| Kleiner et al.47 Canada, 2024 |
To examine physiotherapists’ perceptions of what constitutes a “good” PT. |
12 PTs (6 F and 6 M) working in Canada. At least one year of experience in CMP. |
Semi-structured interviews. |
Hermeneutic phenomenological analysis. |
PTs highlighted the understanding of patients' perspectives, collaborating on their goals, and adapting treatment plans to individual needs. They aimed to balance scientific knowledge with personalized care, ensuring treatments are tailored to each patient. They also strived to be responsive to patients by actively listening to their stories, validating their experiences, and being attentive, open, patient, and empathic, with a focus on understanding patients from a BPS perspective. |
| Kleiner et al.46 Canada, 2023 |
To explore experienced CMP practitioners’ perceptions of “responsiveness” in the practice of a “good” PT. |
12 PTs (6 F and 6 M) working in Canada. At least one year of experience in CMP. |
Semi-structured interviews. |
Hermeneutic phenomenological analysis. |
PTs were concerned about acknowledging and individualizing care based on each patient's unique situation, personality, pain threshold, and interpretations of their experience. Being person-centered emerged as a crucial attribute of a good physiotherapist, characterized by responsiveness to the uniqueness of each patient. |
| Parchment et al.45 United Kingdom, 2023 |
To qualitatively explore PTs’ experiences and acceptability of implementing “Making Every Contact Count Healthy Conversation Skills” in routine practice with patients with CMP. |
11 PTs (9F and 2 M) working in the UK. Without specifying the time of experience in CMP. |
Semi-structured interviews. |
Reflexive thematic analysis. |
PTs emphasized the importance of allowing patients to speak and be heard, making the individual feel more valued and involved in the treatment. They also seek to understand the patient’s unique circumstances when tailoring interventions. PTs, as well, valued patients' knowledge and experiences, seeking to make adaptations on their lifestyle and fostering greater self-awareness. |
| Chala et al.38 Ethiopia, 2022 |
To explore how health care providers understand and conceptualize self-management and how they provide self-management support for people with NSLBP in Ethiopia. |
12 PTs and 12 doctors (7 F and 17 M) working in Ethiopia. Without specifying the time of experience in CMP. |
Semi-structured interviews. |
Inductive thematic analysis. |
PTs commented on the importance of recognizing and validating the patient's own pain management strategies, as well as the importance of offering personalized and individual-specific self-management support. They also highlighted the performance of a BPS assessment and the concern to adapt the language according to the patient's context. |
| Hutting et al.36 Netherlands, 2020 |
To investigate the ideas, opinions and methods used by PTs and exercise therapists regarding self-care and self-management support for patients with chronic NSLBP. |
38 PTs (14F and 17M) and seven exercise therapists (3F and 4M) working in the Netherlands. Experience in CMP from one to 41 years. |
An online questionnaire was developed by the first author and reviewed by the other authors, and pre-tested by four therapists. |
Thematic analysis. |
PTs invested in knowing the patient's history during the evaluation to think about the treatment. Professionals understood support for self-care as an important topic for the management of NSLBP. |
| Hartholt et al.43 United Kingdom, 2020 |
To explore the experiences of PTs in making decisions related to the treatment of people with whiplash injuries. |
5 PTs (without specifying gender) working in the UK. At least two years of experience in CMP. |
Individual, semi-structured interview and reflective diary. The interviewer adopted a hermeneutical phenomenological attitude. |
Interpretive phenomenological analysis.
A hermeneutic circle was used throughout each step of the analysis.
|
PTs sought to value collaborative decision-making with patients and were interested in understanding patients' perceptions of their pain, preferences regarding exercises or activities, and goals with the therapeutic approach. |
| Ahlsen et al.42 Norway and New Zealand, 2019 |
To investigate the understanding of the patient as a person in the PCC through the physiotherapy of patients with CMP. |
5 PTs (3F and 2M) working in Norway. Experience in CMP from two to 15 years. |
Semi-structured interviews. |
Narrative analysis confronting the material with Kristeva's health and healing concept. |
A profile of PTs sought to understand the meaning of pain in patients' lives and sought to understand the different factors that may be interfering with their pain condition. These PTs also understood the therapeutic process as a construction. On the other hand, another profile of PTs focused on goal-oriented interventions aimed at restoring the patient's health. |
| Sullivan et al.44 United Kingdom and Finland, 2018 |
Explore and understand the experiences of PTs who communicate the diagnosis of NSLBP to their patients. |
5 PTs (3F and 2M) working in the UK. At least one year of experience in CMP. |
Semi-structured qualitative interviews. |
Interpretive phenomenological analysis. |
PTs sought to use active listening and questioning to understand patients and thereby plan meaningful approaches to the person. They also made the patient feel believed through empathy and acknowledgment of the patient's perspectives. |
| Cowell et al.40 United Kingdom, 2018 |
To explore the perceptions of PTs in primary care in England who adopt a BPS approach to the treatment of patients with chronic NSLBP. |
10 PTs (3F and 7M) working in the UK. Experience in CMP from three to 14 years. |
Semi-structured qualitative interviews. |
Thematic analysis. |
PTs sought to consider BPS aspects related to pain and for that, they used communication to establish a personalized approach. Professionals also sought to establish trust through the therapeutic bond so that patients could rethink beliefs not favorable to the management of NSLBP. They showed concern about following what is recommended by the guidelines for the treatment of NSLBP and the patient's needs. |
| Miciak et al.41 Canada, 2018 |
Identify the various ways PTs make meaningful connections with their patients. |
11 PTs (6F and 5M) with at least five years of experience in CMP. |
Semi-structured interviews, interview notes, analytical notes and memos. |
Inductive and interactive analysis. |
PTs were concerned with listening and recognizing the patient, and they understood that establishing an effective and trusting relationship helps the patient's collaboration with the treatment. They shared decisions throughout the treatment and invested in knowing different elements of the patient's life - including social elements, in addition to their functional expectations, and incorporating these issues into the treatment. PTs also understood treatment as a construction in which it is necessary to understand the needs of patients at each therapeutic encounter. |
| Lawford et al.48 Australia, 2018 |
Explore the experiences of PTs and the impacts of a PCC training program to support exercise adherence in people with knee osteoarthritis. |
8 clinical PTs (without specifying gender) working in Australia. Experience in CMP of at least two years. |
Semi-structured interviews. |
Thematic analysis according to the constructivist paradigm. |
For them, one of the main aspects of PCC is shared decision-making and patient education about the importance of exercise. PTs held the patient accountable for adherence to treatment and achievement of results. |
| Stenner et al.39 United Kingdom, 2016 |
Explore how shared decision-making and patient partnership are approached by PTs in prescribing exercise for patients with chronic NSLBP. |
8 PTs (without specifying gender) working in the UK. Experience in CMP from two to 19 years. |
Field notes, informal interviews and semi-structured interviews. |
Thematic analysis is guided by Gadamerian hermeneutics. |
As for the PCC, the PTs demonstrated to take into account the perspectives and considerations of the patients when planning the physiotherapy exercises. |
| Sheeran et al.37 United Kingdom, 2014 |
To assess the experiences and perceptions of clinical PTs and managers on barriers and facilitators to better target treatment for chronic NSLBP. |
6 clinical PTs (1F and 5M) and 3 managing PTs (1F and 2M) operating in the UK. Experience in CMP from 12 to 39 years. |
Focus group and individual semi-structured interviews.
Field notes were taken by a research observer.
|
Inductive thematic analysis. |
Clinical PTs and managers were concerned about knowing the patient's history during the physiotherapy assessment. |