Breeding methods and history of bean cultivars released in CBAB - Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology

Métodos de melhoramento e histórico de cultivares de feijoeiro lançadas na CBAB - Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology

ARTICLE

Breeding methods and history of bean cultivars released in CBAB - Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology

Métodos de melhoramento e histórico de cultivares de feijoeiro lançadas na CBAB - Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology

Sarah Ola Moreira^I,*; Marcelo G. de Morais Silva^II; Rosana Rodrigues^I; Alexandre Pio Viana^I; Messias Gonzaga Pereira^I

^IUniversidade Estadual do Norte Fluminense Darcy Ribeiro, Laboratório de Melhoramento Genético Vegetal, 28013-602, Campos dos Goytacazes, RJ, Brazil

^IIInstituto Federal do Norte de Minas Gerais, Fazenda São Geraldo, km 06, C.P. 97, 39.480-000, Januária, MG, Brazil

ABSTRACT

Common bean is a staple food of great economic and social importance and breeding programs are being carried out in different institutions in Brazil and abroad. Aiming to determine how many new cultivars were presented in the journal CBAB - Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology and which breeding methods were used to develop the new genotypes, a historical survey of CBAB from 2001 to 2008 was carried out. During this period, 23 new common bean cultivars were described in CBAB, of which all but two that were bred at universities had been developed by public research institutes. The most commonly used breeding method was the pedigree, followed by bulk and the single pod descent (SPD) method. Since the preference of Brazilian consumers for carioca and black grain beans is noticeable, most bean breeders in the country have focused their research on these two bean types.

Key words: Phaseolus vulgaris L., breeding, development of new genotypes.

RESUMO

O feijoeiro comum é um alimento de grande importância econômica e social, sendo objeto de estudo de programas de melhoramento de diferentes instituições no Brasil e no exterior. O objetivo deste trabalho foi fazer um diagnóstico das cultivares de feijoeiro que tiveram seu lançamento divulgado na revista CBAB - Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology, entre 2001 e 2008, identificando os métodos de melhoramento utilizados para a sua obtenção. Neste período, foram lançadas 23 cultivares de feijoeiro e todas foram obtidas por institutos públicos de pesquisas e em apenas duas delas houve participação de universidades. O método de melhoramento mais utilizado foi o Pedigree, seguido pelo Bulk e pelo Descendente de uma Única Vagem (SPD). Os grãos do tipo carioca e do tipo preto são os que têm maior aceitação dos consumidores, sendo os de maior interesse dos melhoristas.

Palavras-chave:Phaseolus vulgaris L., melhoramento, obtenção de novas cultivares.

INTRODUCTION

Common beans are consumed in Brazil by all social classes. Particularly for the portion of the low-income population common bean is the main source of protein, minerals and vitamins (Carbonell et al. 2008a). Around the world, an average of 27 million hectares is planted every year and approximately 20 million tons of beans are harvested in more than 100 countries, of which Brazil is the largest producer (Chiorato et al. 2008).

The establishment of bean cultivars that satisfy farmers as well as consumers involves dedication of the breeders in research work in genetics and plant breeding. Aside from yield, the main target traits in the improvement of the crop are grain type and size besides pathogen resistance.

For the grain type, breeding should take the consumers' preference into account. It is known that carioca grain is the most consumed in all the country, accounting for 79% of the total consumption, followed by black beans with 17%, and other types representing 4% of the national consumption (Faria et al. 2008). For this reason more effort is spent on breeding programs to obtain cultivars with carioca grain. Other traits related to the grain type, such as little browning during storage and ease of cooking should also be observed (Faria et al. 2004).

For growth habit, the improvement targets are more upright plants (with determinate or type I growth habit), of which cultivation is easier and crop losses and pathogen incidence are lower. The yields of such plants is however lower than of plants with indeterminate growth habit (type II, III and IV) (Silva et al. 2006).

In terms of disease resistance, the use of resistant cultivars has been the most effective control method (Abreu et al. 2007). Among the most important diseases of common bean are anthracnose (caused by Colletotrichum lindemuthianum) and angular leaf spot (caused by Phaeoisariopsis griseola) (Costa et al. 2006).

Common bean is an autogamous and also cleistogamous plant. Due to this pollination system, bean cultivars are normally a pure line or a mixture of several pure lines. Since the genetic constitution of the plants will remain unchanged over successive generations, farmers can produce seeds from their own crops.

The following breeding methods are mostly used for autogamous plants: population or bulk, genealogical or pedigree and the single seed descent (SSD) method. A variation of the SSD is used for common bean, called Single Pod Descent (SPD) method, where the generations are advanced using a pod rather than a seed of each plant (Peloso et al. 2004).

The common bean improvement programs in Brazil are restricted to and predominantly concentrated in the public sector. First programs were initiated around 1930, but most activities began after 1970 (Voysest 2000). According to Matos et al. (2007), the contributions of any breeding program, especially when resources are limited, should periodically be critically analyzed and new methodologies sought for that could improve the efficiency.

The purpose of this study was a diagnosis of the release and announcement of bean cultivars in the journal Crop Breeding Applied Biotechnology, the main scientific journal in the field of plant breeding in Brazil between 2001 and 2008, identifying the main improved characteristics and most commonly used breeding methods.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

All published volumes of the journal CBAB - Crop Breeding Applied Biotechnology from January 2001 to December 2008 were consulted for a literature review of the announcement of the release of new bean cultivars. These articles in the CBAB report the main characteristics of each new cultivar and describe the breeding methods used and the research institutions involved.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

In the studied period, 23 new bean cultivars were released CBAB (Table 1). Ten of these were obtained by Empresa Brasileira de Pesquisa Agropecuária (Embrapa), in Goiania, where the institution does most of its research on rice and beans. Two of these cultivars were obtained by Embrapa Rice and Beans in partnership with federal universities in the state of Minas Gerais (Universidade Federal de Viçosa - UFV and Universidade Federal de Lavras - UFLA) and a research company of the same state (Empresa de Pesquisa Agropecuária de Minas Gerais - EPAMIG). Cultivar BRS Horizonte was obtained in a partnership of Embrapa Rice and Beans and the International Center for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT).

It is noteworthy that only in two cases public universities were involved in the release of cultivars announced in the CBAB journal, whereas federal or state research institutions were involved in the development of 100% of the cultivars reported in CBAB. In general, the main objective of universities is to training researchers, aside from the operational and financial difficulties of maintaining relatively large experiments over several years, which is an essential factor for the development of a cultivar. There are few common bean breeding programs in Brazil, and in view of the nation-wide importance of the crop, the number of breeders is still low. The interest of private seed companies in maintaining their own breeding program is also small. Thus, the responsibility to obtain new lines that can advantageously replace the existing will rest with programs of the public sector, namely of universities, the Embrapa and other state companies (Matos et al. 2007).

To obtain common bean cultivars the pedigree or also called genealogical method was most commonly used. It was used in 48 % of the cultivars announced in CBAB, alone or in combination with other methods. In the pedigree method, plants of the segregating population are individually evaluated and selected. Thus, each generation should be grown in the representative region and planting time of the environment where the cultivar will be used (Borém and Miranda 2005). Perhaps for this reason, this method was only used in the later generations, as in the cases of the cultivars IAPAR 81, IPR Graúna and IPR Juriti (Moda-Cirino et al. 2001b Moda-Cirino et al. 2003a, Moda-Cirino et al. 2003b).

It should be emphasized that when the population is advanced by the pedigree method, the progeny is derived from a plant. Thus, in most cases the available seed quantity limits the use of a larger number of plots, replications and/or locations for evaluation. Therefore, the experimental conditions in the field trials with a view to uniform plant stands must be planned very carefully. Also, the importance of an adequate plant management should be observed due to its influence on the experimental accuracy and selection success (Moreto et al. 2007). The institutions that used this method most were the Instituto Agronômico do Paraná (IAPAR) and the Instituto Agronômico de Campinas (IAC).

The bulk method was used alone or combined with other breeding methods in the development of 35% of the cultivars reported by CBAB during the considered period. In four cases it was used alone and in four other cases it was associated with the Single Pod Descent (SPD) method. In the latter case, for the early generations of the populations the bulk method was used, with Colletotrichum lindemuthianum inoculation, to eliminate susceptible plants. The remaining population was conducted by the SPD method (Costa et al. 2006). The bulk method was most used for improvement by Embrapa Rice and Beans.

The bulk method was proposed in the early 20^th century; in this method the plants from F₂ onwards are harvested in bulk, from which a seed sample is taken to obtain the F₃ generation. The process is repeated for a few generations. Then the plants are harvested individually (opening of the bulk) and give rise to families that are evaluated in an experiment with replication, until identifying superior lines (Allard 1971). An important question regarding this method is about the correct moment for the bulk opening which usually happens in the F₅ generation, when 93.75% of homozygosis is expected. From this point onwards, there is no advantage in the maintenance of the bulk, since the increase in the proportion of homozygotes is small. However, the method is known for its flexibility, enabling a delay, in case of lack of resources, of the opening of the bulk until a more appropriate moment. Besides, over the generations, the population is exposed to natural selection, subjecting the plants to competition (Vieira et al. 1999).

The Single Pod Descendant (SPD) method was adopted to obtain seven cultivars from different populations. As already mentioned, for four of these cultivars this method was used in combination with the bulk and for three other cultivars, together with the pedigree method. In the association of SPD with pedigree, the early segregating populations (F₂, F₃ and F₄) were obtained by SPD and then the progeny was selected and conducted by the pedigree method to more advanced generations (F₇, F₈) (Moda-Cirino et al. 2003a). This association was only used at the Instituto Agronômico do Paraná (IAPAR).

According to Vieira et al. (1999), the SPD method is widely used to obtain common bean cultivars, taking advantage of the fact that sampling losses can be reduced and segregating generations advanced requiring less labor and space. In most Brazilian states, where up to three growing seasons per year are possible, time savings in advancing generations are rather significant.

To obtain the cultivars Carnaval and Jalo MG-65, both developed by EPAMIG, germplasm was introduced. According to Vieira et al. (1999) this method is rather widespread, particularly in the case of germplasm from CIAT. The development of some common bean cultivars that were widely used in Brazil such as 'Rico 23' and 'Capixaba Precoce' was based on the introduction of germplasm from abroad. In this method the accessions are released as cultivar after assessments in experiments in representative regions; the great advantage is the almost immediate availability of superior genotypes, similar to those developed in breeding programs (Borém and Miranda 2005).

The selection of inbred lines was the method used to obtain a plant variety obtained by the partnership of Embrapa Rice and Beans with CIAT. The selection method of inbred lines is based on the selection of individual plants in the original population, followed by the evaluation of the progenies (Allard 1971). In the bean cultivars obtained by this method, the inbred lines were selected in a segregating population originating from controlled crosses rather than from heterogeneous populations, based on mutations, mechanical seed mixing or natural crosses, as originally proposed by the method.

Finally, recurrent selection, a method originally developed based on an alogamous plant, was used to obtain the cultivar BRSMG Talisman, resulting from a partnership project of Embrapa Rice and Beans, UFLA, UFV and EPAMIG (Abreu et al. 2004). According to Ramalho et al. (2005), this method consists of performing re-selection generation after generation, intercrossing the selected genotypes to achieve genetic recombination. Recurrent selection is therefore a cyclical and continuous process, which involves the development of individuals or families, the assessment, selection and intercrossing of superior genotypes, aiming at a higher frequency of favorable alleles and, consequently, a better expression of the trait under selection (Cargnin 2007). The advantage of this method is that the yield a cultivar can achieve is not determined by an original plant only, but by the most favorable combination of existing genes in a group of original plants.

With regard to the grain type (Table 1), 43.5 % of the new cultivars have carioca grain, in other words, striped, cream colored grains. According to Faria et al. (2008), carioca grain is the most consumed throughout the country, accounting for about 80% of the total consumption. The cultivars with carioca grain probably have cultivar Carioca as common ancestor, which according to Ramalho (personal communication) is the most productive in the absence of diseases, even compared to newer cultivars with this grain type. Cultivars with black grain represent 21.75% of the cultivars released in the studied period. According to Carbonell et al. (2008b), the consumer demand is highest for cultivars with carioca and black grain, which are therefore of greatest interest for researchers.

According to Singh (2001), remarkable efforts to collect, characterize, and evaluate the genetic diversity in common bean have been made in the second half of the 20^th century. Likewise, the main yield limits and deficient traits in bean cultivars were determined. The main achievements of several decades of bean breeding include early cultivars adapted to higher latitudes and with high yields and new cultivars with increased production of better quality pods and seeds, erect growth habit and disease, pest and drought resistance. However, the genetic base of commercial cultivars within specific market classes is narrow. The overall average yield of bean is still low (below 900 kg ha^-1), and production is affected by a wide range of restrictions of biotic and abiotic stresses causing some loss in total production. This makes the importance of breeding for this species evident and the need to ensure the continuity of such programs, targeting high-quality cultivars that are suitable for sustainable production systems.

Received 4 March 2010

Accepted 10 June 2010

• Abreu AFB, Ramalho MAP, Carneiro JES, Gonçalves FMA, Santos JB, Peloso MJD, Faria LC, Carneiro GES and Pereira Filho IA (2004) 'BRSMG Talismã': common bean cultivar with Carioca grain type. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 4: 372-374.
• Abreu AFB, Ramalho MAP, Carneiro JES, Peloso MJD, Paula Junior TJ, Faria LC, Melo LC, Barros EG, Moreira MA, Pereira Filho IA, Martins M, Santos JB, Rava CA, Costa JGC and Sartorato A (2007) BRSMG Majestoso: another common bean cultivar of carioca grain type for the state of Minas Gerais. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 7: 403-405.
• Allard RN (1971) Princípios do melhoramento genético de plantas Edgard Blücher, São Paulo, 381p.
• Borém A and Miranda GV (2005) Melhoramento de plantas Editora UFV, Viçosa, 525p.
• Carbonell SAM, Chiorato AF, Carvalho CRL, Benchimol LL, Beraldo ALA, Gonçalves JGR, Ticelli M, Souza PS and Gallo PB (2008a) IAC-Galante and IAC-Centauro: special commom bean types. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 8: 177-180.
• Carbonell SAM, Chiorato AF, Ito MF, Perina EF, Gonçalves JGR, Souza PS, Gallo PB, Ticelli M, Colombo CA and Azevedo Filho JA (2008b) IAC-Alvorada and IAC-Diplomata: new commom bean cultivars. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 8: 163-166.
• Cargnin A (2007) Seleção recorrente no melhoramento genético de plantas autógamas Embrapa Cerrados, Brasília, 24p. (Documentos 184)
• Chiorato AF, Carbonell SAM, Ito MF, Benchimol LL, Colombo CA, Perina EF, Ito MA, Ramos Junior EU, Freitas RS and Pereira JCVNA (2008) IAC-Boreal and IAC-Harmonia: common bean cultivars with striped grains. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 8: 170-173.
• Costa JGC, Faria LC, Rava CA, Peloso MJD, Melo LC, Díaz JLC, Faria JC, Silva HT, Sartorato A, Bassinello PZ and Zimmermann FJP (2006) BRS 7762 Supremo a black common bean cultivar with erect plant type. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 6: 182-184.
• Faria LC, Peloso MJD, Melo LC, Costa JGC, Rava CA, Díaz JLC, Faria JC, Silva HT, Sartorato A, Bassinello PZ and Trovo JBF (2008) BRS Cometa: a carioca common bean cultivar with erect growth habit. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 8: 167-169.
• Faria LC, Costa JGC, Rava CA, Peloso MJD, Melo LC, Carneiro GES, Soares DM, Díaz JLC, Abreu AFB, Faria JC, Sartorato A, Silva HT, Bassinello PZ and Zimmermann FJP (2004) 'BRS Requinte': new common bean Carioca cultivar with delayed grain darkness. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 4: 366-368.
• Faria LC, Peloso MJD, Costa JGC, Peloso MJD, Costa JGC, Rava CA, Carneiro GES, Soares DM, Díaz JLC, Sartorato A and Faria JC (2003) 'BRS Radiante' sugar common bean. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 3: 307-310.
• Matos JW, Ramalho MAP and Abreu AFB (2007) Trinta e dois anos do programa de melhoramento genético de feijoeiro comum em Minas Gerais. Ciência e Agrotecnologia 31: 1749-1754.
• Melo LC, Faria LC, Rava CA, Peloso MJD, Costa JGC, Díaz JLC, Faria JC, Silva HT, Sartorato A, Bassinello PZ and Zimmermann FJP (2005) 'BRS Horizonte': new bean variety of the carioca grain type. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 5: 473-474.
• Moda-Cirino V, Oliari L, Lollato MA and Fonseca Júnior NS (2001a) IAPAR 80 Common bean. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 1: 201-202.
• Moda-Cirino V, Oliari L, Lollato MA and Fonseca Júnior NS (2001b) IAPAR 81 Common bean. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 1: 203-204.
• Moreira et al. Moda-Cirino V, Oliari L, Lollato MA and Fonseca Júnior NS (2001c) IPR88 Uirapuru common bean. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 1: 205-206.
• Moda-Cirino V, Oliari L, Fonseca Júnior NS and Lollato MA (2003a) IPR Graúna common bean cultivar. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 3: 301-302.
• Moda-Cirino V, Oliari L, Fonseca Júnior NS and Lollato MA (2003b) IPR Juriti common bean cultivar. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 3: 303-306.
• Moreto AL, Ramalho MAP, Nunes JAR and Abreu AFB (2007) estimação dos componentes da variância fenotípica em feijoeiro utilizando o método genealógico. Ciência e Agrotecnologia 31: 1035-1042.
• Peloso MJD, Costa JGC, Rava CA, Carneiro GES, Soares DM, Faria LC, Díaz JLC, Antunes IF, Silveira EP, Mesquita NA, Sartorato A and Faria (2003) 'BRS Valente' black common bean. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 3: 311-314.
• Peloso MJD, Melo LC, Faria LC, Costa JGC, Rava CA, Carneiro GES, Soares DM, Díaz JLC, Abreu AFB, Faria JC, Sartorato A, Silva HT, Bassinello PZ and Zimmermann FJP (2004) 'BRS Pontal': new common bean cultivar with Carioca grain type. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 4: 369-371.
• Rava CA, Faria LC, Costa JGC, Peloso MJD, Melo JLC, Faria JC, Silva HT, Sartorato A, Bassinello PZ and Zimmermann FJP (2005) 'BRS Pitanga': new dry bean variety of the small purple group. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 5: 475-476.
• Ramalho MAP, Abreu AFB and Santos JB (2005) Genetic progress after cycles of recurrent selection for yield and grain traits in common bean. Euphytica 144: 23-29.
• Silva MGM, Santos JB and Abreu AFB (2006) Seleção de famílias de feijoeiro resistentes à antracnose e mancha angular. Pesquisa Agropecuária Brasileira 41: 1499-1506.
• Singh SP (2001) Broadening the genetic base of common bean cultivars: a review. Crop Science 41: 1659-1675.
• Vieira C, Borém A and Ramalho MAP (1999) Melhoramento do feijão. In Borém A (Ed.) Melhoramento de espécies cultivadas Editora UFV, Viçosa, p. 273-349.
• Vieira RF, Vieira C, Pinto CMF and Pereira JM (2002) CARNAVAL Common bean cultivar. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 2: 483-484.
• Vieira RF, Fonseca JR and Vilarinho LBO (2004) Jalo MG-65 Common bean cultivar. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology 4: 364-365.
• Voysest VO (2000) Mejoramento genético del frijol (Phaseolus vulgraris L.): legado de variedades de América Latina 1930-1999. Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical, Cali, 195p.

Publication Dates

• Publication in this collection
  14 Apr 2011
• Date of issue
  Dec 2010

History

• Accepted
  10 June 2010
• Received
  04 Mar 2010