Services on Demand
On-line version ISSN 1518-8345
Rev. Latino-Am. Enfermagem vol.16 no.1 Ribeirão Preto Jan./Feb. 2008
Aluminum as a risk factor for Alzheimer's disease
Pricilla Costa FerreiraI; Kamila de Almeida PiaiI; Angela Maria Magosso TakayanaguiII; Susana Inés Segura-MuñozIII
IUndergraduate Nursing Student, e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
IIPh.D., Associate Professor, e-mail: email@example.com
IIIPh.D., Professor, e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org. University of São Paulo at Ribeirão Preto College of Nursing, WHO Collaborating Centre for Nursing Research Development, Brazil.
The purpose of the study was to condense existing scientific evidence about the relation between aluminum (Al) exposure and risk for the development of Alzheimer's Disease (AD), evaluating its long-term effects on the population's health. A systematic literature review was carried out in two databases, MEDLINE and LILACS, between 1990 and 2005, using the uniterms: "Aluminum exposure and Alzheimer Disease" and "Aluminum and risk for Alzheimer Disease". After application of the Relevance Test, 34 studies were selected, among which 68% established a relation between Al and AD, 23.5% were inconclusive and 8.5% did not establish a relation between Al and AD. Results showed that Al is associated to several neurophysiologic processes that are responsible for the characteristic degeneration of AD. In spite of existing polemics all over the world about the role of Al as a risk factor for AD, in recent years, scientific evidence has demonstrated that Al is associated with the development of AD.
Descriptors: Alzheimer disease; aluminum; risk factors
Aluminum (Al) is a common metal in the environment and one of the most abundant in the terrestrial crust. Al is liberated in the environment by natural processes of soil erosion, volcanic eruptions and anthropogenic actions. Bauxite is the most important source, containing 55% of Al oxide.
The larger portion of Al ingestion is provided through food in different ways: food contaminated by Al, water, and industrialized food that contains Al as conservant and/or colorant.
Even though food is an important source of Al ingestion, it is water which presents a higher bioavailability to be absorbed by the intestine(1). Al salts are largely used as coagulants to reduce organic matter, turbidness and microorganisms present during treatment of superficial water, which presents the largest quantity of particles in suspension. This use, although useful for water treatment in many cities, can increase the concentration of Al at the final point of consumption(2).
Some studies appoint the presence of Al in potable water and in food as one of the etiological agents of mental diseases. There is also a hypothesis that exposure to this element represents a risk for the development of Alzheimer's disease(1).
In 1965, an intracerebral inoculation of Al phosphate in rabbits was reported. It resulted in neurofibrilar degeneration significantly similar to the neurofibrilar degeneration of Alzheimer's Disease (AD), which led to the assumption that there is a relation between Al and AD. In 1973, the first article that evidenced increase in Al concentration in patients with AD was published(3).
AD is a neurodegenerative disorder prevalent in the senile population. It is clinically characterized by the progressive loss of memory and other cognitive abilities and pathologically by severe neuronal loss, glial proliferation and amyloid plaques composed of β-amyloid protein (Aβ) surrounded by degenerated nervous terminations and neurofibrilar tangles(4). This pathology is diagnosed when other dementia causes are excluded, because only necropsy permits the establishment of a definitive AD diagnosis(5).
AD is probably the result of a multifactorial process in which genetic and environmental components are included. It is supposed that individual genetic characteristics modulate environmental exposures. Environmental risk factors related to the development of AD include exposition to Al, one of the most studied potential environmental risk factors. AD has also being related with other risk factors, such as the chemical risk related to the reduction of neurotransmitters, which would be responsible for intellectual and behavioral performance in brains of patients with AD(6).
Another risk factor is the Apolipoprotein E susceptibility gene, which is related to AD(5). Some researchers believe that alterations in aging neurons can lead to a self-immune answer, giving origin to AD(6).
There is also a hypothesis of association with alterations in the hematoencephalic barrier and with severe brain injury, which lead to a loss of conscience and eventual development of AD(6). Age and a family history of dementia appear as the most important risk factors in the disease etiology.
Considering that there is a natural loss of immune answer capacity during the aging process, the development of pathologies is most frequent and most severe in aged persons. In addition, there are extrinsic factors, life style, socioeconomic condition and psychosocial and environmental factors determining functional, cellular and molecular alterations, which lead to diminished homeostatic balance and, consequently, greater predisposition to diseases(7).
Demographic and epidemiological data indicate population aging all over the world. It is estimated that the number of people affected by AD in the world will surpass 26 million; in Brazil, estimates refer to around 500 thousand people. The disease prevalence ranges from 1.4% of individuals between 65 and 69 years old to 20.8% of those between 85 and 89 years old, reaching approximately 38.6% of those between 90 and 95 years old(7). AD represents 70% of the set of diseases that affect the geriatric population.
This article condensed existing scientific evidence of the relation between Al exposure and the risk of development of AD from research results published between 1990 and 2005, using a reproducible bibliographic review technique called Systematic Literature Review.
The systematic literature review was conducted according to a sequence of steps described in Figure 1.
The relation between exposure to Al and the risk of developing AD was the focus of this study. The literature search was conducted in publications between 1990 and 2005, in two databases, MEDLINE and LILACS. The articles were identified through the uniterms: Aluminum Exposure and Alzheimer Disease, and Aluminum and Risk for Alzheimer Disease.
The criteria defined in the Relevance Test were used for the selection of studies. Only studies that positively answered all inclusion criteria participated in the Systematic Literature Review. These criteria are: a) Is the study about AD and/or Al toxicity? ; b) Does it address potential etiological agents or risk factors for development of AD?; c) Was it published between January 1990 and December 2005?; d) Was it published in English, Spanish, Portuguese or French?
The search in the databases and application of the Relevance Test, both to abstracts as to full texts, were carried out by two researchers independently, aiming to assure method objectivity. The Relevance Test was applied twice. It was first applied to the abstracts and, then, the articles that would participate preliminarily in the study were selected(8). After that, all full articles were collected for the application of the second Relevance Test. After the study was completely read, its inclusion or exclusion in the study was confirmed. In view of divergences regarding the inclusion or exclusion of some studies, a third researcher was consulted, according to recommendations by the Cochrane Foundation. Bibliographic, editorial reviews, or communications were not included in the Systematic Literature Review.
Once the full texts had been selected, the information was analyzed and organized in synoptic charts, presenting the bibliographic reference. Thus, the existing experimental evidence on the relation between exposure to Al and the risk of developing AD was condensed from the results of this study.
In this search, 174 studies related with the theme were obtained. After the application of the Relevance Test, 69 studies were selected and 16 were excluded because they included no abstracts, 40 did not affirmatively answer all questions of the Relevance Test, 43 were review articles and 6 were comments. From the 69 studies selected through the first application of the Relevance Test, 46 full texts were obtained.
The 46 full texts were reviewed and analyzed, aiming to identify the type of relation between Al and AD. After the second application of the Relevance Test, 34 studies were selected and 12 articles were excluded: two were comments, six did not affirmatively answer all questions of the Relevance Test and four were reviews. Of the 34 articles selected for the study, 68% (23 studies) established a relation between Al and AD, 23.5% (8 studies) did not present conclusive data and 8.5% (three studies) did not establish any relation between Al and AD. Table 1 shows studies that did not present conclusive data or did not establish a relation between Al and AD and Table 2 presents articles that established a relation between Al and AD.
Despite the epidemiological, social, and economic importance of AD in the world, this study evidenced that few studies have been published on this topic in Latin America. Almost all selected studies originated in Europe, the United States, Canada or Asia; only one of the selected studies is from Latin America, specifically from Brazil.
According to the Systematic Literature Review, AD is associated with a general reduction of cerebral tissue, with localized loss of neurons, mainly in the hypofield and basal forebrain. An experimental study performed with mice treated with Al demonstrated a statistically significant reduction in their brain weight(9). Two microscopic aspects are typical in AD, the extra cellular amyloid plaques, also called senile plaques, which consist of extra cellular deposits of Aβ protein, and neurofibrilar intraneuron tangles that consist of filaments of a fosforilated form of a protein associated to microtubes (Tau). Alteration in the processing of the Aβ protein from its precursor, APP (amyloid precursor protein), is recognized as an essential characteristic in the AD pathogeny(10).
There are two types of Aβ protein, Aβ40 and the Aβ42. The Aβ40 protein is normally produced in small quantities, though the Aβ42 presents a super production due genetic mutations. Both proteins aggregate to form amyloid plaques. However, the Aβ42 presents a higher tendency to do this than Aβ40, constituting the main responsible in the formation of amyloid plaques. The Aβ40 and Aβ42 are produced by proteolytic cleavage of a precursor amyloid protein, the APP, a protein of larger membrane and normally expressed by many cells, including neurons of the central nervous system(10). The APP mutations of genes ease the formation of Aβ, especially the Aβ-42 (Figure 2), with consequent increase in the formation of amyloid plaques(10). It has been observed that Al increases the Ab protein neurotoxicity, the degeneration of neurons exposed to it and also aggregation of Aβ protein(11).
Tau protein becomes abnormally fosforilated in AD and is deposited intracellulary under the form of paired helical filaments with a characteristic microscopical aspect. When the cell dies, these filaments aggregate as neurofibrilar extracellular tangles. There is a strong influence of Al ions on fosforilation which can be the cause, because neurofibrilar tangles contain hyperfosfolated microtubules associated to the Tau protein. It is possible that the Tau fosforilation is intensified by the existence of myloid plaques. Its fosforilation compromises rapid axonal transport, a process that depends on the microtubule(10).
The increased concentration of Al favors the formation of Tau protein and, consequently, the formation of neurofibilar tangles(12). It was discovered in a previous study that the amyloid plaques are surrounded by glial reactive cells, Thus, exposition to Al can activate the oxidative processes of glial cells, which in turn can indirectly damage the neurons integrity(13).
The neuron degeneration observed in AD can also occur due to oxidative stress. Oxidative stress refers to conditions like as hypoxia, characterized by compromised protection mechanisms, as the neurons become more susceptible to excitotoxic lesion. Oxidative stress is induced in brains exposed to Al(10).
It was demonstrated in an epidemiological study that individuals who used to ingest food with high Al contents presented a two times higher risk of developing AD(14).
Studies show that mice with prolonged exposure to Al soluble salt can develop AD, with selective loss of neurons and the cholinergic function. Al also diminishes the transmission of acetylcholine and attenuates its release, causing reduction of reflexes. Al appears as a reductor of neuronal activity, showing similarity with the decreased cholinergic action in AD. Al leads to behavioral alterations only in old rabbits, not in the young ones. Thus, mature brains are more susceptible to Al toxicity than immature ones(15).
Results show that 68% of the analyzed studies present Al as one of the risk factors for AD, confirming and describing the toxicological mechanisms through which Al affects the nervous tissue.
In this study, the need to understand the importance of environmental factors is highlighted, especially exposure to Al, as determinants in the population's health-disease process, stressing its potential to affect, positively or negatively, natural aging processes.
It was verified through a general evaluation of studies that, according to an important group of researchers, Al affects several neurophysiological processes, responsible for the degeneration characteristic of AD. Therefore, scientific evidence has shown that, in the last years, Al has been associated with the development of AD. Thus, preventing exposure to certain environmental factors like Al, among others, could diminish the incidence of chronic-degenerating diseases like AD, which in recent years has acquired great importance for collective health all over the world.
This study was funded by CNPq through the concession of undergraduate scientific grant CNPq/PIBIC (Process N° 111339/2004-9) and CAPES -ProDoc/CAPES Program (Process N° 00023/03-5).
1. Martyn CN, Coggan D, Inskip H, Lacey RF, Young WF. Aluminum concentrations in drinking water and risk of Alzheimer's disease. Epidemiology 1997 May; 8(3):281-6. [ Links ]
2. Bates AJ. Water as consumed and its impact on the consumer-do we understand the variables? Food Chem Toxicol 2000; 38(1 Suppl):29-36. [ Links ]
3. Alfrey AC. Aluminium and renal disease. In: Bourke E, Mallick NP, Pollak VE. Moving points in nephrology. Contrib Nephrol 1993; 102:110-24. [ Links ]
4. Selkoe DJ. Normal and abnormal biology of the beta-amyloide precursor protein. Annu Rev Neurosci 1994; 17:489-517. [ Links ]
5. Yokel RA. The toxicology of aluminum in the brain: a review. Neurotoxicology 2000 Octuber; 21(5):813-28. [ Links ]
6. Associação Brasileira do Alumínio. Alumínio e saúde. 2ª ed. São Paulo (SP): ABAL; 2000. [ Links ]
7. Freitas EV, Py L, Neri AL, Cancado FAX, Gorzoni ML, Rocha SM. Tratrado de geriatria e gerontologia. Rio de Janeiro (RJ): Guanabara Koogan; 2002. [ Links ]
8. Segura-Muñoz SI, Takayanagui AMM, Lopes TM, Trevilato TMB, Hering SE. Estudo do efeito neurotóxico da exposição ocupacional ao manganês, mercúrio e chumbo utilizando como ferramenta metodológica a revisão sistemática de literatura. Mundo da Saúde 2003 outubro-dezembro; 27(4):589-95. [ Links ]
9. Tanino H, Shimohama S, Sasaki Y, Sumida Y, Fujimoto S. Increase in phospholipase C-δ1 protein levels in aluminum-treated rat brains. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 2000 May; 271(3):620-5. [ Links ]
10. Hang HP, Dale MM, Ritter M. Farmacologia. 4ª ed. Rio de Janeiro (RJ): Guanabara Koogan; 2001. [ Links ]
11. Kawahara M, Midori K, Kuroda Y. Effects of aluminum on the neurotoxicity of primary cultured neurons and on the aggregation of β-amyloid protein. Brain Res Bull 2001 May; 55(2):211-7. [ Links ]
12. Campbell A, Kumar A, La Rosa FG, Prasad KN, Bondy SC. Aluminum increases levels of beta-amyloid and ubiquitin in neuroblastoma but not in glioma cells. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 2000 April; 223(4):397-402. [ Links ]
13. Campbell A, Prasad KN, Bondy SC. Aluminum-induced oxidative events in cell lines: Glioma are more responsive than neuroblastoma. Free Radic Biol Med 1999 May; 26(9-10):1166-71. [ Links ]
14. Rogers MA, Simon DG. A preliminary study of dietary aluminium intake and risk of Alzheimer's disease. Age Ageing 1999 March; 28(2):2205-9. [ Links ]
15. Yokel RA, Allen DD, Meyer JJ. Studies of aluminum neurobehavioral toxicity in the intact mammal. Neurobiology 1994 December; 14(6):791-808. [ Links ]
Recebido em: 13.9.2006
Aprovado em: 22.8.2007