Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

MicroCT evaluation for CAD/CAM occlusal veneer fit using two materials and three cement space settings

Abstract

This study was aimed to evaluate the fit of occlusal veneer restoration for two CAD/CAM materials with different cement space settings, using microCT scans. Sixty resin dies were made and divided into two groups (n=30) according to the materials, (I): Hybrid all-ceramic, and (II): zirconia-reinforced lithium silicate glass-ceramic. Each group was subdivided into three subgroups (n=10) according to the cement space parameters (30, 40, and 50 µm). Occlusal veneers for the six subgroups were milled. A circle with 20 different sections was placed at the center of every scanned specimen to measure four different locations (Occlusal, Axial, Marginal, and Absolute marginal discrepancy). Data were analyzed using two-way ANOVA at a 0.05 level of significance. There was no statistically significant effect of material type on the mean values of internal and marginal gaps for the three cement space parameters (P>0.05). There were no statistically significant differences in the occlusal and axial gap between the cement space parameters, furthermore, there were statistically significant differences in marginal gap distances and absolute marginal discrepancies (P>0.05). Hybrid all-ceramic showed smaller marginal and internal discrepancies than zirconia-reinforced lithium silicate glass-ceramic without statistically significant differences, and, for both materials, 50 µm cement space significantly improved the marginal fit and absolute marginal discrepancy.

Key Words:
Occlusal veneer; marginal and internal gaps; cement space; microCT evaluation; CAD/CAM

Resumo

Este estudo teve como objetivo avaliar o ajuste da restauração de facetas oclusais para dois materiais CAD/CAM com diferentes configurações de espaço de cimento, usando microCT. Foram feitos sessenta moldes de resina e divididos em dois grupos (n=30) de acordo com os materiais, (I): cerâmica pura híbrida, e (II): cerâmica de vidro de silicato de lítio reforçada com zircónia. Cada grupo foi subdividido em três subgrupos (n=10), de acordo com os parâmetros do espaço de cimento (30, 40, e 50 µm). As facetas oclusais para os seis subgrupos foram fresadas. Um círculo com 20 secções diferentes foi colocado no centro de cada amostra digitalizada para medir quatro locais diferentes (Oclusal, Axial, Marginal, e discrepância marginal absoluta). Os dados foram analisados utilizando ANOVA bidireccional a um nível de significância de 0,05. Não houve efeito estatisticamente significativo do tipo de material nos valores médios das aberturas internas e marginais para os três parâmetros do espaço de cimento (P>0,05). Não houve diferenças estatisticamente significativas no intervalo oclusal e axial entre os parâmetros do espaço de cimento, além disso, houve diferenças estatisticamente significativas nas distâncias do intervalo marginal e discrepâncias marginais absolutas (P>0,05). A cerâmica pura híbrida mostrou discrepâncias marginais e internas menores do que a cerâmica de vidro de silicato de lítio reforçada com zircónia sem diferenças estatisticamente significativas, e, para ambos os materiais, 50 µm de espaço de cimento melhoraram significativamente o ajuste marginal e a discrepância marginal absoluta.

Introduction

Extensive destruction of occlusal enamel leads to loss of occlusal contacts and ultimately to the formation of parafunctional activities 11. Schlichting, LH; Resende, TH; Reis, KR; Magne, P Simplified treatment of severe dental erosion with ultrathin CAD-CAM composite occlusal veneers and anterior bilaminar veneers. J Prosthet Dent2016; 116:474-482.. The use of a full-coverage crown could be considered a debatable intervention as it involves additional loss of tooth structures for the already affected dentition 22. Varma, S; Preiskel, A; Bartlett, D The management of tooth wear with crowns and indirect restorations. British dental journal. Br Dent J2018; 224:343-347.. For this reason, occlusal veneer restoration represents an appropriate treatment modality 33. Guess, PC; Schultheis, S; Wolkewitz, M; Zhang, Y; Strub, JR Influence of preparation design and ceramic thicknesses on fracture resistance and failure modes of premolar partial coverage restorations. J Prosthet Dent2013; 110:264-273.,44. Muts, EJ; van Pelt, H; Edelhoff, D; Krejci, I; Cune, M. Tooth wear: a systematic review of treatment options. J Prosthet Dent2014; 112:752-759.,55. Ioannidis, A; Bomze, D; Hämmerle, CHF; Hüsler, J; Birrer, O; Mühlemann ,S. Load-bearing capacity of CAD/CAM 3D-printed zirconia, CAD/CAM milled zirconia, and heat-pressed lithium disilicate ultra-thin occlusal veneers on molars. Dent Mater2020; 36:109-116.. Improved CAD-CAM technologies and materials, contributed to the introduction of precise restorations with a reasonable fit for non-retentive conservative preparations with a minimal thickness which still enjoys excellent esthetic and mechanical properties 66. Magne, P; Magne, M; Belser, UC. Adhesive restorations, centric relation, and the Dahl principle: minimally invasive approaches to localized anterior tooth erosion. Eur J Esthet Dent 2007; 2:260-273..

Recently, hybrid ceramic material has been presented, characterized by its high degree of strength and elasticity, therefore, allowing to use of thinner restorations 77. Kurbad, A; Kurbad, S. A new, hybrid material for minimally invasive restorations in clinical use. Int J Comput Dent 2013; 16:69-79.,88. Awada, A; Nathanson, D. Mechanical properties of resin-ceramic CAD/CAM restorative materials. J Prosthet Dent2015; 114:587-593.,99. Mainjot, AK; Dupont, NM; Oudkerk, JC; Dewael, TY; Sadoun, MJ. From Artisanal to CAD-CAM Blocks: State of the Art of Indirect Composites. J Dent Res2016; 95:487-495.,1010. Furtado de Mendonca, A; Shahmoradi, M; Gouvêa, CVD; De Souza, GM; Ellakwa, A. Microstructural and Mechanical Characterization of CAD/CAM Materials for Monolithic Dental Restorations. J Prosthodont2019; 28:587-594.. Optimization of Lithium silicate glass-ceramic with approximately 10 wt % zirconia provides positive characteristics with improved translucency. It stands out as a new aesthetic, strong, and applicable material for dental CAD/CAM restorations 1111. Curran, P; Cattani-Lorente, M; Anselm Wiskott, HW; Durual, S; Scherrer, SS. Grinding damage assessment for CAD-CAM restorative materials. Dent Mater2017; 33:294-308.. In addition to preparation design, the impression technique, and the milling procedure, the digital cement space setting plays an important role in the marginal and internal accuracy of the CAD/CAM restorations 1212. Dauti, R; Lilaj, B; Heimel, P; Moritz, A; Schedle, A; Cvikl, B. Influence of two different cement space settings and three different cement types on the fit of polymer-infiltrated ceramic network material crowns manufactured using a complete digital workflow. Clin Oral Investig2020; 24:1929-1938.. Poor marginal adaptation can affect the integrity of the cement seal leading to caries, plaque accumulation, and finally, periodontal diseases. In addition, an increase in the internal gap could further decrease the fracture strength of ceramic restorations due to the different load concentrations in these areas 1313. Souza, RO; Ozcan, M; Pavanelli, CA; Buso, L; Lombardo, GH; Michida, SM. Marginal and internal dicrepancies related to margin design of ceramic crowns fabricated by a CAD/CAM system. J Prosthodont2012; 21:94-100..

Die spacers application has been effectively used for heat-press and lost-wax procedures to produce suitable marginal and internal gaps, allowing crown restorations to be fully seated. Crown restorations created with (CAD/ CAM) technologies, on the other hand, normally have their spacer thickness specified during the software's design phase. However, the most appropriate spacer thickness setting for proper occlusal veneer adaptation is uncertain 1414. Mously, HA; Finkelman, M; Zandparsa, R; Hirayama, H. Marginal and internal adaptation of ceramic crown restorations fabricated with CAD/CAM technology and the heat-press technique. J Prosthet Dent2014;112: 249-256.. To assess the marginal and internal adaptation, sample sectioning followed by microscopic evaluation was used, but this method is a destructive procedure in addition to the loss of some details of the samples 1515. Nawafleh, NA; Mack, F; Evans, J; Mackay, J; Hatamleh, MM. Accuracy and reliability of methods to measure marginal adaptation of crowns and FDPs: a literature review. J Prosthodont 2013; 22:419-228.,1616. Riccitiello, F; Amato, M; Leone, R; Spagnuolo, G; Sorrentino, R. In vitro Evaluation of the Marginal Fit and Internal Adaptation of Zirconia and Lithium Disilicate Single Crowns: Micro-CT Comparison Between Different Manufacturing Procedures. Open Dent J2018; 12:160-172.. The microcomputed tomography (microCT) scan is considered the most efficient and non-destructive investigational approach for both marginal and internal adaptations 1717. Kim, JH; Jeong, JH; Lee, JH; Cho, HW. Fit of lithium disilicate crowns fabricated from conventional and digital impressions assessed with micro-CT. J Prosthet Dent2016; 116:551-557..

This study was directed to assess the marginal and internal adaptation for occlusal veneer restoration using two types of CAD/CAM materials (zirconia-reinforced lithium silicate glass-ceramic and polymer-infiltrated ceramic network) with three different cement space settings (30 µm, 40 µm, and 50 µm), using microCT scans. The null hypotheses to be tested were that there are no differences in the marginal and internal adaptations between 11. Schlichting, LH; Resende, TH; Reis, KR; Magne, P Simplified treatment of severe dental erosion with ultrathin CAD-CAM composite occlusal veneers and anterior bilaminar veneers. J Prosthet Dent2016; 116:474-482. the two materials used to fabricate the occlusal veneer and 22. Varma, S; Preiskel, A; Bartlett, D The management of tooth wear with crowns and indirect restorations. British dental journal. Br Dent J2018; 224:343-347. the three tested digital cement space parameters.

Materials and methods

Tooth preparation

A typodont mandibular right first molar (KaVo Dental, Biberach, Germany) was prepared for occlusal veneers by a medium grit tapered diamond bur with a rounded end, using a milling machine (BEGO. PARASKOP, Bremen, Germany). The tooth was prepared as follows: 1.5 mm height extending from the margin to the occlusal plane, 1 mm circumferential rounded chamfer, and rounded Axio-gingival angle with 1.0 mm curvature radius 1818. Neves, FD; Prado, CJ; Prudente, MS; Carneiro, TA; Zancopé, K; Davi, LR. Micro-computed tomography evaluation of marginal fit of lithium disilicate crowns fabricated by using chairside CAD/CAM systems or the heat-pressing technique. J Prosthet Dent2014; 112:1134-1140.. 1.5 mm axial reduction with 6° tapering angle, 1.0-1.5 mm anatomically shaped occlusal reduction 1919. Elbadawy, AA; Elaziz, MHA; Alnazzawi, AA; Borzangy, SS. Effect of various digital cement space settings on the adaptation of CAD/CAM occlusal veneer "micro-ct evaluation". Dent mater j2021; 40:625-630.. (Figure 1) Finally, three dimples were made at the level of cementoenamel junction on mesial, distal, and buccal surfaces using round diamond bur) they were used as guides to standardize the position of the die and its corresponding occlusal veneer within the mold during scanning).

Figure. 1
Schematic representation for Occlusal veneer preparation guidelines.

Master die replication and sample grouping

60 resin master dies were made by replicating the prepared tooth using the Cerec inLab 3D system (Sirona, GmbH. D-64625 Bensheiu, German). The dies were randomly and equally assigned to two groups (n=30) according to the materials, group (I): zirconia-reinforced lithium silicate glass-ceramic (Vita Suprinity; VITA Zahnfabrik, Bad Säckingen, Germany), and group (II): Hybrid all-ceramic material (Vita Enamic, VITA Zahnfabrik, Bad Säckingen, Germany) (Table 1). Then, each group was subdivided into three equal subgroups (n=10) according to the cement space parameters (30, 40, and 50 µm) 1212. Dauti, R; Lilaj, B; Heimel, P; Moritz, A; Schedle, A; Cvikl, B. Influence of two different cement space settings and three different cement types on the fit of polymer-infiltrated ceramic network material crowns manufactured using a complete digital workflow. Clin Oral Investig2020; 24:1929-1938.,2121. Şeker, E; Ozcelik, TB; Rathi, N; Yilmaz, B. Evaluation of marginal fit of CAD/CAM restorations fabricated through cone beam computerized tomography and laboratory scanner data. J Prosthet Dent2016;115:47-51..

Table 1
Brands, abbreviations, description, composition, and manufacturers of the materials used in this study.

Digital impression, designing, milling, and crystallization

The master dies were homogenously sprayed using fluorinated hydrocarbon pigment suspension (Optispray, Sirona Dental Systems GmbH), then digital impressions of all master dies were made using the Cerec scanner (Ineos Blue scanner, Sirona Dental Systems GmbH). The same occlusal veneer design with identical external contours for all groups was made. A simulated cement space of 25 µm strap of 0.5 µm above the finish lines was designed, then, additional cement spaces of 30 µm, 40 µm, and 50 µm were set forming the following three tested subgroups for each type of material, a (25-30), B (25-40), and C (25-50) 1919. Elbadawy, AA; Elaziz, MHA; Alnazzawi, AA; Borzangy, SS. Effect of various digital cement space settings on the adaptation of CAD/CAM occlusal veneer "micro-ct evaluation". Dent mater j2021; 40:625-630.,2020. Kale, E; Seker, E; Yilmaz ,B; Özcelik ,TB. Effect of cement space on the marginal fit of CAD-CAM-fabricated monolithic zirconia crowns. J Prosthet Dent2016;116:890-895.,2121. Şeker, E; Ozcelik, TB; Rathi, N; Yilmaz, B. Evaluation of marginal fit of CAD/CAM restorations fabricated through cone beam computerized tomography and laboratory scanner data. J Prosthet Dent2016;115:47-51.,2222. Özçelik, TB; Yilmaz, B; Şeker, E; Shah, K. Marginal Adaptation of Provisional CAD/CAM Restorations Fabricated Using Various Simulated Digital Cement Space Settings. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2018;33:1064-1069..

After designing each type of occlusal veneer material, the data was sent to the Cerec in Lab milling unit (Sirona dental system GmbH. D-64625 Bensheim, German) for occlusal veneers milling. After the milling process, occlusal veneers for the vita suprinity samples were crystallized in program at the P310 furnace (Programat P310, Ivoclar Vivadent AG, Schaan/Liechtenstein). No adjustments were made to the ceramic veneers before marginal and internal adaptation measurements 1818. Neves, FD; Prado, CJ; Prudente, MS; Carneiro, TA; Zancopé, K; Davi, LR. Micro-computed tomography evaluation of marginal fit of lithium disilicate crowns fabricated by using chairside CAD/CAM systems or the heat-pressing technique. J Prosthet Dent2014; 112:1134-1140.,2323. Yildirim, G; Uzun, IH; Keles, A. Evaluation of marginal and internal adaptation of hybrid and nanoceramic systems with microcomputed tomography: An in vitro study. J Prosthet Dent2017;118:200-207..

Sample’s position standardization

To ensure standardization of the sample’s position during scanning, one master dies with its corresponding occlusal veneer placed in a mold with dimensions of 4X3X3 cm filled with light body polyvinyl siloxane (3M, ESPE, Express, Dental Products, St Paul, USA) from its buccal side until mesial and distal dimples are covered, then, a stainless steel wire (0.1mm) was embedded parallel to the longitudinal axis of the mesial side (used as a fixed starting reference point) 1919. Elbadawy, AA; Elaziz, MHA; Alnazzawi, AA; Borzangy, SS. Effect of various digital cement space settings on the adaptation of CAD/CAM occlusal veneer "micro-ct evaluation". Dent mater j2021; 40:625-630..

MicroCT Scan procedures

The occlusal veneers were seated onto their corresponding dies without any luting medium 2020. Kale, E; Seker, E; Yilmaz ,B; Özcelik ,TB. Effect of cement space on the marginal fit of CAD-CAM-fabricated monolithic zirconia crowns. J Prosthet Dent2016;116:890-895.. A circle with 20 different sections (wa ith 9° increase for each) was placed at the center of the standardized position of every scanned specimen 1919. Elbadawy, AA; Elaziz, MHA; Alnazzawi, AA; Borzangy, SS. Effect of various digital cement space settings on the adaptation of CAD/CAM occlusal veneer "micro-ct evaluation". Dent mater j2021; 40:625-630.,2424. Krasanaki, ME; Pelekanos, S; Andreiotelli, M; Koutayas, SO; Eliades, G. X-ray microtomographic evaluation of the influence of two preparation types on marginal fit of CAD/CAM alumina copings: a pilot study. Int J Prosthodont2012;25:170-172. as illustrated in (Figures 2 and 3) to measure four different locations as follow: -

[1] Occlusal gap: the mean of the three occlusal values: After dividing the length of the occlusal surface into four equal parts, one measurement at the middle and one at the middle of each half were taken.

[2] Axial gap: The mean of two right and left axial values: in the middle of axial walls.

[3] Marginal gap: The mean of two right and left marginal values at the middle of the finish line.

[4] Absolute marginal discrepancy value (AMD): The mean of two right and left distances between the margin of occlusal veneer and die margin 1212. Dauti, R; Lilaj, B; Heimel, P; Moritz, A; Schedle, A; Cvikl, B. Influence of two different cement space settings and three different cement types on the fit of polymer-infiltrated ceramic network material crowns manufactured using a complete digital workflow. Clin Oral Investig2020; 24:1929-1938.,1616. Riccitiello, F; Amato, M; Leone, R; Spagnuolo, G; Sorrentino, R. In vitro Evaluation of the Marginal Fit and Internal Adaptation of Zirconia and Lithium Disilicate Single Crowns: Micro-CT Comparison Between Different Manufacturing Procedures. Open Dent J2018; 12:160-172..

Images with a resolution of 9.77 μm /pixel were acquired from 20 slices and were used to measure four sites per slice (occlusal, axial, marginal, and absolute marginal discrepancy) with a total of 80 measuring values for each tooth 1212. Dauti, R; Lilaj, B; Heimel, P; Moritz, A; Schedle, A; Cvikl, B. Influence of two different cement space settings and three different cement types on the fit of polymer-infiltrated ceramic network material crowns manufactured using a complete digital workflow. Clin Oral Investig2020; 24:1929-1938.,2222. Özçelik, TB; Yilmaz, B; Şeker, E; Shah, K. Marginal Adaptation of Provisional CAD/CAM Restorations Fabricated Using Various Simulated Digital Cement Space Settings. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2018;33:1064-1069.. Each tooth was scanned using microCT (Viscom X8060, Viscom AG, Hannover, Germany) with the following setting parameters: Operation at 130 kV, tube current at 160 mA, a 5 - mm thick aluminum plate, 15 X magnification, 4.9 s exposure time.

Figure 2
Schematic representation for samples segmentation on the resin die.

Figuere 3
2D schematic representation for samples segmentation on the horizontal CT scan image.

Measurement procedures

The digital data were developed using reconstruction software (XVRCT, Viscom AG, software version 1.07), and converted into a tagged image file format (TIFF) for the subsequent segmentation (Definiens Developer XD 2.1.1, Definiens AG, Munich, Germany). Using (trabecular thickness) algorithm option by the image processing and analyzing software (Image J, FUJI); the absolute marginal discrepancy (AMD), marginal and internal adaptation have been measured (2525. Doube, M; Kłosowski, MM; Arganda-Carreras, I; Cordelières, FP; Dougherty, RP; Jackson, JS; et al. BoneJ: Free and extensible bone image analysis in ImageJ. Bone 2010;47:1076-1079.,2626. Schneider, CA; Rasband, WS; Eliceiri, KW. NIH Image to ImageJ: 25 years of image analysis. Nat Methods2012;9:671-675.,2727. Schindelin, J; Arganda-Carreras, I; Frise, E; Kaynig, V; Longair, M; Pietzsch, T; et al. Fiji: an open-source platform for biological-image analysis. Nat Methods2012;9:676-682..

Statistical analysis

The sample size and power analysis were calculated using statistical software (nQuery Advisor, version 7.0). The sample mean and standard deviation variance was 84.19 ± 13.69; accordingly, a sample size of 30 per group (10 per cement space parameter) was considered satisfactory to obtain a type I error for power more than 0.99 of alpha of 0.05.

Statistical analyses were performed with statistical software (IBM SPSS Statistics v22.0; IBM Corp). The Shapiro-Wilk test of normality confirmed that the data were normally distributed (P>.05).

A Two-way ANOVA test has been used to identify the main effect of material types and cement space settings on each site of measurement (Occlusal, Axial, Marginal and absolute marginal discrepancy) followed by One - way ANOVA with post hoc tests (LSD) for each effective variable (exhibited statistical significant difference) separately within cement space parameters.

Results

A total of 1200 images were obtained for all tested samples (20 sections X 60 samples), including ten occlusal veneer /subgroup and four measuring value /slice with 4800 measuring values. A summary of mean gap values, standard deviations, minimum and maximum gap values) in micrometer (µm) for both materials (Vita Enamic and Vita Suprinity) at the four tested sites (Occlusal, Axial, Marginal, and Absolute marginal discrepancy) for the three tested cement spaces (30, 40, and 50 µm) are shown in (Table 2).

Regarding the effect of material factor, the two-way ANOVA test indicated no statistically significant effect for the four tested locations (occlusal, axial, marginal, and absolute marginal discrepancy) (P -values = 0.121, 0.09, 0.233, and 0.168 respectively). (Table 3)

Regarding the effect of the cement spaces factor, the two-way ANOVA test indicated that there was no statistically significant effect for both occlusal and axial sites) (P-Value = 0.265 and 0.06 respectively) while there was a statistically significant effect for both marginal and absolute marginal discrepancy (P-Value = 0.00 for both). (Table 3)

Table 2
Descriptive means and standard deviations of internal and marginal gaps in micrometer (µm) for both materials at the four tested sites.
Table 3
Two - way ANOVA results for the main effect of materials and cement spaces factors

One-way ANOVA test for multiple comparison statistics at marginal and absolute marginal discrepancy revealed that from 30 to 40 µm cement spaces, there were no statistically significant differences in the gap distances for both tested materials (P values = 0.064 and 0.057 respectively for Vita Enamic) (P-values = 0.132 and 0.08 respectively for Vita Suprinity). From 30 to 50 µm and from 40 to 50 µm there were statistically significant differences in the gap distances for both tested materials (P values = 0.000). (Table 4 and Table 5)

Table 4
Multiple comparisons statistical results for cement spaces at the marginal gap and absolute marginal discrepancy for Vita Enamic.
Table 5
Multiple comparisons statistical results for cement spaces at the marginal gap and absolute marginal discrepancy for Vita Suprinity.

Discussion

The clinical significance of this study is that the outcomes may help in the clinical assessment of the least cement space setting providing optimal marginal adaptation for Hybrid all-ceramic, and zirconia-reinforced lithium silicate glass-ceramic occlusal veneers.

Based on the results of this study; cement space parameters only affected the marginal adaptation of occlusal veneer restorations, while, the type of material did not affect, so the null hypothesis would be partially rejected.

The material’s relationship with the luting agents plays an important role in the clinical success of occlusal veneer restorations 2828. Lima, JM; Souza, AC; Anami, LC; Bottino, MA; Melo, RM; Souza, RO. Effects of thickness, processing technique, and cooling rate protocol on the flexural strength of a bilayer ceramic system. Dent Mater2013;29:1063-1072.,2929. Rekow, ED; Silva, NR; Coelho, PG; Zhang, Y; Guess, P; Thompson, VP. Performance of dental ceramics: challenges for improvements. J Dent Res2011;90:937-952., therefore, the selection of the materials that were used in this study (polymer-infiltrated ceramic network and Zirconia reinforced lithium silicate) based on their capacity to be etched and bonded to the adhesives 3030. Santos, MJ; Freitas, MC; Azevedo, LM; Santos, GC Jr.; Navarro, MF; Francischone, CE; et al. Clinical evaluation of ceramic inlays and onlays fabricated with two systems: 12-year follow-up. Clin Oral Investig2016;20:1683-1690..

A previous study has postulated that the ideal value for marginal adaptation should be 100 to 200 µm to be clinically acceptable 3131. Renne, W; McGill, ST; Forshee, KV; DeFee, MR; Mennito, AS. Predicting marginal fit of CAD/CAM crowns based on the presence or absence of common preparation errors. J Prosthet Dent 2012;108:310-315.. Another study has considered that it should be less than 100 µm. 1515. Nawafleh, NA; Mack, F; Evans, J; Mackay, J; Hatamleh, MM. Accuracy and reliability of methods to measure marginal adaptation of crowns and FDPs: a literature review. J Prosthodont 2013; 22:419-228. Therefore, the results of marginal and internal gaps for all tested groups presented in this study can be considered clinically acceptable. The marginal gap values for this study were lower than those reported by other studies 1616. Riccitiello, F; Amato, M; Leone, R; Spagnuolo, G; Sorrentino, R. In vitro Evaluation of the Marginal Fit and Internal Adaptation of Zirconia and Lithium Disilicate Single Crowns: Micro-CT Comparison Between Different Manufacturing Procedures. Open Dent J2018; 12:160-172.,2020. Kale, E; Seker, E; Yilmaz ,B; Özcelik ,TB. Effect of cement space on the marginal fit of CAD-CAM-fabricated monolithic zirconia crowns. J Prosthet Dent2016;116:890-895.. These differences may be attributed to the differences in scanning accuracy, used materials, or preparation designs.

In this study, an extremely high resolution of microCT (9.77 μm) was used. The high resolution increases the contrast of the image layers, which subsequently improves the gap measurements. The microscopic evaluation inherently involves projection error due to the frontal view contrary to the sectional view used in microCT. Furthermore, the standard selection of measurement points around the multiple replicas is challenging 3232. Vág, J; Nagy, Z; Bocklet, C; Kiss, T; Nagy, Á; Simon, B; et al. Marginal and internal fit of full ceramic crowns milled using CADCAM systems on cadaver full arch scans. BMC oral health2020;20:189..

In the present study, the same reproduced die was used for each veneer, and standardized positions were used for scanning. To ensure the standardization of the computed tomography images for all slices, each die with its corresponding occlusal veneer was placed in a prefabricated special mold with thin stainless-steel wire (0.1mm) parallel to the longitudinal axis of the mesial side as a fixed starting reference point.

Manual adjustment of restorations after visual inspection could greatly decrease the marginal gap and AMD, but this technique was not applied in this study contrary to other studies 3333. Tabata, LF; de Lima Silva, TA; de Paula, Silveira, AC; Ribeiro, APD. Marginal and internal fit of CAD-CAM composite resin and ceramic crowns before and after internal adjustment. J Prosthet Dent2020;123:500-505.,3434. Gressler May, L; Kelly, JR; Bottino, MA; Hill T. Influence of the resin cement thickness on the fatigue failure loads of CAD/CAM feldspathic crowns. Dent Mater2015;31:895-900..

Polymer-infiltrated ceramic exhibited marginal and internal gap values lower than that for zirconia-reinforced lithium silicate ceramic without statistically significant differences, this may be attributed to reduced brittleness of polymer-infiltrated ceramic providing thin and smooth margin which enhances the milling procedure during manufacturing process unlike Zirconia reinforced lithium silicate, which retains their crystal structure and rupture during the milling process 1010. Furtado de Mendonca, A; Shahmoradi, M; Gouvêa, CVD; De Souza, GM; Ellakwa, A. Microstructural and Mechanical Characterization of CAD/CAM Materials for Monolithic Dental Restorations. J Prosthodont2019; 28:587-594..

The mean internal gap values of all tested groups did not imitate the designed cement spaces in the design software, this result is in accordance with that of the other studies 2323. Yildirim, G; Uzun, IH; Keles, A. Evaluation of marginal and internal adaptation of hybrid and nanoceramic systems with microcomputed tomography: An in vitro study. J Prosthet Dent2017;118:200-207.,3535. Prudente, MS; Davi, LR; Nabbout, KO; Prado, CJ; Pereira, LM; Zancopé, K; et al. Influence of scanner, powder application, and adjustments on CAD-CAM crown misfit. J Prosthet Dent 2018;119:377-383.. This may be attributed to the presence of premature contacts within the fitting surface which may change the proper seating of the occlusal veneer and consequently increase the internal and marginal discrepancies 2020. Kale, E; Seker, E; Yilmaz ,B; Özcelik ,TB. Effect of cement space on the marginal fit of CAD-CAM-fabricated monolithic zirconia crowns. J Prosthet Dent2016;116:890-895..

In agreement with other previous studies 2020. Kale, E; Seker, E; Yilmaz ,B; Özcelik ,TB. Effect of cement space on the marginal fit of CAD-CAM-fabricated monolithic zirconia crowns. J Prosthet Dent2016;116:890-895.,2323. Yildirim, G; Uzun, IH; Keles, A. Evaluation of marginal and internal adaptation of hybrid and nanoceramic systems with microcomputed tomography: An in vitro study. J Prosthet Dent2017;118:200-207.,3636. Shim, JS; Lee, JS; Lee, JY; Choi, YJ; Shin, SW; Ryu, JJ. Effect of software version and parameter settings on the marginal and internal adaptation of crowns fabricated with the CAD/CAM system. J Appl Oral Sci2015;23:515-522., the results of the present study revealed an inverse relationship between marginal gap distance and cement space distance with statistically significant differences among the different virtual cement space settings within the same type of material as the spacer setting compensates for the inaccuracies of the fabrication workflow (which may interfere with restoration’s complete seating) to minimize the marginal gap. Therefore, a lower spacer setting than factory recommendation may inversely increase the gap 3232. Vág, J; Nagy, Z; Bocklet, C; Kiss, T; Nagy, Á; Simon, B; et al. Marginal and internal fit of full ceramic crowns milled using CADCAM systems on cadaver full arch scans. BMC oral health2020;20:189..

The absolute marginal discrepancy is the distance between the preparation margin and restoration margin (It is the hypotenuse of a triangle whose sides are marginal gap and horizontal marginal overextension), therefore, it must be greater than or in an ideal state equal to the marginal gap 3737. Peroz, I; Mitsas, T; Erdelt, K; Kopsahilis, N. Marginal adaptation of lithium disilicate ceramic crowns cemented with three different resin cements. Clin Oral Investig2019;23:315-320.. This study revealed that increasing cement space setting from 30 µm to 50 µm resulted in a lower absolute marginal discrepancy, this result is in agreement with other studies 3636. Shim, JS; Lee, JS; Lee, JY; Choi, YJ; Shin, SW; Ryu, JJ. Effect of software version and parameter settings on the marginal and internal adaptation of crowns fabricated with the CAD/CAM system. J Appl Oral Sci2015;23:515-522.,3838. Zhang, Y; Dudley, J. The influence of different cement spaces on the marginal gap of CAD/CAM all-ceramic crowns. Aust Dent J2019;64:167-174..

Absolute marginal discrepancy values of this study were lower than those evaluated by Yildirim et al using vita Enamic crowns 2323. Yildirim, G; Uzun, IH; Keles, A. Evaluation of marginal and internal adaptation of hybrid and nanoceramic systems with microcomputed tomography: An in vitro study. J Prosthet Dent2017;118:200-207.. The explanation of this difference may be attributed to using a different type of restoration (occlusal veneers instead of full - coverage crowns)

Based on the microCT measurements, the comparison of the different virtual cement space settings for each material showed a statistically significant difference concerning the accuracy of fit. These results indicate that an increase in the cement space setting parameters improves the marginal fit. This result is in agreement with Shim et al 3636. Shim, JS; Lee, JS; Lee, JY; Choi, YJ; Shin, SW; Ryu, JJ. Effect of software version and parameter settings on the marginal and internal adaptation of crowns fabricated with the CAD/CAM system. J Appl Oral Sci2015;23:515-522..

In this study, axial mean gap values were lower than those at the occlusal surface. This is similar to other studies 3939. Zimmermann, M; Valcanaia, A; Neiva, G; Mehl, A; Fasbinder, D. Influence of Different CAM Strategies on the Fit of Partial Crown Restorations: A Digital Three-dimensional Evaluation. Oper Dent2018;43:530-538.,4040. Saab, RC; da Cunha, LF; Gonzaga, CC; Mushashe, AM; Correr, GM. Micro-CT Analysis of Y-TZP Copings Made by Different CAD/CAM Systems: Marginal and Internal Fit. Int J Dent 2018:5189767., the explanation of this difference may be attributed to that, that axial walls are milled with the side of the instrument bur. where the occlusal surface is milled with the tip of the bur.

The major disadvantage of microCT evaluation is the formation of radiation artifacts caused by the differences of radiation absorption coefficients between different materials during the evaluation of the gap distances 4141. Borba, M; Cesar, PF; Griggs, JA; Della Bona, Á. Adaptation of all-ceramic fixed partial dentures. Dent Mater2011;27:1119-1126., in addition to the presence of radiation artifacts, time consumption, a need for technical knowledge, and high cost 4242. de Paula Silveira, AC; Chaves, SB; Hilgert, LA; Ribeiro, AP. Marginal and internal fit of CAD-CAM-fabricated composite resin and ceramic crowns scanned by 2 intraoral cameras. J Prosthet Dent 2017;117:386-392.. Based on the results of this study, the following conclusions were drawn: 1. Vita enamic groups showed smaller marginal and internal discrepancies than vita suprinity groups without statistically significant differences. 2. The marginal and internal gap values were within the clinically acceptable range, and 3. For both vita enamic and vita suprinity occlusal veneer, 50 µm cement space significantly improved the marginal fit and absolute marginal discrepancy but had no statistically significant effect on the internal gap values.

References

  • 1
    Schlichting, LH; Resende, TH; Reis, KR; Magne, P Simplified treatment of severe dental erosion with ultrathin CAD-CAM composite occlusal veneers and anterior bilaminar veneers. J Prosthet Dent2016; 116:474-482.
  • 2
    Varma, S; Preiskel, A; Bartlett, D The management of tooth wear with crowns and indirect restorations. British dental journal. Br Dent J2018; 224:343-347.
  • 3
    Guess, PC; Schultheis, S; Wolkewitz, M; Zhang, Y; Strub, JR Influence of preparation design and ceramic thicknesses on fracture resistance and failure modes of premolar partial coverage restorations. J Prosthet Dent2013; 110:264-273.
  • 4
    Muts, EJ; van Pelt, H; Edelhoff, D; Krejci, I; Cune, M. Tooth wear: a systematic review of treatment options. J Prosthet Dent2014; 112:752-759.
  • 5
    Ioannidis, A; Bomze, D; Hämmerle, CHF; Hüsler, J; Birrer, O; Mühlemann ,S. Load-bearing capacity of CAD/CAM 3D-printed zirconia, CAD/CAM milled zirconia, and heat-pressed lithium disilicate ultra-thin occlusal veneers on molars. Dent Mater2020; 36:109-116.
  • 6
    Magne, P; Magne, M; Belser, UC. Adhesive restorations, centric relation, and the Dahl principle: minimally invasive approaches to localized anterior tooth erosion. Eur J Esthet Dent 2007; 2:260-273.
  • 7
    Kurbad, A; Kurbad, S. A new, hybrid material for minimally invasive restorations in clinical use. Int J Comput Dent 2013; 16:69-79.
  • 8
    Awada, A; Nathanson, D. Mechanical properties of resin-ceramic CAD/CAM restorative materials. J Prosthet Dent2015; 114:587-593.
  • 9
    Mainjot, AK; Dupont, NM; Oudkerk, JC; Dewael, TY; Sadoun, MJ. From Artisanal to CAD-CAM Blocks: State of the Art of Indirect Composites. J Dent Res2016; 95:487-495.
  • 10
    Furtado de Mendonca, A; Shahmoradi, M; Gouvêa, CVD; De Souza, GM; Ellakwa, A. Microstructural and Mechanical Characterization of CAD/CAM Materials for Monolithic Dental Restorations. J Prosthodont2019; 28:587-594.
  • 11
    Curran, P; Cattani-Lorente, M; Anselm Wiskott, HW; Durual, S; Scherrer, SS. Grinding damage assessment for CAD-CAM restorative materials. Dent Mater2017; 33:294-308.
  • 12
    Dauti, R; Lilaj, B; Heimel, P; Moritz, A; Schedle, A; Cvikl, B. Influence of two different cement space settings and three different cement types on the fit of polymer-infiltrated ceramic network material crowns manufactured using a complete digital workflow. Clin Oral Investig2020; 24:1929-1938.
  • 13
    Souza, RO; Ozcan, M; Pavanelli, CA; Buso, L; Lombardo, GH; Michida, SM. Marginal and internal dicrepancies related to margin design of ceramic crowns fabricated by a CAD/CAM system. J Prosthodont2012; 21:94-100.
  • 14
    Mously, HA; Finkelman, M; Zandparsa, R; Hirayama, H. Marginal and internal adaptation of ceramic crown restorations fabricated with CAD/CAM technology and the heat-press technique. J Prosthet Dent2014;112: 249-256.
  • 15
    Nawafleh, NA; Mack, F; Evans, J; Mackay, J; Hatamleh, MM. Accuracy and reliability of methods to measure marginal adaptation of crowns and FDPs: a literature review. J Prosthodont 2013; 22:419-228.
  • 16
    Riccitiello, F; Amato, M; Leone, R; Spagnuolo, G; Sorrentino, R. In vitro Evaluation of the Marginal Fit and Internal Adaptation of Zirconia and Lithium Disilicate Single Crowns: Micro-CT Comparison Between Different Manufacturing Procedures. Open Dent J2018; 12:160-172.
  • 17
    Kim, JH; Jeong, JH; Lee, JH; Cho, HW. Fit of lithium disilicate crowns fabricated from conventional and digital impressions assessed with micro-CT. J Prosthet Dent2016; 116:551-557.
  • 18
    Neves, FD; Prado, CJ; Prudente, MS; Carneiro, TA; Zancopé, K; Davi, LR. Micro-computed tomography evaluation of marginal fit of lithium disilicate crowns fabricated by using chairside CAD/CAM systems or the heat-pressing technique. J Prosthet Dent2014; 112:1134-1140.
  • 19
    Elbadawy, AA; Elaziz, MHA; Alnazzawi, AA; Borzangy, SS. Effect of various digital cement space settings on the adaptation of CAD/CAM occlusal veneer "micro-ct evaluation". Dent mater j2021; 40:625-630.
  • 20
    Kale, E; Seker, E; Yilmaz ,B; Özcelik ,TB. Effect of cement space on the marginal fit of CAD-CAM-fabricated monolithic zirconia crowns. J Prosthet Dent2016;116:890-895.
  • 21
    Şeker, E; Ozcelik, TB; Rathi, N; Yilmaz, B. Evaluation of marginal fit of CAD/CAM restorations fabricated through cone beam computerized tomography and laboratory scanner data. J Prosthet Dent2016;115:47-51.
  • 22
    Özçelik, TB; Yilmaz, B; Şeker, E; Shah, K. Marginal Adaptation of Provisional CAD/CAM Restorations Fabricated Using Various Simulated Digital Cement Space Settings. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2018;33:1064-1069.
  • 23
    Yildirim, G; Uzun, IH; Keles, A. Evaluation of marginal and internal adaptation of hybrid and nanoceramic systems with microcomputed tomography: An in vitro study. J Prosthet Dent2017;118:200-207.
  • 24
    Krasanaki, ME; Pelekanos, S; Andreiotelli, M; Koutayas, SO; Eliades, G. X-ray microtomographic evaluation of the influence of two preparation types on marginal fit of CAD/CAM alumina copings: a pilot study. Int J Prosthodont2012;25:170-172.
  • 25
    Doube, M; Kłosowski, MM; Arganda-Carreras, I; Cordelières, FP; Dougherty, RP; Jackson, JS; et al. BoneJ: Free and extensible bone image analysis in ImageJ. Bone 2010;47:1076-1079.
  • 26
    Schneider, CA; Rasband, WS; Eliceiri, KW. NIH Image to ImageJ: 25 years of image analysis. Nat Methods2012;9:671-675.
  • 27
    Schindelin, J; Arganda-Carreras, I; Frise, E; Kaynig, V; Longair, M; Pietzsch, T; et al. Fiji: an open-source platform for biological-image analysis. Nat Methods2012;9:676-682.
  • 28
    Lima, JM; Souza, AC; Anami, LC; Bottino, MA; Melo, RM; Souza, RO. Effects of thickness, processing technique, and cooling rate protocol on the flexural strength of a bilayer ceramic system. Dent Mater2013;29:1063-1072.
  • 29
    Rekow, ED; Silva, NR; Coelho, PG; Zhang, Y; Guess, P; Thompson, VP. Performance of dental ceramics: challenges for improvements. J Dent Res2011;90:937-952.
  • 30
    Santos, MJ; Freitas, MC; Azevedo, LM; Santos, GC Jr.; Navarro, MF; Francischone, CE; et al. Clinical evaluation of ceramic inlays and onlays fabricated with two systems: 12-year follow-up. Clin Oral Investig2016;20:1683-1690.
  • 31
    Renne, W; McGill, ST; Forshee, KV; DeFee, MR; Mennito, AS. Predicting marginal fit of CAD/CAM crowns based on the presence or absence of common preparation errors. J Prosthet Dent 2012;108:310-315.
  • 32
    Vág, J; Nagy, Z; Bocklet, C; Kiss, T; Nagy, Á; Simon, B; et al. Marginal and internal fit of full ceramic crowns milled using CADCAM systems on cadaver full arch scans. BMC oral health2020;20:189.
  • 33
    Tabata, LF; de Lima Silva, TA; de Paula, Silveira, AC; Ribeiro, APD. Marginal and internal fit of CAD-CAM composite resin and ceramic crowns before and after internal adjustment. J Prosthet Dent2020;123:500-505.
  • 34
    Gressler May, L; Kelly, JR; Bottino, MA; Hill T. Influence of the resin cement thickness on the fatigue failure loads of CAD/CAM feldspathic crowns. Dent Mater2015;31:895-900.
  • 35
    Prudente, MS; Davi, LR; Nabbout, KO; Prado, CJ; Pereira, LM; Zancopé, K; et al. Influence of scanner, powder application, and adjustments on CAD-CAM crown misfit. J Prosthet Dent 2018;119:377-383.
  • 36
    Shim, JS; Lee, JS; Lee, JY; Choi, YJ; Shin, SW; Ryu, JJ. Effect of software version and parameter settings on the marginal and internal adaptation of crowns fabricated with the CAD/CAM system. J Appl Oral Sci2015;23:515-522.
  • 37
    Peroz, I; Mitsas, T; Erdelt, K; Kopsahilis, N. Marginal adaptation of lithium disilicate ceramic crowns cemented with three different resin cements. Clin Oral Investig2019;23:315-320.
  • 38
    Zhang, Y; Dudley, J. The influence of different cement spaces on the marginal gap of CAD/CAM all-ceramic crowns. Aust Dent J2019;64:167-174.
  • 39
    Zimmermann, M; Valcanaia, A; Neiva, G; Mehl, A; Fasbinder, D. Influence of Different CAM Strategies on the Fit of Partial Crown Restorations: A Digital Three-dimensional Evaluation. Oper Dent2018;43:530-538.
  • 40
    Saab, RC; da Cunha, LF; Gonzaga, CC; Mushashe, AM; Correr, GM. Micro-CT Analysis of Y-TZP Copings Made by Different CAD/CAM Systems: Marginal and Internal Fit. Int J Dent 2018:5189767.
  • 41
    Borba, M; Cesar, PF; Griggs, JA; Della Bona, Á. Adaptation of all-ceramic fixed partial dentures. Dent Mater2011;27:1119-1126.
  • 42
    de Paula Silveira, AC; Chaves, SB; Hilgert, LA; Ribeiro, AP. Marginal and internal fit of CAD-CAM-fabricated composite resin and ceramic crowns scanned by 2 intraoral cameras. J Prosthet Dent 2017;117:386-392.

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    26 Aug 2022
  • Date of issue
    Jul-Aug 2022

History

  • Received
    05 Nov 2021
  • Accepted
    20 Apr 2022
Fundação Odontológica de Ribeirão Preto Av. do Café, S/N, 14040-904 Ribeirão Preto SP Brasil, Tel.: (55 16) 3602-3982, Fax: (55 16) 3633-0999 - Ribeirão Preto - SP - Brazil
E-mail: bdj@forp.usp.br