Furious Frederich: Nietzsche’s neurosyphilis diagnosis and new hypotheses

Frederico Furioso: O diagnóstico de neurossífilis de Nietzsche e novas hipóteses

Charles André André Rangel Rios About the authors

Abstracts

The causes of Friedrich Nietzsche’s mental breakdown in early 1889 and of the subsequent slow decay to end-stage dementia along ten years will possibly remain open to debate. The diagnosis of syphilitic dementia paralytica, based only on medical anamnesis and physical examination, was considered indisputable by Otto Binswanger. On the other hand, taking into account recently described diseases, selectively collected evidence lend some support to alternative hypotheses: basal forebrain meningioma, CADASIL, MELAS and frontotemporal dementia.

19th Century; history of medicine; neurosyphilis; diagnosis


As causas da crise neuropsiquiátrica de Friedrich Nietzsche no início de 1889 e de sua lenta deterioração em demência avançada ao longo de 10 anos provavelmente permanecerão uma questão em aberto. O diagnóstico da época, demência paralítica sifilítica, foi considerado por Otto Binswanger como indiscutível. Por outro lado, em vista de novas doenças descritas, evidências seletivamente ordenadas sugerem diversas hipóteses alternativas propostas ao longo das últimas décadas, como meningioma frontal, CADASIL, MELAS e demência frontotemporal.

século XIX; história da medicina; neurossífilis; diagnóstico


Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900) left a provocative philosophical work. Also, the diagnosis of his protracted illness became a controversial issue. After a particularly productive period (1888), Nietzsche suffered a mental breakdown. General paresis of the insane (GPI) was diagnosed by the Ludwig Wille, medical director of the Basel asylum11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.. In Jena, Otto Binswanger, the institution’s director, and his staff, upon consistent examination, corroborated GPI. The diagnosis was never contested by any one of his physicians: as late as 1920 Binswanger, who met him twice after his discharge, reasserted categorically the diagnosis11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.. After January 1889, Nietzsche never recovered. The disoriented, agitated and delirious patient entered a slow process of decay to dementia until pneumonia took his life in 1900. No autopsy was conducted.

MEDICAL HISTORY

Medical records, prescriptions and letters11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990. show that Nietzsche suffered from severe myopia (worse in the right eye) and pupil asymmetry (right one larger), both first detected in childhood11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.,22. Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17.,33. Hemelsoet D, Hemelsoet K, Devreese D. The neurological illness of Friedrich Nietzsche. Acta Neurol Belg. 2008;108(1):9-16.,44. Gower, WR. Syphilis and the nervous system. Philadelphia: Blackstone; 1892. The origin of functional nervous disorders attributed to syphilis on imperfect evidence. (Lecture II: 55-90).. His right eye was functionally blind by age 3011. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.,22. Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17.,33. Hemelsoet D, Hemelsoet K, Devreese D. The neurological illness of Friedrich Nietzsche. Acta Neurol Belg. 2008;108(1):9-16.. Central chorioretinitis was diagnosed in 1878 (severe myopia? toxoplasmosis?). Severe headaches set in from school years on11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.,22. Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17.,33. Hemelsoet D, Hemelsoet K, Devreese D. The neurological illness of Friedrich Nietzsche. Acta Neurol Belg. 2008;108(1):9-16.,44. Gower, WR. Syphilis and the nervous system. Philadelphia: Blackstone; 1892. The origin of functional nervous disorders attributed to syphilis on imperfect evidence. (Lecture II: 55-90).. They were asymmetric (mainly right-sided), frontal/supraorbitary, and accompanied by photophobia and nausea/vomiting, becoming more severe in adult life. After recurrent sick leaves from his professorship chair at Basel (1871, 1876), Nietzsche retired in 1879. During the 1880s, he used to take a variety of medicines for numerous complaints: stomach cramps, constipation, retching, headaches, and severe insomnia, treated with chloral hydrate, apparently in high doses11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.,22. Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17..

Nietzsche’s father, a Lutheran pastor, suffered from recurrent headaches and depression. He died at the age of 36 with seizures and progressive neurological deficits (aphasia, blindness, possibly dementia) along one year. Autopsy disclosed “softening” of the brain11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.,22. Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17.. Nietzsche’s mother, also anisocoric, had abdominal ailments, but only died at the age of 7011. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990. from abdominal cancer33. Hemelsoet D, Hemelsoet K, Devreese D. The neurological illness of Friedrich Nietzsche. Acta Neurol Belg. 2008;108(1):9-16.. Nietzsche’s sister died at the age of 89 and had a healthy life.

Based on letters and testimonies, after 1880, Nietzsche had periods of elation and depressive episodes (1882, 1886-7)11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.,22. Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17.. However, when, due to lack of public recognition, he, for instance, writes that he would be understood only posthumously, it remains doubtful whether this points to megalomania or just resilience11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.,44. Gower, WR. Syphilis and the nervous system. Philadelphia: Blackstone; 1892. The origin of functional nervous disorders attributed to syphilis on imperfect evidence. (Lecture II: 55-90).. During 1888 Nietzsche seemed exalted in many occasions. His mood progressively deteriorates in December, and on next January he develops a full-blown manic episode, signing letters as “Dionysius” or “The Crucified One”.

In March 1890, his mother brought him home. Nietzsche is now unable to take care of himself, exhibits some amnesia, apathy, childish comments, and eventual episodes of aggressiveness11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.,22. Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17.. Headache complaints ceased in 189111. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.. After his mother’s death (1897) he had a number of acute focal symptoms (as reported by his sister) including speech problems and facial paresis, likely due to strokes. By the year 1899, he was hemiparetic (left side) and bedridden (Figure).

Figure
Photographs of Nietzsche at home in an advanced dementia state (A) and exhibiting left arm hemiplegic dystonia (with his sister) (B). Right sided paresis and grasping cannot be excluded.

POSSIBLE DIAGNOSES

Syphilis (GPI) was diagnosed at admission in both Basel and Jena hospices. Grandiose delirium and right pupil sluggish response to light were considered relevant symptoms. However, anisocoria was present since childhood and typical signs, such as dementia, ataxia, and hand and tongue tremor, were absent. Nietzsche admittedly had gonorrhea (“Tripper”) twice in his twenties11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.. Correct differentiation between gonorrhea and primary syphilis at that time would however depend on medical evaluation11. Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.. If asymmetrical findings (e.g., left ankle clonus), and the extended course before death speak against neurosyphilis, on the other hand, lancinating headaches and orbital pain, aniso/dyscoria and a subacute mental breakdown in a middle-aged patient with a history of remote venereal infection comprise a coherent cluster pointing to the diagnosis of neurosyphilis. Motor problems are a relatively late feature in most cases of GPI and would not necessarily be expected at presentation. Also, asymmetrical manifestations are common, and strokes not rare55. Adams RD, Victor M, Ropper AH. Principles of neurology. 6. ed. New York: McGraw-Hill; 1997. Chapter 32, Infections of the nervous system (bacterial, fungal, spirochetal, parasitic) and sarcoid; p. 695-741.. The usual course would lead to death in 3-4 years and in a few cases 5-6 years66. Kraepelin E. Clinical psychiatry. New York: MacMillan; 1907. Chapter 6, Dementia paralytica; 276-322.. Kraepelin refers to “a genuine case of paresis confirmed by autopsy, with a remission of twenty years”44. Gower, WR. Syphilis and the nervous system. Philadelphia: Blackstone; 1892. The origin of functional nervous disorders attributed to syphilis on imperfect evidence. (Lecture II: 55-90).,66. Kraepelin E. Clinical psychiatry. New York: MacMillan; 1907. Chapter 6, Dementia paralytica; 276-322. and to “some cases of so-called arrested paresis66. Kraepelin E. Clinical psychiatry. New York: MacMillan; 1907. Chapter 6, Dementia paralytica; 276-322., even not dismissing the “mooted question” of recoveries from paresis66. Kraepelin E. Clinical psychiatry. New York: MacMillan; 1907. Chapter 6, Dementia paralytica; 276-322.. Binswanger, too, was not impressed by Nietzsche’s survival, laying emphasis on the extremely good care of his mother.

Due to the mood swings, the hypothesis of bipolar disorder was raised, but would not explain the development of dementia after the severe maniac outbreak in 188922. Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17.. A Meningioma of the right optic nerve/basal frontal lobe could explain the longstanding right-sided headaches, psychiatric disturbances and the long course with asymmetrical features77. Sax L. What was the cause of Nietzsche’s dementia. J Med Biogr. 2003;11(1):47-54. doi:10.1177/096777200301100113. The absence of papilledema and the preserved level of consciousness strongly argue against the hypothesis, however.

Frontotemporal dementia (FTD) may cause personality and psychiatric/behavioral manifestations, even psychotic features, in middle-aged individuals, but wouldn’t explain the headaches and late strokes88. Orth M, Trimble MR. Friedrich Nietzsche’s mental illness - general paralysis of the insane vs. frontotemporal dementia. Acta Psychiatr Scand. 2006;114(6):439-44. doi:10.1111/j.1600-0447.2006.00827.x. The remarkable philosophical works in the late 1880s, with complex and well-wrought argumentations, also argue against FTD, and, regarding philosophical works, the alleged rare increase of artistic creativity in some patients88. Orth M, Trimble MR. Friedrich Nietzsche’s mental illness - general paralysis of the insane vs. frontotemporal dementia. Acta Psychiatr Scand. 2006;114(6):439-44. doi:10.1111/j.1600-0447.2006.00827.x is a poor argument.

Worsening migraine in adult life, mood disorder, psychotic behavior and dementia associated with strokes led to a tentative diagnosis of CADASIL33. Hemelsoet D, Hemelsoet K, Devreese D. The neurological illness of Friedrich Nietzsche. Acta Neurol Belg. 2008;108(1):9-16.,99. Perogamvros L, Perrig S, Bogousslavsky J, Giannakopoulos P. Friedrich Nietzsche and his Illness: a neurophilosophical approach to introspection. J Hist Neurosci. 2013;22(2):174-82. doi:10.1080/0964704X.2012.712825. His father’s symptoms could suggest a genetic disease. Childhood onset of migraine, slow decline, and the very late occurrence of (unconfirmed) strokes in Nietzsche’s case stand against CADASIL1010. André C. CADASIL: pathogenesis, clinical and radiological findings and treatment. Arq Neuropsiquiatr. 2010;68(2):287-99. doi:10.1590/S0004-282X2010000200026. Childhood onset of headaches and gastrointestinal ailments, psychiatric manifestations, and recurrent focal neurological deficits could suggest MELAS1111. Koszka C. Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900): a classical case of mitochondrial encephalomyopathy with lactic acidosis and stroke-like episodes (MELAS) syndrome? J Med Biogr. 2009;17(3):161-4. doi:10.1258/jmb.2009.009016. The family history is not comprehensive enough to support this hypothesis22. Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17..

At any rate, CADASIL, MELAS and slowly growing tumors are rare, remaining rather wild guesses.

In conclusion, an eventual exhumation of Nietzsche’s body could provide remnants usable for DNA tests for CADASIL33. Hemelsoet D, Hemelsoet K, Devreese D. The neurological illness of Friedrich Nietzsche. Acta Neurol Belg. 2008;108(1):9-16., mitochondrial or somatic mutations1111. Koszka C. Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900): a classical case of mitochondrial encephalomyopathy with lactic acidosis and stroke-like episodes (MELAS) syndrome? J Med Biogr. 2009;17(3):161-4. doi:10.1258/jmb.2009.009016, or spirochetes. Skull imprints related to slowly growing tumors would suggest meningioma77. Sax L. What was the cause of Nietzsche’s dementia. J Med Biogr. 2003;11(1):47-54. doi:10.1177/096777200301100113. The absence of laboratory and imaging tests in late 19th Century precludes any uncontroversial diagnosis. All in all, neurosyphilis, despite the strong diagnostic bias of that time, was then a common disease. Hence, an atypical GPI may still nowadays be accepted as the most probable diagnosis.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The authors are grateful to Dr. Carlos Estellita-Lins, Dr. Rogério Henriques and the participants of the Nietzsche Study Group for fruitful and evolving discussions on the theme.

References

  • 1
    Volz PD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit. Wurtzburg: Königshausen & Neumann; 1990.
  • 2
    Bosch OG, Höfer FXE. La Gaya Dementia Nietzsche als Patient. Weimar-Jena: Die Grosse Stadt. Das kulturhistorische Archiv. 2010;4(1): 6-17.
  • 3
    Hemelsoet D, Hemelsoet K, Devreese D. The neurological illness of Friedrich Nietzsche. Acta Neurol Belg. 2008;108(1):9-16.
  • 4
    Gower, WR. Syphilis and the nervous system. Philadelphia: Blackstone; 1892. The origin of functional nervous disorders attributed to syphilis on imperfect evidence. (Lecture II: 55-90).
  • 5
    Adams RD, Victor M, Ropper AH. Principles of neurology. 6. ed. New York: McGraw-Hill; 1997. Chapter 32, Infections of the nervous system (bacterial, fungal, spirochetal, parasitic) and sarcoid; p. 695-741.
  • 6
    Kraepelin E. Clinical psychiatry. New York: MacMillan; 1907. Chapter 6, Dementia paralytica; 276-322.
  • 7
    Sax L. What was the cause of Nietzsche’s dementia. J Med Biogr. 2003;11(1):47-54. doi:10.1177/096777200301100113
  • 8
    Orth M, Trimble MR. Friedrich Nietzsche’s mental illness - general paralysis of the insane vs. frontotemporal dementia. Acta Psychiatr Scand. 2006;114(6):439-44. doi:10.1111/j.1600-0447.2006.00827.x
  • 9
    Perogamvros L, Perrig S, Bogousslavsky J, Giannakopoulos P. Friedrich Nietzsche and his Illness: a neurophilosophical approach to introspection. J Hist Neurosci. 2013;22(2):174-82. doi:10.1080/0964704X.2012.712825
  • 10
    André C. CADASIL: pathogenesis, clinical and radiological findings and treatment. Arq Neuropsiquiatr. 2010;68(2):287-99. doi:10.1590/S0004-282X2010000200026
  • 11
    Koszka C. Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900): a classical case of mitochondrial encephalomyopathy with lactic acidosis and stroke-like episodes (MELAS) syndrome? J Med Biogr. 2009;17(3):161-4. doi:10.1258/jmb.2009.009016

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    13 Oct 2015
  • Date of issue
    Dec 2015

History

  • Received
    21 May 2015
  • Reviewed
    28 July 2015
  • Accepted
    18 Aug 2015
Academia Brasileira de Neurologia - ABNEURO R. Vergueiro, 1353 sl.1404 - Ed. Top Towers Offices Torre Norte, 04101-000 São Paulo SP Brazil, Tel.: +55 11 5084-9463 | +55 11 5083-3876 - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
E-mail: revista.arquivos@abneuro.org