Open-access Open Educational Resources in Education in Cape Verde

ABSTRACT

This study analyses the use of Open Digital Educational Resources (ODER) in secondary education in Cape Verde, with a view to identifying the main challenges encountered in implementing the solutions proposed by the DNE regarding the use of digital educational resources at ESML, and presents recommendations for improving the use of digital educational resources. The case study was carried out at Manuel Lopes Secondary School, involving teachers, the headteacher and the National Directorate of Education. The study concludes that, in order to maximise the benefits of REDA in secondary education, greater investment is needed in infrastructure, teacher training and the development of content aligned with the country’s educational needs.

Keywords
Digital Competences; Education; Training; Digital Resources

RESUMO

O estudo analisa o uso de Recursos Educativos Digitais Abertos (REDA) no ensino secundário em Cabo Verde, com o objetivo de identificar os principais desafios encontrados na implementação das soluções propostas pela DNE em relação a utilização dos recursos educativos digitais na ESML e apresentar as recomendações para melhoria da utilização dos recursos educativos digitais. O estudo de caso foi realizado na Escola Secundária Manuel Lopes, envolvendo docentes, o diretor e a Direção-Geral da Educação. O estudo conclui que, para maximizar os benefícios dos REDA no ensino secundário, é necessário um maior investimento nas infraestruturas, capacitação de professores e desenvolvimento de conteúdos alinhados às necessidades educativas do país.

Palavras-chave
Competências Digitais; Educação; Formação; Recursos Digitais

Introduction

The growing digitisation of education and the use of educational technologies have been discussed as promising avenues for improving the quality of education. In Cape Verde, initiatives relating to Open Educational Resources (OER) are being implemented with the aim of facilitating access to knowledge, thereby promoting a more inclusive and interactive education.

As part of the distance learning project, implemented in 2020 in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, there was an urgent need to adapt all ongoing plans and projects of the National Directorate of Education (DNE), thereby embracing the distance learning model (DNE, 2020).

In line with this approach, the DNE, through the Education Multimedia Service (SME), planned a set of support materials for teachers using distance teaching and learning training, drawing on digital educational resources from the previous programme to promote ICT in primary and secondary education. Of particular note is the use of the Moodle platform, social media, and tools from Google and Microsoft to facilitate teaching and learning experiences outside the classroom and school setting.

The aim of the training was, therefore, to provide support to schools in developing distance learning methodologies. To this end, a two-week online workshop was held, which was asynchronous and of a theoretical and practical nature.

As reported by the DNE (2020), the main target audience comprised headteachers of schools or school clusters, form tutors, ICT coordinators and SIGE focal points from each institution. These leaders played an essential role in supporting teachers in choosing the most appropriate distance learning (DL) tool for their schools.

Consequently, we found that there are many challenges to implementing the remote system, as it is necessary to ensure equitable access to ICT, overcoming socio-economic, geographical and educational inequalities through government initiatives and partnerships, so that we may thereby improve education.

To mitigate the negative impacts of inequality in access to internet-connected devices (such as computers, tablets and smartphones), the Cape Verdean government, through the Ministry of Education, launched the ‘Learning and Studying at Home’ educational programme in April 2020. This programme, created as an emergency response during the lockdown, offers pre-recorded lessons broadcast on television, radio and a YouTube channel, ensuring the continuity of the teaching and learning process and keeping pupils connected to educational content. According to the Ministry of Education’s study (2021), the programme broadcasts 30- to 40-minute lessons on television and radio, with replays on YouTube, following a timetable based on core content from the National Curricula and Textbooks for Years 1 to 8 and selected subjects from secondary education. In addition, printed study sheets were distributed, particularly to pupils in remote areas on the islands of Santo Antão and Fogo.

The adoption of such tools in secondary education still faces challenges that undermine their full effectiveness.

This article aims to investigate these challenges through a case study at the Manuel Lopes Secondary School (ESML), located in Cape Verde. Within this context, the research specifically seeks to identify the main obstacles encountered in implementing the solutions proposed by the National Directorate of Education (DNE) regarding the use of digital educational resources. Furthermore, it aims to present concrete recommendations for improving the use of these resources in the school, based on the evidence gathered during the study. The research contributes to the improvement of teaching practices through the adoption of digital technologies, providing insights for reflection and the continuous improvement of secondary education in Cape Verde.

Literature Review

Digital educational resources

In a context characterised by rapid technological advancement – which exerts a growing influence on social dynamics – and by the continuous expansion of access to digital technologies, it is essential to reflect critically on the challenges faced by professionals committed to improving the quality of outcomes in the education sector. This commitment to enhancing educational processes and outcomes has been the focus of attention and dedication over several years, as highlighted by Ramos and Ferreira (2011, p. 11).

According to the aforementioned study, the wide variety of digital educational tools available in the contemporary context has sparked growing interest and curiosity among both teachers and students regarding their integration into the classroom environment.

According to Graziela (2022), the use of Digital Educational Resources (DER) in the school context can be understood as an enriching element of the teaching and learning process, functioning as a pedagogical resource capable of enhancing the presentation and understanding of different content. Given that today’s students, often characterised as digital natives, maintain constant contact with technological devices — such as smartphones — and demonstrate high levels of familiarity with digital technologies, teaching methodologies centred exclusively on oral presentations and the writing of content on the blackboard tend to be less effective in fostering engagement and motivation.

In this regard, the integration of Digital Educational Resources (DER) into the educational process can be seen as a way of aligning teaching strategies with students’ language and socio-technological practices. The resources, contente, and interactive possibilities offered by these tools help to make the topics covered more appealing and meaningful, which can encourage student engagement and, consequently, enhance their academic performance.

Digital Educational Resources (DERs) are widely recognised as tools that contribute to pedagogical mediation in the teaching and learning process. According to Wilev (2000), cited by Medeiros et al. (2018), DERs can be understood, in general terms, as tools and instruments used to support and stimulate educational activities.

In the same vein, Hokama (2016) highlights that digital educational resources act as means of broadening access to knowledge, as they enable the integration of different forms of information representation, such as visual, audio, textual, animated, or multimodal content. This diversity of formats allows for the creation of multimedia resources that are widely used by teachers and students within the educational process.

Based on these approaches, digital educational resources can be understood as pedagogical tools, materials, or content developed with the support of digital technologies, the purpose of which is to support and enrich teaching and learning processes. These resources can be applied at different educational levels and in various contexts, ranging from primary and secondary education to higher education and vocational training. Furthermore, they aim to facilitate access to knowledge and promote more interactive, dynamic and personalised learning experiences, enabling the adoption of diverse pedagogical strategies that cater to different learning styles.

Digital educational platforms for the classroom

During the pandemic, numerous organisations and educational institutions began to adopt remote learning (e-learning). In the face of these challenging circumstances, this approach proved to be the safest and most effective alternative for ensuring the continuity of the educational process. It is essential to have the right tools to ensure that staff, trainers, students and teachers remain connected and have access to the necessary educational resources1 .

Below, we present some educational tools available online for e-learning, which may be considered to provide the best learning experience for students (Colman, 2021).

Learning Management Systems (LMS)

Learning Management Systems (LMS) are software platforms designed to manage, document, monitor, report on, and deliver educational courses or training programmes.

Colman (2021, n.p.) points out that:

To facilitate the efficient distribution of course material to students, it is essential to adopt a Learning Management System (LMS). Unlike traditional methods such as emails and chat messages, an LMS not only simplifies the administration of educational content but also automates tasks such as assessments, statistical analysis, and report generation. With a wide variety of e-learning platforms available, the choice of the most suitable one is at the user’s discretion (n.p.).

We emphasise that digital tools play a crucial role in improving teaching and learning within the classroom. They facilitate the creation and presentation of content more interactively, providing more accurate feedback on students’ understanding of the topics covered

Based on the research by Colman (2021) and Hart (2023), as well as other relevant sources and the author’s teaching experience, it is possible to draw up a concise summary of the main digital educational platforms. These platforms are categorised according to their suitability for distance learning and made available to teachers for training and exploration.

Table 1
Learning Management Systems (LMS)

The table presented here systematises a set of educational tools designed to support teaching practice in a school context, in line with one of the previously defined objectives. However, the selection of a Learning Management System (LMS) should not be viewed as a purely technical or instrumental process, but rather as a strategic decision that requires consideration of the specific characteristics of the educational context, including pedagogical, institutional and technological factors.

In this regard, although these systems offer a diverse range of features and solutions, each has its own potential and limitations that determine its applicability. It is therefore essential to carry out a critical and contextualised analysis that goes beyond the superficial characteristics of the platforms, in order to ensure an informed choice that is consistent with the real needs of the teaching and learning process and with the intended pedagogical objectives.

Content creation tools

Content creation tools play a central role in supporting contemporary teaching practice, as they enable teachers to design and develop more effective, interactive and pedagogically relevant teaching materials. In addition to facilitating the organisation and presentation of information, these tools contribute to the diversification of teaching strategies, promoting greater engagement and autonomy on the part of learners.

In this context, some of the main categories of content creation tools are presented below, along with their respective uses, based on established research and relevant academic references.

Table 2
Content Creation Tools

Video and multimedia resources

Video and multimedia resources play a central role in the design and development of audiovisual productions and multimodal projects. These resources relate not only to the presence of visual elements, but above all to the way in which they are structured, organised and presented within a scene, significantly influencing the construction of meaning and communicative effectiveness. In an educational context, such organisation proves particularly relevant, in that it enhances pedagogical mediation and contributes consistently to improving the teaching and learning process.

Based on an analysis of various studies and theoretical references, combined with the author’s empirical experience, the main elements were systematically organised, resulting in the table set out below:

Table 3
Video and multimedia resources

Communication and collaboration tools

Communication and collaboration tools play a fundamental role in the efficiency and productivity of teams, particularly in contemporary organisational contexts characterised by increasing digitalisation, decentralisation and the demand for flexibility. More than mere operational tools, these solutions constitute socio-technical infrastructures that shape work dynamics, influence decision-making processes and reshape hierarchical and collaborative relationships.

In this sense, such tools encompass a diverse range of applications and technologies that enable information sharing, real-time co-authoring and task coordination. However, it is important to adopt a critical perspective: their effectiveness does not depend solely on technical features, but also on factors such as users’ digital literacy, organisational culture and suitability for the specific needs of teams. Furthermore, the intensive use of these platforms can introduce additional challenges, including information overload, fragmented communication and technological dependency.

Thus, whilst communication and collaboration tools are often presented as catalysts for productivity, their implementation and use require a critical and contextualised analysis in order to maximise their benefits and mitigate potential limitations.

Table 4
Communication and collaboration tools

Repository of educational resources

An educational resource repository can be conceptualised as a structured digital infrastructure aimed at the systematic organisation, storage and dissemination of teaching and learning materials. Beyond a simple archiving function, these environments play a strategic role in the mediation of knowledge, by enabling the curation, reuse and adaptation of content in different educational contexts.

It is important to note that, whilst widely used by teachers, trainers and students to access and share lesson plans, presentations, videos and other resources, the effectiveness of these repositories depends on factors such as the academic quality of the materials made available, the validation criteria adopted and the degree of pedagogical contextualisation. The absence of rigorous evaluation mechanisms may compromise the reliability of the content and limit its impact on the teaching and learning process.

Furthermore, the use of these digital platforms raises issues relating to users’ digital literacy and accessibility, as well as open access policies and copyright, aspects which directly influence equity in access to knowledge.

Based on the literature review and the author’s experience, two repositories of educational resources considered relevant to the context analysed are presented below:

Table 5
Repository of educational resources

Assessment and feedback

Below are two assessment and feedback tools that can be used by teachers in the classroom, aimed not only at assessing pupils’ performance but also at promoting critical reflection on teaching and learning processes.

Table 6
Assessment and feedback

Accessibility and inclusion

Accessibility and inclusion are fundamental principles for guaranteeing equal opportunities, ensuring that individuals with different physical and cognitive abilities can participate fully and effectively in society. This implies not only access to infrastructure, transport, technology and, in particular, education, but also the removal of social and cultural barriers that limit such participation. In this context, tools for accessibility and inclusion play a central role in democratising access to knowledge and the education system, contributing to the creation of a fairer and more equitable society. Two representative tools from this field are presented below.

Table 7
Accessibility and inclusion

Classroom management tools

Classroom management tools consist of a set of resources and teaching strategies employed by the teacher to structure, regulate and optimise the learning environment. In addition to their organisational function, these tools play a crucial role in promoting discipline, encouraging active student participation and ensuring the effectiveness of the teaching and learning process. Based on the author’s experience, combined with relevant theoretical contributions, two of these tools are summarised in the table below.

Table 8
Classroom management tools

In the tables presented above, various digital educational tools aimed at the training and professional development of secondary school teachers have been identified and categorised, to promote a more effective integration of these technologies into everyday teaching practices. The incorporation of these tools into the school environment has been widely recognised as a key factor in the modernisation of teaching and learning processes, as well as in strengthening teachers’ digital skills.

Based on the information summarised in the aforementioned tables and drawing on the theoretical contributions of Correia and Silva (2018), the tools were organised into analytical categories that address the pedagogical and technological needs of teachers in the development of digital teaching. This categorisation allows for a more structured understanding of the potential of each resource, facilitating its strategic selection and use within the educational process. In this regard, with the aim of broadening knowledge and fostering the adoption of digital technologies designed to improve communication and interaction in the learning process of secondary school pupils, the tables initially presented were reorganised and expanded.

Among the resources considered, particular attention is drawn to tools associated with virtual teaching and learning environments, which are widely discussed in the specialist literature and frequently used in contemporary educational contexts. Such environments are characterised by interfaces that facilitate pedagogical interaction, the sharing of information and the collaborative construction of knowledge, constituting digital spaces that foster new forms of didactic mediation.

Furthermore, an analysis of the resources described shows that these educational tools played a central role in the process of adapting to and implementing distance learning, particularly in educational emergency situations. The functional diversity of these resources made it possible to meet the varied needs of teachers and students, contributing to the promotion of digital inclusion and the maintenance of pedagogical continuity. In addition to ensuring the delivery of educational activities during periods of remote and blended learning, these technologies have also acted as catalysts for pedagogical innovation by providing resources that support teachers’ adaptation to the new demands of the digital learning ecosystem.

From a critical perspective, it can be observed that, whilst such tools significantly expand the possibilities for pedagogical mediation and access to knowledge, their effectiveness depends on structural and training-related factors, such as teachers’ level of digital literacy, the available technological infrastructure and institutional policies supporting educational innovation. Thus, the appropriate use of these technologies can help teachers to continue delivering high-quality education, regardless of the mode of delivery adopted — face-to-face, remote or hybrid — provided this is accompanied by training and pedagogical strategies that ensure their critical and contextualised integration into the educational process.

Methodology

Methodological choices

To address the research problem and achieve the proposed objectives, this study adopted a mixed-methods approach, combining qualitative and quantitative procedures within a descriptive and exploratory research design. The use of mixed methods is justified by their ability to combine the interpretative depth that characterises qualitative approaches with the explanatory and generalisable power provided by quantitative data (Creswell; Plano Clark, 2018). This methodological integration allows for a more holistic understanding of the dynamics of Digital Educational Learning Networks (REDA) and digital inclusion practices in the Cape Verdean context.

Empirical data were collected through structured and semi-structured surveys, administered both in face-to-face interviews and via an online questionnaire distributed through the Google Forms platform. This combination of instruments enabled us to obtain detailed insights into the use of REDA, the barriers and opportunities associated with digital inclusion, as well as the everyday practices of the various stakeholders involved in the educational process.

The theoretical framework was developed on the basis of an exhaustive literature review, drawing on a variety of academic and institutional sources. Books, scientific articles, dissertations, theses and official documents were consulted, drawn from international and national repositories and databases, with the aim of providing a theoretical underpinning for the main categories of analysis: Digital Educational Learning Networks, digital inclusion, equity in access to educational technologies and digital skills.

In the context of REDA, authors such as Siemens (2005) and Downes (2007) are fundamental to understanding the theoretical foundations of learning networks as distributed and open structures that mediate interactions, the co-construction of knowledge, and connectivity amongst learners. According to Siemens (2005), learning occurs as a process of connection between nodes of information within a technological and social ecosystem — a definition that underpins the understanding of REDA as complex socio-technical environments.

The discussion on digital inclusion is enriched by the work of Warschauer (2003; 2011), who challenges the simplistic notion of technological access and proposes analysing digital inclusion through multiple dimensions: material (physical access to devices and connectivity), skills, and effective use for meaningful social participation. In this sense, digital inclusion is not merely instrumental, but involves socio-cultural and economic factors that influence individuals’ ability to transform technological access into relevant educational practices.

Authors such as Selwyn (2010) and van Dijk (2006) emphasise that digital disparities persist even in contexts with expanding technological infrastructure, highlighting that the mere provision of devices or platforms does not eliminate inequalities unless accompanied by educational policies, teacher training and the development of critical digital literacy. Van Dijk (2006), in particular, distinguishes between different ‘digital divides’—material, motivational, usage and skills-based—which provide a useful analytical framework for interpreting the empirical data of this study.

Documentary research, understood here as a method for collecting and analysing secondary data, involves the systematic gathering of information from written, visual or multimodal documents, with the aim of extracting empirical evidence capable of shedding light on the phenomenon under study (Fachin, 2005). This approach enabled the identification of conceptual terms, theoretical trends and established empirical evidence, providing a robust framework for interpreting the empirical results relating to REDA practices and digital inclusion.

A critical analysis of the literature reveals that, whilst REDA networks have the potential to foster collaborative, flexible and personalised learning environments, their effectiveness depends on structural and pedagogical factors. Aspects such as adequate technological infrastructure, ongoing teacher training, public policies on digital inclusion and students’ digital skills repeatedly emerge as preconditions for the meaningful and equitable adoption of these networks. This is consistent with the observations of Eynon & Malmberg (2021), who highlight the need to rethink digital educational practices not merely as tools, but as socio-technical spaces integrated into curricular and social dynamics.

Thus, digital inclusion is understood not merely as physical access to technology, but as the ability to engage critically with and through digital mediations, contributing to the democratisation of knowledge and the promotion of educational justice. In this sense, the theoretical approach adopted provides a solid framework for interpreting the empirical evidence collected and for situating the results of this study within contemporary debates on educational technology, equity and human development.

Ethical principles

To investigate the problem and achieve the proposed objectives, this study adopted a mixed-methods approach, combining qualitative and quantitative methods of a descriptive and exploratory nature. Data collection was carried out through surveys, including face-to-face interviews and an online questionnaire made available via Google Forms, enabling methodological triangulation that reinforces the validity of the results.

The theoretical framework was based on a comprehensive literature review, drawing on materials from different periods and sources, such as digital repositories, scientific databases, books, articles, dissertations, theses, and official documents from Cape Verde. The careful selection of these documents sought to ensure the relevance and credibility of the evidence used to underpin the study’s theoretical framework.

Furthermore, documentary research constituted the primary method for obtaining information, enabling the critical analysis of previously recorded data—whether written, visual or oral—with the aim of understanding the phenomenon under study. As Fachin (2005) points out, documentary research makes it possible to explore diverse sources, providing a solid basis for the interpretation and contextualisation of the results.

Data collection technique

Data collection is a crucial stage in any research, as it is at this point that the essential information required to underpin the study is obtained. This process demands rigour in selecting the strategies and tools best suited to the research objective.

In this study, which aims to analyse the impact of teachers’ use of digital educational resources during the pandemic, in comparison with the resources made available by the National Directorate for Education (DNE) via its multimedia services, a mixed-methods approach was adopted: questionnaire surveys targeting a larger group of teachers, supplemented by semi-structured interviews with two key participants, designated Interviewee A and Interviewee B. The questionnaire survey served as the main data collection tool, enabling a significant amount of information to be gathered efficiently and comprehensively.

The questionnaires underwent a validation process to ensure reliability, improve the clarity of the questions, and correct any inconsistencies. Initially, validation was carried out by two experts in educational technology, followed by a pre-test with teachers from other schools in Cape Verde with profiles similar to those of the target sample. After incorporating suggestions from the experts and pre-test participants, the questionnaire was made available online to the target audience via the Google Forms platform.

This procedure ensured a robust, reliable data collection tool that was appropriate for the population under study, enabling a critical and well-founded analysis of the use of digital educational resources in the context of the pandemic.

Description and conduct of the study

This study was conducted with teachers of Years 9 to 12 at Manuel Lopes Secondary School (ESML). Data collection took place via online questionnaires, distributed through individual profiles on various digital platforms, notably the official ‘Espaço Virtual ESML’ group on the Viber app, recognised as the main channel of communication amongst teachers. The selection of this institution was strategic, taking into account my role as coordinator of the Department of Information Technology, Communication and Imaging, as well as my position as a teacher at the time of the research, which facilitated access to participants and optimised the administration of the questionnaires. Furthermore, ESML’s Information and Communication Technology (ICT) infrastructure proved suitable for the scope of the research, contributing to the effectiveness of data collection. Whilst the choice of the school offered logistical and operational advantages, critical reflection is required regarding the generalisability of the results, given the localised and specific nature of the sample.

Presentation of the results

Interviewee A

The questionnaire was distributed to all secondary school teachers at ESML, and responses were received from 55 teachers. We then carried out a comparative analysis of the data with the aim of understanding the challenges faced by ESML teachers in implementing Digital Learning Environments (DLEs) in the teaching and learning process during the pandemic, in comparison with the resources proposed and recommended by the DNE. Interviews were conducted with interviewee A and interviewee B.

The year 2020 was marked by the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic, a global phenomenon that brought about profound and abrupt changes in all areas of society, exacerbating previously overlooked socio-economic and educational problems. To prevent the spread of the virus and contain the pandemic, it was necessary to impose social isolation and, as a consequence, suspend face-to-face classes in schools in various parts of the world (Souza, 2023).

In an effort to mitigate the negative impacts of school closures on pupils’ learning and to ensure the continuity of the right to education, the Ministry of Education (Cape Verde, 2020) published on its Moodle portal a set of digital educational resources intended for teachers for exploration and training purposes, with a view to applying these resources and keeping pupils engaged in the teaching and learning process.

To provide greater clarity in this study, with a view to understanding the main challenges faced and the methods used to overcome them, an interview was conducted with the Headteacher of ESML to investigate these issues.

Regarding the main challenges faced, the headteacher emphasises the need to significantly improve the school’s technological infrastructure, particularly in terms of internet connectivity and the availability of computers. Furthermore, he highlights the crucial importance of training teachers to cope with the digital age and online teaching, as many are encountering this format for the first time, requiring new approaches and methodologies. On the other hand, he acknowledges that the school has a considerable ICT infrastructure, but stresses the urgent need to better equip the computer labs with computers and ensure that the internet reaches all classrooms. However, the greatest challenge arises when both teachers and pupils are at home without internet access or suitable devices, which hinders the continuity of the teaching and learning process.

Furthermore, it is essential to provide technical support to pupils and teachers and to implement policies that facilitate access to the internet and to devices such as computers, tablets and smartphones in their homes, thereby ensuring the continuity of the teaching and learning process. A broader awareness campaign is also needed to promote the appropriate use of digital educational resources, starting with sound educational policies on the part of the relevant authorities.

Interviewee B

During the pandemic, the Ministry of Education implemented various initiatives to ensure the continuity of teaching. Among these initiatives, the ‘Online Training in the Use of Digital Educational Resources’ project stands out, which aimed to train teachers in the use of digital tools for remote teaching. This project included training teachers in online learning platforms, the creation of digital contente, and the distribution of educational materials to pupils without internet access.

According to the data obtained from the interview with Interviewee B, the main objective of the training for teachers was to equip participants with the essential skills and knowledge to create teaching activities in a pedagogically effective and innovative manner, making the most of the digital educational resources available online. The training was predominantly practical, emphasising the participants’ involvement in the development of educational tools, materials and resources.

It is also noted that the distance learning methodology was applied during the training. This active approach was directly reflected in the content discussed, which was predominantly practical, culminating in the completion of specific exercises provided in each module.

Based on the data collected, it was observed that the training programme consisted of nine modules, which provided teachers with digital educational resources for professional development and application in their classrooms, as detailed in the table below. Each module is linked to a specific digital education tool. To support participants in completing the tasks and presenting their practical work at the end of each module, a user manual and tutorial videos were made available. Participants had the flexibility to access the course at any time, whether during the day or at night, according to their personal availability, provided they met the deadlines set for each activity and the course end date.

Table 9
Digital educational resources provided by the DNE

The table above highlights the digital educational resources recommended and promoted by the Ministry of Education, through the National Directorate for Education, in 2020. These resources form part of online training focused on the use of digital educational tools, with the aim of mitigating the impacts of the pandemic. Due to health restrictions and school closures, these resources were implemented to ensure that pupils remain connected to educational content and the learning process.

In addition to presenting the nine digital educational resources mentioned in the table, a carefully curated PDF list was also made available, containing other educational technology tools, accessible via a link, intended for teachers’ exploration and training (DNE, 2020).

Interviewee B emphasised that, amongst the modules made available, there was a focus on the use of social media in education, particularly Facebook Messenger, due to its ease of use and the familiarity of both teachers and pupils with communicating and sharing content. Furthermore, a significant number of teachers were noted to be using Google Classroom.

Furthermore, according to the interview with Interviewee B, the training took place on the Moodle (e-ME) platform, whose tools provide a pedagogical environment conducive to distance learning. To support trainees/participants in the event of queries and/or requests for clarification, in addition to emails from trainers/tutors, remote support tools were made available, such as a Q&A forum, email, and telephone.

He also mentions that, initially, the training was aimed at headteachers of school clusters and non-clustered schools, teachers and ICT coordinators, SIGE focal points, and class- s, with a view to subsequently rolling it out to other teachers in their respective schools.

According to the report on the DNE’s online training course on the Use of Digital Educational Resources (2020) and as per the interview with respondent B, it can be concluded that the overall assessment of the training was positive, as the majority of the established objectives were achieved. The vast majority of participants completed all the modules, with the exception of those who started the training very late.

However, there was some disappointment regarding the participation of coordinating teachers/ICT staff and the SIGE focal point, as 50 per cent of them did not engage with the process. A significant additional challenge was the high number of participants assigned to just four tutors, resulting in considerable dissatisfaction amongst them due to frequently delayed feedback.

According to the same source, overall, the initiative was effectively implemented. Participants rated the organisation of the course positively, highlighting the trainers’ competence in management and appropriate teaching dynamics, as well as the relevance of the content and topics covered, which met their interests.

It is also worth noting that, although the training was conducted collaboratively and dynamically between participants and trainers, it is crucial to reflect on possible improvements for the next phase of the programme.

Furthermore, as indicated in the report, the trainees highlighted areas for improvement for future initiatives, placing particular emphasis on the need for free internet access for teachers. It is worth noting that the high standard evident across all modules contributed significantly to the achievement of the established objectives.

Based on the interview with respondent B and the data from the training report, we present some recommendations and future actions aimed at ensuring better quality and organisation of the training provided by the DNE, thereby guaranteeing that the expected results are achieved:

  • Reduce the number of participants: the proposal is to create groups with a limited number of members or a specific profile, initially focusing solely on ICT coordinators and SIGE focal points.

  • Make the training plan available before the training begins and set aside time for participants to familiarise themselves with the Moodle platform.

  • Include a demonstration session in each module via videoconference.

  • Encourage headteachers to promote and continue the training programmes in their respective schools, appointing support specialists to ensure monitoring and supervision.

It is therefore crucial to enhance teacher training in the digital age and encourage greater participation by teachers, particularly ICT teachers, to foster the dissemination of knowledge within the school or school cluster. Furthermore, it is essential to involve local partners to support the continuous professional development of teachers.

Questionnaire administered to secondary school teachers at ESML

In this sub-chapter, we will present and analyse the data collected from ESML secondary school teachers, obtained via Google Forms.

Challenges in implementing the solutions proposed by the DNE regarding the use of digital educational resources at ESML

Figure 1
Constraints encountered during training

With regard to the challenges faced during the training period, according to the data collected, we can see from the chart above that various obstacles were highlighted by the participants. Around 45.5 per cent mentioned that slow internet speeds significantly hampered the training process. Furthermore, 23.6 per cent expressed dissatisfaction with the quality of the training received, whilst 25.5 per cent pointed to the poor state of ICT facilities at the school. It is important to note that a significant majority – 58.2 per cent of respondents – considered the duration of the training to be insufficient. Furthermore, the overwhelming majority – 76.4 per cent – identified the lack of practical sessions as the main obstacle encountered during the training process.

Figure 2
Challenges encountered after the training

As shown in the graph above, it is evident that teachers faced significant difficulties in applying what they had learnt during the exploratory and training sessions in their classrooms. These difficulties were attributed to various factors, such as slow internet speeds, mentioned by 43.6 per cent of participants; a lack of internet access in some classrooms (50.9 per cent); the need for more practice (60.0 per cent); the training duration, which 52.7 per cent of respondents considered too short; as well as pupils’ difficulties in using digital educational resources, as reported by 63.6 per cent of respondents.

Figure 3
Ways found to overcome the constraints

After receiving training, teachers faced challenges in implementing what they had learnt in the classroom. According to the data obtained, we observed that 52.7 per cent of respondents brought their own computers to school; 63.6 per cent used their own internet connection; 18.2 per cent deepened their knowledge through further study; 23.6 per cent sought assistance from colleagues; 12.7 per cent focused on training their pupils; and 12.7 per cent were unable to find effective methods to overcome the difficulties.

Overall, according to the data presented, a number of concerns have emerged amongst teachers. Among the challenges highlighted are the need for greater emphasis on practical work, pupils’ lack of digital skills, and limited internet access in some classrooms. The headteacher pointed to the insufficient duration of the training and the lack of adequate support for the effective implementation of solutions. Furthermore, interviewee B emphasised the need for more trainers per trainee, greater engagement from ICT teachers to support their colleagues in other subjects, and recommended the establishment of future partnerships between schools and other institutions to promote continuous training in digital educational resources.

Recommendations for improving the use of digital educational resources in secondary schools

The analysis carried out identifies multiple strategic areas for investment and intervention within the educational sector, particularly with regard to the integration of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT). Firstly, there is a pressing need to equip educational institutions with adequate technological infrastructure, ensuring not only access to modern devices and software, but also the ongoing maintenance and updating of these resources.

At the same time, ongoing teacher training is a critical element. Continuing professional development must go beyond technical instruction, incorporating innovative teaching methodologies that enable the effective use of ICT in educational practice. This investment not only strengthens teachers’ digital competence but also contributes to improved learning outcomes, promoting more interactive and student-centred learning experiences.

Another essential aspect is the systematic integration of ICT into the school curriculum across all subjects. The cross-curricular incorporation of these technologies promotes interdisciplinarity, enabling the development of digital skills to be seen as a natural dimension of the educational process, rather than as an isolated add-on. Furthermore, it is necessary to implement mechanisms for ongoing pedagogical support for teachers who face greater difficulties in adopting these tools, ensuring equity in access to digital practices and mitigating disparities in teaching performance.

In the context of educational policies, it is recommended that incentive programmes be established to promote hybrid distance learning, with a view to ensuring inclusive, high-quality education. Such policies should consider not only financial incentives but also the establishment of clear guidelines, institutional monitoring, and continuous evaluation of the impact of technological initiatives on learning.

Teachers’ feedback highlights further areas for improvement in future implementations. These include the need to incorporate more robust practical components, increase the number of hours dedicated to the use of ICT, improve the quality of connectivity, promote more efficient administrative organisation, and ensure greater availability of accessible digital resources. Implementing these recommendations requires strategic coordination between institutions, teachers, and government bodies, in order to establish a sustainable and effective approach to technological integration within the school context.

In summary, the adoption of these measures has significant practical and policy implications, as it requires structural investment, ongoing teacher training, consistent pedagogical support and well-defined incentive policies. When implemented in a coordinated manner, these strategies have the potential to transform the educational environment, promoting greater digital inclusion, pedagogical improvement and, consequently, better academic outcomes.

Critical analysis and comparison with other African countries

An analysis of the use of Open Educational Resources (OER) in Cape Verde, as evidenced by the case study of Manuel Lopes Secondary School, reveals structural challenges that are not unique to the Cape Verdean context but are shared by several African countries. Among the main constraints are infrastructural limitations, insufficient teacher training, and inequalities in access to digital technologies.

From a critical perspective, such limitations highlight a tension between education policies geared towards digitalisation and the material reality of schools. According to Unwin (2008), many African countries adopt policies for integrating ICT into education driven by global agendas, without proper alignment with local conditions. This criticism is corroborated in the Cape Verdean case, where, despite initiatives by the National Directorate of Education (DNE), difficulties persist, such as poor connectivity and the need for a greater practical component in teacher training.

By comparison, countries such as Kenya and South Africa have made more structured progress in integrating educational technologies, although they also face similar challenges. In Kenya, the Digital Literacy Programme (DLP) has promoted the distribution of devices and teacher training, but studies by Piper et al. (2015) indicate that the effectiveness of these initiatives depends heavily on ongoing training and pedagogical support. Similarly, in South Africa, despite significant investment in digital infrastructure, Czerniewicz and Brown (2014) highlight that socio-economic inequalities continue to limit the impact of technology on teaching.

On the other hand, countries such as Ghana have been relying on public–private partnerships to overcome infrastructure constraints. According to Trucano (2016), these partnerships have helped to improve access to the internet and devices, although challenges remain regarding the quality of the pedagogical use of technologies. This experience suggests that Cape Verde could benefit from similar strategies, particularly in strengthening institutional partnerships, as already recommended in the study analysed.

Furthermore, the experience of countries such as Rwanda, often cited as an example of digital transformation in Africa, demonstrates that integrated policies — combining infrastructure, teacher training and the production of local content — are essential for success. As Hennessy et al. (2010) argue, simply making technologies available does not guarantee improvements in learning; a contextualised pedagogical approach is required.

Thus, the comparison shows that Cape Verde is following a trajectory common to developing African countries, characterised by institutional progress but limited by structural constraints. However, its small scale may represent a strategic advantage, enabling the faster implementation of integrated and contextualised policies.

In summary, the comparative analysis reinforces the view that the successful integration of REDAs depends not only on the provision of digital tools, but on an educational ecosystem that brings together infrastructure, continuous training, inclusive policies and adaptation to local realities.

Conclusions

This study has led to the following conclusions, taking into account the established objectives:

Challenges in implementing solutions regarding the use of digital resources in ESML: Although, according to the study, we can see that the majority of teachers have some training in digital technologies, some reported a lack of proficiency in using OER. They emphasise the need for continuous professional development, with a longer duration and a greater practical component. Many teachers need further training to familiarise themselves with new online teaching tools and methodologies; they recommend more qualified trainers, better organisation of training, greater availability of resources (computers, tablets and smartphones) and internet access both at school and at home, as well as greater student capacity, amongst other factors.

Recommendations for improving the use of digital educational resources in ESML: We have identified several areas for investment and action. Firstly, it is crucial to equip the school adequately in terms of ICT. Furthermore, it is necessary to invest in the ongoing training of teachers to ensure they are up to date and able to use these technologies effectively. Another important recommendation is the inclusion of ICT in the curriculum across all subject areas, promoting an integrated and cross-curricular approach. It is also essential to ensure adequate support to assist teachers who face greater difficulties in implementing these technologies. Finally, it is essential to create incentive policies that effectively promote hybrid distance learning, ensuring a high-quality and inclusive education for all pupils.

In conclusion, this case study on the use of Open Educational Resources (OER) in secondary education in Cape Verde, focusing on Manuel Lopes Secondary School, highlights the importance and potential of these tools in the educational process. The analysis revealed that, despite limitations in infrastructure and technical training, OER offer significant opportunities to enrich teaching and learning, promoting greater autonomy amongst students and providing access to up-to-date and diverse materials. Furthermore, the study demonstrated that the effective integration of these resources depends not only on the availability of technology, but also on the involvement of teachers and students in innovative teaching practices. It is therefore recommended that greater investment be made in continuing professional development for teachers and in improving the technological infrastructure of schools, with a view to a more widespread and effective adoption of REDA within the Cape Verdean education system. This study contributes to the debate on digital education in developing countries, emphasising the need for public policies that encourage the use of open digital resources as a fundamental tool for transforming education.

Note

Note

1

Available at: https://www.ispringpro.com.br/blog/ferramentas-ead. Accessed on: 14 Jan. 2025.

Availability of research data

The dataset supporting the results of this study is published in the article itself.

References

  • ARES. Agência Reguladora do Ensino Superior. O sistema educativo em Cabo Verde [S. l.]: ARES, 2018. Disponível em: https://www.ares.cv/assets/documentos/SistemaEducativoCaboverdiano.pdf Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://www.ares.cv/assets/documentos/SistemaEducativoCaboverdiano.pdf
  • CARDOSO, Márcia Regina Gonçalves; OLIVEIRA, Guilherme Saramago de; GHELLI, Kelma Gomes Mendonça. Content analysis: a qualitative research methodology. Cadernos da FUCAMP, Monte Carmelo, v. 20, n. 43, 2021.
  • COLMAN, H. Ferramentas EAD. [S. l.]: iSpring Solutions, 2021. Disponível em: https://www.ispringpro.com.br/blog/ferramentas-ead Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://www.ispringpro.com.br/blog/ferramentas-ead
  • CORREIA, G. R.; SILVA, A. R. Uso das tecnologias digitais pelos professores do ensino secundário da cidade da Praia – Cabo Verde [S. l.: s. n.], 2018.
  • CRESWELL, J. W.; PLANO CLARK, V. L. Designing and conducting mixed methods research 3. ed. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications, 2018.
  • CZERNIEWICZ, L.; BROWN, C. The habitus of digital “strangers” in higher education. British Journal of Educational Technology, [S. l.], 2014.
  • DNE. Direção Nacional da Educação. Escola virtual: exploração de recursos educativos digitais. [S. l.]: Ministério da Educação, 2020. Disponível em: https://recursoseducativosdigitais.blogspot.com/p/o-nosso-conceito-red.html Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://recursoseducativosdigitais.blogspot.com/p/o-nosso-conceito-red.html
  • DNE. Direção Nacional de Educação. Novos horizontes de aprendizagem: programa escola virtual exploração de recursos educativos digitais. Ministério da Educação, 2020.
  • DNE. Direção Nacional de Educação. Outros recursos educativos digitais Ministério da Educação, 2020. Disponível em: https://portal.minedu.gov.cv/mod/resource/view.php?id=1803 Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://portal.minedu.gov.cv/mod/resource/view.php?id=1803
  • DOWNES, S. An introduction to connective knowledge. In: HUG, T. (Ed.). Media, knowledge & education: exploring new spaces, relations and dynamics in digital media ecologies. Vienna: Springer, 2007.
  • EYNON, R.; MALMBERG, L.-E. Understanding the digital generation: teaching and learning in a digital age. London: Routledge, 2021.
  • FACHIN, O. Fundamentos de metodologia científica 5. ed. São Paulo: Saraiva, 2005.
  • FRANCO, M. V.; DANTAS, O. M. Pesquisa exploratória: aplicando instrumentos de geração de dados – observação, questionário e entrevista. [S. l.: s. n.], 2017. Disponível em: https://www.studocu.com/pt-br/document/universidade-de-brasilia/iniciacao-a-metodol-cientifica/pesquisa-exploratoria-aplicando-instrumentos-de-geracao-de-dados-observacao-questionario-e-entrevista/11835150 Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://www.studocu.com/pt-br/document/universidade-de-brasilia/iniciacao-a-metodol-cientifica/pesquisa-exploratoria-aplicando-instrumentos-de-geracao-de-dados-observacao-questionario-e-entrevista/11835150
  • GRAZIELA, B. Recursos educacionais digitais: o que são e onde encontrá-los. [S. l.]: ClipEscola, 2022. Disponível em: https://www.clipescola.com/recursos-educacionais-digitais/ Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://www.clipescola.com/recursos-educacionais-digitais/
  • HART, J. Top 100 tools for learning 2023 [S. l.: s. n.], 2023. Disponível em: https://toptools4learning.com Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://toptools4learning.com
  • HENNESSY, S.; HARRISON, D.; WAMAKOTE, L. Teacher factors influencing classroom use of ICT in Sub-Saharan Africa. Itupale Online Journal of African Studies, [S. l.], 2010.
  • HOKAMA, M. S. Análise de recursos educativos digitais em um curso e-learning 2016. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade de Lisboa, Instituto de Educação, Lisboa, 2016.
  • MED. Ministério da Educação. Aprender e estudar em casa Ministério da Educação, 2020. Disponível em: https://minedu.gov.cv/recursos_educativosaprender_em_casa Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://minedu.gov.cv/recursos_educativosaprender_em_casa
  • MED. Ministério da Educação. Estudo sobre os efeitos da COVID-19 no sistema educativo em Cabo Verde. Direção-Geral do Planeamento, Orçamento e Gestão, 2021.
  • MED. Ministério da Educação. Lei de Bases do Sistema Educativo: Decreto-Lei n.º 2/2010, de 7 de maio, posteriormente alterada pelo Decreto-Legislativo n.º 13/2018, de 7 de dezembro. Boletim Oficial, 2010.
  • MEDEIROS, N. A. et al. Recursos educativos digitais: uma revisão de literatura em anais de congressos em informática na educação. In: CONGRESSO SOBRE TECNOLOGIAS NA EDUCAÇÃO, 2018. Anais [...] [S. l.: s. n.], 2018. Disponível em: https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-2185/CtrlE_2018_paper_83.pdf Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-2185/CtrlE_2018_paper_83.pdf
  • PIPER, B. et al. Kenya’s Digital Literacy Programme: impact and challenges. [S. l.: s. n.], 2015.
  • RAMOS, J. L.; TEODORO, V. D.; FERREIRA, F. M. Recursos educativos digitais: reflexões sobre a prática. Cadernos SACAUSEF, Lisboa, n. VII, p. 11-34, 2011.
  • RODRIGUES, I. Regras de elaboração de um questionário de investigação Santa Maria da Feira: [s. n.], 2021. Disponível em: https://www.eviedvet.eu/assets/files/Rodrigues%20Cong%20Montenegro%202021.pdf Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://www.eviedvet.eu/assets/files/Rodrigues%20Cong%20Montenegro%202021.pdf
  • SANTOS, G. C. Entrevista: técnica de coleta em pesquisa qualitativa. Blog PPEC, Campinas, 2018. Disponível em: https://periodicos.sbu.unicamp.br/blog/index.php/2018/08/15/entrevista/ Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://periodicos.sbu.unicamp.br/blog/index.php/2018/08/15/entrevista/
  • SELWYN, N. Education and Technology: key issues and debates. London: Continuum International Publishing Group, 2010.
  • SIEMENS, G. Connectivism: a learning theory for the digital age. International Journal of Instructional Technology and Distance Learning, [S. l.], v. 2, n. 1, 2005. Disponível em: https://www.itdl.org/ Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://www.itdl.org/
  • SOUZA, P. C. O uso das TIC no ensino: uma revisão de literatura. Revista Espaço do Currículo, v. 16, n. 2, 2023. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15687/rec.v16i2.64491. Acesso em: 14 jan. 2025.
    » https://doi.org/10.15687/rec.v16i2.64491
  • TRUCANO, M. ICT in Education in Africa: a World Bank perspective. [S. l.: s. n.], 2016.
  • UNWIN, T. Survey of ICT and education in Africa: a summary report. Washington: World Bank, 2008.
  • VAN DIJK, J. A. G. M. The network society: social aspects of new media. 2. ed. London: SAGE Publications, 2006.
  • WARSCHAUER, M. Learning in the Cloud: how (and why) to transform schools with digital media. Educational Studies, [S. l.], v. 47, n. 2, p. 121-139, 2011.
  • WARSCHAUER, M. Technology and social inclusion: rethinking the digital divide. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2003.

Editor in charge:

Iris Verena Oliveira

Correspondence

E-mail: ctg@cv.unipiaget.org

Correspondence

E-mail: bruno.goncalves@ipb.pt

Correspondence

E-mail: ssousa751@gmail.com

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    09 Nov 2026
  • Date of issue
    2026

History

  • Received
    17 Oct 2024
  • Accepted
    12 June 2026
location_on
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul - Faculdade de Educação Avenida Paulo Gama, s/n, Faculdade de Educação - Prédio 12201 - Sala 914, 90046-900 Porto Alegre/RS – Brasil, Tel.: (55 51) 3308-3268, Fax: (55 51) 3308-3985 - Porto Alegre - RS - Brazil
E-mail: educreal@ufrgs.br
rss_feed Acompañe los números de esta revista en su lector de RSS
Ir para arriba