# Abstracts

This work describes a method for 15N-isotope-labeled glycine synthesis, as well as details about a recovery line for nitrogen residues. To that effect, amination of alpha-haloacids was performed, using carboxylic chloroacetic acid and labeled aqueous ammonia (15NH3). Special care was taken to avoid possible 15NH3 losses, since its production cost is high. In that respect, although the purchase cost of the 13N-labeled compound (radioactive) is lower, the stable tracer produced constitutes an important tool for N cycling studies in living organisms, also minimizing labor and environmental hazards, as well as time limitation problems in field studies. The tests were carried out with three replications, and variable 15NH3(aq) volumes in the reaction were used (50, 100, and 150 mL), in order to calibrate the best operational condition; glycine masses obtained were 1.7, 2, and 3.2 g, respectively. With the development of a system for 15NH3 recovery, it was possible to recover 71, 83, and 87% of the ammonia initially used in the synthesis. With the required adaptations, the same system was used to recover methanol, and 75% of the methanol initially used in the amino acid purification process were recovered.

stable isotope; glycine; amino acid

isótopo estável; glicina; aminoácido

CHEMICAL SCIENCES

15 N-labed glycine synthesis

Claudinéia R.O. TavaresI; José A. BendassolliI; Fernando CoelhoII; Carlos R. Sant'ana FilhoI; Clelber V. PrestesI

ICentro de Energia Nuclear na Agricultura da Universidade de São Paulo, CENA-USP, Av. Centenário 303, São Dimas, Caixa Postal 96, 13400-970 Piracicaba, SP, Brasil

IIInstituto de Química, UNICAMP, Cidade Universitária "Zeferino Vaz", Rua Josué de Castro, Caixa Postal 6154, Barão Geraldo, 13083-970 Campinas, SP, Brasil

ABSTRACT

This work describes a method for 15N-isotope-labeled glycine synthesis, as well as details about a recovery line for nitrogen residues. To that effect, amination of a-haloacids was performed, using carboxylic chloroacetic acid and labeled aqueous ammonia (15NH3). Special care was taken to avoid possible 15NH3 losses, since its production cost is high. In that respect, although the purchase cost of the 13N-labeled compound (radioactive) is lower, the stable tracer produced constitutes an important tool for N cycling studies in living organisms, also minimizing labor and environmental hazards, as well as time limitation problems in field studies. The tests were carried out with three replications, and variable 15NH3(aq) volumes in the reaction were used (50, 100, and 150 mL), in order to calibrate the best operational condition; glycine masses obtained were 1.7, 2, and 3.2 g, respectively. With the development of a system for 15NH3 recovery, it was possible to recover 71, 83, and 87% of the ammonia initially used in the synthesis. With the required adaptations, the same system was used to recover methanol, and 75% of the methanol initially used in the amino acid purification process were recovered.

Key words: stable isotope, glycine, amino acid.

RESUMO

Palavras-chave: isótopo estável, glicina, aminoácido.

INTRODUCTION

Nitrogen cycle studies can be carried out with tracers consisting of radioactive (13N) or stable (14N/ 15N) nitrogen isotopes. Papers involving 13N applications in biology have been presented in the literature (Krohn and Mathis 1981, Cooper et al. 1985). However, the main inconvenience of using the radioisotopic technique, especially in biological researches, is represented by the time factor, since the radioisotope with the longest half-life is 13N, with only 9.97 minutes (Lide 1997).

With regard to the purchase cost of these products, the price of the labeled compound is lower for the radioisotope (Hauck and Bremner 1976). However, experiments where 13N is used are extremely difficult to conduct, and the results obtained may be misleading (Knowles and Blackburn 1993).When 15N is used, it is possible to develop studies without time limitations, and the material being experimented is not exposed to radiation, making it unnecessary to adopt any safety measures because of radioactivity (Trivelin et al. 1979, 2002, Eriksen 1996, Máximo et al. 2000). In studies developed for the isotopic separation of 34S, Bendassolli et al. (1997) mentioned that the use of stable isotopes is an international current trend, and is especially encouraged in field researches. This trend, together with the possibility of obtaining refined information on the nitrogen cycle, reinforce the reasons for the continued growth of use of the isotopic technique in applied researches.

Although 15N is considered an important tracer in biochemical and agronomic studies, and has been used for almost 7 decades (Shoenheimer et al. 1937, Vickery et al. 1940), it is correct to make the statement that the use of 15N-labeled compounds (especially highly-labeled ones) in applied researches is still limited, especially because of their high price.

Until recently, some nitrogen compounds, among them 15N amino acids, were not produced in South America, due to difficulties of a methodological nature, and had to be imported from the United States of America, Europe, or Asia. The production of ammonia (15NH3) is crucial in obtaining a number of nitrogen compounds. The Stable Isotopes Laboratory of Centro de Energia Nuclear na Agricultura of Universidade de São Paulo (LIE-CENA/USP) dominates the method for obtaining ammonium ion with enrichment in the range of up to 90% 15N atoms (Máximo et al. 2000).

Several nitrogen compounds can be produced from labeled ammonium, among which are: anhydrous ammonia (Bendassolli et al. 1988a); nitric acid, from ammonia-15N combustion; urea (Bendassolli et al. 1988b), and 15N-uran (Bendassolli et al. 1989).

A highly important nitrogen compound is glycine, prominent for being a simple amino acid, and one of the most soluble in water. In living organisms, it is frequently added to other molecules to make them more soluble, so they can be excreted in urine (Campbell 2000). This trait allows the nitrogen cycle to be elucidated in the metabolic medium. Stack et al. (1989) used 15N amino acids to evaluate human nutritional status. Dichi et al. (1996), Marchini et al. (1993), and Schelp et al. (1995) conducted metabolism studies in 15N-labeled proteins. These compounds have provided a safe method in such studies, eliminating invasive procedures and patient exposure to radioactivity, which makes their application extremely favorable in this area (Klein and Klein 1987).

Glycine can be synthesized by means of the Strecker, Hoffmann syntheses, and also by a modification of Gabriel's synthesis for amine, using potassium phthalimide. The latter presents high yield (85%) and allows easy purification (Morrison and Boyd 1973). Although having lower yields (in the order of 40 to 60%), amination of a-haloacids can also be used. In this reaction, a chlorinated or bromated carboxylic acid at a position is submitted to direct ammonolysis, with a great excess of concentrated ammonia solution (Morrison and Boyd 1973). Displacement of the halogen by ammonia forms the amine salt (amino acid).

In the present work, we studied labeled-glycine synthesis, using the a-haloacid amination method. The selection of this method is conditioned to the use of ammonia, the main raw material from the synthesis reaction, already produced at LIE_CENA/USP. Thus, the novelty presented by this work is the use of a previously labeled reagent (15N-ammonia) in the proposed synthesis, paying special attention to the recovery of the previously labeled ammonia reagent; this is crucial due to the high added value of the compound (U$200 per gram of the isotope). Within this context, as this method for obtaining 15N-glycine becomes further developed, it is now possible to contribute for the advancement of research in the biological and biomedical fields, and an important tool is offered that could be used in studies of this nature. MATERIALS AND METHODS In the glycine synthesis reaction described by Vogel (1980), carboxylic chloroacetic acid, ammonium carbonate, and concentrated (23-25% m/v) aqueous ammonia (excess) are used, and the reaction can be represented according to equation 1. The proposed method was modified in relation to that indicated by Vogel (1980), notably for the exclusion of ammonium carbonate from the synthesis process, considering that the use of this compound with natural isotopic abundance (0.366% 15N atoms) would cause isotopic dilution with thehighly enriched aqueous ammonia (50 to 90% 15N atoms), although the reaction yield would be increased to up to 62%. The tests were carried out with three replicates, in which we varied the amount of ammonia (0.73, 1.46, and 2.20 mols), corresponding to 50, 100, and 150 mL of 25% m/v aqueous ammonia, in order to obtain the best economic and operational condition for glycine synthesis. Initially, a chloroacetic acid solution (25 g chloroacetic acid dissolved in 25 mL water) was added slowly under agitation into an adapted 250 mL volumetric flask (two inlets, with a Teflon valve attached to one of them) containing concentrated ammonia. A 1 mL aliquot was taken from the final volume containing ammonia and chloroacetic acid and the initial N content (No) in the reaction volume was quantified (Malavolta et al. 1997). The closed flask remained resting for a period of 24 hours at room temperature. After the rest period, an aliquot was again taken to quantify the N present in excess in the solution (Ne). During the concentration of the solution, the excess nitrogen, in the form of aqueous ammonia, was recovered in two compartments. The first compartment consisted of traps, 9 mm external diameter and 6 mm internal diameter, inserted into three 24 / 40-ground-joint borosilicate tubes 35 cm inheight, 36 mm external diameter, and 32 mm internal diameter, containing 6 mol L-1 sulfuric acid. The first was connected to a second compartment consisting of a MARCONI model MA-120v vacuum rotary evaporator, with an evaporation and recovery flask that operates at reduced pressure, at a temperature of 60ºC. In this second compartment, ammonia traces were retained in a 6 mol L-1 sulfuric acid solution in the system's recovery flask. The nitrogen fraction retained in the compartments was quantified and designated as recovered nitrogen (Nr). After 40 minutes of concentration, new nitrogen determinations were made. The nitrogen present in the form of ammonium chloride (NH4Cl), the main impurity formed during the process, was quantified in the concentrated solution. In the final step, 100 mL methanol (CH3OH) were added to the solution to cause glycine crystallization and thus separate it from the ammonium chloride soluble in methanol. The purification procedure was repeated three times. The methanol used for purification was recovered by fractionated distillation, using a rotary evaporator at reduced pressure at a temperature of 30ºC. In order to verify the presence of glycine, the synthesized samples were submitted to thin-layer chromatography (TLC) analysis, by reaction with ninhydrin (Vilella 1976) and high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). In the TLC analyses, 10 mg from each sample were weighed and solubilized in 1 mL water. Next, the samples were applied with a 10µl automatic pipettor to the silica plate, which was placedin a laboratory bowl containing a mobile phase, consisting of butanol, acetic acid, and water at a 4:1:1 rate, and developed in a 0.2% (m/v) ninhydrin solution. For HPLC determinations, 10 mg from each sample were needed, solubilized in 1 mL purified water (18 MW.cm); 100 µL were taken from thefinal solution and added of 900µL water. Next, the sample was centrifuged and filtered (0.2µm micropore filter). A 10µL sample was taken for analysis from the final volume and mixed into 30µL o-phthaldehyde (OPA), in order to derivatize the amino acid, enabling it to be detected by HPLC. The amino acid was determined in a C18 Superpac ODS-2 4 × 250 mm reverse phase column,0.8 ml.min-1 flow (Supelco), at room temperature, having as mobile phase a phosphate buffer (Buffer A) with pH 7.25 corrected with glacial acetic acid, consisting of 50 mM NaOAc, 50 mM Na2HPO4, 20 mL tetrahydrofuran, 20 mL methanol, and a (Buffer B) consisting of 65% HPLC-degree methanol prepared with purified, degassed water, and vacuum-filtered through a Millipore HVPL 047 membrane. After derivatization of the amino acid, the derivatives were detected by fluorescence with a Shimatsu RF 551 fluorescence detector, adjusted for excitation (l = 250 nm) and emission (l = 480 nm). The isotopic (% 15N atoms) and N content (%) determinations in samples with natural isotopic abundance and in the enriched amino acid (glycine) were performed by mass spectrometry (model ANCA-SL 20-20 mass spectrometer by PDZ Europe). A solution containing 535.3 mg glycine in 10 ml (synthesized and Sigma standard) was prepared for the isotopic and N content determinations in glycine. The use of 10 µL of this solution containing 100 µg N-glycine was sufficient for good analytical precision. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS The nitrogen balance (N recovery in the process) and glycine amino acid production results (gravimetric determination) as a function of 25% (m/v) aqueous ammonia volume (50, 100, or 150 mL) are presented in Table I. The table shows data corresponding to Nitrogen recovery (Nr) in the amino acid concentration system from the excess N (Ne), glycine production, and N mass in the amino acid (NG). The Ne was obtained as described in item 2. Based on the data from Table I it can be determined that N losses in the global process (reaction and amino acid concentration line) were in the order of 3.6 ± 0.3 g N ((No - (Nr + NG)). Nitrogen losses were in gas form (NH3) and especially due to the reagent handling process, were practically independent from the amount of ammoniacal solution employed. With regard to the Ne recovery system (special line at reduced pressure) excess nitrogen, it can be determined, from the data in Table I, that N losses (%) ((Nr/Ne).100) were reduced, since about 94 ± 1% of the excess nitrogen (Ne) present at the end of the reaction were recovered. These data demonstrate the effectiveness of the excess ammonia recovery stage, and confirm that the greatest 15N losses are related to the initial stage (handling, reaction system, reagent transfers). The reduced-scale (micro scale) amino acid synthesis and the elimination of the nitrogen quantification stage (No and Ne) as a routine may bring advantages to the process, especially by reducing ammonia losses at the reaction stage (handling, and volatile reagent transfers, among others). When glycine masses obtained with 50 and 100 mL of aqueous ammonia are compared, it can be observed that the yield increase in amino acidsynthesis was not proportional to the mass of aqueous ammonia used, since doubling the mass of ammonia reagent provided an increase of only 17.6% in the glycine mass obtained. Considering the stoichiometry of the glycine synthesis reaction (equation 1) and the amino acid production data presented in Table I, it was possible to determine that synthesis yield was in the order of 8.7; 10.3; and 16.4% when volumes of 50, 100, and 150 mL aqueous ammonia were used, respectively. In a single test utilizing 50 mL ammonia labeled with 1.0% 15N atoms, it was possible to synthesize 1.7 g glycine with the same isotopic labeling (1.0% 15N atoms), demonstrating that no isotopic fractionation occurs in the proposed process. Thus, the final amino acid labeling is a function of the isotopic abundance of the ammonia used initially. In tests (three replicates) in which 50 mL ammonia were used, 1.7g glycine could be obtained, on average, with N losses (global) in the order of 2.9 g (Table I). Under these conditions and using ammonia with a 95% abundance in 15N atoms(50 mL volume), it can be estimated that the glycine production costs (fixed and variable) with the same degree of enrichment was in the order of R$ 360.00 (Three hundred and sixty reals - 1 US$= R$ 3.0) per gram of the amino acid. Ammonia losses in the synthesis system represent about 85% of amino acid production costs when the methodology is used. These data show that, using the proposed method to obtain 15N-glycine, the final cost was about 5% lower than the FOB price in the international market (without taking into account fees related to import, transport, storage, and others, in case the compound is imported).

The synthesis of organic molecules, especially in the pharmaceutical, agrochemical, and fine chemical industries, among others, many times involves several reaction steps, usually leading to very low yields. Many times, depending on the process, a 10% yield may be considered satisfactory from an economic point of view, but not from an ecological perspective, since byproducts and/or residues are generated. In the 15N-glycine synthesis process (high 15N enrichment), the economic aspect is also relevant (due to the 15N isotope), especially when conversion of reagents into the product of interest is low. For this reason, an effective excess ammonia recovery system becomes important, as well as the ecological aspect given by the generation of residues (methanol and ammonium chloride).

The synthesized glycine was submitted to TLC, HPLC, and MS analyses, as described in item 2, with the objective of verifying its purity.

Figure 1 presents the results obtained by TLC for the 3 synthesized glycine samples (A, B, and C) with natural 15N abundance (0.366% atoms), a 15N-enriched sample (D) (1.0% 15N atoms), and two samples (E and F) of the p.a. standard amino acid (Sigma).

As it can be seen in Figure 1, the synthesized samples, according to the procedure proposed in this work, indicated the presence of the amino acid glycine in comparison with the Sigma standard.

In the HPLC determinations, with the objective of detecting possible impurities, it was observed that the chromatogram relative to the synthesized sample (Figure 2a) presents the same characteristics as the standard (Figure 2b), with a retention time of approximately 26 minutes for both the sample and the standard. According to the chromatograms, no impurity was measured.

The determinations corresponding to the N content in synthesized samples were carried out by ANCA-SL (Automatic Nitrogen Carbon Analyzer, Solid and Liquid) mass spectrometry, from PDZ Europe. The mean results (mg L-1 N) for all synthesized glycine samples (solutions prepared from the amino acid produced) as well as for the Sigma standard can be observed in Table II. These data provide evidence that the N content in the samples are compatible with those in the p.a. Sigma standard, and the amino acid purity is in the same order of magnitude as the standard utilized. The isotopic determinations showed that no fractionation occurred in the synthesized samples, considering that the isotopic value of the ammonium sulfate used for aqueous ammonia production may vary from -10 (0.363% 15N atoms) to 0 (0.366% 15N atoms) (Kreitler et al. 1978, Heaton 1986). In order to make the use of synthesized glycine viable in biomedical assays, supplementary tests should be carried out (pyrogenicity and toxicity). The 15N-glycine thus obtained can be used for the synthesis of other amino acids, as well as in the synthesis pathway of 15N-glyphosate, one of the most used herbicides worldwide.

With regard to the process aimed at the recovery of methanol, the data indicate that it was possible to recover 75% of the solvent used in the assays, on average. The methanol purity obtained in the process was compatible with the requirements for the p.a. product employed in the glycine purification line. The same recovered methanol can be used in the 15N-urea synthesis line (Bendassolli et al. 1988b) and reused in the glycine purification process.

CONCLUSION

The assays allowed to attest the viability of producing this amino acid, despite the fact that yield for the synthesis reaction was low (lower than 20%), regardless of the amount of ammonia used.

The additional use of ammonium carbonate would not be feasible, since it would produce isotopic dilution.

Due to the high effectiveness (94%) observed in the recovery system for excess labeled-ammonia in the reaction, the production cost could be 25% lower than the foreign FOB price.

The analyses performed by TLC, HPLC,RMN, and IR-MS attested the high degree of purity of the synthesized glycine. However, additional assays (pyrogenicity and toxicity) are required if it is to be used in the biomedical field. Another possible use would be as a precursor in the synthesis of other 15N-labeled amino acids, as well as in the synthesis of 15N-glyphosate, which is one of the most important herbicides used worldwide.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The authors thank Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP) for the financial aid (Proceeding 99/09419-5) and a master's scholarship (Proceeding 99/01178-9) to Claudinéia Raquel de Oliveira (student).

Manuscript received on April 28, 2005; accepted for publication on March 22, 2006; presented by EURÍPEDES MALAVOLTA

Correspondence to: Claudinéia R. de Oliveira Tavares

E-mail: crolivei@cena.usp.br

• BENDASSOLLI JA, MORTATTI J, TRIVELIN PCO AND VICTORIA RL. 1988a. Síntese de fertilizantes nitrogenados enriquecidos em 15N. Parte I - Produçăo de amônia anidra enriquecida em 15N. Energ Nucl Agric 9: 66-93.
• BENDASSOLLI JA, TRIVELIN PCO, MORTATTI J AND VICTÓRIA RL. 1988b. Síntese de fertilizantes nitrogenados em 15N. Parte II - Síntese de uréia enriquecida em 15N. Energ Nucl Agric 9: 94-116.
• BENDASSOLLI JA, TRIVELIN PCO AND MORTATTI J. 1989. Preparo de uran-15N com marcaçăo isotópica independente nas fontes N-NO3, N-NH4 e N-NH2, a partir de KNO3-15N e (NH4)2SO4-15N. Energ Nucl Agric 10: 55-69.
• BENDASSOLLI JA, TRIVELIN PCO AND CARNEIRO Jr FC. 1997. Stable sulfur isotope fractionation by anion exchange chromatography. Production of compounds enriched in 34S. J Braz Chem Soc 8: 13-17.
• CAMPBELL MK. 2000. Bioquímica. Parte 2: Aminoácidos e Peptídeos. 3Ş ed., Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil, Artes Médicas Sul, p. 94-117.
• COOPER AJL, GELBARD AS AND REED BR. 1985. Nitrogen-13 as a biochemical tracer. Adv Enzymol Relat Areas Mol Biol 57: 251-356.
• DICHI JB, DICHI I, BERTO SJP, ANGELILI AYD, BICUDO MH, REZENDE TA AND BURINI RC. 1996. Protein-Energy Status and 15N-Glycine Study of Child A Cirrhotic Patients Fed Low-To High-Protein Energy Diets. Nutrition 12: 519-523.
• ERIKSEN J. 1996. Measuring natural abundance of stable isotopes in soil by isotope ratio mass spectrometry. Comm Soil Sci Plant Anal 27: 1251-1264.
• HAUCK RD AND BREMNER JM. 1976. Use of tracers for soil and fertilizer nitrogen research. Adv Agron 28: 219-266.
• HEATON THE. 1986. Isotopic studies of nitrogen pollution in the hydrosphere and atmosphere: A review. Chem Geol 59: 87-102.
• KLEIN PD AND KLEIN ER. 1987. Stable Isotope Usage in Developing Countries: Safe tracer tools to measure human nutritional status. IAEA Bulletin 4: 41-44.
• KNOWLES R AND BLACKBURN TH. 1993. Nitrogen Isotope Techniques. Academic Press, San Diego, CA, USA, 311 p.
• KREITLER CW, RAGONE SE AND KATZ BG. 1978. 15N/14N ratios of ground-water nitrate, long Island, New York. Groundwater 16: 404-409.
• KROHN KA AND MATHIS CA. 1981. The use of isotope nitrogen as a biochemical tracer. In: ROOT JW AND KROHN KA (Eds), Short-lived isotopes in chemistry and biology, Washington DC, USA, Am ChemSoc, p. 233-249.
• LIDE DR. 1997. CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics. 77th ed., CRC Press, Inc Boca Raton, FL, USA.
• MALAVOLTA E, VITTI GC AND OLIVEIRA SA. 1997. Avaliaçăo do estado nutricional das plantas: princípios e aplicaçőes. 2Ş ed., Potafos, Piracicaba, SP, Brasil, 319 p.
• MARCHINI JSJ, CORTIELLA T, HIRAMATSU T, CHAPMAN E AND YOUNG VR. 1993. The requirements for indispensable amino acids in adult humans: A longer-term amino acid kinetic study, with support for the adequacy of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology amino acid requirement pattern. Am J Clin Nutr 58: 670-683.
• MÁXIMO E, BENDASSOLLI JA AND TRIVELIN PCO. 2000. Enrichment of 15N by Coupling Three Systems of Ion-Exchange Chromatography Columns.In: INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ISOTOPE 3, Vancouver. Isotope production and applications in the 21st century. Singapore: World Scientific Printers, p. 137-139.
• MORRISON RT AND BOYD RN. 1973. Química orgânica. 7Ş ed., Lisboa: Fundaçăo Calouste Gulbenkian, Aminas II cap. 22, p. 874-894.
• SCHELP AO, TEIXEIRA UA AND TSUJI H. 1995. Effects of Brain injury and Glucose supplementationon the blood hormones and whole-body protein metabolism in trauma patients fed on high-protein/ energy diet. In: FASEB J 9: 2757.
• SHOENHEIMER R, RITTEMBERG D AND KESTON AS. 1937. Nitrogen isotope (15N) as tool in the study of the intermediate metabolism of nitrogenous compounds. J Am Chem Soc 59: 1768.
• STACK T, REEDS PJ, PRESTON T, HAY S, LOYD DJ AND AGETT PJ. 1989. 15N tracer studies of protein metabolism in low birth weight preterm infants: a comparison of 15N-glycine and 15N-yeast proteinhydrolysate and of human milk and formula fed babies. Pediatr Res 25: 167-172.
• TRIVELIN PCO, MATSUI E AND SALATI E. 1979. Enriquecimento isotópico de 15N por cromatografia de troca iônica. Parte I. Constante de separaçăo isotópica e altura de placas teóricas. Energ Nucl Agric 1: 1-13.
• TRIVELIN PCO, BENDASSOLLI JA, MURUOKA T AND CARNEIRO JR F. 2002. Sulfur utilization by rice and crotolaria juncea from sulfate-34S applied tothe soil. Sci Agric 59: 205.
• VICKERY HB, PUCHER GW, SHOENHEIMER R AND RITTENBERG D. 1940. The assimilation of ammonia by the tobacco plant: A preliminary study with isotopic nitrogen. J Biol Chem 135: 531-539.
• VILELLA GG. 1976. Aminoácidos, Polipeptídeos e Proteínas. 2Ş ed., Guanabara Koogan. Bioquímica Săo Paulo, SP, Brasil 3: 58-70.
• VOGEL AI. 1980. Preparaçăo e reaçăo de compostos alifáticos - glicina e alanina. Química orgânica. Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil, Ao livro técnico 2: 461.

# Publication Dates

• Publication in this collection
18 Aug 2006
• Date of issue
Sept 2006

• Accepted
22 Mar 2006