ABSTRACT
The success of intercropping tuberous crops with cowpea depends on the choice of tuberous crops and the appropriate management of green manuring and plant densities, among other factors. Thus, this study evaluated the productive and monetary benefits of carrot and green cowpea intercropping under green manuring with Merremia aegyptia and Calotropis procera and cowpea population densities in a semi-arid environment during two years of cultivation. The experimental design was a complete randomized block with four replications in a 4×4+2 factorial arrangement of treatment-factors: equitable amounts of biomass of M. aegyptia and C. procera (20, 36, 52, and 68 t/ha on a dry basis) and four population densities of cowpea (80, 120, 160, and 200 thousand plants/ha) plus two additional treatments with carrot and cowpea in monocropping. The greatest agroeconomic advantages of the carrot and green cowpea intercropping system were achieved with a system productivity index (SPI) of 23.17 t/ha, a land equivalence coefficient (LEC) of 0.82, and a monetary equivalence ratio (MER) of 1.23, respectively, in green manure biomass quantities of 68, 68, and 45.30 t/ha at green cowpea densities of 164, 200, and 148 thousand plants/ha. Mixtures of M. aegyptia and C. procera biomass, from the Caatinga ecosystem, proved to be a viable technology as green fertilizers for producers who cultivate carrots with green cowpea in intercropped systems in a semi-arid environment.
Keywords:
Daucus carota
; Vigna unguiculata (L) Walp.; green manuring; crop association
RESUMO
O sucesso do consórcio entre culturas tuberosas e feijão-caupi depende da escolha da cultura tuberosa e do manejo adequado da adubação verde e das densidades populacionais entre outros fatores. Assim, este estudo avaliou os benefícios produtivos e monetários do consórcio cenoura e feijão-caupi verde sob adubação verde com Merremia aegyptia e Calotropis procera e densidades populacionais de feijão-caupi em ambiente semiárido, durante dois anos de cultivos. O delineamento experimental foi em blocos casualizados completos com quatro repetições, em um arranjo fatorial 4×4+2 dos fatores tratamentos: quantidades equitativas de biomassa de M. aegyptia e C. procera (20, 36, 52 e 68 t/ha em base seca) e quatro densidades populacionais de feijão-caupi (80, 120, 160 e 200 mil plantas/ha), além de dois tratamentos adicionais com cenoura e feijão-caupi em monocultivo. As maiores vantagens agroeconômicas do consórcio cenoura e feijão-caupi verde foram alcançadas com um índice de produtividade do sistema (IPS) de 23,17 t/ha, coeficiente de equivalência da terra (CET) de 0,82 e relação de equivalência monetária (REM) de 1,23, respetivamente, nas quantidades de biomassa dos adubos verdes de 68; 68 e 45,30 t/ha nas densidades de feijão-caupi de 164; 200 e 148 mil plantas/ha. Misturas de biomassa de M. aegyptia e C. procera, provenientes do ecossistema da Caatinga, demonstraram ser uma tecnologia viável como fertilizantes verdes para produtores que cultivam cenouras com feijão-caupi verde em sistemas de consórcio em ambiente semiárido.
Palavras-chave:
Daucus carota
; Vigna unguiculata (L) Walp; adubação verde; associação de culturas
The production of vegetable crops in intercropping system in the Brazilian Semi-Arid region is a vital agroecological and socioeconomic strategy for family farming. It optimizes land and water use, increases productivity per area, and boosts the income of rural producers, being widely recommended by research institutions in the region (Borralho et al., 2024). This practice consists of the simultaneous cultivation of two or more species with different cycles and architectures in the same area, during the same growing season, and sometimes sown not necessarily on the same planting day as the crops, in order to reduce competition between the species (Burgess et al., 2022). To be successful, it is essential to combine species with different life cycles, nutritional needs, and root architectures that explore different depths, thus reducing competition for nutrients and water, such as slower-growing tuberous vegetables like carrot with taller food crops like cowpea.
However, the success of the cropping system depends mainly on the management of production factors, such as fertilization and population density of the component crops, since these factors influence the growth and development of the plants, as well as the production and productivity of the crops (Liu et al., 2023). Among the fertilization methods used in family farming systems, green manuring stands out.
The green manuring is an ancestral technique with agroecological and sustainable characteristics that aims to improve the physical, chemical, and biological parameters of the soil. The green manures that have been successfully used in some vegetable and food crops in the semi-arid region of Brazil include M. aegyptia and C. procera, spontaneous plants of the Caatinga biome (Lino et al., 2021; Sá et al., 2022). The M. aegyptia is a herbaceous species with average green and dry matter production of around 36 and 4 t/ha, respectively, with a high nitrogen content of around 26.2 g/kg of dry matter and a C/N ratio of 18/1. On the other hand, the C. procera is a shrubby species with an average biomass production of around 3 t/ha per cut on a dry basis (at 120 days), reaching 9 t/ha per year, with a nitrogen content of around 18.4 g/kg of dry matter and a C/N ratio of 25/1.
Researches have shown the efficiency of using these spontaneous species of green manures in the cultivation of leafy and tuberous vegetables. Silva et al. (2018), studying the intercropping of beetroot with lettuce fertilized with M. aegyptia, obtained the highest agro-economic performance of the intercropping of these vegetables with the incorporation of 35.30 t/ha. On the other hand, Lino et al. (2022) obtained a maximum commercial productivity of radish roots of 8.45 t/ha in an intercropping system with lettuce, by incorporating 20 t/ha of the green manures, M. aegyptia and C. procera, into the soil at a lettuce population density of 300 thousand plants/ha, and a maximum productivity of lettuce leaves (17.72 t/ha) using the combination of 65 t/ha of the green manures and a lettuce population density of 300 thousand plants/ha.
Another very important production factor to investigate in the intercropped plant system is the population density of the component crops that make up the intercropped system, as this factor defines the number of plants per area unit to be used in the system (Lino et al., 2021). It is known that high or low plant density of component crops can result in greater or lesser intra- and interspecific competition for resources such as water, light and nutrients, in addition to influencing yield, green mass and plant architecture (Lino et al., 2021). Studies have been carried out to evaluate the influence of plant population density on reducing competition and increasing the productive efficiency of intercrops in semi-arid regions of the Brazilian Northeast with vegetables such as radish and arugula (Sá et al. 2022) and beetroot and arugula (Lino et al., 2021). The results obtained have been promising, as even at high densities, crop productivity was not negatively affected, remaining equivalent to that of monocropping systems.
In the intercropping system of carrot and cowpea in the Brazilian semi-arid region, challenges related to the success of the intercropping system still exist, mainly regarding the interactions between production factors, such as types and quantities of green manures, population densities of the component crops, among others, which improve complementarity or even minimize intra- and interspecific competition between these crops, optimizing their productive potentials in the system. Therefore, the objective of this study was to optimize agronomically and economically the production and its components of intercropped carrot and cowpea when fertilized with different amounts of biomass from the green manures Merremia aegyptia and Calotropis procera, originating from the Caatinga biome, in two cropping seasons.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Location, climate and soil classification
Two experiments were conducted from July to December 2022 and 2023, at the farm located in the district of Lagoinha, 20 km far from the city of Mossoró, RN (5°03'37"S, 37°23'50"W, altitude of 80 m). The region's climate, according to Köppen's classification, is BShw-dry and very hot, featuring two distinct seasons: a dry season typically from June to January, and a rainy season from February to May (Beck et al., 2018). The period during which the experiments were carried out in the years 2022 and 2023, the average maximum temperatures were 35.1 and 36.3°C, relative humidity 72.2 and 70.9% and rainfall 107.4 and 94 mm.
The soils in the experimental areas were classified as dystrophic Red-Yellow Argisol with a sandy loam texture (Santos et al., 2025). Simple soil samples were collected in each experimental area at a depth of 0-20 cm, and then homogenized, thus obtaining a composite sample representative of the area. Then, the samples were sent for chemical analysis of the soil, using the laboratory analysis methods recommended by EMBRAPA (Teixeira et al., 2017). The results in the 2022 cultivation were: pH (water) = 7.20; EC = 0.19 dS/m; OM = 12.41 g/kg; P = 7.00 mg/dm3; K = 1.16 mmolc/dm3; Ca = 20.10 mmolc/dm3; Mg = 6.10 mmolc/dm3; Na = 0.43 mmolc/dm-3; Cu = 0.20 mg/dm3; Fe = 6.80 mg/dm3; Mn = 12.70 mg/dm3; Zn = 1.70 mg/dm3 and B = 0.48 mg/dm3. In the 2023 cultivation they were: pH (water) = 5.80; EC = 0.41 dS/m; OM = 13.25 g/kg; P = 6.00 mg/dm3; K = 1.77 mmolc/dm3; Ca = 8.40 mmolc/dm3; Mg = 2.70 mmolc/dm3; Na = 1.49 mmolc/dm3; Cu = 0.20 mg/dm3; Fe = 18.70 mg/dm3; Mn = 4.90 mg/dm3; Zn = 0.60 mg/dm3 and B = 0.44 mg/dm3.
Experimental design and treatments
The experimental design was a complete randomized block with four replications in a 4×4+2 factorial arrangement of treatment-factors: equitable amounts of biomass of M. aegyptia and C. procera (20, 36, 52, and 68 t/ha on a dry basis) and four population densities of cowpea (80, 120, 160, and 200 thousand plants/ha), plus two additional treatments with carrot and cowpea monocropping at the population densities of 500 and 200 thousand plants/ha (Silva et al., 2020), respectively, fertilized with 48.87 and 50.48 t/ha of biomass of green manures, M. aegyptia and C. procera, optimized by research in the region, to obtain agro-monetary indices (Freitas et al., 2023; Desravines et al., 2022).
Intercropped cultivation was carried out in alternating crop strips, where 50% of the area was allocated to cowpea and 50% to carrot. Each plot was composed of four rows of cowpeas interspersed with four rows of carrots and flanked by two rows of carrots on one side and two rows of cowpeas on the other side, forming the lateral borders of the plot. The total area of the plot was 3.60 m² (3.00 x 1.20 m), with a harvest area of 2.00 m² (2.00 x 1.00 m).
The useful area of the intercropped plots was made up by two central strips of plants of each crop, excluding the two outer rows of the crops on each side and the last two plants of each row in the strips, used as borders. The carrot spacing in the intercropped treatments was 0.25 m × 0.04 m, giving 500 thousand plants/ha. Each harvest area of the intercropping plot contained 100 carrot plants. Cowpea spacing in the evaluated treatments were 0.25 m × 0.10 m, 0.25 m × 0.125 m, 0.25 m × 0.166 m and 0.25 m × 0.25 m, providing plant populations of 80, 120, 160 and 200 thousand plants/ha, respectively. The numbers of cowpea plants in the harvest area in these evaluated spacings were 16, 24, 32 and 40, respectively.
The carrot monocropping was sown in a total area of 1.44 m² (1.20 m × 1.20 m), containing six rows, and a useful area of 0.80 m² (0.80 m × 1.00 m), containing four rows in the planting spacing of 0.20 m × 0.10 m. On the other hand, cowpea monocropping was implemented in a total area of 3.60 m2 (3.00 m × 1.20 m), containing six rows, and a useful area of 2.00 m2 (2.00 m × 1.00 m), containing four rows, at spacing of 0.50 m × 0.10 m. Crops harvesting in both the intercropped and monocropped systems was carried out in the four central crop lines, excluding the lateral lines, as well as the first and the last plants of each crop line, considered borders.
Soil preparation and crop management
The biomass used as green fertilizers was of hairy woodrose (M. aegyptia) and roostertree (C. procera) plants, collected from native vegetation in sites of the rural area of Mossoró, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil, before flowering began. After collecting the green manures, they were crushed in a conventional forager to obtain fragments of 2 to 3 cm. They were then dehydrated at room temperature until they reached 10% humidity and subsequently subjected to laboratory analyses. The chemical attributes of green manures in the 2022 cultivation were for hairy woodrose: N = 20.56 g/kg, P = 2.83 g/kg, K = 37.08 g/kg, Mg = 7.07 g/kg, Ca = 19.35 g/kg and C:N = 25:1 and for roostertree: N = 15.14 g/kg, P = 2.96 g/kg, K = 24.84 g/kg, Mg = 9.20 g/kg; Ca = 17.00 g/kg and C:N = 27:1. In the 2023 cultivation, the chemical attributes were for hairy woodrose: N = 18.56 g/kg, P = 2.58 g/kg, K = 32.8 g/kg, Mg = 4.48 g/kg; Ca = 17.88 g/kg and C:N = 24:1, and for roostertree: N = 14.66 g/kg, P = 1.27 g/kg, K = 31.0 g/kg, Mg = 5.4 g/kg; Ca = 11.6 g/kg and C:N = 28:1.
The experimental areas were prepared with plowing and harrowing, followed by surveying the planting beds using a rotary digger. Next, pre-planting solarization was carried out using 30 micron Vulca Bril Flex® plastic, for a period of 30 days on the soil surface, with the aim of obtaining control of nematodes and phytopathogens in the soil.
After the solarization period, the mixtures of crushed green manures from the studied treatments were incorporated into the soil in two stages. First, 30% of the doses tested were incorporated into the experimental plots. Twenty days after this first incorporation, the crops were planted on August 16th and 5th, 2022 and 2023, respectively. Thirty days after planting, the second incorporation took place between crop rows with the remaining 70% of the green fertilizer doses, on September 15th and 4th, 2022 and 2023, in open furrows between the plant rows.
The cowpea cultivar planted was ‘BRS Tumucumaque’ and the carrot cultivar was ‘Brasilia’. Both were sown in holes approximately 3 cm deep, with three to five seeds per hole. Thinning in cowpea and carrot crops was carried out five and ten days after sowing, respectively. During the entire period which the experiments were conducted, manual weeding and carrot heap were carried out whenever necessary. No chemical pest or disease control was used.
Irrigations were carried out daily using the microsprinkler irrigation system, divided into two shifts (morning and afternoon). The volume of water supplied was based on the carrot cropping coefficient (main crop) obtained in the region (average Kc of 0.965) (Santos et al., 2021), providing a water depth of approximately 8 mm/day.
In the cowpea crop, three harvests were carried out in each cultivation year. In the first year, the first harvest occurred on October 25, 2022, while in the second year, it was on October 13, 2023. Subsequent harvests always occurred three days after the first harvest. In the first year, the first cowpea harvest occurred 70 days after sowing, and in the second year, 69 days after sowing. For carrots, harvests took place on November 22, 2022, and November 3, 2023, exactly 98 and 90 days after sowing, respectively.
Variables analyzed
The variables analyzed in cowpea were: plant height (cm), number of pods per plant, length of green pods (cm), productivity of green pods (t/ha), weight of 100 green grains (g), and green grain productivity (t/ha). In the carrot crop, the following were evaluated: plant height (cm), number of leaves per plant, fresh mass of shoots (t/ha), dry mass of roots (t/ha), total and commercial productivity of roots (formed from long roots: 17-25 cm and diameter <5 cm; medium: 12-17 cm and diameter >2.5 cm and short: 5-12 cm and diameter >1 cm) and classified productivity of roots, in long, medium, short and scrap (t/ha), following the methodology used by Silva et al. (2020).
The agro-monetary indices of the intercropped carrot and cowpea systems were also evaluated: system productivity index (SPI), land equivalence coefficient (LEC) and monetary equivalence ratio (REM):
a) SPI is an index used to evaluate the intercropping, as it standardizes the productivity of the main crop (carrot) in relation to the secondary crop (cowpea), following the expression (Amanullah et al., 2020): SPI=[(P c / P co )× P COC ]+ P CCO , where: Pc represents the commercial productivity of carrot roots in monocropping; Pco is the productivity of green cowpea grains in monocropping; Pcoc is the productivity of green grains of cowpea in the system intercropped with carrot and Pcco is the commercial productivity of carrot roots in the intercrop with cowpea. The higher the value of this index, the more efficient the intercropping system.
b) The LEC is used to identify whether there was a productive advantage. It was determined by the following formula (Yesuf, 2022): 𝐿𝐸𝐶= 𝐿𝐸𝐶 𝑐 × 𝐿𝐸𝐶 𝑐𝑜 . 𝐿𝐸𝑅 𝑐 = 𝑦 𝑐𝑐𝑜 / 𝑦 𝑐 and 𝐿𝐸𝑅 𝑐𝑜 = 𝑦 𝑐𝑜𝑐 / 𝑦 𝑐𝑜 , where Ycco and Ycoc represent the partial land equivalent ratios of carrot and cowpea in intercropping, respectively. Yc and Yco represent the productivity of commercial carrot roots and green cowpea grains in monocropping. LER is defined as the relative area of land under monocropping conditions, which is required to provide the productivity achieved in the intercropping (Costa et al., 2017). For the intercropping system, the minimum LEC value is 0.25, meaning that a production advantage is obtained if the LEC values in the intercropped system exceed the value of 0.25.
c) Finally, the MER measures the monetary superiority (or not) of the intercropping over the monocropping of the most economical crop. It was determined by the formula (Sá et al., 2022): 𝑀𝐸𝑅=(𝐺𝐿 𝑐𝑐𝑜 + 𝐺𝐿 𝑐𝑜𝑐 )/ 𝐺𝐼 𝑐 where: GIcco is the gross income of carrot in intercropping with cowpea, in R$/ha. GIcoc is the gross income of cowpea in intercropping with carrot, in R$/ha and GIc is the highest gross income of carrot in monocropping, when compared to that of cowpea, in R$/ha. Gross income (RB) was determined by the product of crop productivity/ha through the average prices paid to producers in the cultivations of 2022 and 2023 (Lino et al., 2023). The average price values were R$ 11.00/kg and R$ 6.35/kg for immature cowpea and carrot, respectively. The viability of this index is verified by its value. The higher the value, the more viable the cultivation system.
Statistical analysis
Initially, a univariate analysis of variance was carried out to verify the homogeneity of the variances between crops in each variable studied. After verifying the homogeneity of variances using Bartlett's test, a regression analysis was carried out for each variable, and an adjustment of a response surface as a function of the treatment-factors tested (doses of green fertilizers and cowpea population densities), using the software Table Curve 3D (Systat Software, 2021). Finally, the F test was used to verify whether there was a significant difference or not between the cropping systems (intercropping and monocropping) tested.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Performance of cowpea and carrot crops
No significant interaction was observed between the treatment factors, amounts of M. aegyptia and C. procera biomass and cowpea population densities on evaluated traits in the cowpea and carrot crops. The results of the regression analyses of these tested treatment factors (intercropping systems) are presented in terms of response surface modeling in Figures 1, 2, and 3.
Cowpea traits
A response surface was fitted across all these cowpea traits as a function of studied treatment-factors, recording the highest values for PH, PGP, and W100GG of 67.17 cm, 4.05 t/ha, and 41.69 g, respectively, in the combinations of biomass equitable amounts of green manure of 68 t/ha and cowpea population densities of 200, 168, and 137 thousand plants/ha (Figures 1A, 1D, and 1E). For NGPP, GPL, and PGG, the maximum values obtained were of 7.4; 21.94 cm, and 2.47 t/ha in the combinations of green manures biomass amounts 50.33; 49.21, and 51.09 t/ha in the cowpea population densities of 133, 134, and 200 thousand plants/ha (Figures 1B, 1C, and 1F).
Plant height (A), number of green pods per plant (B), length of green pods (C), productivity of green pods (D), weight of 100 green grains (E) and productivity of green grains (F) of green cowpea intercropped with carrot in different equitable amounts of M. aegyptia and C. procera biomass at diverse cowpea population densities. Mossoró, UFERSA, 2022 and 2023.
Plant height was affected by both treatment factors tested, as its maximum point was reached at the maximum dose of the fertilizers and at the highest density of cowpea studied (Figure 1A). The productivity of green pods and the weight of 100 green grains were more affected by the amounts of the green fertilizers tested, obtaining their maximum values at the highest dose of fertilizers, but at lower cowpea plant densities than the maximum tested (Figures 1D and 1E).
The number of green pods per plant and the length of green pods increased with the combination of treatment-factors; however, their maximum points were reached well below the highest dose of green fertilizers tested and the highest cowpea population density evaluated (Figures 1B and 1C). Green grain productivity was most affected by cowpea population density, reaching the maximum value at the highest density tested, but in a green fertilizer dose lower than the maximum incorporated (Figure 1F).
These different results obtained show that the cowpea ‘BRS Tumucumaque’ is a plant that presents reasonable adaptability in different situations of population density and fertilizer doses tested in edaphoclimatic conditions of the semi-arid region of Northeastern Brazil. Thus, the production variables reached optimized values, promoting an increase in plant productivity up to a maximum point, even with the increase in the density of cowpea plants. These production factors determine the maximum yields obtained per unit area and crop ideal population.
Productive traits such as the number of green pods per plant, the productivity of green pods, and green grains in green cowpea production are considered important, being affected by the increase in population, due to the environment of competition for solar radiation, water, and nutrients. However, it is known that when spacing decreases within rows, population density increases, and within certain limits, production may remain stable or with low variation, due to the level of competition not being strong enough to alter its behavior (Chaves et al., 2020).
Mean values for plant height (PH), number of green pods per plant (NGPP), green pod length (GPL), productivity of green pods (PGP), weight of 100 green grains (W100GG) and productivity of green grains (PGG) of cowpea and for plant height (PH), number of leaves per plant (NLP), fresh mass of shoots (GMS), dry mass of roots (DMR) and classified productivity of carrot roots, in short (PSR), medium (PMR), long (PLR) and scrap (PScR), productivity of commercial (PCR) and total roots (PTR) of carrot in monocropping and intercropping from the interaction from treatment-factors: equitable amounts of M. aegyptia and C. procera biomass and population densities of cowpea.. Mossoró, UFERSA, 2024.
The evaluated traits in cowpea had higher averages in monocropping as compared to the intercropping (Table 1). These results are due to the type of competition between the two cropping systems. In monocropping, the registered competition type is intraspecific, and in the intercropping system they are intraspecific and interspecific. It is expected that in intercropped systems, there will be a maximization of the degree of complementarity between the component crops, thus minimizing the types of competition between them, promoting advantages to the intercropped system (Barot et al., 2017).
The decrease in cowpea productivity in intercropped system with carrot, compared to its monocropping, occurs due to niche overlap and growth asymmetry between the species. When grown together, the plants compete intensely for limited environmental resources. The dynamics of this competition occur as follows: 1) regarding competition for light - Carrot develop a lower and denser rosette of leaves, while cowpea emit branches that extend vertically and laterally. In denser arrangements or when the carrot establishes its canopy first, it intercepts much of the solar radiation before it reaches the lower leaves of the cowpea. This limits the photosynthesis of the cowpea, directly impacting its growth and pod formation. 2) Regarding competition for nutrients, the dynamics of this competition occur as follows: Both crops have root systems that explore similar soil layers. Cowpea is a legume, but in the initial phase of intercropping, carrots have a high demand for nutrients, especially phosphorus and potassium, which are crucial for root and vegetative development. The accelerated absorption of these nutrients by the carrot roots creates depletion zones in the soil. Cowpea, due to having a less aggressive root system or suffering initial suppression, has its nutrient absorption hindered, which is reflected in shorter stature, smaller leaf area and, consequently, lower grain productivity.
Carrot traits
A response surface was adjusted for the carrot agronomic traits, plant height (PH), number of leaves per plant (NLP), fresh mass of shoots (GMS), and dry mass of roots (DMR) as a function of studied treatment-factors (Figure 2). In the PH and NLP traits (Figures 2A and 2B), the combination of cowpea population densities with the tested doses showed maximization and optimization of the degree of complementarity between crops, recording maximum values of 39.75 cm and 7.8 leaves per plant in the densities of 115 and 106 thousand cowpea plants/ha at doses of 44.74 and 44.92 t/ha of green manures biomass, respectively. According to Zhang et al. (2020), high population densities increase in intraspecific competition, inhibit individual plant development, and limit crop yields. This factor may be related to reduce light interception by plants, reduced photosynthetic processes, and intensified competition, both intraspecific and interspecific.
In the GMS and DMR characteristics (Figures 2C and 2D), maximum values of 4.69 and 1.18 t/ha were achieved in the combination of cowpea densities of 200 and 140 thousand plants/ha at the tested doses of 60.32 and 46.51 t/ha of green manure biomass, respectively.
Silva et al. (2020) report that in carrot and cowpea intercropping, increased cowpea density intensifies interspecific competition for light, water, and nutrients. High cowpea densities are known to reduce shoot development and root diameter in the carrot. However, at high fertilization levels, nutrients neutralize this competition, maximizing photosynthetic area and productivity. This statement may justify the observed behavior in the results of carrot agronomic traits.
For the traits, productivity of short roots (PSR), of medium roots (PMR), of long roots (PLR), of scrap roots (PScR), of commercial roots (PCR), and productivity of total roots (PTR) the maximum values of 7.08; 10.31; 6.30; 2.93; 22.03 and 24.21 t/ha were achieved in the combinations of cowpea densities of 135; 147; 80; 80; 130 and 80 thousand plants/ha at the tested doses of 68; 20; 20; 20; 20 and 20 t/ha of green manure biomass, respectively (Figure 3).
It can be observed that only PSR was achieved in the combination of the highest dose of fertilizers tested at an intermediate cowpea density, revealing that carrot plants produce short roots requiring the use of a high dose of green fertilizer. On the other hand, carrot plants produced medium (MR), long (LR), and scrap roots (ScR), commercial roots, and total roots requiring combination of low doses of green manure at low to intermediate cowpea densities.
It is known that high doses of fertilizers allow better development and growth of plants, and when associated with the intermediate population density of one of the crops, the productivity of the system and the growth of the crop expressed by plant height can be optimized, due to better use of the nutrients made available by fertilization and by the environmental resources involved in the intercropped system, thus optimizing the system's production variables.
The results of the PMR, PLR, PScR, PCR, and PTR achieved at a low dose of fertilizer and at low or intermediate population density show that the complementarity of the intercropped system was achieved through crop characteristics such as architecture, cycle and nutritional requirements, among others. This behavior can be explained by the rapid mineralization and availability of nutrients released by green manures. The concept of nutrient synchrony refers to a balance between nutrient supply and ordinary crop demand (Ayamba et al., 2023). At a certain point in the plant cycle, nutritional needs reach a peak, and in this study, this moment may have occurred at the time of nutrient release, thus creating synchrony and, consequently, better utilization of this resource.
The synchronization of the green manures, C. procera and M. aegyptia, of carrot intercropped with cowpea is optimized by the rapid decomposition and nutrient release of the biomass of these green manures, perfectly matching the peak of mineralization with the phase of greatest demand for carrots. The biomass of both, C. procera and M. aegyptia have low C/N ratios (generally ranging from 15:1 to 27:1). This chemical characteristic ensures a rapid decomposition and mineralization process, preventing nitrogen immobilization. The phase of greatest nutritional requirement and root differentiation of carrot occurs around 30 to 50 days after sowing. Management requires splitting or prior incorporation of the biomass (e.g., 30% before planting and 70% as topdressing) so that the peak of nutrient release coincides exactly with this phase. Nitrogen from the mineralization of C. procera and M. aegyptia becomes readily available without harming cowpea nodulation, creating a highly synergistic environment. To ensure the viability of this intercropping system, research conducted in the Brazilian semi-arid region recommends the use of equitable amounts of these green manures, adjusting cowpea population densities to minimize interspecific competition and maximize synergy in nutrient cycling.
Productivity of short roots (A), of medium roots (B), of long roots (C), of scrap roots (D), of commercial roots (E), and productivity of total roots (F) of intercropped carrot with cowpea in different equitable amounts of M. aegyptia and C. procera biomass at diverse cowpea population densities. Long roots: 17-25 cm and diameter <5 cm; medium: 12-17 cm and diameter >2.5 cm and short roots: 5-12 cm and diameter >1 cm). Mossoró, UFERSA, 2022 and 2023.
Within the productivity of commercial roots (22.04 t/ha) in the intercropped system, 7.08 t/ha were of short roots, 10.3 t/ha of medium roots and 6.29 t/ha of long roots. The highest productivities were from short and medium roots. These results differ from those found by Ribeiro et al. (2018), studying the carrot and cowpea intercropping in the same region as this research, based on spatial arrangements and cowpea planting densities, they obtained a commercial root productivity of 24.36 t/ha in the intercropping, where 2.94 t/ha came from short roots, 9.74 t/ha from medium roots and 9.85 t/ha from long roots. These small differences between the studies are due to the small differences in temperature and relative humidity in the experimental locations and the treatment-factors tested, which were spatial arrangements and cowpea planting densities, while in the research in focus, doses of green fertilizers and densities of cowpea were studied. Both authors used the same “Brasilia” carrot variety and found a predominance of medium-sized roots (12-17 cm), a characteristic pattern of this variety.
Analyzing the performance of the cropping systems (monocropping and intercropping) on the agronomic and productive characteristics of carrot, significant differences were observed between them in the green mass of shoots, in the dry mass of roots, and in the productivity of scrap roots, with monocropping standing out from the intercropping system (Table 1). On the other hand, the intercropping system stood out from monocropping only in the total productivity of carrot roots. These results are due to the type of competition that each cropping system is subjected to, resulting from the type of management given to its treatment factors.
Given the results found, it is a viable strategy to increase carrot cultivation in an intercropped system with cowpea. This strategy, according to Algeri et al. (2018), can be extended to other types of intercropping of carrot with other vegetables such as cabbage and lettuce, becoming an option for diversifying producers' income.
Agro-monetary indices
A response surface was adjusted for the agro-monetary indicators, system productivity index (SPI), land equivalent coefficient (LEC), and monetary equivalence ratio (MER) in the carrot and green cowpea intercropping system as a function of treatment-factors: equitable amounts of M. aegyptia and C procera biomass, and cowpea population densities. The maximum values achieved for SPI, LEC, and MER were 23.17 t/ha, 0.82, and 1.23 in the combinations of equitable amounts of green manure biomass of 68, 68, and 45.30 t/ha, in the cowpea population densities of 164, 200, and 148 thousand plants/ha, respectively, (Figure 4).
System productivity index (SPI) (A), land equivalent coefficient (LEC) (B), and monetary equivalence ratio (MER) (C) of the carrot intercropped with cowpea in different equitable amounts of M. aegyptia and C. procera biomass at diverse population densities of cowpea. Mossoró, UFERSA, 2022 and 2023.
The high SPI value (23.17 t/ha) obtained in the combination of 68 t/ha of green manure biomass with 164 thousand cowpea plants/ha demonstrates the agronomic efficiency of the carrot-cowpea intercropped system in this combination in relation to the monocrops of these crops. This result corroborates that obtained (29.23 t/ha) by Chaves et al. (2020) when they intercropped beetroot with cowpea in different populations of cowpea plants and obtained this value at the density of 200 thousand cowpea plants/ha. This index is used to standardize the productivity of the primary crop (carrot) in relation to the secondary crop (cowpea) (Jardim et al., 2021).
Likewise, the high LEC value (0.82) obtained expressed the same agronomic efficiency of the intercropped cultivation of these two vegetables in the combination of 68 t/ha of green manure biomass with 200 thousand cowpea plants/ha. It is known that, when the LEC value is greater than 0.25, the intercropped system presents a production advantage in relation to monocrops (Lino et al., 2022).
Regarding the monetary indicator MER (1.23), the agronomic efficiency of the carrot and cowpea intercropping was translated into economic terms. According to Silva et al. (2025), when the MER is greater than 1.0, intercropped systems are considered more profitable compared to monocrops of the component crops. This superiority of MER can also be attributed to the complementary nature of the cultures involved in the system.
Similar results were obtained by Chaves et al. (2020) when they intercropped beet with different population densities of cowpea in the same region of this research and obtained values of LEC = 0.59 and MER = 1.11, at cowpea population densities of 191 and 200 thousand plants per hectare.
The achievement of good agro monetary indicators can be explained both by the good nutritional contribution provided by green manures and by the ability of intercropped crops to express their agronomic potential, even at high densities. According to Bezerra Neto et al. (2024), regardless of whether green fertilizers come from regional plants or not, they provide the soil with an increase in organic matter, greater availability of nutrients, better aeration, structuring, and storage of water in the soil, thus contributing directly to the chemical, physical, and biological soil balance.
From the results, it is also possible to verify that, even in high densities of the secondary crop (cowpea), interspecific competition may have been reduced, as the component crops have the capacity to explore distinct ecological niches, thus strengthening the degree of complementarity between the component cultures. Finally, it can be noted that some combinations of cowpea with carrots in intercropped systems enable better use of environmental resources due to an effective interaction between intra and interspecific competition, thus increasing the efficiency of the system and productivity of the component crops (Costa et al., 2017).
The maximum production of commercial carrot roots in the intercrop with cowpea was obtained with a productivity of 22.03 t/ha in the amount of 20 t/ha of biomass of M. aegyptia and C. procera incorporated into the soil at density cowpea population of 130 thousand plants/ha, while the maximum production of green cowpea was achieved with a productivity of 2.47 t/ha in the amount of 51.09 t/ha of green manure biomass added to the soil at a population density of 200 thousand cowpea plants/ha.
The greatest agro-economic advantages of the carrot x cowpea intercropping were achieved with a system productivity index (SPI) of 23.17 t/ha, land equivalent coefficient (LEC) of 0.82 and monetary equivalence ratio (MER) of 1.23, respectively, in the combinations of equitable amounts of green manures biomass of 68; 68 and 45.30 t/ha in the cowpea population densities of 164; 200 and 148 thousand plants/ha. Mixtures of M. aegyptia and C. procera biomass, from the Caatinga ecosystem, proved to be a viable technology as green fertilizers for producers who cultivate carrot with cowpea in intercropped systems in a semi-arid environment.
REFERENCES
- ALGERI A; SATO, AJ; LUCHESE, AV; RIBEIRO, I; PETERLE, AC.2018. Cultivo em consórcio de repolho, alface e cenoura. Brazilian Journal of Development, 4(6), 3436-3450.
- AMANULLAH, K; SHAH, K; FARHAN, K; IMRANUDDIN.2020. Influence of irrigation regimes on competition indexes of winter and summer intercropping system under semi-arid regions of Pakistan. Scientific Reports, 10 (1), 8129.
- AYAMBA, BE; ABAIDOO, RC; OPOKU, A; EWUSI-MENSAH, N. 2023. Mechanisms for nutrient interactions from organic amendments and mineral fertilizer inputs under cropping systems: a review. Peer J, 11, e15135.
- BAROT, S; ALLARD, V; CANTAREL, A; ENJALBERT, J; GAUFFRETEAU, A; GOLDRINGER, I; LATA, Jean-Christophe; ROUX, XL; NIBOYET, A; PORCHER, E. 2017.Designing mixtures of varieties for multifunctional agriculture with the help of ecology: a review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 37(2), 13.
- BECK, HE; ZIMMERMANN, NE; MCVICAR, TR; VERGOPOLAN, N; BERG, A; WOOD, EF. 2018. Present and future Köppen-Geiger climate classification maps at 1-km resolution. Scientific Data, 5(1), 1-12.
- BEZERRA NETO, F; ROCHA, JLA; LIMA, JSS. 2024. Adubação verde. In: BEZERRA NETO, F; SILVA, FN; ROCHA, JLA; VENTURI, LAB. (eds). Adubação verde em cultivos agroecológicos em ambiente semiárido. v. 1. Curitiba: Appris. p. 33-50.
- BORRALHO, JF; SANTOS, VB; PEIXOTO, MCR; NUNES, RFC; ROLIM, TL; SILVA, MRM. 2024. Cadernos de Agroecologia, 19(1), 1-5.
- BURGESS, AJ; CANO, MEC; PARKES, B. 2022. The implementation of intercropping and agroforestry as adaptation to climate change. Crop and Environment, 1(2), 145-160.
- CHAVES, AP; BEZERRA NETO, F; LIMA, JSS; SILVA, JN; NUNES, RL; BARROS JÚNIOR, AP; LIMA, GKL; SANTOS, ECS. 2020. Cowpea and beet intercropping agro-economic dynamics under spatial arrangements and cowpea population density. Horticultura Brasileira 38: 192-203.
- COSTA, AP; BEZERRA NETO, F; SILVA, ML; LIMA, JSS; BARROS JÚNIOR, AP; PORTO, VCN. 2017. Intercropping of carrot x cowpea-vegetables: evaluation of cultivar combinations fertilized with roostertree. Revista Caatinga, 30(3), 633-641.
- DESRAVINES, RP; BEZERRA NETO, F; LIMA, JSS; SANTOS, ECS; GUERRA, NM; LINO, VAS. 2022. Optimized production of immature cowpea under green manuring in a semi-arid environment. Revista Caatinga, 35(3), 606-617.
- FREITAS, IAS; BEZERRA NETO, F; LIMA, JSS; SILVA, JPP; FERREIRA, RC; GUERRA, NM. 2023. Productivity and optimized economic efficiency of carrot roots in monocropping under green manuring. Revista Caatinga, 36(3), 572-584.
- JARDIM, AMRF; SILVA, TGF; SOUZA, LSB; ARAÚJO JÚNIOR, GN; ALVES, HKMN; SOUZA, MS; ARAÚJO, GGL; MOURA, MSB. 2021. Intercropping forage cactus and sorghum in a semi-arid environment improves biological efficiency and competitive ability through interspecific complementarity. Journal of Arid Environments, 188, 104464.
- LINO, FKKS; BEZERRA NETO, F; LIMA, JSS; SANTOS, EC; LINO, VAS; GUERRA, NM; DESRAVINES, RP; SILVA, EA; SILVA, JPP. 2022. Agro-economic benefits in radish-lettuce intercropping under optimized green manuring and planting density. Horticultura Brasileira, 40(3), 302-310.
- LINO, FKKS; BEZERRA NETO, F; SANTOS, EC; LIMA, JSS; CHAVES, AP; RODRIGUES, G. S. O; G; GUERRA, NM; SILVA, ÍN; LINO, VAS. 2023. Maximizing agro-bioeconomic benefits in intercropped systems of radish and lettuce in the semi-arid environment. Revista Brasileira de Engenharia Agrícola e Ambiental, 27(2), 121-131.
- LINO, VAS; BEZERRA NETO, F; CHAVES, AP; LINA, JSS; SANTOS, EC; NUNES, RLC; GUERRA, NM; LINO, FKKS, SÁ, JM; PORTO, VCN; DESRAVINES, RP. 2021. Bio-economic return from the green fertilizing and plant population in strip-intercropping of beet and rocket. Research, Society and Development 10(8), e20910817112.
- LIU, Y; Huang, L; Wen, Z; Fu, Y; Liu, Q; Xu, S; Li, Z; Liu, C; Yu, C; Feng, Y. 2023. Effects of intercropping on safe agricultural production and phyremediation of heavy metal-contaminated soils. Science of Total Environment, 875, e162700.
- RIBEIRO, GM; BEZERRA NETO, F; LIMA, JSS; SILVA, ML; BARROS JÚNIOR, AP; SANTOS, EC. 2018. Productive performance of carrot and cowpea intercropping system under different spatial arrangements and population densities. Revista Caatinga, 31, 19-27.
- SÁ, JM; BEZERRA NETO, F; QUEIROGA, RCF; CHAVES, AP; LIMA, JSS; SANTOS, EC; NUNES, RLC; GUERRA, NM; LINO, VAS. 2022. Yield performance and agro-economic efficiency of radish-arugula intercropping under green manuring and planting density. Horticultura Brasileira, 40(2), 44-56.
- SANTOS, HG; JACOMINE, PKT; ANJOS, LHC; OLIVEIRA, VA; LUMBRERAS, JF; COELHO, MR; ALMEIDA, JA; ARAÚJO FILHO, JC; OLIVEIRA, JB; CUNHA, TJF. 2025. Brazilian soil classification system. 6ª ed., revised and expanded - Brasília: Embrapa. 393p.
- SANTOS, MAL; SILVA, TV; SILVA, JC; SANTOS, DP; SANTOS, CS. 2021. Coeficiente de cultivo para cenoura sob a perspectiva de diferentes modelos matemáticos da evapotranspiração de referência. Irriga, 26(1), 134-150.
- SILVA, ÍN; BEZERRA NETO, F; BARROS JÚNIOR, AP; LIMA, JSS; BATISTA, TMV; LINS, HA. 2018. Green manure and spatial arrangement in the sustainability improvement of lettuce-beet intercrops. Revista Brasileira de Engenharia Agrícola e Ambiental, 22(7), 451-457.
- SILVA, GA; BEZERRA, F; LIMA, JSS; SANTOS, EC; LINO, VAS; LINO, FKKS; SILVA, JPP; SILVA, EA. 2025. Productive and monetary efficiency of radish and coriander intercropping under organic management. Revista Ciência Agronômica, 56, e202391762.
- SILVA, JN; BEZERRA NETO, F; LIMA, JSS; SANTOS, EC; NUNES, RLC; CHAVES, AP.2020. Production and benefits in carrot and vegetable cowpea associations under green manuring and spatial arrangements. Revista Ciência Agronômica, 51(4), e20197067.
- SYSTAT SOFTWARE INC. Table curve 3D Academic Edition. San Jose, CA: Systat Software Inc, 2021.
- TEIXEIRA, PC; DONAGEMMA, GK; FONTANA, A; TEIXEIRA, W.G (Editores Técnicos). 2017. Manual de métodos de análise de solo. 3. ed. rev. e ampl. - Brasília, DF: Embrapa. 574p.
- YESUF, H. 2022. Evaluating the compatibility of high land sorghum Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench varieties for relay-intercropping with chickpea Cicer arietinum (L.) at High land areas of west Hararghe, Ethiopia. In: TADESSE, T; TEKALING, A; DESTA, T; MERGA, F (eds). Results of Crop Improvement and Management Research for 2019/20, 1,617-628.
- ZHANG, DS; SUN, ZX; FANG, LS; BAI, N; YANG,Z; ZHANG, GJ; DU, C; FENG, Q; CAI, Q; WANG, Q; ZHANG, Y; WANG, RN; ARSHAD, A; HAO, XY; SUN, M; GAO, ZQ; ZHANG,LZ. 2020. Maize plant density affects yield, growth and source-sink relationship of crops in maize/peanut intercropping. Field Crops Research. 257, 107926.








