| Brasil and Schochat(11), 2018 |
Effectiveness of auditory training using the Programa de Escuta no Ruído (PER) software in schoolchildren with auditory processing disorder and low academic performance |
Intervention research |
Programa de Escuta no Ruído (PER) - Software |
12 sessions of 50 minutes each |
Perception and discrimination, visual closure, figure-ground and visual memory |
Eighteen children aged 8 to 10 years, of both genders (13 boys and 5 girls), participated in this study. The pre-intervention evaluation consisted of a basic audiological assessment (meatoscopy, acoustic immittance, pure tone and vocal audiometry), an auditory processing assessment (speech in noise, PSI, SSW, frequency pattern), and a school performance test, which comprehensively assesses fundamental skills for school performance in the areas of reading, writing, and arithmetic. |
There was no statistically significant difference between the pre-intervention assessment and the reassessment of auditory processing after placebo training, but there was a statistically significant difference between the pre- and post-auditory training conditions. |
| Calarga et al.(12), 2018 |
Translation and cross-cultural adaptation of a listening in noise auditory training software to Brazilian Portuguese
|
Pilot study |
SoftwareCanadian Logiciel d'Écoute dans le Bruit – LEB |
14 to 18 sessions of 45 minutes each |
Sensory perception of the auditory signal also stimulates cognitive and linguistic skills, such as memory, attention, phonological awareness, lexical access, auditory comprehension and interpretation |
Forty-two schoolchildren aged 9 to 10 years participated in this study. All subjects underwent a hearing screening with a pediatric audiometer and were reassessed with the compressed speech test – disyllabic words – 70% compression, and answered a quantitative assessment questionnaire on the LEB. |
The questionnaire revealed that the LEB was well-received and stimulating, providing new learning opportunities. The GT showed significant improvements compared to the GC. |
| Boaz and Biaggio(13), 2020 |
Performance in computerized auditory training |
Longitudinal, comparative, clinical and experimental study |
Software- Active Listening |
12 sessions of 30 minutes each |
Figure-ground, temporal resolution and patterning, binaural integration and separation, and auditory discrimination |
The sample consisted of seven children, aged between 7 years and 8 years and 11 months, of both genders. The initial assessment for sample composition consisted of the following procedures: general history taking, visual inspection of the external auditory canal, pure tone audiometry, speech audiometry, acoustic immittance measurements, and behavioral assessment of the CAP. |
It was not possible to verify a significant difference between the pre- and post-training periods using the software's own evaluation stage, showing the need for further research studies to verify the use of this evaluation tool in a clinical environment. |
| Luís et al.(14), 2023 |
Auditory Processing Intervention Program for school-aged children – development and content validation
|
Cross-sectional, exploratory and descriptive study, with a quantitative approach |
Auditory Processing Intervention Program - PIPA |
Each game/task presents approximately 10 to 15 consecutive stimuli, and if the child achieves 75% accuracy, they can advance to the next level. The number and duration of sessions were not specified. |
Auditory discrimination, auditory attention, auditory memory, closure, figure-ground; binaural separation, binaural integration, and binaural fusion |
The first stage consisted of developing the program and its instruction manual, which included objectives, activities, procedures, materials, reinforcement, instructions, and verbal stimuli for the auditory skills of auditory discrimination, auditory attention, auditory memory, closure, figure-ground, binaural separation, binaural integration, and binaural fusion. The second stage consisted of content validation by two expert panels who analyzed the program using a questionnaire. Content validity was calculated using the content validity index. |
The study allowed the development and validation of an intervention program in auditory processing, with verbal stimuli, selected according to strict linguistic criteria, but without the presence of acceptability and effectiveness. |
| Jutras(15), 2018 |
Listening in noise training in children with auditory processing disorder: exploring group and individual data
|
Exploratory study |
Hearing training program in noise-Logiciel d' ecoute dans le bruit |
13 sessions of 30 minutes |
Auditory attention, auditory discrimination, auditory memory, auditory closure and temporal resolution |
Ten children with auditory processing disorder underwent an auditory training program in noise, and six children with auditory processing disorder comprised a control group. Before and after training, participants were tested on sentence identification in noise and auditory evoked late-latency responses. |
Hearing in noise may improve with training for children with auditory processing disorder. However, this training program may be beneficial for some children with auditory processing disorder, but not all. More data are needed to verify individual-level trends. |
| Moreira et al.(16), 2021 |
Acoustically uncontrolled cognitive and auditory training for elderly population: a case study |
Case study |
SoftwareeArena® |
Six 50-minute sessions |
Attention, memory, figure-ground for verbal sounds, temporal ordering and resolution, auditory closure, executive functions and motor praxis |
The study was carried out in three stages: (1) selection of materials, including existing materials and others created by the authors; (2) analysis by expert judges, for consensus regarding the skills evaluated and type of training; (3) application of the protocol in a clinical case, with a battery of tests for pre- and post-intervention evaluation, consisting of cognitive and auditory evaluation (behavioral and electrophysiological). |
The subject of the clinical case obtained improvements after the intervention and the effectiveness was verified through behavioral tests of central auditory processing, cognitive screening and long-latency auditory evoked potential. |
| Skarzynski et al.(17), 2023 |
The Stimulation of Polymodal Sensory Perception by Skarżyński (SPPS-S): comparison ofstationary and remote therapy results |
Intervention research |
Skarżyński's Polymodal Sensory Perception Stimulation - Telerehabilitation program |
Sessions lasting 5 to 15 days for 2 or 3 hours. |
Temporal discrimination and resolution, binaural integration and separation |
The data used to evaluate the effectiveness of SPPS-S-based therapy included the results of 100 patients who received remote SPPS-S therapy compared with the results of 100 patients who underwent therapy in a specialized center. The therapy typically consists of three levels: passive listening to specially modified sounds, relaxation, multimedia and psychoeducational games, and microphone work. |
The results confirm the high effectiveness of Skarÿyÿski's Polymodal Sensory Perception Stimulation, both in stationary form and implemented remotely. |
| Vendruscolo et al.(18), 2023 |
Cognitive Auditory Training: Comparative Impact of Telerehabilitation and In-person Training
|
Comparative study |
Online Cognitive Auditory Training Program |
10 web sessions |
Auditory closure, selective attention, binaural integration and separation |
The sample consisted of 23 children aged 7 to 9 years, of both genders, divided into two groups: Group I - 13 children undergoing telerehabilitation and Group II - 10 children undergoing auditory training in a soundproof booth. The instruments used were: Pediatric Speech Intelligibility Test (PSI) in ipsilateral competitive messages (ICM condition); Dichotic Digit Test (DD) in binaural integration and separation skills in auditory separation and integration skills. |
The data from this study show that the intervention through the Online Cognitive Auditory Training Program proposed and applied to school-age children contributes to the development and improvement of figure-ground auditory skills through selective attention, figure-ground skills for verbal sounds in the process of sustained attention and selective attention, and binaural integration as it explores cortical reorganization and plasticity. |
| Sakai et al.(19), 2020 |
Auditory abilities stimulation in preschoolers
|
Prospective, analytical and interventional |
Informal therapy using CDs with recorded sounds. |
8 sessions |
Sound localization and memory |
To evaluate the effects of the informal auditory training program intervention, the following procedures were performed pre- and post-intervention: meatoscopy, tympanometry and simplified assessment of central auditory processing. |
Comparison of preschoolers' performance in the test and retest revealed significant improvements in all auditory skills assessed. Preschoolers performed better in sound localization and worse in sequential memory of nonverbal sounds in both the test and retest. |