PROPOSAL FOR THE EVALUATION OF BOOKS AND BOOK CHAPTERS FOR CAPES AREA 21

Ugrinowitsch, Carlos; Corrêa, Umberto Cesar; Tani, Go

Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

Brasil

Español English

sumário « anterior atual seguinte »

Sumário

ARTIGO ORIGINAL • Movimento 27 • 2021 • https://doi.org/10.22456/1982-8918.112162 copy

PROPOSAL FOR THE EVALUATION OF BOOKS AND BOOK CHAPTERS FOR CAPES AREA 21

Authorship SCIMAGO INSTITUTIONS RANKINGS

Abstract

This study proposes a system to evaluate books and book chapters based on the perception of graduate program advisers affiliated to Capes (area 21) regarding the prestige of academic publishers. Ninety professors from all Brazilian regions responded to the questionnaire to assess their perception about the prestige of academic publishers. Almost all respondents (94.25%) considered the scientific quality of books as the most critical factor in determining publishers’ quality. The prestige value of international (N=69) and national (N=97) publishers were divided into deciles. We proposed an eight-level system to classify books and book chapters based on two criteria: a) their international or national publishers; and b) publishers’ deciles. Levels L1 to L4 refer to international publishers (from high to low quality perception), and L5 to L8 refer to national publishers (from high to low quality perception).

Keywords:
Books; Evaluation of Programs and Research Instruments; Education, Graduate; Publications

RESPOSTAS	(%)
A especialização da editora	40,23
A qualidade científica dos livros publicados	94,25
A qualidade técnica das obras (design editorial, correção, leiaute, índices, etc.)	51,72
Sua carreira e o histórico editorial que criou	33,33
O foco dos livros publicados, resultado da visão da editora	34,48
O endosso científico representado pelas editoras e/ou diretores de coleção	39,08
O rigor na seleção de originais da editora	35,63
Os prêmios recebidos pela editora	5,75
A sua própria experiência como autor em relação à eficácia e competência da editora no processo de publicação	25,29
Recomendações dos colegas	11,49
O prestígio da editora entre os colegas	35,63
Sua eficiência nos procedimentos de informação, indexação e marketing	12,64
O fato de as obras serem traduzidas para outras línguas	12,64
As críticas que os seus trabalhos normalmente recebem	10,34
Outro	3,45

Editora	Pts	Editora	Pts	Editora	Pts	Editora	Pts
Elsevier (90%)	243	wiley (80%)	47	Lippicontt Willians & Willians (70%)	29	Blackwell Science (60%)	17
Human Kinects (90%)	191	Pearson (80%)	44	Porto (70%)	28	ÉDITIONS CNRS (60%)	17
Routledge (90%)	188	Thieme (80%)	44	L'Harmattan (70%)	26	Edições Piaget (60%)	13
Springer (90%)	117	Nova (80%)	39	Academic Press (70%)	23	N (60%)	10
Mc Grall Hill (90%)	109	Wolters Kluwer Health (80%)	39	Cambridge Press (70%)	23	Paidotribo (60%)	10
Oxford (90%)	73	Taylor & Francis (80%)	38	Morata (70%)	20	Palgrave (60%)	10
Sage (90%)	73	ThomsonReuters (80%)	31	W.B Saunders (70%)	19	Philadelphia (60%)	10
				Presses Universitaires de France (70%)	18	Plural (60%)	10
						Prentice Hall (60%)	10
						Publisher (60%)	10
						Sydney: Fair Play Publishing (60%)	10

Arnold (50/40%)	9	Basic Books (30/20%)	8	Bertrand Editora (10%)	7	Jones & Bartlett Learning	3
BONECKER (50/40%)	9	Basic Books (30/20%)	8	Demos (10%)	7	La Presses du Réel	3
Developmental Science (50/40%)	9	CNRS (30/20%)	8	Dykinson S. L - Madrid (10%)	7	Siglo XXI de España Editores	3
Editoral Medica Panamericana (50/40%)	9	Edexcel (30/20%)	8	VRIN (10%)	7	Editions AFRAPS	2
F.A. DAVIS (50/40%)	9	Edições 70 (30/20%)	8	Editorial Gedisa (10%)	6	Readers Digest	2
Graó - Espanha (50/40%)	9	Guilford Press (30/20%)	8	North-Holland (10%)	6	Editions EPS	1
Lisboa: Texto Editora (50/40%)	9	InTech (30/20%)	8	Piramide Ediciones (10%)	6	Stanford University Press	1
Masson - França (50/40%)	9	Norton (30/20%)	8
Morgantown: FIT Publishing (50/40%)	9	Prime Books (30/20%)	8
National Strength and Conditioning Association (50/40%)	9	Revinter (30/20%)	8
ndn (50/40%)	9
The MIT Press (50/40%)	9

Editora	Pts	Editora	Pts	Editora	Pts	Editora	Pts	Editora	Pts
Manole (90%)	445	Roca (80%)	78	Cortez (70%)	35	Sulina (60%)	17	Autobiografia (50%)	9
Guanabara (90%)	385	Vozes (80%)	75	UFRGS (70%)	34	Juruá (60%)	16	Cultura Acad (50%)	9
Artmed (90%)	363	Apris (80%)	53	Pro Fono (70%)	32	PanAmericana (60%)	15	FTD (50%)	9
Phorte (90%)	194	Edusp (80%)	50	Pulso (70%)	30	UNB (60%)	15	UFRN (50%)	9
CRV (90%)	140	G. Ed Nacional (80%)	48	Santos (70%)	29	EdUNESP (60%)	15	NDN (50%)	9
Aut.Associados (90%)	112	UFMG (80%)	46	Universitárias (70%)	27	Liber Ars (60%)	14	Pearson (50%)	9
Athneu (90%)	88	Boucher (80%)	39	UNIMEP (70%)	25	UNICAMP (60%)	14	SANARS (50%)	9
Elsevier (90%)	84	Revinter (80%)	38	Sprint (70%)	23	UEM (60%)	13	Secad (50%)	9
Papirus (90%)	83	Booktoy (80%)	38	UFSM (70%)	23	UFRN (60%)	10	Synopsis (50%)	9
Unijuí (90%)	79	Fontoura (80%)	38			EdUFSCar (60%)	10	UEPG (50%)	9
						PANCASTS (60%)	10
						Rubio (60%)	10

Doctor Press (40%)	8	Springer (30%)	6	EUNIFESP (20%)	5	ArtLetras (10%)	3	Annablume	1
HUCITEC (40%)	8	Casa Psicólogo (30%)	6	UNIVERSA (20%)	5	Campus (10%)	3	Cia das Letras	1
Lamparina (40%)	8	CBCE (30%)	6	WAK (20%)	5	eBook Kindle (10%)	3	TECCMEd	1
LTC (40%)	8	COOPMED (30%)	6	Wiley (20%)	5	PUCRS (10%)	3
Routledge (40%)	8	EDUERN (30%)	6	edUFMT (20%)	5	Saraiva (10%)	3
W.B. Saunders (40%)	8	Icone (30%)	6	SESC (20%)	5	UFBA (10%)	3
Plexus (40%)	7	Supimpa (30%)	6	UFJF (20%)	5	Artesã (10%)	2
Realize (40%)	7			CCTA (20%)	4	Átomo & Alínea (10%)	2
Shape (40%)	7			FLORENCE (20%)	4	Intersaberes (10%)	2
UFRJ (40%)	7			Paco (20%)	4	Leader (10%)	2
				Sarvier (20%)	4	Moderna (10%)	2
				Unimontes (20%)	4	Perspectiva (10%)	2
				Ulbra (20%)	4	Sete Letras (10%)	2

Classificação	Decis e Natureza	N	Livro	Capítulo
L1	90% e 80% Internacional	14	320	160
L2	70% e 60% Internacional	19	280	140
L3	50% e 40% Internacional	12	240	120
L4	30% > Internacional	24	200	100
L5	90% e 80% Nacional	20	200	100
L6	70% e 60% Nacional	21	160	80
L7	50% e 40% Nacional	20	120	60
L8	30% > Nacional	36	80	40

Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul Rua Felizardo, 750 Jardim Botânico, CEP: 90690-200, RS - Porto Alegre, (51) 3308 5814 - Porto Alegre - RS - Brazil
E-mail: movimento@ufrgs.br

Acompanhe os números deste periódico no seu leitor de RSS

[1] CONFLITO DE INTERESSES

Os autores declararam que não existe nenhum conflito de interesses neste trabalho.