Description of microscopic lesions of vestibular folds of autopsied adults and their relationship with cause of death and underlying disease

Renata C. Rossi Ana. K. M. Salge Rosana R. M. Correa Mara L. F. Ferraz Vicente P. A. Teixeira Marlene A. Reis Eumenia C. C. Castro About the authors

Abstracts

Com o aumento dos métodos invasivos que são utilizados para o diagnóstico de doenças do trato respiratório é de se esperar que as alterações das pregas vestibulares (PV) sejam mais freqüentes. Além disso, recentemente tem sido discutida a importância das PV na proteção do organismo contra agentes infecciosos e pouco se sabe sobre as lesões microscópicas em pacientes autopsiados, pois o estudo das cordas vocais não é rotina no exame post mortem. OBJETIVO: O objetivo deste estudo foi descrever as alterações microscópicas das pregas vestibulares e realizar a sua relação com as causas de óbito e doença de base de adultos autopsiados. FORMA DE ESTUDO: coorte transversal. MATERIAIS E MÉTODOS: Foram estudadas microscopicamente 82 laringes coletadas de adultos autopsiados sendo realizada a coloração da Hematoxilina-eosina para visualizar as alterações morfológicas microscópicas das PV. RESULTADOS: Das 82 PV analisadas, observamos que 42 (51%) apresentaram reação inflamatória, sendo esta a única lesão encontrada. Quinze (18,3%) casos apresentaram hiperplasia dos folículos linfóides, onze (13,4%) casos infiltrado inflamatório difuso intenso e 16 (19,5%), reação inflamatória aguda. As doenças de base mais freqüentemente encontradas foram as do grupo de doenças do aparelho circulatório 31 (37,8%) e nestas 20 (67,8%) apresentavam reação inflamatória das PV. As doenças infecciosas foram a causa de morte mais freqüente nos pacientes com reação inflamatória das pregas vestibulares. CONCLUSÃO: Além da função anatômica as PV parecem possuir uma função imunológica em relação à infeccção das vias aéreas inferiores. Nosso estudo demonstrou a presença de reação inflamatória nas cordas vocais em pacientes com doenças infecciosas como causa de morte, podendo este achado estar relacionado com o processo séptico generalizado que levou o indivíduo à morte ou ser uma das formas do organismo prevenir a penetração de agentes infecciosos.

adultos; autópsia; inflamação; pregas vestibulares


The increase in invasive methods currently applied to diagnosis airway upper tract infection leads to a possible increase in vestibular folds (VF) lesions. Besides, VF importance in the prevention of the organism against infection pathogens had been stressed and few studies had addressed the microscopic lesions of the VF in autopsied patients because there is no routine VF examination in the postmortem exam. AIM: The aim of this study is morphological microscopic analyses of the VF from autopsied patients and its correlation with basic disease and cause of death. STUDY DESIGN: transversal cohort. MATERIAL AND METHOD: We studied 82 larynges collected during the autopsy exam and performed the Hematoxylin -eosin method for morphological analyses. RESULTS: From the 82 vestibular folds analyzed we observe that 42 (51%) showed an inflammatory reaction. In fifteen (18.3%) vestibular folds we found lymphoid follicular hyperplasia, in eleven (13.4%) diffuse inflammatory infiltrate and in sixteen (19.5%) acute inflammatory reactions. Circulatory diseases were the most frequently underlying diseases found, 31 (37.8%) and from these 20 (67.8%) presented associated vestibular folds inflammatory reaction. The infection diseases were the most frequently cause of death among the patients with inflammatory reaction of the VF. CONCLUSION: Besides the anatomic function, VF seem to have a immunological function preventing lower airway infections. Our study demonstrated inflammatory PV reactions in patients with infections diseases as cause of death; this finding could be a consequence of the sepses that leads the patient to death or a different way used by the organism to prevent infection.

adults; autopsy; inflammation; vestibular folds


ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Description of microscopic lesions of vestibular folds of autopsied adults and their relationship with cause of death and underlying disease

Renata C. RossiI; Ana. K. M. SalgeII; Rosana R. M. CorreaIII; Mara L. F. FerrazIV; Vicente P. A. TeixeiraV; Marlene A. ReisVI; Eumenia C. C. CastroVII

IPhysical Therapist, Master studies under course, Post-graduation in General Pathology, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro

IIRegistered Nurse, Ph.D. studies under course, Post-Graduation in General Pathology, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro

IIIRegistered Nurse, Master studies under course, Post-Graduation in General Pathology, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro

IVBiologist, Discipline of General Pathology, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro

VPhysician, Ph.D. studies under course, Faculty Professor, Discipline of General Pathology, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro

VIPhysician, Ph.D. studies under course, Joint Professor, Discipline of General Pathology, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro

VIIPhysician, Post-doctorate studies under course, Joint Professor, Discipline of General Pathology, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro

Correspondence

SUMMARY

The increase in invasive methods currently applied to diagnosis airway upper tract infection leads to a possible increase in vestibular folds (VF) lesions. Besides, VF importance in the prevention of the organism against infection pathogens had been stressed and few studies had addressed the microscopic lesions of the VF in autopsied patients because there is no routine VF examination in the postmortem exam.

AIM: The aim of this study is morphological microscopic analyses of the VF from autopsied patients and its correlation with basic disease and cause of death.

STUDY DESIGN: transversal cohort.

MATERIAL AND METHOD: We studied 82 larynges collected during the autopsy exam and performed the Hematoxylin -eosin method for morphological analyses.

RESULTS: From the 82 vestibular folds analyzed we observe that 42 (51%) showed an inflammatory reaction. In fifteen (18.3%) vestibular folds we found lymphoid follicular hyperplasia, in eleven (13.4%) diffuse inflammatory infiltrate and in sixteen (19.5%) acute inflammatory reactions. Circulatory diseases were the most frequently underlying diseases found, 31 (37.8%) and from these 20 (67.8%) presented associated vestibular folds inflammatory reaction. The infection diseases were the most frequently cause of death among the patients with inflammatory reaction of the VF.

CONCLUSION: Besides the anatomic function, VF seem to have a immunological function preventing lower airway infections. Our study demonstrated inflammatory PV reactions in patients with infections diseases as cause of death; this finding could be a consequence of the sepses that leads the patient to death or a different way used by the organism to prevent infection.

Key words: adults, autopsy, inflammation, vestibular folds.

INTRODUCTION

Vestibular folds (VF) are two thick laminae, saggitally positioned with doubled-sized mucosa that emerge from the supraglottic wall and form medially the wall of laryngeal ventricle. The mucosa is recovered by non-stratified squamous epithelium and submucous glands. Squamous epithelium may duplicate and increase with aging 1-3.

Vocal folds are located at the glottis and they are the first barrier to the passage of infectious agents to lower airways. As a result of the increase in invasive methods used for the diagnosis of respiratory tract diseases, it is expectable that VF abnormalities become more frequent. Moreover, the importance of VF in protecting the body against infectious agents has been recently discussed 1, 2. In studies conducted with true vocal folds we can find the description of lesions such as thickness of basal membrane of true vocal folds epithelium and their relation with infectious diseases 4, but there is no report on vestibular folds. As to microscopic lesions of VF, there are reports of lymphoid follicle hyperplasia of VF and the suggestion of the term laryngeal tonsil 5 to name the structure, since it has been observed that this tissue presents an organization and that it could be replaced by larynx associated lymphoid tissue 2. However, all studies were conducted with few patients and no other associated lesions were described.

The studies conducted with VF are scarce and insufficient to make us understand the microscopic lesions found in these organs. The objective of the present study was to describe the microscopic affections to vestibular folds and to associate them with cause of death and underlying disease of autopsied adults.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We conducted a retrospective transversal study of consecutive autopsies in adults carried out by the Discipline of General Pathology, University Hospital, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro (FMTM), in Uberaba-MG, between 1993 and 2001. Larynges were removed and all autopsies were fixed with formaldehyde at 10%. Later, the larynx was sectioned transversally at points above and below the glottic cavity and within 3cm one from the other. Parallel sections to the extremity of the vocal folds were made, transversally, and the fragment was processed for paraffin preparation 4. We performed hematoxylin-eosin staining (HE) for morphological analysis. We considered normal VF (Figure 1A) when they had with discreet diffuse mononuclear cell infiltrate or absence of inflammatory cells on lamina propria. VF that had lymphoid follicle hyperplasia or moderate or severe chronic or acute inflammatory reactions were considered as having inflammatory reaction.



We collected gender and age of patients from medical charts. From autopsy reports, we collected diagnosis of death and underlying diseases. The diseases were grouped according to the International Classification of Diseases 6. The present study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro.

To conduct statistical analysis, we used software Sigmastat. Proportions were compared with c2, plus Fisher exact test. For the correlation between variable of normal distribution, we used Pearson correlation coefficient, if not, we applied Spearman coefficient. Differences were considered statistically significant when p was smaller than 5% (p<0.05).

RESULTS

We analyzed 82 VF from autopsied patients. Mean age of patients was 53.0±16.7 years and 48 (59%) were male. There were 40 normal VF (48.8%) and 42 cases (51%) presented morphological abnormalities.

The morphological affection found in the VF was inflammatory reaction of variable severity. We found diffuse marked mononuclear inflammatory infiltrate on the lamina propria of VF in 11 patients (13.4%) (Figure 1B). Hyperplasia of lymphoid follicles was found in 15 cases (18.5%) (Figure 1C). The presence of neutrophils in the inflammatory infiltrate was considered as an acute inflammatory reaction (Figure 1D) and it was diagnosed in 16 (19.5%) of the patients (Table 1). We did not find any other microscopic affections of VF.

As to the group of underlying diseases, we observed that the group of patients that presented normal VF were classified as having infectious and parasitic diseases - 14 cases (35%), and AIDS was diagnosed in 12 cases, the most frequent disease. To patients that presented inflammatory reaction, 20 (48%) had circulatory system diseases, and 8 of them (40%) had chronic Chagas disease (Table 2).

As to cause of death, we detected that infectious and parasitic diseases were the most frequent cause of death both for the normal group (21 - 52%) and the inflammatory reaction group (20 - 50%), being that pneumonitis was the most frequent disease (Table 3).

Intense and diffuse inflammatory reaction in 15 (55.5%) of the cases was found as more frequent among patients that had died of infectious diseases, regardless of underlying disease (table 4).

Out of the total patients who had infectious or parasitic causes of death, 21 (25.6%) cases presented AIDS as underlying disease. Out of these cases, the diagnosis of VF inflammatory reaction was made in 5 cases (6%) and hyperplasia of lymphoid follicles in 4 (4.8%), less frequent than in the other patients (Table 5).

DISCUSSION

The morphological lesion found in the VF was inflammatory reaction, followed by lymphoid follicle hyperplasia. According to the literature, this is a common finding in VF, but we did not find the described percentages to compare with our data 2.

VF function is to lubricate and isolate the true vocal folds to allow vibration 7. Therefore, given that they are neighboring structures and functionally interrelated, we would expect similar lesions. In a study conducted before, different lesions were described from that of true vocal folds 1, but this fact was different concerning our VF because we only found inflammatory affections. These data are in accordance with the hypothesis that there are immunologically different regions in the larynx and that they respond to stimulus in specific ways 1, 2.

Inflammatory and diffuse reactions were more frequently found in patients who had died of infectious diseases, regardless of the underlying disease. There are studies that show production of cytokines in the presence of infectious agents in VF 1, 2. Our findings reinforce the hypothesis that VF may be involved in the defense of the organism in view of infections. Another hypothesis is that the demonstrated inflammatory reaction is part of systemic septic reaction that resulted in death of the patient.

Both the diffuse inflammatory reaction and lymphoid follicle hyperplasia were found as less frequent in immunodepressed subjects. These patients present generalized immunodeficiency, which may justify the lack of inflammatory infiltrate in VF of this group of patients.

CONCLUSION

In addition to the anatomical function, VF have a possible immune function concerning upper airway infections. Our study showed inflammatory reaction in vocal folds of patients with infectious and parasitic diseases as cause of death, which may be a finding related with generalized septic process that led the subject to death or be one of the forms used by the body to prevent penetration of infectious agents through the lower airways.

REFERENCES

  • Correspondence to
    Eumenia Costa da Cunha Castro
    Disciplina de Patologia Geral; Departamento de Ciências Biológicas
    Faculdade de Medicina do Triângulo Mineiro
    Av. Frei Paulino, 30 Bairro Abadia
    38025-180 Uberaba MG
    Tel (55 34) 3318-5428 – Fax: (55 34) 3318-5846
    E-mail:
  • Article submited on March 25, 2004. Article accepted on March 21, 2005.

    The present study was conducted at Discipline of General Pathology, Medical School, Triângulo Mineiro, supported by Fundação de Ensino e Pesquisa de Uberaba (FUNEPU), Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq), Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES) and Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de Minas Gerais (FAPEMIG).

    • 1
      Kutta H, Steven P, Kohla G, Tillmann B, Paulsen F. The human false vocal folds an analysis of antimicrobial defense mechanisms. Anat Embryol (Berl) 2002; 205(4): 315-23.
    • 2
      Kutta H, Steven P, Tillmann B, Tsokos M, Paulsen F. Region-specific Immunological Response of the Different Laryngeal Compartments: Significance of Larynx-associated Lymphoid Tissue. Cell Tissue Res 2003; 311(3): 365-71.
    • 3
      Szewczyk AJ. Correlation of clinical and histological pictures of precancerous conditions and early-stage glottic carcinoma. Otolaryngol Pol 1992; 46(5): 448-56.
    • 4
      Salge AKM, Castro ECC, Ferraz MLF et al Relationship between the morphologic alterations of vocal cords from adult autopsies and the cause of death. Rev Hosp Clin 2004; 59 (2): 63-6.
    • 5
      Frankel B. Der Ventrículus Morgagni. Arch Layngol 1893, 1:1-16.
    • 6
      CID. 10ª Revisão. OMS, Genebra, Suíça. Faculdade de Saúde Pública da Universidade de São Paulo FSP-USP / OMS / OPAS. Edusp – Editora da Universidade de São Paulo, 1997.
    • 7
      Agarwal M, Scherer RC, Hollien H. The false vocal folds: shape and size in frontal view during phonation based on lamonagraphic tracings. Journal of Voice 2003; 17: 97-113.
    • 8
      Courey MS, Shohet JA, Scott MA, Ossoff RH. Immunohistochemical characterization of benign laryngeal lesions. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1996; 105(7): 525-31.

    Correspondence to Eumenia Costa da Cunha Castro Disciplina de Patologia Geral; Departamento de Ciências Biológicas Faculdade de Medicina do Triângulo Mineiro Av. Frei Paulino, 30 Bairro Abadia 38025-180 Uberaba MG Tel (55 34) 3318-5428 – Fax: (55 34) 3318-5846 E-mail: eumenia.pat@dcb.fmtm.br

    Publication Dates

    • Publication in this collection
      02 Aug 2005
    • Date of issue
      Apr 2005

    History

    • Accepted
      21 Mar 2005
    • Received
      25 Mar 2004
    ABORL-CCF Associação Brasileira de Otorrinolaringologia e Cirurgia Cérvico-Facial Av. Indianápolis, 740, 04062-001 São Paulo SP - Brazil, Tel./Fax: (55 11) 5052-9515 - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
    E-mail: revista@aborlccf.org.br