SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

vol.12 issue4Chromosome evolution in fishes: a new challenging proposal from Neotropical speciesDifference in reproduction energy content in muscles on fish from reservoirs in Paraná State, Brazil author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Services on Demand




Related links


Neotropical Ichthyology

Print version ISSN 1679-6225On-line version ISSN 1982-0224

Neotrop. ichthyol. vol.12 no.4 Porto Alegre Oct./Dec. 2014  Epub Nov 11, 2014 


Reproductive biology of the skates Sympterygia acuta Garman, 1877 and S. bonapartii Müller & Henle, 1841 (Chondrichthyes: Rajoidei) in south Brazil

Alexander Basallo 1  

Maria Cristina Oddone 2  

1Universidade Federal do Rio Grande, Instituto de Ciências Biológicas, Programa de Pós-Graduação em Oceanografia Biológica, Av. Itália, Km 8 s/n, Campus Carreiros, 96203-900 Rio Grande, RS, Brazil,

2Universidade Federal do Rio Grande, Instituto de Ciências Biológicas, Fisiologia Animal Comparada, Av. Itália, Km 8 s/n, Campus Carreiros, 96203-900 Rio Grande, RS, Brazil


The present study analyzed the sexual development, sizes at maturity and morphometric relationships for both sexes of Sympterygia acuta and S. bonapartii, endemic of south-western Atlantic Ocean. The examined specimens were obtained through research cruises and commercial fishing trips, during 2011 and 2012, along the southern Brazilian coast, in latitudes ranging from 34°28'S to 31°29'S and at depths between 15 and 142 m. Significant differences (p<0.05) in S. bonapartii and in S acuta between sexes for the relationships total length (cm) - disc width (cm) and total length - total/eviscerated weight (g) respectively, demonstrated sexual dimorphism during the development in both species. The estimated size at maturity for males and females, respectively, were 46.1 and 44.7 cm, for S. acuta, and 58.4 and 59.9 cm, for S. bonapartii. A decrease in size at maturity for both sexes was observed in S. acuta and females of S. bonapartii of the southern coast of Brazil, respect to previous studies carried out over the last 30 years.

Key words: Endemic; Maturity; Morphometric; Oviparity; Reproduction


O presente estudo analisou o desenvolvimento sexual, os tamanhos de maturidade e as relações morfométricas para ambos os sexos das espécies Sympterygia acuta e S. bonapartii endêmica do sudoeste do Oceano Atlântico. Os indivíduos foram coletados em cruzeiros de investigação e viagens de pesca comercial durante 2011 e 2012 ao longo da costa do Sul do Brasil em latitudes que variam de 34°28'S a 31° 29'S, e em profundidades entre 15 e 142 m. Houve diferenças significativas entre sexos para S. bonapartii (p <0,05) e S acuta nas relações comprimento total (cm) - largura do disco (cm) e comprimento - peso total e comprimento total - peso eviscerado (g), demonstrando dimorfismo sexual durante o desenvolvimento em ambas as espécies.Os tamanhos estimados de maturação para machos e fêmeas, respectivamente, foram iguais a 46,1 e 44,7 cm para S. acuta; e 58,4 e 59,9 cm para S. bonapartii. Uma diminuição nos tamanhos de maturidade para ambos os sexos foi observada em S. acuta e fêmeas de S. bonapartii da costa Sul do Brasil, com relação a estudos realizados há 30 anos.


The genus Sympterygia Müller & Henle, 1837 (Chondrichthyes, Rajiformes) constitutes a taxonomically stable clade within the Suborder Rajoidei and includes four neotropical oviparous skate species: S. lima (Poeppig, 1835), S. brevicaudata (Cope, 1877), S. acuta (Garman, 1877) and S. bonapartii (Müller & Henle, 1841) (McEachran, 1982; Ebert & Compagno, 2007). The latter two are endemic to the shelves of the western South Atlantic Ocean shelves (Figueiredo, 1977; McEachran & Aschliman, 2004) and represent an important economic resource in their whole distribution area (Mabragaña et al., 2002; Menni & Stehmann, 2000; Paesch & Domingo, 2003). In southern Brazil (south and southeast), S. acuta and S. bonapartii complete their life cycle in the innercontinental shelf waters (De Queiroz, 1986; Vooren, 1997; Vooren et al., 2005).

Like other elasmobranchs, the rajoids present relatively low fecundity, late sexual maturity and high longevity. These characteristics, together with fish exploitation, have led to population decreases worldwide, including cases of local extinction (Dulvy et al., 2000; Dulvy & Reynolds, 2002; Iglésias et al., 2009). The bignose fanskate S. acuta, is (globally) considered by the IUCN Red List of Threatened species as "Vulnerable". On the other hand, the smallnose fanskate, S. bonapartii, is classified as "Data Deficient" (Massa & Hozbor, 2004; Massa & Lamilla, 2004). However, due to the high fishing pressure to which both species are subject, the mentioned categories may change regionally in a short-term period.

Studies on the reproductive biology, size-at-maturity and abundance of S. bonapartii were carried out in the coasts of Argentina and Uruguay over the last decade, demonstrating an increasing concern for the fisheries effects upon their populations, as well as the need for biological data (especially on reproduction) in order to ensure their sustainable exploitation (Mabragaña et al., 2002; Oddone & Velasco, 2004).

De Queiroz (1986) analyzed the reproductive biology of Sympterygia spp. in the southern Brazilian shelf. Apart from these data being part of an unpublished thesis, they were collected in the period 1981-1984, i.e., almost 30 years ago. Moreover, it is a well-known fact that in the reproductive parameters, such as the size-at-maturity, may change in the rajoids due to the pressure of excessive fishing (Walters & Martell, 2004).

It is, therefore, necessary, to provide an updated study on the reproductive biology of genus Sympterygia in southern Brazil, in order to guide the management decisions needed for their conservation, including measures such as closed areas and minimum landing sizes. The aim of this study was , thus, to provide updated information on the reproductive parameters of S. bonapartii and S. acuta in the southernmost continental shelf of Brazil between Conceição (31° 43'S) and Chui (33°45'S).

Material and Methods

Samples of Sympterygia spp. were obtained from two sources: one-day-long research cruises aboard the research vessel "Larus" (Instituto de Oceanografia, Universidade Federal de Rio Grande), done in May, June, July and August 2011; and two commercial fishing trips carried out along the coast of Rio Grande do Sul State (southern Brazil), from September 22nd to 30th 2011 and from January 30th to February 10th 2012. The studied area was located between the latitudes of 34°28'Sand 31°29'S at depths between 15 and 142 m (Fig. 1). Voucher specimens of S. acuta (SA001C; SA002C) and S. bonapartii (SB003C; SB004C) were stored in the fish collection of the Laboratory of Morphology and Histology, ICB / FURG, Brazil. A total of 92 males and 125 females of S. bonapartii and 17 males and 28 females of S. acuta were obtained and analyzed. Of each specimen, the following data were registered: total length (TL) from the snout to the tip of the tail, the width of the disc (DW) measured as the length between opposite pectoral fin tips, total weight (TW), eviscerated weight (EW), liver weight (LW) and gonad weight (GW) (measured values in cm and g, respectively) (sensu Oddone et al. 2007a).

For males, the clasper and clasper gland length, the number of alar thorns and rows of alar thorns were recorded. Alar thorns considered as ''developing'' were registered as a circular light mark on a darker epidermis, being evident laterally on the dorsal region of both pectoral fins (sensu Oddone & Vooren, 2005) The calcification of the clasper was manually assessed and classified as "flexible" or "rigid". From females, the height of the oviducal glands, according to Serra Pereira et al. (2011), the number of vitellogenic follicles larger than 1 cm (Mabragaña et al., 2002) and smaller than 1 cm (Díaz Andrade et al., 2011), the uteri width, diameter and the colour of the largest ovarian follicle, as well as the presence or absence of egg capsules in the uteri and in the cloacal region were registered (Oddone & Vooren, 2005). According to the development of the above-mentioned reproductive structures in relation to TL, the individuals were classified in three maturity categories: immature, adolescent and mature (Oddone et al., 2007a).

Fig. 1 Map of the study area. Left map represents South America. The square is a detail of the study area. The right map represents south of Brazil indicating the trawling stations where the specimens of Sympterygia were captured; research cruises of the research vessel "Larus" (triangles) and commercial bottom trawl fishing trips (circles). 

Morphometric measurements of both species and sexes were compared. Total length-width disc, total length-total weight and total length-eviscerated weight were log-transformed to become linear and the F-test was used to establish comparisons (Souza, 1998). In this respect, a covariance analysis was applied, where the variable "sex" was a factor. We verified if the curves fitting separately substantially reduced the sum of the squared residuals. The logistic equation was used to estimate the size of sexual maturity, as

PTL=1/ (1-e(a+bTL))

where, PTL is the fraction of mature individuals for each class of TL, a and b are the model parameters. The TL50, or the size at which 50% of the population is mature, is given by the ratio a/b (Restrepo & Watson, 1991). As the relationships between clasper length and TL and clasper gland length and TL followed a sigmoid-shaped curve, the logistic equation was also fitted in order to estimate the inflexion point of these relationships, and therefore assess the adolescent phase through these variables. In using parametric/non-parametric tests, normality and homogeneity of variance of the variables were tested by Lilliefors' and Levene's tests, respectively. Parametric comparisons were performed using the Student t-test, which was applied to compare the mean number of alar thorns and the mean number of rows of alar thorns and to assess the statistical significance of the differences between the number of ovarian follicles in mature females and egg-bearing females (Sokal & Rohlf, 2012). Reproductive parameters were expressed in terms of mean and standard deviation as mean ± S.D. In all cases "n" is the size of the sample. A level of significance of 0.05 was considered for all the applied tests.


Morphometric relationships in Sympterygia bonapartii and

S. acuta. Total length of male S. bonapartii ranged between 47.2 cm and 76.8 cm. Immature males had TLs of 47.2-62.5 cm (mean=56.12; SD=4.41; n=14); adolescents of 55.0-71.6 cm (mean=61.38; SD=4.78; n=19) and in mature specimens TL varied from 58.6 to 76.8 cm (mean=65.46; SD=4.39; n=59). The relationship between TL and DW in males was linear (Fig. 2a) (Table 1).

Total length of female S. bonapartii varied between 30.8 and 79.1 cm. Values in immature females varied from 30.8 to 67.5 cm (mean=56.2; SD=12.55; n=17). Adolescents had total length ranging from 36.8 to 73.3 cm (mean=65.1; SD=9.99; n=12). In matures females, TL varied from 58.0 to 79.1 cm (mean=68.8; SD=4.20; n=96) and egg-bearing females had TL ranging from 68.0 to 71.2 cm (mean=69.3; SD=1.35; n=4). The relationship between TL and DW in females was linear (Fig. 2a) (Table 1).

According to F-test results, significant differences were detected between sexes for to the relationship TL-DW, TL-TW and TL-EW for S. bonapartii (Table 1, Fig. 2a-c).

Total length of male S. acuta varied from 29.5 to 56.5 cm. The values of TL for immature individuals ranged between 29.5 and 47.0 cm (mean=41.5; SD=8.19; n=4). Adolescents ranged from 43.8 to 46.5 cm TL (mean=45.15; SD=1.90; n=2). Mature specimens had TLs varying between 47.0 and 56.5 cm (mean=50.25; SD=2.70; n=11). The relationship between TL and DW in males was linear (Fig. 2d) (Table 1).

In female S. acuta, TLs ranged between 21.0 and 60.0 cm. Immature females had TLs of 21.0-51.4 cm (mean=33.07; SD=11.08; n=7); adolescents of 48.9-52.7 cm (mean=50.76; SD=1.46; n=5); and mature specimens of 49.6 to 60.0 cm (mean=53.65; SD=3.08; n=11). Egg-bearing females had values between 47.7 and 58.0 cm TL (mean=53.14; SD=3.74; n=5). The relationship between TL and DW in females was linear (Fig. 2d) (Table 1). In S. acuta the relationships between TL-DW, TL-TW and TL-EW showed significant differences (Table 1, Fig. 2 d-f).

Table 1 Relationships analyzed for S. bonapartii and S. acuta. TL=total length (cm), DW=disc width (cm), TW=total weight (g), EW=eviscerated weight (g) for males (M) and females (F) with the respective potential regression equation; correlation coefficient (r) and sample number (n). 

Curve Sex Equation r n F-test results
S. bonapartii
TL-DW M DW=2.213+0.6252*TL 0.911 92 F=3.106;d.f.=(2,213);p<0.001
F DW=1.921+0.6488*TL 0.890 125
TL-TW M TW=0.019968TL2.71552 0.852 87 F=3.314;d.f.=(2,203);p<0.001
F TW=0.043169TL2.5428 0.745 120
TL-EW M EW=0.022659TL2.66553 0.879 87 F=3.174;d.f.=(2,203);p<0.001
F EW=1.30685TL2.95601 0.743 120
S. acuta
TL-DW M DW=2.275+0,5069 *TL 0.956 17 F=4.449;d.f.=(2,39);p=0.015
F DW=1.295+0.5181*TL 0.970 26
TL-TW M TW=0.901592TL2.15908 0.922 17 F=3.438;d.f.= (2,41);p=0.006
F TW=0.041639TL2.43972 0.754 28
TL-EW M EW=0.002462TL3.1534 0.883 17 F=3.461;d.f.= (2,41);p=0.006
F EW=0.048513TL2.36878 0.761 28

Sexual development of male Sympterygia bonapartii. The clasper length in immature individuals varied from 3.8 to 11.3 cm (mean=8.73; SD=2.16; n=14). Adolescents had clasper length ranging from 9.5 to 15.4 cm (mean=12.26; SD=1.73; n=19) and in mature males these values varied between 13.5 and 18.1 cm (mean=15.53; SD=1.05; n=59). The onset of clasper calcification was observed at TL=55.2 cm. The inflexion point of the clasper length-TL relationship was estimated to be at 53.2 cm (r=0.81; n=92) (Fig. 3a).

Fig. 2 Sympterygia bonapartii (circles) with relationship between total length (cm) and (a) disc width (cm), (b) total weight (g) and (c) eviscerated weight (g) (by sex). Sympterygia acuta (triangles) with relationship between total length (cm) and (d) disc width (cm), (e) total weight (g) and (f) eviscerated weight (g). 

The clasper gland length in immature individuals ranged between 1.8 and 3.6 cm (mean=2.94; SD=0.59; n=14). In adolescents this length ranged from 3.1 to 6.7 cm (mean=4.63; SD=0.94; n=19) and in mature individuals from 5.5 to 9.0 cm (mean=6.99; SD=0.77; n=59) (Fig. 3b). The inflexion point of the clasper gland-TL relationship was estimated at 57.3 cm (r=0.60; n=92).

Testicular lobules became macroscopically visible at TLs of 47.2 cm onward. Immature individuals had testicular lobules with diameters varying between 0.1 and 0.5 cm (mean=0.3; SD=0.14; n=14).The adolescent lobule diameter ranged between 0.3 and 0.7 cm (mean=0.47; SD=0.12; n=19). Mature males had testicular lobules with diameters between 0.3 and 0.8cm (mean=0.52; SD=0.12; n=59) (Fig. 3c).

Fig. 3 Sympterygia bonapartii. Relationship between total length (cm) and (a) clasper length (cm), (b) clasper gland length (cm), (c) diameter of the testicular lobule (cm), (d) testicles weight (g) and (e) total number of alar thorns (left Y axis) and total number of rows of alar thorns (right Y axis). 

Testicles weight varied from 1.5 to 21.1 g (mean=11.34; SD=6.91; n=14) in immature specimens, from 8.4 to 32.1 g (mean=22.14; SD=7.19; n=19) in adolescents and from 10.2 to 34.7 g (mean=20.45; SD=4.96; n=59) in mature males (Fig. 3d). The number of alar thorns rows varied from 1 to 6 on each pectoral fin. No significant difference was detected between left and right pectoral fins regarding the mean alar thorn rows number (mean=2.49, SD=1.38, n=77; mean=2.46, SD=1.47, n=77, respectively) (t=0.11; d.f.=76; p=0.91). The number of alar thorns ranged between 6 to 88 on the right fin and from 6 to 94 on the left one (mean=30.64, SD=19.84, n=77; mean=30.57, SD=20.60, n=77, respectively) with no significant differences between fins (t=0.019; d.f.=76; p=0.98). The number of developing thorns varied from 6 to 24 and from 6 to 20 for right and left pectoral fins, respectively (mean=11.05, SD=4.22, n=20; mean=10.75, SD=4.12, n=20, respectively) (Fig. 3e). Differences between fins were not significant (t=0.22; d.f.=38; p=0.82).

Immature individuals with developing thorns had TLs smaller than 62.5 cm. An adolescent individual with TL of 50.0 cm showed developing thorns, which were also recorded in two mature specimens with TLs of 59.6 and 61.3 cm respectively (Fig. 3e).

The size at which 50% of the population is mature, TL50 was estimated at 58.4 cm (r=0.98; n=92) for male S. bonapartii (Fig. 4).

Sexual development of male Sympterygia acuta. The measures of clasper length in immature individuals of S. acuta varied 0.9 to 3.7 cm (mean=2.8; SD=1.29; n=4); in adolescents from 7.6 to 9.4 cm (mean=8.5; SD=1.27; n=2); and in mature individuals from 7.3 to 13.0 cm (mean=9.5; SD=1.92; n=11). The onset of calcification occurred when males attained a TL of 43.8 cm. The inflection point of the curve clasper length vs. Total length was 43.9 cm (r=0.69; n=17) (Fig. 5a).

Fig. 4 Percentage of mature individuals by total length class for males and females Sympterygia acuta (black line) and S. bonapartii (grey line). Empty triangles represent male Sympterygia bonapartii and full triangles, male S. acuta

Empty circles represent female S. bonapartii and full circles, female S. acuta. Individuals with TL between 43.8 and 52.5 cm, had values of clasper gland length between 2.3 and 5.2 cm. (Fig. 5b).

The testicular weight of immature individuals varied between 0.5 and 2.0 g (mean=1.39; SD=0.61; n=4). The testicles weight in adolescents varied between 5.0 and 10.0 g (mean=7.5; SD=3.53; n=2). Mature males had testicular weights between 6.0 and 13.9 g (mean=10.79; SD=2.24; n=11) (Fig. 5c).

The number of alar thorns rows varied between 4 and 6, on both right and left pectoral fins (mean=5, SD=0.63, n=11; mean=4.9, SD=0.70, n=11, respectively) with no significant differences between fins (t=0.31; d.f.=10; p=0.75). The number of alar thorns varied from the 16 to 75 on the right and from 14 to 68 on the left pectoral fin (mean=29.36, SD=21.03, n=11; mean=27.91, SD=18.8, n=11, respectively) (Fig. 5d) with no significant difference (t=0.17; d.f.=10; p=0.86) (Fig. 5d). The TL50for S. acuta males, was estimated at 46.1 cm (r=0.99; n=17) (Fig. 4).

Sexual development of female Sympterygia bonapartii.

Females with ovary weights between 1.2 and 10.2 g, were immature with no vitellogenic activity (mean=6.8; SD=2.81; n=13). Adolescent females had white and yellow ovarian follicles, with gonad weight ranging from 0.5 to 16.2 g (mean=8.7; SD=3.87; n=12). Mature females had ovaries weighing between 4.8 and 108.5 g, bearing only yellow vitellogenic follicles (mean=29.2; SD=18.69; n=92). Vitellogenic follicles in egg-bearing females occurred with corresponding ovarian weights between 28.1 and 72.2 g (mean=46.9; SD=18.61; n=4) (Fig. 6a).

White follicles diameter ranged between 0.1- 1.0 cm (mean=0.4; SD=0.27; n=17) and were recorded in immature individuals and adolescents of up to 72.5 cm TL. The onset of vitellogenesis occurred when follicles attained a diameter of 0.4 cm. The smallest female with vitellogenic yellow follicles was 36.8 cm TL. The diameter of vitellogenic follicles in mature females varied between 0.4- 4.0 cm (mean=2.0; SD=0.83; n=97). Egg-bearing females had follicles with a diameter between 2.3 and 2.9 cm (mean=2.6; SD=0.25; n=4) (Fig. 6b).

Mean values for uterus width in females varied among all the maturity stages analyzed. Immature individuals had uteri ranging from 0.2 to 2.2 cm wide (mean=1.0; SD=0.62; n=17). Meanwhile, adolescent females had uteri with widths of 0.4 to 2.4 cm (mean=1.5; SD=0.55; n=12). In mature individuals, uteri width varied from 1.0 to 3.8 cm (mean=2.5; SD=0.48; n=92). Within this group, egg-bearing females had uteri ranging between 2.1 and 3.3 cm wide (mean=3.8; SD=0.43; n=4) (Fig. 6c).

The Oviducal gland height (OGH) varied from 0.4 to 1.9 cm (mean=1.1; SD=0.47; n=13) in immature females and from 0.4 to 1.9 cm (mean=1.2; SD=0.51; n=10) in adolescents. Mature females had OGHs varying from 1.3 to 3.5 cm (mean=2.1; SD=0.42; n=91), while egg-bearing females had OGHs ranging from 2.1 to 3.3 cm (mean=2.6; SD=0.52; n=4) (Fig. 6d). Ovarian fecundity varied from 9 to 74 (mean=29.81; SD=10.85; n=82). The number of vitellogenic yellow follicles with less than <1 cm in diameter, in individuals classified as adolescent and mature, varied from 4 to 54 follicles (mean=23.16; SD=15.46; n=13). In egg-bearing females, the number of follicles varied from 21 to 35 (mean=29.3; SD=6.02; n=4). No difference was observed, between the number of vitellogenic follicles larger than 1 cm and the number of follicles in egg-bearing females (t-test for independent samples, t=0.10; d.f.=84; p=0.91) (Fig. 6e). The TL50 estimate for S. bonapartii was 59.9 cm (r=0.99; n=125) (Fig. 4).

Fig. 5 Sympterygia acuta. Relationship between total length (cm) and (a) clasper length (cm), (b) clasper gland length (cm), (c) testicles weight (g) and (d) total number of alar thorns (left Y axis) and total number of rows of alar thorns (right Y axis). 

Sexual development of female Sympterygia acuta. Ovaries of immature females weighted between 0.4 and 3.0 g (mean=1.46; SD= 1.10; n= 5). Adolescents had both white and yellow follicles, with ovaries weighting between 3.8 and 8.5 g (mean=6.04; SD=2.18. n=5). Mature females bore yellow follicles and had ovaries weighting between 8.2 and 35.0 g (mean=21.71; SD=8.96; n=7). Ovaries of egg-bearing females weighted between 20.8 and 40.0 g (mean=33.95; SD=9.07; n=4) (Fig. 7a).Uteri width in immature females varied from 0.1 to 0.6 cm (mean=0.31; SD=0.19; n=7). Adolescent females had uteri width ranging from 0.6 to 2.0 cm (mean=1.38; SD=0.50; n=5). In matures females, uteri width varied from 0.4 to 1.7 cm (mean=0.81; SD=0.55; n=11) and egg-bearing females had uteri width from 2.6 to 3.6 cm (mean=3.08; SD=0.37; n=5) (Fig. 7b).

Immature females with TL up to 51.4 cm had white follicles diameter varying from 0.1 to 0.5 cm (mean=0.20; SD=0.2; n=5). Vitellogenesis was macroscopically evident when follicles attained a diameter of 0.6 cm. The smallest female with vitellogenic yellow follicles was 48.9 cm long. The diameter of vitellogenic follicles in mature females varied between 0.6 and 2.4 cm (mean=1.6; SD=0.51; n=14) and in the egg-bearing females from 1.5 to 2.5 cm (mean=2.04; SD=0.43; n=4) (Fig. 7c).

OGH varied from 0.1 to 0.6 cm (mean=0.41; SD=0.19; n=4) in immature females; from 1.3 to 1.7 cm (mean=1.52; SD=0.17; n=4) in adolescents, and from 2.0 to 3.1 cm (mean=2.48; SD=0.27; n=11) in mature females. Egg-bearing females had OGHs varying from 2.0 to 2.7 cm (mean=2.36; SD=0.28; n=5) (Fig. 7d). The TL50 was estimated at 44.7 cm (r=0.90; n=28) for female S. acuta (Fig. 4).


The relationships TL-DW, TL-TW and TL-EW for S. acuta and S. bonapartii indicated differences between males and females for both species. Sexual dimorphism in these relationships has been described for S. bonapartii (Mabragaña et al., 2002) and for other SW Atlantic rajoids (Mabragaña & Cousseau, 2004; Oddone & Vooren, 2004; Oddone & Amorim, 2007; Orlando et al., 2011).

The relationship TL-DW was sexually dimorphic in S. bonapartii, similarly to the congeneric species, S. lima, endemic of the coast of Chile, Southeast Pacific Ocean (Lamilla et al., 1984).

The TL-DW relationship in S. acuta indicated that immature males had higher size when compared with females in this first stage of development. However, in adolescents and mature individuals just the opposite was observed. Such morphometrics differences throughout the ontogeny were also recorded in Atlantoraja cyclophora (Regan, 1903) and Rioraja agassizi (Muller & Henle, 1841) in southern Brazil (Oddone & Vooren, 2004; Oddone et al.,2007b). On the other hand, the growth pattern in S. bonapartii demonstrated that, in this species, females had larger DW than males for any TL considered.

Fig. 6 Sexual development for females of Sympterygia bonapartii. Relationship between total length (cm) and (a) ovaries weight (g), (b) diameter of the largest follicle (cm), (c) uteri width (cm), (d) oviducal gland height (cm) and (e) number of follicles. 

Minimum size at first maturity was similar (or close) for both sexes of S. bonapartii. Mabragaña et al. (2002) observed similar situation in the same species off Argentina. However, according to Mabragaña et al. (2002) different populations might have distinct size at maturity, as it seems to be the case for individuals captured off Argentina (63.5 cm for females and 65.0 cm for males) when compared with those obtained in the present study, off southern Brazil.

The length of clasper in relation to TL in males of S. bonapartii described a sigmoid curve, typically observed for the sexual development of rajoids and most elasmobranchs. Studies on other species of the family Arhynchobatidae (Fowler, 1934) demonstrated that the total clasper length and clasper gland length fitted a sigmoid growth curve, at least in the genus Atlantoraja and Rioraja agassizi (Oddone & Vooren 2005; Oddone et al., 2007a; Oddone & Amorim 2008; Oddone et al., 2008).This type of logistic growth curves were also observed in four species of the family Rajidae (Blainville, 1816), namely, Leucoraja ocellata (Mitchill, 1815), Leucoraja erinacea (Mitchill, 1825), Amblyraja radiata (Donovan, 1808) and Malacoraja senta (Garman, 1885), distributed off the east coast of Canada (McPhie & Campana, 2009).

The number of rows of alar thorns in males of S. bonapartii varied between 1 and 6, in agreement with data reported by Mabragaña et al. (2002), and also similar to the pattern observed in A. cyclophora (Oddone & Vooren, 2005) and Bathyraja albomaculata (Ruocco et al., 2006). This sexual character present in males can vary among species, being an important parameter used for maturity staging.

Sympterygia bonapartii showed a high level of overlap among the three stages of sexual development, regarding the following variables: testicle weight, diameter of lobule, clasper gland length, number of rows of thorns and alar thorns. However, mean values of these variables indicate differences between each stages of sexual development.

Fig. 7 Sexual development for females of Sympterygia acuta. Relationship between total length (cm) and (a) ovaries weight, (b) uteri width (cm), (c) diameter of the largest follicle (cm) and (d) oviducal gland height (cm). 

Males S. bonapartii were found to mature with a TL of 58.4 cm. De Queiroz (1986), however recorded a value of 52 cm for this parameter for southern Brazil, indicating that TL50 may have increased in 3.3 % (6.4 cm) over a ~30-year period. However, the differences in the estimated sizes at maturity may also be due to methodological differences (Oddone & Velasco, 2004). De Queiroz (1986) methodology for recording clasper length (based on Hubbs & Ishiyama, 1968) differed from the one used in the present paper, though he used virtually the same reproductive variables for male sexual maturity staging. For male S. bonapartii, TL50 (58.4 cm) also differed from those calculated from other south western Atlantic areas, such as Argentina (65 cm) and Uruguay (57 cm) (Mabragaña et al., 2002; Oddone & Velasco 2004), though the value reported by Oddone & Velasco (2004) off Uruguay (50.0-57.0 cm) was very close to the one obtained in the present study. This similarity may be a consequence of the proximity of the area of the sampled specimens (in the extreme south of Brazil), with the border area between the coasts of Brazil and Uruguay.

In male S. acuta, the inflection point of the curve fit for the relationship between clasper length and TL coincided with the value of minimum TL for the clasper calcification. Therefore, the size at maturity based solely on the TL-clasper length relationship could be underestimated. A similar situation was also observed in S. bonapartii, demonstrating the importance of the determination record of the clasper calcification degree used for assessing maturity in males of Chondrichthyes.

Adult males of S. acuta bore a maximum of 6 rows of alar thorns, similarly to S. bonapartii. Other studies have also demonstrated a similarity in this number of maximum of rows of alar thorns, for other species of the same family (Mabragaña et al., 2002; Oddone & Vooren, 2005; Ruocco et al., 2006).

Contrarily to what was observed for males of S. bonapartii, a decrease in TL50 corresponding to 3.0 % (5.9 cm) was observed for males of S. acuta, when the present data are compared with the value obtained by De Queiroz (1986) for the same region.

Likewise, the ovary weight of mature females of S. bonapartii analysed by De Queiroz (1986) varied from 25 to 170 g. For mature specimens of S. acuta the same author recorded ovaries weight of 10 to 50 g. When compared to the data found in this study, ovary weights for mature females seem to have decreased since the work done by De Queiroz (1986). Females of both species may have developed at least some degree of reproductive plasticity, reflected in this case in a decrease of gonadal size of mature individuals, which could be a result of fishing mortality in the region during the past decades.

Ovarian follicles larger than 1.0 cm were considered vitellogenic by Mabragaña et al. (2002) for S. bonapartii. Agreeing with these authors, De Queiroz (1986) stated that vitelogenesis started at 1.0 and 1.5 cm in S. bonapartii and S. acuta, respectively. However, Díaz Andrade et al. (2011) examined ovarian follicles smaller than 1.0 cm in mature females of S. bonapartii through the histological analysis of the ovary and concluded that the traditional macroscopic assessment of the follicular vitellogenesis may turn into a subjective parameter of analysis, turning the classification of the development stage difficult.

They demonstrated that vitellogenic follicles with diameters larger than 0.3 cm are characteristic of mature females of S. bonapartii, a size that is very close to the diameter of vitellogenic follicles found in the present study (0.4 cm). The analysis performed by Díaz Andrade et al. (2009) in females of S. acuta, in turn, revealed that, at histological level, vitellogenesis would start at 0.55 cm, a size again similar to the obtained in the present study, where vitellogenesis was macroscopically detected from follicles with diameters of 0.6 cm onward.

Serra Pereira et al. (2011)analyzed the relationship of various measures of oviducal gland, including height, width and thickness, in Raja clavata (Linnaeus, 1758), in relation to maturity stages (i.e., "in development"; "spawning capable"; "actively spawning"), finding differences among stages. Differences in the OGH were also detected in S. bonapartii and S. acuta, whit their values increasing during sexual development.

The size of maturity obtained for females of S. bonapartii and S. acuta, when compared with those values reported by De Queiroz (1986) in southern Brazil, indicated a considerable decrease in the size of maturity over the last 30 years, corresponding to 7.0 and 4.4 % (or 10 and 8.3 cm) for female S. bonapartii and S. acuta, respectively. Such a reduction may be caused by fishing mortality (as well as fishing gear selectivity), which is very intense in the southern region of Brazil. This was demonstrated in other areas by Walters & Martell, 2004; Paesch & Oddone, 2008. The TL50estimates obtained for both sexes of S. bonapartii demonstrated differences at regional level. The restricted distribution of the species could indicate the existence of two different populations of S. bonapartii, the first occupying the higher latitudes of the south western Atlantic Ocean, in the coast of Argentina, and a second one composed by individuals that transit between the coastal zones of Uruguay and southern Brazil. This could be attributed to the transport of water masses from the Brazil Current and the Malvinas Current, accentuated mainly during summer and winter, respectively (Miloslavich et al., 2011).

The genus Sympterygia from the south-western Atlantic may have suffered a decline as a consequence of strong fishing pressure upon their populations over the decades. Characteristics related to reproduction such as the maturity size may change in oviparous skates that are affected by fishing (Ebert et al., 2008; Paesch & Oddone, 2008; Orlando et al., 2011). As it is the case of Sympterygia spp., it is essential to have current data on reproduction. Furthermore, future research should also be focused on the reproductive cycle

both temporally and spatially. Significant decrease in the size at maturity as a result of fishing pressure was documented for Dipturus chilensis (Paesch & Oddone, 2008) in the south-western Atlantic Ocean.

Data on the reproductive biology of the genus Sympterygia endemic to the south-western Atlantic Ocean presented in this study, may provide tools for the evaluation of the stocks, in order to properly conserve and manage the populations of Sympterygia spp. that are used for human consumption and exploited unrestrictedly as fishery resources.


We are grateful to skipper Charles Da Hora and crew of the fishing vessels "Da Hora C II" and "Menina Lybia" and to all those who helped to carry out this study. Sample collection aboard the research vessel "Larus" were enabled by Dr. Luiz Felipe Cestari Dumont, from the Laboratório de Crustáceos Decápodos (FURG). Marco Antonio de Oliveira kindly provided the maps in Fig. 1. This study was funded by CNPq through a postgraduate grant, process N° 133653/2011-0.

Literature Cited

De Queiroz, E. L. 1986. Estudo comparativo da alimentação de Sympterygia acuta. Garman, 1877 e S. bonapartei Mûller & Henle, 1841 (Pisces: Rajiformes) com relação a: distribuição, abundância, morfologia e reprodução nas águas litorâneas do Rio Grande do Sul - Brasil. Unpublished Master Thesis. Universidade do Rio Grande, RS. l37p. [ Links ]

Díaz Andrade, M. C., E. Galíndez & S. Estecondo. 2009. The ovary of the bignose fanskate Sympterygia acuta Garman, 1877 (Chondrichthyes, Rajidae) in the Bahia Blanca estuary, Argentina: morphology and reproductive features. Brazilian Journal of Biology, 69: 405-413. [ Links ]

Díaz Andrade, M. C., E. J. Galíndez, A. López Cazorla & S. Estecondo. 2011. Ovarian folliculogenesis in the smallnose fanskate Sympterygia bonapartii (Muller & Henle, 1841) (Chondrichthyes, Rajidae). International Journal of Morphology, 29: 174-181. [ Links ]

Dulvy, N. K., J. D. Metcalfe, J. Glanville, M. G. Pawson & J.D. Reynolds. 2000. Fishery stability, local extinctions, and shifts in community structure in skates. Conservation Biology, 14: 283-293. [ Links ]

Dulvy, N. K. & J. D. Reynolds. 2002. Predicting extinction vulnerability in skates. Conservation Biology, 16: 440-450. [ Links ]

Ebert, D. A. & L. J. V. Compagno. 2007. Biodiversity and systematics of skates (Chondrichthyes:Rajiformes: Rajoidei). Environmental Biology of Fishes, 80: 111-124. [ Links ]

Ebert, D. A., L. J. V. Compagno & P. Cowley. 2008. Aspects of the reproductive biology of skates (Chondrichthyes: Rajiformes: Rajoidei) from southern Africa, ICES Journal of Marine Science, 65: 81-102. [ Links ]

Figueiredo, J. L. 1977. Manual de Peixes Marinhos do Sudeste do Brasil. Introdução: cações raias e quimeras. Museu de Zool. Univ. De São Paulo, 104p. [ Links ]

Iglésias, S. P., L. Toulhoatand & D. Y. Sellos. 2009. Taxonomic confusion and market mislabelling of threatened skates: important consequences for their conservation status. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 20: 319-333. [ Links ]

Hubbs, C. L. & R. Ishiyama. 1968. Methods for the taxonomic study and description of skates (Rajidae). Copeia, 3: 48-3491. [ Links ]

Lamilla, J. G., G. Pequeño & H. Figueroa. 1984. Aspectos biológicos de Psammobatis lima, Poeppig, 1835, en el litoral de Valdivia, Chile (Elasmobranchii, Rajidae). Revista de la Comisión Permanente del Pacífico Sur, 14: 183-209. [ Links ]

Mabragaña, E. & M. B. Cousseau. 2004. Reproductive biology of two sympatric skates in the south-west Atlantic: Psammobatis rudis and Psammobatis normani. Journal of Fish Biology, 65: 559-573. [ Links ]

Mabragaña, E., L. O. Lucifora & A. M. Massa. 2002. The reproductive biology and abundance of Sympterygia bonapartii endemic to the south-west Atlantic. Journal of Fish Biology, 60:951-967. [ Links ]

Massa, A. & N. Hozbor. 2004. Sympterygia acuta. In: IUCN 2012. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2012.2. <>. Downloaded on 02 January 2013. [ Links ]

Massa, A. & J. Lamilla. 2004. Sympterygia bonapartii. In: IUCN 2012. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2012.2. <>. Downloaded on 02 January 2013. [ Links ]

McEachran, J. D. 1982. Revision of the American Skate Genus Sympterygia (Elasmobranchii: Rajiformes). Copeia, 1982: 867-890. [ Links ]

McEachran, J. D. & N. Aschliman. 2004. Chapter 3. Phylogeny of batoidea. Pp.79-114. In: Carrier, J. C., J. A. Musick & M. R. Heithaus, (Eds.). Biology of sharks and their relatives. Boca Raton, CRC Press. [ Links ]

McPhie, R. P. & S. E. Campana. 2009. Reproductive characteristics and population decline of four species of skate (Rajidae) off the eastern coast of Canada. Journal of Fish Biology, 75: 223-246. [ Links ]

Menni, R. C. & M. F. W. Stehmann. 2000. Distribution, environment and biology of batoid fishes off Argentina, Uruguay and Brazil. A review. Revista del Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales, 2: 69-109. [ Links ]

Miloslavich, P., E. Klein, J. M. Díaz, C. E. Hernández, G. Bigatti, L. Campos, F. Artigas, J. Castillo, P. E. Penchaszadeh, P. E. Neill, A. Carranza, M. V. Retana, J. M. Díaz de Astarloa, M. Lewis, P. Yorio, M. L. Piriz, D. Rodríguez, Y. Yoneshigue Valentin, L. Gamboa & A. Martín. 2011. Marine Biodiversity in the Atlantic and Pacific Coasts of South America: Knowledge and Gaps. Public Library of Science, 6: e14631. [ Links ]

Oddone, M. C. & A. F. Amorim. 2007. Length-weight relationships, condition and population structure of the genus Atlantoraja (Elasmobranchii, Rajidae, Arhynchobatinae) in Southeastern Brazilian waters, SW Atlantic Ocean. Journal of Northwest Atlantic Fishery Science, 38: 43-52. [ Links ]

Oddone, M. C. & A. F. Amorim. 2008. Size at maturity of Atlantoraja platana (Günther, 1880) (Chondrichthyes: Rajidae: Arhynchobatinae) in the south-west Atlantic Ocean. Journal of Fish Biology, 72: 1515-1519. [ Links ]

Oddone, M. C., A. F. Amorim & P. L. Mancini. 2008. Reproductive biology of the spotback skate, Atlantoraja castelnaui (Ribeiro, 1907) (Chondrichthyes, Rajidae) in southeastern Brazilian waters. Revista de Biología Marina y Oceanografía, 43: 327-334. [ Links ]

Oddone, M. C., A. F. Amorim, P. L. Mancini, W. Norbis & G. Velasco. 2007a. The reproductive biology and cycle of Rioraja agassizi (Muller and Henle, 1841) (Chondrichthyes: Rajidae) in southeastern Brazil, SW Atlantic Ocean. Scientia Marina, 71: 593-604. [ Links ]

Oddone, M. C., A. Amorim, P. L. Mancini & W. Norbis. 2007b. Size composition, monthly condition factor and morphometrics for fishery-dependent samples of Rioraja agassizi (Chondrichthyes, Rajidae), endemic to the SW Atlantic Ocean. Neotropical Ichthyology, 5: 415-424. [ Links ]

Oddone, M. C. & G. Velasco. 2004. Size at maturity of the smallnose fanskate Sympterygia bonapartii (Muller and Henle, 1841) (Pisces, Elasmobranchii, Rajidae) in the SW Atlantic. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 61: 294-297. [ Links ]

Oddone, M. C. & C. M. Vooren. 2004. Distribution and abundance of Atlantoraja cyclophora (Regan 1903) (Elasmobranchii, Rajidae) with regard to salinity, temperature and depth in southern Brazil, south-western Atlantic. Neotropical Ichthyology, 2: 137-144. [ Links ]

Oddone, M. C. & C. M. Vooren. 2005. Reproductive biology of Atlantoraja cyclophora (Regan 1903) (Elasmobranchii, Rajidae) off southern Brazil. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 62: 1095-1103. [ Links ]

Orlando, L., I. Pereyra, L. Paesch & W. Norbis. 2011. Size and sex composition of two species of the genus Atlantoraja (elasmobranchii, rajidae) caught by the bottom trawl fisheries operating on the Uruguayan continental shelf (Southwestern Atlantic Ocean). Brazilian Journal of Oceanography, 59: 357-364. [ Links ]

Paesch, L. & A. Domingo. 2003. La pesca de condrictios en el Uruguay. Frente Marítimo, 19: 207-216. [ Links ]

Paesch, L. & M. C. Oddone. 2008. Change in size-at-maturity of the yellownose skate Dipturus chilensis (Guichenot, 1848) (Elasmobranchii: Rajidae) in the SW Atlantic. Neotropical Ichthyology, 6: 223-230. [ Links ]

Restrepo, V. R. & R. A. Watson. 1991. An approach to modelling crustacean egg-bearing fractions as function of size and season. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science, 48: 1431-1436. [ Links ]

Ruocco N. L., L. O. Lucifora, J. M. Diaz de Astarloa & O. Wöhler. 2006. Reproductive biology and abundance of the white-dotted skate, Bathyraja albomaculata, in the Southwest Atlantic. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 63:105-116. [ Links ]

Serra Pereira, B., F. Afonso, I. Farias, P. Joyce, M. Ellis, I. Figueiredo. & L. S. Gordo. 2011. The development of the oviducal gland in the rajid thornback ray, Raja clavata. Helgoland Marine Research, 65: 399-411. [ Links ]

Sokal, R. R. & F. J. Rohlf. 2012. Biometry: the principles and practice of statistics in biological research. 4th edition. In: Freeman, W. H. & Co (Eds.). New York, ISBN 978-0-7167-8604-7. 937p. [ Links ]

Souza, G. S. 1998. Introdução aos Modelos de Regressão Linear e Não-Linear. Brasília: Embrapa- SPI / Embrapa -SEA. 505 p. [ Links ]

Vooren, C. M. 1997. Demersal Elamobranchs. Pp. 141-146. In: Environment and Biota of the Patos Lagoon Estuary. In: Seeliger, U., C. Odebrecht & J. P. Castello. (Eds.). Subtropical convergence environments: the coast and sea in the south western Atlantic. Berlim. Springer-Verlag, 308p. [ Links ]

Vooren, C. M., Klippel, S. & A. B. Galina. 2005. Chapter 3. Os elasmobrânquios das águas costeiras da plataforma sul. Pp. 113-120. In: Vooren, C. M. & S. Klippel. (Eds.). Ações para a conservação de tubarões e raias no sul do Brasil. Porto Alegre. Igaré, 262p. [ Links ]

Walters, C. J. & S. J. D. Martell. 2004. Chapter 3. Strategies requirements for sustainable fisheries. Pp. 43-64. In: Walters C. J. & S. J. D. Martell (Eds.). Fisheries ecology and management. Princeton, Princeton University Press. [ Links ]

Received: August 23, 2013; Accepted: March 24, 2014

Creative Commons License This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium provided the original work is properly cited.