The only question that has been lingering in my mind in the modern Marxist studies on law is this: what is the dialectical and compound association between alienation of labor and the practice of judicial? The analytical cases chosen in this paper include three socialist societies the Soviet Union, China, and Cuba in an attempt to determine how Marxist labor theory is implanted in legal orders, and also how it exposes the underlying tensions (Xia; Zhang, 2025).
One must admit that Xia and Zhang (2025) have done a significant job in systematizing historical documents and cross-national comparison, especially when it comes to comprehending the similarities and dissimilarities in the labor legislation of these three countries, which shows quite a wide scholarly perspective. Yet, when we place our judgment of the article in comparison with the critical spirit and the philosophical-historical profundity required by the Marxist theory itself, we feel that we may be digging further. Engels put it very clearly in Dialectics of Nature: Theoretical thinking is merely an inborn ability. This ability should be acquired and honed. And to this refinement, so far, there has been no other way than the study of previous philosophy (Engels, 1971). Having read this article, I strongly believe that it will still take a long time to answer the emerging new labor expressions in the digital age to Marxist jurisprudence.
From a philosophical perspective, Marx’s labor theory of value is not only a critique of economic exploitation but also a reflection on the mode of existence of human beings. To this end, the labor is alienated under capitalistic conditions, whereby labor becomes the coercive power outside of the laborer. Additionally, this was furthered by Pashukanis, who held the view that the very legal form is itself the outcome of a commodity-exchange relation (Pashukanis, 2017). Unfortunately, despite the fact that this article raises the issue of the phenomenon of bureaucratic alienation in its discussion of the labor laws of socialist countries, it does not carry out a profound philosophical examination of the duplicity, such as in this alienation. That is, the state, the embodiment of the common power, in its legal exercise seeks to overcome the logic of capital but naturally creates new forms of domination. Using the case of the Soviet Union, the so-called workers committees, which had been set up as part of the initial legal system, were given management roles but slowly engulfed by the bureaucracy during Stalinism. Not only does this transformation reveal the constraints of institutional design, but it also represents the inherent paradox in Marxist theory in relation to the relationship of states and society. A deeper insight into the reason socialist law, though theoretically against alienation, tends to consolidate the oppression of laborers in reality, would come with the introduction of the theory of cultural hegemony by Gramsci and the Ideological State Apparatus of the Ideology, as formulated by Althusser.
In terms of the current dilemmas of the digital age, the article has provided an acknowledgment of the new kinds of alienation through the platform economy, but it has not been exhaustive in exploring the theoretical levels on which these issues have taken place, such as data ownership, politics of technology, and governance of algorithms. The general intellect formulated by Marx and further extended by such scholars as Virno has turned into cognitive capitalism theories and highlights how knowledge, affect, as well as social cooperation are core to modern-day labor. In this view, as in traditional exploitation, platform laborers experience the twofold pressure of data alienation and algorithmic domination. Using the case of food delivery riders, their work is always tracked and streamlined by algorithms; the process of work turns secondary to the production of data, and the methods are not allowed to formal workers anymore, introduced as the so-called independent contractors. By presenting these critical theories of technology, the analysis of the gig economy may go beyond superficial labor protections to address the philosophical questions of the nature of labor in the digital era. In the same way, bringing up the topic of automation technology, the article only briefly mentions the notion of Universal Basic Income (UBI), and manifests a relatively conservative conception of the law that is legal imagination that entertains the imaginary post-work society. A key task of Marxist jurisprudence, in my sense, could be to theories the legal paradigm beyond “employment-centrism” in order to no longer use the principles of labor law to govern employment relationships, but rather to facilitate free and complete realization of human beings.
Methodologically, the hermeneutic comparison, used in the article, is rather valuable, however, I think, more extensive use of the historical materialist principle of the concrete totality, that places legal practice in the context of global capital flows and geopolitical changes, might be more fruitful. The comparative study of the three countries in the labor legislation of this article remains rather institutionalized and does not incorporate the legal practice into the overall picture of the global movement of capital, geopolitical shifts, and transformation of the domestic stratification. As an example with the alterations in the Cuban labor law, the domestic economic factors are not the only motive and force that impact it, but the international chess game of hegemony of the US dollar and the Latin American leftist movements also influence it. On the same note, the redesigning of global supply chains is considerably ascribed to the metamorphosis of the Chinese labor law. It would perhaps be better to introduce more macro perspectives, including but not limited to World-Systems Theory, which would better expose structural dilemmas of socialist labor law within the context of globalization, and the possibilities of a breakthrough. These are the very practical problems of the world that Marxist jurisprudence will have to face and address.
Overall, this article is, in a way, like a window is thrown open to us, giving us a peek into the profuse terrain of the judicial practice of Marxist labor theory, but the exterior is yet to be traversed appropriately. This is an age of the fastest changing labor formations where Marxist jurisprudence needs the bravery of imagination to penetrate the standard models, with their foundations in history but their face to reality of the moment, to give theory the actual explanatory strength and dynamism that it deserves.
References
- ENGELS. Dialectics of Nature. Beijing: People’s Publishing House, 1971.
- PASHUKANIS. The General Theory of Law and Marxism. London: Routledge, 2017.
-
XIA, L. L.; ZHANG, M. Y. An attempt to eliminate the alienation of labor: interpretation of Marx’ s view of labor in the socialist countries’ legal practice. Trans/Form/Ação: Unesp journal of philosophy, Marília, SP, v. 48, n. 5, p. e025054, 2025. Available at: https://revistas.marilia.unesp.br/index.php/transformacao/article/view/16904
» https://revistas.marilia.unesp.br/index.php/transformacao/article/view/16904
