Open-access Affirmative Action in Brazilian Higher Education: a systematic review (1995-2023) from the historical-dialectical perspective

ABSTRACT

This article presents a systematic review of academic studies (1995 to 2023) on affirmative action policies in access to Brazilian higher education. Grounded in the theoretical and methodological framework historical-dialectical materialism, it analyzes the contradictions of these policies within the capitalist state. Methodologically, a systematic review was conducted in the CAPES and BDTD/IBICT databases; of the 179 identified studies, 32 were included in the research sample. The findings indicate that such policies, although necessary, do not, on their own, overcome disparities operating in neoliberal contexts. Effective democratization requires expanding access, ensuring quality retention, and combating racism and the commodification of education.

Keywords
Affirmative Actions; Higher Education; Educational Democratization

RESUMO

Este artigo analisa produções acadêmicas (1995-2023) sobre políticas de ações afirmativas no acesso ao ensino superior brasileiro. Metodologicamente, trata-se de uma revisão sistemática feita no portal CAPES e BDTD/IBICT, em que do total de 179 estudos identificados, 32 compuseram a amostra da pesquisa, sendo analisados sob a orientação teórico-metodológica do materialismo histórico-dialético para compreender as contradições dessas políticas no contexto do Estado capitalista. Concluiu-se que tais políticas, embora necessárias, não superam isoladamente as disparidades, operando em contextos neoliberais. A democratização efetiva exige ampliar o acesso, garantir permanência com qualidade e combater o racismo e a mercantilização da educação.

Palavras-chave
Ações Afirmativas; Ensino Superior; Democratização da Educação

Introduction

Affirmative action policies constitute a state response, achieved through the struggle of social movements – especially the black movement – to recognize the historical debt to population groups systematically excluded. According to Gomes (2001), such policies are aimed at realizing the constitutional principle of material equality and neutralizing the effects of discrimination based on race, gender, age, national origin, and physical appearance.

However, in a capitalist society, permeated by antagonistic class interests, the implementation of these policies occurs in a field of tension. For authors like Ferraz (2020) and Netto (2016), they operate in a fundamental contradiction: although they promote access and represent a victory for social movements, their operationalization within the state apparatus positions them as mechanisms that can ultimately serve to mediate conflicts and maintain the existing order, without radically altering the capitalist structure that produces and naturalizes inequalities. This critical-dialectical analysis – which sees affirmative actions simultaneously as a conquest and a limit – guides the analysis presented in this article.

In Brazilian higher education, affirmative actions, especially quota policies, have consolidated as a formal strategy to expand access for historically marginalized groups. However, such measures do not represent a structural solution, as they do not question the logic of the capitalist system that sustains educational inequalities. The mere guarantee of entry proves insufficient for substantive democratization, facing challenges such as the lack of robust retention policies and the persistence of an often hostile academic environment.

In light of this context, this article presents a systematic bibliographic review that aimed to map and critically analyze academic productions (theses and dissertations) on affirmative actions in access to Brazilian higher education from 1995 to 2023, from the perspective of historical-dialectical materialism. The investigation, which originated from a master's research completed in 2020, was expanded for this article and sought to identify the main axes of understanding, contradictions, and gaps present in the specialized literature, contributing to the debate on the limits and possibilities of these policies in the contemporary educational landscape.

To this end, a survey was conducted in the databases of the Thesis and Dissertation Catalog of the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel (CAPES) and the Brazilian Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations of the Brazilian Institute of Information in Science and Technology (BDTD/IBICT). The expansion of the scope until 2023 enabled the incorporation of recent studies evaluating the post-implementation challenges of affirmative action, thereby updating the discussion.

Initially, the methodological procedures used to conduct this bibliographic research will be detailed. Subsequently, the consolidated understandings in the literature will be presented and discussed, categorized into four analytical axes, and the correlations and contradictions among them examined.

Methodology

This study is characterized as a systematic bibliographic review, guided by the theoretical-methodological perspective of historical-dialectical materialism (HDM). According to Masson (2012), this approach presupposes that understanding a phenomenon requires analyzing it in its concrete totality, considering its historicity and the contradictions inherent to its social formation. In the capitalist context, this implies recognizing the State as an instrument for perpetuating the status quo, in which capital and State are intrinsically interconnected.

For Ferraz (2020) and Netto (2016), HDM allows one to transcend the immediate appearance of phenomena, analyzing their contradictions and transformative potentialities – not only in the legal realm but also in social practice. This perspective is fundamental for analyzing public policies such as affirmative action, which, although they are achievements of social movements, often operate within the structural limits of the system they intend to transform.

To map the academic productions on the subject, a survey was conducted in the banks of the Catalog of Theses and Dissertations of the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel (CAPES) and the Brazilian Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations (BDTD) of the Brazilian Institute of Information in Science and Technology (IBICT). The search strategy used the following descriptors (or keywords), combined with the boolean operator AND to ensure precision: "Affirmative Action Policy"; "Affirmative Action Program"; and "Democratization of Access to Higher Education". These descriptors were "placed in quotation marks" so that the search would be conducted jointly, rather than in isolation, encompassing productions that included all words related to the topic.

It was decided to include the variations Policy and Program to cover different terminologies. To refine the results, a filter by area of knowledge was used, specifically selecting the field Education. No initial temporal cut-off was established, allowing for a broad survey, which resulted in the identification of productions from 1995 onward.

The eligibility criteria for the final selection of works were established as follows: theses and dissertations available in full online, in Portuguese, that had as their central focus the analysis of policies or programs of affirmative actions in access to Brazilian higher education were included. Works that dealt only with student retention, without linking to affirmative action policies, studies on basic education, or duplicative research across the databases, were excluded.

The selection process followed these steps:

  1. Initial search: a total of 179 productions were identified (131 from CAPES and 48 from BDTD/IBICT);

  2. Removal of duplicate productions: 15 duplicate productions were removed between the databases;

  3. Screening by title and abstract: the remaining 164 productions were analyzed based on the eligibility criteria. This stage resulted in the exclusion of 132 works for not fitting the study focus;

  4. Research universe: after screening, 32 productions made up the analysis universe, consisting of 23 master's dissertations (71.9%) and 9 doctoral theses (28.1%).

The distribution of academic productions by type and platform is detailed in Table 1.

Table 1
Distribution of academic productions by type and platform

The 32 works that made up the research universe were subjected to a critical-inspired categorical content analysis, which involved floating reading, in-depth analysis of the texts, and categorization of the predominant understandings about affirmative actions. From this exercise, four analytical axes emerged, capturing the main positions and contradictions in the literature.

The temporal cut (1995-2023) enabled the inclusion of research analyzing different phases of the implementation of affirmative action policies in Brazil. The most recent studies stand out (Barbosa, 2022; Dentz, 2021; Vieira, 2022; Ferraz, 2020; Silva, 2019), which evaluate the effects and perceptions post-consolidation of Affirmative Actions, bringing important reflections on: (a) the limits of permanence policies; (b) the reproduction of inequalities within institutions; and (c) the disputes surrounding the interpretation and application of regulations. These works revealed how Brazilian universities have dealt with the challenge of transforming formal access into substantive inclusion.

From this survey, the next section sought to detail the productions found by breaking them down into four axes of understanding about Affirmative Actions in higher education: 1) enabled access as a possibility for social mobility by representing a form of democratization of access to higher education; 2) configure as an excluding inclusion policy that did not promote, thus, an effective democratization of access to higher education; 3) provide partial democratization of access, as they cannot be considered the only option to solve problems of inequalities and exclusion; 4) there were clashes and contradictions in the processes of implementing quotas.

Analysis of Academic Productions on Actions Affirmative Actions and Access to Higher Education

Access to Higher Education through affirmative action, specifically quotas, sparked controversy at public universities. Thus, it became, in addition to a subject of discussion, the object of various research, which enabled the development of theses, dissertations, articles, and other academic publications on the subject.

Considering 32 (thirty-two) productions selected from the digital databases of CAPES and IBICT, Graph 1 presents the distribution of theses and dissertations by year.

Graph 1
Annual Distribution of Theses and Dissertations in CAPES and IBICT (1995-2023)

As can be seen, the first research based on the chosen descriptors dates to 1995 (Oliveira, 1995). After this milestone, research activity began in 2006 at low frequency and became more frequent starting in 2014.

This scenario reflects the historical context of implementing affirmative action policies in Brazil, initially driven by social movement pressures and adopted through institutional resolutions or state legislation – even before federal regulation under Law No. 12,711/2012. The case of UERJ is noteworthy, as it incorporated, even without the implementation of a Quota Law (Law No. 12,711/2012 and regulated by Decree No. 7,824/2012), the criteria for establishing reserved spots for students from public schools who self-declare as black or brown.

In 2000, the Legislative Assembly of the State of Rio de Janeiro (ALERJ) approved Law No. 3,524/2000, which introduced changes to the access criteria for state universities in Rio de Janeiro and reserved 50% of the spots for graduates of public schools. In 2001, this Assembly approved Law No. 3,708/2001, which allocated 40% of spots to self-declared black and brown individuals. By 2003, these laws were modified and replaced by Law No. 4,151/2003. The legislation for reserving spots also included Laws No. 5,074/2007 and No. 5,346/2008.

Among the 32 selected productions, it was not possible to find the file of the research titled "Study of the Possibilities of Democratizing Access to Higher Education: the case of Tocantins," by Oliveira (1995), only through the information available in the CAPES thesis and dissertation database, leaving 31 productions to be analyzed in more detail. Most are concentrated in the Southeast region (10 studies – 32.26%), followed by the South region (9 studies – 29.03%), Northeast (5 studies – 16.13%), North (4 studies – 12.90%), and Central-West (3 studies – 9.68%). The majority of studies focus on federal higher education institutions, with few state institutions addressing access to higher education through affirmative action. Particularly noteworthy in the State of Bahia are the State University of Santa Cruz (UESC), which conducted research on this theme during the studied period (Figueiredo, 2015), and the State University of Southwest Bahia (UESB) (Ferraz, 2020). This gap underscores the relevance of the present bibliographic survey.

In this sense, it can be suggested, based on the descriptors used, that research at State Universities is scarce. It is important to note that state universities have their specificities, while federal universities have become a more defined and cohesive group since the implementation of Law No. 12,711/2012. State universities, even being pioneers in Affirmative Actions, continue to be governed by their own regulations, that is, some by internal institutional resolutions and others defined by state legislation.

Based on historical-dialectical materialism, the findings of the 31 studies were categorized into four axes, as shown in the table below:

Table 2
Axes of positioning on Affirmative Actions in Higher Education

As can be observed, the amount of work in each of the four groups is similar, showing a certain balance between the number of productions. The exception is Axis 4, which has nine works, differing from the first three axes, which have six and eight works each.

Axis 1: affirmative actions facilitate access to Higher Education, representing a democratization of access and a possibility for social mobility

The research analyzed in this axis highlights that affirmative action has facilitated access to higher education for historically excluded groups, representing progress in educational democratization and a potential avenue for social mobility. However, from the perspective of historical-dialectical materialism, these results coexist with structural contradictions inherent to the capitalist system.

Ávila (2012) argues that quotas institutionalized equal opportunities by equalizing unequal social positions. In this sense, access to higher education through the quota system did not violate the principle of merit. Among the interviewed students, there is an understanding of affirmative actions as a reparative measure for the black population, especially highlighting them as a victory for all people excluded from society, or as an improvement in the schooling process of black individuals, or as an opportunity that other black individuals did not have, or even as a historically denied right and citizenship.

Despite these perceptions, the study reveals a central contradiction: affirmative actions function as a "counterweight" to the logic of the capitalist system. In other words, they are simultaneously a victory for social movements that pressured for historical reparations and a mediation by the State to maintain the hegemony of the dominant class. In this case, it remained only in legal form through legislation – the right for all – without altering the exclusionary essence of access to education.

Still, when analyzing scholarship students' perceptions of the Affirmative Action Program, Erig (2016) emphasizes that scholarship students view the policies as a gateway to university, but highlight their insufficiency to ensure retention – thereby evidencing the lack of structural support (student assistance, pedagogical adaptation, etc.).

Figueredo (2015) corroborates this view by demonstrating that, although quotas have increased completion rates among scholarship students and contributed to a more egalitarian society, they do not resolve the systemic lack of opportunities for the majority of the population.

Therefore, the idea that the quota policy should not be adopted materializes neoliberal ideals, according to which the individual is responsible for life's opportunities rather than the system that imposes certain conditions, thereby ignoring unequal material conditions (Ferraz, 2020).

Santana (2015) goes further, arguing that affirmative actions in education are essential to boost the social ascension process of more black individuals and, therefore, should be maintained and expanded, in addition to promoting, through collectives, the struggle for resolving structural problems that still contribute to maintaining social and ethnic-racial inequalities in Brazilian education.

Colen (2019) addresses the relevance of the black university as a counter-hegemonic project, capable of questioning the colonial and racist structures that permeate not only educational institutions but also public policies and social dynamics. For the author, this proposal goes beyond formal inclusion, constituting a space for critical reflection and the production of alternative knowledge, fostering practices of resistance and re-existence that challenge the established order.

Moreover, the quota law originated from a provocation by the black social movement that, after a long period of processing, was realized. Thus, as Santos (2018) presents, it represented an important achievement in Brazilian higher education and has contributed to its democratization. From this, it was reflected whether affirmative actions really brought a victory for the excluded segments of access to higher education, or if they also corresponded to the consent of the dominant class to maintain the status quo.

The analysis of these studies, in light of the theoretical framework of historical-dialectical materialism, allows for the explicit characterization of the contradictory and ambiguous nature of quotas, which manifests in two interconnected dimensions:

Advances and Achievements: The policy has proven effective in quantitative expansion of access, representing formal recognition of rights and symbolic mobility for historically excluded groups, establishing itself as an important victory in social struggles.

Structural Limits: Simultaneously, the persistence of material inequalities is evident, an adaptation to the neoliberal logic that focuses responsibility on the individual, and the insufficiency of complementary policies for retention and assistance that are fundamental to convert formal access into substantive inclusion.

Thus, the contribution of affirmative actions, although undeniable, operates within the framework of a state mediation that, while granting access, does not overcome the exclusionary essence of higher education in capitalism.

Axis 2: it is an exclusionary-inclusive policy, thus not promoting effective democratization of access to Higher Education

The studies in this area reveal a fundamental contradiction in affirmative action policies: although they formally expand access to higher education, they perpetuate mechanisms of structural exclusion, configuring themselves as an exclusive inclusion. This analysis, aligned with historical-dialectical materialism, demonstrates how such policies, while necessary, do not question the capitalist logic that sustains educational inequalities.

In this context, Rosa (2019) highlights that the guarantee of access, on its own, is insufficient to ensure equity in the academic journey. The author argues that without robust retention policies – such as student assistance, pedagogical adaptations, and psychosocial support – inclusion becomes mere formality, reproducing exclusion at new stages of the educational system. This institutional fragility is evident in that many quota students, despite entering university, remain marginalized in activities such as research and extension, as previously noted by Doebber (2011).

According to Doebber (2011), in his research at the Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), evaluative practices for quantitative monitoring of student entry were found; however, retention policies were not included in the evaluation. As a consequence, the affirmative policy that aimed to be inclusive becomes exclusive right at the moment of access.

In this sense, institutional practices could be considered as in/exclusion, since, despite the implementation of the quota policy, there was also no change in the structure of the courses. For this reason, the movement proved to be contradictorily inherent to the very system that promoted access, yet did not ensure the academic conditions for retention in higher education.

This symbolic inclusion is further exposed by Pereira Santos (2023), who problematizes the idea that the numerical increase in Black students in certain courses represents a genuine racial and epistemic transformation in educational institutions. The author demonstrates that, even with greater representativeness, the university maintains its colonial core intact: curricula anchored in Eurocentric epistemologies, academic dynamics marked by veiled racism, and the naturalization of racial hierarchies. In other words, the presence of Black bodies does not translate into power or recognition, highlighting that the supposed "change of color" of institutions is, in reality, an illusion that masks the permanence of oppressive structures.

At the same time that the demand of Black people for education was incorporated, the possibility of access to quality public education and guaranteed retention in university was denied. As Figueiredo (2008) points out, the policy of reserving spots did not make a significant contribution to the expansion of democracy. For the author, affirmative action policies in higher education, particularly the reservation of spots/quotas, were a formal solution to the problem of access to higher education in Brazil and did not constitute an essential solution from the workers' perspective, as they did not question the logic of capital, private property, and the appropriation of surplus value.

Moreover, as portrayed by Hamú (2014), initiatives to formulate and implement public policies recognizing rights are not isolated and disconnected from the new political and social context experienced by the country, both nationally and in its international relations (Braga 2020). As a result, it became essential to understand the object of study in its entirety, as it cannot be comprehended in its magnitude in a compartmentalized manner. However, the need to understand the whole and move to the particular case was revealed by highlighting the mediations that underlie it.

Regarding the quota system, Freire (2017) highlighted that a legitimate demand from people excluded from access to public higher education was met. Thus, the success of the policy required continuous evaluation and monitoring of the academics who benefited. According to the author, the adoption of affirmative action policies for higher education has undoubtedly enabled a significant increase in the number of people with higher education degrees.

However, it was understood that the discourse about expanding access to education actually created a fetish of democratization and increased metrics of schooling (requirements from international organizations), thereby masking the phenomenon occurring in peripheral countries – mass certification – as it omitted the bias of focusing educational processes on the lower levels and the lack of quality in education (critical training). Such evidence emphasized the commodification of knowledge and education, in which the perverse effects of education were externalized, becoming a "marketable good" (Freire, 2017), subordinated to economic interests.

In this sense, as highlighted by Alphonse (2015), programs such as Affirmative Action and Social Inclusion (PAAIs) implemented at UNICAMP did not function as they should have, revealing that there was: a discrepancy between discourse and practice, as the policy remained in the realm of appearance (legal formalities); and a failure to achieve full inclusion, due to the lack of concrete support mechanisms.

From the perspective of historical-dialectical materialism, the studies in this area expose: formal achievements (statistical increase in access), symbolic recognition of rights, pressure met (social movements), structural exclusions (persistence of material inequalities), education as a commodity, and neoliberal adaptation (international metrics). Affirmative actions, although necessary, are insufficient to democratize higher education, as they operate within the limits of the capitalist system – which transforms rights into commodities.

Axis 3: affirmative actions partially provide democratization of access, as they cannot be considered the only option to solve problems of inequalities and exclusion

The studies in this area recognize affirmative actions as a partial advance in the democratization of higher education, but highlight their insufficiency to overcome structural inequalities. It is worth noting that the very distinction between affirmative actions (broad measures) and quotas (reserved spots) exposes a contradiction: in Brazilian practice, the policies have been reduced to quantitative access, ignoring permanence and institutional adaptation – as evidenced by Silva (2019) and Toubia (2016). The analysis, based on historical-dialectical materialism, reveals how these policies, unaccompanied by complementary measures, reproduce inherent contradictions of the capitalist system.

As Ferraz (2020, p. 93) rightly emphasized, the affirmative action policy in higher education, "by itself, is not capable of solving problems of inequalities and educational exclusion in the country, but it imposes itself as an important step in the pursuit of a fairer and more diverse society." Authors Pizza (2015) and Rosa (2016) demonstrate that universities, inserted in the capitalist logic, face insufficient structures to meet the demands of quota students. Moreover, the budgetary contingencies imposed by the State have weakened educational quality and the affirmative policies themselves.

In this context, Barbosa (2022, p. 105) reinforces the need for permanent monitoring of access policies, arguing that only in this way will it be possible to advance in the "approach of the racial agenda to the pluralization and democratization of the academic space," including the incorporation of anti-racist content and the monitoring of quota students. However, as studies point out, the same structure that enabled access did not guarantee the material conditions for permanence or educational quality.

This structural limitation is deepened by Dentz (2021) when analyzing that educational inequalities have roots in basic education, where the processes of exclusion of the less favored groups begin. The author emphasizes that "the accumulated school capital in this phase is decisive for performance in higher education", requiring policies that combat disparities from their initial stages. This perspective complements Toubia's (2016) view on the "the access–permanence–success triad", demonstrating that isolated affirmative actions at the higher education level are insufficient without an equitable educational foundation.

Toubia's (2016) research proposes a comprehensive approach, arguing that affirmative actions should be evaluated beyond access, as it is also necessary to monitor both permanence (dropout and student assistance) and academic success (graduation rates and professional insertion). Without this trinomial, the quotas become "bridges without continuity" – they allow access but do not provide effective social mobility.

It should also not be forgotten that another relevant factor in affirmative actions was related to student assistance policies, which needed to be combined with the quotas, as discussed by Santos (2014) in his study. According to the author, the democratization of access to university through affirmative policies for historically excluded groups needed to be linked to the very persistence of students through state policies. Thus, a contradiction was witnessed, as at the same time it "affirmed" the right to access higher education, it "denied" the conditions for persistence (economic support, pedagogical adaptations, and adequate infrastructure) to continue undergraduate courses.

Santos (2014) further notes that such policies must consider the inseparable relationship between education and the material and economic conditions required to cover expenses and meet academic requirements. In light of the issues raised earlier, the reports of students in Souza's (2017) research were understood to indicate that the quota policy has been successful but needs adjustments, especially in persistence policies.

From this understanding of the authors, during a critical synthesis, quantitative advances in access were observed, but structural limits, such as material conditions and fragmented actions, as can be seen in Table 3.

Table 3
Achievements and Structural Limits of Affirmative Actions

In addition to what was previously stated and the systematization presented in Table 3, we add that affirmative actions are necessary but not sufficient for educational democratization. Its effectiveness requires: 1) Integrated policies (student assistance and curricular adaptations); and 2) Questioning the capitalist logic that subordinates education to market interests.

Axis 4: there are clashes and contradictions in the processes of implementing quotas

The implementation of quotas in Brazilian higher education was marked by structural tensions, revealing ideological resistances and the persistence of the myth of racial democracy. The analysis, anchored in historical-dialectical materialism, highlights how these conflicts reflect deep contradictions in Brazilian social formation.

The experience of the State University of Goiás (UEG), studied by Santos Junior (2016), illustrates how these policies were often implemented in a top-down manner, through legislative decisions without proper articulation with university communities. This process resulted in weak measures, limited to formal access without ensuring conditions for permanence, revealing a contradiction between the inclusive discourse and institutional reality.

At the Federal University of Santa Maria (UFSM), the main issue concerned racial quotas, as highlighted by Lopes (2014). In this context, little was discussed regarding the relevance of reserving spots for indigenous people or for individuals with disabilities. However, when the possibility of allocating spots for black individuals was raised, the controversy became widespread. Furthermore, to understand the object in its entirety, the historical and social conditioning factors could not be detached, as positions evidenced by Lopes (2014) reaffirmed the slaveholding, clientelistic, and patriarchal past of the Brazilian state formation process, which, according to the author, does not recognize itself as a country marked by racial inequalities.

As Marçal (2016) aptly pointed out, due to reactionary movements manifested by various political agents in different political-institutional spaces, a relationship of "compliance" with the myth of racial equality was established. Based on this myth, structural racism was made invisible, and the idea that social reparation policies were unnecessary became ingrained in the collective imagination of society. This allowed for astonishments, or even contrary perceptions of such policies, as if there were no need for racial quotas; after all, everyone is considered equal. As José (2017) shows, when analyzing the statements of members of the Superior Council of the Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS) during the implementation of quotas, they ignored the right to education as a historical reparation, in addition to mechanisms that naturalized meritocratic inequality.

In this context of disputes, the works of Silva (2019) and Vieira (2022) make important contributions. In this context of disputes, Silva (2019) demonstrates that the quota policy of the Federal University of Acre (UFAC) became a field of interpretive battle, in which different social actors reconstruct the meaning of the law according to their interests. Vieira (2022), when analyzing the Federal University of Amapá (UNIFAP), reveals how the absence of monitoring systems – including the lack of data on admission, permanence, and completion of quota beneficiaries – transforms the policy into mere formality, incapable of promoting substantive changes.

Crosara (2017) emphasized that the democratization of access to higher education allowed for the realization of a fundamental right for groups that are underrepresented at this level of education. In the case of the Federal University of Uberlândia (UFU), the locus of the study of its research, in accordance with the minimum number of spots for groups benefiting from quotas, meant keeping them underrepresented relative to the Brazilian and Minas Gerais populations.

Fernandes' work (2006) emphasizes that one can still reflect on the paths taken and the possibilities of contributing to the building of alternatives for the democratization of public higher education in the country, as a tool to combat racism. However, as Araújo (2016) highlights, international organizations have exerted greater influence on the shaping of discourses on education as a human right. Thus, according to the author, for this right to be effectively exercised, it is necessary to combat discrimination in the educational sphere and to ensure equality in access and retention conditions for individuals and socially discriminated groups.

These cases demonstrate that the disputes surrounding quotas go beyond merely technical issues, expressing deeper struggles for power and recognition. As Araújo (2016) points out, even when the State incorporates progressive international norms, it often does so in a way that is disconnected from structural transformations.

This analysis reveals that the contradictions in the implementation of quotas are not isolated failures but symptoms of a society that has yet to resolve its foundational dilemma: how to combine legal formality with real social transformation. Conflicts are seen as a dialectical expression, where disputes are not mere errors along the way, but expressions of class and race struggle in a country that legislates on historical reparations but maintains conservative institutions; inclusive discourses are adopted, but there is a failure to redistribute opportunities effectively.

Final Considerations

The analysis of the authors' positions enabled an understanding of the State's perspective on Brazilian society when reflecting on affirmative actions in their entirety. Affirmative action in Brazil, while representing a symbolic advance in access to higher education, reproduces the logic of capital even as it contests it. These policies, in their appearance, affirm rights, but in their essence deny the structural transformation necessary for the real democratization of education.

Apparently, there is a fetishization of this aspect, as if there were truly a democratization of access for all popular layers to the university. On the one hand, they include historically excluded minorities in academic spaces; on the other hand, they keep them in subordinate conditions, whether through the precariousness of public universities, as evidenced by budget cuts, or through the quantitative and qualitative limitations on vacancies. The official discourse fetishizes the democratization of access, hiding the fact that meritocracy in selection processes still privileges those who already have better material and symbolic conditions.

From the perspective of historical-dialectical materialism, this phenomenon reveals how dominant language and discourse distort reality, transforming minimal concessions into supposed achievements of civilization. Education, commodified and massified, becomes a product of capitalism, in which the expansion of higher education does not translate into emancipation, but into the maintenance of social hierarchies.

In light of this, unveiling and combating such contradictions related to education as a right may help expand access to higher education for historically excluded segments of society in a universal manner. In this context, the defense of education as a universal right clashes with neoliberal international assumptions that prioritize dismantling public education. The Brazilian government, aligned with this agenda, not only reduces investments but also denies structural racism by propagating the myth of racial democracy.

In 2020, the federal government, in opposition to existing affirmative action educational public policies, through the Minister of Education – Abraham Bragança de Vasconcellos Weintraub – issued Ordinance No. 545 of June 16, 2020, revoking Normative Ordinance No. 13 of May 11, 2016, which encouraged Affirmative Action in Postgraduate Studies. In light of the negative repercussions of this procedure, through Ordinance No. 559/2020, of June 22, 2020, the Ministry of Education rendered Ordinance No. 545/2020 ineffective. Such a fact exemplifies the contradiction: even though the ordinance has been reversed, the measure exposed the performative and fragile nature of these policies, subject to the interests of a minimal state and an austerity agenda.

Finally, the analysis of the productions reveals that affirmative actions, although necessary, are not sufficient to overcome inequalities. They are embedded in a broader framework of neoliberal reforms that reinforce exclusion and naturalize disparities. True democratization requires not only expanding access but also ensuring material conditions for quality retention and completion, in addition to combating racism and the logic of commodification of education. As long as the Brazilian state is subordinated to the imperatives of capital, social policies will continue to be palliative, rather than instruments of radical transformation.

Availability of research data

The dataset supporting the results of this study is published in the article itself.

References

  • ALPHONSE, Fritznel. Análise do Programa de Ação Afirmativa e Inclusão Social (PAAIS) implementado pela UNICAMP no período de 2005-2014 2015. 379 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, 2015.
  • ARAÚJO, Rafaela Santos Venâncio de. Globalização e Política de Cotas para Ingresso na Educação Superior: análise da normativa de direitos humanos e de documentos internacionais. 2016. 118 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal da Paraíba, João Pessoa, 2016.
  • ÁVILA, Mariângela Mattos. O Significado das Cotas para Estudantes Negros do IFSC - campus São José 2012. 122 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, 2012.
  • BARBOSA, Maria Carolina Rosa Orlando. Avanços e Desafios nas Políticas de Promoção de Acesso e Permanência de Estudantes Negros (Cotistas) na UFSCar 2022. 121 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal de São Carlos, São Carlos, 2022.
  • BRAGA, Maria do Rosário de Fatima Fortes. Ações Afirmativas na Educação Superior: Análise de Significados de Políticas e Ações Institucionais para Acesso do Estudante Autodeclarado Negro nos Cursos de Medicina e Licenciatura em Matemática na Ufma. 2020. 143 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Universidade Federal do Maranhão, São Luís, 2020.
  • COLEN, Natália Silva. Uma universidade negra é possível? A criação da UFRB no contexto das políticas de ações afirmativas no Brasil. 2019. 143 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Faculdade de Educação, 2019.
  • CROSARA, Daniela de Melo. A Política Afirmativa na Educação Superior: contributos e dilemas no sistema de cotas da Lei 12.711/2012. 2017. 290 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Uberlândia, 2017.
  • DENTZ, Schirlei Russi Von. Desigualdades Escolares e Educação Superior: as Ações Afirmativas na Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina. 2021. 436 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, 2021.
  • DOEBBER, Michele. Reconhecer-se Diferente é a Condição de Entrada - tornar-se igual é a estratégia de permanência: das práticas institucionais à constituição de estudantes cotistas negros na UFRGS. 2011. 164 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, 2011.
  • ERIG, Marisa Helena. Estudantes Universitários em Contextos Emergentes: experiências de participantes da Política de Ação Afirmativa na UFRGS. 2016. 95 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, 2016.
  • FERNANDES, Fátima Lobato. Políticas de Ação Afirmativa e Acesso ao Ensino Superior: os impactos da introdução da lei de reserva de vagas na UERJ. 2006. 71 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, 2006.
  • FERRAZ, Maisa Oliveira Melo. O Programa de Ações Afirmativas da Universidade Estadual do Sudoeste da Bahia (UESB) na perspectiva de discentes, docentes e gestores. 2020. 211 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Estadual do Sudoeste da Bahia, Vitória da Conquista, 2020.
  • FIGUEIREDO, Erica Suruagy Assis de. As Ações Afirmativas na Educação Superior: política de inclusão à lógica do capital. 2008. 196 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal Fluminense, Niterói, 2008.
  • FIGUEREDO, Diogo Barbosa. Acesso ao Ensino Superior e Políticas Afirmativas: estudo da política de cotas nas Universidades públicas do Estado da Bahia. 2015. 135 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Economia Regional e Políticas Públicas) – Universidade Estadual de Santa Cruz, Ilhéus, 2015.
  • FREIRE, Jeane de Amorim. Ações Afirmativas no Contexto das Políticas Neoliberais: a implementação do sistema de cotas na UFAM. 2017. 160 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Serviço Social e Sustentabilidade na Amazônia) – Universidade Federal do Amazonas, Manaus, 2017.
  • GOMES, Joaquim Benedito Barbosa. Ação afirmativa e o princípio constitucional da igualdade. Rio de Janeiro: Renovar, 2001.
  • HAMÚ, Daura Rios Pedroso. Desigualdades, Direitos Humanos e Ações Afirmativas: história e revelações do Programa UFG Inclui. 2014. 211 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Goiás, Goiânia, 2014.
  • JOSÉ, Adriano Rodrigues. Processo de Institucionalização do Programa de Ações Afirmativas na UFRGS: embates, disputas e contradições. 2017. 143 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, 2017.
  • LOPES, Toni Ronei. Ações Afirmativas: a igualdade e o acesso pleno à educação superior dos grupos historicamente excluídos. 2014. 218 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal de Santa Maria, Santa Maria, 2014.
  • MARÇAL, José Antônio. Políticas Afirmativas para Negros nas Universidades Federais entre 2002-2012: processo e sentidos na UNB, UFPR e UFBA. 2016. 258 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Universidade Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, 2016.
  • MASSON, Gisele. As contribuições do método materialista histórico e dialético para a pesquisa sobre Políticas Educacionais. In. Seminário de Pesquisa em Educação da Região Sul, 9. 2012, Caxias do Sul. Anais [...]. Caxias do Sul: Anped Sul, 2012. p. 1-13.
  • NETTO, José Paulo. Introdução ao método de Marx com José Paulo Netto (primeira parte e segunda parte) - PPGPS/SER/UnB. Canal Iva Boschetti no YouTube. 2016. Disponível em: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WndNoqRiq8 Acesso em: 13 maio 2020.
    » https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WndNoqRiq8
  • OLIVEIRA, José Manoel Miranda de. Estudo das Possibilidades de Democratização do Acesso ao Ensino Superior: o caso do Tocantins. 1995. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal de Pernambuco, Pernambuco, 1995.
  • PEREIRA SANTOS, Marina Santos. A Universidade Mudou de Cor? Implementação das cotas e racismo institucional na UEMA. 2023. 189 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Universidade Federal do Pará, Belém, 2023.
  • PIZZA, Samira Nathalia. Programa de Ações Afirmativas da UFSCar: o processo de construção da política de reserva de vagas nos cursos de graduação. 2015. 112 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal de São Carlos, São Carlos, 2015.
  • ROSA, Aline Anjos da. A Implementação das Cotas Raciais e Sociais na UFGD e sua contribuição para a Política de Ações Afirmativas (2012-2014). 2016. 150 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal da Grande Dourados, Dourados, 2016.
  • ROSA, Claudia Cristina Borba de Barros da. A Implementação das Políticas Públicas de Ações Afirmativas na Universidade Tecnológica Federal do Paraná (UTFPR), Câmpus de Francisco Beltrão. 2019. 145 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade do Oeste do Paraná, Francisco Beltrão, 2019.
  • SANTANA, Jusciney Carvalho. Tem Preto de Jaleco Branco? Sobre Ações Afirmativas na Faculdade de Medicina na Universidade Federal de Alagoas. 2015. 237 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Universidade Federal de Alagoas, Maceió, 2015.
  • SANTOS JUNIOR, Ronaldo Rosa dos. Política de Cotas para Ingresso na Educação Superior Pública: 10 anos da Universidade Estadual de Goiás (2005-2015). 2016. 180 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Goiás, Goiânia, 2016.
  • SANTOS, Adilson Pereira dos. Implementação da Lei de Cotas em Três Universidades Mineiras. 2018. 221 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação, Conhecimento e Inclusão Social) – Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, 2018.
  • SANTOS, Sérgio Pereira dos. “Os ‘Intrusos’ e os ‘Outros’ Quebrando o Aquário e Mudando os Horizontes”: as relações de raça e classe na implementação das cotas sociais no processo seletivo para os cursos de graduação da UFES — 2006-2012. 2014. 390 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo, Vitória, 2014.
  • SILVA, Jessiane Gisele Barroso da. A Política de Cotas Raciais na UFAC e sua Materialização como Política de Acesso à Educação Superior. 2019. 116 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal do Acre, Rio Branco, 2019.
  • SOUZA, Eliane Almeida de. Dez Anos de Cotas na UFRGS: um estudo das Ações Afirmativas na perspectiva do acesso, permanência e empoderamento dos alunos negros diplomados. 2017. 253 f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, 2017.
  • TOUBIA, Ariane Andreia Teixeira. Políticas de Ações Afirmativas no Brasil: A UFSCar-Sorocaba como objeto de pesquisa. 2016. 169 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal de São Carlos, Sorocaba, 2016.
  • VIEIRA, Enilton Ferreira. LEI N. 12.711/2012: Trajetória Histórica, Limites da Ação Afirmativa e Aplicabilidade na Universidade Federal do Amapá - UNIFAP (2013 A 2020). 2022. 195 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Educação) – Universidade Federal do Amapá, 2022.

Correspondence

E-mail: maisamf@uesb.edu.br

Correspondence

E-mail: enniadebora@uesb.edu.br

Correspondence

E-mail: hilheno@hotmail.com

Editor in charge:

Iana Gomes de Lima

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    30 Oct 2026
  • Date of issue
    2026

History

  • Received
    28 July 2025
  • Accepted
    15 Oct 2025
location_on
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul - Faculdade de Educação Avenida Paulo Gama, s/n, Faculdade de Educação - Prédio 12201 - Sala 914, 90046-900 Porto Alegre/RS – Brasil, Tel.: (55 51) 3308-3268, Fax: (55 51) 3308-3985 - Porto Alegre - RS - Brazil
E-mail: educreal@ufrgs.br
rss_feed Stay informed of issues for this journal through your RSS reader
Go to top