Open-access Continuity of care: trust-based relationship and availability of personalized information in user experience

Continuidad de la atención: relaciones de confianza y disponibilidad de información personalizada en la experiencia del usuario

Abstract:

This article analyzes the continuity of care in the relational domain based on user experience. This is a qualitative case study based on 45 interviews with person living with HIV (PLH) followed-up in polyclinics and 38 interviews with users diagnosed with systemic arterial hypertension (SAH) registered in basic health units (BHU) in a large city in the state of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. The results were analyzed according to two dimensions of relational continuity: trust-based relationship and availability of personalized information. The strongest trust-based relationships and the protagonism in the availability of health information were established with the family health team (FHT) physician and the infectious disease specialist in the polyclinics. Among the differences, according to users with SAH, the relationship bonds were broken by health care provider turnover. In the absence of relationships with other FHT professionals, continuity and access were simultaneously affected. Among PLH users, nursing professionals played an important role in care. In both cases, the results showed a care with little concern for interprofessional practices, collective actions and promotional initiatives to strengthen continuity. The lack of technology-mediated communication required users to attend health care services to solve their demands and contact professionals. The results indicate the importance of a regular point of care for establishment of the bond and consequent relational continuity. However, health care work management-related problems in the Brazilian Unified National Health System aggravate health care provider turnover and favor disruptions in therapeutic follow-up.

Keywords:
Continuity of Patient Care; Integrality in Health; Health Services Accessibility

Resumo:

Este artigo analisa a continuidade do cuidado no domínio relacional a partir da experiência de usuários. Foi realizado um estudo de caso qualitativo com base em 45 entrevistas com pessoas que vivem com HIV (PVH) acompanhadas em policlínicas e 38 com usuários com diagnóstico de hipertensão arterial sistêmica (HAS) cadastrados em unidades básicas de saúde (UBS) em um município de grande porte do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, Brasil. Os resultados são analisados a partir de duas dimensões da continuidade relacional: as relações de confiança e a disponibilidade de informações personalizadas. Junto ao médico da equipe de saúde da família (EqSF) e ao infectologista nas policlínicas se estabeleciam as mais fortes relações de confiança e o protagonismo na disponibilização das informações em saúde. Entre as diferenças, para os usuários com HAS, os vínculos foram cindidos pela rotatividade médica. Na vacância de relações com outros profissionais das EqSF, a continuidade e o acesso foram simultaneamente afetados. Entre as PVH, profissionais de enfermagem desempenhavam importante papel no acolhimento. Nos dois casos, os resultados revelaram um cuidado pouco afeito às práticas interprofissionais, ações coletivas e promocionais no fortalecimento da continuidade. A ausência de comunicação intermediada por tecnologias exigia dos usuários idas aos serviços para resolução de suas demandas e contato com os profissionais. Os resultados sinalizam a importância de um ponto regular de cuidado para a consecução do vínculo e a consequente continuidade relacional. Por outro lado, problemas relacionados à gestão do trabalho no Sistema Único de Saúde intensificam a rotatividade profissional e favorecem as rupturas no seguimento terapêutico.

Palavras-chave:
Continuidade da Assistência ao Paciente; Integralidade em Saúde; Acessibilidade aos Serviços de Saúde

Resumen:

En este artículo se analiza la continuidad de la atención en el ámbito relacional desde la experiencia del usuario. Se llevó a cabo un estudio de caso cualitativo basado en 45 entrevistas con personas que viven con VIH (PVH) monitoreadas en policlínicas y 38 con usuarios diagnosticados con hipertensión arterial sistémica (HAS) registrados en unidades básicas de salud (UBS) en un gran municipio del estado de Rio de Janeiro, Brasil. Los resultados se analizan desde dos dimensiones de la continuidad relacional: relaciones de confianza y disponibilidad de información personalizada. Junto con el médico del equipo de salud familiar (EqSF) y el infectólogo en las policlínicas, se establecieron las relaciones de confianza más fuertes y el protagonismo en la disponibilidad de información de salud. Entre las diferencias para los usuarios con HAS, los bonos se dividieron en función de la rotación médica. En ausencia de relaciones con otros profesionales de EqSF, la continuidad y el acceso se vieron afectados simultáneamente. Entre las PVH, los profesionales de enfermería desempeñaron un papel importante en la acogida. En ambos casos, los resultados revelaron poco cuidado con las prácticas interprofesionales, acciones colectivas y promocionales para fortalecer la continuidad. La ausencia de comunicación mediada por tecnologías requiere que los usuarios acudan a los servicios para resolver sus demandas y contactar con los profesionales. Los resultados revelan la importancia de un punto de atención regular para lograr el vínculo y la consecuente continuidad relacional. Por otro lado, los problemas relacionados con la gestión laboral en el Sistema Único de Salud intensifican la rotación profesional y favorecen las rupturas en el seguimiento terapéutico.

Palabras-clave:
Continuidad de la Atención al Paciente; Integralidad en Salud; Accesibilidad a los Servicios de Salud

Introduction

Continuity of care has been associated with reduced hospitalizations, mortality and use of emergency services, in addition to strengthening adherence to health promotion and the relationship between professionals and users 1,2,3,4. Its achievement represents a major challenge to health care systems worldwide, whose implementation of policies and actions is concentrated in the scope of primary health care (PHC) 4,5. However, for people living with chronic diseases or complex health needs, ensuring continuity involves specialized, hospital, social and community services 6,7.

The classic concept by Haggerty et al. 8, widely adopted and adapted to different contexts, proposes a framework of continuity of care in three domains: informational, managerial and relational. The first presupposes the continuous use of relevant information about the patient’s history and their living and health conditions with a view to making current and future care adequate. Managerial continuity involves coherence in clinical management based on cooperation and communication between the various providers to provide care in a timely manner and without duplication. The domain of relational continuity, the focus of this article, involves the quality and coherence of the relationship produced between health care professionals/team and users 8,9.

The interdependence between the three domains is undeniable. It is argued that, although continuity is a multidimensional construct, it needs to be considered in the process of organizing health care services and, above all, in user experience 10. For users, family members and caregivers, continuity is perceived and facilitated when they receive support from professionals or teams that assume responsibility for therapeutic plans and offer support in the management of various resources (medicines, treatments, functioning of the health system) 11.

Relational continuity is positioned in the micro dimension of the health care system. It implies the establishment of lasting and personalized relationships between professionals/teams and users, as well as a holistic approach to health problems 4. It represents more than “having contact with the same doctor”, but rather a 2-way commitment based on mutual trust and the health care provider’s responsibility for their patients, whose intensity increases as the relationships become more stable and sustainable 10. From this perspective, continuity is close to the concept of “longitudinality” by incorporating the establishment of trust-based relationships over time with a provider recognized as a regular source of care 12.

Sidaway-Lee et al. 3 note that relational continuity has effects on health outcomes through mechanisms such as frequent contact, accumulated knowledge, sense of responsibility of the professional, quality of the relationship, trust, and empathy. Maintaining the same health care team favors such continuity, enabling relationships based on user needs (clinical, mental, social and environmental needs) and adequate access to available resources 13. Thus, it favors adherence to and trust in the guidance of professionals 11, who, in turn, with prolonged contact, develop a more comprehensive view of the care offered in the various health care services and the role of family members 4.

In Brazil, social inequality and difficulties in the operationalization of Health Care Networks (HCN) have effects on the continuity of care, which often depends on informal mechanisms adopted by users and family members 14. Brazilian studies 12,15,16 indicate weaknesses in the interpersonal relationship between users and professionals, possibly related to difficulties in accessing PHC. Even so, a set of strategies and tools for continuity of care were found, such as safe discharge, clinic management, case discussion, lines of care, case manager nurse, regulatory complexes and permanent education, although not necessarily implemented in the country 17. However, organizational arrangements that catalyze work processes in an interprofessional perspective for effective relational continuity and shared communicational flow remain little explored, especially in situations of health care gaps 18, conflicted territories 19 and for populations whose approach to health care requires higher cultural competence 20.

This article analyzes the continuity of care in the relational domain based on the experience of person living with HIV (PLH) whose care is centralized in a specialized service and users with systemic arterial hypertension (SAH) registered in basic health units (BHU). We seek to answer the following research question: considering different health care contexts (specialized services and BHUs), what factors favor or hinder relational continuity from the users’ perspective? Both conditions, due to their chronic nature, require continuous follow-up that contributes to adherence to individual and collective health care. It is argued that, despite technical advances, especially in biomedical technologies, relational factors continue to be important predictors of health outcomes even though, contradictorily, there is a decrease in the value attributed to personal contact between teams, professionals and users 1. In addition, comparing diversified experiences in different types of health care providers and conditions deepens the understanding of the continuity of care, which is one of the main contributions of this study. Accordingly, most analysis models and concepts are based on studies in high-income countries, contrasting with the reality of contexts with limited resources and high fragmentation, such as that of Brazil 14,21.

Methodology

Study type

This is a case study, with a qualitative approach, based on interviews with users diagnosed with SAH, registered by Family Health teams (FHTs), and PLH users followed-up in polyclinics. The participants’ care trajectories in the search for PHC health care to the other points of the HCN were reconstructed, including in the private sector. For this article, we traced and analyzed results that informed on the relational domain of continuity of care.

Study setting and participant selection criteria

The study setting was a municipality located in the state of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, with a population of approximately 500,000 inhabitants.

We conducted 38 face-to-face interviews with users with SAH, from February to July 2022, in 10 of the 43 BHUs; and 45 interviews with PLH, between December 2021 and June 2022, in the seven municipal specialty polyclinics that, in the study setting, are the main follow-up services.

The selection prioritized BHUs with 3 to 6 FHTs, distributed in the seven health regions, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, which reduced the flow of users, making it difficult to find them in services with fewer teams. In addition, the selection of BHUs with this profile considered the vacancy/exchange of professionals, resulting from a public service admission exam during the study period.

After selection of BHUs, possible participants were identified by the interviewers with the help of the respective FHT, according to the inclusion criteria: having a diagnosis of SAH and being registered by an FHT; request for referral by the PHC for consultation or specialized examination in the last 12 months prior to the interview (verified in the medical records or registration books); being 18 years old or older; and not presenting physical or psychological impairment impeding the interview, according to the evaluation of the FHT professionals. Based on this initial selection, which varied in each of the selected BHUs, potential participants were invited to attend the service or consulted about the possibility of conducting the interview at home.

Regarding PLH users, users linked to the seven municipal polyclinics were interviewed, based on the inclusion criteria: being 18 years old or older; residing in the municipality; with positive HIV testing for at least one year prior to the interview. Participants were identified, with the help of service professionals, and invited to participate during the wait or shortly after the consultation with the infectious disease specialist.

Data production

The interviews were conducted by previously trained researchers and adopted a semi-structured guide. Regarding the two health problems, the interview guide contained the following blocks: sociodemographic profile, habits and lifestyle, diagnosis discovery, care received in PHC and specialized care, other paths taken in the Brazilian Unified National Health System (SUS, acronym in Portuguese) and in the private network, care during the COVID-19 pandemic and general assessment of the care received. Continuity of care, as understood in this article, is the “amalgam” that favors the users’ perception of the care continuum and was addressed within the experiences of care at each health care level or service and in the transition between them. Interviews with SAH users, with an average of 30 minutes, and interviews with PLH, with an average of one hour, were recorded, transcribed in full for analysis and interpretation of the results. Data production was terminated based on the obtention of adequate and sufficient information to understand the phenomenon 22, composed of accounts of users of the seven health care areas of the municipality.

Data analysis

For the analysis of the results, general ordering of data was carried out. The transcripts were read exhaustively and the thematic nuclei were categorized based on the pre-established dimensions for relational continuity. The interpretation was guided by thematic content analysis, identifying convergences and divergences 23. In addition, the most representative excerpts were selected and distributed in the respective categories.

For the description and interpretation of the results, based on the reference of Haggerty et al. 8 and complementary references 3,4,10,11,21,24, dimensions linked to the domain of relational continuity - trust-based relationships and availability of personalized information - and their respective definitions were previously identified, presented in Box 1. Subsequently, the reports produced through the interviews were compared to the dimensions to define and adapt the actions/activities that compose the analysis matrix (Box 1).

Box 1
Dimensions, definition and actions/activities of relational continuity in user experience.

The proposed model, although it seeks to identify elements related to the domain of relational continuity, should be considered in the light of the relation between the other components - informational and managerial, since they are dependent and interrelated 18.

The study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the Human Sciences Institute , Fluminense Federal University (opinion n. 4,456,756), with the consent of the municipality. Participants were identified by acronym (PLH or SAH), number that corresponds to the interview and a letter assigned to each service - polyclinic in the case of HIV and BHU in the case of SAH.

Results

Respondent profile

Table 1 shows the profile of the study participants. Among the PLH, about half were men, the age group was concentrated between 41 and 60 years, with partners and children. The vast majority identified themselves as black and mixed-race (75.5%), with high school education (44.4%), family income of up to two monthly minimum wages (53.3%), and as home providers (53.3%). Among the 38 participants diagnosed with SAH, there was a predominance of females (76.3%), self-declared black and mixed-race (71%) and aged over 60 years (55.3%). Most of them were the main providers of the household (60.5%), with a family income of up to one monthly minimum wage (52.6%). Half of the participants with SAH (50%) received some type of social or social security benefit. In both groups, most did not have health insurance plans, especially among users with SAH, who also had lower income (Table 1).

Table 1
Characterization of study participants. Large municipality, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.

Trust-based relationship between health care providers/services and users

The FHT physician was the main reference for the follow-up of users with SAH over time, although due to the public selection that occurred at the time and the post-COVID-19 pandemic context, several professionals were no longer part of the teams. Users resented the changes and explained that “Here [BHU] there is no continuity for anything” (SAH/30/H). A significant set of participants reinforced the deleterious effects of health care provider turnover on the rupture of bonds and the abandonment of the search for the health care service (Box 2). In the same context of complaints about provider turnover, spontaneous accounts about the relationship established with Cuban doctors from the More Doctors Program who worked in some BHUs, until 2018, were recorded. Aspects defined as “kindness”, attention and integral view of the subject were related to satisfaction and the feeling of being cared for (Box 2).

Box 2
Trust-based relationship between health care providers/services and users - expressive accounts of participants. Large municipality, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.

Unequivocally, PLH indicated the infectious disease specialist as the main reference for monitoring health in general, and, in some cases, the only one. They highlighted the strength of the bond with the infectious disease doctor, recognized as the professional to whom “life was entrusted” (PLH/15/F). Mention was made of the care provided by nurses, in four of the seven services. The regularity in the pre-scheduling of appointments with the infectious disease specialist - quarterly or biannual - was pointed out by the PLH as favoring the bond and access. Most respondents considered themselves assiduous in appointments and recognized that, mainly, infectious disease specialists and nurses had an expanded understanding of their clinical and life histories. Although, at the time, there was also public selection for polyclinics professionals, turnover did not appear in an important way in the accounts, although some users were afraid of possible changes of professionals based on previous experiences (Box 2).

Community health workers (CHWs) were mentioned by users with SAH as an important reference for the intermediation of the demands presented to the BHU, communicating about the possibility of scheduling appointments, status of appointments for specialized services, results of exams, absence of professionals and updating of the registration (Box 2). In the case of PLH, there were no reports of bonds with CHWs. Just over half of the participants (26 PLH) reported having a BHU registration and only four reported using it regularly. When home visits occurred, they were commonly directed to family members with health problems and, rarely, to PLH. The activities reported were similar to those of users with SAH, but directed to other family members. In addition, the PLH pointed out the fear about the breach of diagnostic confidentiality as an obstacle to bonding with the CHWs (Box 2).

Subsequently, several participants with SAH cited nursing technicians as a reference, especially for procedures such as blood pressure measurement, anthropometry, capillary glycemia and care in BHUs. The nurse was referred to in a few cases, and clinical appointments for the management of SAH were not reported. Among the PLH, the nursing professional, in some polyclinics, had a role highlighted and valued by the participants in care and active search (telephone/message) in cases of absenteeism. These professionals organized the flow of internal care in the service, since some of these units had no fixed offices for appointments and users felt lost and exposed (Box 2).

Participants with SAH emphasized that clinical histories were lost due to physician turnover, which also broke the experience of “intimacy” (Box 2). In addition to the rupture of bonds, vacancy periods aggravated problems of access to PHC. The monitoring of SAH was restricted, and attempts to “fitting into schedule”, through spontaneous demand, were common. Several SAH users gave up seeking the BHU or sought other forms of care such as measuring blood pressure at home or seeking appointments and exams in low-cost health insurance plans (Box 2).

In the case of PLH, turnover did not appear significantly. Participants considered themselves linked to polyclinics and sought professionals for almost all health problems. There were very frequent reports of seeking an infectious disease specialist in situations such as influenza, hypertension control, among other needs. Several users presented to the infectious disease doctor prescriptions and results of tests prescribed by other professionals - from PHC, hospitals, emergency care units or specialists from the private network - for follow-up purposes or even for conduct review (Box 2).

SAH and PLH participants reported no strategies or actions that could constitute the construction of a singular therapeutic project (STP) between the FHT and polyclinics, with the participation of other health care providers or services. In polyclinics, despite the possibility of internal referrals to other specialists, there were no reports of STP production. The delegation of the function of communicating the respective clinical and life histories was under the responsibility of the users or family members, which required memory, understanding of all guidelines and prescriptions to transmit them in the various appointments, which generated dissatisfaction (Box 2).

Availability of personalized information

The primary source of information for SAH care was the physician. Some reports indicated that the trust necessary to clarify doubts or exchange information about health problems was established only with this professional. For PLH, infectious disease specialists and nurses played this role (Box 3).

Box 3
Personalized information - expressive accounts of participants. Large municipality, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2022.

Some SAH users felt comfortable talking about health problems with other FHT professionals, especially those with lower turnover. Regarding communication and familiarity, nursing technicians were noted as an important support for relationships and dialogs addressing issues beyond the health problem. When users perceived the absence of empathy in any type of health care service, they withdrew. In general, provider turnover and the COVID-19 pandemic affected the construction of dialogical relationships in PHC (Box 3). A recurring pattern in the accounts showed this perception: “I don’t even know who is here [BHU] now” (SAH/02/A).

The PLH mentioned the high number of appointments as one of the factors that made communication difficult, due to decreased available time. Few of them did not clearly understand examinations, adverse effects or recommended treatments and followed unrestrictedly the instructions of health care professionals, who guided important decisions in their lives. In addition, one participant, a travesti, considered the consultation time short to clarify doubts, for example, about adverse effects related to the use of antiretroviral therapy (ART) (Box 3).

Collective actions geared toward the production of health literacy and self-care in the health services were absent in the accounts of almost all participants. As SAH-related self-care practices, just over half reported monitoring blood pressure at home with the use of digital devices, without regularity. As for the PLH, they received instructions on eating and performing physical activities, at different frequencies between polyclinics. Several of them reported trying to adopt such instructions as a means of preventing diseases caused by the continuous use of antiretrovirals. Most of them had easy access to free prophylactics. There were common reports of association between the use of ART as self-care to ensure good health, long life, undetectable viral load and prevent sexual transmission (Box 3).

Although some of the users mentioned physicians, nursing technicians and CHWs as reference professionals for monitoring SAH, in different intensity, and infectious disease specialists and nurses in the case of PLH, this relationship was limited to clinical care provided in BHUs and polyclinics. There were few reports on guidance on SAH during CHW visits or through some collective or educational activity. In both cases - SAH and PLH -, individual approaches occurred during consultations and were highly valued by users (Box 3).

Three younger participants with SAH reported the internet as a source of health information. In disagreement, part of them reported difficulties in using it or lack of trust in the information. As for the PLH, half of them used the internet as an important source of health information on HIV/AIDS, with searches related to cure, vaccination, new therapies and scientific research, prejudice, food, among other topics. The others considered the infectious disease specialist, television, magazine, newspaper and friends - some, too, living with HIV - as reliable sources. Several of them reported consulting websites they considered reliable and the infectious disease doctor to avoid misinformation news. On the other hand, difficulties in accessing other health care professionals in the HCN caused procedures to be performed without adequate guidance based on information from the internet (Box 3).

No SAH or PLH participant mentioned institutional strategies or devices for receiving information. In the case of participants diagnosed with SAH, information on appointments or exams required a home visit of the CHW or, in many cases, consecutive visits to the BHU (Box 3). The participants did not identify formal communication channels (phone, message or email) for contact with a reference health care provider or service. This lack was a cause of complaint for some PLH, as they were not notified of canceled appointments or needed to reschedule them in person. In some polyclinics, there was such contact, conducted informally by nurses, through personal WhatsApp messages, with interruption when the professionals were replaced. The application was used as a communication channel by few infectious disease specialists for clinical guidance between consultations, on their own initiative.

Discussion

The findings reinforce the importance of relational technologies as predictors of health outcomes, comparing diversified user experiences in PHC and specialized care in order to trace, at both health care levels, factors that facilitate and hinder the achievement of continuity of care. The results indicate aspects that differentiate and approximate the different experiences. In common, trust-based relationships and protagonism in the conduction of health care trajectories were established with the FHT physician or infectious disease specialist. Among the differences, according to SAH users monitored in PHC, relationship bonds were broken by health care provider turnover. In the absence of relationships with other FHT professionals, continuity and access were simultaneously affected. Among the PLH, the most significant characteristic was the strong trust-based relationship built with the infectious disease doctor, who had higher stability in the health care service. In the cases of the two conditions, the results showed a care with little concern for interprofessional practices and collective actions to strengthen continuity. Anyway, the study results indicate that relational continuity is important, and that it is highly valued by users.

The health-disease process has an unnatural history 25, whose sharing with the health care professional is part of the construction of trust-based relationships, which go beyond biological aspects 26. Accordingly, conditions permeated by stigma and prejudice, such as HIV, that determine inequalities of different orders - gender-related, social, among others 27 -, when shared with the professionals, can represent an important warning sign for changes in their practices, which often make invisible such dimensions of the health-disease-care process 28.

Trust is a psychological construct that influences health behaviors related to adherence to guidelines, prescribed medications and preventive measures 29, which are essential in the management of chronic conditions. Consultations with the same provider help develop a relationship of trust and reliability while unfamiliar settings and providers can generate anxiety and stress 3,4. Despite an a priori institutional trustworthiness granted to physicians, it can be limited and weakened by several factors 3, as observed in the experiences of SAH users, affected by the turnover of providers.

In addition, continuity enables health care providers to understand patient hopes, fears and desires, thus improving their clinical and personal skills 3, as seemingly indicated by the experience of PLH and not observed in the case of SAH users due to health care provider turnover. Consistently, when a health care provider learns about their patient, they increase their ability to perceive non-obvious or non-verbally expressed needs, to provide better care in emergencies, in addition to minimizing the repetition of the clinical and life history at each new meeting, an aspect that provides improved security and trust to users 4,30. The repetition of the clinical history at each new meeting, as found in the experience of people with SAH, is a cause of major dissatisfaction 31. Accordingly, to ensure care consistency and improve patient experience, it is necessary that clinical information is shared among health professionals in a timely manner 32, which can be delayed by the repetitive recording of the same information.

As mentioned, all the possibilities of strengthening the different dimensions of relational continuity lose power in the face of health care provider turnover, especially physician turnover, an issue not addressed in work management in SUS 33 and present in the most diverse contexts pari passu to the growth of PHC services 4. In addition to continuity, turnover compromises access to health care services, because, due to the expectation of non-provision of services, users no longer seek them 34, as found in the experience of people with SAH in this study.

Health care provider turnover made difficult the monitoring of users with SAH, even though care remained excessively centered on the physician. Other providers, such as nursing technicians and CHWs, had a secondary role, limited to mediating access, especially by scheduling appointments and exams and performing procedures. Thus, even when present in the health care setting, the other functions were subsumed to the biomedical logic 35.

No less relevant, in the case of PLH and SAH users, was the secondary role attributed to the work of nursing professionals in the sharing of clinical health care. Nurses in transitional care programs reduce re-hospitalizations, costs and improve the quality of life of people with chronic diseases 36. In addition, they work in the coordination and continuity of care, planning post-discharge care, coordinating points of care, conducting health education activities, managing complex cases, evaluating clinical and social aspects, and facilitating users’ navigation through health care services 12,14. From this perspective, promoting multiprofessional care both in PHC and specialized care, with protagonism of the role of nurses 37, seems to be a means to strengthen the coordination of care in the HCN and contribute to the users’ perception of continuity.

The bond with nursing professionals in hospitality was highly valued, especially among PLH and SAH users. As a soft care technology 38, hospitality favored adherence to treatment and the feeling of being cared for. The Cuban doctors’ approach was noted for the “kindness” and comprehensiveness, reinforcing the importance of these skills for the bond and continuity of care 13,39 and that, therefore, they cannot be considered secondary.

Health literacy is a multidimensional process that encompasses individual and collective skills to seek, evaluate and interpret health-related information, for self-care or the care of others 40. In the study with PLH, infectious disease specialists centralized the management of information crucial to the health of users. People with SAH also valued the centrality of physicians, even though the bonds were weakened. In both groups, individual consultations were the main space for health guidance, although this space is recognized by the asymmetry of power and in which the expectation for the resolution of health problems is directed to health care providers 10. Collective health education practices 40, or even external ones, during the visit of CHWs, could be strategic to expand literacy from a perspective that would include diverse experiences, with sharing of knowledge and care practices.

The availability of personalized information is essential for relational continuity and maintains a direct relation with the informational domain. However, the absence of information and communication technologies (ICT), as found in this study, makes it difficult to provide person-centered care. ICTs have potential to improve the quality, sharing and accessibility of information for users, such as by minimizing the need for in-person visits 41.

Relational continuity strengthens security and avoids the repetition of clinical histories, facilitating navigation in the health care system 30. This study found no formal strategies, such as STP, to enable the contact and sharing of therapeutic plans between users and professionals of the HCN, with predominance of informal initiatives. These aspects concomitantly indicate weaknesses in the domains of managerial and informational continuity. In these cases, although patients and family members are assigned the position of single link between different points of care with the mission of facilitating continuity of care, this responsibility does not come with the necessary skills or confidence 42.

The results of this study confirm that continuity cannot be analyzed while assuming that other attributes of health care systems and services have been fully achieved. A broad understanding that can be translated into policies, actions and practices to achieve continuity requires a consideration of the global context, especially with regard to access to and quality of health care 21.

As limits of the study, it is noted that the complexity inherent in the care of people with complex needs requires mechanisms at the individual level that ensure relational continuity, as well as actions within the organizational scope of the health care system that are capable of mitigating health care fragmentation and that were not the focus of this study. Ensuring informational and managerial continuity is part of this broad set of strategies, which are not directly addressed in this article, albeit interrelated. In any case, it is argued that the diversity of experiences, based on the context of the participants in different sets of care, provide a dense analysis of the situation, which does not exclude other experiences and interpretations.

Final considerations

At the interface between the population and the health care system, health care providers must conduct their practice centered on the person in order to enable a relationship of therapeutic trust and reciprocity. The results of this article indicate the importance of a regular point of care for achievement of the bond and consequent relational continuity. On the other hand, health care work management-related issues contribute to health care provider turnover and sequential disruptions in therapeutic follow-up with detrimental impacts on all - users, professionals and managers. It is also argued that continuity of care needs to be transversal to the HCN and is strengthened as multiprofessional teams are involved in the production of coherent, coordinated therapeutic projects in synergy with the needs and interests of users. In the case of chronic and long-term diseases, the loss of relational continuity compromises adherence and loyalty, leading to reaggravations, abandonment of treatment, withdrawal from seeking care or seeking private and emergency care services, thereby increasing inequalities among more vulnerable groups.

Acknowledgments

The study was funded by the Applied Project Development Program (PDPA), a partnership between the Municipality of Niterói and the Fluminense Federal University. P. F. Almeida and A. M. Santos are Research Productivity fellows from the Brazilian National Research Council.

References

  • 1 Pereira Gray DJ, Sidaway-Lee K, White E, Thorne A, Evans PH. Continuity of care with doctors-a matter of life and death? A systematic review of continuity of care and mortality. BMJ Open 2018; 8:e021161.
  • 2 Baker R, Freeman GK, Haggerty JL, Bankart MJ, Nockels KH. Primary medical care continuity and patient mortality: a systematic review. Br J Gen Pract 2020; 70:e600-11.
  • 3 Sidaway-Lee K, Pereira Gray D, Harding A, Evans P. What mechanisms could link GP relational continuity to patient outcomes? Br J Gen Pract 2021; 71:278-81.
  • 4 Ljungholm L, Edin-Liljegren A, Ekstedt M, Klinga C. What is needed for continuity of care and how can we achieve it? Perceptions among multiprofessionals on the chronic care trajectory. BMC Health Serv Res 2022; 22:686.
  • 5 Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. Realising the potential of primary health care. https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/realising-the-potential-of-primary-health-care_a92adee4-en.html (accessed on 15/Apr/2024).
    » https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/realising-the-potential-of-primary-health-care_a92adee4-en.html
  • 6 Brand S, Pollock K. How is continuity of care experienced by people living with chronic kidney disease? J Clin Nurs 2018; 27:153-61.
  • 7 González-Ortiz LG, Calciolari S, Goodwin N, Stein V. The core dimensions of integrated care: a literature review to support the development of a comprehensive framework for implementing integrated care. Int J Integr Care 2018; 18:10.
  • 8 Haggerty JL, Reid RJ, Freeman GK, Starfield BH, Adair CE, McKendry R. Continuity of care: a multidisciplinary review. BMJ 2003; 327:1219-21.
  • 9 Uijen AA, Schers HJ, Schellevis FG, van den Bosch WJHM. How unique is continuity of care? A review of continuity and related concepts. Fam Pract 2012; 29:264-71.
  • 10 Hill KM, Twiddy M, Hewison J, House AO. Measuring patient-perceived continuity of care for patients with long-term conditions in primary care. BMC Fam Pract 2014; 15:191.
  • 11 Ljungholm L, Klinga C, Edin-Liljegren A, Ekstedt M. What matters in care continuity on the chronic care trajectory for patients and family carers? A conceptual model. J Clin Nurs 2022; 31:1327-38.
  • 12 Maciel AMM, Lettiere-Viana A, Mishima SM, Fermino TZ, Matumoto S. The longitudinality of care from the perspective of family health users. Rev Esc Enferm USP 2024; 58:e20240051.
  • 13 World Health Organization. Continuity and coordination of care: a practice brief to support implementation of the WHO Framework on integrated people-centred health services. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241514033 (accessed on 01/Apr/2024).
    » https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241514033
  • 14 Santos MT, Halberstadt BMK, Trindade CRP, Lima MADS, Aued GK. Continuity and coordination of care: conceptual interface and nurses' contributions. Rev Esc Enferm USP 2022; 56:e20220100.
  • 15 Ribeiro AMVB, Vilasbôas ALQ, Almeida PF. Experiences of access and use of primary health care by users with systemic arterial hypertension. Rev Esc Enferm USP 2024; 58:e20240109.
  • 16 Acylino EM, Almeida PF, Hoffmann LMA. Acesso e continuidade assistencial na busca por cuidado em saúde: tecendo a rede entre encontros e entrelaços. Physis (Rio J.) 2021; 31:e310123.
  • 17 Belga SMMF, Jorge AO, Silva KL. Continuidade do cuidado a partir do hospital: interdisciplinaridade e dispositivos para integralidade na rede de atenção à saúde. Saúde Debate 2022; 46:551-70.
  • 18 Santos AM, Giovanella L, Fausto MCR, Cabral LMS, Almeida PF. Dinâmica da regionalização e repercussões dos vazios assistenciais na comercialização da saúde em municípios rurais remotos. Cad Saúde Pública 2024; 40:e00194523.
  • 19 Costa VC, Baptista TWF, Cunha MB. O SUS em territórios vulnerabilizados: reflexões sobre violência, sofrimento mental e invisibilidades nas favelas do Rio de Janeiro. Saúde Debate 2022; 46:974-86.
  • 20 Müller MR, Lima RC, Ortega F. Repensando a competência cultural nas práticas de saúde no Brasil: por um cuidado culturalmente sensível. Saúde Soc 2023; 32:e210731.
  • 21 Meiqari L, Al-Oudat T, Essink D, Scheele F, Wright P. How have researchers defined and used the concept of 'continuity of care' for chronic conditions in the context of resource-constrained settings? A scoping review of existing literature and a proposed conceptual framework. Health Res Policy Syst 2019; 17:27.
  • 22 Martínez-Salgado C. Amostra e transferibilidade: como escolher os participantes em pesquisas qualitativas em saúde? In: Bosi MLM, Gastaldo D, editors. Tópicos avançados em pesquisa qualitativa em saúde: fundamentos teórico-metodológicos. Petrópolis: Editora Vozes; 2021. p. 170-201.
  • 23 Eakin JM, Gladstone B. Na caixa-preta da análise qualitativa: dar sentido aos dados com uma abordagem que "agrega valor". In: Bosi MLM, Gastaldo D, editors. Tópicos avançados em pesquisa qualitativa em saúde: fundamentos teórico-metodológicos. Petrópolis: Editora Vozes; 2021. p. 202-36.
  • 24 Nóbrega VM, Silva MEA, Fernandes LTB, Viera CS, Reichert APS, Collet N. Chronic disease in childhood and adolescence: continuity of care in the Health Care Network. Rev Esc Enferm USP 2017; 51:e03226.
  • 25 Rocha PR, David HMSL. Determinação ou determinantes? Uma discussão com base na Teoria da Produção Social da Saúde. Rev Esc Enferm USP 2015; 49:129-35.
  • 26 Franco TB, Hubner LCM. Clínica, cuidado e subjetividade: afinal, de que cuidado estamos falando? Saúde Debate 2019; 43(n.esp 6):93-103.
  • 27 Silva LAV, Duarte FM, Magno L, Dourado I, Squire C. Moral barriers to HIV prevention and care for gay and bisexual men: challenges in times of conservatism in Brazil. Sociol Health Illn 2021; 43:424-40.
  • 28 Santos AM, Magno L, Anjos EF, Porto JP, Barroso RRF, Araújo MPN, et al. Quality of nursing care perceived by people with HIV in Brazil: a cross-sectional study. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care 2023; 35:40-50.
  • 29 Parchman ML, Burge SK. The patient-physician relationship, primary care attributes, and preventive services. Fam Med 2004; 36:22-7.
  • 30 Palmer B, Hemmings N, Rosen R, Keeble E, Williams S, Paddison C, et al. Improving access and continuity in general practice: evidence review. https://www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/research/improving-access-and-continuity-in-general-practice (accessed on 22/Feb/2024).
    » https://www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/research/improving-access-and-continuity-in-general-practice
  • 31 Rhodes P, Sanders C, Campbell S. Relationship continuity: when and why do primary care patients think it is safer? Br J Gen Pract 2014; 64:e758-64.
  • 32 Prior A, Vestergaard CH, Vedsted P, Smith SM, Virgilsen LF, Rasmussen LA, et al. Healthcare fragmentation, multimorbidity, potentially inappropriate medication, and mortality: a Danish nationwide cohort study. BMC Med 2023; 21:305.
  • 33 Cury GC, Fonseca AF. A retomada do Programa Mais Médicos em 2023. Trab Educ Saúde 2023; 21:e02415229.
  • 34 Dantas MNP, Souza DLB, Souza AMG, Aiquoc KM, Souza TA, Barbosa IR. Fatores associados ao acesso precário aos serviços de saúde no Brasil. Rev Bras Epidemiol 2021; 24:e210004.
  • 35 Silva TWM, Velloso ISC, Araújo MT, Fernandes ARK. Configuration of power relations in physicians and nurses' professional practices. Rev Bras Enferm 2020; 73 Suppl 1:e20180629.
  • 36 Coors M, Schüttig W, Reber KC, Darius H, Holzgreve A, Karmann S, et al. Cost-effectiveness and cost-utility analysis of a nurse-led, transitional care model to improve care coordination for patients with cardiovascular diseases: results from the "Cardiolotse" study. Eur J Health Econ 2024; [Online ahead of print].
  • 37 Sousa MF, Alvarenga JPO, Guimarães RCP. Práticas de enfermagem na atenção primária à saúde no Brasil: conjugações singulares e plurais. Brasília: Editora EcoS; 2023.
  • 38 Rollo AA, Campos GWS. Atenção aos pacientes crônicos na APS: ir onde o povo está, conversar, versar, fazer conversação, com verso e ações. In: Guedes F, Campos GWS, Terra L, Viana MO, editors. Nas entrelinhas da atenção primária à saúde. São Paulo: Hucitec Editora; 2021. p. 234-51.
  • 39 Ventura F, Moreira IMPB, Raposo V, Queirós PJP, Mendes A. A prática centrada na pessoa: da idiossincrasia do cuidar à inovação em saúde. Cad Saúde Pública 2022; 38:e00278121.
  • 40 Peres F. Alfabetização, letramento ou literacia em saúde? Traduzindo e aplicando o conceito de health literacy no Brasil. Ciênc Saúde Colet 2023; 28:1563-73.
  • 41 Pal DS, Pal M. Importance of information and communication technology (ICT) in healthcare department - a literature review. Int J Innov Sci Res Technol 2023; 8:1169-72.
  • 42 Coleman EA. Falling through the cracks: challenges and opportunities for improving transitional care for persons with continuous complex care needs. J Am Geriatr Soc 2003; 51:549-55.

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    18 July 2025
  • Date of issue
    2025

History

  • Received
    17 June 2024
  • Reviewed
    01 Feb 2025
  • Accepted
    25 Mar 2025
location_on
Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública Sergio Arouca, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz Rua Leopoldo Bulhões, 1480 , 21041-210 Rio de Janeiro RJ Brazil, Tel.:+55 21 2598-2511, Fax: +55 21 2598-2737 / +55 21 2598-2514 - Rio de Janeiro - RJ - Brazil
E-mail: cadernos@ensp.fiocruz.br
rss_feed Acompanhe os números deste periódico no seu leitor de RSS
Ir para o topo Reportar erro