Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair: single-row <i>vs.</i> double-row - clinical results after one to four years

Senna, Luís Filipe; Ramos, Max Rogério Freitas; Bergamaschi, Ricardo Folador

doi:10.1016/j.rboe.2018.05.010

Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

Brasil

Revista Brasileira de Ortopedia

Español English

Brasil

Español English

sumário « anterior atual seguinte »

Sumário

Artigos Originais • Rev. bras. ortop. 53 (4) • Jul-Aug 2018 • https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rboe.2018.05.010 copy

Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair: single-row vs. double-row - clinical results after one to four years

Authorship SCIMAGO INSTITUTIONS RANKINGS

ABSTRACT

Objective:

Evaluate and compare the results of single-row (SR) vs. double-row (DR) arthroscopic rotator cuff repair.

Methods:

From December 2009 to May 2013, 115 arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs were performed using suture anchors. After applying the exclusion criteria, there were 75 patients (79 shoulders) to be evaluated, retrospectively, of whom 53 (56 shoulders) attended re-evaluation. The patients were divided into two groups: SR with 29 shoulders, and DR) with 27 shoulders. The scoring systems for clinical evaluation were those of the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA) and the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES).

Results:

The mean follow-up period in the SR group was 37.8 months vs. 41.0 months in the DR group. The average UCLA score was 30.8 in the SR group vs. 32.6 in the DR group. This difference was not statistically significant (p > 0.05). The averages measured by the ASES score also showed no significant difference - 82.3 and 88.8 in the SR and DR groups, respectively.

Conclusion:

No statistically significant difference was found between SR and DR arthroscopic rotator cuff repair performed by a single surgeon in the comparative analysis of UCLA and ASES scores.

Keywords:
Rotator cuff; Shoulder; Bursitis; Arthroscopy

Case	G-A	Diabetes	Tobacco	Size (cm)	SR DR	T (months)	UCLA	ASES	Satisfaction	Return to work	Labor claims
1	M-55	Yes	No	3	SR	41	33	90	Yes	Yes	No
2	M-58	Yes	No	2	SR	37	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
3	M-57	No	No	2	SR	30	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
4	M-66	Yes	No	3.5	SR	35	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
5	F-65	No	No	3	SR	36	33	67	Yes	Yes	No
6	M-66	No	No	1.5	SR	33	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
7	M-65	No	No	2.8	SR	33	32	93	Yes	Yes	No
8	M-53	Yes	No	4	SR	22	31	80	Yes	Yes	No
9	F-74	No	No	3	SR	39	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
10	F-59	Yes	No	3	SR	38	16	40	Yes	No	No
11	F-59	Yes	No	2	SR	25	16	40	Yes	No	No
12	F-58	No	No	2	SR	56	35	98	Yes	Yes	No
13	F-53	No	No	1	SR	47	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
14	M-51	No	No	2	SR	48	35	95	Yes	Yes	No
15	F-50	No	No	2	SR	23	13	17	No	No	No
16	F-56	No	No	3	SR	43	33	90	Yes	Yes	No
17	M-38	No	No	1	SR	37	17	55	Yes	No	Yes
18	M-53	No	No	1	SR	54	32	65	Yes	Yes	No
19	F-53	No	No	4	SR	33	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
20	M-56	Yes	No	1	SR	34	32	92	Yes	Yes	No
21	F-64	No	No	2.5	SR	53	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
22	F-48	No	No	2	SR	31	33	78	Yes	Yes	No
23	F-48	No	No	2	SR	15	31	73	Yes	Yes	No
24	F-67	No	No	3	SR	23	34	100	Yes	Yes	No
25	M-56	No	No	4	SR	32	29	70	Yes	Yes	No
26	F-59	No	No	2.5	SR	40	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
27	F-54	Yes	No	3	SR	30	29	72	Yes	Yes	No
28	F-54	Yes	No	2	SR	17	29	72	Yes	Yes	No
29	M-73	No	No	1	SR	53	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
30	F-50	No	No	3	DR	36	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
31	M-57	No	No	2	DR	31	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
32	F-66	No	No	2	DR	22	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
33	F-57	No	No	1.5	DR	30	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
34	M-59	Yes	No	3	DR	50	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
35	F-64	No	No	3.5	DR	53	28	63	Yes	Yes	No
36	F-40	No	No	3	DR	36	33	83	Yes	Yes	No
37	F-56	No	No	1.5	DR	56	33	100	Yes	Yes	No
38	F-44	No	No	1	DR	40	30	77	Yes	Yes	No
39	M-48	No	No	1.5	DR	56	14	18	Yes	Yes	Yes
40	M-55	Yes	No	3	DR	41	33	90	Yes	Yes	No
41	M-59	No	No	5	DR	54	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
42	F-57	No	No	1.5	DR	53	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
43	F-53	No	No	1	DR	31	30	73	Yes	Yes	No
44	F-51	No	Yes	2	DR	30	23	32	No	No	Yes
45	F-48	No	No	2	DR	52	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
46	F-48	No	No	1	DR	30	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
47	F-48	No	No	2	DR	23	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
48	F-72	No	No	2	DR	22	34	100	Yes	Yes	No
49	F-56	No	No	3	DR	30	35	95	Yes	Yes	No
50	F-50	No	Yes	3	DR	35	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
51	F-60	No	No	3	DR	30	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
52	M-44	No	No	3	DR	43	30	80	Yes	Yes	No
53	F-72	No	No	1.5	DR	55	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
54	F-57	No	No	2.5	DR	48	35	100	Yes	Yes	No
55	F-65	No	No	5	DR	36	32	87	Yes	Yes	No
56	F-68	No	No	2	DR	31	35	100	Yes	Yes	No

Sociedade Brasileira de Ortopedia e Traumatologia Al. Lorena, 427 14º andar, 01424-000 São Paulo - SP - Brasil, Tel.: 55 11 2137-5400 - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
E-mail: rbo@sbot.org.br

Acompanhe os números deste periódico no seu leitor de RSS

[1] Conflicts of interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.