Open-access THE WORLDS OF AMERINDIAN SLAVERY AND THE MULTIDIRECTIONAL GRADIENT OF LABOR MODALITIES IN THE AMERICAS IN THE MODERN PERIOD1

Abstract

The article examines the diverse forms of enslavement of Amerindian peoples in the Modern Period, emphasizing the analytical potential of their study to complexify the concept of slavery itself. With this objective, the authors propose the allegory of a multidirectional gradient of forms of slavery, which, in turn, both fits into and unfolds within a broader multidirectional gradient of labor modalities. Two particular phenomena (“de condição” and “a la usanza” slavery) – geographically distant, but both part of the same historical context (mid-seventeenth century southern Chile and Portuguese Amazonia respectively) – serve as a testing ground and demonstration of the proposal.

Keywords
Indian Slavery; Colonial America; Worlds of Labor; Amerindian population; Indian Laws

Resumo

O artigo discute a variedade das modalidades de escravização dos povos ameríndios na Época Moderna, enfatizando os potenciais analíticos de seu estudo para complexificar o próprio conceito de escravidão. Para isso, os autores propõem a alegoria de um gradiente multidirecional de formas de escravidão que, por sua vez, ao mesmo tempo se enquadra e se desdobra em um gradiente multidirecional ainda mais amplo e diversificado de modalidades laborais. Dois fenômenos particulares (o da escravidão “de condição” e o da escravidão “a la usanza”) – geograficamente distantes, mas pertencentes a uma mesma conjuntura histórica (respectivamente o sul do Chile e a Amazônia portuguesa em meados do século XVII) – servem como campo de teste e demonstração da proposta oferecida.

Palavras-chave
Escravidão indígena; América colonial; Mundos do trabalho; População ameríndia; Direito indiano

1. Slavery, gradient, and continuum: the ship’s rope

In the introductory essay to a collective work published a few years ago, Les mondes de l’esclavage: une histoire comparée (2021), its editor, Paulin Ismard, proposed a bold revision of the category of “slavery.” Far from being necessarily and invariably the “antonym of freedom,” as it is often portrayed, he argues:

What we call slavery appears rather as an extreme form of exploitation that takes place within a hierarchy of multiform dependencies encompassing all members of society, allowing for the recognition of slaveholding situations within a bundle of elements whose composition never ceases to vary. Slavery should be approached not as an invariant or universal phenomenon but through a multiplicity of traits that interlock and intersect, and it is their kinship, rather than their identity, that allows us to recognize, from one society to another, the presence of slavery.

(ISMARD, 2021, pp. 11-12) [Our translation].

As an alternative to the numerous universal definitions of “slavery” found in historiography, guided by the ambition of fixed characterizations (whatever they may be: dishonor, desocialization, property over a person, deprivation of legal protection, etc.) and valid for any historical situation, Ismard concludes: “it is preferable to adopt an analysis in terms of gradients” (ISMARD, 2021, pp. 11-12). Indeed, as we will emphasize on more than one occasion throughout this article, there is no disagreement with the author on this point: any rigorous definition of slavery must always be thought of within precise historical contexts. It should be noted, moreover, that the notions underpinning Ismard’s proposed revision are fundamentally those of “gradient”, “continuum”, “combination”, and “interweaving”, all evoked together to account for the multiple concrete realities of slavery throughout human history. To illustrate his argument, he resorts to the metaphor of a ship’s rope, formulated by Ludwig Wittgenstein in support of his “ressemblance de famille” model (WITTGENSTEIN, 1996 [1958]): imagine “a rope that holds the ship to the dock, the rope made of fibers, but its strength does not result from a single fiber running from one end to the other, but rather from the fact that it consists of a considerable number of overlapping fibers” (ISMARD, 2021, p. 13).

The refusal to attribute abstract and timeless meanings to the phenomenon of slavery in human history serves well the ambitious purposes of the book in which it appears – a work composed of ninety-six chapters whose themes traverse different spaces (involving all continents) and times (from Mesopotamian antiquity to the present day). In this scenario, the different “worlds” of slavery are discussed sometimes separately, sometimes overlapping, sometimes compared, and sometimes observed through their articulations and intersections. The multiple connections between these different worlds (always in the plural) are pursued by the dozens of participating authors not through the search for general characteristics but through the exploration of the similarities and connections acquired by two or more of these realities when situated in specific historical circumstances, fundamentally arranged in a diachronic chain, following the precise logic of Ismard/Wittgenstein’s model and metaphor, already mentioned.

If the foundations proposed by the author for the undertaking of a diachronic and spatial comparative historical perspective of slavery in Les mondes de l’esclavage are thus well laid out, allowing for the analytical incorporation of the different and simultaneous forms of slavery that proliferated specifically in the Americas, why does Indigenous slavery appear so scarcely in the book, even though it often assumed the extreme form of so-called commodity slavery? In this sense, concerning the combinations and interweaving of the themes covered by Amerindian slavery, the monumental scope of the book, in its comparative dimension, is somewhat limited. Beyond scattered and occasional comments (hence unsystematic) that can be found throughout the book7, the articles by Brett Rushforth (“Amérindiens Français et Britanniques: les esclavages Canadiens”) and David Jabin (“Maîtres et esclaves chez des chasseurs-cueilleurs: les Yuqui d’Amazonie, Bolivie, 1955-2020”) constitute exceptions, but both concern atypical realities with demographic, spatial, and temporal scale limitations that prevent a comprehensive understanding of what happened in the rest of the continent, especially during the Modern Period8. This is a verifiable trend in other, more or less recent, similarly globalizing collections dedicated to the phenomenon of slavery, in which the difficulty persists in offering Indigenous enslavement something more than a restricted place, almost always detached from the enslavement of Africans and other subjects9.

From these relative absences derive theoretical and methodological consequences. On the one hand, to adequately understand slavery from a historical and comparative viewpoint, it would be fitting to describe all the mediations between the scales of observation, from individuals to the different groups to which slaves simultaneously belonged, as well as the spaces and societies to which they were linked, including, beyond their masters, relations with other groups and social classes. On the other hand, it would be necessary to describe the relations with other forms of labor with which the enslaved are known to have frequently worked in a joint and combined manner (among which we may highlight the multiple modalities of encomienda, mita, peonage, and wage labor, to remain, for now, only with the most general sets). For this reason, we argue, as a starting point, that a consistent and systematic incorporation of the multiple forms of Indigenous labor – and, in the case of the American continent during the centuries of European colonization, especially Amerindian slave labor, given all the modal and relational complexities that characterized them, as we will demonstrate in this article – offers a privileged terrain for better understanding the situations and transformations of the very concept of slavery and, consequently, deepening comparisons between its concrete manifestations in time and space.

The historiographical production on Indigenous slavery in the Americas has expanded in recent decades10, despite the different “turns” in historiography which, since the 1980s, have sought to sweep categories such as exploitation, domination, social change, conflict, class, and labor under the rug11. Although the available data for its study are generally more fragmentary and ambiguous than, for example, documentary evidence on the enslavement of Africans12, a general survey of recent bibliography suffices to demonstrate that, even quantitatively, we are far from dealing with a negligible phenomenon. Cécile Vidal estimated that Indigenous slavery affected “between 2.5 and 5 million individuals across the Americas between the late fifteenth and late nineteenth centuries” (VIDAL, 2021, p. 889). Brett Rushforth suggested a similar figure, between two and four million (RUSHFORTH, 2012, p. 9), while Andrés Reséndez’s intuitions led him closer to Vidal’s maximum threshold of five million (RESÉNDEZ, 2016, p. 324). Going further, when considering the survey conducted by Camila Loureiro Dias, Fernanda Aires Bombardi, and Eliardo Costa solely for the case of Portuguese Amazonia between 1680 and 1750, whose results point to around 200,000 enslaved Indigenous people (recruited through private and official ‘rescues,’ wars, raids, and other illegal means, but excluding legally “free” Indigenous people captured in descimentos) (DIAS, BOMBARDI; COSTA, 2020, pp. 1-40), it is not difficult to conclude that the unknown total for the entire continent over about four centuries of European colonization could have been much larger, certainly reaching the millions.

In any case, in Portuguese America, workers of African origin only surpassed Amerindians in number during the eighteenth century13, while in most continental areas of Spanish America, this demographic reversal never occurred. On the other hand, their geographical distribution was profoundly unequal: in Portuguese America, more Africans and native blacks were employed in productive units near the coast (especially the east-northeast coastline)14, and far more Indigenous people in the surrounding regions and the interiors of the southern captaincies (notably São Paulo)15 and the State of Maranhão and Grão-Pará to the north16. In Spanish America, where the presence of populations of African origin were generally more visible only in major urban spaces17 (with the exception of the Caribbean islands, where the slave trade became the main source of labor by the mid-sixteenth century), the legal slaveholding activity targeting Amerindian groups as its main subjects remained entrenched and operative long after the promulgation of the Leyes Nuevas of 1542, especially but not exclusively in decisive zones of colonial expansion – and retreat – (highlighted here are Southern Chile, the Charcas region, the northwest of the Río de la Plata basin, the Caribbean extension of New Granada, Northern Mesoamerica, Florida, and the entire region of New Biscay, today the western United States)18. If we wish to go even further and add to this quick overview American territories colonized by the English, French, and Dutch in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, the foci of systematic appropriation of Indigenous slave labor involved numerous medium and long distance trade networks which channeled Amerindian slaves of multiple societal and ethnic origins to the fortifications, cities, mines, and plantations of colonized areas such as Virginia, South Carolina, Barbados, Jamaica, and the Guianas19.

Wherever we direct our gaze, singular forms of Indigenous enslavement appear as constituent and significant elements of the general dynamics of labor, sociability, and production in the colonized American continent. It falls to the analyst, however, to retain a sensitive disposition to recognize them. If the interest of the historian of the colonization of Brazil or the Circum-Caribbean is focused exclusively on sugar production for the European market, the slave trade, European mercantile interests, and the accumulation of capital directed to European powers, what happened on the margins of the sugar system may receive less attention . However, if there is also interest in the ancillary systems that enabled the sugar system or, more broadly, in the social, economic, cultural, military, and political systems that constituted and reproduced themselves in the Americas (perhaps in their connections with sub-Saharan Africa, Europe, and, albeit to a lesser extent, the rest of the world), it matters and even demands an effective view of the whole that contemplates the existence, singularity, and roles played by Indigenous labor within the broad and diversified bundle of social relations that formed the modern world itself.

At this point in the discussion, we encounter a second limitation of the synthesis proposed by Paulin Ismard, to which we return a final time. The image of the gradient, pertinent in itself for its openness to the variations of form and content assumed by the phenomenon of slavery in each singular historical moment and/or context, takes on a linear character when presented in terms of a chain, in which each link connects in isolation with two others, without these finding space to attach among themselves and/or with other links in the same flow. This linearity is reinforced both by the use of the term “continuum” and by the representation of the ship’s rope, which suggests a broad chain of variations and connections that, however, linked one extreme to the other (“from one end to the other”, in his words). What are these extremes? While on one side slavery is defined as “an extreme form of exploitation,” on the other it is situated “within a hierarchy of multifarious dependencies.” It is understood that the gradient is, like a simple scale of gray tones, a gradient of “multiform dependencies” situated between a presupposed white zone, understood as the complete absence of “domination,” and a black zone characterized, on the contrary, by the absolute presence of this same “domination.” In this framework, the author finally succumbs to the same temptation he initially sought to reject, pointing to the condition of “debt” as the common element that generically permeated the different forms of forced labor, from its most extreme form (“commodity slavery”) to so-called “free” labor:

In the manner of a continuum, composed of multiple successive stages within which debt plays a central role, the path that leads from slavery to free labor must be considered (...) debt has always been constitutive of servitude relations, which should often be approached in the form of a continuum leading to slavery. (...) debt slavery was frequently a stage of commodity slavery

(ISMARD, 2021, pp. 483-484) [Our translation].

“Stage,” “phase,” “path that leads from slavery to free labor.” All this, it seems clear to us, clashes with his rejection of the notion of slavery in transhistorical terms, as the “antonym of freedom.” Ismard, therefore, presents us with an ambiguity, though without clarifying it sufficiently: in his understanding, is slavery merely a segment or moment in the links of a broader chain of multiform dependencies, or is it a multiform gradient encompassing multiple situations emerging from varied contexts?

2. The multidirectional gradient of labor modalities and Amerindian slavery

Let us consider, alternatively, a gradient even broader than that supposed in the metaphor of the ship’s rope, a gradient without absolute boundaries and which is essentially multidirectional. A gradient in which the multiple tones and colors are spatially distributed in varied directions, without these being known or fixed beforehand. Let us imagine this gradient, moreover, in three-dimensional form (shapeless and mobile, to better reflect the described procedural historical reality), its always nuanced edges corresponding to the many historical forms of commodity slavery, itself variable, while the center, which from all sides approaches white without ever fully becoming so, corresponds to a labor freedom only virtually imagined but which, in the reproductive logic of colonial American societies, is never full, assuming other juridical-moral features and practical characteristics20. Its tenuous edges and content full of transitions illustrate the analytical impracticality of attributing rigid separations between what, from historical processes, would or would not fall within the category of slavery, as well as between this and the other compulsory labor relations involving Indigenous people, blacks of African origin, mestizos, Asians, and other subjects21. Such a scheme allows us to understand, compare, classify, and analyze the practical and juridical-moral features that the phenomenon of slavery (and, more specifically, Amerindian slavery) acquired under concrete historical contexts.

Observing the colonial imperial and Atlantic slaveholding system from its various margins – especially from the interior of the continent outward, as it were (as well as from its specific configurations in relation to the multiple modalities of Indigenous labor) – enhances the understanding of the dynamics of their entanglements. These cannot always be perceived through the conceptual resources usually employed to study slave labor (markedly the rigid and abstract polarization between “slavery” and “freedom,” as we have said), but in fact tend to be better recognized when considering the regional variations of singular forms, the disjunction (to varying degrees) between regulatory norms and effective practices, and, above all, their correspondences and/or connections with other forms of labor. This is an aspect that cannot be underestimated.

On another occasion, Velloso proposed a distinction between regimes, systems, and modalities of labor22, thereby calling attention to the

singular historical forms that are never fully repeated in different spaces and temporalities, even though their manifestations may effectively present analogies, similarities, coincidences, or else share a common origin. Under certain circumstances, the modalities can convert into regimes when confirmed by some type of legislation, without thereby losing their specificities or the peculiar characteristics that define them – in other words, without losing the condition of local and specific labor modalities.

(VELLOSO, 2020, p. 30) [Our translation].

The differentiation aligns with the notion developed here of a multidirectional gradient of the different forms of enslavement (Amerindian, but not only), since approaching local or regional situations as modalities of a legal regime or a system makes it possible to describe the concrete manifestations of Indigenous slavery both in themselves and in a manner proximate and/or related to (I) the slavery of Africans and other subjects, as well as (II) that multiplicity of other forms of Amerindian labor already referred to, with which it not rarely interweaves and merges in its own specific contexts. In a complementary way, the relation between these three formative moments that may or may not characterize a labor relation in its intrinsic historicity demands a descriptive effort of contextualization that ends up reinforcing and, once again, broadening what was once formulated by Orlando Patterson; in other words, more than the logic of property (without thereby excluding it), the central criterion that would define not only slavery but all other forms of coerced labor, and even the relation between them, is the historical and concrete modality of a power (PATTERSON, 2008 [1982], pp. 39-64). It is, therefore, the description of the concrete modalities of labor that allows us, on the one hand, to distinguish them from the juridical regimes that resulted from them and/or sought to govern them and, on the other hand, to identify the essential characteristics that define them as singular labor systems, despite their internal variations and their entanglements and combinations with other forms of labor. The modalities constitute, finally, the closest observation point to the concrete historical expression of a form of labor, where the precise delineation of its contours is perceived, including from what resulted from the practical action of the remaining characters of the original Amerindian societies.

If the considerations we present here about slavery can be extrapolated to other forms of forced labor found in the Americas of the Modern Period, the bundle of variable elements that interlock and intersect within a hierarchy of multifarious dependencies (arranged in a multidirectional gradient without clearly defined or fixed boundaries) equally serves to describe all that transcends the specific limits of slavery and refers to its interweaving and combination with the various other forms of labor that were and/or are contemporary to it. Hence, the metaphor of the multidirectional gradient is powerful not only because it accommodates the comparative, diachronic, and spatial perspective of slavery in itself and allows for the serious consideration of the captivity and enslavement of Amerindians as decisive historical objects, but because it also permits us to accommodate other forms of labor that intertwined with it, synchronically.

Having described the contextual dynamics and the socioeconomic relations that associated with them, historian can undertake comparisons can be made with other regions and temporalities. For this, the description of a certain form of labor must be conducted rigorously, considering the historical context of its practical realization. This is the condition for being able to aspire, subsequently, to make comparisons with the historical variations of a similar regime, but also to perceive how that form of labor combines and intertwines with so many others. Moreover, no matter how much a modality may have concentrated in certain locations and thus reproduced itself, it is neither useful nor viable to examine any form of labor in a “pure” and isolated manner in any reality. Slavery a la usanza and slavery de condição, which we will address next, seem to us to evidence the historical foundation of this affirmation. As a consequence, it is also as a result of the rigorous contextualization that each form, in its concrete historical expression, can be positioned within a gradient that, as suggested, should be thought of in a multidirectional space where the forms of coercion associated with each specific labor modality are distributed. Moving then from the abstract to the concrete, all these operations demand the identification and circumscription of some common elements that enable the establishment of the historical relations and processes that historians have interest in reconstituting and explaining.

3. “A la usanza” and “de condição” Slavery

To clarify the proposal more effectively, let us examine the genesis and the efforts toward the legal constitution of two singular modalities of Amerindian slavery forged by Iberian colonizers under a common historical juncture (the 1650s): the so-called “a la usanza” and “de condição” forms of slavery, whose names denounced in themselves their initial contradiction with the legal and moral devices then in force and, at the same time, evidenced that Amerindian slavery was an organic part of the general systems of social reproduction in each of their regions (respectively, Southern Chile and Portuguese Amazonia). Such a procedure will allow us to observe the construction and reproduction of the slaveholding system from its margin. Other scholars have already shown that, despite the Leyes de Burgos (1512) and the Leyes Nuevas (1542) in Spanish America, as well as the laws of 1609, 1652, and 1680 in Portuguese America – which generically intended to affirm the “freedom” of Indigenous populations, although some of them were never effectively applied. Indigenous slavery persisted legally and illegally in different areas of Iberian colonization, especially in their territorial frontiers or peripheries, where exceptions to the norms could easily be justified through the evocation of the titles of rescue and just war23. The two juridical forms of enslavement that concern us, however, in the mid-seventeenth century, allowed just war and rescue themselves to become, in an unprecedented manner, titles to some extent dispensable for the reduction of Indigenous people to slavery.

The expressions “ventas a la usanza” and “servidumbre a la usanza” began to be systematically employed in southern Chile from the last years of the 1640s. Both referred to the conversion of Mapuche individuals into slavery (generally women and children, though not exclusively, as it applied to any person in conditions of dependence and vulnerability) sold to merchants, soldiers, and Hispanic colonial authorities by the very chiefs (lonko) of their families and/or communities of origin (lof). The defenders of this modality of slavery justified it with the argument that it was already customarily practiced by the native populations themselves before contact with the Spaniards, which is the reason why it was conventionally designated with the expression “a la usanza.” Such justification was, however, a notable interpretative distortion of a matrimonial practice of Mapuche culture according to which a male, upon joining with a woman, should offer animals and other gifts to her father, in respect to the precepts of reciprocity that sustained the reproduction of those societies (VELLOSO, 2021, pp. 271-287). Even so, the thesis carried the potential to harmonizing that practice with the Indian Law of the period, in which custom exercised great centrality as a source of law (TAU ANZOÁTEGUI, 2000, pp. 21-86). Another argument advanced by social sectors interested in the institutionalization of slavery a la usanza consisted in presenting it as an act of Christian charity that allowed both the spiritual salvation and the physical survival of the Indigenous people themselves (as well as of their relatives, whose received payments in the commercial operation would help to remove them from misery), who, henceforth living in Spanish settlements, even as servants or slaves, would receive doctrine, sustenance, and clothing (VELLOSO, 2022-2023, pp. 233-246).

Among the educated slaveholding sectors of the region24, there were also those who invoked Roman law (Codex Imperatoris Justiniani novus, liber 4, 43, “de patribus qui filios distraxerunt”) to justify the legitimacy of a father selling his son in cases of extreme necessity. An argument frequently evoked in Portuguese America, it should be said that it was one of the main justifications for the practice of “resgate” (rescue) following only the most current one of prisoners of intertribal wars25. The counterpart of this argument was, precisely, the fact that slavery a la usanza was a convenience recognized by the Indigenous people themselves, corresponding to their interests and “will” – which could be recorded in the official certifications of the purchase and sale operation, leading even some defenders of this modality of labor to argue that it was not properly “slavery”, given the transitory and supposedly voluntary nature of that captivity, but rather a particular mode of “servitude”, even though these same certifications ratified by themselves the condition of human merchandise of the transacted. Finally, but no less important, an attempt was made to justify that mode of slavery based on the evaluation of its “utility” for the interests of the monarchy and the “common good”, both from the economic viewpoint, evident in itself, and from the military viewpoint, since the Indigenous people thus enslaved (the majority of them, remember, composed of women and children) could serve to dissuade the adult men “with arrows” from attacking Spanish settlements26.

Despite the latter arguments, the general protector of the Indians and judge of the Royal Audience of Chile in the period, Antonio Ramírez de Laguna, contradicted the validity of their strategic-military foundations, as well as the legitimacy of the other justifications referred to above, and in 1652 requested from King Felipe IV the urgent prohibition of the said “usanza.” It is presumable that in the evaluation of the monarch, mediated by his Council of the Indies, however, the advantages affirmed by the defenders of that modality of slavery initially seemed more interesting, judging by the fact that Ramírez de Laguna’s plea, which gave origin to a long judicial process handled in the Audiência of Chile for three years, received no response or final decision by the Crown until 165627, not by chance some months after the outbreak of a massive Indigenous insurrection that placed the great majority of Mapuche men of the region in arms against the Spanish colonial settlements. However, when the prohibition arrived, it did not suffice to prevent other modalities of forced extraction of human labor from continuing to be practiced on the margins of imperial legislation for many decades, even after the official abolition of all forms of Indigenous slavery in the region, in 1674 (note this detail: 132 years after the Leyes Nuevas...)28.

In the same years that the legitimacy or not of practicing “a la usanza” slavery in Southern Chile was being debated, the concept of “de condição” slavery understood as a modality of temporary enslavement admitted under certain circumstances, was legislated for, apparently also for the first time, in northern Portuguese America. To the extent that it did not generate opposition, as in the Chilean case, and neither resulted in royal prohibition, “de condição” slavery acquired broader spatial dissemination (Portuguese Amazonia) and duration (seventeenth and eighteenth centuries). According to the norm that regulated this labor modality, a royal provision issued on April 9, 1655, based on the alteration of another from October 17, 165329, Indigenous prisoners who were bought after being obtained through intertribal wars considered unjust or of doubtful legitimacy should serve in the condition of slaves for five years to, in this way, reimburse the expenses assumed by their buyers with their “rescue” (that is, the axes, sickles, cachaça, Indian and European fabrics, candles, and beads given in payment to the Indigenous intermediaries who sold them). After this time, the rescued Indigenous people who survived the epidemics and exhaustive labor were to be brought to the settlements administered by religious missionaries – where they would, however, be subjected to other forms of coerced labor30.

The duration of service to pay the “rescue” was debated in a council convened to assess the captives rescued in 1655. André Vidal de Negreiros, then governor of the State of Maranhão, argued that, while captives of just war should serve indefinitely, those of unjust war should do so only for five years, while those originating from wars with doubtful legitimacy should serve for seven. Fr. Antônio Vieira counterargued that the time of service should be the same in both cases, since the price of the rescue was equal in both – thus leaving it implied that he accepted the reimbursement of the “rescue” as justification for this form of captivity and slavery. In other words: in those circumstances neither the Jesuit, nor the governor, nor the “residents” debated the legitimacy of the reduction to slavery of captives of intertribal wars recognized as unjust or doubtful. To put it briefly, the correlation of forces showed itself clearly favorable to the interests of the slaveholding sectors of Luso-Amazonian colonial society (even if they were often “residents” of lesser economic expression31).

The 1655 law likely marked the beginning of the regulation of “de condição” slavery in colonial Amazonia. Its innovation did not lie in the duration of labor required to repay the price of the rescue, but rather the authorization of the reduction to slavery of captives from wars explicitly recognized as unjust or doubtful. Although it is difficult to identify the origin of the expression “escravo de condição,” Antônio Vieira registered that it was “vulgarly” utilized in 165532 and even though, in the law, the practice under examination here was not exactly named as such, its description corresponds perfectly to it: “finding that the war was not just, the said Indians can nevertheless be rescued to serve them for the space of five years, which the law limits as sufficient for the satisfaction of the price that was given for them, and after the said five years they will be placed in the Villages of the free”33. Nevertheless, this practical modality of submission to slavery was still widely employed a century later, as evidenced in a royal letter from 173434, in the Livro das Canoas (1739-1755)35, in the minutes of the courts of the Juntas das Missões of the State of Maranhão in the 1740s and 1750s36, or even in petitions for the freedom of Indigenous men and women, where we see complaints that the five-year term authorized by the law tended to be extrapolated, including with the condition of slave being transmitted to the descendants37.

Despite their opposing effects (prohibition in the former case, ratification in the latter. and diffusion in both) the fact that these two juridical forms of enslavement emerge around the same time is significant. The discussions that gave them life occurred in courts located in two peripheral areas (but neither marginal nor external or unconnected from the American economic and institutional centers) of two colonial empires that, in those years of the mid-seventeenth century, shared a context of profound crisis, with the Dutch occupations in the Americas and Africa, military conflicts among themselves and with France, the Netherlands, and Great Britain, accentuated indebtedness, and chronic difficulties to settle their pending issues with foreign merchants, proliferation of internal rebellions, and recent movements of insubordination (some with separatist projects, markedly in the Spanish case: see the examples of Catalonia, Naples, the Netherlands, and Portugal), accentuated presence of pirate vessels in the Circum-Caribbean, increase in denunciations of fiscal evasion, among other problems.

In both cases, protecting the frontiers against the potential presence of foreign operators was fundamental, which implied at the same time guaranteeing the stability of their own occupations in those peripheries by organizing the reproduction of the regional economic activities. However, recruitment mechanisms justified by the concept of just war were impaired. In Southern Chile, a series of diplomatically oriented negotiations with the principal chiefs of the autonomous Mapuche societies established there made the rhythm of institutionalized war decline to minimal levels, obstructing a secular source of forced laborers and thus creating impediments for the material reproduction of the colonial settlements in the customary molds38. In Portuguese Amazonia the complete or partial breakdown of Amerindian societies previously situated near Portuguese ports and forts as a result of the intensification of the slave trade and the proliferation of epidemics39 provoked the advance of rescue and capture expeditions toward the interior, making the verification of the effective circumstances of recruitment more difficult, whether by royal officials or by missionaries, henceforth placed in situations of heightened risk and vulnerability.

Under these conditions, the Portuguese and Spanish legislation authorized (or, at least, temporarily tolerated) forms of submission to the condition of slave that, despite their unconventional nature from the viewpoint of civil law and moral theology, met the necessities of the residents while they still did not dispose of the means to reproduce the societies and economies of those two regions of still incipient colonization in a connected manner and/or in accordance with the basic mechanisms of the imperial commercial and slaveholding system, in the Atlantic and Pacific spaces. Moreover, the two forms discussed here constituted attempts to legitimize slaveholding practical modalities projected no longer only over those Amerindian subjects taken as declared enemies of the Crown and of Christendom, but also over those who strictly speaking should have been free subjects in colonial society, whether in the condition of allies, vassals, or catechumens. In both cases, the frontiers between the slaveholding regime stricto sensu and the conditions of a virtual freedom conditioned to a transitory captivity (ideals synthesized in the category servidumbre, in the Chilean case) are more than porous, they are almost nonexistent. The fluidity of categories and the relative misalignment between them and concrete labor relations are, hence, characteristic elements of the configuration processes of the relations developed in the margins of the Atlantic colonial system.

Spatially distant in the Americas, but closely linked within the multidirectional gradient of forms of labor, “a la usanza” and “de condição” slavery present themselves as radically historical phenomena, that is, they become intelligible only when situated within precise historical conjunctures. To the extent that both accommodate typical practices of the “commodity slavery” model (the purchase and sale of people, forced labor, and the hereditary transmission of the “pieces” among masters, for example), but are also bearers of a peculiar juridical condition that distinguishes them from that model form (derived from the supposed native custom, from the transitory condition of the slaves, or from the artifice conducive to debt slavery), “a la usanza” and “de condição” slavery both challenge and unsettle (I) the traditional separation between slavery and other forms of labor and (II) the opposition between slavery and freedom on a linear scale – thereby complexifying the very concept of slavery.

4. Slavery, compulsory labor, asymmetric dependency, and other possible analytical developments

The analysis of the theoretical and practical emergence of the devices of “de condição” slavery and servidumbre a la usanza40 provides scope for significant analytical developments for the interpretation of the American colonial realities of the Modern Period. In the impossibility of offering a satisfactory development for each within the limits of a single article, we limit ourselves here to enumerating those insights that appear most important, even if they may by chance extrapolate the specific boundaries of the previous analysis.

1. Just as Antônio Vieira accepted the institution of “de condição” slavery “for the satisfaction of the said price” of the rescue and because “all the service of the residents of that State [is] with native Indians of the land”41, at the same time as well as some years later Diego de Rosales, also a Jesuit, defended that in addition to being a “very just and much needed” institution, a la usanza slavery was “a use that in itself does not include any malice nor anything against good customs among these Indians,” so that the benefits of those “sales” seemed to him to be simultaneously advantageous to the Spaniards (who used that labor to make their productive units function), to the lineage chiefs (who remedied their miseries with the money collected with the sales), and to the very children and other ‘reduced’ people (who thus received catechization and discipline)42. Understanding the decisive role of the religious orders in colonial America, especially that of the Jesuits, in the processes of conception, justification, and practice of these forms, requires, above all, a perspective on their activity that is, so to speak, unconstrained43. Such a perspective enables us to recognize the missionaries as participants in a network of social and political relations that extrapolate the frontiers of their orders and, as a consequence, definitively rejects the old but still persistent myth of the absolute opposition of the religious to Amerindian slavery.

2. In describing these modalities, what becomes evident is not only the regional variations expressed within them but also a genetic disjunction between regulatory norms and effective practices. Indeed, it is unsurprising that the laws of the period attempting to regulate Amerindian labor, as well as contemporary chroniclers’ descriptions of it, employed language that ultimately lagged behind the realities on the ground – with practice being markedly more complex and nuanced than the norms that often followed it. In the seventeenth century, different regions experienced different temporalities, yet they were interconnected within the same colonial empire, which modulated its legislation according to the dynamics of each constituent region. In the case of “a la usanza” slavery, belatedly prohibited under the pressure of the 1655 Mapuche rebellion, as well as in the case of “de condição” slavery – an unusual modality legitimized through its regulatory regime – the primacy given to establishing economic relations which ensured the survival of colonial settlements in expanding regions of the Iberian empires and the colonial economy was clear. In this process, the particular interests of conquerors and colonizers tended to prevail, even when their demands contradicted the general legal principles of the monarchies and the moral tenets of theologians or when they opened space for an internal slave trade that, in theory, conflicted with the regular mechanisms of the Atlantic trade, based on monopoly and exclusive licensing principles meant to safeguard the interests of the Crown and major merchants. These concessions can themselves be understood as part of the slave system, insofar as the expansion and control over those frontier regions were conditions for the “peaceful” functioning of Atlantic circuits in American territories and their progressive enlargement. In this sense, a la usanza and de condição slaveries constituted forms of legal exception within the framework of Iberian legal regimes, yet they still indirectly sustained the Atlantic slave system by supporting its reproduction and projecting its expansion into those spaces.

3. Conversely, any restrictions on such modalities of slavery – whether arising from Jesuit pressures, royal advisors, or assessments by Crown officials regarding pacification and colonial institutionalization in those frontier areas – tended to strengthen the specific interests of merchants controlling the Atlantic slave trade. Thus, examining these forms of labor and their specific regimes helps illuminate not only their particular historical characteristics but also the very dynamics of the Atlantic trade and its defining inflections, sustained by a tense equilibrium between, on the one hand, the local interests of expanding and receding regions of the Iberian empires and, on the other, the financial interests of the Crown and its associated major merchants. In other words, Indigenous labor in its various manifestations also clarifies, both historically and methodologically, what occurred in regions more closely integrated into the Atlantic circuit and how they could depend, in turn, on developments in the interior margins of the American continent.

4. Contrary to the currently fashionable “decolonial” prescriptions, neither of these modalities of Indigenous enslavement was grounded in strict racial precepts. The criteria for subjugating Amerindian groups in each case were fundamentally political (protection, alliance, and “will”), economic (“necessity” and “interest” of the Crown, its subjects, “God,” and Christendom), social (custom and “misery”), and legal (invoking jurisprudence to assess legitimate or illegitimate enslavement titles). In contemporary texts, it was natural law – with greater effectiveness, precedence, and geographic and demographic scope – that discriminated and hierarchized populations while justifying and legitimizing trafficking and slavery. Thus, if one seeks to trace processes of racialization and racism (as products, rather than drivers, of historical processes unfolding in the longue durée of Indigenous and African forced labor in early modernity), it is more pertinent first to examine the role of theologians, jurists, and philosophers who established distinctions among peoples and nations based on natural law – and, where applicable, theories of purity of blood – while accounting for the complex mediations between them. However, before them and their texts, attention must be paid to the forms of practical violence exercised by Indigenous captors (what Sartre called “practical racism”44). With regard to gender precepts, exaggeration is also unwarranted. The preference (though never exclusivity) for Indigenous women and children as “pieces” on the margins of the system can be explained, on one hand, as a mechanism for dissolving internal communal bonds in Indigenous societies and, on the other, as a logical consequence of the warrior qualities typically expected of adult men in Amazonian and Southern Andean Amerindian contexts – proximity to whom was understandably avoided by masters and traders.

5. The practice of enslaving allied subjects and/or individuals of presumably illegitimate captivity reflects the broader desensitization to violence in slave societies – though not exclusively in them –, as this theme has been explored by thinkers like Jean-Paul Sartre, Albert Memmi, and Frantz Fanon in contexts closer to our own. However, it was already present in ancient Christian literature, framed as the mutual moral corruption of master and slave, and later transposed, in the modern colonial period, to the relationship between colonizer and colonized. Between the late seventeenth and mid-eighteenth centuries, for instance, Antônio Vieira, Giorgio Benci, and Giovanni Antonio Andreoni – Jesuits active in slaveholding Brazil – as well as the priest and judge Manoel Ribeiro Rocha, argued that excessive punishments (though not institutionalized, everyday violence itself) signaled the masters’ departure from immutable moral values of humanity45.

All these issues are closely linked to our three central propositions: (I) the phenomenon of slavery in the early modern Americas (between the sixteenth and eighteenth centuries) must be examined with serious consideration of the mutable nature of both its forms and its situated historical contexts; (II) far from presenting itself historically as a single, rigid institution separated from other human forms of labor by a fictive boundary (legal, moral, or conceptual), slavery in its varied local expressions constitutes moments within an even broader diversity of coerced labor forms which, in intersecting ways, globally underpinned the construction of the modern world; (III) within the multiplicity of compulsory labor forms overlapping under specific contexts and conjunctures – usefully represented as a multidirectional gradient with tenuous transitional borders – examining distinct Indigenous enslavement modalities (and other labor appropriation patterns) offers the advantage of revealing the regular or structural dynamics of Atlantic systems through the many seemingly exceptional situations that arose at their margins.

Specialized readers may justifiably note parallels between our analyses and current debates in prominent Northern academic circles concerning the concept of “asymmetrical dependency” (WINNEBECK et al., 2023). Indeed, the basic premise that multiple forms of dependency should be examined for their relational character among concrete social subjects, the comparative approach mediating between empirical descriptions and studies of phenomena across uneven times and spaces, and the effort to construct typologies for classification are elements that closely align the two proposals. Nonetheless, we must be cautious when a concept like this – however refined and compelling – is formulated a priori with explanatory ambitions for realities spanning nearly all human history.

In fact, the term “asymmetrical dependency” has the merit of saying very little in advance about what it seeks to describe. Thus, if we flexibly appropriate it as an analytical category (rather than an explanatory concept from the outset), we can observe a far wider range of situations and processes of change than the isolated category of “slavery” permits. That said, any radical use of “asymmetrical dependency” in substitution of “labor” risks mutilating these very dependencies by stripping away what gives meaning to most of them (especially in the period under consideration): their systemic linkage as relational social practices to the material functioning and reproduction of early modern societies.

Although Americanist historiography has often reduced early modern labor systems to just a few (notably encomienda, mita, and slavery itself), recent decades of temporally and geographically focused research have shown that the range of forms of incorporation of Indigenous labor in colonial societies was far broader. In addition to confirming the genesis of two unique regional forms of enslavement in peripheral areas of the Atlantic systems (Southern Chile and the Portuguese Amazon, as seen) in the same decade (the 1650s), it is worth noting that an exhaustive case study such as that published by Luis Miguel Glave and María Isabel Remy in 1983 was in itself capable of uncovering no less than seven specific categories of native workers in the historical formation of a single Andean town in the long term (Ollantaytambo between the sixteenth and nineteenth centuries)46. Any projection of these trends to a continental scale suggests that the actual totality of lived experiences was far greater. Yet a new synthesis in light of recent historiography remains to be undertaken.

In any case, within the broad gradient of intertwined regimes, systems and modalities of work – including dissonant patterns of Indigenous slavery as marginal yet decisive moments – what Marcus Rediker and Peter Linebaugh termed a “motley crew” (from the expression “motley crowd”, coined by Marx and Engels to refer to those expropriated by land enclosures) of workers of diverse origins, physiognomies, and legal-social conditions in the early modern Atlantic takes on particular significance47. In general terms, a heterogeneous group of dispossessed characters who were then converted into forced laborers, circulating and being occupied in multiple spaces around the world at different speeds and rates, among which we highlight the case of the Iberian colonized Americas between the sixteenth and eighteenth centuries. Where, in the eyes of a contemporary observer, it would have been easy to conflate workers (blacks, Indians, Asians) enslaved by any means of ‘recruitment’ (raids, descimentos, or repartimientos) or titles considered legitimate for enslavement (ransom, just war, usanza, “miserables”, “condition”), with commissioned Indians, mitayos, administered (by the Crown, by ecclesiastics, or by private individuals), peons of all kinds, naborías, mingas, mingakos, mitmacs, yanakonas, among many others48.

The model of a multidirectional gradient encompassing multiple forms of slavery, in turn part of and resulting from an even broader gradient of the forms of human labor, offers a foundational image of a historical unit of diverse labor relation, that is both complex and contradictory, in which these forms dialectically combine and clash in practice, as they are themselves (as well as their actors and subjects: the direct workers, their masters, and the distinct intermediaries between them) agents of the processes of conflict and social change.

“A la usanza” and “de condição” Amerindian slavery are concrete expressions of this multiplicity of coerced labor forms that characterized the colonial Americas (from the sixteenth to the eighteenth centuries). Their study not only expands the prevailing historiographical framing of Indigenous slavery (demonstrating that its manifestations often exceeded classical, regulated circumstances such as “just war” and “ransom”) but also complicates the very category of slavery, subjecting it to historical – rather than merely lexical or conceptual – scrutiny. In other words, the two cases examined here demonstrate that slavery’s historical forms (particularly Amerindian slavery) cannot be fully understood without intrinsic relation to the conjunctures and contexts of their materialization and development. A model of a multidirectional gradient encompassing multiple slavery forms – itself part of an even broader gradient of human labor modalities – offers a basic image of a historically complex and contradictory unity of labor relations, where these, in practice, dialectically combine and clash, being themselves (as much as their actors and subjects: the direct workers, their masters and the different intermediaries between them) agents of the processes of conflict and social change.

I would like to thank FAPESP (Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo) for the research grant that allowed me to carry out the basic archival work that supported some of the conclusions presented in this article (Process no. 2018/01316-5).

I would like to thank MCT/CNPq (Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico) for funding the research that enabled this article (Process no. 310223/2023-7).

1

Article unpublished on any preprint platform. It draws on fully referenced sources and bibliography, emerging from collaborative research we conduct within the LABORÍNDIO – Grupo de Pesquisa sobre o Trabalho nas Américas. The authors participated in the various phases of the research and preparation of the article. They extend their gratitude to Anne-Charlotte Martineau, Forrest T. Hylton, and the anonymous reviewers appointed by the Revista de História editorial board for their critiques of earlier drafts.

3

Full Professor, Department of History, Faculty of Philosophy, Letters, and Human Sciences, Universidade de São Paulo. Participant Member of the International Research Laboratory 2034 – Worlds in Transition (USP-CNRS). I would like to thank MCT/CNPq (Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico) for funding the research that enabled this article (Process no. 310223/2023-7).

4

Artigo não publicado em plataforma preprint. Todas as fontes e bibliografia utilizadas são referenciadas. Este artigo resulta de um trabalho conjunto que os autores vêm realizando junto ao LABORÍNDIO – Grupo de Pesquisa sobre o Trabalho nas Américas. Agradecemos a Anne-Charlotte Martineau e a Forrest T. Hylton (como também aos dois pareceristas anônimos designados pelos editores da Revista de História) por seus comentários sobre versões anteriores deste texto.

5

Professor do Departamento de História da Faculdade de Filosofia, Letras e Ciências Humanas da Universidade de São Paulo. Agradeço à Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP) pela concessão da bolsa de pesquisa que permitiu realizar o trabalho documental de base que amparou algumas conclusões apresentadas neste artigo (Processo nº 2018/01316-5).

6

Professor do Departamento de História da Faculdade de Filosofia, Letras e Ciências Humanas da Universidade de São Paulo. Membro Participante do International Research Laboratory 2034 – Mundos em Transição (USP-CNRS). Agradeço ao MCT/CNPq – Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico, pela concessão da bolsa de pesquisa que permitiu a realização deste trabalho (processo: 310223/2023-7).

7

Paulin Ismard makes brief mentions in “Captifs”, and Cécile Vidal in “Culture”, “Maîtres”, “Résistance”, “Traite”, and “Violence”. In the “Transformations” section, Indigenous peoples appear marginally in Charlotte de Castelnau-L’Estoile’s article and in a more articulated and systematic manner – as the section demands – in the two articles by Cécile Vidal included there. In his review published in the New West Indian Guide, Richard Price had already pointed out other omissions in the book, noting a lack of greater attention devoted to the phenomena of resistance and marronage, as well as to slavery on the American continent (which, by his estimate, accounted for only 10% of the articles in the first section). Price attributes this, along with the fact that the book follows the Anglophone trend of presenting a history of “world slavery,” to France being more assimilationist and less interested in the topic than the Anglophone world – an approach that may have the unintended effect of diverting attention from the role France played in colonialism and slavery (PRICE, 2022, p. 352).

8

Rushforth’s study intersects with some of the issues discussed here, such as “the forms assumed by slavery” – “diverse, ranging from local practices like capture and integration into Indigenous kinship systems to the intensive exploitation of bodies through forced agricultural labor under a commodity slavery tied to global empires” – with the latter performing various roles “as servants, domestic workers, agricultural laborers, or factory workers”. However, the author cites only “more than 10,000” enslaved individuals of Indigenous and African descent in the eighteenth century (RUSHFORTH, 2021, pp. 179–185), meaning that, in this regard, his case study remains of limited significance compared to the vast scale of slavery in the Americas.

10

The most widely recognized work of this movement is undoubtedly Andrés Reséndez’s book The Other Slavery (RESÉNDEZ, 2016). Notable for its broad analytical scope, for which reason it perhaps achieved rapid dissemination despite not being truly pioneering.

20

During the period under consideration, even those “Indians” deemed legally free within colonial society were typically subjected to various forms of coerced labor. Indeed, this assessment does not account for the preserved freedom of Indigenous societies that maintained effective political autonomy relative to the contemporaneous colonial world. Yet even in such cases, the very notion of freedom must be approached with caution, as our contemporary or historical understanding of it would generally have been foreign to Indigenous cultural frameworks, rendering such conceptualizations, at their core, anachronistic.

21

In this sense, the conceptual expansion proposed through the image of a multidirectional gradient finds resonance with Marcel van der Linden’s formulation of mature capitalism. As he argues, “there is an almost endless variety of producers in capitalism, and the intermediate forms between the different categories are fluid rather than sharply defined”. (VAN DER LINDEN, 2008, p. 22). The author thus positions four “forms” on a relational plane: free wage labor, self-employment, slavery, and the lumpenproletariat. The limit of this parallel lies in the greater multiplicity of labor forms in the colonial American world and the heightened complexity of the societies where they operated.

22

In examining what he terms “the ‘long century’ of Indigenous slavery” (spanning the last three decades of the sixteenth century through the end of the seventeenth) in São Paulo, he demonstrated how in this context it acquired “all the necessary characteristics to be considered simultaneously as: 1) a concrete labor modality (insofar as it was effectively practiced and widespread in social reality); 2) a labor system (by playing an organic function in the structural reproduction mechanisms of society); and 3) a labor regime (being regulated by a set of institutional rules that were recognized and shared, at least in their elementary foundations, by different members of the social body)” (VELLOSO, 2020, p. 35).

23

In relation to this, see: VIDAL, 2021, p. 889; and VAN DEUSEN, 2023a, pp. 395-432.

24

These and other arguments in favor of the royal ratification of “servidumbre a la usanza” were summarized for the court by the Sergeant Major of Chile in 1651, Martín Cerdán: Martín Cerdán. Declaration. Santiago, June 5, 1651. Archivo General de Indias, Chile 13, r. 5, n. 32, ff. 6r-8r.

27

This documentation is located at: Archivo General de Indias, Chile 13, r. 5, doc. 32, 48 fols (“Autos que remitió Don Antonio Ramírez de Laguna con carta de 30 de junio de 1652 sobre vender los indios a sus hijos, hermanos y parientes”).

28

The debates that culminated in the promulgation of the 1674 law can be traced in: AGI, Chile 57 (“Expediente de la libertad de los indios esclavos de guerra”). See also: OBREGÓN; ZAVALA, 2009, pp. 20-24; VALENZUELA, 2019, pp. 240-253; VELLOSO, 2022-2023, pp. 329-330. The royal decrees of 1656 and 1674, which respectively prohibited “esclavitud a la usanza” and Mapuche slavery in general, have been transcribed and published in: JARA; PINTO, 1982, pp. 286-287 and 319-325. Cases involving the persistence of “a la usanza” slavery despite its prohibition can be examined in: VILAR; JIMÉNEZ, 2001, pp. 31-55 and CHUECAS SALDÍAS, 2017, pp. 167-194.

29

Both can be consulted at: Anais da Biblioteca Nacional, n. 66, pp. 19-21 and 25-28; and PERRONE-MOISÉS, 2021, pp. 123-124 and 130-131.

31

Particularly eloquent in this regard is the final ruling in favor of the widow Anna de Fonte in the mid-eighteenth century, in the well-documented case of the enslaved woman Francisca analyzed by David G. Sweet: “Francisca’s case was first heard by the chief justice of the colony, who found that the woman should be declared a free person. This was because Dona Anna had been unable to produce a certificate of legitimate enslavement and because Francisca had been brought from the sertão by people licensed not to go slaving but only to go up after cacao. The widow Fonte then appealed the case to the Council of Missions, a body consisting of the heads of all the religious orders established in Pará, which held final jurisdiction in matters involving the administration of the Indians. The council reversed the judge’s decision (...). Expressing its belief that justice was better served by attending to the ‘truth’ than to the confusing details of the evidence assembled in the case, the council ordered that Francisca return obediently to the service of her mistress. When all was said and done, she was no more or less than an ordinary escrava resgatada, a slave bought and delivered by the traders of Pará, who was by custom obliged to work for a lifetime to repay the cost of her purchase (SWEET & NASH, 1981, p. 289).

32

“If the captives were taken in war, it shall be ascertained whether the war was just or unjust; and if found to be unjust, they may be ransomed according to His Majesty’s law, to serve for five years, what are commonly called escravos de condição”. VIEIRA, 1951 [1655], p. 29. The provisional status of some enslaved individuals had longstanding legal precedent, regulated since one of the earliest Indigenous laws in 1587, which authorized the purchase of an Indian “to prevent them from being eaten by other Indians, when there was no other means to save them from the inhuman cruelty by which they eat each other. Those thus purchased shall remain captive until they have repaid their purchaser”. See: “Lei que SM passou sobre os Indios do Brasil que não podem ser captivos e declara os que o podem ser”, 24/02/1587. In: PERRONE-MOISÉS, 2021, pp. 67-68 (the original document is held at: Arquivo Histórico Ultramarino, Códice 112, fols. 47-47v).

33

“Ley que se passou pelo Secretario de Estado em 9 de Abril de 655 sobre os Indios do Maranhão. 09/04/1655”. In: Anais da Biblioteca Nacional. Rio de Janeiro, vol. 66, p. 25-28; and PERRONE-MOISÉS, 2021, p. 131.

34

See: “Carta Régia ordena S. Magestade [D. João V] ao Governador [Joze da Serra] que como por alguas ordens suas está determinado que os Indios em que há duvida no seu Captiveiro se dem de condição por cinco annos no fim delles livres, e para saber os que assim se achão haja hum Livro em que se matriculem, o qual terá o Procurador dos Indios para que findo o termo dos cinco annos lhes solicite a Liberdade” (13/04/1734). In: Anais da Biblioteca Nacional. Rio de Janeiro, vol. 67, 1948, p. 258-259.

35

The full original title is: “Livro que há de servir para o registro das canoas que se despacharem para o sertão ao cacau e às peças, e das que voltarem com escravos. E nele hão de assinar termo os cabos das mesmas canoas”. The document is transcript in: MEIRA, 1994.

38

That is the conclusion of: VELLOSO, 2021, pp. 272 and 280.

39

On the spatial dynamics of the advance of the colonial presence in the Amazon River basin and its vicissitudes, see: DIAS, 2014a, pp. 59-89; and BOMBARDI, 2024, pp. 31-98.

40

For more thorough and systematic treatments of how each of these forms tended to be practiced in their respective local societies, including some information (not always as precise as one might wish) regarding the immediate circumstances of their implementation, the profiles of the enslaved individuals, owners and intermediaries, their frequency and scope, among other aspects, consult the aforementioned references: VILAR; JIMÉNEZ, 2001; CHUECAS SALDÍAS, 2017; VELLOSO, 2022-2023 (regarding “servidumbre a la usanza”); ZERON, 2016; and PRADO, 2024 (concerning “de condição” slavery).

41

“Informação sobre o modo com que foram tomados e sentenciados por cativos os índios do ano de 1655” and “Resposta aos capítulos que deu contra os religiosos da Companhia, em 1662, o Procurador do Maranhão Jorge Sampaio”. The references are, respectively, in: VIEIRA, 1951, pp. 65 and 298.

42

43

In the mid-1990s, Luce Giard and Pierre-Antoine Fabre conceptualized a “désenclavement” of religious history (GIARD, 1995; GIARD; VAUCELLES, 1996; FABRE, 1999a; FABRE, 1999b). This same perspective emerged in Mexico (in the journal Historia y Grafía in 1996) through theoretical propositions derived from Michel de Certeau’s work.

47

LINEBAUGH; REDIKER, 2008, pp. 155-186 and 224-261. According to the authors, the expression can be found both in eighteenth century writings (such as those of merchant Henry Laurens and South Carolina governor William Bull) and in The German Ideology (1845-6), by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels (pp. 212 and 20, respectively).

48

These represent just a few of the dozens of forms of labor and systems already identified and analyzed in the historiography. Unfortunately, a more substantial treatment than mere mention proves unfeasible within the scope of this article, given that both the historiography and historical evidence from the period present divergences regarding their characteristics, dynamics, scope, and definitions. For concise instrumental definitions of these and other categories of Indigenous labor systems conceptualized and practiced between the sixteenth and nineteenth centuries, readers may consult the “Glossary” we have developed through LABORÍNDIO (Grupo de Pesquisa sobre o Trabalho nas Américas), available at the website www.laborindio.fflch.usp.br.

Research data availability

all data are available in the text

References

  • AUTOS que remitió Don Antonio Ramírez de Laguna con carta de 30 de junio de 1652 sobre vende los indios a sus hijos, hermanos y parientes. Archivo General de Indias, Chile 13, r. 5, doc. 32, 48 fols.
  • EXPEDIENTE de la libertad de los indios esclavos de guerra. Archivo General de Indias, Chile 57.
  • CERDÁN, Martin Declaração. Santiago, 05.06.1651. Archivo General de Indias, Chile 13, r. 5, n. 32, ff. 6r-8r.

References

  • JARA, Alvaro; PINTO, Sonia (eds.). Fuentes para la historia del trabajo en el Reino de Chile: legislación 1546-1810, tomo 1. Santiago: Editorial Andrés Bello, 1982.
  • MEIRA, Márcio (org.). O livro das canoas: documentos para a história indígena da Amazônia. São Paulo: NHII/USP/Fapesp, 1994.
  • PERRONE-MOISÉS, Beatriz (org.). Documentos de legislação indigenista colonial. Parte 1: 1500-1700. São Paulo: Centro de Estudos Ameríndios, 2021.
  • ROSALES, Diego de. Manifiesto apologético de los daños de la esclavitud del Reino de Chile (1670). Santiago: Catalonia, 2013 [1670].
  • VIEIRA, Antônio. Obras escolhidas, vol. V (obras várias em defesa dos índios) Lisboa: Livraria Sá da Costa Editora, 1951.

References

  • BOMBARDI, Fernanda Aires. Redes indígenas e missionárias: descimentos carmelitas e reducciones jesuíticas entre omáguas, yurimáguas, aysuares e manaos (1686-1757) 2024. Tese (Doutorado em História Social) - Universidade de São Paulo, 2024.
  • BROOKS, James. Captives & cousins: slavery, kinship, and community in the Southwest borderlands. Chapel Hill and London: The University of North Carolina Press, 2002.
  • CHAMBOULEYRON, Rafael; ARENZ, Karl Heinz. Amazonian Atlantic: cacao, colonial expansion and indigenous labour in the Portuguese Amazon Region (seventeenth and eighteenth centuries). Journal of Latin American Studies, v. 53, 2021, p. 221-244. Disponível em: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-latin-american-studies/article/abs/amazonian-atlantic-cacao-colonial-expansion-and-indigenous-labour-in-the-portuguese-amazon-region-seventeenth-and-eighteenth-centuries/7404230520C4AC7825DCBD30F2B1577F Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022216X21000213.
    » https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022216X21000213» https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-latin-american-studies/article/abs/amazonian-atlantic-cacao-colonial-expansion-and-indigenous-labour-in-the-portuguese-amazon-region-seventeenth-and-eighteenth-centuries/7404230520C4AC7825DCBD30F2B1577F
  • CHUECAS SALDÍAS, Ignacio. ‘Venta es dar una cosa cierta por precio cierto’: cultura jurídica y esclavitud infantil en pleitos fronterizos chilenos (1673-1775). In: CORDERO FERNÁNDEZ, Macarena; GAUNE CORRADI, Rafael; MORENO JERIA, Rodrigo. (comps.). Cultura legal y espacios de justicia en América, siglos XVI-XIX Santiago: Centro de Investigaciones Barros Arana, 2017, p. 167-194.
  • DIAS, Camila Loureiro; BOMBARDI, Fernanda Aires; COSTA, Eliardo Guimarães da. Dimensão da população indígena no Estado do Maranhão e Grão-Pará entre 1650-1750: uma ordem de grandeza. Revista de História (USP), n. 179, 2020, p. 1-40. Disponível em: https://revistas.usp.br/revhistoria/article/view/163670 Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.11606/issn.2316-9141.rh.2020.163670.
    » https://doi.org/10.11606/issn.2316-9141.rh.2020.163670» https://revistas.usp.br/revhistoria/article/view/163670
  • DIAS, Camila Loureiro. Indigenous Labor and Agency in Brazilian Colonial History: A Historiographic Assessment. History of Anthropology Newsletter, v. 42, 2018, p. 3.
  • DIAS, Camila Loureiro. L’Amazonie avant Pombal. Politique, Économie, Territoire. Tese de Doutorado, Histoire et Civilisations, École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales, 2014a.
  • DIAS, Camila Loureiro. O Livro das Canoas, uma descrição. In: CHAMBOULEYRON, Rafael & ARENZ, Karl-Heinz (orgs.). In: ENCONTRO INTERNACIONAL DE HISTÓRIA COLONIAL, 4., 3,14. Anais...Belém: Açaí, 2014b, p. 57-70.
  • DIAS, Camila Loureiro. Os índios, a Amazônia e os conceitos de escravidão e liberdade. Estudos Avançados, v. 33, 2019, p. 235-252. Disponível em: https://www.revistas.usp.br/eav/article/view/164947 Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-4014.2019.3397.013
    » https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-4014.2019.3397.013» https://www.revistas.usp.br/eav/article/view/164947
  • ELTIS, David; ENGERMAN, Stanley Lewis (eds.). The Cambridge World History of Slavery, v. 3 (AD 1420 – AD 1804). New York: Cambridge University Press, 2011.
  • FABRE, Pierre-Antoine. Présentation. Conversions religieuses: Histoires et récits. Annales. Histoire, Sciences Sociales, ano 54, n. 4, 1999b, p. 805-812.
  • FABRE, Pierre-Antoine. Histoire génerale. Revue de Synthèse, v. 120, 1999b, p. 433-439.
  • FARAGE, Nádia. As muralhas dos sertões: os povos indígenas no Rio Branco e a colonização Rio de Janeiro: Paz e Terra, 1991.
  • GALLAY, Alan. The Indian slave trade: the rise of the English empire in the American south 1670-1717. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2002.
  • GIARD, Luce (ed.). Les jésuites à la Renaissance: système éducatif et production du savoir. Paris: PUF, 1995.
  • GIARD, Luce; VAUCELLES, Louis de (eds.). Les jésuites à l’âge barroque: 1540-1640. Grenoble: Jéróme Millon, 1996.
  • GIUDICELLI, Christophe. La raya de los pulares: institution d’une frontière indienne coloniale au sein du Valle Calchaquí (1582-1630). In: OBREGÓN ITURRA, Jimena Paz; CAPDEVILA, Luc; RICHARD, Nicolas (dirs.). Les indiens des frontières coloniales: Amérique australe, XVIe siècle/temps présent Rennes: Presses Universitaires de Rennes, 2011, p. 27-57.
  • GLAVE TESTINO, Luis Miguel & REMY, María Isabel. Estructura agraria y vida rural en una región andina: Ollantaytambo entre los siglos XVI y XIX Cuzco: Centro de Estudios Rurales Andinos “Bartolomé de Las Casas”, 1983.
  • GONZALES JAUREGUI, Yobani Maikel. Legislación canónica y matrimonios de esclavizados en la América colonial Lima: Cedet, 2021.
  • HÄMÄLÄINEN, Pekka. Indigenous America: the epic contest for North America. New York: Liveright, 2023.
  • HYLTON, Forrest Timothy. The sole owners of the land: empire, war, and authority in the Guajura Peninsula, 1761-1779. Atlantic Studies, v. 13, 2016, p. 315-344. Disponível em: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14788810.2016.1192797 Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/14788810.2016.1192797.
    » https://doi.org/10.1080/14788810.2016.1192797» https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14788810.2016.1192797
  • ISMARD, Paulin (dir.). Les mondes de l’esclavage: une histoire comparée. Paris: Seuil, 2021.
  • JARA, Álvaro. Guerre et société au Chili: essai de sociologie coloniale Paris: Université de Paris, 1961.
  • KLEIN, Herbert. African Slavery in Latin America and the Caribbean. London: Oxford University Press, 1988 [1986].
  • LINEBAUGH, Peter; REDIKER, Marcus. A hidra de muitas cabeças: marinheiros, escravos, plebeus e a história oculta do Atlântico revolucionário. Tradução de Berilo Vargas. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras, 2008 [2000].
  • MELLAFE, Rolando. La esclavitud en Hispanoamérica. Buenos Aires: Editorial Universitaria de Buenos Aires, 1984.
  • MONTEIRO, John Manuel. Negros da terra: índios e bandeirantes nas origens de São Paulo São Paulo: Companhia das Letras, 1994.
  • OBREGÓN ITURRA, Jimena Paz; ZAVALA CEPEDA, José Manuel. Abolición y persistencia de la esclavitud indígena en Chile colonial: estrategias esclavistas en la frontera araucano-mapuche. Memoria Americana, n. 17, v. 1, 2009, p. 11-35. Disponível em: http://revistascientificas.filo.uba.ar/index.php/MA/article/view/11907 Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.34096/mace.v17i1.11907
    » https://doi.org/10.34096/mace.v17i1.11907» http://revistascientificas.filo.uba.ar/index.php/MA/article/view/11907
  • PARGAS, Damian Alan; SCHIEL, Juliane (eds.). The Palgrave Handbook of Global Slavery throughout History Londres: Palgrave MacMillan, 2023.
  • PATTERSON, Orlando. Escravidão e morte social: um estudo comparativo. Tradução de Fábio Duarte Joly. São Paulo: Edusp, 2008 [1982].
  • PÉREZ GARCÍA, Rafael Mauricio; FERNÁNDEZ CHAVES, Manuel Francisco; FRANÇA PAIVA, Eduardo (coords.). Tratas, esclavitudes y mestizajes: una historia conectada, siglos XV-XVIII. Sevilha: Editorial Universidad de Sevilla, 2020.
  • PETRONE, Pasquale. Aldeamentos Paulistas São Paulo: Edusp, 1995.
  • PRADO, Luma. Cativas litigantes: demandas indígenas por liberdade na Amazônia portuguesa (1706-1759). São Paulo: Elefante, 2024.
  • PRICE, Richard. Les Mondes de l’esclavage: une histoire comparée by Paulin Ismard, Benedetta Rossi and Cécile Vidal. New West Indian Guide, v. 96, n. 3/4, 2022, p. 351-352. Disponível em: https://brill.com/view/journals/nwig/96/3-4/article-p351_11.xml Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1163/22134360-09603008.
    » https://doi.org/10.1163/22134360-09603008» https://brill.com/view/journals/nwig/96/3-4/article-p351_11.xml
  • RÉ, Henrique A., SAES, Laurent Azevedo Marques de & VELLOSO, Gustavo (orgs.). História e historiografía do trabalho escravo no Brasil: novas perspectivas. São Paulo: Edições BBM, 2020.
  • RESÉNDEZ, Andrés. The Other Slavery: the uncovered story of Indian enslavement in America. Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2016.
  • REVILLA ORÍAS, Paola. E ntangled Coercion: African and Indigenous Labour in Charcas (16th-17th Century) Berlim: De Gruyter, 2021 [2019].
  • RUSHFORTH, Brett. Amérindiens Français et Britanniques: les esclavages Canadiens. In: ISMARD, Paulin (dir.). Les mondes de l’esclavage: une histoire comparée. Paris: Seuil, 2021, p. 179-186.
  • RUSHFORTH, Brett. Bonds of alliance: indigenous & Atlantic slaveries in New France. North Carolina: The University of North Carolina Press, 2012.
  • SARTRE, Jean-Paul. Critique de la raison dialectique (précédé de Questions de Méthode) Tome I: Théorie des ensembles pratiques. Paris: Gallimard, 1960.
  • SCHWARCZ, Lilia Moritz; GOMES, Flávio (orgs.). Dicionário da escravidão e liberdade: 50 textos críticos. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras, 2018.
  • SCHWARTZ, Stuart. Segredos internos: engenhos e escravos na sociedade colonial. Tradução de Laura Teixeira Motta. São Paulo: Companhia das Letras, 2011 [1985].
  • SOMMER, Barbara. O sertão colonial: expedições amazônicas e o comércio de escravos indígenas. Tradução de Raduan van Velthem Meira e Márcio Meira. Revista do Instituto Histórico e Geográfico do Pará, v. 10, n. 1, 2023 [2005], p. 149-171. Disponível em: https://ihgp.net.br/revistaojs/index.php/revihgp/article/view/59 Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.17648/ihgp.v10i1.59.
    » https://doi.org/10.17648/ihgp.v10i1.59» https://ihgp.net.br/revistaojs/index.php/revihgp/article/view/59
  • SWEET, David.; NASH, Gary (eds.). Struggle and Survival in Colonial America Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press, 1981.
  • TAU ANZOÁTEGUI, Victor. El poder de la costumbre: estudios sobre el derecho consuetudinario en América hispana hasta la emancipación Edição do autor, 2000. Disponível em: https://www.larramendi.es/es/consulta/registro.do?id=1115 Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025.
    » https://www.larramendi.es/es/consulta/registro.do?id=1115
  • VALENZUELA MÁRQUEZ, Jaime. Esclavos mapuches: para una historia del secuestro y deportación de indígenas en la Colonia. In: GAUNE, Rafael & LARA, Martin (eds.). Historias de racismo y discriminación en Chile. Santiago: Uqbar Editores, 2009, p. 225-260.
  • VALENZUELA MÁRQUEZ, Jaime. Los indios cautivos en la frontera de guerra chilena: entre la abolición de la esclavitud y la recomposición de la servidumbre esclavista. In: ALVEAL, Carmen; DIAS, Thiago (orgs.). Espaços coloniais: domínio, poderes e representações. São Paulo: Alameda, 2019, p. 229-261.
  • VAN DER LINDEN, Marcel. Trabalhadores do mundo: ensaios para uma história global do trabalho. Tradução de Patrícia de Queiroz Carvalho Zimbres. Campinas: Editora da Unicamp, 2013 [2008].
  • VAN DEUSEN Nancy. Indigenous Slavery from Out on the Edge. Ethnohistory, n. 67, v. 4, 2020, p. 603–619. Disponível em: https://read.dukeupress.edu/ethnohistory/article-abstract/67/4/603/167235/Indigenous-Slavery-from-Out-on-the-Edge?redirectedFrom=fulltext Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1215/00141801-8579258.
    » https://doi.org/10.1215/00141801-8579258» https://read.dukeupress.edu/ethnohistory/article-abstract/67/4/603/167235/Indigenous-Slavery-from-Out-on-the-Edge?redirectedFrom=fulltext
  • VAN DEUSEN, Nancy. In the Tethered Shadow: Native American Slavery, African Slavery, and the Disappearance of the Past. The William and Mary Quarterly, v. 80, n. 2, 2023a, p. 355-388. Disponível em: https://muse.jhu.edu/article/895075 Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: 10.1353/wmq.2023.0020
    » https://doi.org/10.1353/wmq.2023.0020» https://muse.jhu.edu/article/895075
  • VAN DEUSEN, Nancy. Why Indigenous slavery continued in Spanish America after the New Laws of 1542. The Americas, n. 80, v. 3, 2023b, p. 395-432. Disponível em: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/americas/article/why-indigenous-slavery-continued-in-spanish-america-after-the-new-laws-of-1542/3189EAB5FBC018DBE89AE97B07AFC5D7 Acesso em: 10/01/2025. Doi: 10.1017/tam.2023.33.
    » https://doi.org/10.1017/tam.2023.33» https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/americas/article/why-indigenous-slavery-continued-in-spanish-america-after-the-new-laws-of-1542/3189EAB5FBC018DBE89AE97B07AFC5D7
  • VELLOSO, Gustavo. Esclavitud a la usanza: historicidad de una modalidad de enajenación humana (Chile, 1655-1662). In: FERNÁNDEZ CHAVES, Manuel Francisco; PÉREZ GARCÍA, Rafael Mauricio (orgs.). Tratas atlánticas y esclavitudes en América: siglos XVI-XIX. Sevilha: Editorial Universidad de Sevilla, 2021, p. 271-287.
  • VELLOSO, Gustavo. História e historiografia do trabalho indígena em São Paulo colonial. Revista de Historia de América, n. 159, v. 1, 2020, p. 13-49. Disponível em: https://revistasipgh.org/index.php/rehiam/article/view/690 Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.35424/rha.159.2020.690.
    » https://doi.org/10.35424/rha.159.2020.690» https://revistasipgh.org/index.php/rehiam/article/view/690
  • VELLOSO, Gustavo. Ociosos e sedicionários: populações indígenas e os tempos do trabalho nos Campos de Piratininga (século XVII) São Paulo: Intermeios, 2018.
  • VELLOSO, Gustavo. Os nós da flecha: crise e sublevação nas fronteiras meridionais do império espanhol (Chile, 1655-1662). 2022. Tese (Doutorado em História Social) - Universidade de São Paulo, 2022-2023.
  • VIDAL, Cécile. Des empires esclavagistes : impérialisme, colonialisme et esclavage dans les mondes atlantiques, XVe-XVIIIe siècles. In: ISMARD, Paulin (dir.). Les mondes de l’esclavage: une histoire comparée Paris: Seuil, 2021, p. 861-896.
  • VILA VILAR, Enriqueta. Hispanoamérica y el comercio de esclavos Sevilha: Escuela de Estudios Hispanoamericanos, 1977.
  • VILLAR, Daniel; JIMÉNEZ, Juan Francisco. ‘Para servirse de ellos’: cautiverio, ventas a la usanza del pays y rescate de indios en las Pampas y Araucanía (siglos XVII-XIX). Relaciones de la Sociedad Argentina de Antropología, n. 26, 2001, p. 31-55. Disponível em: https://repositoriodigital.uns.edu.ar/handle/123456789/3074 Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: http://repositoriodigital.uns.edu.ar/handle/123456789/3074.
    » https://repositoriodigital.uns.edu.ar/handle/123456789/3074
  • WINNEBECK, Julia et alii The Analytical Concept of Asymmetrical Dependency. Journal of Global Slavery, n. 8, 2023, p. 1-59. Disponível em: https://www.dependency.uni-bonn.de/images/pdf-files/the-analytical-concept-of-asymmetrical-dependency.pdf Acesso em: 10 jan. 2025. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1163/2405836X-00801002.
    » https://doi.org/10.1163/2405836X-00801002» https://www.dependency.uni-bonn.de/images/pdf-files/the-analytical-concept-of-asymmetrical-dependency.pdf
  • WITTGENSTEIN, Ludwig. Le cahier bleu et le cahier brun Paris: Gallimard, 1996 [1958].
  • ZERON, Carlos Alberto de Moura Ribeiro. A construção de uma ordem colonial nas margens americanas do Império português: discussões sobre o “bem comum” nas disputas de moradores e jesuítas pela administração dos índios. 2009. Tese (Livre-Docência do Departamento de História) Universidade de São Paulo, 2009.
  • ZERON, Carlos Alberto de Moura Ribeiro. Antônio Vieira e os escravos de condição: os aldeamentos jesuíticos no contexto das sociedades coloniais. In: FERNANDES, Eunícia Barros Barcelos (org.). A Companhia de Jesus e os índios. Curitiba: Prismas, 2016, p. 235-262.
  • ZERON, Carlos Alberto de Moura Ribeiro. Linha de Fé: a Companhia de Jesus e a escravidão no processo de formação da sociedade colonial (Brasil, séculos XVI e XVII). São Paulo: Edusp, 2011.

Correspondence

Contacts Universidade de São Paulo Faculdade de Filosofia, Letras e Ciências Humanas Departamento de História Av. Prof. Lineu Prestes, 338 05508-000 – São Paulo – São Paulo – Brazil gustavo.velloso@usp.br zeron@usp.br

Conflict of interests

Nothing to declare

Editors Responsible

Miguel Palmeira and Stella Maris Scatena Franco

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    12 Jan 2026
  • Date of issue
    2025

History

  • Received
    20 Feb 2025
  • Accepted
    07 July 2025
location_on
Universidade de São Paulo, Faculdade de Filosofia, Letras e Ciências Humanas, Departamento de História Av. Prof. Lineu Prestes, 338, 01305-000 , Tel.: (55 11) 3091-3701 - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
E-mail: revistahistoria@usp.br
rss_feed Acompanhe os números deste periódico no seu leitor de RSS
Ir para o topo