Abstract
Phytogeographic studies are essential for ensuring the reliability and traceability of honey, allowing for the identification and characterization of vegetation surrounding apiaries, thereby guaranteeing product authenticity and food safety. Western Paraná stands out in honey production due to its phytogeographic diversity, favorable climate, and strong beekeeping tradition. This study aimed to analyze the phytogeographic composition around georeferenced apiaries in western Paraná, certified with a Indication of Source Seal, by assessing land use and cover within a three-kilometer buffer zone, assumed as the foraging area of the bees. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was applied and the most important variables identified were water bodies and agricultural areas for PC1, and vegetation and pasture areas for PC2. Data clustering reflected land use patterns: apiaries near the lake were predominantly surrounded by water and vegetation, while those farther away were mainly located in agricultural areas. These findings are consistent with the phytogeographic characteristics of the region. This study provides important information, as it will allow the association of the region’s phytogeography with the previously investigated physicochemical and floristic composition of honey. It may thus provide support for obtaining the Designation of Origin seal for honey from the western region of Paraná.
Key words
Beekeeping; Geographic Identity; Trophic Resources; Use and Occupation
INTRODUCTION
Brazil has significant beekeeping potential due to its diverse flora, vast territorial extension, and climatic variability, which allows for year-round honey production. This contrasts with other countries where beekeepers typically harvest honey only once a year (Hanel et al. 2020). Another relevant aspect is the strict consumer market regarding quality, food safety, and honey traceability, making the geographical characterization of apiaries an important tool (Camargo et al. 2014).
According to Klosowski et al. (2020), in addition to being a complementary agricultural activity with a significant increase in productivity, beekeeping provides additional income opportunities for producers through the sale of honey and by-products such as beeswax, royal jelly, propolis, and apitoxin. Furthermore, bees play a crucial role as primary pollinators of plants intended for human consumption.
Beekeeping in Paraná, particularly in the western region of the state, has a long-standing tradition and has been driven over the past two decades by a network of technical assistance, research, and training institutions, as well as the strengthening of associations and cooperatives.
With the validation of these network-based actions and the proven quality of the honey, through research conducted at the Western Paraná State University (UNIOESTE) in partnership with SEBRAE and ITAIPU-Binacional, the Solidarity Agro-Family Beekeepers’ Cooperative of Western Paraná (COOFAMEL) applied to the National Institute of Industrial Property (INPI), for a Geographical Indication (GI) seal, under the Indication of Origin (IP) category. The right to use the seal, named “Oeste do Paraná”, was granted in July 2017 (INPI 2017).
The producers’ next goal is to obtain the Designation of Origin (DO) seal, which aims to further enhance the product’s identity and value, according to INPI regulations, this requires proof of the relationship between the product and its origin (INPI 2017).
The phytogeography of the region is characterized by the presence of the Itaipu Lake and the riparian forest strip, which has been restored throughout the Paraná River basin that supplies this reservoir.
In the case of honey from the western region, 15 years of university research can support the verification of this relationship between honey characteristics and its phytogeographical origin. These studies include physicochemical and bioactive compound characterizations (Camargo et al. 2014, Moraes et al. 2014, Galhardo et al. 2020, Ribeiro et al. 2022, Chiamolera et al. 2023, Favreto et al. 2023a, b), melissopalynological analysis (Carvalho et al. 2019, Moraes et al. 2019) and pesticide residues in honey (Cunha et al. 2024).
Regarding the environment surrounding the apiaries, floristic surveys were conducted (Camargo et al. 2014, Tonelli et al. 2022), along with the georeferencing of apiaries and geoprocessing of the collected data (Camargo et al. 2014, Cunha et al. 2024), which contribute to the phytogeographic characterization of these apiaries. In these studies, however, it was not possible to demonstrate any differentiation between the phytogeography of apiaries located closer to the Itaipu Lake and those situated farther away, which had been expected due to the presence of the lake’s protective strip (riparian forest) and the predominance of agriculture in the surrounding region.
In this context, studies related to the local phytogeography aim to complement and continuously update information on the characterization and origin of the produced honey. The phytogeographic analysis of species encompasses fields of knowledge such as taxonomy, climatology, ecology, and physiology, among others, to assess the influence of environmental factors on plant formations (Pereira et al. 2018). According to these authors, phytogeographic analyses provide insights into the relationship between climatic and physiographic factors and plant growth and development, as well as identifying the most prominent species in the research area.
The phytogeographic characterization of the areas surrounding georeferenced apiaries belonging to producers selected for the use of the Indication of Source (IP) seal is important, as it will contribute to defining the local identity of the honey and support the application for the Designation of Origin (DO) seal. Furthermore, the phytogeography of these apiaries is representative of the environments found in most apiaries located in municipalities bordering the Itaipu Lake, in the western region of Paraná.
Thus, this study aims to analyze the land use and land cover surrounding these apiaries and their statistical grouping, in order to consolidate the phytogeographic characterization of apiaries in the western region of Paraná.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Geographical information of the study area
Apiaries of Apis mellifera bees were georeferenced in counties of western Paraná, which contain some remnants of Semideciduous Seasonal Forest, also found in the northern region of Paraná State (Maack 2002, Veloso et al. 1991). Ribeiro et al. (2014), in land-use covering the western region of Paraná, identified soybean, corn, and wheat crops as temporary, and reported the presence forest fragments, which can reach up to 20 km² in sloped areas, which include both native and replanted vegetation, as well as pastures, play a significant role in the local landscape.
The study area is situated within the Third Paraná Plateau, characterized predominantly by low-relief plains (Maack 2002). According to Köppen’s (1948) climate classification, the region has a Cfa climate, classified as humid subtropical and mesothermal, with an annual precipitation of 1,600 mm. The average annual temperature is 21°C, with minimum and maximum averages of 15°C and 28°C, respectively.
Most of the counties containing the georeferenced apiaries are riparian counties (Figure 1); that is, they have all or part of their territory bordering Itaipu Lake, Paraná River (Da Silva & Schwaab Thibes 2021). The vegetation surrounding this lake consists of anthropized riparian forest, reforested starting in 1979 with the construction of the Itaipu Hydroelectric Power Plant. It averages 300 meters in width on both riverbanks and extends for approximately 2,900 kilometers, in addition to riparian forest areas along the tributary rivers that form the flooded portion of the Paraná River (Paraná III Basin), as well as Legal Reserve areas (Ostrovski 2014).
For the phytogeographic study, specific apiary locations were selected from beekeepers in western Paraná who were authorized to use the Indication of Origin seal. Although 50 beekeepers were granted this designation, statistical analyses were performed on data from 35 producers who provided honey samples consistently across all harvest seasons over a 10-year period. These beekeepers were affiliated with COOFAMEL (Solidarity Agro-Family Beekeepers’ Cooperative of Western Paraná) and/or regional beekeeping associations, including APIOESTE (Beekeepers’ Association of Western Paraná), APIER (Beekeepers’ Association of Entre Rios do Oeste), and APITERRA (Beekeepers’ Association of Terra Roxa).
The geographical coordinates of the apiaries were obtained using a GNSS (Global Navigation Satellite System) receiver, specifically the Garmin Etrex model. Spatial analysis of the apiaries was conducted using Geographic Information Systems (GIS) software, including QGIS and ArcGIS. The land use and land cover map was generated using SPRING GIS software, based on Landsat-8 satellite imagery (orbit/path 224/77) dated October 23, 2019. The classification method employed was ISOSEG, and the classified areas was defined based on a 3-km buffer around each apiary, considered the foraging radius of A. mellifera, a value commonly applied in landscape studies as a typical operational foraging range (Beekman & Ratnieks 2000, Steffan-Dewenter & Kuhn 2003, Couvillon et al. 2014).
The classified land use categories included agriculture, water bodies, pasture, vegetation, and urban areas, with all variables expressed in hectares (ha) and corresponding to regions within western Paraná. This analysis aimed to assess potential differences in landscape composition surrounding the apiaries, based on their proximity to Itaipu Lake and its tributaries, categorized as Near the Lake (PL) or Distant from the Lake (DL).
The classification of the apiaries as being near (PL) or distant (DL) from the Itaipu Lake was defined based on their geographic location in relation to the main water body and its tributary arms. An empirical criterion of physical proximity was adopted, also based on the designation of “riparian counties” (Da Silva & Schwaab Thibes 2021), similar to that used in previous studies conducted in the region. In this study, multivariate analysis was applied alongside land use and land cover analyses, which, to some extent, allowed for the evaluation of the consistency of this terminology.
Statistical analysis
For the analysis of Land Use and Occupation data, was used GENES software (version 7.0) (Cruz 2013). Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was performed, followed by clustering based on the quadrants derived from the PCA results, with each quadrant in the scatter plot considered as a group, and evaluation of the importance of variables in the principal components.
The land use and occupation variables evaluated were: water body area, agricultural area, pasture area, vegetation area, urban area, and total buffer area, all expressed in hectares (ha). A 3 km radius surrounding each apiary was considered for the area assessment. These data were used to characterize the landscape surrounding the apiaries and to identify spatial patterns, emphasizing the proximity of the analyzed areas to the water bodies associated with the Itaipu Reservoir in western Paraná.
In applying the PCA technique, environmental variables were standardized to a mean of zero and a variance of one to prevent the influence of differences in measurement scales. This standardization ensured that all variables contributed proportionally to the principal components. Prior to PCA, possible collinearity among the variables: water body area, agricultural area, pasture area, vegetation area, urban area, and total buffer area, was evaluated.
The number of components to be retained was determined using Kaiser’s criterion (eigenvalues ≥ 1), complemented by a visual inspection of the scree plot to identify the inflection point. To facilitate interpretation and identify structural groupings among the evaluated sites, an orthogonal varimax rotation was applied. Additionally, factor loadings were analyzed to determine the relevance of each variable in the composition of the principal components, with loadings above 0.60 considered as highly contributing to the formation of multivariate axes.
Based on the principal component scores obtained for each apiary, the sampling units were classified according to their spatial distribution across the four quadrants formed by the first two PCA axes. In this way, the apiaries were grouped according to their relative position in the multivariate plane, reflecting patterns of similarity in the land use and land cover classes within the 3 km buffer surrounding each apiary.
RESULTS
Figure 2 shows the distribution of the evaluated apiaries, taking as a reference point the location where most of the hives in each apiary were placed, allowing the observation of their positioning within the counties and in relation to Itaipu Lake. In these areas, agricultural land, vegetation, and water bodies can be observed, including both the lake and the streams that flow into the municipalities of western Paraná (Paraná River Basin III).
Distribution of identified and georeferenced apiaries in municipalities of the Western Region, Paraná, Brazil, delineated within the area (buffer) corresponding to the action radius of Africanized bees. Within each buffer, Land Use and Occupation were calculated based on the characterization of areas within the following categories, designated by colors: blue = water bodies; beige = agriculture; pink = pasture; green = vegetation; and gray = urban area.
Table I presents the average areas of the georeferenced apiaries, classified as near (PL) and distant (DL) from Itaipu Lake, along with the average areas of each group formed in the multivariate analysis and the average areas of each outlier apiary identified in this statistical analysis, for each land use and occupation category analyzed.
Mean areas of apiaries for each analyzed category of Land Use and Occupation (water bodies, agriculture, pasture, vegetation, urban area, and total buffer area), expressed in hectares (ha).
The Land Use and Occupation results indicate extensive areas dedicated to agriculture, water bodies, and both vegetated and pasture areas surrounding the evaluated apiaries, as observed from the average values of the apiaries classified as near (PL) and distant (DL) from Itaipu Lake in Table I. Larger areas of water bodies and vegetation can be observed in the PL apiaries, whereas greater agricultural and pasture areas are found in the DL apiaries.
Figure 3 was generated through principal component analysis, resulting in four quadrants, with each quadrant being considered a group.
Distribution of the 35 georeferenced apiaries (T) into four groups formed according to a multivariate principal component analysis, based on the characterization of areas within each buffer in the following categories: water bodies, agriculture, pasture, vegetation, urban area and total buffer area, with all values expressed in hectares (ha).
In Figure 3, derived from principal component analysis, four quadrants were identified, each representing a distinct group. The vegetation variable had the greatest influence in distinguishing the Group 1 apiaries from the others. The water bodies and total buffer area were the most influential variables for Group 2 apiaries, while agriculture and urban area were the defining factors for Group 3 apiaries. Finally, pasture was the most significant variable for Group 4 apiaries.
The most important variables evaluated were water body area and agricultural area for PC1, and vegetation area and pasture area for PC2, with loadings greater than 0.60 in each principal component. Together, these two components explained 65.5% of the total variation in the analyzed dataset, indicating the reliability of applying this type of analysis to the collected data. The weighting of each variable in the principal component and the explanatory power of the analysis using the two components provided a high discriminative capacity among the appiaries evaluated in this study. These variables: water body areas associated with agricultural areas, and vegetation areas associated with pastures, are intrinsic characteristics of the Itaipu Lake region and its protection zone, extending through its slopes toward agricultural areas.
In Group 1, the analyzed apiaries included T1, T12, T17, T20, and T23. Group 2 consisted of apiaries T13, T19, T22, T24, T25, T27, T28, T30, T31, T32, T34, and T35. The samples classified under Group 3 came from apiaries T2, T5, T6, T7, T8, T11, T18, T29, and T33, whereas Group 4 included apiaries T3, T4, T9, T10, T14, T15, T16, T21, and T26.
In a multivariate cluster analysis, an outlier (or atypical point) is an observation that differs significantly from the others with respect to the set of analyzed variables. It is a point that is not clearly associated with any group (cluster) or exhibits a much greater multivariate distance from the center (or centroid) of the clusters. The statistical identification of outliers can be performed using the Mahalanobis distance, which measures the distance of each observation from the multivariate mean, taking into account the covariance among the variables (Filzmoser et al. 2005).
In the context of this study, such an atypical point may represent an apiary located in a landscape with characteristics distinct from those of the formed groups but still of important representativeness; therefore, these data were not removed. For instance, it may correspond to an apiary situated farther from the lake, in a non-riparian county, yet surrounded by extensive vegetation that makes it resemble apiaries located closer to the lake, or the opposite situation.
The results related to the clustering of apiaries according to the Land Use and Occupation categories of their surroundings are presented and discussed below.
DISCUSSION
The vegetation observed in these georeferenced locations (Figure 2) consists of green areas predominantly covered by forest, composed of both native and exotic plant species, most of which were introduced during the reforestation carried out by Itaipu Binacional. These forests extend into the municipalities, along the slopes, and also into Legal Reserve areas (Ostrovski 2014). The figure also shows extensive agricultural areas, some of which are adjacent to forested zones.
Table I shows that apiary T1 was identified as an outlier in the cluster analysis. This apiary belongs to the county of Terra Roxa, classified in this study as Distant from Itaipu Lake (DL). Figure 3 and Table I show that the surrounding area of this apiary includes an extensive riparian forest (1,412.28 ha), larger than the mean value observed for Group 1 (1,116.41 ha), which was clustered mainly according to vegetation, and substantially larger than the mean areas for the PL (732.24 ha) and DL (573.48 ha) apiaries. It can also be observed that the water area (469.17 ha) within the surrounding buffer is smaller than the average for Group 1 (593.01 ha), Group 2 (989.36 ha), where the water variable contributed significantly to group formation, and smaller than the mean value for PL apiaries (702.50 ha).
The environmental explanation for this atypical condition is that apiary T1 is located near the main channel of the Paraná River, but in a narrower section that is not part of the Itaipu Lake reservoir, resulting in a smaller water area within the buffer compared to PL apiaries. On the opposite bank of this apiary lies an island belonging to Ilha Grande National Park, a Strictly Protected Conservation Unit (SPCU). Thus, although this area did not undergo the reforestation implemented by Itaipu Binacional, as occurred in the riparian zones along the non-flooded margins of the river where most PL apiaries are located, the proximity of the CU contributed to the large vegetation cover within the buffer of this DL apiary.
The presence of this PPA is highly relevant because, even though the hives are located outside the island, on the opposite bank of the river, it allows bees to access the abundant trophic resources available within that forest. Bees are capable of crossing water barriers to sustain colony survival. Studies on bee movement and foraging behavior have shown that many species (including A. mellifera) can traverse landscape structures, including aquatic stretches, when environmental conditions and resource availability are favorable; thus, river corridors function both as resource sources and as dispersal pathways (Zurbuchen et al. 2010).
Santa Helena is one of the counties located near the lake (PL), where the evaluated hives were distributed along the flooded section of the Paraná River (Itaipu Lake) and its tributary branches. The images of the apiaries located in this county (Figure 3) generally show high proportions of water within the bees’ foraging range (3 km buffer zones). However, some apiaries from Santa Helena were classified as distant from the lake (DL), such as apiary 20, which lies on the border between the municipalities of São José das Palmeiras and Diamante d’Oeste, and was identified as an atypical apiary in the cluster analysis (Table I). The land use and land cover analysis of its surroundings indicated a large vegetated area (1,332.27 ha), a pattern more typical of PL apiaries and Group 1, but a low proportion of water (25.02 ha), which is more characteristic of Group 4.
Apiaries located closer to the lake (PL) tend to show higher proportions of both water and vegetation due to the presence of the riparian buffer zone that borders the reservoir. This particular apiary (20) presents a low water area, closer to the mean value for DL apiaries (5.31 ha). However, the large vegetated area, greater than the mean value observed for PL apiaries (732.24 ha), can be explained by its location near a narrow branch of the lake that contains a reforested riparian zone belonging to the Paraná River Basin III.
From an ecological perspective, the creation or preservation of small temporary water bodies and riparian zones, such as infiltration basins, drainage ditches, and temporary ponds, together with the restoration and maintenance of vegetation along their margins, can locally increase the availability of floral resources and nesting sites for bees. Such features may therefore contribute to sustaining bee diversity and abundance in highly modified landscapes (Mitchell et al. 2021, Twerd et al. 2022).
The counties of Pato Bragado, Entre Rios do Oeste, and Missal also contain apiaries positioned along the lake’s tributaries, extending further into the municipal territory rather than being limited to the flooded riverbanks. According to Figure 3, it can be observed that the apiaries in these municipalities generally present relatively high proportions of water in their surroundings. However, Figure 3 also shows that the extensive agricultural areas characteristic of the region are prominent in these municipalities, as well as in some apiaries located in Santa Helena. Table I indicates that some apiaries in these municipalities (T10, T11, T18, T26, and T33) were considered atypical in the cluster analysis, not following the same variable patterns as most apiaries. Similar to what was observed for apiary 20 (T20), although these apiaries are located farther from the lake (DL), some had large areas of vegetation and water, and in some cases, also extensive agricultural areas—likely explained by their location along river tributaries that meander through agricultural zones.
The counties of Marechal Cândido Rondon, Mercedes, Toledo, and São José das Palmeiras contain some georeferenced apiaries classified as distant from the lake (DL) and its tributaries. As shown in Figure 3, these apiaries presented smaller proportions of water and vegetation, and larger areas of agriculture and pasture, consistent with the average values of these variables for DL apiaries (Table I). Some of these areas, however, contain small vegetation fragments located along riverbanks or within designated Legal Reserve areas.
Considering the ecological importance of these vegetation remnants, changes in riparian landscapes, such as the loss of riparian forests or alterations in hydrological regimes, can negatively affect the provision of pollination services within river basins. In other words, rivers and their margins play a direct role in the stability and productivity of crops dependent on pollinators (Rahimi et al. 2022). These authors reviewed 93 studies examining the influence of forest fragments on bees in agricultural landscapes between 1991 and 2021, and reported that increasing the distance (up to 2 km) from forest fragments, regardless of bee species, crop type, or the size and number of fragments, leads to decreased bee diversity and abundance.
It can also be observed from the images in Figure 3 that there is an overlap of the foraging areas (buffers) of certain apiaries, such as T10 and T11, as well as T22, T23, and T24, indicating an overconcentration of hives in these zones. This higher density of apiaries is generally found in areas dominated by forest vegetation along the edges of water bodies, both around the lake and its tributaries.
Camargo et al. (2014), in their study on honey production, land use and occupation, and floristic surveys in the counties of Santa Helena and Marechal Cândido Rondon, analyzed areas with varying degrees of hive overlap. Their findings suggest that the higher availability of trophic resources in areas with extensive forest cover and greater biodiversity influenced honey production more significantly than hive overpopulation in these areas.
Camargo et al. (2014) conducted a study on honey production, land use and land cover, floristic surveys, and Simpson diversity index in the municipalities of Santa Helena and Marechal Cândido Rondon, located closer to and farther from Itaipu Lake, respectively. The study compared areas with greater and lesser hive overlap in both municipalities. The results showed a higher floristic diversity index in the area with greater hive overlap in Santa Helena, which also exhibited the highest average honey production when compared to the more densely populated area of Marechal Cândido Rondon, which had the lowest floristic diversity index and honey yield. The opposite pattern was observed regarding floristic diversity in less populated areas: the less populated area in Santa Helena showed lower diversity than that in Marechal Cândido Rondon, and both exhibited intermediate average honey production.
Another aspect of the region’s phytogeography, captured by the images and the study of Land Use and Occupation, is the presence of representative forest areas around some apiaries located further inland within the counties, farther from the river tributaries. This indicates the important presence of ARL (Legal Reserve Areas) in some locations. These areas enable the implementation and maintenance of these activities, as they allow the planting of nectar and pollen producing plant species, both native and exotic, which is legally prohibited in Permanet Preservation Areas (PPAs).
Groups 1 and 2 primarily comprised apiaries located near Itaipu Lake (PL - Proximate to the Lake), where vegetation and water bodies were the most significant variables. Conversely, Groups 3 and 4 were determined based on apiaries located farther from the lake (DL - Distant from the Lake), grouped for having common characteristics, such as significant agricultural areas (Group 3) and pasture areas (Group 4) in their surroundings.
Overall, the highest recorded values were associated with agricultural land (Table I), reflecting the predominant land use in western Paraná, particularly in apiaries classified as distant from the lake (DL). In descending order, the values for vegetation areas were also relatively high, especially near the lake (PL) due to the presence of APPs, but also in more distant regions (DL), mainly within Legal Reserve Areas. This suggests favorable foraging conditions for bees across the 35 analyzed apiaries. Another notable aspect was the presence of water bodies, linked to the Paraná III Basin, which was significantly higher in regions closer to the lake (PL).
In general, analyzing the samples based on the previously designated groupings, classified as near or distant from the lake (PL and DL), it was observed that some samples differed or were outliers within the formed groups. This was because their classification regarding proximity to Itaipu Lake diverged from the other samples associated with this categorization, as shown in Table I.
Samples T1 and T20, designated as distant from Itaipu Lake (DL) due to their physical distance from the lake, were grouped into Group 1, which was predominantly composed of apiaries located close to the lake (PL)—a grouping mainly influenced by the greater presence of vegetation. These apiaries were considered atypical, as previously explained, since apiary 1 was located near the Ilha Grande National Park (a Strictly Protected Conservation Unit - SPCU), which justifies the large vegetated area within its buffer, although situated on the non-flooded portion of the Paraná River, with a smaller water surface visible in the satellite image. Apiary 20, on the other hand, was located near a tributary of Itaipu Lake, bordered by a protected riparian zone (PPA), which resulted in a high vegetated area in its surroundings, leading to its inclusion in Group 1 (Table I).
In Group 2, no discrepancies were identified, as all twelve samples within this group displayed characteristics consistent with those of apiaries located near the lake.
Upon analyzing the Group 3 samples, which are characterized as being far from the lake (DL), three samples deviated from their original georeferenced classification: T11, T18, and T33. Although these apiaries were originally labeled as near the lake (PL), they were grouped within the distant from the lake category (DL). These samples had high agricultural land coverage, which placed them within Group 3, defined primarily by its large agricultural areas. Despite their physical proximity to the lake, their landscape composition was heavily influenced by agricultural activity.
In Group 4, only two of the studied apiaries — T10 and T26 — were classified as “close to the lake (PL)”, and they were grouped together with seven other apiaries classified as “distant from the lake (DL)”. The T10 and T26 samples exhibited intermediate values across multiple variables and were positioned near the origin of Figure 3, indicating that they did not possess a single dominant characteristic. Instead, their classification resulted from the combined influence of all analyzed variables.
It is notable that georeferenced points located near Itaipu Lake, particularly in the areas surrounding the studied apiaries, are distinguished by the more pronounced presence of agricultural or pasture land coverage, rather than the presence of water bodies or vegetation, which were identified as the most relevant landscape components in this research. When analyzing the mean values of the two predefined groups (near and far from Itaipu Lake), the agriculture class exhibited the highest values (Table I). In western Paraná, extensive areas are devoted to grain production, particularly soybean and maize, which occupied 1,018,294 and 750,341 ha, respectively, in 2020 (IBGE 2020). Wheat is also an important crop in the region, which stands out for its contribution to wheat production in Paraná (SEAB 2018).
Through the present study, the terminology “Beira Lago”, Lakeside, Lakeshore, Near the Lake, and “Afastada do Lago”, Far from the Lake, frequently used in previous research to designate honey, plant, and geographic sampling points collected in the same counties of western Paraná, was also validated. This arbitrary differentiation had previously been made due to the large number of samples obtained from these municipalities, as well as the perception of specific phytogeographic characteristics and their relationship with honey properties, as mentioned in the studies cited below.
In addition to supporting this differentiation, the land use and land cover analysis around the apiaries (Beekman & Ratnieks 2000, Steffan-Dewenter & Kuhn 2003, Couvillon et al. 2014), as well as the formation of apiary groups based on the main landscape characteristics of the region, with few atypical apiaries (outliers) identified in the multivariate analysis, primarily highlight the relevance of the methodologies applied in this study.
The presence of the lake and its surrounding riparian forest provides distinctive characteristics to the honey produced in this region, as demonstrated in several studies conducted in the region.
Regarding the physicochemical characteristics of the honey, Camargo et al. (2014), Galhardo et al. (2020) and Carvalho (2022), with data from 10 years of research, founded that lighter-colored honey (light amber and water white) was more prevalent in samples from the lakeside region, whereas darker honey (amber and dark amber) was more common in samples from distant areas. Moraes et al. (2019), in melissopalynological analyses, observed pollen types that differentiated honey samples from lakeside regions, which showed a predominance of Hovenia dulcis (Japanese raisin tree) pollen, and from regions distant from the lake, characterized by a predominance of Glycine max (L.) Merrill (soybean) pollen. Ribeiro et al. (2022) compared honey samples from both lakeside and distant counties, reporting higher flavonoid concentrations in lakeside honey. This was attributed to the greater floristic diversity and higher temperatures in areas closer to Itaipu Lake.
Regarding studies relating the phytogeography of the region to the quantitative and qualitative production of honey, Camargo et al. (2014), in their study involving a floristic survey, Simpson diversity index, assessment of quantitative honey production, land use and land cover, and the effect of apiary overlap, concluded that the lakeside area exhibited greater floristic diversity and higher honey yield than the areas located farther from the lake, as previously described.
Cunha et al. (2024) evaluated land use and occupation in 15 apiaries within the county of Santa Helena, analyzing honey samples collected from three georeferenced hives per apiary. The study assessed the presence of three organochlorine pesticides (p,p’-DDE, Mitotane, and Bicyclo [2.2.1]) and four organophosphates (Ethoprophos, Methyl Parathion, Chlorpyrifos, and Fenchlorphos). The results indicated that 59% (±21%) of the foraging area (1.5 km radius around each apiary) was occupied by agriculture, pasture, or bare soil, 25% (±13%) by forest areas, 10% (±12%) by water bodies, and 6% (±9%) by constructed areas. However, no significant relationship was found between land area composition and contamination levels in honey samples, though collection period did have a significant effect.
Silva et al. (2024) conducted a land use and occupation study, along with nutritional and palynological analyses of pollen collected by 25 Apis mellifera colonies and 13 Scaptotrigona postica colonies, to assess how landscape structure and land use practices impact the composition and nutritional value of these food sources for both bee species. The study was conducted in the metropolitan region of Sorocaba, São Paulo, Brazil, in apiaries and meliponaries located in seven areas with different landscape compositions and land use types. The authors reported that S. postica was more sensitive to land use changes, showing greater nutritional variation in stored pollen, whereas A. mellifera was more affected by landscape heterogeneity. They concluded that maintaining landscape heterogeneity through the preservation of forest remnants near apiaries and meliponaries is crucial.
Although some factors, such as sampling data differences, collection periods, and vegetation conservation status, can hinder direct comparisons between study areas and influence biodiversity assessments (Cielo-Filho et al. 2009), integrating Land Use and Occupation studies provides critical support for phytogeographic characterizations of a given region.
The data from apiaries belonging to producers selected for the Indication of Source (IP) seal were clustered according to Land Use and Occupation categories, with the evaluated characteristics being directly associated with the phytogeography of western Paraná, contributing to the phytogeographic characterization of apiaries in this region.
This study provides important tools for validating previous research on honey characterization in the region, floristic surveys, and other land use and occupation studies, linking honey characteristics to their phytogeographic origin. These information may support the application for a Designation of Origin seal (DO) for honey produced in the Western region, potentially with greater specificity for certain apiaries and specific times of the year due to varying floral blooms.
Acknowledgements
To the Western Paraná State University (UNIOESTE) for logistical and structural support, to the Secretariat of Science, Technology, and Higher Education of the State of Paraná (SETI), Brazil, for the scholarship (TC81/20 – Paraná Mais Orgânico Program), and to the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq), Brazil, for financial support (Process: 44332/2016-2: Mel Oeste – Geographic Identity, Food Safety, and Added Value for Family Beekeeping).
Data availability
References
- BEEKMAN M & RATNIEKS FLW. 2000. Long-range foraging by the honey-bee, Apis mellifera L. Funct Ecol 14: 490-496. Available at: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2656543.
-
CAMARGO SC ET AL. 2014. Implementation of a geographic information system (GIS) for the planning of beekeeping in the west region of Paraná. An Acad Bras Cienc 86: 955-971. https://doi.org/10.1590/0001-3765201420130278.
» https://doi.org/10.1590/0001-3765201420130278 - CARVALHO LLN. 2022. Caracterização físico-química de amostras de mel da região Oeste do Paraná, de 2008 a 2018, em função da época de colheita e localização dos apiários. Tese de Mestrado. Universidade Estadual do Oeste do Paraná, 44 p. Available at: https://tede.unioeste.br/handle/tede/6575. (Unpublished).
-
CARVALHO LLN, GARCIA RC, RIBEIRO RJ, SOUSA PH, STROHER SM, CAMARGO SC, CERNY BLM & TONELLI LL. 2019. Análise polínica do mel de Apis mellifera de Santa Helena e Terra Roxa, região oeste do Paraná, das safras 2016, 2017 e 2018-resultados preliminares. In: Aguilera JG & Zuffo AM (Eds), Ciências Agrárias: Campo Promissor em Pesquisa 3. Atena Editora, Ponta Grossa, BR, p. 6-10. Available at: https://atenaeditora.com.br/catalogo/post/analise-polinica-do-mel-de-apis-melifera-de-santa-helena-e-terra-roxa-regiao-oeste-do-parana-das-safras-2016-2017-e-2018
» https://atenaeditora.com.br/catalogo/post/analise-polinica-do-mel-de-apis-melifera-de-santa-helena-e-terra-roxa-regiao-oeste-do-parana-das-safras-2016-2017-e-2018 -
CHIAMOLERA SR, FAVRETO LP, CAMARGO SC, CARVALHO DR, JOHANN AV, STRÖHER SM, PIRES BG, KOEFENDER E, CARVALHO LLN & GARCIA RC. 2023. Análise de pH e acidez do mel de Apis mellifera provenientes da região oeste do Paraná - safra 2019-2020 e 2020-2021. In: Barbosa FC (Ed), Ciências Agrárias: A Multidisciplinaridade dos Recursos Naturais. Editora Conhecimento Livre, Piracanjuba, BR, p. 124-127. https://doi.org/10.37423/231008368
» https://doi.org/10.37423/231008368 -
CIELO-FILHO R, BAITELLO JB, PASTORE JA, AGUIAR OTD, SOUZA SCPMD, TONIATO MTZ, DE LIMA CR & RIBEIRO AP. 2009. Ampliando a densidade de coletas botânicas na região da bacia hidrográfica do Alto Paranapanema: Caracterização florística da Floresta Estadual e da Estação Ecológica de Paranapanema. Biota Neotrop 9: 255-276. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1676-06032009000300025.
» https://doi.org/10.1590/S1676-06032009000300025 -
COUVILLON MJ, RIDDELL PEARCE FC, HARRIS-JONES E, KUEPFER AM, MACKENZIE-SMITH SJ, ROZARIO LA, SCHÜRCH R & RATNIEKS FLW. 2014. Waggle dance distances as integrative indicators of seasonal foraging challenges. PLoS ONE 9(4): e93495. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0093495.
» https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0093495 -
CRUZ CD. 2013. GENES: software para análise de dados em estatística experimental e em genética quantitativa. Acta Sci Agron 35: 271-276. https://doi.org/10.4025/actasciagron.v35i3.21251.
» https://doi.org/10.4025/actasciagron.v35i3.21251 -
CUNHA F, CHAMBÓ ED, COELHO SRM, CAMARGO SC, GAMA DC & GARCIA RC. 2024. Land use and occupation and pesticide contamination assessment in honey from Africanized honey bees (Hymenoptera: Apidae) using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. An Acad Bras Cienc 96: e20230547. DOI 10.1590/0001-3765202420230547.
» https://doi.org/10.1590/0001-3765202420230547 -
DA SILVA JC & SCHWAAB THIBES J. 2021. Os royalties de Itaipu na educação: uma análise nos municípios lindeiros Oeste do Paraná (1985-2017). Rev Binacional Bras-Arg 10: 290-311. https://doi.org/10.22481/rbba.v10i01.8822.
» https://doi.org/10.22481/rbba.v10i01.8822 - FAVRETO LP, CAMARGO SC, PIRES BG, STRÖHER SM, RIBEIRO RJ, CARVALHO DR, JOHANN AV, CARVALHO LLN, CHIAMOLERA SR & GARCIA RC. 2023a. Análise de flavonoides em amostras de méis de Apis mellifera do Oeste do Paraná da safra 2018-2019. In: Barbosa FC (Ed), Ciências Agrárias: A Multidisciplinaridade dos Recursos Naturais. Editora Conhecimento Livre, Piracanjuba, BR, p. 87-89. Available at: https://certificates-congresse-me.herokuapp.com/zootec/resumos/12441.pdf?version=original.
-
FAVRETO LP, CHIAMOLERA SR, CAMARGO SC, STRÖHER SM, CARVALHO DR, JOHANN AV, PIRES BG, TONELLI LL & GARCIA RC. 2023b. Análise de cor e hidroximetilfurfural do mel de Apis mellifera do oeste do paraná das safras 2019/2020 e 2020/2021. In: Barbosa FC (Ed), Ciências Agrárias: A Multidisciplinaridade dos Recursos Naturais. Editora Conhecimento Livre, Piracanjuba, BR, p. 87-89. Available at: https://certificates-congresse-me.herokuapp.com/zootec/resumos/12462.pdf
» https://certificates-congresse-me.herokuapp.com/zootec/resumos/12462.pdf -
FILZMOSER P, GARRETT RG & REIMANN C. 2005. Multivariate outlier detection in exploration geochemistry. Comput Geosci 31: 579-587. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cageo.2004.11.013.
» https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cageo.2004.11.013 -
GALHARDO D, GARCIA RC, SCHINEIDER CR, BRAGA GB, CHAMBÓ ED, FRANÇA DLB & STROHER SM. 2020. Physicochemical, bioactive properties and antioxidant of Apis mellifera L. honey from Western Paraná, Southern Brazil. Food Sci Technol 41: 247-253. http://dx.doi.org/10.22571/2526-4338585.
» https://doi.org/10.22571/2526-4338585 - HANEL SN ET AL. 2020. Características físico-químicas do mel da produção apícola nas ilhas do Rio Paraná em Guaíra-PR. Embrapa Pantanal (INFOTECA-E). In: Prandel JÁ (Ed), Conhecimentos teóricos, metodológicos e empíricos para o avanço da sustentabilidade no Brasil. Atena Editora, Ponta Grossa, BR, p. 41-53. DOI: 10.22533/at.ed.9432030014.
-
IBGE – INSTITUTO BRASILEIRO DE GEOGRAFIA E ESTATÍSTICA. 2020. Produção agrícola municipal 2020. Rio de Janeiro, 47: 1-8. Available at: https://www.ibge.gov.br/biblioteca/visualizacao/periodicos/66/pam_2020_v47_br_informativo.pdf
» https://www.ibge.gov.br/biblioteca/visualizacao/periodicos/66/pam_2020_v47_br_informativo.pdf - INPI - INSTITUTO NACIONAL DA PROPRIEDADE INDUSTRIAL. 2017. Patentes Sessão IV. RPI 2426: 42.
- KLOSOWSKI ALM, KUASOSKI M & BONETTI MBP. 2020. Apicultura brasileira: inovação e propriedade industrial. RPA 29: 41. Available at: https://rpa.sede.embrapa.br/RPA/article/view/1461.
- KÖPPEN W. 1948. Climatologia. Fondo de Cultura Econômica. Casa Walter de Gruyter & Co., Mexico, 466 p.
- MAACK R. 2002. Geografia física do Estado do Paraná, Curitiba. Imprensa Oficial do Paraná, Curitiba, BR, 440 p.
-
MITCHELL SR, DEBANO SJ, ROWLAND MM & BURROWS S. 2021. Feed the bees and shade the streams: riparian shrubs planted for restoration provide forage for native bees. Restor Ecol 30(3): e13525. https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13525.
» https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.13525 -
MORAES FJ ET AL. 2014. Caracterização físico-química de amostras de mel de abelha africanizada dos municípios de Santa Helena e Terra Roxa (PR). Arq Bras Med Vet Zootec 66: 1269-1275. https://doi.org/10.1590/1678-6865.
» https://doi.org/10.1590/1678-6865 -
MORAES FJ, GARCIA RC, GALHARDO D, CAMARGO SC, PIRES BG, PEREIRA DJ & DE SOUSA PHAA. 2019. Pollen analysis of honey samples produced in the counties of Santa Helena and Terra Roxa, Western Region of Paraná, Southern Brazil. Sociobiology 66: 327-338. https://doi.org/10.13102/sociobiology.v66i2.3680.
» https://doi.org/10.13102/sociobiology.v66i2.3680 - OSTROVSKI D. 2014. Itaipu Binacional: Implantação, Reflexos Socioambientais e Territoriais. Rev Percurso 6: 3-26. Available at: https://periodicos.uem.br/ojs/index.php/Percurso/article/view/49606.
-
PEREIRA TMS, SILVA JAL & MOURA DC. 2018. Fitogeografia e análise integrada da paisagem em afloramentos rochosos no semiárido paraibano. RVBMA 4: 14. https://doi.org/10.66205/rvbma.v4i1.76.
» https://doi.org/10.66205/rvbma.v4i1.76 -
RAHIMI E, BARGHJELVEH S & DONG P. 2022. Amount, distance-dependent and structural effects of forest patches on bees in agricultural landscapes. Agric Food Secur 11: 10. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40066-022-00360-x.
» https://doi.org/10.1186/s40066-022-00360-x - RIBEIRO CM ET AL. 2014. Mapeamento da cobertura da terra na Bacia Hidrográfica do Paraná III a partir de técnicas de sensoriamento remoto. In: Congresso Brasileiro de Geógrafos, 7, Vitória, BR, p. 1-2.
-
RIBEIRO RJ, GARCIA RC, TONELLI LL, CAMARGO SC, GALHARDO D, CHIAMOLERA SR, FAVRETO LP & OLIVEIRA SS. 2022. Physicochemical characterization, bioactive compounds and antioxidant activity of Apis mellifera honey from western Paraná State, Brazil. Acta Brasiliensis 6: 95-100. https://doi.org/10.22571/2526-4338585.
» https://doi.org/10.22571/2526-4338585 -
SEAB – SECRETARIA DE ESTADO DA AGRICULTURA E DO ABASTECIMENTO. 2018. Paraná vai produzir 39 milhões de toneladas de grãos em 2018. Curitiba: SEAB. Available at: https://www.agricultura.pr.gov.br/Noticia/Parana-vai-produzir-39-milhoes-de-toneladas-de-graos-em-2018
» https://www.agricultura.pr.gov.br/Noticia/Parana-vai-produzir-39-milhoes-de-toneladas-de-graos-em-2018 -
SILVA CI, ARENA MVN, SILVA ECM, MARTINES MR, MALASPINA O, CHIOVATTO G, NASCIMENTO JEM, TADEI R & TOPPA RH. 2024. Landscape and land use affect composition and nutritional values of bees’ food. J Environ Manage 352: 120031. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2024.120031.
» https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2024.120031 -
STEFFAN-DEWENTER I & KUHN A. 2003. Honeybee foraging in differentially structured landscapes. Proc R Soc B Biol Sci 270: 569-575. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2002.2292.
» https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2002.2292 -
TONELLI LL, GARCIA RC, OLIVEIRA RB, RIBEIRO RJ & CHIAMOLERA SR. 2022. Levantamentos florísticos e sua importância para a produção de mel no Oeste Paranaense. Ciênc Florest 32: 417-450. https://doi.org/10.5902/1980509864084.
» https://doi.org/10.5902/1980509864084 -
TWERD L, SOBIERAJ-BETLIŃSKA A, KILIŃSKA B, WALDON-RUDZIONEK B, HOFFMANN R & BANASZAK J. 2022. Unexpectedly, creation of temporary water bodies has increased the availability of food and nesting sites for bees (Apiformes). Forests 13(9): 1410. https://doi.org/10.3390/f13091410.
» https://doi.org/10.3390/f13091410 -
VELOSO HP, RANGEL FILHO ALR & LIMA JCA. 1991. Classificação da vegetação brasileira, adaptada a um sistema universal. IBGE, Rio de Janeiro, BR, 123 p. Available at: https://acervo.socioambiental.org/acervo/documentos/classificacao-da-vegetacao-brasileira-adaptada-um-sistema-universal
» https://acervo.socioambiental.org/acervo/documentos/classificacao-da-vegetacao-brasileira-adaptada-um-sistema-universal -
ZURBUCHEN A, CHESTER A, KELLER A, LANDEKER J, MÜLLER A, HEINRICH B & DORN S. 2010. Are landscape structures insurmountable barriers for foraging bees? Apidologie 41: 497-509. https://doi.org/10.1051/apido/2009084.
» https://doi.org/10.1051/apido/2009084






