian Torres (orgs.), Na metrópole: textos de antropologia urbana. São Paulo: Edusp. pp. 12-53. [ Links ]
Magnani, José Guilherme Cantor. 2002. "De perto e de dentro: notas para uma etnografia urbana". Revista Brasileira de Ciências Sociais, 17(49): 11-29 [ Links ]
Magnani, José Guilherme Cantor. 2003. "Antropologia urbana e os desafios da metrópole". Aula inaugural do curso de Ciências Sociais da FFLCH/USP, março. Download at http://www.n-a-u.org/AntropologiaUrbanadesafiosmetropole.html. [ Links ]
Malinowski, Bronislaw. 1978. "Introdução". In: Argonautas do Pacífico Ocidental: um relato do empreendimento e da aventura dos nativos nos arquipélagos da Nova Guiné Melanésia. Rio de Janeiro: Abril Cultural, Col. Os Pensadores. pp. 17-34. [ Links ]
Mayer, Adrian C. 2010. "A importância dos 'quase-grupos' no estudo das sociedades complexas". In: Bela Feldman-Bianco (org.), Antropologia das sociedades contemporâneas: métodos. São Paulo: Unesp. 2ª edição. pp. 139-170 [ Links ]
Mitchell, Clyde (org.) 1969 "The concept and use of social network". In: Social networks in urban situations. Manchester: Manchester University Press. pp. 1-50. [ Links ]
Mitchell, Clyd. 2010. "A Dança Kalela: aspectos das relações sociais entre africanos urbanizados na Rodésia do Norte". In: Bela Feldman-Bianco (org.), Antropologia das sociedades contemporâneas: métodos. São Paulo: Unesp. 2ª edição. pp. 365-436. [ Links ]
Moura, Cristina Patriota. 2003. Ilhas urbanas: novas visões do paraíso. Tese de Doutorado, PPGAS, Museu Nacional, UFRJ. [ Links ]
Moura, Cristina Patriota. 2010. "Condomínios horizontais em Brasília: elementos e composições". In: "Dossiê: cidade, teoria, etnografia". Antropolítica, 28: 47-68. [ Links ]
Novaes, Sylvia Caiuby. 2010. "O Brasil em imagens: caminhos que antecedem e marcam a antropologia visual no Brasil". In: Luiz Fernando Dias Duarte (org.), Horizontes das ciências sociais no Brasil: Antropologia. São Paulo: Anpocs/Barcarolla/Discurso Editorial/ICH. v. 1. pp. 457-487. [ Links ]
O'donnell, Julia. 2008. De olho na rua: a cidade de João do Rio. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
O'donnell, Julia. 2011. Um Rio Atlântico: culturas urbanas e estilos de vida na invenção de Copacabana. Rio de Janeiro, PPGAS/MN/UFRJ (Tese de doutorado). [ Links ]
Oliven, Ruben George. 1980. "Por uma antropologia em cidades brasileiras". In: Gilberto Velho (org.), O desafio da cidade. Rio de Janeiro: Campus. pp. 23-36. [ Links ]
Oliven, Ruben George. 1985. A antropologia dos grupos urbanos. Petrópolis: Vozes. [ Links ]
Park, Robert E. 1967 . "A cidade: sugestões para a investigação do comportamento humano no meio urbano". In: Otávio G. Velho (org.). O fenômeno urbano. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar. pp. 29-72. [ Links ]
Peirano, Mariza. 2006. A teoria vivida. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Peixoto, Clarice Ehlers. 1999. "Antropologia e filme etnográfico: um travelling no cenário literário da antropologia visual". BIB. Revista Brasileira de Informação Bibliográfica em Ciências Sociais, 48: 91-116. [ Links ]
Peixoto, Fernanda Áreas. 2006. "As cidades nas narrativas sobre o Brasil". In: Heitor Frugoli; Luciana T. Andrade; Fernanda A. Peixoto (orgs.), A cidade e seus agentes: práticas e representações. Belo Horizonte: Edusp/Puc-Minas. pp. 177-197. [ Links ]
Ribeiro, Luiz César Queirós e KOSLINSKI, Mariana C. 2009. "A cidade contra a escola? O caso do município do RJ". Revista Contemporânea de Educação, 4: 351-78. [ Links ]
Rocha, Ana Luiza C.; ECKERT, Cornelia (orgs.). 2005. O tempo e a cidade. Porto Alegre: Ed. UFRGS. [ Links ]
Rogers, Alisdair; VERTOVEC, Steven (orgs.). 1995. The urban context. Ethnicity, social networks and situational analysis. Oxford: Berg. [ Links ]
Sahlins, Marshall. 1997. "O 'pessimismo sentimental' e a experiência etnográfica: por que a cultura não é um 'objeto' em vias de extinção (Partes I e II)". Mana. Estudos de Antropologia Social, 3(1):41-73 and 3(2):103-150 [ Links ]
Sanjek, Roger. 1990. "Urban anthropology in the 1980s: a world view". Annual Review of Anthropology, 19: 151-186. [ Links ]
Santos, Carlos Nelson Ferreira dos. 1981. Movimentos urbanos no Rio de Janeiro.Rio de Janeiro: Zahar. [ Links ]
Simmel, Georg. 1978 . "The style of life". In: The philosophy of money. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. cap. 6. pp. 429-512. [ Links ]
Simmel, Georg. 1967 . "A metrópole e a vida mental". In: Otávio G. Velho (org.), O fenômeno urbano. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar. pp. 13-28. [ Links ]
Simmel, Georg. 1971 . "Group expansion and the development of individuality". In: On individuality and social forms. Donald N. Levine (ed.), Chicago/London: The University of Chicago Press. pp. 251-293. [ Links ]
Simmel, Georg. 2006. Questões fundamentais da sociologia: indivíduo e sociedade. Celso Castro (org.) Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Van velsen, J. 2010. "A análise situacional e o método de estudo de caso detalhado". In: Bela Feldman-Bianco (org.), Antropologia das sociedades contemporâneas: métodos. São Paulo: Unesp (2ª edição). pp. 437-468. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. 1973. A utopia urbana: um estudo de antropologia social. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. (org.) 1980. O desafio da cidade. Rio de Janeiro: Campus. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. 1981. Individualismo e cultura: notas para uma antropologia da sociedade contemporânea. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. 1994. Projeto e metamorfose. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. 1995. "Estilo de vida urbano e modernidade". Estudos Históricos, 8(16): 227-234. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. (org.). 1999. Antropologia urbana: cultura e sociedade no Brasil e em Portugal. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. 2003. "Continuidades e inovações na antropologia portuguesa: cidade e diversidade". In: Graça Índias Cordeiro; Luís Vicente Baptista e António Firmino Costa (orgs), Etnografias urbanas. Oeiras: Celta. pp. 207-211. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. (org.). 2008. Rio de Janeiro: cultura, política e conflito. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. ; KUSCHNIR, Karina (orgs.) 2001. Mediação, cultura e política.Rio de Janeiro: Aeroplano. [ Links ]
Velho, Gilberto. ; KUSCHNIR, Karina (orgs.) 2003. Pesquisas urbanas.Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
velho, Otávio G. (org.) 1967. O fenômeno urbano. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar. [ Links ]
Vianna, Hermano. 1988. O mundo funk carioca. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar. [ Links ]
Vianna, Hermano. 1997. Galeras cariocas: territórios de conflitos e encontros culturais. Rio de Janeiro: UFRJ. [ Links ]
Villas bôas, Glaucia K. 2008. "O ateliê do Engenho de Dentro como espaço de conversão (1946 - 1951)". In: André Botelho; Elide Bastos, Glaucia Villas-Bôas (orgs.), O moderno em questão: a década de 1950 no Brasil. Rio de Janeiro: Topbooks. pp. 137-167. [ Links ]
Whyte, William Foote. 2005 . Sociedade de esquina. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar Editor. [ Links ]
Wirth, Louis. 1967 . "O urbanismo como modo de vida". In: Otávio G Velho. (org.), O fenômeno urbano. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar. pp. 97-122. [ Links ]
Zaluar, Alba. 1985. A máquina e a revolta: as organizações populares e o significado da pobreza.Rio de Janeiro: Brasiliense. [ Links ]
About the author
Karina Kuschnir received her MA (1993) and Ph.D. (1998) in Social Anthropology from the Museu Nacional, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro. She is assistant professor at the Department of Cultural Anthropology and the Postgraduate Program in Sociology and Anthropology (PPGSA) of IFCS/UFRJ, where she coordinates the Laboratory of Urban Anthropology (LAU). She is a research productivity award holder from CNPq and was a FAPERJ's Young Scientist in the Our State program. Among other books, she is the author of Antropologia da Política (Zahar 2007) and O cotidiano da política (Zahar 2000) and co-editor with Gilberto Velho of Pesquisas urbanas: desafios do trabalho antropológico (Zahar 2003).
*All the images illustrating this text can be seen at www.desenhandoacidade.wordpress.com. The use of small inserted images is inspired by the cover of Gregory 2008 and merely serves to remind the reader to consult the original online. I would like to thank Juva Batella (without his support, I would not have gone to USK-Lisbon; and for the revision of the original texts in Portuguese), Gilberto Velho (for the encouragement and for the suggestions for this version), Andréa Barros, Arbel Griner and Vera Herrmann (for their readings and lively comments) and Daphne Kuschnir (for essential images at the last moment).
1. All the quotations in this paragraph are from Brito 2009, pages 4 and 5. On the origin and plurality of meanings of the word "desenhar" [draw], see Gomes 1996.
2. Detailed information on USK, its history and events, can be found at www.urbansketchers.org. I should immediately point out that in the text I make recurrent use of some terms typical to the universe of blogs clearly familiar to readers: online, post, link, site, blogger, etc.
3. Available at http://www.urbansketchers.org/p/about-usk.html.
4. Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary (software), Cambridge University Press, v. 1, 2003.
5. This and later citations from Teresa Carneiro are taken from her text "Desenhar o olhar sobre o mundo" [Drawing the gaze onto the world], published in Salavisa (2011).
6. His three main books are cited in the bibliography. Gregory was also the creator and moderator of an online discussion group that was founded in 2004, which now has more than 4,000 members and is hosted on the Yahoo Groups site (http://groups.yahoo.com/group/everydaymatters/). Since 2010, his blog has become more like a website and can be found at www.dannygregory.com. As well as these web addresses, there are various others related to Gregory, with groups on Flickr, Facebook etc.
7. A reference to the concept of a ""graphic novel""– an established term for books of sequential art with denser themes aimed at adults that do not fit into the category of ""comics.""About these terms, see chapter 7 of Comics and Sequential Art by Will Eisner (1985; translated into Portuguese as Quadrinhos e a arte sequencial, 1999).
8. Gregory (2003:13).
9. The quotes are from Reflections and Shadows, Steinberg (2002:70).
10. The passage from Berger (2005) is cited by Teresa Carneiro in Salavisa (2011).
11. Published in the section ""About us" "on the blog Urban Sketchers, available at http://www.urbansketchers.org/p/about-usk.html.
12. All the links to the blogs of the cited lecturers can be found at http://symposium.urbansketchers.org.
13. Gregory (2006:51). The expression "draw with the right-side of the brain" became famous through the title of the book (and the method) of Betty Edwards (2005) and, in brief, means making an observational drawing divested of the intellectually known "concepts" relating to the observed objects. The work is widely cited in books and blogs in the USK universe.
14. Information given by Matthew Brehm in his workshop at the 2nd USK Symposium in Lisbon.
15. Devices presented by António Jorge Gonçalves in his lecture at the 2nd USK Symposium in Lisbon.
16. Eckert (2010:180).
17. My thanks to Alberto Goyena for this precious reading suggestion.
18. Wilde (1889). Available at http://www.mnstate.edu/gracyk/courses/philofart/wildetext.htm.
19. Bourdieu (1986:184-5).
20. Sources here include Bourdieu (1996b), Lagrou (2002, 2007 and 2009), Dabul (2001), Villas Bôas (2008), Novaes (2010), Barbosa, Cunha & Hikiji (2009), Peixoto (1999), Gonçalves (2008), among others.
21. On the world of illustration, see the important work by Cavalcante (2010). In terms of thinking about Rio de Janeiro from an urbanistic, sociological and historical viewpoint, I highlight the works of Santos (1981), Abreu (1987), Ferreira (2000), Freitag (2009), Oliveira & Fernandes (2010) and Pinheiro (2010).
22. Another important work of this kind was published in June 2011, edited by Cathy Johnson (2011) and including the collaboration of several of the sketchers mentioned here.
23. Another example, published in Brazil, are Debret's Cadernos de Viagem from 1816 (in the bibliography, see Debret 2006).
24. These ideas appear in Certeau (2000), cited by Rosengarten (2011). On this topic, we can also pick out Goffman (1975) and Machado Pais (2009), among others.
25. Manoel João Ramos's text is published in Salavisa (2011), pages 152-3. In the future I hope to be able to develop a comparison between this concept of "lived experience" through drawing and that of "lived theory" through ethnography, as proposed by Peirano (2006). Still in the field of anthropological research with graphic art, I would cite the fundamental work of Els Lagrou (2007, 2009) on Amerindian indigenous designs, and that of Fruzzetti & Östör (2007) on art among Naya women in India.
26. "Padaria" (bakery) in São Paulo slang.
27. Interview about the book Avenida Paulista (Caffé 2009) for the site of Editora Cosac & Naify. Available at: http://editora.cosacnaify.com.br/ObraSinopse/10224/Av-Paulista.aspx.
28. The source is the same cited in the previous note. Caffé was also the author of an award-winning column, Cidade Nua [Naked City], with drawings and texts about the city of São Paulo, published in the magazine of the Folha de São Paulo newspaper between 1991 and 1994.
29. See Goslin (2010), Rebelo (2007) and Jano's book in Michel (2001).
30. Compared to the 19th century, the 20th century shows a steady decline in the predominance of drawing in forms of artistic expression. This is an interesting theme that could be explored in the research. On this topic, see the extremely detailed study by Korzenik (1985) on the teaching of drawing in American schools in the 19th and 20th centuries.
31. O'Donnell (2008) coined this concept in her dense analysis of the relation between João do Rio's work and the city of Rio de Janeiro.
32. On other themes in the work of Ginzburg, see Kuschnir (1993). For an in-depth discussion of the relations between anthropology and history, see Darnton (1986 and 1990). I also suggest Le Goff (1998) on art and the city from a historical perspective.
33. As well as Agier's synthesis (2011), heavily inspired by Hannerz (1980), various other edited works and texts look to provide a panorama of anthropological research conducted in cities: Amin (2002), Augé (1997), Fox (1977), Giner (2004), Gmelch (2002), Gutwirth (2010), Low (2005), Rogers (1995) and Sanjek (1990).
34. In the US, under the influence of Simmel (1967, 1971, 1978, 2006), we cannot fail to cite Park (1967), Wirth (1967) and other authors collected in Velho, O. (1967). In the Chicago tradition, I would also highlight the works of Hughes (1993) and Becker (1982, 2007, 2009). There are also the exemplary ethnographies of Gans (1962) and Jankowski (1991). In the English tradition, we can pick out the fundamental collection of Feldman-Bianco (2010), including contributing authors such as Gluckman (2010), Mayer (2010) and Van Velsen (2010). Here I would also cite Epstein (1969), Mitchell (1969), Bott (1976) and Barth (2000). The study by Elias & Scotson (2000) is also an important reference work for understanding 20th century urban life.
35. For works by Gilberto Velho, see the list provided in the bibliography. For works by other Brazilian authors, see Cardoso (1986), Cavalcanti (2006 and 2010), Duarte & Velho (2010), Durham (1973), Durham & Cardoso (1973), Eckert (2010), Eckert & Rocha (2005), Frehse & Leite (2010), Frúgoli Jr. (2006 and 2007), Frúgoli, Andrade & Peixoto (2006), Gomes & Frúgoli Jr. (2010), Kuschnir (2000, 2003), Magnani (1984, 2000, 2002 and 2003), Moura (2003 and 2010), O'Donnell (2008 and 2011), Oliven (1980 and 1985), Peixoto (2006), Vianna (1988 and 1997) and Zaluar (1985). In relation to urban research in Portugal, see Cordeiro (1997 and 2003), Cordeiro & Costa (1999), Costa (2003), Fortuna & Leite (2009) and Lima & Sarró (2006).
36. On methodological questions, see Malinowski (1978), Velho (1981), Becker (1993, 2007), Leach (1982), Sahlins (1997), Geertz (1997 and 2001), Kuschnir (2003), O'Donnell (2008) and Castro (2008).
37. Regarding my work in the audio-visual area, I should also note that I was a professor in the Department of Social Communication at PUC-Rio for sixteen years, where I offered courses with a special focus on discourse analysis, iconography and film narrative. I have worked in research studies on television and political advertising. I was a consultant for the documentary film Vocação do poder (2006, Eduardo Escorel and José Joffily). And in 2007 I was also one of coordinators of the team that developed the project "Social scientists from Portuguese-speaking countries: life histories' – renewed in 2010 under the titles "Audio-visual history of the Social Sciences in the Community of Portuguese Language Countries' (www.fgv.br/cpdoc/cientistassociais).
38. The full program of the event can be found here: http://symposium.urbansketchers.org/.
39. The urban anthropology texts on Rio de Janeiro, such as those of Gilberto Velho and Julia O'Donnell, are listed in the general and theoretical bibliography. Works on Rio de Janeiro, but focused on the artists who drew them, such as those of Loredano, are found in the initial bibliographic section. This small selection of texts on Rio de Janeiro is not intended as a comprehensive overview of the theme, which is indeed vast, as shown by Ferreira (2000) and several of the cited authors.