The occurrence of Diaretiella rapae parasitising Lipaphis erysimi and Brevicoryne brassicae in canola field (Brassica napus) was evaluated through two sample methods in Dourados-MS. The methods, used weekly, were: entomologic sweep net and plants sacking. The aphids population was observed from initial to the senescence plant development. Aphids were more abundant during the flowering phase, and they were usually located in the stems of the inflorescence and development fruits. In this phase the largest parasitism level for D. rapae (89,7%) occurred. The sample method with a sweep net captured significantly (t=4,484, P <= 0,01) more D. rapae while sacking method captured more parasitise aphids (t=2,199 with P <= 0,05) and active aphids (t=3,513, P <= 0,01).
Canola; Brassica napus; Diaretiella rapae; Parasitism; Lipaphis erysimi; Brevicoryne brassicae
Os índices de parasitismo de Diaretiella rapae em Lipaphis erysimi e Brevicoryne brassicae em uma cultura de canola (Brassica napus), foram avaliados através de dois métodos de amostragem em Dourados-MS. Os métodos utilizados, semanalmente, foram a varredura com rede entomológica e o ensacamento das plantas. A população de afídeos foi observada desde a fase de elongação até a senescência das plantas. Os afídeos foram mais abundantes no estádio de florescimento, sendo que nesta fase, localizavam-se preferencialmente nas hastes das inflorescência e frutos em desenvolvimento. Nesta fase ocorreram os maiores índices de parasitismo por D.rapae (89,7%). O método de varredura com rede entomológica capturou significativamente mais D.rapae (t = 4,484, P <= 0,01) enquanto que o método do ensacamento capturou maior número de afídeos parasitados (t=2,199, P<= 0,05) e afídeos ativos (t=3,513, P <= 0,01).
Canola; Brassica napus; Diaretiella rapae; Parasitism; Lipaphis erysimi; Brevicoryne brassicae
Occurrence of Diaretiella rapae (Mc´Intosh, 1855) (Hymenoptera: Aphidiidae) Parasitising Lipaphis erysimi (Kaltenbach, 1843) and Brevicoryne brassicae (L. 1758) (Homoptera: Aphididae) in Brassica napus in Mato Grosso do Sul
Rosilda Mara Mussury1* * Author for correspondence and Wedson Desidério Fernandes2
1UNIGRAN (Centro Universitário da Grande Dourados) Rua Balbina de Matos 2121-CP 79800-000, Dourados - MS, Brazil; 2UFMS/Campus de Dourados/Departamento de Ciências Exatas e Biológicas Dourados - MS, Brazil
The occurrence of Diaretiella rapae parasitising Lipaphis erysimi and Brevicoryne brassicae in canola field (Brassica napus) was evaluated through two sample methods in Dourados-MS. The methods, used weekly, were: entomologic sweep net and plants sacking. The aphids population was observed from initial to the senescence plant development. Aphids were more abundant during the flowering phase, and they were usually located in the stems of the inflorescence and development fruits. In this phase the largest parasitism level for D. rapae (89,7%) occurred. The sample method with a sweep net captured significantly (t=4,484, P £ 0,01) more D. rapae while sacking method captured more parasitise aphids (t=2,199 with P £ 0,05) and active aphids (t=3,513, P £ 0,01).
Key words: Canola, Brassica napus, Diaretiella rapae, Parasitism, Lipaphis erysimi, Brevicoryne brassicae
Canola (Brassica napus L.) was obtained by the genetic improvement of colza (Brassica oleracea L. and Brassica campestris L.). The insect pests are one of the main limiting factors of its productivity in Brazil, causing economic damages (Dias, 1992).
The inappropriate control of B. napus pest has many consequences, such as: population outbreak of certain species by the constant elimination of their predators and parasitoids, toxic residues, populations of resistance pest and pest ressurgence problems. According to Changer and Phadke (1994), many researchers recommended chemical controls system against aphids in order to prevent severe losses in the crop.
Insect pests and natural enemies occurence in colza crops are variable (Silva and Ruedell, 1984). Cruciferous aphid Brevicoryne brassicae L.,1758 (Homoptera: Aphididae) and green aphid Myzus persicae S.,1776 (Homoptera: Aphididae) are strongly attracted by sinigrin stimulant for the insects (Lara, 1979; Silva and Ruedell, 1984).
Among pests, B. brassicae had always been observed, causing accented damages in cabbage (Bortoli and Castellane, 1994). Its occurrence in the maturation phase was observed in small and dispersed colonies (Chouéne, 1986, Dias, 1992 and Domiciano, 1995). According to Link et al., (1982) B. brassicae occurred in the stuffing siliquas phase in not very numerous colonies, causing small reduction in the seeds yield. Hughes (1963) reported that B. brassicae and Lipaphis erysimi (Kaltenbach, 1843) were economically important pest, causing considerable damages to cruciferous corps.
Studies in Dourados-MS with the aphids and their natural enemies are important because they supply subsidies for the integrated management pests. Lipaphis erysimi, Brevicoryne brassicae and Myzus persicae have not been mentioned in that area (Souza-Silva and Ilharco, 1995), and Diaretiella rapae was described as the main primary parasitoid of cabbage aphid by several authors (Souza and Bueno, 1992, Pimentel, 1961 and Hagen and Van Den Bosch, 1968).
The objective of this was to study the aphids populational fluctuation associated to canola and its relation to the parasitism levels promoted by D. rapae in Dourados-MS.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The research was carried out at São Lourenço farm, highway MS 162, km 07 in Dourados-MS, Brazil (22o 14 ' S and 54o 49' W), in a 1 ha area with soil that originally presented natural vegetation with cultures such as corn, wheat, turnip, alfalfa, soybean, bean, and others. Cultivar CTC-4 seeds were planted on May 15 using 8 kg/ha of seeds (Brasil, 1992). During observation period, no chemical product was used for pest and weeds control.
Observations were made between June to September, reaching all phenological phases: rosette, elongation, flowering and maturation.
Insects were collected weekly at 4 pm with an entomologic sweep net. The samples were made at ten points (repetitions) in a distance of approximately eight meters one from each other. Captured insects were taken to the laboratory for posterior selection and identification.
Another method used for insects evaluation was the sacking plants. Ten plants were aleatorically sacked and totally removed from field. In the laboratory, the plants phenological phase and the insect specimens abundance were observed.
Insect population density was analyzed by calculating the average and the standard deviation of the individuals number in each phenological phase. The data were transformed to and "t" Student test was applied. Polinomial regression of the relationship percentage between parasitism in function of plant phenological phase and the average number of active aphids were also analyzed.
Climatic data were obtained by Centro de Pesquisa Agropecuária do Oeste, Embrapa-CPAO Dourados-MS.
Percentage of parasitism was calculated according to this formula:
We considered active aphids those that were active (mainly feeding and locomotion) and parasitise aphids were those with low activity and difficult to locomotion, due to parasitoid development. Aphids species observed in the samples were counted together.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The observed and identified aphids were: Lipaphis eysimi and Brevicoryne brassicae. Aphids population collected by entomologic sweep net increased during the elongation and flowering period (Figure 1) probably because of the low fecundity of winged individuals at the beginning of the invasions. These results agree with Wratten´s (1977) observations.
The absence of rain and temperatures around 22ºC during the increased period favored the reproduction and the populational growth of aphids; although predators such as coccinellids (Cycloneda sanguinea, Eriopis connexa, Coleomegilla maculata and Allograpta exotic) and the parasitoid D. rapae had been identified in the area.
D. rapae was the most common parasitoid during the aphids colonies installation period. According to Zuniga-Salinas (1982), this species prefers aphids from Brassica plants, although they have been observed in wheat. D. rapae, when closing to the aphid, touches it with antennas in different body areas. According to Hagen and Van Den Bosch (1968) that behavior had been observed in most Aphidiidae and the acceptance of the hosts for some parasites of that family required aphid movement.
It was observed that parasitoids emergence in the attacked aphids occurred usually in the posterior region of the body (aphid abdomen), cutting the abdominal cuticle with the mandibles in a rotative movement. The same process was also observed by Bueno and Souza (1992).
Temperature is a decisive factor in the biology of the aphids parasites, especially during the adult life, when it influences directly the longevity, mating and oviposition (Stary, 1970). From Figure 1, a synchronism between aphids population and the parasitoids could be observed. The increase of the aphids populational density favored the increase of D. rapae populational density. We observed an improvement in the parasitic activity of D. rapae reaching a level of 65.3% during the elongation phase. In this period, the mean temperature was 24.7ºC. In the flowering period (July 22), these occured a reduction in the mean temperature (from 21.8ºC to 12.2ºC), which might be responsible for a decreasing in the parasitoid population with the parasitism level dropped from 31.5% to 18.52%. During the same period (July 29), when the registered mean temperature was 24ºC, an increase in the active aphids density (AA) and a decrease in the parasite (PA) activity (Figure 1) was observed. D. rapae should probably be at a quiescence state, previously induced by the falls of the mean temperature (12.2ºC) (Figs 1 and 2).
Probably another factor that increased the populational density of D. rapae was the presence of the surrounding vegetation that maintained natural enemies reservoirs. D. rapae is a parasitoid of several aphids in grassland, cruciferous and ornamentals. The experimental area was surrounded by a corn field, turnip and wheat, probably part of D. rapae population migrated from those field to canola. The variation in the host number species was recognized as a strategy, allowing the parasites to occupy several microhabitats and not to suffer drastic populational reductions in the absence of a preferential host. It is important to point out that the percentage of native and diversified vegetation must be used for maintenance and protection of the natural enemy.
For sacking method reductions in aphid and protection of parasitoid populations were observed during flowering (July 22) with identical values for sweeping method, probably due to low temperature (Figure 3). This promoted leaves drying, resulting in an increase in the number of winged morphs individuals that when reached the adult phase, migrated and caused a reduction in the aphids numbers. By the sacking method, the attack of D. rapae reached 89.7% at the end of culture cycle. During this period there were not abrupt falls in temperature and this was a favorable factor to the multiplication of D. rapae and for which the reduction of the aphids population was attributed. Once with the end of the culture cycle, the senescence leaves no longer served as habitat.
Significant differences were observed between the results obtained by the sweeping method and the sacking one (Table 1). The method used for capturing the insects can be influenced by the insects behaviour and their location on the plant, besides the phenological culture stage. The sample method with a sweep net captured significantly more D.rapae while the sacking method provided satisfactory estimates of aphids populations that lived in groups and presented low mobility. This occurs because D. rapae has only free life in its adult phase which is winged and aphids have a low number of winged forms besides a low mobility or flight cited below.
It was observed that D. rapae population increased in agreement with the populational growth of its host, indicating that a positive correlation existed in the populational development of the two species (Figure 4). A positive correlation was also observed between the plant phenological phase and the percentage of parasitism caused by D. rapae (Figure 5).
With the plant growth an increase in flowers, fruits number, and aphids population was observed providing then an increase of the D. rapae population with an increment in the percentage of parasitism. The largest aphids population was observed during the flowering phase.
R. Mussury thanks Universidade Federal do Mato Grosso do Sul and CAPES the opportunity for doing her Master´s dissertation work. We also thank to Flávia Maria Margutti Ramos (ANGLO/UNIGRAN) on her help in the preparation of the manuscript.
Os índices de parasitismo de Diaretiella rapae em Lipaphis erysimi e Brevicoryne brassicae em uma cultura de canola (Brassica napus), foram avaliados através de dois métodos de amostragem em Dourados-MS. Os métodos utilizados, semanalmente, foram a varredura com rede entomológica e o ensacamento das plantas. A população de afídeos foi observada desde a fase de elongação até a senescência das plantas. Os afídeos foram mais abundantes no estádio de florescimento, sendo que nesta fase, localizavam-se preferencialmente nas hastes das inflorescência e frutos em desenvolvimento. Nesta fase ocorreram os maiores índices de parasitismo por D.rapae (89,7%). O método de varredura com rede entomológica capturou significativamente mais D.rapae (t = 4,484, P £ 0,01) enquanto que o método do ensacamento capturou maior número de afídeos parasitados (t=2,199, P£ 0,05) e afídeos ativos (t=3,513, P £ 0,01).
Received: December 23, 1999;
Revised: July 11, 2000;
Accepted: February 16, 2001.
- BortolI, S. A. de and Castellane, P. D. (1994), Controle químico do pulgão e curuquerê em repolho. Horticultura Brasileira, 12(2), 194-195.
- Brasil, Ministério da Agricultura e Reforma Agrária. (1992) Departamento Nacional de Produção Vegetal. Divisão de sementes e mudas. 188pp.
- Bueno, V. H. P. and Souza, B. M. de. (1992), Aspectos etológicos e longevidade de Diaretiella rapae M´Intosh,1855 (Hymenoptera/Aphidiidae), Revista de Agricultura, 67(1), 49-54.
- Changer, S. and Phadke, K. G. (1994), Economic injury levels of rapeseed (Brassica campestris) aphids (Lipaphis erysimi) determined on natural infestations and after different insecticide treatments. International Journnal Of Pest Management,,40(1), 107-110.
- Chouéne, C. E. (1986), Ocorrência e flutuação populacional de artrópodes associados à cultura da colza. In: Reunião Técnica Anual de Culturas Energéticas, Porto Alegre, Instituto de Pesquisas Agronômicas, 169-173.
- Dias, J. C. A. (1992), Canola/colza-alternativa de inverno com perspectivas de produção de óleo comestível e energético. Capão do Leão: EMBRAPA-CPATB. Boletim de Pesquisa, 3, Pelotas, 46pp.
- Domiciano, N. L. (1995), Levantamento e influência de épocas de semeadura na infestação de pragas da canola (Brassica napus x Brassica campestris) em Londrina - PR. In: Congresso Brasileiro de Entomologia, 15. Caxambú,. Anais , Lavras, SEB/ESAL, 181pp.
- Hagen, K. S. and Van Den Bosch, R. (1968) Impact of pathogens parasites, and predators on aphids. Annual Review of Entomology, 13, 325-384.
- Hughes, R. D. (1963), Population dynamics of the cabbage aphid Brevicoryne brassicae (L), J. Anim. Ecol., 32, 392-424.
- Lara, F. M. (1979), Princípios de resistência de plantas a insetos Piracicaba: Ed. Livroceres, 318pp.
- Link, D.; Costa, E. C.; Mario. J. L. and Tarragó, M. F. S. (1982), Entomofauna da colza. I. Insetos fitófagos. In: Reunião Anual de Programação de Pesquisa e de Assistência Técnica da Cultura da Colza, Porto Alegre, 11-12.
- Pimentel, D. (1961), Natural control of aphid populations on cole crops. Journal of Economic Entomology, College Park, 54(5), 885-888.
- Silva, M. T. B. da. and Ruedell, J. (1984), Comparação de três métodos de amostragem de insetos-praga e inimigos naturais em colza. In: : Reunião Anual de Programação de Pesquisa e de Assistência Técnica da Cultura da Colza. Pelotas, 17-23.
- Souza, B. M. de and Bueno, V. H. P. (1992), Parasitóide e hiperparasitóide de múmias de Brevicoryne brassicae (Linnaeus, 1758) (Hemiptera-Homoptera: Aphidiidae), Revista de Agricultura, 67(1), 55-62.
- Souza-Silva, C. R. and Ilharco, F. A. (1995), Afídeos do Brasil e suas plantas hospedeiras (lista preliminar), ed. UFSCar, 85pp.
- Stary, P. (1970), Biology of aphid parasites (Hymenoptera, Aphidiidae), With respect to integrated control. The Hague W. Junk., 575pp.
- Wratten, S. D. (1977), Reproductive strategy of winged and wingless morphs of the aphids Sitobion avenae and Metopolophum dirhodum Ann. Appl. Biol., 85: 319-331.
- Zuniga-Salinas, E. (1982), Controle biológico dos afídeos do trigo (Homoptera: Aphididae) por meio de parasitóides no planalto médio do Rio Grande do Sul, PhD Thesis, Brasil. UFPR-Curitiba, 319pp.
Author for correspondence
Publication in this collection
07 Oct 2002
Date of issue
16 Feb 2001
23 Dec 1999
11 July 2000