LOGISTICS PROJECTS BASED ON RADIO FREQUENCY IDENTIFICATION: MULTI-CRITERIA ASSESSMENT OF BRAZILIAN AIRCRAFT INDUSTRY

Castro, Jefferson Inácio de; Muniz Jr., Jorge; Bernardes, Ednilson; Tramarico, Claudemir Leif

doi:10.1590/0101-7438.2021.041.00244928

Jefferson Inácio de Castro ^**Corresponding author

Universidade Estadual Paulista Júlio de Mesquita Filho Faculdade de Engenharia, Campus de Guaratinguetá. Av. Dr. Ariberto Pereira da Cunha, 333, 12516-410 Guaratinguetá, SP, Brazil - E-mail: jeffidcastro@gmail.com

https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9276-9516

Jorge Muniz Jr.

Universidade Estadual Paulista Júlio de Mesquita Filho Faculdade de Engenharia, Campus de Guaratinguetá. Av. Dr. Ariberto Pereira da Cunha, 333, 12516-410 Guaratinguetá, SP, Brazil - E-mail: jorge.muniz@unesp.br

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3496-0256

Ednilson Bernardes

West Virginia University, 1601 University Avenue, PO Box 6025, Morgantown, WV 26506, USA - E-mail: ednilson.bernardes@mail.wvu.edu

https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6782-7323

Claudemir Leif Tramarico

Universidade Estadual Paulista Júlio de Mesquita Filho Faculdade de Engenharia, Campus de Guaratinguetá. Av. Dr. Ariberto Pereira da Cunha, 333, 12516-410 Guaratinguetá, SP, Brazil - E-mail: claudemir.tramarico@unesp.br

https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9348-9391

*Corresponding author

#	Most cited articles	Journal	Proposed RFID approach	Method	Authorship
1	Integrating RFID and BIM technologies for mitigating risks and improving schedule performance of prefabricated house construction	Journal of Cleaner Production	Application of RFID enabled building information modelling platform	Case study	^{LI et al. (2017}35 LI CZ, ZHONG RY, XUE F, XU G, CHEN K, HUANG GG & SHEN GQ. 2017. Integrating RFID and BIM technologies for mitigating risks and improving schedule performance of prefabricated house construction. Journal of Cleaner Production, 165: 1048-1062.)
2	An RFID-based tracking system for denim production processes	The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology	Implementation of RFID including design, configuration and deployment	Case study	^{Oner et al. (2017}49 ONER M, USTUNDAG A & BUDAK A. 2017. An RFID-based tracking system for denim production processes. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 90(1-4): 591-604.)
3	RFID-Aided Tracking System to Improve Work Efficiency of Scaffold Supplier: Stock Management in Australasian Supply Chain	Journal of Construction Engineering and Management	Application of RFID-Aided tracking system	Case study	^{Moon et al. (2018}42 MOON S, XU S, HOU L, WU C, WANG X & TAM VW. 2018. RFID-aided tracking system to improve work efficiency of scaffold supplier: Stock management in Australasian supply chain. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 144(2): 04017115.)
4	Monitoring on-shelf availability, out-of-stock and product freshness through RFID in the fresh food supply chain	International Journal of RF Technologies	Implementation of RFID in a fresh food supply chain.	Case study	^{Bottani et al. (2017}6 BOTTANI E, BERTOLINI M, RIZZI A & ROMAGNOLI G. 2017. Monitoring on-shelf availability, out-of-stock and product freshness through RFID in the fresh food supply chain. International Journal of RF Technologies, 8(1-2): 33-55.)
5	Using look-ahead plans to improve material flow processes on construction projects when using BIM and RFID technologies	Construction Innovation	Propose a workflow using RFID and building information modelling	Simulation	^{Chen et al. (2020}9 CHEN Q, ADEY BT, HAAS C & HAL DM. 2020. Using look-ahead plans to improve material flow processes on construction projects when using BIM and RFID technologies. Construction Innovation, 20(3): 471-508.)
6	Improving logistics processes of surgical instruments: case of RFID technology	Business Process Management Journal	Implementation of RFID to improve the traceability of surgical instruments in a hospital environment	Case study	^{Moatari-Kazerouni & Bendavid (2017)}41 MOATARI-KAZEROUNI A & BENDAVID Y. 2017. Improving logistics processes of surgical instruments: case of RFID technology. Business Process Management Journal. 23(2): 448-466.
7	Building materials management system based on RFID technology	International Journal of RF Technologies	Propose and implement a closed-loop information flow to facilitate building materials based on RFID	Case study	^{Ren & Li (2018}59 REN Y & LI H. 2018. Building materials management system based on RFID technology. International Journal of RF Technologies , 9(1-2):63-74.)
8	State of the art of item-level RFID deployments in fashion and apparel retail	International Journal of RF Technologies	Present a literature overview of the current adoption of RFID technology in fashion and apparel retail	Content analysis study	^{Cilloni et al. (2019}8 CILLONI G, LEPORATI R, RIZZI A & ROMAGNOLI G. 2019. State of the art of item-level rfid deployments in fashion and apparel retail. International Journal of RF Technologies , 10(3-4): 65-88.)
9	Introducing a new support model for access control of road cargo vehicles at Brazilian ports through Radio Frequency Identification Technology (RFID)	Brazilian Journal of Urban Management	Propose a model for access control and optimization of cargo loading at ports based on RFID	Simulation	^{Bittencourt et al. (2018}5 BITTENCOURT R, VALENTE AM & LOBO E. 2018. Introducing a new support model for access control of road cargo vehicles at Brazilian ports through Radio Frequency Identification Technology (RFID). urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana, 10(3):)
10	Sharing information on public transport with RFID and NFC technologies: an application proposal	Brazilian Journalof Urban Management	Propose an application of smart bus using near field communication and RFID	Case study	^{Nassar & Vieira (2017}47 NASSAR V & VIEIRA MLH. 2017. O compartilhamento de informações no transporte público com as tecnologias RFID e NFC: uma proposta de aplicação. urbe. Revista Brasileira de Gestão Urbana , 9(2): 327-340.)

Project		Definition	Reference
A	Tracking loads along the supply chain	Location and staging information among supply chain	^{Attaran (2007}3 ATTARAN M. 2007. RFID: an enabler of supply chain operations. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 12(4): 249-257.)
			^{Bose & Yan (2011}7 BOSE I & YAN S. 2011. The green potential of RFID projects: a case-based analysis. It Professional, 13(1): 41-47.)
			^{Lee & Lee (2010}32 LEE I. & Lee BC. 2010. An investment evaluation of supply chain RFID technologies: A normative modeling approach. International Journal of Production Economics , 125(2): 313-323.)
			^{Lyu et al. (2009}39 LYU J, CHANG SY & CHEN TL. 2009. Integrating RFID with quality assurance system - Framework and applications. Expert Systems with Applications , 36: 10877-10882.)
			^{Sarac et al. (2010}64 SARAC A, ABSI N & DAUZÈRE-PÉRÈS S. 2010. A literature review on the impact of RFID technologies on supply chain management. International Journal of Production Economics , 128(1): 77-95.)
			^{Trebar et al. (2015}74 TREBAR M, LOTRIČ M & FONDA I. 2015. Use of RFID temperature monitoring to test and improve fish packing methods in styrofoam boxes. Journal of Food Engineering, 159: 66-75.)
			^{Wu et al. (2006}82 WU NC, NYSTROM MA, LIN TR & YU HU. 2006. Challenges to global RFID adoption. Technovation, 26: 1317-1323.)
			^{Zhou (2009}84 ZHOU W. 2009. RFID and item-level information visibility. European Journal of Operational Research , 198(1): 252-258.)
B	Automatic Inventory	Automatic verification during the process collecting data and counting products	^{Dutta et al. (2007}19 DUTTA A, LEE HL & WHANG S. 2007. RFID and operations management: technology, value, and incentives. Production and operations management, 16(5): 646-655.)
			^{Lee & Chan (2009}31 LEE CK & CHAN TM. 2009. Development of RFID-based reverse logistics system. Expert Systems with Applications , 36(5): 9299-9307.)
			^{Lee et al. (2004}30 LEE YM, CHENG F & LEUNG YT. 2004. Exploring the impact of RFID on supply chain dynamics in Proceedings of the 2004 Winter Simulation Conference, IEEE, 2: 1145-1152.)
			^{Lin et al. (2011}37 LIN CS, CHEN LS & HSU CC. 2011. An innovative approach for RFID product functions development. Expert Systems with Applications , 38(12): 15523-15533.)
			^{Lyu et al. (2009}39 LYU J, CHANG SY & CHEN TL. 2009. Integrating RFID with quality assurance system - Framework and applications. Expert Systems with Applications , 36: 10877-10882.)
			^{Nativi & Lee (2012}48 NATIVI JJ & LEE S. 2012. Impact of RFID information-sharing strategies on a decentralized supply chain with reverse logistics operations. International Journal of Production Economics , 136(2): 366-377.)
			^{Ngai et al. (2007)}45 NGAI EWT, CHENG TCE, LAI KH, CHAI PYF, CHOI YS. & Sin, RKY. 2007. Development of an RFID-based traceability system: experiences and lessons learned from an aircraft engineering company. Production and operations management , 16(5): 554-568.
			^{Ozguven & Ozbay (2015}50 OZGUVEN EE & OZBAY K. 2015. An RFID-based inventory management framework for emergency relief operations. Transportation research part C: emerging technologies, 57: 166-187.)
			^{Rekik et al. (2008}58 REKIK Y, SAHIN E & DALLERY Y. 2008. Analysis of the impact of the RFID technology on reducing product misplacement errors at retail stores. International Journal of Production Economics , 112(1): 264-278.)
			^{Wang et al. (2008}79 WANG SJ, LIU SF & WANG WL. 2008. The simulated impact of RFID-enabled supply chain on pull-based inventory replenishment in TFT-LCD industry. International Journal of Production Economics , 112(2): 570-586.)
C	Vehicles/assets/equipment identification	Identify and control vehicles, asset in general and equipment in the process	^{Attaran (2007}3 ATTARAN M. 2007. RFID: an enabler of supply chain operations. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 12(4): 249-257.)
			^{Lin et al. (2011}37 LIN CS, CHEN LS & HSU CC. 2011. An innovative approach for RFID product functions development. Expert Systems with Applications , 38(12): 15523-15533.)
			^{Lyu et al. (2009}39 LYU J, CHANG SY & CHEN TL. 2009. Integrating RFID with quality assurance system - Framework and applications. Expert Systems with Applications , 36: 10877-10882.)
			^{Dai et al. (2015}15 DAI H, GE L & ZHOU W. 2015. A design method for supply chain traceability systems with aligned interests. International Journal of Production Economics , 170: 14-24.)
D	Reverse logistics	Identify and control products or packages in a reverse logistics process	^{Lee & Chan (2009}31 LEE CK & CHAN TM. 2009. Development of RFID-based reverse logistics system. Expert Systems with Applications , 36(5): 9299-9307.)
			^{Nativi & Lee (2012}48 NATIVI JJ & LEE S. 2012. Impact of RFID information-sharing strategies on a decentralized supply chain with reverse logistics operations. International Journal of Production Economics , 136(2): 366-377.)
			^{Trappey et al. (2010}73 TRAPPEY AJ, TRAPPEY CV & WU CR. 2010. Genetic algorithm dynamic performance evaluation for RFID reverse logistic management. Expert Systems with Applications , 37(11): 7329-7335.)
E	Decision support/predictive logistics (risk and uncertainty management in the process)	Use data and RFID information available to support decision in a supply chain	^{Attaran (2007}3 ATTARAN M. 2007. RFID: an enabler of supply chain operations. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 12(4): 249-257.)
			^{Dutta et al. (2007}19 DUTTA A, LEE HL & WHANG S. 2007. RFID and operations management: technology, value, and incentives. Production and operations management, 16(5): 646-655.)
			^{Nativi & Lee (2012}48 NATIVI JJ & LEE S. 2012. Impact of RFID information-sharing strategies on a decentralized supply chain with reverse logistics operations. International Journal of Production Economics , 136(2): 366-377.)
			^{Ozguven & Ozbay (2015}50 OZGUVEN EE & OZBAY K. 2015. An RFID-based inventory management framework for emergency relief operations. Transportation research part C: emerging technologies, 57: 166-187.)
			^{Trappey et al. (2010}73 TRAPPEY AJ, TRAPPEY CV & WU CR. 2010. Genetic algorithm dynamic performance evaluation for RFID reverse logistic management. Expert Systems with Applications , 37(11): 7329-7335.)
F	Pallets incoming (dense readings)	Read a huge quantity of boxes in a pallet avoiding unpacking/deconsolidation process	^{Attaran (2007}3 ATTARAN M. 2007. RFID: an enabler of supply chain operations. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 12(4): 249-257.)
			^{Dutta et al. (2007}19 DUTTA A, LEE HL & WHANG S. 2007. RFID and operations management: technology, value, and incentives. Production and operations management, 16(5): 646-655.)
			^{Ngai et al. (2007)}45 NGAI EWT, CHENG TCE, LAI KH, CHAI PYF, CHOI YS. & Sin, RKY. 2007. Development of an RFID-based traceability system: experiences and lessons learned from an aircraft engineering company. Production and operations management , 16(5): 554-568.
			^{Sarac et al. (2010}64 SARAC A, ABSI N & DAUZÈRE-PÉRÈS S. 2010. A literature review on the impact of RFID technologies on supply chain management. International Journal of Production Economics , 128(1): 77-95.)
			^{Véreonneau & Roy (2009)}77 VÉRONNEAU S & ROY J. 2009. RFID benefits, costs, and possibilities: The economical analysis of RFID deployment in a cruise corporation global service supply chain. International Journal of Production Economics , 122 (2): 692-702.
G	Industrial process automation (in-out portals)	Automatic status and location definition using RFID process	^{Attaran (2007}3 ATTARAN M. 2007. RFID: an enabler of supply chain operations. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 12(4): 249-257.)
			Daí & Tseng (2012)
			^{Hellström & Wiberg (2010}27 HELLSTRÖM D & WIBERG M. 2010. Improving inventory accuracy using RFID technology: a case study. Assembly Automation, 30(4): 345-351.)
	Incoming/Storage/Inventory/Segregation/Expedition		^{Lim et al. (2013}36 LIM MK, BAHR W & LEUNG SC. 2013. RFID in the warehouse: A literature analysis (1995-2010) of its applications, benefits, challenges and future trends. International Journal of Production Economics , 145(1): 409-430.)
			^{Ngai et al. (2007)}45 NGAI EWT, CHENG TCE, LAI KH, CHAI PYF, CHOI YS. & Sin, RKY. 2007. Development of an RFID-based traceability system: experiences and lessons learned from an aircraft engineering company. Production and operations management , 16(5): 554-568.
			^{Ustundag & Tanyas (2009}76 USTUNDAG A & TANYAS M. 2009. The impacts of radio frequency identification (RFID) technology on supply chain costs. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 45(1): 29-38.)
			^{Véreonneau & Roy (2009)}77 VÉRONNEAU S & ROY J. 2009. RFID benefits, costs, and possibilities: The economical analysis of RFID deployment in a cruise corporation global service supply chain. International Journal of Production Economics , 122 (2): 692-702.
H	Process materials recycling management	Identify and control waste-controlled materials process	^{Attaran (2007}3 ATTARAN M. 2007. RFID: an enabler of supply chain operations. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 12(4): 249-257.)
H	Process materials recycling management	Identify and control waste-controlled materials process	^{Bose & Yan (2011}7 BOSE I & YAN S. 2011. The green potential of RFID projects: a case-based analysis. It Professional, 13(1): 41-47.)
I	High added value pieces management	Identify and control high value asset in the process	^{Ngai et al. (2007)}45 NGAI EWT, CHENG TCE, LAI KH, CHAI PYF, CHOI YS. & Sin, RKY. 2007. Development of an RFID-based traceability system: experiences and lessons learned from an aircraft engineering company. Production and operations management , 16(5): 554-568.
J	Automatic replacement - Supply Chain Pull Systems/ Support to JIT	Automatic replenishment requisition using RFID information	^{Attaran (2007}3 ATTARAN M. 2007. RFID: an enabler of supply chain operations. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 12(4): 249-257.)
J		Automatic replenishment requisition using RFID information	^{Wang et al. (2008}79 WANG SJ, LIU SF & WANG WL. 2008. The simulated impact of RFID-enabled supply chain on pull-based inventory replenishment in TFT-LCD industry. International Journal of Production Economics , 112(2): 570-586.)
K	Incoming with item segregation/separation	Identify, select and sort material in receiving process	^{Lee & Chan (2009}31 LEE CK & CHAN TM. 2009. Development of RFID-based reverse logistics system. Expert Systems with Applications , 36(5): 9299-9307.)
L	In-truck inventory	Monitor material during transportation process	^{Lee & Chan (2009}31 LEE CK & CHAN TM. 2009. Development of RFID-based reverse logistics system. Expert Systems with Applications , 36(5): 9299-9307.)
L	In-truck inventory	Monitor material during transportation process	^{Trebar et al. (2015}74 TREBAR M, LOTRIČ M & FONDA I. 2015. Use of RFID temperature monitoring to test and improve fish packing methods in styrofoam boxes. Journal of Food Engineering, 159: 66-75.)
M	Information traffic via RFID (component/process data) without Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)	Share information among supply chain using RFID storage capability	^{Lee & Chan (2009}31 LEE CK & CHAN TM. 2009. Development of RFID-based reverse logistics system. Expert Systems with Applications , 36(5): 9299-9307.)
M			^{Ngai et al. (2007)}45 NGAI EWT, CHENG TCE, LAI KH, CHAI PYF, CHOI YS. & Sin, RKY. 2007. Development of an RFID-based traceability system: experiences and lessons learned from an aircraft engineering company. Production and operations management , 16(5): 554-568.

Attribute		Definition	Reference
1	Cost	This attribute has definitions: the cost to implement RFID technology as a challenge and saving in you process applying the technology	^{Attaran (2007}3 ATTARAN M. 2007. RFID: an enabler of supply chain operations. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 12(4): 249-257.)
			^{Dai et al. (2015}15 DAI H, GE L & ZHOU W. 2015. A design method for supply chain traceability systems with aligned interests. International Journal of Production Economics , 170: 14-24.)
			^{Lee & Chan (2009}31 LEE CK & CHAN TM. 2009. Development of RFID-based reverse logistics system. Expert Systems with Applications , 36(5): 9299-9307.)
			^{Lee Lee (2010}32 LEE I. & Lee BC. 2010. An investment evaluation of supply chain RFID technologies: A normative modeling approach. International Journal of Production Economics , 125(2): 313-323.)
2	Operational efficiency	This attribute is related to productivity. The relation between resource and production.	^{Dutta et al. (2007}19 DUTTA A, LEE HL & WHANG S. 2007. RFID and operations management: technology, value, and incentives. Production and operations management, 16(5): 646-655.)
			^{Lee & Chan (2009}31 LEE CK & CHAN TM. 2009. Development of RFID-based reverse logistics system. Expert Systems with Applications , 36(5): 9299-9307.)
			^{Véreonneau & Roy (2009)}77 VÉRONNEAU S & ROY J. 2009. RFID benefits, costs, and possibilities: The economical analysis of RFID deployment in a cruise corporation global service supply chain. International Journal of Production Economics , 122 (2): 692-702.
3	Information	Level of visibility, tracking and information sharing among the supply chain.	^{Zhou (2009}84 ZHOU W. 2009. RFID and item-level information visibility. European Journal of Operational Research , 198(1): 252-258.)
			^{Dai et al. (2015}15 DAI H, GE L & ZHOU W. 2015. A design method for supply chain traceability systems with aligned interests. International Journal of Production Economics , 170: 14-24.)
			^{Lim et al. (2013}36 LIM MK, BAHR W & LEUNG SC. 2013. RFID in the warehouse: A literature analysis (1995-2010) of its applications, benefits, challenges and future trends. International Journal of Production Economics , 145(1): 409-430.)
			^{Lee & Lee (2010}32 LEE I. & Lee BC. 2010. An investment evaluation of supply chain RFID technologies: A normative modeling approach. International Journal of Production Economics , 125(2): 313-323.)
			^{Nativi & Lee (2012}48 NATIVI JJ & LEE S. 2012. Impact of RFID information-sharing strategies on a decentralized supply chain with reverse logistics operations. International Journal of Production Economics , 136(2): 366-377.)
4	Quality	Quantity of errors in the process and process reliability.	Daí & Tseng (2012)
			^{Dutta et al. (2007}19 DUTTA A, LEE HL & WHANG S. 2007. RFID and operations management: technology, value, and incentives. Production and operations management, 16(5): 646-655.)
			^{Hellström & Wiberg (2010}27 HELLSTRÖM D & WIBERG M. 2010. Improving inventory accuracy using RFID technology: a case study. Assembly Automation, 30(4): 345-351.)
			^{Lim et al. (2013}36 LIM MK, BAHR W & LEUNG SC. 2013. RFID in the warehouse: A literature analysis (1995-2010) of its applications, benefits, challenges and future trends. International Journal of Production Economics , 145(1): 409-430.)
			^{Rekik et al. (2008}58 REKIK Y, SAHIN E & DALLERY Y. 2008. Analysis of the impact of the RFID technology on reducing product misplacement errors at retail stores. International Journal of Production Economics , 112(1): 264-278.)
			^{Ustundag & Tanyas (2009}76 USTUNDAG A & TANYAS M. 2009. The impacts of radio frequency identification (RFID) technology on supply chain costs. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 45(1): 29-38.)
			^{Wang et al. (2008}79 WANG SJ, LIU SF & WANG WL. 2008. The simulated impact of RFID-enabled supply chain on pull-based inventory replenishment in TFT-LCD industry. International Journal of Production Economics , 112(2): 570-586.)
5	Technology	Regulations and standards available, knowledge of the technology and their benefits and restrictions; equipment and installation required to apply RFID in the process.	^{Bose & Yan (2011}7 BOSE I & YAN S. 2011. The green potential of RFID projects: a case-based analysis. It Professional, 13(1): 41-47.)
			^{Lee & Chan (2009}31 LEE CK & CHAN TM. 2009. Development of RFID-based reverse logistics system. Expert Systems with Applications , 36(5): 9299-9307.)
			^{Lim et al. (2013}36 LIM MK, BAHR W & LEUNG SC. 2013. RFID in the warehouse: A literature analysis (1995-2010) of its applications, benefits, challenges and future trends. International Journal of Production Economics , 145(1): 409-430.)
			^{Lee & Lee (2010}32 LEE I. & Lee BC. 2010. An investment evaluation of supply chain RFID technologies: A normative modeling approach. International Journal of Production Economics , 125(2): 313-323.)
			^{Ngai et al. (2007)}45 NGAI EWT, CHENG TCE, LAI KH, CHAI PYF, CHOI YS. & Sin, RKY. 2007. Development of an RFID-based traceability system: experiences and lessons learned from an aircraft engineering company. Production and operations management , 16(5): 554-568.
			^{Wu et al. (2006}82 WU NC, NYSTROM MA, LIN TR & YU HU. 2006. Challenges to global RFID adoption. Technovation, 26: 1317-1323.)
6	Customer satisfaction	The level of satisfaction of your customer in the process.	^{Lim et al. (2013}36 LIM MK, BAHR W & LEUNG SC. 2013. RFID in the warehouse: A literature analysis (1995-2010) of its applications, benefits, challenges and future trends. International Journal of Production Economics , 145(1): 409-430.)
6	Customer satisfaction	The level of satisfaction of your customer in the process.	^{Ngai et al. (2007)}45 NGAI EWT, CHENG TCE, LAI KH, CHAI PYF, CHOI YS. & Sin, RKY. 2007. Development of an RFID-based traceability system: experiences and lessons learned from an aircraft engineering company. Production and operations management , 16(5): 554-568.
7	Cycle Time	This attribute is the time spend in the process including idle time and inventory process.	^{Sarac et al. (2010}64 SARAC A, ABSI N & DAUZÈRE-PÉRÈS S. 2010. A literature review on the impact of RFID technologies on supply chain management. International Journal of Production Economics , 128(1): 77-95.)
7	Cycle Time		^{Trappey et al. (2010}73 TRAPPEY AJ, TRAPPEY CV & WU CR. 2010. Genetic algorithm dynamic performance evaluation for RFID reverse logistic management. Expert Systems with Applications , 37(11): 7329-7335.)
8	Safety	Include reliability, integrity and availability. Data confidentiality and cargo integrity is related to this attribute.	^{Ngaia et al. (2008}46 NGAI EWT, MOON KK, RIGGINS FJ & CANDACE YY. 2008. RFID research: An academic literature review (1995-2005) and future research directions. International Journal of Production Economics , 112(2): 510-520.)
8	Safety		^{Trappey et al. (2010}73 TRAPPEY AJ, TRAPPEY CV & WU CR. 2010. Genetic algorithm dynamic performance evaluation for RFID reverse logistic management. Expert Systems with Applications , 37(11): 7329-7335.)
9	Sustainability	Environmental, social and economic aspects involved in the process.	^{Bose & Yan (2011}7 BOSE I & YAN S. 2011. The green potential of RFID projects: a case-based analysis. It Professional, 13(1): 41-47.)
			^{Lim et al. (2013}36 LIM MK, BAHR W & LEUNG SC. 2013. RFID in the warehouse: A literature analysis (1995-2010) of its applications, benefits, challenges and future trends. International Journal of Production Economics , 145(1): 409-430.)
			^{Nativi & Lee (2012}48 NATIVI JJ & LEE S. 2012. Impact of RFID information-sharing strategies on a decentralized supply chain with reverse logistics operations. International Journal of Production Economics , 136(2): 366-377.)

Item	Value
Number of articles	21
Number of cited references	144
Average of citation	7
h-index	6

Function/Experience	up to 5 years	up to 10 years	more than 10 years
Engineer /Expert	0	3	2
Supervisor	1	3	3
Manager/Director	1	3	7

	CO	CS	CY	IN	OE	QU	SA	SU	TE
Cost (CO)	1	0.40	1.01	1.54	1.35	0.51	0.32	1.83	1.25
Customer Satisfaction (CS)	2.50	1	2.88	3.32	3.01	1.38	0.49	3.23	3.50
Cycle (CY)	0.99	0.35	1	1	0.86	0.53	0.33	1.70	1.31
Information (IN)	0.65	0.30	1	1	0.77	0.34	0.43	1.78	0.94
Operational Efficiency (OE)	0.74	0.33	1.17	1.29	1	0.48	0.3	1.91	1.48
Quality (QU)	1.96	0.73	1.89	2.95	2.08	1	0.89	3.62	2.28
Safety (SA)	3.10	2.02	3.04	2.35	3.34	1.13	1	6.38	5.26
Sustainability (SU)	0.55	0.31	0.59	0.56	0.52	0.28	0.16	1	0.90
Technology (TE)	0.80	0.29	0.76	1.06	0.68	0.44	0.19	1.12	1

	Availability	Integrity	Reliability
Availability	1	0.38	0.55
Integrity	2.61	1	0.78
Reliability	1.83	1.28	1

	Business value	CO2 reduction	Reuse/ recycling	Social responsibility
Business value	1	1.53	2.31	1.40
CO2 reduction	0.65	1	0.68	0.66
Reuse/recycling	0.43	1.48	1	0.48
Social responsibility	0.71	1.51	2.09	1

	Integration	Management/ Tracking	Visibility
Integration	1	0.48	1.85
Management/Tracking	2.09	1	1.7
Visibility	0.54	0.59	1

	Infrastructure	Standardization	Technology development/updating
Infrastructure	1	0.94	0.75
Standardization	1.06	1	0.71
Technology development/updating	1.34	1.41	1

Attribute	Normalization
Cost	0.082
Customer satisfaction	0.191
Cycle	0.073
Information	0.066
Operational efficiency	0.076
Quality	0.160
Safety	0.250
Sustainability	0.044
Technology	0.057

Level	Importance
Absolute	5
Very large	4
Large	3
Small	2
No	1

Project/ Attribute	Cost		Customer	Cycle		Information			Efficiency	Quality		Safety			Sustainability				Technology
	Benefit	Challenge	Customer satisfaction	Waiting time	time time	Visibility	Management/Tracking	Integration	Operational efficiency	Error reduction	Reliability	Reliability	Integrity	Availability	Reuse/Recycling	Social Responsibility	Business value	CO2 reduction	Standardization	Infrastructure	Updating or Development
P1.Tracking in the supply chain	3	3	3	2	2	4	4	3	3	3	4	2	3	3	2	2	3	1	3	2	2
P2.Automatic inventory	4	3	3	3	4	4	4	3	4	4	4	2	4	4	1	1	4	1	4	2	2
P3.Components and assets identification	2	3	2	2	3	4	4	3	3	3	4	2	4	4	2	1	3	2	4	2	3
P4.Reverse logistics	2	3	3	2	3	4	4	4	4	4	4	3	3	3	2	2	3	2	3	2	2
P5.Decision support/predictive logistics	3	3	3	4	3	4	4	4	4	4	4	2	3	4	2	1	3	2	4	2	3
P6.Pallets receiving (dense Reading)	3	3	2	3	3	3	3	3	4	4	4	2	3	4	2	1	3	2	4	2	3
P7.Industrial process automation - Income inspection	3	3	3	3	3	4	4	4	4	4	4	3	3	4	2	1	3	2	3	2	3
P8.Industrial process automation Storage	3	2	3	2	4	4	4	3	4	4	4	2	3	4	2	1	3	2	4	2	3
P9.Industrial process automation Picking	3	3	2	3	4	4	4	3	4	4	4	2	3	4	2	1	3	2	4	2	3
P10.Industrial process automation Expedition	3	3	3	3	4	4	4	3	4	4	4	2	3	4	2	1	3	2	4	2	3
P11.Automatic resupplying	3	2	2	3	3	4	3	3	3	3	3	3	2	3	2	1	3	2	3	2	2
P12.Monitoring items that are inside transportation vehicles	2	2	2	2	2	3	3	3	3	3	3	2	3	3	2	1	2	2	2	2	2
P13.Data transfer by RFID (without EDI)	3	3	3	2	3	4	4	4	4	4	3	3	3	3	2	1	3	1	4	2	3
P14.Recycling process management	2	2	2	2	3	3	3	3	2	3	3	2	2	2	3	2	2	2	2	2	2
P15.Monitoring of high value items	2	4	3	2	3	4	4	3	4	3	4	2	3	3	2	1	4	1	4	2	3

Project		Normalized	Idealized	Ranking
P2	Automatic inventory	0.0766	1,000	1
P7	Industrial processes automation - Income inspection	0.0749	0.978	2
P10	Industrial processes automation Expedition	0.0734	0.9588	3
P5	Decision support/ Predictive logistics	0.0731	0.9548	4
P8	Industrial processes automation storage	0.0717	0.9371	5
P4	Reverse logistics	0.0717	0.9362	6
P13	Data transfer by RFID (without EDI)	0.0703	0.9179	7
P15	High value items monitoring	0.0691	0.9031	8
P9	Industrial processes automation - Picking	0.0683	0.8919	9
P6	Pallets receiving (dense reading)	0.0656	0.8574	10
P3	Components and assets identification	0.0646	0.8437	11
P1	Supply chain tracking	0.0645	0.8431	12
P11	Automatic resupply	0.0564	0.7366	13
P12	Monitoring of items inside transportation vehicle	0.0519	0.6783	14
P14	Recycling process management	0.0479	0.626	15

Project	Description
P1	Supply chain tracking
P2	Automatic inventory
P3	Components and assets identification
P4	Reverse logistics
P5	Decision support/ Predictive logistics
P6	Pallets receiving (dense reading)
P7	Industrial processes automation - Income inspection
P8	Industrial processes automation - storage
P9	Industrial processes automation - Picking
P10	Industrial processes automation - Expedition
P11	Automatic resupply
P12	Monitoring of items inside transportation vehicle
P13	Data transfer by RFID (without EDI)
P14	Recycling process management
P15	High value items monitoring

[1] *Corresponding author

Brasil

Brasil

LOGISTICS PROJECTS BASED ON RADIO FREQUENCY IDENTIFICATION: MULTI-CRITERIA ASSESSMENT OF BRAZILIAN AIRCRAFT INDUSTRY

ABSTRACT