Replacement of animal protein with vegetable protein in the diets of Astyanax altiparanae

Substituição de proteína animal por proteína vegetal em dietas para lambari-do-rabo- amarelo Astyanax altiparanae

Abstracts

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of replacing animal protein with vegetable protein sources on the productive performance of Astyanax altiparanae (lambari-do-rabo-amarelo). Five experimental diets were formulated with increasing replacement levels of animal protein by vegetable protein. A total of 9000 individuals (initial mean weight 1.18 ± 0.12 g, initial mean length 2.1 ± 0.3 cm) were distributed in 20 net cages (1 m³) with a density of 450 ind. m-3. Cages were randomly placed in a pond (180 m², 1.5 m deep, 10% water renewal per day). After 63 days of cultivation, total count and individual biometrics from 20% of each experimental unit were taken. Mean weight, total length, survival, feed conversion, biomass weight gain and proximate body composition were evaluated. The experimental design was completely randomized with five treatments and four replications. The reduction in the formulation cost achieved by increasing levels of vegetable protein compensated the slight decrease in biomass gain. Besides that, inclusion of vegetable protein resulted in greater fat deposition, suggesting future exploration of A. altiparanae as a functional food.

productive performance; nutrition; fat deposition; intensive production

O objetivo desse trabalho foi avaliar o efeito da substituição de fontes de proteína animal por fontes proteicas vegetais no desempenho produtivo do Astyanax altiparanae (lambari-do-rabo-amarelo). Cinco dietas experimentais foram formuladas com níveis crescentes de substituição de proteína animal por proteína vegetal. Foi distribuído o total de 9.000 indivíduos (peso médio inicial 1,18 ± 0,12 g, comprimento médio inicial 2,1 ± 0,3 cm) em 20 tanques-rede (1 m³; 450 ind. m-3). Os tanques-rede foram aleatoriamente dispostos em um viveiro (180 m², profundidade: 1,5 m, renovação de água: 10% ao dia). Após 63 dias de cultivo, foi realizada a contagem total dos indivíduos e biometria individual de 20% de cada unidade experimental. Foram avaliados peso e comprimento médios, sobrevivência, conversão alimentar, ganho em biomassa e composição corporal. O delineamento experimental foi inteiramente casualizado, com cinco tratamentos e quatro repetições. A diminuição alcançada no custo de formulação pela inclusão de níveis crescentes de proteína de origem vegetal mais que compensou a ligeira diminuição no ganho em biomassa. Ademais, a inclusão de proteína vegetal resultou em maior deposição lipídica, sugerindo exploração futura de A. altiparanae como alimento funcional.

desempenho produtivo; nutrição; deposição lipídica; produção intensiva

AQUACULTURE

Replacement of animal protein with vegetable protein in the diets of Astyanax altiparanae

Substituição de proteína animal por proteína vegetal em dietas para lambari-do-rabo- amarelo Astyanax altiparanae

Fábio Rosa Sussel^{I, *}; Elisabete Maria Macedo Viegas^II; Mariana Machado Evangelista^I; Giovani Sampaio Gonçalves^I; Fernando André Salles^I; Ligia Uribe Gonçalves^II

^IAgência Paulista de Tecnologia dos Agronegócios, Av. Três de Maio, 654, 18133-445, São Roque, São Paulo, Brazil

^IIDepartamento de Zootecnia, Faculdade de Zootecnia e Engenharia de Alimentos, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil

ABSTRACT

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of replacing animal protein with vegetable protein sources on the productive performance of Astyanax altiparanae (lambari-do-rabo-amarelo). Five experimental diets were formulated with increasing replacement levels of animal protein by vegetable protein. A total of 9000 individuals (initial mean weight 1.18 ± 0.12 g, initial mean length 2.1 ± 0.3 cm) were distributed in 20 net cages (1 m³) with a density of 450 ind. m^-3. Cages were randomly placed in a pond (180 m², 1.5 m deep, 10% water renewal per day). After 63 days of cultivation, total count and individual biometrics from 20% of each experimental unit were taken. Mean weight, total length, survival, feed conversion, biomass weight gain and proximate body composition were evaluated. The experimental design was completely randomized with five treatments and four replications. The reduction in the formulation cost achieved by increasing levels of vegetable protein compensated the slight decrease in biomass gain. Besides that, inclusion of vegetable protein resulted in greater fat deposition, suggesting future exploration of A. altiparanae as a functional food.

Keywords: productive performance, nutrition, fat deposition, intensive production.

RESUMO

O objetivo desse trabalho foi avaliar o efeito da substituição de fontes de proteína animal por fontes proteicas vegetais no desempenho produtivo do Astyanax altiparanae (lambari-do-rabo-amarelo). Cinco dietas experimentais foram formuladas com níveis crescentes de substituição de proteína animal por proteína vegetal. Foi distribuído o total de 9.000 indivíduos (peso médio inicial 1,18 ± 0,12 g, comprimento médio inicial 2,1 ± 0,3 cm) em 20 tanques-rede (1 m³; 450 ind. m^-3). Os tanques-rede foram aleatoriamente dispostos em um viveiro (180 m², profundidade: 1,5 m, renovação de água: 10% ao dia). Após 63 dias de cultivo, foi realizada a contagem total dos indivíduos e biometria individual de 20% de cada unidade experimental. Foram avaliados peso e comprimento médios, sobrevivência, conversão alimentar, ganho em biomassa e composição corporal. O delineamento experimental foi inteiramente casualizado, com cinco tratamentos e quatro repetições. A diminuição alcançada no custo de formulação pela inclusão de níveis crescentes de proteína de origem vegetal mais que compensou a ligeira diminuição no ganho em biomassa. Ademais, a inclusão de proteína vegetal resultou em maior deposição lipídica, sugerindo exploração futura de A. altiparanae como alimento funcional.

Palavras-chave: desempenho produtivo, nutrição, deposição lipídica, produção intensiva.

Introduction

Among different feedstuffs available worldwide for farm animals, the total included in the diets for aquatic organisms represent 3% of the total; however, this sector is responsible for the consumption of 46% of the fish meal produced (TACON, 2005). There is a widespread concern about the stagnation of world fisheries resources and great efforts are made to reduce the use of fish meal in aquatic feeds (TACON; METIAN, 2008). Plant-based ingredients are a good source to replace fish meal in aquatic feed, because they have a continuous supply and high quality nutrients (TUSCHE et al., 2012). However, plant-based protein sources commonly have low digestibility, are deficient in lysine and methionine and may have anti-nutritional characteristics (CYRINO et al., 2010; NRC, 2011).

Experiments replacing animal protein (AP) with vegetable protein (VP) showed no significant reductions in growth both in marine (KAUSHIK et al., 2004; SALZE et al., 2010) and freshwater species (THIESSEN et al., 2004; WATANABE et al., 1998).

Omnivorous fish have morphological and physiological adaptations that enable the use of diets with high percentages of vegetable ingredients, because these organisms exhibit better assimilation of carbohydrates (KUBARIK, 1997) and amino acids from vegetable sources (TENGJAROENKUL et al., 2000) compared with carnivorous fish.

Astyanax altiparanae (lambari-do-rabo-amarelo) is native to Brazil and has attracted interest as a suitable species for aquaculture; however, only a small number of studies have been conducted on its nutrition (ABIMORAD; CASTELLANI, 2011). This omnivorous species has a number of desirable traits, such as high prolificacy, easily obtained fingerling, adaptation to thermal variations and fast growth, reaching market weight (10-15 g) within approximately 3 months (GARUTTI, 2003). In Brazil, this fish is used as live bait for the sport fishing of the peacock bass (Cichla spp.) among other species, as well as for human consumption as an appetizer (PORTO-FORESTI et al., 2005).

Within the context of formulating diets using alternative ingredients of high quality and availability, the present study aimed to evaluate the replacement of animal protein with vegetable protein on the growth performance of A. altiparanae, as well as its possible effect on fish body composition.

Material and methods

Experimental diets

Five experimental diets were formulated with increasing replacement levels of animal protein sources by vegetable protein sources (Table 1). Poultry viscera meal, meat meal and marine fish meal were the sources of animal protein, added on diet VP0 at 12.97; 10.80 and 7.00% of the total diet, respectively. Levels of animal protein sources on subsequent diets (VP25, VP50 and VP75) were 75, 50 and 25% of those values of VP0. VP100 had no animal origin ingredients. The level of crude protein (CP) was the same for the five experimental diets (26% CP). The final cost was calculated taking into account the current price of each ingredient, on January 2012, in the factory where feeds were produced (CIF price, Santa Fé do Sul- São Paulo State). In addition to nutrition, technical and commercial issues were considered in the diet formulation. Feed ingredients were ground to a 0.9-mm particle size, mixed and then moistened (10% water: volume). Diets (Table 1) were extruded into 3-mm pellets using an equipment with 30 kg h^-1 capacity (Inbramaq, Ribeirão Preto, São Paulo State, Brazil), oven dried (forced air; 40ºC; 24h), stored in plastic bags and frozen (-20ºC).

Experimental procedure

The experiment was carried out at the Unidade de Pesquisa e Desenvolvimento de Pirassununga - São Paulo State, Brazil. A total of 9,000 individuals (1.18 ± 0.12 g; 2.1 ± 0.3 cm) were distributed in 20 net cages (5 mm mesh size) of 1m³ and a density of 450 ind. m^-3. The experimental units were randomly placed in a pond (180 m²), 1.5 m deep and with 10% water renewal per day.

The experiment lasted a total of 63 days, during which, fish were fed 3 times a day to apparent satiation, with no leftovers. The water quality in the experimental pond was monitored daily for temperature (25-32ºC) and dissolved oxygen (3.5-5.3 mg L^-1), while the pH (6.3-7.6) and total ammonia (0-2.0 mg L^-1) were evaluated weekly.

At the end of the experimental period, fish were fasted for 24h, counted and weighed. Individual biometrics was measured in a sample of 20% (n = 90) of the subjects from each experimental unit, which were euthanized by anesthetic overdose with benzocaine (30 mg L^-1), and frozen to subsequent analysis. Whole-body composition was determined in pooled samples of 20 fish per cage (80 fish per treatment). Samples of whole-body were analyzed for proximate composition, according to the procedures described by AOAC (1990).

Moisture obtained by air oven drying (105ºC) for 16 hours;

Ash content by burning at high temperatures in a muffle furnace for four hours;

Crude protein by semi-micro Kjeldahl method. A factor of 6.25 was employed.

Lipid extraction by petroleum ether during six hours (Soxhlet).

The growth parameters were calculated as follow: biomass (g) weight gain (BG, %) = 100 x (total final weight – total initial weight) ÷ total initial weight; mean weight gain (WG, %) = 100 x (final mean weight_(g) – initial mean weight _(g)) ÷ initial mean weight_(g); feed conversion (FC) = feed intake_(g) ÷ weight gain_(g); survival rate (SU, %) = 100 (n initial of fish – n final of fish) and length (LT).

The experiment was a completely randomized design with five treatments (VP0; VP25; VP50; VP75; VP100) and four replications for each treatment. Data were subjected to one-way ANOVA and evaluated by a simple linear regression analysis using the PROC GLM from SAS 9. Additionally, the occurrence of significant differences among treatments was assessed by Tukey's test at the significance level of 0.05.

Results and discussion

Performance data are presented on Table 2. There were no significant differences among the treatments following increasing levels of vegetable protein on fish diets.

However, regression analysis indicated a negative linear effect (p = 0.0461) for the replacement of AP with VP on Biomass Gain (Figure 1), according to the following expression:

BG (g) = 2.945g - 2.2VP

where:

BG: Biomass Gain;

VP: 100*(ratio of replacement of animal protein with vegetable protein).

A proper analysis of the effects of changes in diet composition for fish generally cannot be made only on the basis of statistical comparisons (HUA; BUREAU, 2012). Therefore, considering the lower cost of the formula (-15.9%) of the diet with 100% VP in relation to that with 100% AP (US$ 294.71 against US$ 350.42; Table 1), it is suggested that in economic terms, the difference on production performance can be compensated by this factor.

A. altiparanae is a fish with high trophic plasticity (BENNEMANN et al., 2005). Thus, the absence of significant changes in production performance parameters for A. altiparanae observed in the present study may be related to the high feeding plasticity of this species, explained by the fact that omnivorous fish generally have adaptations that enable the better use of carbohydrates and proteins (TENGJAROENKUL et al., 2000). Similar results were found for others omnivorous species.

Furuya et al. (2004) evaluated the effect of the total replacement of fish meal with soybean meal on Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) nutrition and suggested that in diets formulated only with VP and supplemented with synthetic amino acids, it is possible to replace the fish meal with no adverse effect on the growth performance, yield or carcass chemical composition. Likewise, Lin and Luo (2011) evaluated the replacement of fish meal with soybean meal at 0, 25, 50, 75, and 100% for tilapia juvenile (O. niloticus x O. aureus), and found no adverse effects on growth with up to 75% replacement.

Even for carnivorous species, such as the rainbow trout, it is possible to replace the fish meal almost completely with a vegetable-based meal (WATANABE et al., 1998). In marine fish species, an almost complete replacement of AP has also already been demonstrated (KAUSHIK et al., 2004; SALZE et al., 2010).

Hua and Bureau (2012), using a meta-analysis system, studied the results of several researches regarding the replacement of AP with VP in the diet for salmonids. The authors observed that a low or moderate addition of VP (40%) replacing AP does not affect the performance of salmonids; however, the total replacement of AP with VP causes harm, even when the diets were apparently nutritionally complete.

Taking into account that such analyses refer to carnivorous species (trout and salmon), it is suggested that for omnivorous species, which have a greater ability to use vegetable sources, the levels of VP inclusion can be higher, as observed in the present study for A. altiparanae.

Sales (2009) also used the meta-analysis technique to study the effect of replacing fish meal with VP concentrates on the growth of several fish species. No evidence was found supporting a trend defined for the optimum replacement level, given that replacements of up to 40% of fish meal, regardless of the protein level, do not affect growth, and for replacements above 40%, supplementation with synthetic amino acids, particularly methionine, is recommended.

In the present study, the protein content did not differ with increasing VP in the diets (Table 3). The crude protein level was around 16.00%, as also reported for A. altiparanae fed with 38% CP (COTAN et al., 2006) and 36% CP with different sources of oil (GONÇALVES et al., 2012).

However, the values of dry matter and lipids found by the cited authors differed considerably from the present study. While the mean value of dry matter in the present study was 36.1%, and of lipids was 15.80%, Cotan et al. (2006) and Gonçalves et al. (2012), observed values of 29.48 and 27.98%, respectively, for the dry matter and 10.05 and 5.62%, respectively, for lipids, and it can be explained by differences in the diet formulation.

The difference in the mean dry matter is most likely related to the fish size because higher levels of dry matter are expected in conjunction with higher levels of mineral matter within the same species for larger fish. According to Shearer (1994), in juvenile fish, the carcass (muscle, in particular) growth is greater than the growth of other body parts, and the relative sizes of the tissues and organs under appropriate nutritional conditions depend on the fish size and life cycle.

Regarding the difference in lipid levels, A. altiparanae with a mean weight of 7.12 g are already sexually mature, and the presence of developed gonads in females implies higher ether extract levels because, this species mobilizes large amounts of lipids for the maturation of gonads (GONÇALVES et al., 2012).

In treatments with greater amounts of VP, higher lipid levels were observed (Table 3). Lipids are a good source of digestible energy for fish (TOCHER, 2003), but the digestibility can be affected by the fatty acid composition (MENOYO et al., 2003). Martins et al. (2009) verified that the use of poultry fat as the main lipid source in diets for Atlantic halibut resulted in low overall fatty acid digestibility. Therefore, the fatty acid composition of animal ingredients (poultry viscera meal, meat meal, blood meal) present at higher concentration in VP0 and VP25 formulations may have decreased the digestibility of lipids, and it can reflect the lower lipid concentration of fish carcasses that fed these diets.

According to Gonçalves et al. (2012), A. altiparanae is able to desaturate and elongate F-18 carbon fatty acid chains (long chain fatty acids), producing arachidonic acid (AA), eicosapentaenoic (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). EPA and DHA are the main constituents of the omega-3 family of essential fatty acids, which play important roles in the cell membrane structure and in metabolic processes. These fatty acids have been the focus of numerous studies over the last several decades, which suggest their various functions in the human body (MARTIN et al., 2006). However, the human body is unable to synthesize these fatty acids, thus depending on their exogenous sources. Based on these results and on the data from Gonçalves et al. (2012) and the ability of fish to deaminate the dietary protein and use it as an energy source (CYRINO et al., 2010), it is possible to turn A. altiparanae into a functional food that is capable of providing the essential fatty acids for human consumption through diet manipulation.

Conclusion

The replacement of animal protein with vegetable protein resulted in a saving of 15.9% on the cost of diets. The reduction in the formulation cost achieved by increasing levels of vegetable protein compensated the slight decline in biomass gain. Besides that, inclusion of vegetable protein resulted in greater fat deposition, suggesting future exploration of A. altiparanae as a functional food.

Received on May 8, 2014.

Accepted on June 26, 2014.

• ABIMORAD, E. G.; CASTELLANI, D. Exigências nutricionais de aminoácidos para o lambari-do-rabo-amarelo baseadas na composição da carcaça e do músculo. Boletim do Instituto de Pesca, v. 37, n. 1, p. 31-38, 2011.
• AOAC-Association of Official Analytical Chemists. Official methods of analysis Arlington: 15th ed. Washington, D.C.: AOAC, 1990.
• BENNEMANN, S. T.; GEALH, A. M.; ORSI, M. L.; SOUZA, L. M. Ocorrência e ecologia trófica de quatro espécies de Astyanax (Characidae) em diferentes rios da bacia do Rio Tibagi, Paraná, Brasil. Iheringia: Série Zoologia, v. 95, n. 3, p. 247-254, 2005.
• COTAN, J. L. V.; LANNA, E. A. T.; BOMFIM, M. A. D.; DONZELE, J. L.; RIBEIRO, F. B.; SERAFINI, M. A. Níveis de energia digestível e proteína bruta em rações para alevinos de lambari tambiú. Revista Basileira de Zootecnia, v. 35, n. 3, p. 634-640, 2006.
• CYRINO, J. E. P.; BICUDO, A. J. A.; YUJI, S. R.; BORGHESI, R.; DAIRIKI, J. K. A piscicultura e o ambiente - o uso de alimentos ambientalmente corretos em piscicultura. Revista Brasileira de Zootecnia, v. 39, p. 68-87, 2010.
• FURUYA, W. M.; PEZZATO, L. E.; BARROS, M. M.; PEZZATO, A. C.; FURUYA, V. R. B.; MIRANDA, E. C. Use of ideal protein concept for precision formulation of amino acid levels in fish-meal-free diets for juvenile Nile tilápia (Oreochromis niloticus L.). Aquaculture Research, v. 35, n. 12, p. 1110-1116, 2004.
• GARUTTI, V. Piscicultura ecológica São Paulo: Unesp, 2003.
• GONÇALVES, L. U.; PARISI, G.; BONELLI, A.; SUSSEL, F. R.; VIEGAS, E. M. M. The fatty acid compositions of total, neutral and polar lipids in wild and farmed lambari (Astyanax altiparanae) broodstock. Aquaculture Research, v. 45, n. 2, p. 1-9, 2012.
• HUA, K; BUREAU, D. P. Exploring the possibility of quantifying the effects of plant protein ingredients in fish feeds using meta-analysis and nutritional model simulation-based approaches. Aquaculture, v. 356, n. 1, p. 284-301, 2012.
• KAUSHIK, S. J.; COVÈS, D.; DUTTO, G.; BLANC, D. Almost total replacement of fish meal by plant protein sources in the diet of a marine teleost, the European seabass, Dicentrarchus labrax Aquaculture, v. 230, n. 1, p. 391-404, 2004.
• KUBARIK, J. Tilapia on highly flexible diets. Feed Inernational, v. 6, p. 16-18, 1997.
• LIN, S.; LUO, L. Effects of different levels of soybean meal inclusion in replacement for fish meal on growth, digestive enzymes and transaminase activities in practical diets for juvenile tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus × O. aureus. Animal Feed Science and Technology, v. 168, n. 1-2, p. 80-87, 2011.
• MARTIN, C. A.; ALMEIDA, V. V.; RUIZ, M. R.; VISENTAINER, J. E .L.; MATSHUSHITA, M.; SOUZA, N. E.; VISENTAINER, J. V. Ácidos graxos poli-insaturados ômega-3 e ômega-6: importância e ocorrência em alimentos. Revista de Nutrição, v. 19, n. 6, p. 761-770, 2006.
• MARTINS, D. A.; VALENTE, L. M. P.; LALL, S. P. Apparent digestibility of lipid and fatty acids in fish oil, poultry fat and vegetable oil diets by Atlantic halibut, Hippoglossus hippoglossus L. Aquaculture, v. 294, n. 1, p. 132-137, 2009.
• MENOYO, D.; LOPEZ-BOTE, C. J.; BAUTISTA, J. M.; OBACH, A. Growth, digestibility and fatty acid utilization in large Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) fed varying levels of n-3 and saturated fatty acids. Aquaculture, v. 225, n. 1, p. 295-307, 2003.
• NRC-Nacional Research Concil. Nutrient requirement of fish and shrimp Washington, D.C.: National Academic Press, 2011.
• PORTO-FORESTI, F.; CASTILHO-ALMEIDA, R. B.; FORESTI, F. Biologia e criação do lambari-do-rabo-amarelo (Astyanax altiparanae). In: BALDISSEROTTO, B.; GOMES, L. C. (Org.). Espécies nativas para piscicultura Santa Maria: UFSM, 2005. p. 105-120.
• SALES, J. Linear models to predict the digestible lipid content of fish diets. Aquacuture Nutrition, v. 15, n. 5, p. 537-549, 2009.
• SALZE, G.; MCLEAN, E.; BATTLE, P. R.; SCHWARZ, M. H.; CRAIG, S. R. Use of soy protein concentrate and novel ingredients in the total elimination of fish meal and fish oil in diets for juvenile cobia, Rachycentron canadum Aquaculture, v. 298, n. 3/4, p. 294-299, 2010.
• SHEARER, K. D. Factors affecting the proximate composition of cultured fishes with emphasis on salmonids. Aquaculture, v. 119, n. 1, p. 63-88, 1994.
• TACON, A. G. J. Salmon aquaculture dialogue: status of information on salmon aquaculture feed and the environment. Aquafeed International, v. 8, n. 4, p. 22-37, 2005.
• TACON, A. G. J.; METIAN, M. Aquaculture feed and food safety. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, v. 1140, n. 1, p. 50-59, 2008.
• TENGJAROENKUL, B.; SMITH, B. J.; CACECI, T.; SMITH, S. A. Distribution of intestinal enzyme activities along the intestinal tract of cultured Nile tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus L.. Aquaculture, v. 182, n. 3/4, p. 317-327, 2000.
• THIESSEN, D. L.; MAENZ, D. D.; NEWKIRK, R. W.; CLASSEN, H. L.; DREW, M. D. Replacement of fish meal by canola protein concentrate in diets fed to rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Aquaculture Nutrition, v. 10, n. 6, p. 379-388, 2004.
• TOCHER, D. R. Metabolism and functions of lipids and fatty acids in teleost fish. Reviews in Fishery Sciences, v. 11, n. 2, p. 107-184, 2003.
• TUSCHE, K.; ARNING, S.; WUERTZ, S.; SUSENBETH, A.; SCHULZ, C. Wheat gluten and potato protein concentrate - promising protein sources for organic farming of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Aquaculture, v. 344-349, n. 4, p. 120-125, 2012.
• WATANABE, T.; VERAKUNPIRIYA, V.; WATANABE, K.; VISWANAT, K.; SATOH, S. Feeding of rainbow trout with non-fish meal diets. Fisheries Science, v. 63, n. 2, p. 258-266, 1998.

Publication Dates

• Publication in this collection
  14 Oct 2014
• Date of issue
  Dec 2014

History

• Accepted
  24 June 2014
• Received
  08 May 2014