A artrite pode afetar a laringe com rouquidão e fadiga vocal. OBJETIVO: Avaliar as manifestações laríngeas da artrite reumatoide. MÉTODOS: Estudo prospectivo de 27 pacientes com artrite reumatoide por meio de videolaringoestroboscopia, avaliação perceptivo-auditiva da voz por meio da escala GIRBAS, análise acústica e questionário do Índice de desvantagem vocal. RESULTADOS: Queixas laríngeas foram descritas por 19 pacientes, principalmente disfonia intermitente e sensação de corpo estranho na garganta. O achado laringoscópico mais frequente foi o cavalgamento das aritenoides. Três pacientes apresentaram pitch considerada grave. Nove tiveram o grau de disfonia e rugosidade discretos. As medianas das medidas acústicas foram: F0, 198,39 Hz; Jitter, 0,815; Shimmer, 4,915; e NHR, 0,144. Em relação ao índice de desvantagem vocal, a mediana foi zero para todos os domínios. Existiu significância estatística relacionando a queixa vocal com todos os domínios desse índice. A classe funcional teve relação estatisticamente significante com: cavalgamento de aritenoides (p = 0,001), PPQ (p = 0,0257), Shimmer (p = 0,0295), APQ (p = 0,0195) e com o domínio físico e total do IDV (p = 0,0227 e p = 0,0425). CONCLUSÃO: Queixa laríngea foi referida por 70,4% dos pacientes e alterações laringoscópicas foram verificadas em 48%. A avaliação acústica da voz e a autopercepção mostraram-se alterados.
artrite reumatóide; laringe; laringoscopia; voz
Arthritis may affect the larynx and produce symptoms such as hoarseness and vocal fatigue. OBJECTIVE: This paper aimed to evaluate the laryngeal manifestations of rheumatoid arthritis. METHODS: This is prospective study assessed 27 patients with rheumatoid arthritis with the aid of videolaryngostroboscopy, auditory-perceptual analysis of the speech using the GIRBAS scale, acoustic analysis and the Voice Handicap Index questionnaire. RESULTS: Nineteen patients had laryngeal complaints, the main ones being intermittent dysphonia and sensation of a foreign body in the throat. The most frequent laryngoscopical finding was overlapping arytenoids. Three patients had low pitch, nine patients had mild dysphonia and roughness. Median acoustic measures were: F0, 198.39 Hz; Jitter, 0.815; Shimmer, 4.915; and NHR, 0.144. Regarding the Voice Handicap Index, the median score was zero in all domains. There was a statistically significant correlation between voice complaints and the domains of this index. Functional classes were significantly correlated to: overlapping arytenoids (p = 0.001), PPQ (p = 0.0257), Shimmer (p = 0.0295), APQ (p = 0.0195), and the VHI physical (p = 0.0227) and total domains (p = 0.0425). CONCLUSION: Laryngeal complaints were reported by 70.4% of the patients and laryngoscopical alterations were observed in 48% of the subjects. Voice acoustic evaluation and self-perception were altered.
arthritis, rheumatoid; laryngoscopy; larynx; voice
IMSc. Lusíada Foundation - Santos (Assisting Surgeon in the Head and Neck Surgery Service of the Santa Casa da Misericórdia de Santos, Ana Costa Hospital. Professor in the Lusíada Foundation Medical School)
IIAssistant Professor. Supervisor of the Larynx Group in the Department of Head and Neck Surgery of the Hospital of the Medical School of the University of São Paulo (MD)
IIIMSc. Heliópolis Hospital - São Paulo. (Head and Neck Surgeon, Santo Amaro Hospital - Guarujá and Municipality of São Vicente)
IVPhD - University of São Paulo. (Speech and Hearing Therapist in the Speech and Hearing Therapy of the Ana Costa Hospital in Santos and Heliópolis Hospital in São Paulo)
VMSc. - Heliópolis Hospital - São Paulo (Speech and Hearing Therapist - Head and Neck Surgery Service of the Santa Casa da Misericórdia and Ana Costa Hospital in Santos)
Send correspondence to
Arthritis may affect the larynx and produce symptoms such as hoarseness and vocal fatigue.
OBJECTIVE: This paper aimed to evaluate the laryngeal manifestations of rheumatoid arthritis.
METHODS: This is prospective study assessed 27 patients with rheumatoid arthritis with the aid of videolaryngostroboscopy, auditory-perceptual analysis of the speech using the GIRBAS scale, acoustic analysis and the Voice Handicap Index questionnaire.
RESULTS: Nineteen patients had laryngeal complaints, the main ones being intermittent dysphonia and sensation of a foreign body in the throat. The most frequent laryngoscopical finding was overlapping arytenoids. Three patients had low pitch, nine patients had mild dysphonia and roughness. Median acoustic measures were: F0, 198.39 Hz; Jitter, 0.815; Shimmer, 4.915; and NHR, 0.144. Regarding the Voice Handicap Index, the median score was zero in all domains. There was a statistically significant correlation between voice complaints and the domains of this index. Functional classes were significantly correlated to: overlapping arytenoids (p = 0.001), PPQ (p = 0.0257), Shimmer (p = 0.0295), APQ (p = 0.0195), and the VHI physical (p = 0.0227) and total domains (p = 0.0425).
CONCLUSION: Laryngeal complaints were reported by 70.4% of the patients and laryngoscopical alterations were observed in 48% of the subjects. Voice acoustic evaluation and self-perception were altered.
Keywords: arthritis, rheumatoid, laryngoscopy, larynx, voice.
Since the paper by Mackenzie, in 18941, rheumatism has been correlated to laryngeal involvement and symptoms such as hoarseness and vocal fatigue, and occasionally severe glottic obstruction. In this sense, ankylosis of the cricoarytenoid joint (CJ) was believed to be a much more common disease than what is generally supposed2.
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) may lead to significant distortion and ankylosis of the CJ. The main mechanism that limits joint function is the unilateral or bilateral fixation of the vocal fold by ankylosis consequent to RA. Laryngeal examination may not reveal anything, but it should be done to find out whether there is CJ involvement in RA cases3. The following signs have been described: hyperemia and edema of the mucosa covering the CJ; the CJ may become disorganized and the joint ankylosed in a deforming position; and the fixation of one or both vocal folds may occur medially4.
These patients may present altered acoustic voice analysis results (disturbed amplitude), a finding connected to the presence of rheumatic nodes on the vocal folds and edema5.
Prevalence rates of dysphonia in patients with rheumatoid arthritis ranges between 12% and 27%6. The more active rheumatoid arthritis is, the higher is the voice handicap index (VHI) presented by the patients7.
In this paper videolaryngostroboscopy was used to assess laryngeal alterations secondary to RA and perceptive-auditory, acoustic, and self-perception of voice handicap tests were applied to analyze voice alterations voice alterations.
This study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of our institution and given permit nº CEP - 024/2009.
This prospective study enrolled 27 patients with rheumatoid arthritis seen between January and August of 2010. Patients were recruited consecutively in the rheumatology ward of the institution.
The sample consisted of 27 female patients, 23 Caucasians and four non-Caucasians. Ages ranged between 33 and 76 years. One patient was a heavy smoker. Rheumatoid factor blood tests were positive for all patients at some moment in the course of the disease. Table 1 describes patient characteristics.
The revised ACR-91 criteria used to categorize the functional status of RA patients are: class I - able to perform usual activities of daily living (self-care, vocational, and avocational); class II - able to perform usual self-care and vocational activities, but limited in avocational activities; class III - able to perform usual self-care activities but limited in vocational and avocational activities; class IV - limited in ability to perform usual self-care, vocational, and avocational activities.
In order to be enrolled in the study, patients had to be at least 20 years old at the time of symptom onset and be categorized on RA functional classes I, II or III (ACR-91). Exclusion criteria included previous orotracheal intubation for 24 hours or more, documented head and neck cancer, larynx surgery, neck trauma, head and neck radiotherapy, central or peripheral neurologic disorders, and having collagenose other than RA.
Patients were required to answer a questionnaire as part of the assessment protocol including the following: 1) Identification data; 2) Data on rheumatoid arthritis (time of disease, association with Sjörgen's syndrome, other associated diseases, functional categorization, extra-articular manifestations, and therapy; 3) Laryngeal complaints. Part of the data was gathered from the patients' charts and from their attending rheumatologists.
Videolaryngostroboscopy was performed using a rigid Karl Storz® de 70º scope connected to a Kay Elemetrics® RLS 9100 B stroboscope and a Toshiba CCD (charge-coupled device) IK-M41A camera. Images were visualized on a Sony KV-1311 CR video monitor and recorded using a Sony NS67P DVD recorder. Examination was carried out under sustained emission of vowels /e/ and /i/ in modal sounds and at a comfortable volume.
The data sets recorded on DVD were analyzed independently by two ENT and Head and Neck Surgery specialists with experience in laryngostroboscopy. Reports were then analyzed and a mean score was produced and considered as the standard for each studied parameter. The observed parameters were aspect of the free border, glottic closure, predominant glottic cycle phase, vertical level of approximation, range of motion, mucosal wave, phase symmetry, periodicity, arytenoid assessment, hyperfunction, site of mucosal wave, aspect of mucosa, and mucus formation8. Additionally, the following vocal fold lesions were considered: telangiectasia9, arytenoid edema, bamboo nodes, hyperemia, and reduced vocal fold mobility10. Data sets were assessed in a semi-quantitative fashion.
Patients were asked to sustain vowel /a/ in their usual tone and intensity, to count from one to ten, and to produce a segment of connected speech for the purposes of perceptive-auditory and acoustic voice analysis. A Shure® PG 48 professional microphone was used.
Voice acoustic analysis included computer-based acoustic measurements made using software program MDVP (Multi Dimensional Voice Program) by Kay Elemetrics®. Voice quality was assessed using the GRBASI scale for voice perceptive-auditory analysis11,12. The GRBASI scale is made up of six parameters: G - grade of dysphonia; R - roughness; B - breathiness; A - asthenia; S - strain e I - instability. All parameters were assessed for their absence of presence and degree of severity, namely: 0 - absent; 1 - mild; 2 - moderate e 3 - severe.
The following parameters were considered in acoustic analysis: a) fundamental frequency (F0); b) frequency and amplitude perturbation measurements: jitter (%), PPQ (pitch perturbation quotient), shimmer (%); and APQ (amplitude perturbation quotient); c) noise measurements: NHR (noise-to-harmonic-ratio); and VTI (voice turbulence index).
Pitch was assessed as adequate, low, or high; resonance was categorized as balanced, laryngopharyngeal, or hypernasal; and speech modulation, articulation, and pneumophonoarticulatory coordination were assessed as adequate or abnormal, and the degree of abnormality was graded as mild, moderate, or severe. Parameters were judged by three speech therapists each with over five years of experience in treating patients with dysphonia.
The voice handicap index (VHI) questionnaire was used to assess the subjects' sepf-perception of voice handicap. The questionnaire is divided into three domains - functional, physical, and emotional - each containing ten questions with scores ranging from zero to four, zero being the highest and four the lowest score. Each domain's score is defined by the summation of the answers given by the patients and the final score is defined based on the summation of the scores of the three domains. Final scores may range between zero to 120 points. Thus, the higher the score the more severe is the voice handicap. Scores between zero and 40 indicate mild or absent impact; 41 to 60 means moderate impact; and 61 to 100 suggest severe impact13-15.
The data gathered from laryngoscopy, self-perceptive and acoustic voice assessment, and VHI were tested for possible correlations with time of RA, RA class, and larynx complaints.
Measures of central tendency and variability were used to describe numeric variables (age, time of RA, acoustic measurements, and VHI) and category frequency distribution (grade of dysphonia, RA class, Sjörgen's, laryngoscopy data, and voice variables).
The Mann-Whitney U test was used to verify the association between numeric variables (measurements) and the groups with two categories, while the Kruskal-Wallis test was used for groups with three categories. Fisher's exact test was used to compare categorical variables on 2x2 tables.
A significance level of 5% was adopted in all statistical tests. Software program STATA version 7.0 was used in statistical analysis.
Laryngoscopy indicated that only two patients had closure predominantly in the open phase. In terms of overriding arytenoids, five patients had positional asymmetry in adduction. In all cases the glottic wave was situated in the glottis. The mucosal wave was dry in two patients and with edema in four subjects. Overriding arytenoids were the only laryngoscopy parameter statistically correlated to RA class.
In perceptive-auditory assessment, three of the 27 patients had low pitch. Nine had mild dysphonia and roughness. None had asthenia and one had mild breathiness. Six patients had mild vocal strain and five had mild vocal instability. Fourteen patients had balanced and 13 had laryngopharyngeal resonance. Twelve subjects had present phonatory effort (Table 4). Almost all acoustic analysis variables were altered (Table 5).
Only a few patients reported abnormalities in the complaints related to the vocal handicap index (VHI), but the three domains - functional (VHI-F), physical (VHI-P), and emotional (VHI-E) - were statistically correlated to dysphonia.
Acoustic analysis results were statistically correlated to RA class, PPQ, shimmer, and APQ. RA class was statistically related to the physical domain of VHI and the total VHI score.
Although well known, laryngeal involvement in rheumatoid arthritis is variable and its symptoms less obvious than its pathological manifestations16,17.
In our study, larynx complaints were reported by 19 of the 27 patients (70.4%). The most common symptoms were dysphonia and sensation of a foreign body in the throat, followed by vocal fatigue and xerostomy. There was no statistical correlation between time of RA and the other studied parameters, possibly due to the lack of a linear correlation between functional class and time of disease. Such correlation could have been elicited if the series were larger. Despite the lack of statistical significance, patients with complaints of dysphonia had RA for longer. In acoustic analysis the worse results were seen in patients with RA for longer than 10 years.
Gairola et al.18 studied 50 Indian patients with classic RA, 42 females and eight males. Mean duration of RA was 37 years. Most subjects (92%) were on functional classes II and III. Six patients (12%) had symptoms suggestive of laryngeal involvement according to laryngoscopical examination. Mucosal thickening and irritation above the arytenoids were the most commonly seen signs. Only one patient had evidences of acute involvement, with edema and hyperemia in the arytenoids and reduced left vocal fold mobility.
In our series ages ranged between 33 and 76 years (mean age 55.2 years). Only one of the subjects was a chronic smoker. Time of clinical history varied from one to 36 years. Five patients also had Sjörgen's syndrome. In terms of functional categorization (ACR-9119), thirteen subjects were on class II, eight on class I, and six on class III. Nine of the 27 patients complained of dysphonia (33.3%).
A wide range of laryngoscopical findings has been described in the literature20-25. Overriding arytenoids was the main laryngoscopical finding in this study, and five patients had positional asymmetry. Other frequent findings were arytenoid edema, anterior cleft, and angiodysgenesis. No statistical correlation was found between laryngostroboscopy findings and time of disease and complaint of dysphonia. However, a statistical correlation was identified between RA class and the laryngostroboscopy finding of overriding arytenoid cartilages. Indeed, overriding occurs as a consequence of CJ arthritis and ankylosis, and such finding develops as the disease progresses.
Five of the seven patients with overriding arytenoids presented increased phonatory effort, six had increased APQ, and all had increased shimmer, NHR, and VTI.
According to the tests performed, three (11.1%) of the 27 patients had low pitch. Nine had mild dysphonia and mild roughness. None had asthenia or breathiness. Six subjects (22.2%) had mild vocal strain and five had mild vocal instability. Fourteen patients (51.8%) had balanced and 13 (48.2%) had laryngopharyngeal resonance. Twelve subjects (44.4%) had present phonatory effort.
Alterations in vocal acoustic analysis (amplitude disturbances) have been reported in patients with rheumatic nodes and vocal fold edema. In our series, when voice acoustic analysis findings were considered along with RA class (grouping subjects on classes II and III and comparing them to class I individuals),time of disease, and complaint of dysphonia, statistical correlations between functional class and PPQ, shimmer, and APQ were found.Jitter, NHR, and VTI values were higher in patients on functional classes II and III than in subjects on functional class I.
The clinical diagnosis of CJ arthritis is challenging, and is not always connected to disease activity26. Other authors disagree, as in their series the more active RA was, the greater was the vocal handicap index presented by their patients7. In a certain study, the number of subjects with VHI scores greater than zero and some degree of dysphonia was significantly greater than the number seen in the control group. The exception being the emotional domain, in which the total scores of the control group was greater than that of the case group6.
Our study revealed statistical correlations between VHI (physical and total) scores and RA class, and VHI (all domains) scores and complaint of dysphonia. This may be explained by the fact that the VHI is a self-perception vocal handicap index. One of the patients had significantly higher VHI scores when compared to the rest of the series, with possible impacts upon the resulting statistical analysis.
The findings in this study are exploratory. Given the characteristics of the sample, comparisons were made without statistical adjustments and may contain false-positive findings - type I error; the sample size was not calculated and many comparisons may have low statistical power, possibly resulting in type II error.
As an explanation for "omitted diagnosis", RA patients have many evident generalized signs and symptoms, such as disturbed joints, severe pain related to arthritis in many parts of their bodies, which may shadow the laryngeal symptoms produced by CJ arthritis3. Additionally, the sedentary way of life of these patients makes them adapt to the disease's alterations24. However, considering state-of-the-art diagnostic tests and the development of a better understanding over laryngeal manifestations of RA, laryngeal involvement by RA is frequent, but not always accompanied by symptoms and apparently not associated with chronic disease.
Complaint of dysphonia was reported by 70.4% of the subjects. Dysphonia and sensation of a foreign body in the throat (33.3%) were the most common complaints. Laryngoscopical alterations were observed in 48% of the patients. Voice acoustic tests and self-perception based on VHI had altered results. Statistically significant correlations were found between complaint of dysphonia and and all VHI domains; disease functional class was correlated with: arytenoid overriding, acoustic measurements of PPQ, shimmer, and APQ, and physical and total domains in VHI.
- 1. Mackenzie GH. Rheumatism of the larynx. Edinb Med J. 1894;40:507-9.
- 2. Harris JT. Anchylosis of the cricoarytenoid articulation with the report of a case presenting involvement of both joints and requiring tracheotomy. Laryngoscope. 1919;29(3):139-43.
- 3. Grossman A, Martin JR, Root HS. Rheumatoid arthritis of the crico-arytenoid joint. Laryngoscope. 1961;71:530-44.
- 4. Bayar N, Kara SA, Keles I, Koç C, Altimok D, Orkun S. Cricoarytenoiditis in rheumatoid arthritis: radiologic and clinical study. J Otolaryngol. 2003;32(6):373-8.
- 5. Wojnowski W, Karlik M, Wiskirska-Woznica B, Walczak M. Voice disorders in rheumatoid arthritis. Otolaryngol Pol. 2005;59(4):603-6.
- 6. Speyer R, Speyer I, Heijnen MA. Prevalence and relative risk of dysphonia in rheumatoid arthritis. J Voice. 2008;22(2):232-7.
- 7. Fisher BA, Dolan K, Hastings L, McClinton C, Taylor PC. Prevalence of subjective voice impairment in rheumatoid arthritis. Clin Rheumatol. 2008;27(11):1441-3.
- 8. Cruz WP, Dedivitis RA, Rapoport A, Guimarães AV. Videolaryngostroboscopy following frontolateral laryngectomy with sternohyoid flap. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2004;113(2):124-7.
- 9. Fayos JV. Carcinoma of the endolarynx: results of irradiation. Cancer. 1975;35(6):1525-32.
- 10. Chatani M, Matayoshi Y, Masaki N. Radiation therapy for larynx carcinoma: long-term results of stage I glottic carcinoma. Strahlenther Onkol. 1993:169(2):102-6.
- 11. Hirano M. Clinical examination of voice. New York: Springer-Verlag; 1981. p.81-4.
- 12. Dejonckere PH, Remacle M, Fresnel-Elbaz E. Reliability and relevance of differentiated perceptual evaluation of pathological voice quality. In: Clement MP (Ed.): Voice Update. Amsterdam: Elsevier; 1996. p.321-4.
- 13. Jacobson BH, Johnson A, Grywalski C, Silbergleit A, Jacobson G, Benninger MS, et al. The Voice Handicap Index (VHI). Development and validation. Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 1997;6(3):66-70.
- 14. Santos LM, Gasparini G, Behlau M. Validação do protocolo do Índice de Desvantagem Vocal (IDV) no Brasil [monografia]. São Paulo: Centro de Estudos da Voz; 2007.
- 15. Moerman M, Pieters G, Martens JP, Van der Borgt MJ, Dejonckere P. Objective evaluation of the quality of substitution voices. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2004;261(10):541-7.
- 16. Gardner DL, Holmes F. Anaesthetic and postoperative hazards in rheumatoid arthritis. Br J Anaesth. 1961;33:258-64.
- 17. Bienenstock H, Ehrlich GE, Freyberg RH. Rheumatoid arthritis of the cricoarytenoid joint: a clinicopathologic study. Arthritis Rheum. 1963;6:48-62.
- 18. Gairola A, Kacker S, Kumar A, Malaviya A. Laryngeal and ear involvement in rheumatoid arthritis in north India. Br J Rheumatol. 1991;30(1):65-6.
- 19. Stucki G, Stoll T, Brühlmann P, Michel BA. Construct validation of the ACR 1991 revised criteria for global functional status in rheumatoid arthritis. Clin Exp Rheumatol. 1995;13(3):349-52.
- 20. Montgomery WW, Loefgren RH. Usual and unusual causes of laryngeal arthritis. Arch Otolaryngol. 1963;77:29-33.
- 21. Pinals RS. Rheumatoid arthritis presenting with laryngeal obstruction. Brit Med J. 1966;1(5491):842.
- 22. Harris ER Grossmann A, Martin JR. Cricoarytenoid joint involvement in rheumatoid arthritis: its detection and manifestation. Arthritis Rheum. 1973;16:553.
- 23. Lawry GV, Finerman ML, Hanafee WN, Mancuso AA, Fan PT, Bluestone R. Laryngeal involvement in rheumatoid arthritis. A clinical, laryngoscopic, and computerized tomographic study. Arthritis Rheum. 1984;27(8):873-82.
- 24. Geterud A. Rheumatoid arthritis in the larynx. Scand J Rheumatol. 1991;20(3):215.
- 25. Charlin B, Brazeau-Lamontagne L, Levesque RY, Lussier A. Cricoarytenoiditis in rheumatoid arthritis: comparison of fibrolaryngoscopic and high resolution computerized tomo) ;ic findings. J Otolaryngol. 1985;14(6):381-6.
- 26. Brooker DS. Rheumatoid arthritis: otorhinolaryngological manifestations. Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci. 1988;13(3):239-46.
Videolaryngostroboscopy and voice evaluation in patients with rheumatoid arthritis
Mario Augusto Ferrari de CastroI; Rogério Aparecido DedivitisII; Elio Gilberto Pfuetzenreiter JúniorIII; Ana Paula Brandão BarrosIV; Débora dos Santos QueijaV
Publication in this collection
24 Oct 2012
Date of issue
10 June 2012
10 Aug 2012