Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

Women of the Sea: performative practices as a critique of Brazilian patriarchal colonial myths

ABSTRACT

Women of the Sea: performative practices as a critique of Brazilian patriarchal co-lonial myths – The text analyses the Mulheres do Mar (Women of the Sea) project, conducted with elderly women from the Serviluz community in Fortaleza (CE). Through performance workshops, the colonial myth Iracema, by José de Alencar, was challenged. Feminist analyses in conjunction with Diana Taylor’s approach to archives and repertoires underpin the critique of the novel. Next, aspects of the methodological approach to creation are shared, with an emphasis on cartographies of the self. It reflects on how the collective development of a counter-narrative to the patriarchal heritage summarised in Iracema contributes to the debate on decolonial artistic-pedagogical practices.

Keywords:
Performative Practices; Feminism; Decolonial; Memory; Archive

RESUMO

Mulheres do Mar: práticas performativas como crítica aos mitos coloniais patriarcais brasileiros – O texto analisa o projeto Mulheres do Mar, realizado com idosas da comunidade Serviluz em Fortaleza (CE). Através de oficinas de práticas performativas, questionou-se o mito colonial Iracema, de José de Alencar. Análises feministas articuladas com a abordagem dos arquivos e repertórios de Diana Taylor fundamentam a crítica do romance. Em seguida, compartilham-se aspectos da abordagem me-todológica de criação, com ênfase nas cartografias de si. Reflete-se como a elaboração coletiva de uma contranarrativa à herança patriarcal sintetizada em Iracema contribui para o debate sobre práticas artísti-co-pedagógicas decoloniais.

Palavras-chave:
Práticas Performativas; Feminismo; Decolonial; Memória; Arquivo

RÉSUMÉ:

Mulheres do Mar: pratiques performatives comme critique des mythes coloniaux patriarcaux brésiliens – Le texte analyse le projet Mulheres do Mar, méné avec des femmes âgées de la communauté Serviluz à Fortaleza (CE). Par le biais d’ateliers de pratiques performatives, le mythe colo-nial Iracema, de José de Alencar, a été remis en question. Des analyses féministes articulées avec l’approche des archives et des répertoires de Diana Taylor étayent la critique du roman. Ensuite, des aspects de l’approche méthodologique de la création sont partagés, en mettant l’accent sur les car-tographies de soi. La réflexion porte sur la manière dont l’élaboration collective d’un contre-récit à l’héritage patriarcal résumé dans Iracema contribue au débat sur les pratiques artistico-pédagogiques décoloniales.

Mots-clés:
Pratiques Performatives; Féminisme; Décolonial; Mémoire; Archives

Introduction

Can creative processes and the learning of performative practices chal-lenge standardised archives in the contemporary imaginary that still reveal shadows of a colonial past? How can we stimulate and enable counter-narratives to the patriarchal heritage summarised in colonial myths? How can participatory art projects carried out with women in territories traversed by social, economic and political tensions question the colonial patriarchal structure and allow devices and platforms to share these counter-narratives?

These questions inspired the creation of the performative practices workshop project that resulted in the participatory cartography Mulheres do Mar1 1 Este artigo resume aspectos desenvolvidos na dissertação em Artes Cênicas Mu-lheres do Mar: um olhar sobre práticas performativas participativas criadas com in-tersecção de discursos feministas, de Marie Araujo Auip (2022), orientada por Marcos Aurélio Bulhões Martins, na Universidade de São Paulo em 2022. (Women of the Sea), held in the community of Serviluz, in Fortaleza/CE, between 2019 and 2021, involving women2 2 O grupo do Centro Comunitário Luíza Távora era composto por uma média de 60 idosas/os, dos quais 85% eram mulheres cisgênero. Por se tratar de um grupo que já mantinha relações estabelecidas e institucionalizadas, a proposito-ra não pôde fazer uma convocatória aberta que pudesse incluir outras mulheres cisgênero, pessoas transgenêro e não-binárias. aged between 65 and 90, novices in the Performing Arts. This article aims to explore some of the theoretical and methodological principles of these workshops and their out-comes in an attempt to answer the following question: how do performative games connected with an autobiographical approach make it possible to create a cartographic counter-narrative to the colonial patriarchal archive Iracema, written by José de Alencar?

The novel and its author have been elements of national canonical cul-ture for decades. It’s part of the school curriculum, has been adapted into films, samba school themes, comic strips and the main character has been the inspiration for monuments and street names in Brazilian cities. In Ceará, the author’s homeland, the encounter between the indigenous Tabajara woman and the Portuguese invader, Martim Soares Moreno, was considered the founding myth of the local culture by the state government3 3 Informações em: https://www.casacivil.ce.gov.br/2011/04/25/palacio-iracema/. Acesso em: 02 set. 2023. . However, the constant repetition of this narrative, which symbolises the colonisation process in a romanticised way, reiterates gender policies imposed on women, marked by the perversity of slavery and patriarchal domination.

Initially, we discuss the notions of patriarchy and coloniality in the light of decolonial feminist theories, articulated with Diana Taylor’s (2013)TAYLOR, Diana. O arquivo e o repertório: performance e memória cultural nas Américas. Belo Horizonte: Editora UFMG, 2013. notions of archive and repertoire, in order to analyse the novel Iracema (2019). Next, we explain the reasons for choosing the Serviluz territory and discuss the main procedures carried out in the performative practice work-shops, with an emphasis on the approach to the cartographies of the self, as well as commenting on the results of interviews with project participants.

The presence of feminist and gender studies in Performing Arts re-search dismantles epistemological hegemony, questioning the submission to patriarchal discourse to which women have been subjected in activities linked to the production of knowledge. In Brazil, the intersection between these two fields is found in the studies of Dodi Leal, Lúcia Romano, Marta Baião, Nina Caetano, Sarah Duarte, Stela Fischer and Yasmin Nogueira, among others. The multiplicity of research resulted in the creation of the Mulheres da Cena (Women of the Stage) Working Group at the Associação Brasileira de Pesquisa e Pós-graduação em Artes Cênicas (Brazilian Association for Research and Postgraduate Studies in the Performing Arts) (ABRACE).

Our goal is to contribute to a reflection on the creation and learning of participatory performance practices carried out in the Northeast by ana-lysing a practice with women who formulated a counter-narrative to a Cea-rá myth that took on national dimensions. In this sense, we would also like to highlight the focus of the research group Mito, Rito e Cartografias Femi-nistas nas Artes (MOTIM – Myth, Rite and Feminist Cartographies in the Arts), coordinated by Professor Luciana Lyra, which addresses the complex-ity of the power of myth and seeks to dilute the boundaries that make work from the Northeast invisible.

Iracema, myth of the Colonial Patriarchy’s formation

Iracema, a novel published in 1865 by José de Alencar from Ceará, depicts, through the meeting of two characters, an idealised plot based on the colonisation process that unfolded on the Brazilian coast. In a meta-phorical plot, we are introduced to Martim Soares Moreno, “a young war-rior whose white complexion is not coloured by American blood” (Alencar, 2019, p. 15ALENCAR, José. Iracema. Brasília: Biblioteca Digital da Câmara dos Deputa-dos, 2019. Disponível em: https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcamara/11854. Acesso em: 23 abr. 2023.
https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcam...
), a Portuguese coloniser with a first name that refers to the Roman god Mars, whose characteristics are aggression and violence. Then there is Iracema, a Tabajara Indian, whose name in Guarani means “the virgin with the honey lips” (Alencar, 2019, p. 16ALENCAR, José. Iracema. Brasília: Biblioteca Digital da Câmara dos Deputa-dos, 2019. Disponível em: https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcamara/11854. Acesso em: 23 abr. 2023.
https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcam...
), an explicit reference to the sexuality and sweet personality of the Brazilian natives.

At the beginning of the novel, in a moment of rest, Iracema realises that she is being watched by a strange warrior; she, in her naked vulnerabil-ity, and he, dressed not only in cloth, but armed with weapons. Feeling threatened, she immediately protects herself with the arrow of her bow and hits him. Alencar recounts Martim’s disappointment that this act should have been committed by a woman, since “the young warrior was taught in his mother’s religion, where women are symbols of tenderness and love” (Alencar, 2019, p. 17ALENCAR, José. Iracema. Brasília: Biblioteca Digital da Câmara dos Deputa-dos, 2019. Disponível em: https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcamara/11854. Acesso em: 23 abr. 2023.
https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcam...
). However, as is to be expected from the narrator’s perspective, Iracema soon becomes the character to whom loving affection and docility belong, and she takes care of the foreigner, tending to his wound and welcoming him into her culture.

Continuing the Alencarian plot, Iracema breaks her vow of chastity when she becomes amorously involved with the foreigner and has to aban-don the Tabajara people. Refugees on a deserted beach, she is saddened to realise how much Martim misses his homeland. Alone, Iracema gives birth to the first Brazilian mestizo: “You are Moacir, son of my suffering” (Alen-car, 2019, p. 76). At the end of the story, Iracema is unable to feed her son, claiming that her “ungrateful breasts no longer had any food to give him” (Alencar, 2019, p. 81ALENCAR, José. Iracema. Brasília: Biblioteca Digital da Câmara dos Deputa-dos, 2019. Disponível em: https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcamara/11854. Acesso em: 23 abr. 2023.
https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcam...
), handing the child over to Martim shortly before her death. Symbolised in Iracema’s death, we can see that the fate of the native peoples, from the perspective of the colonising white man, was to disappear, and for civilisation to succeed, a new nation had to be founded and guided by the European hand.

The first encounter between Iracema and Martim, the birth of their son Moacir and Iracema’s death are three moments that we consider deci-sive in our dialogue about the work being a formative myth that perpetuates the interests of patriarchy through the modern colonial system. The novel in question is a publication from the Second Reign period, in which Em-peror Pedro II financed the shaping of an Indianism that aligned with the nationalist ideas of the time, whose political project involved the construc-tion and consolidation of a Brazilian cultural identity forged in racial de-mocracy4 4 O mito da democracia racial está contido na ideia de que o Brasil se construiu a partir de sua capacidade de vincular diversas nações e culturas em perfeita igualdade e harmonia racial. . Based on these elements, our aim is to approach Alencar’s novel in the light of various analyses of colonial and patriarchal violence and the masks attached to this national mythology.

In her book Sobre o autoritarismo brasileiro (2019) (Brazilian Authori-tarianism), historian and anthropologist Lilia Schwarcz, introducing us to one of the first engravings depicting the discovery of America, dating from around 1580, points out the intrinsic relations between race and gender, perpetuated from the very beginning of colonisation. In the engraving, as described in the first section of Iracema, the European is portrayed as a clothed white man, in contrast to a naked woman, who is allegorised as America. Sitting in a hammock, she gestures towards him, disposed to hav-ing a relationship with the discoverer, who in turn holds in his hands sym-bols that refer to the idea of civilisation: a staff with a crucifix, an astrolabe and a Southern Cross flag.

The engraving portrays the encounter between explorer Américo Ves-púcio and America, which bears a feminised version of his name. The passage taken from José de Alencar’s work also places Iracema in an encounter with the coloniser, her name being an anagram of America. As such, both readings are aligned with a representation of Abya Yala5 5 Termo que vem sendo utilizado por pesquisadoras/es como autodesignação dos povos originários em relação ao seu território, em contraponto à América, designação dada pelo colonizador. as a woman who awaits, desires or accepts this encounter, in a domination of the Old World over the New, of the masculine over the feminine and of civilisation over nature.

This process of forming the cultural identity of the new continent, through different archival processes, was aligned with a Christian, racist, pa-triarchal, heteronormative and Eurocentric perspective, highlighting a de-termined temporal narrative to the detriment of that of the native peoples. In this sense, Schwarcz (2019)SCHWARCZ, Lilia Moritz. Sobre o autoritarismo brasileiro. São Paulo: Com-panhia das Letras, 2019. stresses the importance of critically illumi-nating these archives in order to understand how they create a rhetorical battlefield by inventing and elevating certain memory rituals, classifying them as the authentic model and the others as dark, uncivilised and in need of control or elimination.

The thinking of decolonial, Black and anti-capitalist feminism contrib-utes to this discussion by conceptualising gender hierarchies linked to race as fictional categories, created in the embryo of historical colonialism, which con-solidated a patriarchal regime exercised with violence and state intervention against women. In addition to the authors Aura Cumes, Silvia Federici, Sueli Carneiro and Yuderkys Espinosa Miñoso, used in this text, we draw inspira-tion from Angela Davis, Julieta Paredes, Lélia Gonzalez, María Lugones, Ochy Curiel, Oyèrónke Oyewùmí, Rita Segato and Patricia Hill Collins.

The studies carried out by philosopher Silvia Federici (2017;FEDERICI, Silvia. Calibã e a Bruxa: mulheres, corpo e acumulação primitiva. São Paulo: Editora Elefante, 2017. 2019)FEDERICI, Silvia. O ponto zero da revolução: trabalho doméstico, reprodução e luta feminista. São Paulo: Elefante, 2019. help us to understand that the colonisation process in Abya Yala brought with it a form of patriarchy forged in European societies. The author argues that the transition from European feudalism to capitalism is a key period for understanding the redefinition of productive and reproductive tasks in Western male-female relations, and she does so through extensive docu-mentary research of historical moments. One of these was the persecution and execution of thousands of women in the witch-hunt, which served as an instrument to subjugate their bodies, labour, sexual and reproductive capac-ities under the control of the State, giving them an essential function for the continuity of the system: the reproduction and creation of the workforce.

In line with this dynamic, the closure of communal lands, followed by the process of privatising and fencing them off, had the symbolic-social consequence that women became substitutes for the land that men had lost: “their most basic means of reproduction and a common possession that an-yone could appropriate and use at will” (Federici, 2017, p. 191). This grad-ually established a system of domination in which men took political, eco-nomic, social and cultural control, not only having more access to common property, but also making women one of these assets.

Activist and researcher Aura Cumes (2019)CUMES, Aura. Colonialismo patriarcal y patriarcado colonial: violência y despo-jo em las sociedades que nos dan forma. In: LEYVA SOLANO, Xochitl; ICAZA, Rosalba (Coord.). En tiempos de Muerte: Cuerpos, Rebeldías, Resistencias. Buenos Aires: Cooperativa Editorial Retos, 2019. defends and deepens this perspective by engaging in a dialogue with the writings contained in the Popol Wuj, one of the most important ancient documents from Abya Yala, which contains Mayan cosmogony, history and genealogy, from which Cumes descends. In her analysis, she presents arguments according to which, in Mayan culture, the genders were treated in such a way as to com-plete each other, defending the importance of the meaning of parity in hor-izontality. This understanding arises both in the recovery of the expression winaq, which means person or people without gender attribution, contrary to the Western notion of man, and in the observation of the Mayan myth of origin and its idea of pairs that relate to each other – “man and woman, heaven and earth, mother and father, animal and people” (Cumes, 2019, p. 300CUMES, Aura. Colonialismo patriarcal y patriarcado colonial: violência y despo-jo em las sociedades que nos dan forma. In: LEYVA SOLANO, Xochitl; ICAZA, Rosalba (Coord.). En tiempos de Muerte: Cuerpos, Rebeldías, Resistencias. Buenos Aires: Cooperativa Editorial Retos, 2019.) – who have the same capacity for action and relevance.

According to the author, these relations of parity were radically modi-fied as a result of colonial-patriarchal domination which established a re-gime of subordination of women through a hierarchy between them and men and the project of dominating nature itself. In colonial thinking, “[...] nature is a woman, she is wild, capricious, unintelligible, irrational, and re-bellious. She requires a superior force in order to be dominated, subjugated and placed at the disposal of those who know how to make use of it” (Cumes, 2019, p. 303CUMES, Aura. Colonialismo patriarcal y patriarcado colonial: violência y despo-jo em las sociedades que nos dan forma. In: LEYVA SOLANO, Xochitl; ICAZA, Rosalba (Coord.). En tiempos de Muerte: Cuerpos, Rebeldías, Resistencias. Buenos Aires: Cooperativa Editorial Retos, 2019.). Therefore, the colonisers warned that the Indians had not learnt to dominate nature, because they did not dominate their women. In this relationship, in order to affirm his questioned virility, the indigenous male subject began to reproduce and display his ability to con-trol women, weakening the strength of the Mayan sense of existence.

Similar to the European dynamic that privatised communal lands and women’s reproductive labour, the colonial process imposed a form of patri-archy that disempowered and murdered women.

The capitalist patriarchy embodies the condition of the human predator, a status constructed in the face of the expropriation of women, peasants, other non-Catholic and non-Western men of colour, and the domination of na-ture. This patriarch, as a coloniser, is the owner of indigenous families and communities, as well as enslaved Black men and women, and assumes him-self to be the owner and master of nature itself. This colonial patriarch rules and exerts violence under this legitimacy (Cumes, 2019, p. 306CUMES, Aura. Colonialismo patriarcal y patriarcado colonial: violência y despo-jo em las sociedades que nos dan forma. In: LEYVA SOLANO, Xochitl; ICAZA, Rosalba (Coord.). En tiempos de Muerte: Cuerpos, Rebeldías, Resistencias. Buenos Aires: Cooperativa Editorial Retos, 2019.).

In dialogue with these authors, we see Iracema as the romanticised sto-ry of a violent structure perpetrated against indigenous and Black women who were enslaved during colonisation. In his thesis entitled “Iracema, hori-zonte do mito incessante” (Iracema, horizon of the incessant myth), Professor Tiago Parente (2019, p. 132)PARENTE, Tiago Coutinho. Iracema, Horizonte de memórias do mito inces-sante. 2019. Tese (Doutorado em Memória Social) – Programa de Pós-Graduação em Memória Social, Universidade Federal do Estado do Rio de Janei-ro, Rio de Janeiro 2019., in dialogue with the concept of violence pro-posed by Heleieth Saffioti, states that “Iracema is a book that tells a highly violent story. A colonial violence”. And he warns that repeating this story uncritically exalts the process “that raped women and exterminated non-white ethnic groups” (Parente, 2019, p. 28PARENTE, Tiago Coutinho. Iracema, Horizonte de memórias do mito inces-sante. 2019. Tese (Doutorado em Memória Social) – Programa de Pós-Graduação em Memória Social, Universidade Federal do Estado do Rio de Janei-ro, Rio de Janeiro 2019.). In this sense, philosopher and activist Sueli Carneiro (2020)CARNEIRO, Sueli. Enegrecer o feminismo: a situação da mulher negra na América Latina a partir de uma perspectiva de gênero. NEABI, Artigos, 2020. Disponível em: https://www1.unicap.br/neabi/?page_id=137. Acesso em: 23 abr. 2023.
https://www1.unicap.br/neabi/?page_id=13...
points out that colonial violations resulted in miscegenation, which was the basis for the formation of the myth of cordi-ality and racial democracy:

This colonial sexual violence is also the ‘cement’ of all the gender and racial hierarchies present in our societies, configuring what Angela Gilliam defines as ‘the great theory of sperm in our national formation’, through which, ac-cording to Gilliam: ‘The role of Black women is denied in the formation of national culture; inequality between men and women is eroticised; and sex-ual violence against Black women has been converted into a novel’ (Car-neiro, 2020, p. 1).

Given that colonisation was mostly male, the indigenous and Black women were relegated to their roles in agriculture, the mansions, cities and mining, but they also “served their owners as instruments of pleasure and enjoyment” (Schwarcz, 2019, p. 203SCHWARCZ, Lilia Moritz. Sobre o autoritarismo brasileiro. São Paulo: Com-panhia das Letras, 2019.). White women were assigned the model imported by the coloniser of the delicate housewife, distanced from productive work and politics, leaving her with the domestic sphere. In other words, just as the construction of gender separated men and women, there was also a racial and class construction that made it possible for white wom-en to have more privileges in life (Cumes, 2019CUMES, Aura. Colonialismo patriarcal y patriarcado colonial: violência y despo-jo em las sociedades que nos dan forma. In: LEYVA SOLANO, Xochitl; ICAZA, Rosalba (Coord.). En tiempos de Muerte: Cuerpos, Rebeldías, Resistencias. Buenos Aires: Cooperativa Editorial Retos, 2019.).

Even with the so-called legal-political independence, brought about by the end of the European metropolises’ administration of colonial territories – in the case of Brazil, in 1822 – relations of exploitation, domination and conflict over race-sex-class-gender privileges have persisted in aspects of life today. It is in the criticism of this continuity, of the transition from modern colonialism to global coloniality, that decolonial feminism produces its thought and practice.

In an explanatory summary, philosopher and writer Yuderkys Espinosa Miñoso (2017)MIÑOSO, Yuderkys Espinosa. Sobre porque é necessário um feminismo decolo-nial: diferenciação, dominação coconstitutiva da modernidade ocidental. Solar, Revista de Filosofía Iberoamericana, Dossier Epistemologías feministas latino-americanas, v. 12, n. 1, p. 141-171, 2017. points out that the term decolonial feminism was proposed by Argentinian sociologist María Lugones. Her proposal comes from the intersec-tional perspective – which constituted the work of Black feminism and Third World women – and dialogues with the concept of coloniality, articulated by Aníbal Quijano (2009, p. 73)PINHO, Érika B. M. O tempo bom do Farol: prostituição, gênero e distinção nas trajetórias de ex-prostitutas idosas. In: ENCONTRO DE CIÊNCIAS SOCIAIS DO NORTE E NORDESTE, 15., 2012, Teresina. Anais [...]. Teresina, 2012., who succinctly defines it as follows:

Coloniality is one of the constitutive and specific elements of the global standard of capitalist power. It is based on the imposition of a racial/ethnic classification of the world’s population as the cornerstone of this system of power and operates on each of the planes, means and dimensions, both ma-terial and subjective, of everyday social existence and on the societal scale. It originates and is globalised from America.

Artist and researcher Stela Fischer (2017)FISCHER, Stella Regina. Mulheres, performance e ativismos: a ressignificação dos discursos feministas na cena latino-americana. 2017. Tese (Doutorado em Artes Cênicas) – Programa de Pós-Graduação em Artes Cênicas, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 2017. explains that colonialities are categorised as those of power, knowledge and being. These colonialities es-tablish discriminatory processes based on dichotomous relations (civilised white Eurocentric subject over non-white, subaltern, non-civilised subject), which “[...] use race as the main way of granting legitimacy to relations of domination and exploitation” (Fischer, 2017, p. 18FISCHER, Stella Regina. Mulheres, performance e ativismos: a ressignificação dos discursos feministas na cena latino-americana. 2017. Tese (Doutorado em Artes Cênicas) – Programa de Pós-Graduação em Artes Cênicas, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 2017.). María Lugones makes this analysis more complex by proposing what she calls a modern colonial gender system, stating that the race-gender categories are “[...] constitutive of the modern colonial episteme and cannot be thought of outside this epis-teme, nor can they be thought of separately from each other” (Miñoso, 2017, p. 8MIÑOSO, Yuderkys Espinosa. Sobre porque é necessário um feminismo decolo-nial: diferenciação, dominação coconstitutiva da modernidade ocidental. Solar, Revista de Filosofía Iberoamericana, Dossier Epistemologías feministas latino-americanas, v. 12, n. 1, p. 141-171, 2017.). In other words, coloniality also dictates a gender hierarchy, in which men have more power and contaminate political, economic, sexual, spiritual and epistemological relations with chauvinism and misogyny.

Considering the discussion about the permanence of coloniality, Iracema reveals racial and gender privilege linked to epistemic privilege, as it reaffirms a valued and universal model that is white, Eurocentric and patri-archal. Hence, by treating the archival memory of the work as one of the founding myths of the Brazilian people, we are favouring a narrative that subordinates women. In line with these stimuli, in the Mulheres do Mar (Women of the Sea) project process, we draw on Diana Taylor’s (2013)TAYLOR, Diana. O arquivo e o repertório: performance e memória cultural nas Américas. Belo Horizonte: Editora UFMG, 2013. discussion of the distinction between archive and repertoire6 6 Os padrões de expressão cultural do arquivo existem, na forma de textos, do-cumentos, cartas, em materiais que, prioritariamente, têm a capacidade de per-sistir ao longo do tempo; o repertório consiste na cultura incorporada através de performances, gestos, oralidades, dança, entre outros. , and how artistic practices can affect the fabrics of normative sharing, helping us to reflect on the emergence of myths and their ability to serve the interests of maintaining powers.

Taylor analyses how societies produce and transmit knowledge based on these two systems, which operate in different ways, work together and are sources of information, whether in literate or semi-literate societies. The prob-lematisation that runs through her research is in relation to the degree of legit-imacy that Western epistemology has invested in the archives (written) in rela-tion to the incorporated practices (“repertoire”) of the original peoples of America. In doing so, the author provokes us to shift our focus from the transmission and production of literary and historical documents to the per-formative, in order to perceive other memories and struggles and also to ques-tion what the archives normalise in our ways of seeing, doing and being.

Based on the notion of performative practices worked on at the Labor-atory of Performative Practices (Universidade de São Paulo), which seeks to investigate collective ways of establishing islands of poetic and critical dis-order inside and outside the art system, we propose to share these decoloni-al reflections in the field of learning and artistic creation. The Mulheres do Mar (Women of the Sea) project came about from the questioning of the colonial myth in the novel Iracema, in which autobiographical performative devices were proposed and worked on in partnership with a group of wom-en who live in the territory known as Greater Mucuripe, in the city of For-taleza. Below we will discuss the guiding reasons for choosing this territory and share some of the aspects of the methodological approach developed, as well as the political implication of understanding that not only literate and powerful people can lay claim to the organisation of shared culture.

Vicente Pinzón and Iracemas of Greater Mucuripe: territorial and gen-der choice

Located between the Cais do Porto and Vicente Pinzón neighbour-hoods, the Serviluz community is surrounded by the most expensive land7 7 O turismo representa em média 36% do PIB de Fortaleza. A orla marítima é um dos principais motivos de atratividade dos turistas, haja vista os altos inves-timentos da gestão municipal em “requalificar” alguns trechos da orla. in Fortaleza. Its location makes it a symbol of resistance to the growing heg-emonic expansion of the Avenida Beira-Mar property market, the tourist dynamics of Praia do Futuro, the industrial activity that takes place behind the containers of Porto do Mucuripe and the public authorities focused on the economy of competitiveness.

In his thesis on the production of Fortaleza’s coastline, Eider Caval-cante (2017) explains that until the beginning of the 20th century, land by the sea was undervalued in economic and social dynamics, and was mainly a refuge for fishermen and rural retreatants. As the elite of Fortaleza began to savour their seaside encounters, the government put measures in place to ensure that this area was inhabited by this segment of the population. The logic of the coastal space began to be inverted and urban and moral zoning strategies were applied with the aim of forging a new image for the area.

In the vicinity of Serviluz, there began the construction of Avenida Beira Mar, with the aim of turning it into an upper-middle class residential neigh-bourhood, with luxury shops and hotels. In order to do this, the fishermen were expropriated, forcing them to move to more distant neighbourhoods; the prosti-tution zone along the coastline that spanned Avenida Beira Mar and Praia de Iracema was compulsorily transferred to the vicinity of Porto do Mucuripe.

Unfortunately, attempts to remove people from the Serviluz commu-nity are constant. In 2010, the dispute centred on a project to set up a ship-yard, which would have removed more than 400 families from Cais do Por-to. The project did not materialise due to the actions and mobilisations un-dertaken by civil society and artistic collectives. As an alternative, the mu-nicipal government of Fortaleza approved funding for the Aldeia da Praia project in 2011, and since then the population has united to prevent the removal of the residents of Rua General Titã for the construction of a square8 8 Informações: https://serviluzquepermanece.wixsite.com/especial/serviluz. Aces-so em: 02 abr. 2023. . By highlighting these examples, we can see that the strategy of re-moving the most vulnerable populations for economic gain is a practice in-herited from the colonial period and, despite the resistance of the commu-nities, continues unabated.

In the symbolic field, during a visit to the Mucuripe Archive9 9 Projeto de história e memória das comunidades do Grande Mucuripe. , Diêgo de Paula presented us with a map that includes seven neighbourhoods that have been divided up and renamed, a region that used to be known as Mucuripe. For the founder of the archive, this division of the region into different administrative areas was a planned strategy to segregate the people who lived there, their cultures and identities. By no coincidence, part of what used to be named after an indigenous etymology is now called Vicente Pinzón, a 16th century Spanish navigator and explorer. When we look at the map, we notice that Diêgo’s proposal – painting the neighbourhoods in the same colour – is to establish possibilities for mapping the city using an intuitive approach, as opposed to traditional authority. In this sense, the construction of the territory from within the population is taken into ac-count, and this choice of narrative guided the discussions with the women taking part in the project.

Image 1
Map of Greater Mucuripe, Fortaleza (CE).

The Mulheres do Mar (Women of the Sea) project took place in differ-ent neighbourhoods of the city, but we chose to start with the community of Serviluz because, in addition to the fact that it is a territory in significant dispute with the modern capitalist world-system, its origins have been marked by the protagonism of women. As we have seen, for more than five decades women have been arriving forcedly from prostitution zones in differ-ent areas of the city. In an article that analyses the trajectory of elderly ex-prostitutes, Érika Pinho (2012)PINHO, Érika B. M. O tempo bom do Farol: prostituição, gênero e distinção nas trajetórias de ex-prostitutas idosas. In: ENCONTRO DE CIÊNCIAS SOCIAIS DO NORTE E NORDESTE, 15., 2012, Teresina. Anais [...]. Teresina, 2012. highlights their importance in the demands for a modicum of public infrastructure in the neighbourhood, which, along with shellfish gatherers, fishermen, dockworkers and workers from nearby industries, built the community.

In addition to the founding process, Pinho addresses the issue of the sex trade that took place in the region, fuelled by its location close to the port area. In an interview, Pinho says that because of the relationships es-tablished with foreigners – Dutch, Danish, American, Japanese and Ger-man – these women had access to countless consumer goods, highlighting the 1960s and 1970s as Serviluz’s golden age. However, when we analyse the historical process of the region, we can’t help but notice that this narrative implies a continuity of the Alencarian perspective stamped on Iracema. Be-cause the representation of the golden age, made possible by the encounter with the foreigner, without providing social and economic autonomy for them a posteriori, reinforces the “hierarchisation of relations that expropri-ate and promote discriminatory processes”, as Fischer (2017, p. 17)FISCHER, Stella Regina. Mulheres, performance e ativismos: a ressignificação dos discursos feministas na cena latino-americana. 2017. Tese (Doutorado em Artes Cênicas) – Programa de Pós-Graduação em Artes Cênicas, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 2017. explains with regard to colonialities.

As we delve into local histories, we realise how the myth of Iracema becomes entangled in many of the dynamics contained in official archives – theses, articles, newspapers. However, as a result, repertoires – incorporated culture – aligned with these dynamics are also produced and transmitted. Inspired by the Alencarian work, the show Tudo passa sobre a terra, by artist Rosa Primo, has the following synopsis: “We all are. We become. Life after life. [...] It was an invasion, not a discovery. That’s why we are. A move-ment that never ceases to repeat itself in differences. Iracemas are many of us”10 10 Disponível em: https://cargocollective.com/rosaprimo/Tudo-passa-sobre-a-terra. Acesso em: 02 abr. 2023. . In this sense, we become, we compose, we form Iracemas. In fact, in this historical cross-section of the coast, we highlight the traces that dia-logue with this archive: the sexual exploitation of women and real estate speculation on the coastal strip, which expropriates communities from their land.

In contrast, the project proponent prioritised a few questions: how could one access what remains forgotten in the unspoken words of a charac-ter who almost doesn’t speak, written by a man? What would the Iracemas who are scattered around the city of Fortaleza say? What repertoires could we create to counter what the hegemonic archive has produced in our bod-ies? To this end, the proposer chose to start in this territory and to dialogue through artistic workshops and interviews with women who live in the neighbourhood, not necessarily former prostitutes, but who experienced the process of forming the neighbourhood and the community.

Mulheres do Mar: performative practices as methodological approach to creation and learning

In developing a project to create and learn performative practices based on a critical approach to the colonial myth of Iracema, participatory and contextual in nature, in the sense attributed by Ardenne (2002)ARDENNE, Paul. Un arte contextual: Creación artística en medio urbano, en situacion, de intervención, de participación. Cartagena: Flammarion, 2002., out-side institutionalised spaces, the researcher faced the challenge of making her initial assumptions more flexible, adopting an attitude of constant po-rosity in relation to the context of the Serviluz territory. It also became nec-essary to establish listening spaces in order to establish a collaborative, non-hierarchical relationship with the group of women who answered her call, in terms of action planning. Below we will comment on some of the strate-gies for approaching and negotiating with the participants, as well as some of the project’s limitations, adaptations, procedures and developments.

The Mulheres do Mar (Women of the Sea) performative cartography began with the collaboration and receptiveness of three women working in the community towards the project, which at the outset was open from the point of view of the exact actions, having only the decolonial conceptual ar-gument. Various social and cultural institutions working in the area were contacted in order to make it possible for the artist and the women of the region to connect and engage in dialogue. However, it wasn’t until the pro-poser met with coordinator Maria do Socorro, social worker Ivone Lima and psychologist Carolina Teles that the cartography was able to begin at the Luíza Távora Community Centre. Group activities were carried out in January and February 2019 and January 2020, in partnership with the el-derly people’s socialising and bonding service group, which is made up of an average of 60 elderly people aged between 65 and 90, 85% of whom are women.

At first, the proposed workshop was adapted to the group’s ongoing schedule of activities. At the time, one of the main activities was the part-nership the Community Centre developed with physiotherapy students, in-cluding talks on health, as well as a few hours set aside for conversations with the group’s coordinator. For two months, twice a week, it was possible to follow these activities and establish the initial dialogues on the themes discussed in the Iracema colonial archive, such as the characteristics of the territory and hierarchical gender relations. However, before starting to map possible repertoires through their memories, it was important to build a re-lationship of closeness, affection and security, which took place not only in the meetings at the Community Centre, but also over shared breakfasts, car rides to the bus stop, conversations that weren’t recorded, rehearsals of car-nival songs and visits to the participants’ homes.

The first meetings were essential for establishing a place of listening and understanding the strategies that would help in the process of de-hierarchising the figure of the artist and breaking the racial-social-epistemic privilege that was shown in her white, middle-class, academic corporeality. One example was in a lecture on the content of feminist criticism regarding the term sorority. For most of the women, the lexicon sounded strange, and they also showed little interest in the historiographical approach that had been taken. In the dialogue about the meaning of the term, however, in re-lation to the union between women, involving empathy and solidarity, we saw in several reports the activation of a theorisation – not in academic terms – about the relationship built between them, in a way that was close to feminist theories.

Accordingly, as Professor Helena Vieira explains to us in the virtual class Introdução à História dos Feminismos (Introduction to the History of Feminisms) (2022), not all women’s struggles will be thought of within feminist struggles because there is a set of movements and knowledge that circulate and strengthen beyond feminist critique and political practices – despite the discursive encounters between the two. This approach has be-come a critical operator in the sense of breaking with the thinking of a dominant epistemology that is seen as unique, as Linda Alcoff points out in relation to the dominance of discursivity in the West:

Epistemology presumes the right to judge, for example, the knowledge claimed by midwives, the ontologies of native peoples, the medical practice of colonised peoples and even first-person accounts of experience of all kinds. Is it realistic to believe that a simple ‘master epistemology’ can judge all kinds of knowledge originating from diverse cultural and social locations? (Alcoff, 2016, p. 131ALCOFF, Linda. Uma epistemologia para a próxima revolução. Revista Socie-dade e Estado, v. 31, n. 1, p. 129-143, 2016.).

Following this line of reasoning, the proposer sought to deviate from this dominant logic, and was willing to change strategies. In the second year, after consolidating the dialogues, understanding the context and some of the participants’ limitations and desires, the meetings took place more frequently. The dynamics of lectures and theatrical editing, as they were used to, were rethought, and the specific devices of performance art were prioritised. Eleonora Fabião (2008, p. 237)FABIÃO, Eleonora. Performance e Teatro: poéticas e políticas na cena contem-porânea. Revista Sala Preta, São Paulo, v. 8, p. 235-246, 2008. provokes us by saying that the power of performance lies in “de-habituating, de-mechanising, brushing against the grain”; in other words, this potential for subverting normative social systems was important in establishing a counter-narrative to Iracema’s perspective. Another important element of this artistic language is the inter-est in exploring one’s own characteristics through autobiography and/or corporeality, allowing participants to position themselves as agents of their own narratives.

Image 2
Classes and exercise in performance, Mulheres do Mar.Source: Photographs by Ivone Lima (2019).

Image 3
Exercises in class, Mulheres do Mar.

Instead of proposing an already formatted performance image, the proposer took on the role of producer who would start from the relation-ships established within the collective, as elements for formulating and ex-periencing performative practices. One of the first motifs arose when we observed the empowerment strategies that were being formed among the women in the group, in the face of the precariousness that was being estab-lished structurally, due to issues of gender, ageism and social class. In inter-views with some of the participants, the proposer realised the importance of these support networks:

Francisca França: There’s respect from the whole community here, no one goes into anyone’s house, but if anything happens, everyone runs. Nobody leaves any-body. No one needs anyone, but when they do, everyone comes together. It’s nice, I like it.

Maria Ester: I don’t like being in anyone’s house for hours and hours talking. But if I need Maria, if I need something, I’ll go and chat and everything. There’s an-other thing: I visit the sick a lot. I like to know how they’re doing; I help in any way I can. I communicate a lot with people to find out what they’re going through and help them. I go to one person’s house and another’s house to find out how they’re doing. I have this gift, which I inherited from my mum. (oral re-port)11 11 FRANÇA, Francisca; NASCIMENTO, Maria Ester. Conversa 1. Fortaleza, jan. 2020. Vídeo 29 min. .

Ivone Lima, the social worker who co-ordinates the group, when asked in an interview what her biggest concern was in relation to this stage of life’s development, explained:

In my opinion, the biggest concern for the elderly is when they no longer have the autonomy to leave the house. They usually lose this autonomy when they fall ill, lose their bonds of friendship and society, and start to feel sad. When they lose contact with their friends, they may even have contact with their family, but we find a lot of lonely elderly people without much contact with their family or friends. And this bond of friendship does a lot of good. When they get ill, they can’t go out, they can’t attend groups. [...] It’s a loss of autonomy (Oral report)12 12 LIMA, Ivone de Oliveira. Entrevista 1. Fortaleza, jan. 2020. Áudio 16:45min. .

Ivone’s account confirmed the research process that was being carried out into the support networks they maintained among themselves, and the perception that the Community Centre was a space where these alliances could be formed came to light. The satisfaction that these integrative prac-tices give many of them is shown in Maria do Carmo’s speech:

I really like it there. There we have fun. We listen there, we find out about life, and after we leave it’s back here (home) and that’s it. Then we don’t like it when we don’t have it, because I’m a person who just stays indoors (Oral report)13 13 CARMO, Maria. Conversa 1, 2020. .

After discussion, the materialities and images that could represent this alliance between them were collectively devised. In this way, the group came up with the idea of the performative use of the fishing net object. In the subjective field, the net brings the meaning of weft and networks of re-lationships; and from a historical perspective, fishing is linked to the for-mation of the cultural identity of Greater Mucuripe. The territory, which has been a fishing community for many decades, is still home to those who make a living from this activity. In this way, the symbolic charge of the fish-ing net is also attributed to a resistance to the property speculation that sur-rounds the region and that seeks to remove the community, as participant Maria Ester emphasised:

Because there (Serviluz) they can go and fish, they have things to eat, there’s crab, there’s swordfish, there’s camurupi, all that. And for them to remove those houses that are marked, these people, who knows where they’ll go afterwards. If it’s somewhere far away where they have nowhere to fish, there’s no work, as it stands, right? [...] Half the people of Serviluz live from fishing. They have their nets, they fish, there are times when there are so many sardines, there are times when there are swordfish, and they themselves say that they don’t want to leave. They don’t want to leave to go far away (Oral report)14 14 NASCIMENTO, Maria Ester da Costa. Conversa 1, 2020. .

After establishing the materiality of the fishing net as a collective im-age, strategies were organised to collect the participants’ individual memo-ries. Two methodological approaches guided the performative practice that took place at the end of the meetings in January 2020. The first refers to the “Cartographies of the Self” training system, developed by Professor Sumaya Mattar from the University of São Paulo, which proposes the de-velopment of an autobiographical account through reflective and creative writing. The sharing of this among the participants and the use of this car-tography of stories acts as a device for developing artistic works or actions.

In an article published in 2018, Mattar explains that, in addition to officialised history, there are stories that are built up over the course of a lifetime, and which gain relevance and a social dimension when told. In our view, by identifying the act of mapping stories as a political act, the pro-posal of the Cartographies of Self system engages in a complementary dia-logue with Taylor’s (2013)TAYLOR, Diana. O arquivo e o repertório: performance e memória cultural nas Américas. Belo Horizonte: Editora UFMG, 2013. archive and repertoire studies. Both understand the centrality given to archival records in Western societies, but propose a change in focus by promoting a discussion based on personal memories. As such, we sought to adapt this methodological perspective to the Mulheres do Mar project, with the aim of bringing together other narratives in a decolo-nial counterpoint to the Iracema myth.

The second approach emerged as a complementary guide to the first, in order to flesh out the repertoire aspect. Realising that many of the partic-ipants did not have writing skills, another procedure for accessing their memories was proposed. Performance art has used autobiographical materi-als to construct actions since the 1960s. As inspiration, we used the proce-dure of the La Pocha Nostra group, coordinated by Guillermo Gómez-Peña, who asks participants in his workshops to bring propositional objects– props – to be used in the creation of performance actions.

Following this proposal, the participants were asked to bring objects from their homes and, from these objects, choose a memory to share as a group. They were then asked to place the objects in a fishing net, with the aim of unifying a kaleidoscope of narratives in one image. Antônia Alves Teixeira, Francisca França, Francisca Almeida, Francisca Pereira, Francisca Rodrigues, Geralda Evangelista, Julia Agostinho, Libania Alves, Lourdes Leocadio, Marlucia Maia, Maria do Carmo, Maria das Graças, Maria Vidal, Maria de Lourdes, Quintela, Raimunda Gonçalves, Raimunda Nonata and Rosa Muniz took part in this performance experience.

Image 4
Organising a performance exercise, Mulheres do Mar.Source: Photographs by Ivone Lima (2020).

Personal photographs, as well as those of sons, daughters, husbands, records of their participation in maracatu, items of personal adornment, fishing net weaving needles, a plush toy given to them by a son who lives in Paris, trophies for best Avon saleswoman, handicrafts that were sold on the Beira Mar promenade. These were some of the objects that materialised and fuelled the beginning of the sharing of oral discourses and their memories. For Schwarcz (2019)SCHWARCZ, Lilia Moritz. Sobre o autoritarismo brasileiro. São Paulo: Com-panhia das Letras, 2019., while history contains gaps and misunderstandings about the past, being a field of clashes and disagreements, memory brings a subjective dimension to analysis. Memory translates the past into the first person and focuses on the memory of the person who produces it, “thus, it recovers the ‘present of the past’ and makes the past also become present” (Schwarcz, 2019, p. 13SCHWARCZ, Lilia Moritz. Sobre o autoritarismo brasileiro. São Paulo: Com-panhia das Letras, 2019.).

When presenting their object, each participant formulated a return to the past, in an attempt to present this imagined place in the present mo-ment through the objects; even if they were individual materials, they dia-logued with the cultural identity of that community. As Professor Gabriela Monteiro (2016)MONTEIRO, Gabriela Lírio Gurgel. Autobiografia na cena contemporânea: ten-sionamentos entre o real e o ficcional. Revista Pós, Belo Horizonte, v. 6, n. 11, p. 79-91, 2016. explains in an article on the choice and appropriation of autobiographical materials and personal objects in contemporary theatre,

[...] the documental character and improvisation that arise from dealing with documents and objects recapture the sense of belonging to a particular community, triggered by the idea of social memory, which in many cases exposes pressing ethical issues, such as the presentation of biographical ar-chives which, in addition to revealing ‘images of oneself’, reveal images of Other(s) who are indirectly part of the narrative and are not always aware of its realisation (Monteiro, 2016, p. 81MONTEIRO, Gabriela Lírio Gurgel. Autobiografia na cena contemporânea: ten-sionamentos entre o real e o ficcional. Revista Pós, Belo Horizonte, v. 6, n. 11, p. 79-91, 2016.).

Examples of the performative practice carried out at the Community Centre speak to the point made above. The first refers to the object brought by Rosa Muniz: a photo-painting of her with her mother. When she pre-sented the object, she said: “here’s my mum and me when I was younger... my mum taught me how to raise myself in the mangroves, baking things to sell, I was raised without a father [...] and she didn’t raise just me, she raised five, purely through her own will” (Oral report)15 15 MUNIZ, Rosa. Registro de exercício 1. Fortaleza, jan. 2020. Vídeo 2:02min. . In an interview after the exercise, she added: “My father abandoned me when I was very young. She was the one who brought me up. Working, washing clothes, collecting manioc until the wee hours of the morning, she would come home with a little money and go to buy our food” (Oral report)16 16 MUNIZ, Rosa. Entrevista 1. Fortaleza, nov. 2020. Vídeo 9:52min. . In sharing this memory, Muniz dialogues with the issue of parental abandonment which, according to data released by the IBGE (Caldas, 2023CALDAS, Ana Carolina. Desemprego, medo e sobrecarga: a realidade de mães solo na pandemia. Brasil de Fato, 2023. Disponível em: https://www.brasildefato.com.br/2021/05/01/desemprego-medo-e-sobrecarga-a-realidade-de-maes-solo-na-pandemia. Acesso em: 27 set. 2023.
https://www.brasildefato.com.br/2021/05/...
), states that more than 11 million women cannot count on the participation of fathers to look after and educate their children.

Image 5
Objects, participants and fishing net, Mulheres do Mar.

As a project that arose from the desire to retell Fortaleza by criticising one of its most important formative colonial myths, the sea emerged in many stories, becoming a symbolic marker of the ways in which patriarchal structural contexts traversed the singularities of these women. Below are fragments of the stories that evoked memories in this context:

Maria do Carmo, when speaking of her relationship with daughters and sons:

In this photo I was 25 years old at Praia do Mucuripe, I was already a mum, I had two children. I had 10 children, two died young, and then another, he was 33 and they killed him. I was left with just seven. Five women and two men. In this other photo they called to me: ‘Mum, let’s go to the beach’, so I went, and when I got there, there was a man who took this photo of them (Oral report)17 17 CARMO, Maria. Registro de exercício 1. Fortaleza, jan. 2020. Vídeo 2:18 min. .

Lourdes Leocádio, talking about her wedding:

I married a fisherman, here are his photos, he was a skipper, we got married and spent 35 years married, only in civil law, I didn’t get married in the church, but I got married in civil law, I have my documents. During this time together I had five children, here’s proof (shows photo) that he was a fisherman, that he worked on a fishing boat, at the time he caught fish, lobster and he was also a cook on the boat for his crew. [...] 35 years together, we’ve never split up (Oral report)18 18 LEOCADIO, Lourdes. Registro de exercício 1. Fortaleza, jan. 2020. Vídeo 2:56 min. .

Image 6
Women with objects brought along for a performance exercise. Left to right: Rosa Muniz, Ma-ria do Carmo, Lourdes Leocadio.

Like Lourdes, other women shared how their partners worked at sea. Because it required long periods of distance between the couple, the work ended up generating conflicts, mainly because the men were jealous of their wives. According to some of them, while they were at sea, they weren’t al-lowed to make friends with men or spend much time away from home, even when they needed to go to the doctor or the market.

In these narratives, we see the maintenance of the modern colonial gender system, which made women’s bodies a common property in which men could exercise their domination through psychological and physical violence. Along these lines, participants Rosa Muniz and Geralda Evange-lista reported that:

We have no value to men, they can do whatever they want, we have no value. He wants to boss us around, he wants to step on us, he wants to beat us, he wants to kill us. We’re nothing to men (Oral report)19 19 MUNIZ, Rosa. Entrevista 1, 2020. .

The worst thing in the world is these men killing women every day. [...] They’re killing a lot of women, some of them so young, beautiful, working to survive, they want to be the owner, they want to have the right, to be the owner of that person [...] they don’t let the woman stand up and live her life. [...] no one has the right to own anyone, it didn’t work out, everyone goes their own way, it’s about being free, you don’t have the right to kill, that’s what I think is most wrong, men kill-ing women, every day they kill three, four of them (Oral report)20 20 EVANGELISTA, Geralda. Entrevista 1. Fortaleza, nov. 2020. Vídeo 10:50 min .

The memories resulting from the performance practices, as well as the interview reports that have been highlighted here, show that the singulari-ties of these women are similar – in urban territorial violence that causes mothers to lose their children, in parental abandonment and in psychologi-cal gender violence – or opposes it – on reporting femicide – to Alencar’s mnemonic archive, in relation to the colonial patriarchy that the work re-veals.

The initial proposal was to use this procedure to create images and performances that would unify these memories. Unfortunately, however, the Covid-19 pandemic put a stop to all the meetings at the Community Centre, as this is a group of elderly women at high risk of viral contamina-tion. Nevertheless, we managed to produce an image that united the ob-jects, the fishing net and the sea at Praia do Titanzinho, as a way of strengthening the bonds that they defend so much in relation to belonging to this community: “I live here, I value it here, [...] I love living here and I built my house here. [...] I’ll only leave here when God takes me away” (Oral report)21 21 EVANGELISTA, Geralda. Entrevista 1, 2020. .

Image 7
Image produced from the performative exercise.

At the end of 2020, produced by the Ceará-based contemporary art research and circulation platform Imaginários, we held the performance in-stallation22 22 No Farol da Juventude (Instituto Cultural Iracema), houve obras de partici-pantes das residências do Serviluz e Centro Cultural Belchior. Produção e pro-vocação cênica de Eduardo Bruno Freitas e identidade visual de Kerensky Ba-rata pela Plataforma Imaginários. Mulheres do Mar in a container on the sands of Praia de Irace-ma. This territory, as well as being named after Alencar’s work, is also home to the expropriation of a fishing community and constant property specula-tion due to tourism, which is one of the region’s major attractions. There-fore, the decision to place the performative installation there was an attempt to critically question the extractivist narrative established between tourism and the local population.

The aim of the project was to strengthen our ability to tell, through our memories, other historicities, beyond those imposed socio-historically through performative practices. However, due to the limitations imposed by the pandemic, the discussion around the ephemerality and permanence of artistic actions became latent. Despite the divergence between authors, rather than defining the ontology of performance in this respect, we are in-terested in seeing the debates as fostering a political questioning. Diana Taylor (2013, p. 30)TAYLOR, Diana. O arquivo e o repertório: performance e memória cultural nas Américas. Belo Horizonte: Editora UFMG, 2013., in asking who has claimed history, “if performative practices lack the staying power to transmit vital knowledge?”, encourages us to think about the project in a new dimension. If the archive operates as the central axis of Western epistemology, from performative practices we can weave critical strategies to the archival supports that perpetuate these colonial histories.

From performative practices to the decolonial archive and repertoire

We can consider the concept of decoloniality based on the struggle against the logic of coloniality and its economic, epistemic and symbolic ef-fects. As the philosopher Maldonado-Torres (2019, p. 36)MALDONADO-TORRES, Nelson. Decolonialidade e pensamento afrodi-aspórico. São Paulo: Autêntica, 2019. explains, since coloniality is a constitutive element of capitalist modernity, the decolonial proposal seeks to create a world “where many worlds can exist”, including different conceptions of time, space and subjectivity that relate to each oth-er productively. This mode of agency played an important role in the for-mulation of the performative practices and archival supports in the Mul-heres do Mar (Women of the Sea) project.

Given the impossibility of carrying out the corporeal action with the women of Serviluz, due to the sanitary rules imposed by the pandemic, the Pescaria (Fishing) performance was proposed. For six days, at sunset, at var-ious tourist attractions in Praia de Iracema, the researcher sat in a rocking chair next to a speaker that carried the voices of Francisca, Lourdes, Maria do Carmo and Geralda telling their memories. Based on these verbalisa-tions, the performer filled in pieces of fabric and sewed them onto the fish-ing net. Next to her, another chair was available as an invitation for women who live and work in the area to sit down and continue the cartography. In this way, the action was seen as an act of rupture from the modes of visibil-ity constructed in that landscape.

Image 8
Pescaria Performance – Praia de Iracema beach, 2020.

Another outcome of the project, which dialogues with archival strate-gies such as the power to endure in history, was the publication of the vir-tual exhibition platform. Based on the idea of an affective map as opposed to a GPS map, the proposal was to chronicle Fortaleza through the fiction-ality proposed by the participants, enabling global access to these stories.

Image 9
Mulheres do Mar Site.

In December 2022, as the Covid vaccination progressed, the artist-researcher was able to return to the Serviluz Community Centre and meet the group of participants again. In the same room where the project’s first performance exercise was held in 2020, photographs and fabric cut-outs with written memories were displayed, and the website was presented. Lourdes and Maria do Carmo took the fabrics with their stories to their homes. Asked about her perceptions of being published on a website, Fran-cisca Rodrigues replied: “It’s great, because that way everyone will know who the women of Farol were and we’ll be remembered. Because the theme is never about our history” (Oral report)23 23 RODRIGUES, Francisca. Entrevista 1. Fortaleza, mar. 2023. Áudio 16:47 min. . Geralda Evangelista adds when talking about being forgotten: “Our activities, our work weren't exhibited, many people didn't know what we did, but they learnt about it” (Oral report)24 24 EVANGELISTA, Geralda. Entrevista 2. Fortaleza, mar. 2023. Áudio 14:50 min. . Corresponding to their voices, when women put themselves in a position of power to publish their stories, they oppose a system that has placed a high degree of value on the archive and exercised its dominance based on a white, Eurocentric and patriarchal order.

Final considerations

Colonial and patriarchal archives are the fruit of institutional selection and inscription, serving the interests of an elite made up mostly of white men. The myth of Iracema has been endorsed to this day, helping to main-tain an idyllic and appeased narrative of the Brazilian people’s formation. The romanticisation of the countless forms of violence inherent in colonisa-tion contributes to the persistence of abuses and inequalities that intersect gender-class-race-sexuality, including the high rate of femicide and murders of LGBTQIA+ people in Brazil.

The participants’ accounts revealed that the project managed to chal-lenge the logic of narratives that mask relations of oppression. In this sense, developing participatory and performative creative processes with older women who are new to the artistic field and excluded from the dynamics of cultural and academic institutions was fundamental to building and creat-ing new ways of understanding this myth of formation, enabling counter-narratives. Through autobiographical narratives, the participants were able to position themselves as agents of their memories and raised issues of gen-der, sexuality, race and class.

The interaction, between performative games and cartographies of the self, proved to be an effective approach allowing the project to trigger re-flections in the sense of establishing new relationships of authorship and an understanding that it is not only literate and powerful people who can pro-duce and share narratives and historical points of view. Even though the in-itial proposal, which included a workshop phase followed by performances with the participants, was affected by the pandemic and did not include physical actions due to social isolation, the incentive to share the powerful narratives resulted in the idea of an exhibition platform.

By creating a fracture in the thinking of this hegemonic archive as the holder of knowledge, we collectively produced gaps and lines of escape, through decolonial repertoires and archives generated through performative practices, making visible what was not there to see in the history of Fortaleza. We believe that this reflection on the process of creating the Mulheres do Mar cartography can contribute to studies on feminist and decolonial participa-tory artistic practices, as well as the pedagogy of the Performing Arts, an area that is increasingly expanding beyond the boundaries of theatrical language.

Notes

  • 1
    This article summarises aspects developed in the dissertation Mulheres do Mar: um olhar sobre práticas performativas participativas criadas com intersecção de dis-cursos feministas, by Marie Araujo Auip (2022)AUIP, Marie Araujo. Mulheres do Mar: um olhar sobre práticas performativas participativas criadas com intersecção de discursos feministas. 2022. Dissertação (Mestrado em Artes Cênicas) – Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 2022., supervised by Marcos Aurélio Bulhões Martins, at Universidade de São Paulo in 2022.
  • 2
    The group at the Luíza Távora Community Centre was made up of an average of 60 elderly people, 85% of whom were cisgender women. Because it was a group that already had established and institutionalised relationships, the pro-poser was unable to make an open call that could include other cisgender wo-men, transgender and non-binary people.
  • 3
    Information at: https://www.casacivil.ce.gov.br/2011/04/25/palacio-iracema/. Accessed on: 02 Sept. 2023.
  • 4
    The myth of racial democracy is contained in the idea that Brazil was built on its ability to link diverse nations and cultures in perfect equality and racial harmony.
  • 5
    A term that has been used by researchers as a self-designation of the original peoples in relation to their territory, as opposed to America, the designation given by the coloniser.
  • 6
    The archive’s standards of cultural expression exist in the form of texts, docu-ments, letters, in materials that, primarily, have the capacity to persist over ti-me; the repertoire consists of the culture embodied through performances, ges-tures, orality, dance, among others.
  • 7
    Tourism accounts for 36% of Fortaleza's GDP on average. The seafront is one of the main attractions for tourists, with heavy investment by the municipal government to “requalify” certain stretches of the seafront.
  • 8
    Information: https://serviluzquepermanece.wixsite.com/especial/serviluz. Accessed on: 02 abr. 2023.
  • 9
    History and memory project for the communities of Greater Mucuripe.
  • 10
  • 11
    FRANÇA, Francisca; NASCIMENTO, Maria Ester. Conversa 1. Fortaleza, Jan. 2020. Video 29 min.
  • 12
    LIMA, Ivone de Oliveira. Entrevista 1. Fortaleza, jan. 2020. Audio 16:45min.
  • 13
    CARMO, Maria. Conversa 1, 2020.
  • 14
    NASCIMENTO, Maria Ester da Costa. Conversation 1, 2020.
  • 15
    MUNIZ, Rosa. Exercise recording 1. Fortaleza, Jan. 2020. Video 2:02min.
  • 16
    MUNIZ, Rosa. Entrevista 1. Fortaleza, Nov. 2020. Video 9:52min.
  • 17
    CARMO, Maria. Exercise recording 1. Fortaleza, Jan. 2020. Video 2:18 min.
  • 18
    LEOCADIO, Lourdes. Exercise recording 1. Fortaleza, Jan. 2020. Video 2:56 min.
  • 19
    MUNIZ, Rosa. Interview 1, 2020.
  • 20
    EVANGELISTA, Geralda. Interview 1. Fortaleza, Nov. 2020. Video 10:50 min
  • 21
    EVANGELISTA, Geralda. Interview 1, 2020.
  • 22
    At Farol da Juventude (Instituto Cultural Iracema), there were works by partici-pants from the Serviluz and Centro Cultural Belchior residencies. Production and staging by Eduardo Bruno Freitas and visual identity by Kerensky Barata for Pla-taforma Imaginários.
  • 23
    RODRIGUES, Francisca. Interview 1. Fortaleza, Mar. 2023. Audio 16:47 min.
  • 24
    EVANGELISTA, Geralda. Interview 2. Fortaleza, Mar. 2023. Audio 14:50 min.
  • Availability of research data:
  • This original paper, translated by Tony O’Sullivan, is also published in Portuguese in this issue of the journal.

Availability of research data:

the entire set of data supporting the results of this study has been made available in USP’s Repository and on its own website and can be accessed at any time at DOI: 10.11606/D.27.2022.tde-29112022-115532 and https://www.mulheresdomar.com/pescaria.

This original paper, translated by Thuila Farias Ferreira, is also published in Portuguese in this issue of the journal.

Referências

  • ALCOFF, Linda. Uma epistemologia para a próxima revolução. Revista Socie-dade e Estado, v. 31, n. 1, p. 129-143, 2016.
  • ALENCAR, José. Iracema Brasília: Biblioteca Digital da Câmara dos Deputa-dos, 2019. Disponível em: https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcamara/11854. Acesso em: 23 abr. 2023.
    » https://bd.camara.leg.br/bd/handle/bdcamara/11854.
  • AUIP, Marie Araujo. Mulheres do Mar: um olhar sobre práticas performativas participativas criadas com intersecção de discursos feministas. 2022. Dissertação (Mestrado em Artes Cênicas) – Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 2022.
  • ARDENNE, Paul. Un arte contextual: Creación artística en medio urbano, en situacion, de intervención, de participación. Cartagena: Flammarion, 2002.
  • CALDAS, Ana Carolina. Desemprego, medo e sobrecarga: a realidade de mães solo na pandemia. Brasil de Fato, 2023. Disponível em: https://www.brasildefato.com.br/2021/05/01/desemprego-medo-e-sobrecarga-a-realidade-de-maes-solo-na-pandemia. Acesso em: 27 set. 2023.
    » https://www.brasildefato.com.br/2021/05/01/desemprego-medo-e-sobrecarga-a-realidade-de-maes-solo-na-pandemia.
  • CARNEIRO, Sueli. Enegrecer o feminismo: a situação da mulher negra na América Latina a partir de uma perspectiva de gênero. NEABI, Artigos, 2020. Disponível em: https://www1.unicap.br/neabi/?page_id=137. Acesso em: 23 abr. 2023.
    » https://www1.unicap.br/neabi/?page_id=137.
  • CAVALCANTE, Eider. Os meandros do habitar na metrópole: expansão ur-bana e controle territorial na produção do litoral de Fortaleza. 2017. Tese (Dou-torado em Geografia) – Programa de Pós-Graduação em Geografia, Universidade Federal do Ceará, Fortaleza, 2017.
  • CUMES, Aura. Colonialismo patriarcal y patriarcado colonial: violência y despo-jo em las sociedades que nos dan forma. In: LEYVA SOLANO, Xochitl; ICAZA, Rosalba (Coord.). En tiempos de Muerte: Cuerpos, Rebeldías, Resistencias. Buenos Aires: Cooperativa Editorial Retos, 2019.
  • FABIÃO, Eleonora. Performance e Teatro: poéticas e políticas na cena contem-porânea. Revista Sala Preta, São Paulo, v. 8, p. 235-246, 2008.
  • FEDERICI, Silvia. Calibã e a Bruxa: mulheres, corpo e acumulação primitiva. São Paulo: Editora Elefante, 2017.
  • FEDERICI, Silvia. O ponto zero da revolução: trabalho doméstico, reprodução e luta feminista. São Paulo: Elefante, 2019.
  • FISCHER, Stella Regina. Mulheres, performance e ativismos: a ressignificação dos discursos feministas na cena latino-americana. 2017. Tese (Doutorado em Artes Cênicas) – Programa de Pós-Graduação em Artes Cênicas, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 2017.
  • MALDONADO-TORRES, Nelson. Decolonialidade e pensamento afrodi-aspórico São Paulo: Autêntica, 2019.
  • MATTAR, Sumaya. O lugar do relato autobiográfico no sistema formativo Carto-grafias de si. Revista digital do LAV, Santa Maria, v. 11, n. 2, p. 269-273, 2018.
  • MIÑOSO, Yuderkys Espinosa. Sobre porque é necessário um feminismo decolo-nial: diferenciação, dominação coconstitutiva da modernidade ocidental. Solar, Revista de Filosofía Iberoamericana, Dossier Epistemologías feministas latino-americanas, v. 12, n. 1, p. 141-171, 2017.
  • MONTEIRO, Gabriela Lírio Gurgel. Autobiografia na cena contemporânea: ten-sionamentos entre o real e o ficcional. Revista Pós, Belo Horizonte, v. 6, n. 11, p. 79-91, 2016.
  • PARENTE, Tiago Coutinho. Iracema, Horizonte de memórias do mito inces-sante 2019. Tese (Doutorado em Memória Social) – Programa de Pós-Graduação em Memória Social, Universidade Federal do Estado do Rio de Janei-ro, Rio de Janeiro 2019.
  • PINHO, Érika B. M. O tempo bom do Farol: prostituição, gênero e distinção nas trajetórias de ex-prostitutas idosas. In: ENCONTRO DE CIÊNCIAS SOCIAIS DO NORTE E NORDESTE, 15., 2012, Teresina. Anais [...]. Teresina, 2012.
  • QUIJANO, Aníbal. Colonialidade do poder e classificação social. In: SANTOS, Boaventura de Sousa; MENESES, Maria Paula. Epistemologias do Sul Coim-bra: Edições Almedina, 2009.
  • SCHWARCZ, Lilia Moritz. Sobre o autoritarismo brasileiro São Paulo: Com-panhia das Letras, 2019.
  • TAYLOR, Diana. O arquivo e o repertório: performance e memória cultural nas Américas. Belo Horizonte: Editora UFMG, 2013.
  • VIEIRA, Helena. Introdução à História dos Feminismos Youtube, 2022. Dis-ponível em: https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=Xj_Ic9Jp--4. Acesso em: 01 abr. 2023.
    » https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=Xj_Ic9Jp--4.

Edited by

Editor in charge: Fabiana de Amorim Marcello

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    26 Feb 2024
  • Date of issue
    2024

History

  • Received
    30 Apr 2023
  • Accepted
    27 Nov 2023
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul Av. Paulo Gama s/n prédio 12201, sala 700-2, Bairro Farroupilha, Código Postal: 90046-900, Telefone: 5133084142 - Porto Alegre - RS - Brazil
E-mail: rev.presenca@gmail.com