ABSTRACT
Have you already encountered the epistemological contributions of Psychoanalysis to Geography? How does Earth's spelling the particular and singular spelling of a language being? What links us to places? These were some of the moving questions in the doctoral research that are present in this text. The theoretical-methodological encounter presents the concept of geopsychic place constituted and lived topologically with psychic dynamics and terrestrial dynamics. Geopsychic Place is located in two chains of transmission in the encounter between classic references in Humanist Geography, such as Yi-Fu Tuan, David Lowenthal, Éric Dardel, J.K. Wright, and classic references in Psychoanalysis, such as Sigmund Freud and Jacques Lacan. The article presents aspects and characteristics that are inseparable from the geopsychic place present in the words of the people who participated in the research. The encounter between Geography and Psychoanalysis presents a possible and necessary path in carrying out geographical research, a path that includes listening, the unconscious, and highlights the word.
Keywords:
geopsychic place; unconscious; psychic reality; topology; Humanist Geography
RESUMO
Você já se encontrou com as contribuições epistemológicas da psicanálise à geografia? Como a grafia da Terra se encontra com a grafia particular e singular de um ser de linguagem? O que nos vincula aos lugares? Essas foram algumas perguntas moventes na pesquisa de doutoramento que estão presentes neste texto. O encontro teórico-metodológico apresenta o conceito de lugar geopsíquico constituído e vivido topologicamente com dinâmicas psíquicas e dinâmicas terrestres. Lugar geopsíquico localiza em duas cadeias de transmissão no encontro entre referências clássicas da Geografia Humanista, como Yi-Fu Tuan, David Lowenthal, Éric Dardel, J.K. Wright, com referências clássicas na psicanálise, como Sigmund Freud e Jacques Lacan. O artigo apresenta aspectos e características indissociáveis ao lugar geopsíquico presentes nas falas das pessoas que participaram da pesquisa. O encontro entre a geografia e a psicanálise apresenta um caminho possível e necessário no fazer da pesquisa geográfica, um caminho que inclui a escuta, inconsciente e destaca a palavra.
Palavras-chave:
lugar geopsíquico; inconsciente; realidade psíquica; topologia; Geografia Humanista
RÉSUMÉ
Avez-vous déjà eu rendez-vous avec les apports épistémologiques de la Psychanalyse à la Géographie? Comment la graphie de la Terre rencontre-t-elle la graphie singulière d’un être de langage? Qu’est-ce qui nous relie aux lieux? Voilà quelques questions bougeantes de la recherche doctorale qui sont présentes dans ce texte. Cette rencontre permet d’envisager la réalité psychique et la réalité géographique dans la constitution de lieu et d’expérience sur Terre à différentes échelles et temporalités. Le lieu géopsychique se situe dans deux chaînes de transmission à la rencontre de références classiques de la Géographie Humaniste, telles que Yi-Fu Tuan, David Lowenthal, Éric Dardel, J.K. Wright, avec des références en psychanalyse, comme Sigmund Freud et Jacques Lacan. L’article présente des caractéristiques indissociables au lieu géopsychique, présents dans les discours des personnes qui ont participé à la recherche. La rencontre entre Géographie et Psychanalyse ouvre un chemin possible dans la recherche géographique, qui inclut l’écoute, l’inconscient, et qui met en valeur la parole.
Mots clés :
lieu géopsychique; inconscient; réalité psychique; topologie; géographie humaniste
Introduction
People. This was the answer to what first came to mind when I thought of “geography”. Continuing with the answer: “people in their geographies. A way of looking at people and practicing Geography with and for people”. But that answer still did not encompass what was already unconsciously present in my thoughts, so I was able to ask myself other questions: “How is a place constituted? How do we connect to places?”.
These questions allowed me to build an investigative research path during my doctorate and, at the end, present the concept of geopsychic place. It is important to highlight that the thesis “[XX]” also marks the encounter between psychoanalysis and Brazilian Geography and new epistemological contributions. Therefore, I consider it important to highlight some psychoanalytic concepts for understanding geopsychic place. So, with this inaugural term, what can we say about geopsychic place?
The first statement is that the concept of geopsychic place was born from a perspective of humanist geography with a psychoanalytic basis. This means the encounter between classic references of humanist geography, such as Yi-Fu Tuan, David Lowenthal, Éric Dardel and J.K. Wright, with classic references in psychoanalysis, such as Sigmund Freud and Jacques Lacan. Thus, although the concept of geopsychic place is new, it was developed and is located in two chains of transmission (Dias, 2019b) in which my predecessors are present in the way the term was woven. Therefore, although geopsychic place inaugurates a theoretical perspective, it is not isolated in geographical science as it includes questions born through the reflective encounter with these predecessors from both fields.
That said, a humanist geographer was central to setting my thinking in motion during the production of the research. Yi-Fu Tuan and his concept of place allowed me to ask questions that deepen our geographical understanding of place, now with the inclusion of the unconscious.
Tuan turned to the scale of the person and their experiences in the world to build his perspective of place. His emphasis on human experience was innovative for geographical science, with research being conducted for a few decades now, and there still being trails along this path through the unknown lands (Wright, 1947; Lowenthal, 1961), now with the unconscious. This theoretical basis, deepened by psychoanalysis, also methodologically includes listening to and reading the words of the people present in their discourse throughout the text.
Based on the philosopher Gaston Bachelard (2005), Tuan uses the term topophilia as “the emotional link between a person and a place or physical environment” (Tuan, 2012, p. 19). This concept, which has been cited countless times worldwide, does not end there, but rather, it allows us to ask ourselves other questions within geographical thought. So, how does this link between person and place occur? How does our lived experience lead us to connect with the place?
Another widely cited statement assumes the place as a center of meaning constructed by experience (Tuan, 1975). However, another question was driving the thesis: what is a center of meaning? In this same perspective, another quote is widely disseminated: “Place is a pause in movement” (Tuan, 2013, p. 169; Tuan, 2011, p. 12). So, I began to ask myself: is it possible to pause? What movement? What relationships between place and pause? What are the relationships between place and movement? We will continue this article along the lines of these questions with reflections woven into this encounter between geography and psychoanalysis.
Topological fold
Geopsychic place is constituted and experienced in the topological fold between the internal and the external world, with terrestrial dynamics and psychic dynamics (Dias, 2019a). With this formulation of the geopsychic place, the first term I need to highlight is the topological fold of Lacanian inspiration. So, to begin, for the image of the fold, imagine a cylinder. This three-dimensional geometric shape with an orientable surface is important for us to make the transition to the flexible geometry used by Lacan. The cylinder is composed of two circular and parallel bases. When we touch its external part, we can travel along its surface and go completely around it without coming across the internal face. There is a rigidity in this geometric shape that divides the space into two portions with two margins that separate the external side and the internal side of the cylinder. However, we will need to make a transition between two images: from the cylinder to the Möbius strip.
August Ferdinand Möbius (1790 - 1868) was a German mathematician who performed projective transformations in Euclidean geometry, such as through the so-called Möbius strip, band or loop. Unlike a cylinder, the Möbius strip has characteristics such as: a non-orientable surface, with a unique edge and margin. For example, this means that, apparently, when we move our finger along the Möbius strip, sometimes it will be “inside” and sometimes it will be “outside”, without there being a delimitation between inside and outside. This mode of movement can be seen in the movement of the ants present in the work “Möbius Strip II”, by the Dutch graphic artist Maurits Cornelis Escher (1898-1972). The Möbius strip is also present in our daily lives, but we will follow it starting from the Lacanian topology so that, geographically, we can continue with the geopsychic place.
According to Marar (2019), there are several “geometries that can be considered in the same space, each of which establishes an organizational process. With Felix Klein (1849-1925), postmodernity began in geometry and topology is one of these non-Euclidean geometries” (Marar, 2019, p. 71). Thus, according to the transformation and its geometry, our spatial perception of objects will be altered. Therefore, to state that this work follows the topology and not the Euclidean geometry is to state that we are interested in the study of characteristics that are not metric and whose properties of objects change.
With topology, it is possible to work with continuous spatial transformations in objects, such as deformations that stretch, shrink, twist and bend shapes, and with them we can, geographically, ask ourselves about places and the spatial relationships that we establish on and with the Earth. Topologically, what is it possible to say about places? How can we read our geographicity, at the same time, with and beyond spatial metrics? What inspiration does Lacanian topology provide for considering relationships between places and experience?
Topology focuses on changes in form, the position of elements and the emptying of meanings. So, let us continue with this possibility that does not establish a priori definitions about places. The French psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan (2003 [1961-1962]) explored topology throughout his work, with emphasis on “Seminar 9 - Identification”, through which he worked on the surface topology of the torus, the cross-cap and the Möbius strip. The psychoanalyst also works with a conception of topology linked to a “flexible geometry that mathematically deals with issues of neighborhood, continuous transformation, borders and surface, without always involving metric distance” (Chemama, 1995, p. 212). But what is the relationship between the unconscious and the topology worked on by Lacan?
The topology in Lacanian psychoanalysis surprises not only mathematicians, but also all those who, faced with figures of flexible geometry, can reflect on the human. I will continue with the topology of the one-sided figure of the Möbius strip, which allows us to consider two worlds in univocity. This structure has no right or wrong side, and this inclusion of the wrong side by Lacan is, according to Chemama (1995), what represents the relationship of the unconscious with that which is present in conscious discourse.
Lacan works with a structure for subjectivation that is derived from a two-sided surface to consider that signifier and signified slide together on this one-sided surface to form meaning (Victora, 2013). This Möbius structure originates from the transformation of the cylinder, through a topological fold or torsion, into a one-sided surface. This torsion causes the inside and outside sides to be on a single continuous face.
From this perspective, the constitution of the geopsychic place occurs in the topological fold. With it, the internal (psychic dynamics) and external (terrestrial dynamics) are folded topologically in the constitution and experiences of the geopsychic place.
This operation of the topological fold can be followed through an excerpt from the field notes present in the doctoral research. The scenario was a conversation between women about motherhood. One of them, called Laís, had recently given birth to her first child and was taking her first trip after giving birth. Laís returned to her hometown to visit her friends and family. Then, she recounted her achievements and difficulties experienced in living in another state of Brazil, far from her parents and with a small baby. However, at a certain point in the conversation, Laís spoke about something different that she had felt during a walk through the city in Minas Gerais. We already have the scenario that will cross some signifiers for Laís, such as motherhood and her hometown. Read as signifiers, we can ask ourselves what motherhood is for Laís? How did motherhood become present when she was walking around her city?
Laís said that she had left her baby with her grandmother so that she could go downtown to a street known as “Halfed Street”. She used to go to the shops on that street, but that day she was shocked. “You guys won’t believe it! I was walking down that street and it felt like I was on the Champs-Élysées. (Laughter)” (Dias, 2019a, p. 102). Her shock provoked laughter among the people participating in the conversation and, at the same time, allowed us to open up questions about the work.
When we compare the landscape of the Champs-Élysées with Halfed Street, it will be very difficult to list similar elements. If we cannot identify such elements materially, what happened to the street that Laís experienced? What triggered the presence of another place during Laís’s walk along the street? There is already something of Laís' psychic dynamics sliding topologically with the two cities she mentions.
Laís continued to talk about her astonishment, saying that she had never been to Paris, but that she had the impression that she was walking down that street. Somehow she already realized that what she experienced and told us seemed to make no conscious sense. And she concludes: “I never liked Juiz de Fora so much! I realized that I love Juiz de Fora. I only found out when I stayed far away” (Dias, 2019a, p. 102).
Given Laís's disbelief and her reading of the unconscious, we can ask ourselves what could have been the reasons that led her to feel like she was in Paris even though she was in Juiz de Fora. If we follow the signifiers that name the cities, what do Champs-Élysées and Juiz de Fora mean to her? How can we geographically investigate Laís's perception? How is it possible to be at one point on the Earth's surface and feel like you are somewhere else? How can you feel like you are in the French capital without ever having visited that country? Given the disconnect that Laís perceived, what had changed in Juiz de Fora?
The conversation reveals many elements of her life that seem to meet on the sidewalk, including different temporalities coexisting. Laís talks about her relationship with her family, the experience of being a mother, about a city she visited in person, about moving to another city, about her relationship with her current city, her hometown, and Paris. The emphasis needs to be on Laís's words and we should avoid any speculation beyond what she herself said. Laís reports that her life has changed, but she finds the sidewalk strange and finds it strange to love Juiz de Fora. The significant changes in her personal life spilled over into the way she experienced her walk and reverberated in the spatiality of the sidewalk. Her speech indicates that the change was present through a mismatch between the street she was physically on and the conscious impression of being in another city. So, I ask, is the street the same or not?
Laís perceives a discontinuity in her feelings and in the way she sees herself on the street she used to walk on. By perceiving the sidewalk as other, an overlapping and intertwining of times and places could be placed in the presence of her estrangement. There is an intertwining of signifiers such as Juiz de Fora, the birth of her son, moving to another city, visiting her hometown, and the Champs-Élysées. We can identify the topological fold in a loop in the Möbian band. Her hometown is no longer the same due to Laís' subjective changes, and at the same time she wonders about Juiz de Fora. With the topological return, we are no longer the same and Laís realizes that the place is not the same either. This is topologically a folding of what she is experiencing internally into the external world. At the same time, the external world was able to give her some information that something was not as before.
Laís' perception and experience when walking along the sidewalk indicate to us that the changes in her life were present spatially and through her words in that dialogue. Laís and the sidewalk had changed in this topological fold. One had changed with the other. It is not up to us to say that the sidewalk has not changed and that it does not resemble the Champs-Élysées. The experience lived at that point on the earth's surface was linked to other times and places. It is in this plasticity of language that topology is placed and made present in a discursive reality that goes beyond the internal and external dichotomy as two parallel spheres.
With this flexible and qualitative geometry, we can find topological equivalences and invariants. A place can transform and link itself to another through deformation and with preserved properties, such as Juiz de Fora and Paris. These characteristics are important and fundamental in the understanding, constitution and plasticity of the geopsychic place.
To continue along this path, a question is appropriate at this point in the text: how do geographic reality and psychic reality meet and are experienced in the topological fold with the internal and external worlds?
Psychic reality and psychic dynamics
One late afternoon, we were in a house located on one of the busiest streets in the city and Mrs. Celma enthusiastically told me about the time she used to play going up and down that hill. She pointed her hand towards a house and said: “look, that was my room”. However, where she was showing me was another house and no longer the one where she had lived her childhood. But she kept pointing out the current house and talking about her old house. As if she were looking back decades, she showed me which window was in the girls' room, the boys' room, the living room, the warehouse and the steps where she used to chat.
Mrs Celma could see a house that I, standing next to her, could not see, and it was not a matter of difference in point of view or any other sensory difficulty. Since then I have found myself reflecting on a concern: how can I respond geographically to that statement “look, that was my room”? This was the question that challenged me and showed me a research problem to be investigated. I highlight four points in this sentence.
First, Mrs Celma chose, based on some criteria, her room as a place to be shown and explained to someone. In the second point, the verb “was” indicates that something was experienced in another temporality, but that was present at the time of that conversation. The “was” signaled something that no longer existed, however, she saw her room. In the third point, the “there” spatialized that memory, locating her room in a reference between the place in the past and the present. The fourth point brings the narrative addressed through the command “look”.
These four points indicate to us that there is something that is present in her account, but that reveals agreements and disagreements between what she and I saw. From the topological fold, another conceptual perspective needs to be highlighted and emphasized in this relationship between internal and external worlds: psychic reality.
The term “psychic reality” is adopted in Freudian work from the “Interpretation of Dreams” of 1900, related to the unconscious as the true psychic reality, as a special form of existence and a decisive reality. For Freud (2019 [1900]), this reality reveals to us that our internal world is also unknown and not only the external world due to its vast extension. “Geographers have not been slow to recognize this. More than simply a model of the personal psyche, psychoanalysis has offered geographers a way to understand the unconscious on the outside; the worlds’ unconscious worlds” (Kingsbury; Pile, 2014, p. 29).
Laplanche and Pontalis (1997) warn us that the term “psychic reality” is not determined by the field of psychology, but refers to what assumes the value of reality in the subject’s psyche. It refers to unconscious processes, is mediated by external reality, has a centrality in relation to material or factual reality and must be considered geographically. This core of the psyche refers to the way reality is signified and our history is represented to us in our lives. “The geopsychic place in all its effect and significance is experienced through psychic reality” (Dias, 2022, p. 211).
Geographically, I am considering the contact and assimilation between psychic reality and geographic reality in the way we experience places, signify them and how they constitute us. It is in the topological fold of these two realities that geopsychic place is constituted and experienced. Therefore, it is not random that a place is significant for one person and not for another. Psychic reality is something that allows us to experience the world based on our experiences and as a collective. The way we are in the world is directly linked to the mediation of psychic reality and this is located in the epistemological revolution carried out by Freudian theory.
Geographer Éric Dardel (2011) presented us with reflections on geographic reality beyond its materiality by pointing out the conflict marked by elements of subjective life. Through geographic and psychic realities, the geopsychic place is constituted and we establish our relationships with the Earth on the most different scales and forms.
With psychic reality, condensation and displacement as mechanisms for elaborating dreams are also fundamental to the geopsychic place. Freud (2014 [1916-1917) argued that dreams present us with manifest contents through which we can read and talk about the unconscious material. From this perspective, dreams have daytime residues and, at the same time, bring something encrypted that needs dream language to manifest itself and be read.
For Freud (2014 [1916-1917]), these mechanisms work with the material experienced and recorded as a separate latent element, which comes together during the formation of the dream and presents itself as a unit of the manifest dream. With this mechanism, a person can be present in our dream with their waking life appearance, but with clothes usually worn by a second person, performing the work of a third person, and we can even say to a fourth person: “I dreamed about you”. With this example, we can, in an illustrative way, identify the four separate elements that manifested themselves together in a person. The same occurs with geopsychic place.
During the research, Sebastião, a participant, told me “Paraty is Tiradentes with water. I like going to Tiradentes because it reminds me of Ressaquinha at my grandmother’s house.” In this account, there is a link by condensation between Paraty-Tiradentes-Ressaquinha grandmother’s house. As in a dreamlike process, these places become present, intertwined in Sebastião's words, and they can exist in them through their psychic reality in the way they present themselves to us.
Each person relates to the landforms, objects, urban problems, agricultural areas, or other geographical aspects, based on their lived history. We could ask ourselves: who is this person? Why did they choose this topic to investigate scientifically? What drives this person to move in the world? What geographically concerns them on Earth? When we turn radically to the human, another question arises: how do we connect to geopsychic place?
Transference
From the perspective of the geopsychic place, “it is the people who make the place” (Dias, 2019a, p. 122). This is one of the main axes of this concept and was constructed through its presence in the words of the people who took part in the research. This specific association between people and places has its origin in the twisting of the psychoanalytic concept of transference.
Transference is inherent to humans, it is a device for analytical work and affects the way we relate to the geopsychic place. For Freud, “transference is only revealed and isolated by analysis. It is a general human phenomenon [...] and even governs a person’s relationships with their human environment” (Freud, 2011a [1925], p. 124). In his text “Dynamics of Transference”, he signals to us that every human being acquires a “characteristic way of conducting love life, that is, the conditions that love establishes, the drives that it then satisfies, the objectives that it sets for itself” (Freud, 2010a [1912], p. 134).
For Chemama (1995), the intense emotional bond experienced in transference is central to the working relationship between analyst and analysand. But not only this. Transference involves trust, an intense emotional bond, the possibility of addressing and listening to someone, and feelings that move.
This characteristic and singular way of each of us also operates in our emotional ties with places. Feelings for a certain place precede the encounter with the place itself and can become present. And then, I started to wonder: how can this way of relating have an impact on places?
The geopsychic place is constituted and experienced through the significant relationships we establish with people with whom we have a strong transferential bond (Dias, 2019a). It is through transference that people are associated and become geopsychic places.
Another field note that I share in this text occurred during a conversation between two sisters about a certain wall that is located in the same neighborhood where they have lived for over 30 years. With a smile on her lips and a sparkle in her eyes, the older sister says: “Ah! That wall in the square (sigh). It’s so beautiful! I like to look at it.” However, laughing, her sister interrupts her and says that the wall is hideous. That was when I decided to join the conversation and asked what the wall they were talking about was like. The youngest sister quickly replied, laughing, that it was just a wall. Then her sister disagreed: “It’s not hideous! That’s where I first kissed my husband” (Dias, 2019a, p. 129).
We are not supposed to evaluate the beauty of the wall. Nor is the core of the conversation about whether or not it is hideous, but about the relationship between lived experience, psychic reality, and the topological fold that unites these elements. The presence in language, through the adjective, indicates that the wall is linked to lived experiences. The older sister associates the wall with a special person in her life. A wall not of separation, but of union in marriage. Talking about the wall is remembering the day of the kiss, the meeting with her husband, and the presence of love in an unexpected spot in the neighborhood, at least for her younger sister. There is an inseparability between husband and wall that is marked by transference. This association is linked to a transfer between the feeling experienced by someone and the place, in this case, the wall.
The geopsychic place can trigger some affection that we already carry and that can be associated with what is currently experienced at that point on Earth. The place can make different feelings emerge from our “preconscious and conscious” system (Freud, 2010b [1915]), and connect to the old representatives that have already been experienced. The subject, for Lacan, “preserves an articulated chain outside consciousness, inaccessible to consciousness” (Lacan, 2010 [1960-1961]), p. 126). We are constituted by this signifying chain and this will affect the transferential relations and the constitution of geopsychic places.
What we experience is imprinted, marked and constitutes us, which does not mean that all of this record is accessible and conscious and we will be able to explain its origin. A significant part of what we experience will compose our memory and may or may not be remembered. For Lacan (2010 [1960-1961]), the presence of the past is the reality of transference. Bruna, one of the participants in the research, told me: “I loved going to Brasília. I didn’t even care about the 1000 km distance. I would go happily and return, marking on my calendar when my next trip there would be. It seemed close and far at the same time. I can’t explain it. But if you ask me if I would go back to Brasília today, I will tell you: not even for free.” I continued the conversation and asked her what had changed to make her not want to go to that city again and Bruna quickly, with a certain obvious tone, said to me: “Wow?! Because I separated from my husband who lives there. What am I going to do in Brasília?” Through metrics, we know that the city did not become farther away, but in this form of libidinal investment, the name of love was synonymous with the city, so, topologically, starting or ending a relationship affects spatiality.
Lacanian topology helps us to read these words beyond metrics, while at the same time signaling to us that the topological fold in the experience with geopsychic places affects the way we move across the surface of the Earth. Traveling 1000 km towards love simultaneously shortens and widens distances, as Bruna realizes without knowing how to explain. Unconscious knowledge is present even if we cannot explain it with the reason of consciousness. For Bruna, it seemed obvious that talking about Brasília was talking about her husband.
During the research, I met people who, when speaking with love, respect and admiration for someone, also felt the cities of their loved ones in the same way. It is through transference that the link between people and places allows the geopsychic place to become the person. This is linked to the ways in which we connect with the Earth and live our daily lives. Geographically, it is possible to say that people establish transferential relationships between themselves and these relationships affect the way in which places are constituted for each of us.
Significant
During a class for undergraduate Geography students, a group presented a project in which they created an image that had the outline of the boundaries of the state of São Paulo and was filled with photographs that presented what was part of the group's imagination about the state. Until one student in the class said: “Very unfair”. She pointed to the image presented by the group and stated that the capital of São Paulo was not like that. So I asked her to tell us about her trip to that city and she said: “People, the city shines! I would stand with my hands on the bus window and my eyes would shine as well” (Dias, 2021, p. 162). At the same time as she told us, she recalled the trip and again her eyes were shining, this time in front of the class.
Through the unfair signifier , Laura shows us that there is a difference between her São Paulo and the one presented by the group and that is what we will continue with. We are marked by signifiers and the way we address places is permeated by these psychic marks and impressions, in the subject as an effect of the signifier (Tyszler, 2011). There is nothing unfair in itself, but she came with this signifier, what we have to do is to build a path of research with what she tells us. What does Laura call unfair?
One of Lacan's elaborations on the unconscious is that it is structured and woven from language and its role is fundamental in relation to meaning. "What in effect characterizes language is the system of the signifier as such. [...] Meaning is human discourse insofar as it always refers to another meaning." (Lacan, 1988 [1955-1956], p. 142). In Laura's speech there was the brightness of the city, the brightness in her eyes when narrating and the brightness in the memory of what she experienced. There is a link between her body and the city. We can ask ourselves if São Paulo shone or if there was a topological fold between Laura's internal world and what she experienced on the outside.
In language as structure, the signifier has a property in the topological substrate that Lacan refers to the signifying chain as a set of “rings of a necklace that is a ring in another necklace made of rings.” (Lacan, 1998, p. 505). Topologically, the signifier closes and the signification is produced, as for example, the full stop of a sentence produces signification for the first word (Vandermersch, 2014). A signifier is supported by the reference of another and is different from itself, which can be presented retroactively.
This is how the geopsychic place as a signifier integrates a chain of signifiers, which allows us to consider the variations of São Paulo such as the one highlighted in the classroom. In the field recording made with Sebastião, I asked him to tell me more about his trip to Paraty (Tiradentes with the sea), and he said: “I felt at ease there, because it reminded me of my grandmother’s house”. Once again, another place was present in his speech, this time associated with an important person in his life. He continued: “The windows, which you have to lift to open, the wooden planks of the houses, the smell of the churches, the silence of the stone streets”. Unlike the example of the Champs-Élysées, here there is a rapprochement of the elements of the landscapes of Paraty and Sebastião’s grandmother’s house. Which allows us to ask: did he like Paraty or what was present there? Once again, there is a topological fold between his world and the one he found in Paraty. And he concludes: “I felt like I was in Ressaquinha, it was great to get to know Paraty. I remembered my grandmother and my father a lot.”
What is the relationship between Paraty, Tiradentes and Ressaquinha? Delving deeper into the question, what is the relationship for Sebastião? Delving deeper again, what is the relationship between Paraty, Tiradentes and Ressaquinha, Sebastião’s father and grandmother? How can we read his experience in Paraty through the signifiers he presents to us? How can we respond geographically?
Topologically and, considering the unconscious structured as language, this deformation, as in dreams, allows us to read geopsychic places through plasticity when someone tells us about Paraty, associated with Ressaquinha, together with Tiradentes, mixed with grandmother, with father, etc. Geopsychic places have their form altered when someone starts talking about them. There is no restriction in language to start talking about Paraty and continue with Tiradentes. Our geographical borders do not remain when someone places themselves in the movement of words about geopsychic places.
For Freud, these relationships in dreams can be “of the part for the whole; of approximation or allusion; of the symbolic relationship and the plastic representation of words.” (Freud, 2014 [1916-1917], p. 230). Through condensation and displacement, research on geopsychic places also revealed that places mix and generate, in language, another place. Paraty-Tiradentes with water is just one excerpt that exemplifies this possibility of work.
Lacan continues with the principle of condensation for metaphor and with displacement for metonymy and works with the questions triggered by speech. In this structure of the speaker’s field, the indeterminate has a place, the signifier is identifiable and the function of representation creates geopsychic places (Dias, 2022). In the linking of signifiers, the value of one is given in relation to the others, and Sebastião presents us with one of these links with Paraty-Ressaquinha-Tiradentes. For Lacan (1998), the metonymic formulation makes the connection from word to word and the metaphorical one from one word to another. In this connection between two signifiers, one replaces the other, “while the hidden signifier remains present in its (metonymic) connection with the rest of the chain” (Lacan, 1998, p. 510).
The geopsychic place as a signifier integrates a singular chain of signifiers, which allows us to consider variations, such as Paraty and São Paulo. In the same way as in dreams, “each significant element of the dream, each image, refers to a whole series of things to be signified, and, conversely, each thing to be signified is represented in several signifiers” (Lacan, 2009 [1953-1954], p. 346). With psychic reality we have a chain of signifiers operating in the subject and, therefore, in its relationship with places.
Movement, interval and object
During the research, Simone, a 45-year-old woman from Minas Gerais, told me about a family holiday house where she spent her summers for many years. She used to play on the street, and she said she experienced a sense of freedom that she did not experience in her hometown.
With a photograph in her hand, she said to me: “Look, here is the street that I used to play on when I was little.” While she talked about that place, she pointed her fingers at her house as if we were in front of it. Despite the command for me to also see something, it was her words that could be heard and that allowed me to follow her along with the imagery. Simone saw the house through the eyes of her memory and, through her words, I had the opportunity to learn about her experience.
Other memories also came to her mind, which required careful listening. Simone spoke emotionally about relatives who had passed away and who had lived in the same house at that time. As she told me, her words indicated her longing for her relatives, the absence of that time and place, and a certain emptiness due to the discontinuity of what had been experienced.
Simone continued: “I walked alone, feeling the same smell as when I was a teenager, and I saw the places where I used to play.” She walked with her feet in the present tense, but through the eyes of memory, her past also became present in every part of her street, and she said that time seemed to stop. When she decided to walk, she also unconsciously decided to keep in her memory the arrangement of the furniture as her parents had decorated the house. By consciously deciding to walk in silence, she had no control over which sounds would emerge in her memory when she encountered that geopsychic place.
Simone says that there was an atmosphere that was abruptly dissipated with the return of her traveling companions. They called her, but she said that, suddenly, she seemed to have moved away and forgotten that past that took hold of her memories.
Simone spoke about the freedom she experienced in that coastal city when she was younger and, in doing so, she also spoke about the city where she was born, but without this freedom present in her life. By condensation, Simone speaks of different cities and with the common thread marked by movement. Her words indicate to us the significant freedom present in the movement in seeking to live it or relive it in the encounter with the geopsychic place that she chose to talk about in the research. The movement can be read in two vectors: one towards the encounter and the other towards avoiding the encounter. The movements are topologically linked to the life story regulated by the principles of pleasure and reality.
In the text “Beyond the Pleasure Principle”, Freud (2010d [1920]) assures us that the regulation of psychic processes is marked by what he called the pleasure principle. In this principle we not only seek pleasure, but we also find it by avoiding displeasure. With this regulation, we also have a certain stability in the face of oscillations of pleasure and displeasure. The renunciation of pleasure or the postponement of satisfaction are examples of this functioning in the replacement of the pleasure principle by the reality principle. Simone makes a move to avoid encountering change and this maintains the place of the fond memories she felt. Remembering that this search carries unconscious and conscious marks and, therefore, movements with choices that are not only deliberate.
According to Freud (2010d [1920]), this regulation gives us the possibility of forgetting some experiences, even if they continue to affect us unconsciously. However, through the mechanism of repetition, when they return, these lived experiences can generate displeasure.
For psychoanalysts Laplanche and Pontalis (1997), there is a pair formed by the pleasure principle and the reality principle, which is adapted to our living world. Sensations and feelings can become conscious or be blocked, which means that we do not always perceive the relationship between feelings, lived experiences and geopsychic places. There are places that affect us more and provoke movement in the regulation of the pleasure principle. We can feel and perceive the sensation, but it is later that the sense of geopsychic place can emerge.
In everyday life, it is common to hear people talk about their dream of visiting a specific place on Earth. What is there in each place that makes us want to visit? To approach this question, I use the term Trieb, which was used by Freud to indicate this moving force. “Something that manifests itself ‘for’ the subject, making itself represented at an internal and intimate level, as if it were his will or a personal imperative” (Hanns, 1996, p. 339).
This perspective of movement is linked to the drive elements, their characteristics, and one of the possibilities is to say that the drive energy accumulates its quantum and pours and drains like water in each of us. This drive charge accumulates and drains in a circuit that connects different historical moments of our lives. In this drive circuit there is internal stimulus, linked to the psychic apparatus, and external stimuli. Something borderline between external and internal, organic and psychic, body and culture in the search for satisfaction, even if it is not possible to find it completely.
I named another important aspect for understanding the geopsychic place: the interval. The geopsychic place is constituted and lived in the interval (Dias, 2019a). This interval contains what is between the lived experience, its psychic record and the connection with the place.
The interval does not speak about chronological precision, but highlights the timelessness of the unconscious, including what we forget and what we remember. In the same way that it is not possible to measure the speed at which some content manifests itself or is repressed. Something needs to be experienced and interrupted, so that something else can later appear. An interval that can lead us to the encounter with the geopsychic place that can be known retroactively and is not fixed. The interval signals to us that the geopsychic place is not identical in different temporalities of someone's life and will not be the same for two people who may apparently name the same place.
People try to preserve some record of their memories because they know, in some way, that the place is no longer the same, as in Simone's account. The attempt to adjust it leads us to another concept in the field of Psychoanalysis: object.
I already anticipate that I will stick to just one perspective and will also make a twist on this object of psychoanalysis so that we can include it in the epistemology of Geography. For Laplanche and Pontalis (1997), the relationship between the drive and the object can be read in the drive movement that seeks to achieve its goal of satisfaction. For the authors, this can be linked to a person or a partial object, and we will not distinguish whether it will be of the order of reality or fantasy.
This instinctual object becomes unique in our lives and affects the way we are on Earth. The places we choose, with conscious and unconscious psychic processes, call us to movement linked to this instinctual object. Movement does not occur without some libidinal investment. We are marked by signifiers and the way we approach places is permeated by these psychic marks and impressions, in the subject as an effect of the signifier and as caused by the object (Tyszler, 2011).
Geographically, we can consider that this search affects the transference relationship between person and geopsychic place. But one question is important: is it possible to find the object we are looking for? Is it possible to find this place? This loss allows us to read the association between the loved one and the place on different scales and, for Freud (2010c [1917]), we are faced with the concept of lost object.
For Freud (2011b [1925]), when an object is invested with energy, we may have the sensation of something that we experience in continuity and not in rupture. As the object is lost, the lack also constitutes us, at the same time that it moves us in search of this lost object-place.
In this sense, it is not possible to find the geopsychic place. It is lost. A loss linked to rupture. A rupture that speaks of the impossibility of a place remaining. A place that is lost. A place that does not exist in itself. The geopsychic place emerges and exists in language (Dias, 2019a).
Final considerations
I will return to a question that I have been asking myself: what is inseparable from the geopsychic place? First, “the geopsychic place is constituted and experienced in the topological fold between the internal world and the external world, with terrestrial dynamics and psychic dynamics” (Dias, 2019a). A place that, in order to be created, needs the psychic processes experienced by the subject in their relationship with the external world. In this sense, the term geopsychic place encompasses the two realities that make up the place: the geographic reality and the psychic reality.
Second, the geopsychic place is constituted through the significant relationships that we establish with people, with whom we have a strong transferential bond (Dias, 2019a). It is through transference that people are associated, interconnected and become geopsychic places.
Third, the geopsychic place is made and made present through psychic mechanisms such as condensation and displacement. Fourth, the geopsychic place is constituted in the interval. Something is experienced and interrupted, so that something else can later appear and, retroactively, the geopsychic place can be spoken of. The interval indicates ruptures and permanences in the experience lived by each of us and points to the possibility of becoming something else, at the same time as it signals to us that the geopsychic place is not identical. The geopsychic place is not permanent, but through displacements and condensations it can be present in other places that are linked and offer us a sense of continuity or non-rupture. This dimension of the interval allows us to consider the timelessness of the unconscious that can be present and place us before experiences that were once repressed.
Fifth, the geopsychic place sets us in motion. It is not possible to pause this movement. The unconscious works without pauses, the geopsychic place includes it and lives in this movement.
Sixth, the geopsychic place exists in language. Thus, research can enable speakers and listeners to meet and set us in motion in geographical science towards our experiences, our signifiers and our geopsychic places, which, marked by the unconscious, will be strange and familiar. Understanding psychic processes with terrestrial dynamics means considering that there are manifestations that are not deliberated by consciousness and that affect the way we are on the Earth. Including the unconscious, through the contribution of psychoanalysis to the epistemology of Geography, I find in words and listening the possibility of understanding human experience in its different temporalities and geopsychic places.
References
- BACHELARD, Gaston. A poética do espaço. São Paulo: Martins Fontes, 2005.
- CHEMAMA, Roland. Dicionário de Psicanálise. Porto Alegre: Artes Médicas Sul Ltda, 1995.
- DARDEL, Eric. O Homem e a Terra: natureza da realidade geográfica. São Paulo: Perspectiva, 2011.
- DIAS, Juliana Maddalena Trifilio. Lugar geopsíquico: onde a Psicanálise e a Geografia se encontram. Goiânia: C&A Alfa Comunicação, 2022.
- DIAS, Juliana Maddalena Trifilio. Grafar os espaços: experiências e narrativas de uma professora-ouvinte e lugares geopsíquicos. Cadernos de Estágio, v. 3, n. 2, 2021.
- DIAS, Juliana Maddalena Trifilio. Lugar geopsíquico: contribuições da Psicanálise para uma epistemologia da Geografia. 2019. 172f. Tese (Doutorado em Geografia) - Programa de Pós-Graduação em Geografia, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, 2019a.
- DIAS, Juliana Maddalena Trifilio. Geógrafos humanistas clássicos como referências: a cadeia de transmissão na produção do conhecimento geográfico. Geograficidade, v. 10, p. 106-116, 2019b.
- FREUD, Sigmund. A interpretação dos sonhos. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras, 2019 [1900]. (Edição Companhia das Letras das Obras Psicológicas Completas de Sigmund Freud, v. 4).
- FREUD, Sigmund. A dinâmica da transferência. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras , 2010a [1912]. (Edição Companhia das Letras das Obras Psicológicas Completas de Sigmund Freud, v. 10).
- FREUD, Sigmund. Observações sobre o amor de transferência. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras , 2010b [1915]. v. 10.
- FREUD, Sigmund. Conferências introdutórias à Psicanálise. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras , 2014 [1916-1917]. v. 13.
- FREUD, Sigmund. Luto e melancolia. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras , 2010c [1917]. v. 12.
- FREUD, Sigmund. Além do princípio do prazer. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras , 2010d [1920]. v. 14.
- FREUD, Sigmund. Autobiografia. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras , 2011a [1925]. v. 16
- FREUD, Sigmund. A negação. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras , 2011b [1925]. v. 16
- HANNS, Luiz Alberto. Dicionário comentado do alemão de Freud. Imago, 1996.
- KINGSBURY, Paul; PILE, Steve (org.). Psychoanalytic Geographies. Burlington: Ashgate, 2014.
- LACAN, Jacques. A função criativa da palavra. In: LACAN, Jacques. O seminário, livro 1: os escritos técnicos de Freud, 1953-1954. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar, 2009. [1953-1954]
- LACAN, Jacques. O seminário, livro 3: as psicoses, 1955-1956. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar, 1988 [1955-1956].
- LACAN, Jacques. O seminário, livro 8: a transferência, 1960-1961. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar, 2010 [1960-1961].
- LACAN, Jacques. O seminário, livro 9: a identificação, 1961-1962. Recife: Centro de Estudos Freudianos do Recife, 2003 [1961-1962].
- LACAN, Jacques. Escritos. Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar, 1998.
- LAPLANCHE, Jean; PONTALIS, Jean Bertrand. Vocabulário da Psicanálise. São Paulo: Martins Fontes , 1997.
- LOWENTHAL, David. Geography, experience, and imagination: towards a geographical epistemology. Annals of the association of american geographers, v. 51, n. 3, p. 241-260, 1961.
- MARAR, Ton. Topologia Geométrica para inquietos. São Paulo: Editora da USP, 2019
- TUAN, Yi-Fu. Espaço e lugar - a perspectiva da experiência. Londrina: Editora da UEL, 2013.
- TUAN, Yi-Fu. Topofilia. Um estudo da percepção, atitudes e valores do meio ambiente. Londrina: Editora da UEL, 2012.
- TUAN, Yi-Fu. Espaço, tempo, lugar: um arcabouço humanista. Geograficidade, v. 1, n. 1, p. 4-15, 2011.
- TUAN, Yi-Fu. Place: an experiential perspective. Geographical review, v. 65, n. 2, p. 151-165, 1975.
- TYSZLER, Jean Jacques. As metamorfoses do objeto. Clínica da pulsão, da fantasia e da letra. Revista Tempo Freudiano. n. 9, setembro, 2011.
- VANDERMERSCH, Bernard. Douze leçons de topologie à Montpellier. Paris: Editions de l’Association Lacanienne Internationale, 2014.
- VICTORA, Ligia. Topologia e clínica psicanalítica. Porto Alegre: Redes, 2013.
- WRIGHT, John K. Terrae incognitae: The place of the imagination in geography. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, v. 37, n. 1, p. 1-15, 1947.
