Abstract
This study examines how Black students and alumni from federal universities, who benefited from affirmative action quotas, interpret the effects of this policy on their professional trajectories and social mobility. In this qualitative study, 124 interviews were analyzed by thematic analysis. The results indicate that higher education expands opportunities for professional integration, promotes intergenerational mobility, and reshapes family trajectories. However, these advances coexist with labor market racialization processes, expressed in the delegitimization of competence, occupational segmentation, and restricted access to prestigious positions. Social mobility is possible, but it remains constrained by racial inequalities.
Keywords
affirmative action policy; social mobility; career trajectories; racial inequalities; higher education
Resumo
Este artigo analisa como estudantes e egressos negros cotistas de universidades federais interpretam os efeitos da política de cotas em suas trajetórias profissionais e na mobilidade social. Trata-se de pesquisa qualitativa, baseada em 124 entrevistas analisadas por Análise Temática. Os resultados indicam que a formação superior amplia oportunidades de inserção profissional, favorece a mobilidade intergeracional e reconfigura trajetórias familiares. Contudo, esses avanços coexistem com processos de racialização no mercado de trabalho, expressos na deslegitimação da competência, na segmentação ocupacional e na restrição do acesso a posições de prestígio. Conclui-se que a mobilidade social é possível, mas permanece condicionada pelas desigualdades raciais.
Palavras-chave
política de cotas; mobilidade social; trajetórias profissionais; desigualdades raciais; ensino superior
Resumen
Este estudio analiza cómo los estudiantes y egresados negros de universidades federales que se beneficiaron de las cuotas de acción afirmativa interpretan los efectos de esa política en sus trayectorias profesionales y su movilidad social. En este estudio cualitativo se analizaron 124 entrevistas mediante análisis temático. Los resultados revelan que la educación superior amplía las oportunidades de integración profesional, promueve la movilidad intergeneracional y transforma las trayectorias familiares. Sin embargo, estos avances coexisten con procesos de racialización en el mercado laboral, que se manifiestan en la deslegitimación de la competencia, la segmentación ocupacional y el acceso restringido a puestos de prestigio. La movilidad social es posible, pero sigue condicionada por las desigualdades raciales.
Palabras clave
política de acción afirmativa; movilidad social; trayectorias profesionales; desigualdades raciales; educación superior
Introduction
This study analyzes how Black students and alumni1 who benefited from quota systems at federal universities interpret the effects of the quota policy on their professional trajectories and social mobility processes. The quota policy, established by Law no. 12,711/2012, set aside places in federal higher education institutions to expand access for students from public schools, with distribution based on income and self-declared race/color (Brasil, 2012). Later, Law no. 13,409/2016 included people with disabilities into the system (Brasil, 2016). After the decennial review, Law no. 14,723/2023 improved that policy by including quilombolas, establishing that quota candidates first compete for open (non-reserved) places and are considered for reserved places only if not admitted through general admission, expanding the ways of proving completion of high school, prioritizing quota students in retention measures, and encouraging affirmative action in graduate programs (Brasil, 2023).
This set of legal changes and the progress of affirmative action have contributed to changing the historically elitist profile of federal universities, expanding access for Black and low-income students from public schools and promoting greater social and racial diversity in these institutions (Andrews, 2014; Almeida & Ernica, 2015). The literature has highlighted the positive impacts of the quota policy regarding access democratization and student profile diversification, consolidating it as one of the main recent transformations in Brazilian higher education (Gomes et al., 2021; Golgher, 2021; Paula et al., 2022; Ribeiro, 2023; Rodrigues & Barcelos, 2020; Santos et al., 2024; Silame et al., 2020).
However, despite widely recognized advances in access and diversity, the effects of the quota policy on the career trajectories of its beneficiaries, including students undergoing professional integration processes and alumni from undergraduate and graduate programs, remain underexplored. In particular, it remains poorly understood how Black students and alumni who benefit from affirmative action interpret the effects of access to higher education on their career paths, professional expectations, and social mobility, especially in a labor market that has been historically structured by racial inequalities. This gap is significant because entering public higher education can change educational trajectories, but it does not by itself overcome the structural inequalities that shape the world of work. In Brazil, racial hierarchy remains present in the division of labor, socioeconomic inequalities, access to prestigious positions, and the production of knowledge (Costa, 2020), indicating that the racial division of labor is historical and structural. More than verifying whether the policy has expanded access to higher education, it is important to understand the extent to which this access translates in to effective social mobility given the tensions between the democratization of educational opportunities and the persistence of structural racism in the labor market.
This study contributes to this debate by analyzing the interpretations of Black students and alumni who benefited from quotas regarding the effects of the quota policy on their professional trajectories and social mobility processes. It stems from the understanding that social mobility is a relational, gradual, and contested process rather than an automatic result of schooling.
Theoretical framework
Structural racism, race relations, and inequalities in the labor market
The contemporary understanding of racism in Brazil is based on the perspective of structural racism, which goes beyond individual acts of discrimination (Oliveira, 2021). This perspective is in line with a well-established tradition in Brazilian social sciences inaugurated by Hasenbalg (1979), who empirically showed the persistence of racial inequalities beyond differences in class and social origin. However, as Guimarães et al. (2024) argue, sociological research should empirically investigate how racism operates in social practices. The weakness of the individualistic view of racism has been pointed out by Almeida (2018), whereas Bento (2022) has shown how the narcissistic pact of Whiteness naturalizes the privileges of White people in education and work. Linked to the legacies of slavery (Gouvêa & Oliveira, 2020), these dynamics sustain persistent mechanisms of occupational segmentation, wage differentiation, and exclusion from positions of power.
For Hasenbalg (1979), racial discrimination constitutes a mechanism for reproducing inequalities in the capitalist order, and his contribution consolidated a sociology of racism guided by empirical evidence (Campos, 2024).As Campos (2024) notes, although this tradition has broadened our knowledge of the effects of racism on social stratification, little is known about how it concretely operates in institutional practices. This study lies within this gap as it analyzes participants’ reported professional experiences.
We adopt Guimarães’ (2024) understanding that racism does not dispense with the idea of race or human agency. Thus, structural racism, embedded in institutions, norms, and organizational practices, is perpetuated via actions, discourses, and interactions that racialize individuals and reproduce inequalities, manifesting itself as direct discrimination and as naturalized differential treatment, symbolic invisibility, and systematic restriction of opportunities (Guimarães et al., 2024).
Data from the Inter-Union Department of Statistics and Socio-Economic Studies (DIEESE, 2023) show that the Brazilian labor market remains structured by the perpetuation of racial inequalities. Employment opportunities and career advancement remain unequal for the Black population, especially for Black women, who face intersecting discrimination based on race and gender. Although they represent 56.1% of the working-age population, Black individuals account for 65.1% of the unemployed, indicating greater exposure to unemployment.
Even when they are part of the labor market, they face more precarious conditions. Nearly half of the employed Black population is in unprotected jobs, reaching 46.5% and 45.8% among Black women and men, respectively, whereas this proportion totals 34% among non-Black people. Moreover, one in six employed Black women works as a domestic worker, highlighting their concentration in historically undervalued positions (DIEESE, 2023).
Pay disparities also persist. On average, Black workers earn 39.2% less than non-Black workers, and the average income of the Black population across all job positions is lower than that of the non-Black population. Inequality worsens when we look at access to positions of greater prestige and decision-making power: only 2.1% of Black workers, both men and women, held executive or managerial positions, compared with 5.5% among non-Black men (DIEESE, 2023).
Such evidence reveals that racial exclusion in the labor market is not limited to income inequality, being expressed in systematic forms of precariousness and restriction of professional horizons, approaching the condition of “death in life” described by Mbembe (2018). These indicators are in line with the findings of this study by highlighting, based on participants’ perspectives, how these inequalities manifest in professional trajectories. In this context, the career paths of Black students and alumni who benefited from affirmative action quotas unfold within a labor market that has been historically structured by racial inequalities that limit the capacity of higher education to produce full social mobility on its own.
Quota policy and social mobility
The quota policy, established by Law no. 12,711/2012 (and subsequently improved by Laws no. 13,409/2016 and no. 14,723/2023) increased the number of reserved places in federal higher education institutions, strengthened retention mechanisms, and incorporated new beneficiary groups. As Gomes et al. (2021) argue, affirmative action constitutes one of the main democratic changes in recent Brazilian education. Official data show that these policies have expanded access for low-income students from public schools and those who self-identify as Black, making universities more diverse and socially representative (Law no16.914/2024).
According to Mendonça and Aranha (2020), the quota policy should be understood as an instrument for promoting equity and social justice insofar as it seeks to address inequalities historically produced by slavery and institutionalized racism in Brazil. The authors point out that the exclusion of the Black population from higher education stems from structural processes that have restricted their access to education, skilled work, and prestigious positions for generations. Thus, reserved places democratize public higher education by recognizing historical inequalities and promoting material equality.
Barbosa (2019) argues that schooling has become established as an important resource for social positioning. Gomes et al. (2021, 2022) regard higher education as a right and a mechanism for the democratic redistribution of opportunities, arguing thatthe mobility resulting from university education as a structural rather than an individual process.
School of Social Work at Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro (UERJ), Barros (2019) shows that completing higher education expands professional opportunities and improves living conditions, especially via access to formal employment and civil service exams (Pinheiro & Soares, 2020). However, these advances remain constrained by job insecurity and the persistence of structural racism, evincing gradual social mobility.
Cordeiro (2013) argues that access to, retention in, and success in higher education represent a change in social status, especially for Black women. In line with this, Silva et al. (2022) found that alumni from affirmative action programs develop expectations of upward mobility and specific career paths.
However, although higher education represents an important achievement for students and alumni who have benefited from affirmative action and who have faced historical barriers to higher education access, their processes of entering and operating in the labor market remain fraught with challenges. Nascimento and Gomes (2024) point out that, even with academic and professional training, corporate social dynamics still subjugate Black people. In other words, they are often discredited regarding their intellect and their prospects for advancement in their industries, even in companies that claim to be inclusive. This reality can compromise these individuals’ social mobility. This body of evidence corroborates and challenges Barbosa’s (2019) interpretation, indicating that, although schooling functions as an important mechanism of mobility, its limited effects are too limited to overcome the structural inequalities that permeate the labor market.
Thus, the relationship between affirmative action policies and social mobility must be analyzed in a relational and contextualized manner considering the progress due to the democratization of access to public higher education and the limitations imposed by a labor market that has historically been structured by racial inequalities. Although the expansion of access to higher education furthered the democratization of educational opportunities (Gomes et al., 2022; Sá, 2022), the professional trajectories of Black students and alumni who benefited from affirmative action quotas unfold in a labor market that has historically been marked by racial inequalities, which challenge the effectiveness of higher education as a mechanism for social advancement (Barbosa, 2019; Batista, 2018; Golgher, 2021; Nascimento & Gomes, 2024; Rodrigues et al., 2017; Sá, 2022).
These individuals’ social mobility must be understood as a relational process in which schooling acts as a necessary but insufficient condition to reconfigure the social positions they occupy. Public policies for educational inclusion enhance this process, whereas the persistence of structural racism limits it as it delegitimizes qualifications, creates occupational segmentation, and restricts access to prestigious positions. Thus, this study assumes that the quota policy opens concrete possibilities for mobility by expanding access to educational credentials that have historically been restricted, but that its effects are mediated by unequal social structures that continue to shape the labor market.
Methodological approach
This qualitative and descriptive study aims to understand the experiences and meanings participants attribute to the affirmative action policy in their professional trajectories. Its empirical corpus consists of semi-structured interviews with Black students and alumni who benefited from affirmative action quotas in undergraduate and graduate programs at federal universities. The inclusion of participants at different points in their academic careers made it possible to analyze concrete experiences of professional integration as well a career expectations among those who were yet to enter the labor market. Participants’ aspirations, expectations, and career plans were analyzed in cases with no professional integration. In total, 124 interviews were conducted.
With participants’ authorization, all interviews were recorded, transcribed in full, and analyzed. Participation was voluntary and dependent on participants signing informed consent forms. This study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the Federal University of Minas Gerais, CAAE no. 88109625.1.0000.5149. Overall, 63 undergraduate students, 37 alumni, and 24 graduate students or alumni participated in this study. Since all the graduate participants had completed at least one undergraduate degree, 61 had completed higher education, making it possible to analyze the effects of the degree on their professional trajectories.
Participants were affiliated with federal universities in all regions of the country: North (15), Northeast (23), Midwest (6), Southeast (70), and South (9). The regional total exceeds the total number of participants since two participants had dual institutional affiliations. The distribution resulted from voluntary participation in the call for participants, which was disseminated via networks of researchers, Black student collectives, and institutional channels of federal universities across the country. No prior quotas of participants by region were established.
The participants were distributed across the nine CAPES major fields of knowledge, with a predominance of applied social sciences (37) and humanities (36), followed by linguistics, literature and arts (17), health sciences (11), exact and earth sciences (9), engineering (8), multidisciplinary (3), biological sciences (2), and agricultural sciences (1). The presence of participants associated with the nine major fields of knowledge highlights the diversity of the corpus and allows us to examine the professional trajectories in different fields of education and practice, preventing the analysis from being restricted to the specificities of a single field of knowledge. To preserve anonymity, participants were identified by alphanumeric codes (E1, E2, E3…).
The empirical material was analyzed by thematic analysis, as systematized by Aronson (1995) and subsequently developed by Braun and Clarke (2006). This allowed us to identify, organize, and interpret recurring patterns of meaning in qualitative data, from which we developed themes aligned with the objectives of this study. According to Braun and Clarke (2006), themes correspond to relevant aspects of the dataset that capture shared and recurring meanings in the participants’ narratives.
In this study, thematic analysis was conducted in a data-driven manner so that the initial coding resulted from the systematic reading and re-reading of the interviews (Braun & Clarke, 2006). The analytical process included (1) familiarization with the empirical material, (2) generation of initial codes, (3) identification and organization of potential themes, (4) review and refinement of these themes, and (5) definition and naming of analytical categories. The use of thematic analysis provided an in-depth understanding of experiences related to the quota policy considering the plurality of reported institutional contexts and trajectories.
Coding constituted a central step in the analytical process, assigning meanings to excerpts from the interviews by codes representing aspects relevant to this research (Braun & Clarke, 2006). The following codes stand out: the transition from university to the labor market, reconfiguration of family trajectories, academic credentials as a legitimizing factor, job insecurity, professional microaggressions, discrediting of qualifications, degrees as a necessary but insufficient condition, the limits of education as a mechanism for mobility, the persistence of racial hierarchies, affirmative action in the labor market, gradual progress, and the ongoing struggle. Broader themes were identified based on these codes, such as: higher education as a driver of mobility, professional integration mediated by education, structural racism in the workplace, delegitimization and the need for constant proof of competence, tension between degrees and real equality, and critical hope. The progressive refinement of the themes defined the analytical categories that guide the interpretative analysis in this study, namely: (1) Racialization and inequalities in professional trajectories, (2) higher education and professional integration, and (3) breaking generational cycles of poverty.
Data presentation and analysis
Racialization and inequalities in career trajectories
In participants’ accounts, racialization processes emerge not as a one-off obstacle but as a constitutive element of their professional trajectories, operating in a continuous and multifaceted way. Although the quota policy guarantees access to higher education and the attainment of a degree, the data indicate that academic qualifications do not neutralize the racial inequalities that structure the labor market. This is in line with Almeida’s (2018) understanding of structural racism, which indicates that inequalities go beyond individual attitudes, being embedded in the very institutional and organizational dynamics that regulate professional access, recognition, and advancement.
Such dynamics constitute expressions of the racialization process, that is, the reduction of people and groups to hierarchically structured racial categories, with concrete effects on their life opportunities (Guimarães, 2024). Racialization occurs via explicitly racist doctrines or discourses, institutional practices, everyday interactions, and organizational structures that produce and perpetuate racial classifications, contributing to the reproduction of hierarchies and inequalities. Thus, seemingly routine or neutral practices can have racially differentiated effects when embedded in social contexts historically structured by racial hierarchies (Guimarães et al., 2024).
One of the most common aspects of this process is the requirement for ongoing proof of competence. Reports indicate that Black professionals are shifted from a position of presumed recognition to one of ongoing validation. E21 explains this logic by stating that competing on an equal footing requires an exceptional resume and results above those of White colleagues. Similarly, E65 interprets the presence of Black professionals as a “gamble” from companies, implying the need to continuously show excellence, often to the detriment of their physical and mental health. This finding empirically substantiates what Bento (2022) calls the narcissistic pact of Whiteness, which naturalizes White competence and permanently questions Black competence (which must be repeatedly proven).
This logic is linked to the normalization of Whiteness in positions of prestige, so that the presence of Black professionals in these spaces is met with surprise and estrangement. This is a concrete manifestation of the racialization process described by Guimarães (2024), which perceives the occupation of certain positions by White people as natural and expected but treats the presence of Black people in these spaces as an exception that requires an explanation or justification. E85 reports that she needs to prove her ability “at all times,” noting that colleagues and clients are often surprised when they realize her technical proficiency. Similarly, E28 states that she is often asked whether she is “a human doctor or a veterinarian,” emphasizing that this type of question would not be directed at a White doctor. E84, also reports the constant pressure to perform impeccably as a teacher at an elite private school and the need to justify his practices in detail. Such accounts reinforce the idea that racism operates as a mechanism for discrediting Black intellectuals (Nascimento & Gomes, 2024), even when these individuals have education equivalent to or higher than that of their peers.
Professional delegitimization also occurs via invisibility and symbolic downgrading processes. E57 reports being mistaken for a cleaning lady, whereas E42 observed a racial division of labor in their internship, in which heavier tasks were mostly performed by Black people, whereas administrative and intellectual roles remain concentrated among White people. These accounts reveal the persistence of a racial division of labor in Brazil (Costa, 2020) in which certain occupations remain racially marked, reproducing historical hierarchies within organizations. This segmentation, rather than accidental, expresses the way in which the process of racialization operates within organizational structures, associating Black bodies with certain roles and spaces and White bodies with others, causing this distribution to be perceived as natural rather than as the product of historically constructed power relations (Guimarães, 2024).
These dynamics go beyond the private sector, indicating the structural nature of the phenomenon. E120 reports that, in the public sector, users often question their authority, whereas E54 states that, during a competitive exam, she was asked if she was “really a nutritionist.” These accounts challenge the idea of formal meritocracy associated with public service and reinforce the understanding that racism permeates even institutions regulated by seemingly objective criteria, corroborating the critique of the individualistic view of the phenomenon (Almeida, 2018). The accounts highlight the analytical challenge pointed out by Guimarães et al. (2024) of understanding how the attitudinal and behavioral dimensions of racism are linked to systemic and structural mechanisms of exclusion and hierarchy. The data show the simultaneous and coordinated operation of these dimensions.
Another relevant dimension concerns microaggressions and hostility in power and prestige spaces. E80 reports that, while working as an adjunct professor at a federal university, he faced recurring situations of mistrust that directly impacted his mental health and led him to question his career as an academic. Similarly, E30 highlights the devaluation of their technical knowledge, reporting their management’s resistance to following their guidance. These experiences configure everyday expressions of structural racism, which manifest themselves in major discriminatory events and in routine interactions that produce cumulative stress and limit life trajectories.
The lack of representation emerges as another structuring element of the analyzed trajectories. E88, E35, and E83 report isolation experiences, feeling like the only Black people in their work environments. Moreover, E82 notes that organizational diversity tends to be concentrated in entry-level positions, whereas E84 points out that leadership positions remain mostly occupied by White people. These reports show barriers to advancement, which have been highlighted by data from DIEESE (2023), according to which the presence of Black people in executive and management positions is significantly lower than that of non-Black people, indicating a persistent pattern of exclusion from positions of power.
Regarding conditions for professional integration, the data also reveal inequalities in the distribution of symbolic and material resources. E123 points out that White students often enter university a network of contact, whereas Black students have to “navigate the job market on their own,” facing selection processes in which the privilege of connections outweighs technical knowledge. E38, for their part, emphasizes that quota students enter the labor market without the “cultural capital” inherited by White people from higher classes, with consequences that extend even to mental health. These accounts show that professional integration is mediated by formal credentials and by socially inherited and unequally distributed resources.
Finally, everyday microaggressions emerge as a cross-cutting dimension of the reported experiences. E64 describes the strain of dealing with racist jokes and exclusionary looks, whereas E56 reports being mistaken for another Black colleague. E57 mentions the hypersexualization of her body, and E58 points to the burden of being constantly called upon as a “racial reference” in the institution. These experiences show how racism manifests itself in subtle and recurring practices that, accumulated, produce concrete effects on people’s well-being and career trajectories.
This analytical category shows that a university degree, although fundamental, does not break with the racial structures that organize the labor market. This context requires reflecting on the limits of schooling as a mechanism of social mobility (Barbosa, 2019), especially in contexts marked by historical inequalities. Thus, participants’ trajectories remain marked by a tension between the advances provided by the democratization of access to higher education and the limits imposed by a labor market that continues to delegitimize, hierarchize, and restrict the presence of Black people in prestigious positions. This tension highlights the coexistence of institutional democratization processes and the persistence of racialization mechanisms that continue to hierarchically organize the world of work.
Higher education and professional integration
Access to high-quality higher education positively influenced participants’ career paths as it increased their opportunities for integration and socioeconomic advancement. Although a degree does not shield them from structural racism in the labor market, academic training creates the conditions for participants to enter more skilled positions and reshape their future prospects.
Among the main benefits found we highlight the access to higher-skilled professional opportunities and changes in socioeconomic circumstances. This movement corroborates Barbosa’s (2019) understanding that schooling is an important mechanism for social positioning, even though its limited effects it cannot, by itself, guarantee full mobility by themselves.
Access to higher education via the quota system has enabled many participants to leave precarious or low-paying jobs (such as telemarketing or informal work) to enter specialized careers, changing their financial situation and that of their families. E76, for example, became a biologist at a private company thanks to the master’s degree she earned via the quota system, and she reports that her education enabled her to “have a good quality of life” and completely transform her career path. E88, who currently works as a remote teacher under flexible hours, says that quotas were decisive in enabling her to avoid more exhausting jobs, such as in retail. This set of accounts indicates that higher education operates as a concrete mechanism to break away from precarious occupational trajectories, expanding professional horizons that were previously limited by socioeconomic conditions of origin.
E61 and E56 point out that higher education gave them access to more dignified jobs with higher pay than their parents had, contributing to a change in their families’ socioeconomic structure. E59 reports that the quotas were crucial for entering undergraduate studies and for gaining access to an MBA at Universidade de São Paulo, which secured their current job and financial stability. Similarly, E31 and E32 acknowledge that they would be limited to jobs with no prospects for growth in their hometowns without their degrees. Overall, the data suggest that higher education increases individual opportunities and reshapes expectations and possibilities for social mobility when compared to previous generations.
In some cases, access to university was linked to other affirmative action initiatives in the labor market, as in the case of E82, who secured an internship and was subsequently hired as a museologist via a program focused on racial diversity. E124 and E20 reported a similar situation, entering the labor market via organizational inclusion and diversity policies. E36 reports getting their first formal job via a trainee program exclusive to Black people and their education at a federal university, interpreting this opportunity as a direct result of the quota policy. These findings reinforce and expand Gomes et al.’s (2021) understanding by showing that the effects of affirmative action go beyond access to education, affecting dynamics of professional integration and increasing channels for entry into the skilled labor market.
In addition to technical skills, university also fostered career paths guided by specific interests and greater social awareness. E77 points out that their participation in research projects has helped to orient their academic background toward education and ethnic-racial relations, giving them greater confidence to work in their current position. Similarly, social worker E78 states that her university education was “100% responsible” for her voice, enabling her to apply the sensitivity and racial literacy she developed in academia to the corporate environment. This shows that higher education plays a role in technical training and in shaping critical individuals, which is in line with Gomes et al.’s (2022) perspective on university as a space to produce social awareness and struggle for recognition.
Another relevant finding relates to the centrality of public service in interviewees’ professional aspirations. Unlike contemporary discourses that value entrepreneurship or reject formal employment relationships, participants saw civil service exams as the main path toward financial stability and security. E84, for example, has passed a competitive exam for a teaching position at the university from which where he completed his undergraduate degree. E58 also emphasizes that affirmative action was decisive for her trajectory, enabling her to enter a master’s program and pass a municipal civil service exam. E44, in turn, reports that, after a trajectory marked by physically exhausting jobs, such as working as a day laborer, the opportunity to study via quotas gave her the prospect of working as a tenured teacher in basic education. This finding corroborates the argument of Barros (2019) and Pinheiro and Soares (2020) that higher education expands access to formal and more stable employment, especially in the public sector, showing that this mobility occurs amidst job insecurity, in which such positions play a strategic role for individuals who have historically been vulnerable.
Moreover, the university experience the quotas provided contributed to skill development and network expansion. E84 points out that experiences such as presenting papers at conferences and participating in outreach projects were key to improving his communication and performance in interviews. At the same time, the university through university they built networks of relationships that increased their access to professional opportunities. These data indicate that professional integration depends on formal credentials and on social and relational capital, which has historically been distributed unequally among social groups.
Entering university also influenced the construction of interviewees’ professional identities. E27 states that the absence of Black role models during her undergraduate studies, combined with the opportunities provided by quotas, motivated her to focus on areas related to ethnic-racial relations. E67 points out that their involvement with student movements steered their career toward research on racial issues, and E01 reports that the quota policy was fundamental to the development of their racial awareness, enabling them to confront racism in the workplace. As E65 summarizes, the university experience served as a “preparatory exam” for dealing with racism in the labor market. These elements show that higher education also plays a role in producing subjectivities and constructing meanings about work and professional trajectories.
Another recurring element in the narratives is the development of a strong social commitment. E28, a medical school graduate, chose to work in rural areas via the Mais Médicos program, seeking to provide dignified care to marginalized populations. Similarly, E05 and E32 plan to work in outlying regions to contribute to the improvement of living conditions for these populations. This movement reinforces the collective dimension of affirmative action, in line with the perspective of Mendonça and Aranha (2020) that its effects extend beyond the individual and produce broader social impacts.
For undergraduates, the quota policy represents a real possibility of a different future. E68 and E70 see university as the provider of access to better opportunities. E24, 63 years of age, expresses this expectation by stating that completing the course will have an impact comparable to winning a World Cup. For E44, a domestic worker living in a rented home, sees her university admission is as an opportunity to envision a better financial and professional future. These accounts highlight the role of university as a horizon of possibilities, especially for individuals whose trajectories have historically been marked by structural constraints.
Despite these changes, participants also pointed out limitations and challenges. E74 highlights the need for the labor market to advance at the same pace as the democratization of access to higher education, whereas E63 suggests greater institutional coordination for labor inclusion policies. E77 expresses concern about the devaluation of degrees, and E73 believes that the changes will occur gradually. These observations challenge the idea of automatic mobility, corroborating Barros (2019) interpretation that social mobility resulting from higher education tends to be fragile, gradual, and structurally conditioned.
In summary, participants believe that the influence of affirmative action policies on their professional trajectories has a transformative potential, acting as an important gateway to the skilled labor market and socioeconomic advancement. However, the narratives also show that expanding access to higher education does not eliminate structural inequalities, indicating that persistent barriers continue to hinder these individuals’ professional integration, resulting in trajectories marked by mobility that is both possible and limited, i.e., structurally constrained.
Breaking generational cycles of poverty
The analysis of the interviews shows that racial and social quotas operate as an important mechanism for socioeconomic mobility on an individual level and in the reconfiguration of interviewees’ family structures. The reports indicate an increase in purchasing power and opportunities and, above all, the beginning of processes that break generational cycles of poverty. However, these results should be understood as part of a gradual movement, the effects of which tend to consolidate in the medium and long term, as argued by Barbosa (2019) and Barros (2019).
This process becomes evident when observing respondents’ backgrounds. E31 and E33, for example, report that their families depended on Bolsa Família and informal work to survive. In this context, E31 states that the university represented the only concrete possibility of building a trajectory different from one marked by precariousness. Similarly, E32, a medical student, envisions his future profession as a way to lift his family out of vulnerability, ensuring better living conditions for his parents and access to goods considered inaccessible in his hometown. E30 explains that their dedication to their studies and work directly stems from their goal of transforming the economic reality of their family and the region in which they live.
The intergenerational dimension of this process appears even more strikingly in accounts such as that of E52, who describes the trajectory of a family consisting of five siblings, the children of a mother who was a cleaning lady and an unemployed father, in which, by combining affirmative action policies and student funding, all could access higher education. For the interviewee, this movement represents a profound transformation of educational status and their family’s financial structure. Similarly, E54 observes that the quota policy changed the fate of the Black women in her family: while the previous generation mostly engaged in domestic work, the current generation has taken up professions in law, administration, and teaching. These findings expand on the understanding of Mendonça and Aranha (2020) by showing that affirmative action broadens access to higher education and produces concrete intergenerational effects, reconfiguring family trajectories that have historically been marked by exclusion.
The reports also show that the effects of quotas go beyond the directly benefited generation. E06, a teacher, single mother, and the daughter of a coconut breaker, points out that completing her master’s degree will enable her to advance in her career and enjoy better retirement conditions. She also celebrates the fact that a nephew of hers is studying electrical engineering via the quota system, interpreting this achievement as a milestone of upward mobility for a family that has historically been vulnerable. Similarly, E68 questions the idea of enrichment, emphasizing that education mainly aims at stability and quality of life, highlighting that access to basic goods, such as better-quality food, is no longer perceived as a luxury, becoming part of everyday life.
In some cases, the effects of the quota policy are evident during the academic trajectory. E12 reports using part of their retention scholarship to financially support their father, showing that the policy also immediately impacts family dynamics. Similarly, E38 points out that access to higher education and subsequently to the formal labor market gave them financial autonomy and the real possibility of providing better living conditions for their mother and sister. These accounts reinforce the idea that social mobility is not restricted to the individual, but extends to family networks, broadening its effects.
This reconfiguration also appears in future projections. E61 states that his and his siblings’ access to higher education opened up new possibilities for structuring their family’s finances. E58, in turn, points out that, in addition to becoming a public servant, she is no longer the only Black person in the family with access to higher education since her siblings have also gone to university, suggesting that future generations will not face the same limitations her mother experienced. E65, in turn, shares the story of a fellow quota student who, coming from a background of extreme vulnerability, managed to find work abroad and now contributes financially to supporting his family in Brazil. In the same vein, E78 projects that, within 10 to 20 years, it will be possible to see Black families in which different generations will have access to undergraduate and graduate education, breaking with trajectories marked by low levels of schooling.
The expansion of material possibilities is also reflected in access to previously inaccessible experiences. E80, who balanced work and study in three shifts, reports participating in an exchange program in Europe via an affirmative action policy. For him, this experience allowed him to devote himself fully to his studies and opened up spaces and experiences that have historically been restricted to socially privileged groups, highlighting the potential of affirmative action to broaden symbolic and material horizons.
However, despite these advances, the reports also show that students often remain in university under high vulnerability. E121, E124, and E15 highlight the central role of student aid grants in enabling students to continue their studies, whereas E120, E53, and E100 report the need to balance work and academic education as a strategy to alleviate financial pressure on families. E120 and E100 emphasize that a large part of their income goes toward rent and debts incurred to stay in university, revealing the material limitations that still affect these trajectories.
Despite these constraints, participants see that higher education represents a turning point in their trajectories. E77 sums up this perception by stating that, despite structural difficulties, having a university degree ensures greater financial security and dignity than lacking it. This perception reinforces Barbosa’s (2019) and Barros’ (2019) arguments, for whom schooling is a potential vector of social mobility, even though its gradual effects do not amount to overcoming structural inequalities.
In summary, the data indicate that the quota policy plays a central role in triggering intergenerational social mobility processes, increasing educational and professional opportunities and reconfiguring family trajectories that have historically been marked by exclusion. However, such transformations occur gradually and coexist with structural limitations that continue to hinder the full effectiveness of this mobility. Thus, the accounts make it clear that breaking generational cycles of poverty, rather than an immediate or automatic result of access to higher education, constitutes a gradual process of reconfiguring material conditions, expectations for the future, and the educational and professional opportunities available to the families of quota students. In this sense, the identified main transformation, rather than necessarily lying in an abrupt social rise, stems from the progressive broadening of the horizons of possibility between different generations of the same family.
Final considerations
This study aimed to analyze how Black students and alumni who benefited from affirmative action quotas at federal universities interpret the effects of the quota policy on their professional trajectories and social mobility processes. This research assumed that mobility due to access to higher education is mediated by unequal social structures that continue to shape the Brazilian labor market rather than occurring automatically.
The results show that access to quality higher education significantly drives change in individuals’ trajectories, expanding professional opportunities, reshaping expectations for the future, and enabling concrete changes in living conditions. Academic education emerges as a central element in breaking with precarious occupational trajectories, gaining access to formal employment relationships, and expanding opportunities for professional integration, including via coordination with diversity policies in the labor market. Furthermore, the findings indicate effects that go beyond the individual, highlighting processes of intergenerational mobility, a reconfiguration of family trajectories, and an expansion of educational and professional horizons for subsequent generations.
However, the data also reveal that such progress coexists with significant structural limitations. Participants’ accounts show how processes of racialization occur in work relationships via the delegitimization of competence, the constant demand for proof of ability, occupational segmentation, and the estrangement with which others react to Black professionals in prestigious positions. Taken together, these experiences reveal persistent patterns of exclusion and racial hierarchy in the labor market. Thus, a university degree is a relevant but insufficient condition for full social mobility, challenging the idea of schooling as an automatic mechanism for upward mobility. The main contribution of this study lies in empirically showing the relational, gradual, and contested nature of the social mobility of Black students and alumni who benefited from affirmative action quotas. By articulating the positive effects of democratizing access to higher education, the processes of racialization that permeate professional integration, and the intergenerational effects in family trajectories, this study furthers the understanding that the mobility of these individuals constitutes nor an abrupt, but rather a process of progressively expanding opportunities and horizons of possibility conditioned by unequal social and racial structures. This interpretation helps to shift away from simplistic analyses that directly associate higher education with social advancement, recognizing the coexistence of changing trajectories and the persistence of inequality mechanisms. Moreover, this study broadens analyses of affirmative action policies by showing that their effects go beyond access to and retention in higher education and involve professional, family, and subjective dimensions, thus contributing to the development of critical individuals, the construction of professional identities, and the strengthening of social commitments. Thus, affirmative action can be understood not only as an instrument of educational inclusion but also as a policy that can more broadly reconfigure social structures.
Finally, the results indicate the need to strengthen the connection between educational policies and those for inclusion in the labor market to enhance the effects of affirmative action and address the structural barriers that limit the social mobility of the Black population. As a future research agenda, we suggest further analysis of long-term professional trajectories and studies that integrate different social markers (such as gender and class) to assess the dynamics of professional entry and advancement.
Acknowledgements
Ministério da Igualdade Racial (MIR) and the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq) for the support provided via CNPq/MIR Call no. 03/2024.
Support and funding:
Use of AI:
Copy editing services:
1
Data availability:
The authors will make the research data available upon reasonable request.
References
- Almeida, A. M. F., & Ernica, M. (2015). Social effects of university expansion and affirmative action in public higher education in Brazil: a view from the state of São Paulo. In R. T. Teranishi et al. (Ed.), Mitigating Inequality: Higher Education Research, Policy, and Practice in an Era of Massification and Stratification (pp. 149-167). Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
- Almeida, S. (2018). O que é racismo estrutural? Editora Letramento.
-
Andrews, G. R. (2014). Racial inequality in Brazil and the United States, 1990- 2010. Journal of Social History, 47(4), 829-854. https://doi.org/10.1093/jsh/shu026
» https://doi.org/10.1093/jsh/shu026 -
Aronson, J. (1995). A pragmatic view of thematic analysis. The Qualitative Report, 2(1), 1-3. https://doi.org/10.46743/2160-3715/1995.2069
» https://doi.org/10.46743/2160-3715/1995.2069 -
Barbosa, M. L. D. O. (2019). Democratização ou massificação do Ensino Superior no Brasil?. Revista de Educação PUC-Campinas, 24(2), 240-253. https://doi.org/10.24220/2318-0870v24n2a4324
» https://doi.org/10.24220/2318-0870v24n2a4324 -
Barros, C. F. R. (2019). Universidade e mercado de trabalho: A trajetória social dos alunos cotistas egressos da Faculdade de Serviço Social da Uerj. Em Pauta: Teoria Social e Realidade Contemporânea, 17(43), 172–186. https://doi.org/10.12957/rep.2019.42538
» https://doi.org/10.12957/rep.2019.42538 -
Batista, N. C. (2018). Cotas para o acesso de egressos de escolas públicas na Educação Superior. Pro-Posições, 29(3), 41-65. https://doi.org/10.1590/1980-6248-2015-0158
» https://doi.org/10.1590/1980-6248-2015-0158 - Bento, C. (2022). O pacto da branquitude Companhia das letras.
-
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77-101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
» https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa -
Campos, L. A. (2024). Racismo no Brasil: de hipótese a premissa, sem passar por objeto. Tempo Social, 36(2), 13-35. https://doi.org/10.11606/0103-2070.ts.2024.222555
» https://doi.org/10.11606/0103-2070.ts.2024.222555 -
Cordeiro, A. L. A. (2013). Ações afirmativas na educação superior: Mulheres negras cotistas e mobilidade social. Revista Pedagógica, 17(30), 297-314. https://doi.org/10.22196/rp.v15i30.1572
» https://doi.org/10.22196/rp.v15i30.1572 -
Costa, G. (2020). Trabalhadores negros na origem da política social brasileira. Em Pauta: Teoria Social e Realidade Contemporânea, 18(46), 68-84. https://doi.org/10.12957/rep.2020.51982
» https://doi.org/10.12957/rep.2020.51982 -
DIEESE. (2023). As dificuldades da população negra no mercado de trabalho (Boletim Especial, 20 de novembro de 2023) DIEESE. https://www.dieese.org.br/boletimespecial/2023/conscienciaNegra2023.html
» https://www.dieese.org.br/boletimespecial/2023/conscienciaNegra2023.html -
Golgher, A. B. (2021). Evolução recente da presença e do perfil de minorias na Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais. Cadernos de Pesquisa, 51, 1-23. https://doi.org/10.1590/198053147351
» https://doi.org/10.1590/198053147351 -
Gomes, N. L., Silva, P. V. B. D., & Brito, J. E. D. (2021). Affirmative action for the promotion of racial equality in education: struggles, achievements and challenges. Educação & Sociedade, 42, e258226. https://doi.org/10.1590/ES.258226
» https://doi.org/10.1590/ES.258226 -
Gomes, N. L.; Jesus, R. E. de; Colen, N. S., & de Costa, S. R. J. (2022). Ações afirmativas na UFMG: entrevista com Nilma Lino Gomes. Revista Docência do Ensino Superior, 12, 1-23. https://doi.org/10.35699/2237-5864.2022.41616
» https://doi.org/10.35699/2237-5864.2022.41616 -
Gouvêa, J. B., & Oliveira, J. S. (2020). Por que branquitudes, por que (somente) agora?. Caderno de Administração, 28(2), 5-14. https://doi.org/10.4025/cadadm.v28i2.57245
» https://doi.org/10.4025/cadadm.v28i2.57245 -
Guimarães, A. S. A. (2024). Raças e racismos, junções e disjunções. Tempo Social, 36(2), 37-59. https://doi.org/10.11606/0103-2070.ts.2024.221936
» https://doi.org/10.11606/0103-2070.ts.2024.221936 -
Guimarães, A. S. A., Campos, L. A., & Gato, M. (2024). Introdução: por uma sociologia do racismo. Tempo Social, 36(2), 5-12. https://doi.org/10.11606/0103-2070.ts.2024.226504
» https://doi.org/10.11606/0103-2070.ts.2024.226504 - Hasenbalg, C. A. (1979). Discriminação e desigualdades raciais no Brasil (vol. 86) Graal.
- Mbembe, A. (2018). Necropolítica: Biopoder, soberania, estado de exceção, política da morte N-1 Edições.
-
Mendonça, E. S., & Aranha, M. L. M. (2020). Política de cotas raciais: Instrumento de promoção de equidade e justiça social. Em Pauta: Revista da Faculdade de Serviço Social da UERJ, 18(45), 180-195. https://doi.org/10.12957/rep.2020.47226
» https://doi.org/10.12957/rep.2020.47226 -
Nascimento, I., & Gomes, M. (2024, 12 de novembro). Saímos da universidade. E agora? O Racismo no ramo corporativo e a geração Z negra. Portal Geledés https://www.geledes.org.br/saimos-da-universidade-e-agora-o-racismo-no-ramo-corporativo-e-a-geracao-z-negra/
» https://www.geledes.org.br/saimos-da-universidade-e-agora-o-racismo-no-ramo-corporativo-e-a-geracao-z-negra/ - Oliveira, D. (2021). Racismo estrutural: Uma perspectiva histórico crítica Dandara Editora.
-
Paula, G. B.de, Nonato, B. F., & Nogueira, C. M. M. (2022). Ações afirmativas e estratificação horizontal: comparação entre bônus e Lei de Cotas na UFMG. EDUR- Educação em Revista, 39, 1-25. https://doi.org/10.1590/0102-469837918
» https://doi.org/10.1590/0102-469837918 -
Pinheiro, C. L. F., & Soares, M. L. (2020). A lei de cotas por um fio: O retrocesso social atual. Em Pauta: Revista da Faculdade de Serviço Social da UERJ, 18(45), 196–210. https://doi.org/10.12957/rep.2020.47228
» https://doi.org/10.12957/rep.2020.47228 -
Ribeiro, M. (2023). Uncovering and expanding horizons: affirmative actions and anti-racism as strategies for educational inclusion. Psicologia & Sociedade, 35, e278161. https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-0310/2023v35e278161
» https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-0310/2023v35e278161 -
Rodrigues, D. D., & Barcelos, M. (2020). Stories in the agenda: a narrative policy framework study. Revista de Administração Pública, 54(6), 1632-1653. https://doi.org/10.1590/0034-761220190395x
» https://doi.org/10.1590/0034-761220190395x - Rodrigues, E. C., Matos, D. A. S., & Ferreira, A. D. S. (2017). Nível socioeconômico e ensino superior: cálculo e aplicações. Avaliação: Revista da Avaliação da Educação Superior (Campinas), 22(2), 494-511.
-
Sá, T. A. D. O. (2022). Políticas de democratização do ensino superior e a reprodução de desigualdades sociais: estudo de caso. Educação e Pesquisa, 48,1-30. https://doi.org/10.1590/s1678-4634202248248527por
» https://doi.org/10.1590/s1678-4634202248248527por -
Santos, A. S., Silva, V. M. F., Barros, G. S. F., Gama, G., Souza e Silva, C. L., Rodrigues, T., Umbelino, B., Reis, R. dos S., & Ferreira, P. P. S. (2024). Ampliando a diversidade no Programa de Pós-Graduação em Ecologia da Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro através de um curso preparatório. Oecologia Australis, 28(2), 150-158. https://doi.org/10.4257/oeco.2024.2802.07
» https://doi.org/10.4257/oeco.2024.2802.07 -
Silame, T. R., Martins Júnior, H., & Fonseca, A. H. S. (2020). O efeito das cotas: desempenho acadêmico dos estudantes cotistas da Universidade Federal de Viçosa-Campus Rio Paranaíba. Revista Brasileira de Ciência Política, (33), 1-36. https://doi.org/10.1590/0103-3352.2020.33.193375
» https://doi.org/10.1590/0103-3352.2020.33.193375 -
Silva, L. F. O. A., Ferreira, A., Teodoro, P., & Silva, Y. V. (2022). Ações afirmativas na educação superior e mobilidade social: Um estudo de campo. Revista Actualidades Investigativas en Educación, 22(2), 1-29. https://doi.org/10.15517/aie.v22i2.48876
» https://doi.org/10.15517/aie.v22i2.48876
