Open-access Appropriation of Social Technology in Rural Sanitation: Theoretical Reflections and a Case Study in Amazon

Apropiación de la tecnología social en el saneamiento rural: reflexiones teóricas y un estudio de caso en la Amazonía

Abstract

Social technologies (STs) are developed and/or applied within communities to promote social inclusion and improve living conditions, with their sustainability being linked to the process of appropriation. This article aims to present theoretical reflections on appropriation, analyze its different components associated with social technologies, and understand the appropriation process of an ST of sewage treatment in a rural community in the Central Amazon (Santa Maria Community, Tefé/AM) through interviews conducted with residents who benefited from the technology. Of the mentioned components, three-quarters are associated with acceptance, education, and counterpart, and it was possible to verify eight out of the nine components of ST appropriation identified from the literature review. It is important that these components be considered in projects involving social technologies in the sanitation sector to foster their sustainability.

Keywords:
Sewage treatment; floodplain; rural sanitation; septic tank; qualitative research

Resumo

Tecnologias sociais (TSs) são desenvolvidas com a população para promover inclusão social e melhorar a qualidade de vida, sendo sua sustentabilidade ligada à apropriação. Este artigo analisa teoricamente a apropriação e seus componentes em TSs, focando no caso de um sistema de tratamento de esgoto em uma comunidade rural da Amazônia Central (Santa Maria, Tefé/AM). Foram realizadas entrevistas com moradores beneficiados, identificando que – dos componentes analisados estão relacionados à aceitação, educação e contrapartida. A pesquisa verificou oito dos nove componentes de apropriação mencionados na literatura. Conclui-se que considerar esses elementos em projetos de TSs no saneamento é essencial para garantir sua sustentabilidade.

Palavras-chave:
Tratamento de esgoto; áreas alagadas; saneamento rural; fossa séptica; pesquisa qualitativa

Resumen

Las Tecnologías Sociales (TS) se desarrollan y/o aplican junto a la población para generar inclusión social y mejorar las condiciones de vida, y su sostenibilidad está asociada al proceso de apropiación. Este artículo tiene como objetivo presentar reflexiones teóricas sobre la apropiación, analizar sus diferentes componentes asociados a las tecnologías sociales y comprender el proceso de apropiación de una TS de tratamiento de aguas residuales en una comunidad rural de la Amazonia Central (Comunidad Santa Maria, Tefé/AM), mediante entrevistas realizadas con los residentes beneficiados por la tecnología. De los componentes mencionados, tres cuartas partes están asociados con la aceptación, la educación y la contraparte, y fue posible verificar ocho de los nueve componentes de la apropiación de una TS identificados a partir de la revisión de la literatura. Es importante que tales componentes sean considerados en proyectos que involucren tecnologías sociales en el área de saneamiento para fomentar su sostenibilidad.

Palabras-clave:
Tratamiento de aguas residuales; llanura aluvial; saneamiento rural; tanque séptico; investigación cualitativa

Introduction

Social technologies (STs) can be defined as a “set of transformative techniques and methodologies, developed and/or applied in interaction with the population and appropriated by it, representing solutions for social inclusion and improvement of living conditions” (INSTITUTO DE TECNOLOGIA SOCIAL, 2004). More recently, Dagnino (2019) introduced the concept of “Solidary Technoscience” to emphasize the interaction between science and technology from a perspective associated with the solidarity economy, constructing knowledge of various natures (scientific, technological, religious, ancestral, etc.) and origins (academia, businesses, Indigenous peoples, popular movements, marginalized groups, etc.).

In the field of wastewater treatment, social technologies-a term that will be used throughout this study-have proven to be essential in improving access to basic sanitation services in the country. Positive experiences with various technologies, such as the green cesspit (AMABS, 2016), the root zone wastewater treatment system (RODRIGUES; LAPOLLI, 2015), the biodigester septic tank (GALINDO et al., 2010), and the riverside ecological toilet (NEU; SOUZA DOS SANTOS; FERRAZ MEYER, 2016), stand out as examples of this positive impact. In the state of Amazonas, an ST called “Elevated Community Septic System (ECSS)” (FUNDAÇÃO BANCO DO BRASIL, 2021) was implemented in the middle Solimões River region, specifically in the community of Santa Maria (Tefé/AM).

This technology was implemented with community participation throughout the entire process, from planning to construction. During this process, a study was conducted on the motivations for adopting and continuously using the toilets and the fecal water treatment system that comprised the ST (BORGES PEDRO et al., 2023). After its installation, the need arose to understand the process of technology appropriation by the beneficiary population.

For STs to be genuinely appropriated by users, their implementation process must ensure effective participation of the people involved, the appreciation of, and when applicable, the incorporation of traditional knowledge. This approach allows for the transformation of realities and the empowerment of individuals and communities. In this context, the appropriation of technology is understood as the process by which the beneficiary population takes ownership of its infrastructure, processes, demands, problems, and solutions, creating an environment of independence from the team initially involved in its conception and implementation.

Thus, considering the guidelines outlined in the country’s public policies on rural sanitation (BRASIL, 2019), this article aims to present theoretical reflections on appropriation, analyze its different components related to social technologies, and understand the appropriation process of an ST for wastewater treatment in a flood-prone community in the Amazon through a case study.

2. Methodological Approach

This manuscript employs two methodological approaches. The first focuses on reflections regarding the concepts of social technology appropriation and the analysis of its components through a literature review. The second presents the methods used in the case study on the appropriation of a social technology in the Brazilian Amazon, employing the Content Analysis technique.

2.1. Theoretical Reflections on the Appropriation of Social Technologies

To support the reflections on the concept of appropriation, the main theoretical references on social technologies in Brazil were consulted, as they are widely cited in national publications. The search for references followed the “reference web” method (adapted from BOOTH, COLOMB, and WILLIAMS, 2009), in which a relevant reference enables the active search for its own references, allowing the identification of relevant works.

Based on the literature review, components that characterize and/or facilitate the appropriation of STs were identified, along with the domains to which these components relate and the interactions between them.

2.2. Case Study: Appropriation of a Wastewater Treatment ST in a Floodplain Community

Data Collection

This research was conducted with residents of the Santa Maria Community (3°19’44.2”S 64°39’48.5”W), located on Tarará Island, in the middle Solimões River region, near the city of Tefé-AM (Figure 1). The Santa Maria community is primarily engaged in fishing and family farming, producing vegetables that supply the city of Tefé. The community is situated in a floodplain area (várzea), near two conservation units: the Mamirauá and Amanã Sustainable Development Reserves.

In 2021, the community had 32 resident families and approximately 130 inhabitants. Santa Maria is located in a seasonally flooded environment, meaning that it is submerged by the Solimões River between May and July, during which the river can rise by up to 10 meters (BORGES PEDRO, 2022). The dynamics of the water impose several challenges on the residents’ lives, including technological and operational difficulties in treating generated wastewater.

Figure 1
Location of the Santa Maria community on Tarará Island, in Tefé-AM, participant in this case study

The residents considered as research informants were those who benefited from the installation of toilets and their respective wastewater treatment systems. This arrangement (toilet + wastewater treatment) was referred to as the Elevated Community Septic System (ECSS) (Figure 2), a social technology certified by the Banco do Brasil Foundation for Social Technologies in 2021.

The ECSS consists of a septic tank, an anaerobic filter, and a soak pit, with the first two units installed on an elevated platform to ensure protection during river floods (BORGES PEDRO, 2022). During the implementation process of the STs, three Community Elevated Septic Systems were installed to serve six households.

Figure 2
The Community Elevated Septic System (CESS), a wastewater treatment technology for flood-prone areas. Installed in the Santa Maria Community, Tefé-AM.

Information regarding the use and appropriation of the toilets and the wastewater treatment system was gathered through interviews with the couple responsible for each of the households served. The interviews conducted with women were led by female researchers from the Mamirauá Institute for Sustainable Development. This precaution was necessary to avoid discomfort between researchers and interviewees regarding intimate gender-related issues.

In total, 14 individual interviews were conducted (06 men, 06 women, and 02 young individuals), representing 6% of all community residents (130 people) or 33% of all residents benefiting from the ST (24 in total). The interviews lasted an average of 40 minutes.

The interview script contained open-ended questions about prior defecation practices, the importance and cleanliness of the toilets, willingness to invest in and maintain the treatment system, and participation in the technology implementation processes. The script was based on a study on the determinants of access to wastewater treatment in rural communities (HIRAI et al., 2018). Participation in the research was voluntary, and all interviews were recorded with the informants’ consent, following ethical guidelines. The project was ethically approved by a Research Ethics Committee (CAE 3.231.146).

To complement the data collection from the interviews and provide a broader understanding of the research context, Participant Observation was employed, following the guidelines of Minayo (2002) and Mônico et al. (2017). In this method, the research team not only observes passively but also actively participates in all stages of the research, including the implementation of the STs. This observation was conducted continuously during meetings, visits, and activities in the community, allowing for full immersion in the studied environment.

Data Analysis

The interviews were transcribed and subsequently analyzed using Bardin’s (2004) Content Analysis method. The transcription process fully preserved the participants’ statements to maintain the quality of the information. Based on Câmara (2013), the content analysis was structured into three phases: Pre-analysis - This phase involved organizing and performing an initial floating reading of all transcribed statements, thereby constructing the research corpus; Material exploration - In this phase, the transcripts were coded, categorized, and classified, focusing on the central objective of the study: theoretical reflections on appropriation, analysis of its components associated with social technologies, and understanding the process of appropriation of a specific ST; Results processing - This phase included making inferences and interpreting the participants’ statements. A similar approach in the sanitation field was conducted by Barnes (2014).

In other disciplines such as health, administration, and education, Content Analysis is widely employed to generate knowledge based on individuals’ perceptions (LIMA; ANTUNES; SILVA, 2015; SILVA; FOSSÁ, 2015; SOUSA; SANTOS, 2020).

The entire process of organizing and analyzing the material was carried out using the Atlas.ti software (WALTER; BACH, 2015). In the results section, informants’ statements were identified as “anonymous”, followed by a unique identification number generated by the software.

3. Results and Discussion

3.1. Appropriation of a Social Technology: Identification of Its Components

What can be observed from the literature review is that there is still no universal definition for the “appropriation of a social technology,” but it is possible to identify points of convergence. The bibliographic survey revealed some definitions of appropriation, which will help advance the analysis of its components (Table 1).

Table 1
Theoretical Concepts of Appropriation of Social Technology.

When analyzing the different definitions presented in the accessed literature, it was possible to identify common elements that denote similar ideas regarding the social role of appropriation, blending these ideas with the very concept of Social Technologies (ST). From this literature, it was possible to identify nine components that characterize the process of appropriation:

  1. Use and adaptation to context: The diversity of use of STs is a presupposition of social appropriation, which foresees different forms of use depending on the context. Thus, adaptation can incorporate the social behaviors of a particular group (FRANÇA FILHO, 2018), although it should be done with caution to avoid compromising the technical aspect of the ST. According to Carroll (2004), “appropriation involves mutual adaptation: [...] users utilize the technology for unintended purposes, and at the same time, their practices are shaped by it.”

  2. Acceptance: Acceptance relates to positive perceptions regarding the ST and its use. It is the feeling expressed by users when they notice the improvements provided by the ST. Lienert and Larsen (2010) use some criteria to evaluate the acceptance of sanitation systems: whether users consider them a good idea, whether they would recommend the use and adoption of the systems, and whether they would have the systems at home or at work. Another point highlighted by Anand and Apul (2014) that enhances the acceptance of the ST is knowledge about it, its design, and functionality.

  3. Counterpart: ST projects that foresee some form of counterpart from the benefiting users tend to be more successful. When a counterpart exists, whether in the form of financial support for part of the project, provision of materials (such as wood), labor for installation, food, or other resources, it creates a sense of belonging to that context and a sense of ownership, which in turn allows users to feel responsible, to some extent, for the ST (KAZI, 2003; TAM, 2012).

  4. Participation in implementation: Engagement and active participation during the installation of social technologies stimulate their appreciation and care (KHURTSIA, 2015). Active participation includes actions such as working during installations (“hands-on”), leading the process with local residents, preparing food for workers, and similar actions.

  5. Empowerment of women: More recent discussions, stemming from prominent approaches in an international gender equality agenda, have shown that the empowerment of women, particularly in this sector, contributes to the success of sanitation projects. Knowledge, information, participation, recognition of women’s importance throughout the process, and female leadership are considered empowering elements that positively impact the articulation of community needs. Empowering enables appropriation (DERY et al., 2020).

  6. Participation in decision-making processes: Sanitation workers with over 10 years of experience confirm that involving users in planning processes is a critical factor that enhances the success of projects (BARNES, 2014). Considered a principle of ST (RODRIGUES; BARBIERI, 2008), participation in decisions engages users and facilitates appropriation.

  7. Proximity to service providers: An idea presented by the National Rural Sanitation Program, at the local level, suggests that proximity between the population and service providers increases the capacity for public involvement in actions, which, in turn, leads to the appropriation of technologies (BRASIL, 2019). By expanding service possibilities, constant contact between beneficiaries of STs and other institutions, such as universities and research institutions, increases the level of appropriation through the building of trust and transparency (BARNES, 2014).

  8. Incorporation of social, cultural, and environmental characteristics: Valuing and incorporating traditional knowledge into STs fosters user engagement. Considering the environmental aspects of the locality by ST planners (including local residents) respects the cultural values of a population, which typically views the environment as an inseparable part of their lives, essential (and even sacred) to their way of life (ARAGÃO et al., 2019; HAYASHI; SOUSA; ROTHBERG, 2011). The soil, river, animals, and other elements are part of a whole, which together forms the community. Respect for local values stimulates trust between practitioners (FIGUEROA; KINCAID, 2010) and institutions (JACKSON et al., 2019). According to Dagnino, Brandão, and Novaes (2004), ST is “conceived through the contextualization of local reality, prioritizing the local knowledge of its beneficiaries, and carrying values that are consistent with their beliefs.”

  9. Education for ST: One of the strategic axes of the National Rural Sanitation Program, education is considered a determining factor for the appropriation of sanitation technologies (BRASIL, 2019). According to the criteria proposed by Ribeiro, Faria, and Dias (2017) in this Program, educational processes are classified as: informal (linked to people’s daily lives and social relationships that allow learning), formal (related to the regular educational system, such as preschool, high school, or higher education), and non-formal (which goes beyond formal education and complements it, such as courses, workshops, trainings, etc.). According to the program developers, these pedagogical processes, which must consider “life experiences forged in relationships with nature and agricultural and extractive production” (BRASIL, 2019), the way of life, and a systemic view of the environment, lead to transformative action in individuals and the appropriation of technologies (NUNES, 2004).

The nine components identified can be grouped into three domains of action (Figure 3).

Figure 3
Domains of Social Technology Appropriation Components and Their Interaction Flows.

The domain “Individual or Collective” represents the direct field of action of individuals or groups benefiting from a Social Technology (ST), whether as individuals or as part of a group (associations, cooperatives, informal groups, families, or various collectives). In this domain, individuals or groups directly engage with the following components: “i. Use and adaptation to the context,” where users integrate the technological device (or methodology) into their daily lives and adapt the use of the ST to their own living context; “ii. Acceptance,” related to perceptions and feelings about the ST; and “iii. Contribution,” through support for the implementation of the ST.

The “Institutional” domain refers to the actions carried out by institutions that promote and develop STs in partnership with the population. This domain is characterized by formal processes, such as research project development, execution schedules, detailed budgets, dimensioning descriptive reports, interview scripts, etc. In this domain, the components “viii. Incorporation of social, cultural, and environmental characteristics” and “ix. Education for ST” are found. The first ensures that the mentioned apparatuses respect and incorporate the environmental conditions in which the ST is situated, along with the social and cultural characteristics of the beneficiary population. The second component refers to the spaces created to promote the ST concept in an educational context, enabling the population to understand the entire implementation and operational process of the ST and to be capable of replicating or adapting it safely to their context, without losing its essence, integrating it into their daily lives with ownership.

In this domain, institutions such as universities, research institutions, NGOs, and public-interest private companies (FONSECA; SERAFIM, 2009) are responsible for providing formal and non-formal educational spaces for the population to access a transformative process of ST appropriation. In the context of ST in the Amazon, collective participation in community workdays has proven effective. According to Nascimento, Moura, and Teisserenc (2018), training sessions are also crucial for the appropriation of technologies by families.

Lastly, the “Combined” domain blends the other two fields of action. Operating as an intersection, it allows interaction between the two domains so that the components of appropriation receive contributions from both sides. The components “iv. Participation in implementation” and “vi. Participation in decision-making processes” are tasks for individuals but require institutional support. While “v. Empowerment of women” may be an intrinsic feature of female leadership, it should also be stimulated and fostered by institutions to continuously strengthen it. The domain “vii. Proximity to service providers” clearly shows this interaction between individual/collective and institutional components.

The analysis of appropriation components also enabled the identification of interaction flows between different domains. The components do not act statically, but dynamically, influencing each other. Below, we highlight some of these interactions to illustrate the process. When the population provides a contribution (iii), such as supplying wood or food during a workday, they are also actively participating in the implementation of the ST (iv). Contribution actions are essential for the project’s progress and fundamental to the process of valuing and appropriating the technology.

Respect for local sociocultural and environmental particularities (viii) influences (or should influence) the decision-making processes (vi) involved in ST projects and leads to the use and adaptation of technology to meet the needs of the involved population (i). Educational processes (ix) interact within all three domains, facilitating the broad acceptance (ii) of the ST and fostering the empowerment of women (v) through continuous actions that valorize their history and encourage leadership (MARINHO; GONÇALVES, 2016).

It is important to emphasize that the diversity of appropriation concepts found in the literature review and presented in this discussion reflects the diversity of themes and approaches in the field of ST. In this sense, professionals or actors who seek to implement an ST and assess its appropriation must remain attentive to this diversity of components that characterize it and the perspective under which it will be analyzed.

3.3. Case Study: The Process of Appropriation of the Elevated Community Septic System

The analysis of the interview transcripts resulted in 407 quotes or excerpts related to the process of appropriation of the ECSS, a social technology adopted in the project. The quotes were classified into 61 codes and subsequently grouped into the same categories described earlier, representing the nine proposed components of appropriation. It is important to note that the category “vii. Proximity to Service Providers” was not identified during the interview analysis. Furthermore, the categories “iv. Participation in Implementation” and “vi. Participation in Decision-Making Processes” were unified to facilitate the interpretation of the results. Figure 4 presents all the codes and categories resulting from the content analysis process.

The most expressive category in the analysis was “ii. Acceptance,” representing 49% of all citations. Several statements demonstrated the acceptance of the technology implemented in the community, through feelings of gratitude, a desire to keep the sanitary facilities operational, and the recognition that the technology improved local sanitation conditions. Additionally, the residents declared that they did not encounter difficulties using the new device, further indicating their acceptance. These sentiments are reflected in the following statement:

“Now it’s perfect, as I said (laughs), it’s great inside the house, the sinks to wash hands. All of this was a difficulty, right, because there was nowhere to wash, and even getting here to wash. We had to walk back and forth. We didn’t know where we were putting our hands, right... now it’s good... then everything got really great. Inside the house, at any time, right, sometimes we were sick and needed it, and there was nothing, we would rush out to the forest at night. But here, inside the house, it’s not like that, it’s close by. It really is perfect.” (anonymous 9:4)

In the same category, several reports pointed to a recognition that the technology is robust because it meets the residents’ demands and functions normally, even during the flooding period. Additionally, the positive perception that the sanitary facility + treatment system does not generate unpleasant odors was mentioned several times as a quality of the technology. The absence of odor is recognized as an important characteristic for the acceptance of the system, as previously demonstrated by Rheinländer et al. (2013). The statements also associate the absence of odor with the improvement of sanitary conditions.

Figure 4
Components of appropriation emerged from interviews with residents benefiting from the Elevated Community Septic System social technology

One element that stood out in this category was the learning generated through participation in the process. The residents’ opinion was that participating in the planning and installation of the technology enabled them to develop new work skills (such as working with masonry and plumbing) and other knowledge, such as the importance of using the sanitary facility and its proper maintenance. As shown in Figure 2, the components of participation and education are interconnected. The training activities played a crucial role in facilitating the learning and appropriation process, confirming that non-formal education naturally occurs during the implementation of TSs through practical experiences (PEREIRA & FREITAS, 2018). The learning through practice can be observed in the following reports:

“I learned, I learned to work with the cement thing, which I didn’t know, I had never worked before, I had the privilege, right, to do it, to handle it a little, so I learned... one thing I didn’t know... about pipes, a little more... if I were to do it now, I might hurt myself... it might not come out perfect, right, but I believe it will come out...” (anonymous 1:55)

“I learned a lot, hygiene, organization, right... taking care of the bathrooms. Well, everything, right, that I didn’t do before, we didn’t have it, right. Encouraging the kids to use the bathroom, to wash their hands, all that...” (anonymous 9:23)

The category “iii. Counterpart” was identified as the third most influential in the appropriation process of the ECSS. The provision of wood by the residents for the construction of the sanitary facilities was a significant demonstration of commitment, as it required them to set aside their daily agricultural and fishing tasks to focus on the extraction of wood, an activity that allowed for subsistence and improved the community’s infrastructure. Thus, the contribution played a significant role in the feeling of appropriation due to the time and resources dedicated to this activity, and it was also connected to participation in the implementation, as outlined in the flow diagram in Figure 2.

The performance of small repairs by the resident users also demonstrated that they had mastered the technology and were invested in ensuring its proper functioning. The act of performing maintenance and small repairs on the technology, rather than abandoning it when problems arose, shows a commitment to the TS and its importance to the families, who reported being willing to invest part of their income to cover any repairs.

The category “viii. Incorporation of Social, Cultural, and Environmental Characteristics” was evidenced as the interviewees reported that their demands regarding the desired model of the toilet were met. As previous studies have shown, residents of the Amazon floodplains prefer having a toilet inside the house to ensure security, comfort, and privacy (BORGES PEDRO et al., 2023). The adaptation of the technology to the natural characteristics of the region was expressed through statements about the suitability of the sanitary facility to the flood-prone environment and the surrounding forest:

“Because it got better, right, we don’t have to leave the house to go to the woods, everything is right here in the house, that’s why I think it made things a lot easier... Yes, it was good. Because now there’s no problem of having to take the canoe out at night, right, when you need to go, you used to have to go at night, now, when you feel like it, you can take care of it well, right.” (anonymous 6:6/6:25)

Other categories that emerged from the analysis of the interviews were “iv. Participation in the implementation” and “vi. Participation in decision-making processes.” According to the interviewees, participating from the beginning of the project, in the planning of actions and decision-making, was important for the success of the technology implementation. There were also reports that their participation was crucial for the successful completion of the installations. Seen as a form of support, the men’s participation took place in various ways, such as transporting construction materials, digging holes, performing carpentry tasks, and cleaning the area.

For the women, participation occurred in two ways: by substituting their husbands in the fields, and by performing activities that supported the installation work. Regarding the first form of participation, when the construction of the TSs coincided with the harvest day, the division of labor was as follows: the men worked on the TS construction, while the women were responsible for harvesting, storing the products, selling them in the city, and preparing meals for the family and the work team (the second form of contribution by the women).

However, during the interviews, it became clear that the women did not recognize that they had an effective role in the project, nor did they acknowledge the importance of their contributions. In a somewhat shy manner, the women stated that their contribution was only through preparing meals for the workers, including their husbands and children. For them, the most significant form of participation was the manual labor carried out during the construction of the structures, which is typically done by the men. These statements illustrate these feelings:

“I helped a little, I helped a little with everything. For me, it was important to be helping you, the ones who brought this project here for us. For me, this help I gave was a lot.” (Anonymous 2:48)

“I think my participation was good, both in the lunch we made, and in the snack, I stayed there watching them.” (Anonymous 9:24)

Emphasizing the social participation of the population, Jesus and Costa (2013) argue that this process ensures the effectiveness of the technological solution as it incorporates local knowledge and know-how. According to Roma and Jeffrey (2010), this demonstrates that community participation in the implementation tends to contribute to the acceptance and management of technologies. Participating in the construction of their own sanitary facilities leads to a high level of acceptance (JORRITSMA; FEDTKE; ERGÜNSEL, 2009) and care for the systems.

Another element that contributed to the appropriation of the ECSS was the encouragement provided by women to their families and their strength in engaging the family in the project, expressed through the category “v. Empowerment of women.” However, previous statements do not fully reinforce the sense of empowerment.

In this study, efforts were made to listen to women at all stages of the social technology implementation. It was the women who initiated the acceptance of the project within the community: while the men had doubts, the women were already convinced of the ECSS’s benefits for the family. The location where the toilet was installed was also decided by the women. The decision to remove the shower from the project was theirs as well. The women cited a lack of privacy and difficulty cleaning toilets with showers, and the men agreed that the wood would deteriorate quickly if constantly wet.

During the interviews, women recognized that their role as advocates for the social technology, albeit subtly and within the family unit, was essential and that it generated the involvement of their husbands. In this sense, the importance of women in the adoption and use of the toilets within the family, as well as their role in the regular cleaning of the toilets, became evident. Similar observations were recorded in studies in other rural Brazilian contexts (SILVA et al., 2020). As stated by Ghimire (2015), women are central figures for change and are essential for community engagement. The statement of one interviewed woman illustrates her role in the appropriation of the social technology:

“It was very important that, as a mother and daughter-in-law, I encouraged them. Sometimes they wanted to give up, and I encouraged them, not that the priority was for us here, but I encouraged them. The priority was for my daughter, who is special, so she got our house, which we already had one before, and we included her. I encouraged them; for me, it was important because through me I encouraged others, and the project moved forward.” (anonymous 8:17)

3.4. Some Limitations of Appropriation

Although a process of appropriation, recognition, and acceptance by the residents was observed, some positions from the interviewees indicated that certain components were not sufficiently addressed with the community and, therefore, acted as limitations to full appropriation. It is important to highlight that this assessment occurred one to two years after the implementation of the ECSS, and thus, some positions and reflections may not yet be fully settled among the residents interviewed.

Slightly more than half of the residents stated that they did not understand how the sewage treatment system and the “boxes” worked, even though they acknowledged the importance of the treatment and recommended it to their neighbors. They also mentioned difficulties in performing basic maintenance on the toilet, such as repairing pipes, or they expressed fear of “damaging the system” during maintenance, showing dependence on the technical team for these services. Statements like “I don’t understand these things at all, these things are not for me” or “So, until now I don’t understand why it wasn’t done like this...” illustrate that these residents still couldn’t fully comprehend how the system worked, despite the field instructions. Some observations made in other Amazonian regions, such as on Ilha das Onças/Pará (NEU; SOUZA DOS SANTOS; FERRAZ MEYER, 2016), suggest that some communities were completely excluded over the years and treated as incapable of thinking and doing, which led many to internalize feelings of powerlessness and incapacity.

Additionally, the development of social technology, from its conception to implementation and monitoring, involves unique interactions between researchers and each resident and community. In this educational process, which aims to stimulate the autonomy of the residents, there can be failures related to the formation and experiences of the researchers, who are also in the process of building knowledge, which may impact the appropriation of the technology by the residents.

Therefore, it is of fundamental importance for the effective functioning of the social technology to carry out new educational interventions in order to generate clarification and real empowerment of the community members regarding the Elevated Community Septic System, thereby further strengthening the appropriation of the technology.

4. Conclusions

This study allowed for the construction of what has been termed “components of social appropriation,” which are the main themes that enable its analysis. The following components were proposed: user contribution (iii); active participation in the implementation of the sanitary technologies (iv); participation in decision-making processes (vi); educational processes for the implementation of the technologies (ix); proximity between service providers and the community (vii); respect and incorporation of socio cultural and environmental characteristics in the technologies (viii); usage and adaptation to the local context; acceptance and recommendation of the technologies (ii); daily challenges (i); and approaches that enable the empowerment of women (v). Acting in the individual/collective, institutional, and combined domains, these components lead to a relative degree of social appropriation.

In the case study presented, in a riverside community in Central Amazonia, it was found that three-quarters of all the components reported by the residents that led to the appropriation of the sewage treatment technology were related to acceptance, non-formal education, and contribution.

Moreover, women played a decisive role in the appropriation of the Elevated Community Septic System . According to their self-declaration, they influenced the process in an “invisible” yet essential way, convincing their families to adopt the sanitary technology. Therefore, the need for recognizing and valuing the active and integral participation of women in social technology projects related to sanitation is emphasized.

It is important to highlight that the proposed components of appropriation should be considered in projects involving the development and implementation of social technologies in the sanitation field, in order to maximize the chances of successful interventions, and that educational processes with residents, especially non-formal ones, should be valued.

Finally, it is recommended that public sanitation policies be regionalized, grouped by communities with similar environmental and/or social characteristics, taking into account the specific nature of each region, considering the distinct ecosystems and numerous peoples, each with their beliefs and habits, which need to be respected and considered in the design and implementation of social technologies.

5. Acknowledgements

The authors would like to express their gratitude to the riverside residents of the Santa Maria community, to the National Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq), to the Amazonas State Research Support Foundation (FAPEAM), and to the Mamirauá Institute for Sustainable Development (IDSM/OS) for making this work possible.

References

  • AMABS. Saneamento Rural - FOSSA EVAPOTRANSPIRADORA (Tanque de evapotranspiração - TEvap). Projeto Águas Mais Limpas para Comunidade, 2016.
  • ANAND, C. K., APUL, D. S. Composting toilets as a sustainable alternative to urban sanitation - A review. Waste management, v. 34, n. 2, p.329-343, 2014.
  • ARAGÃO, E. de M., OLIVEIRA, J. K. de, JESUS, V. de, SANTOS, M. J. C. dos, RUSSO, S. L. Tecnologia Social Sob A Ótica Da Adequação Sociotécnica. In: V Encontro Nacional de Propriedade Intelectual, 1, Florianópolis. Anais [...] Florianópolis: 2019.
  • BARDIN, L. Análise de Conteúdo. 3a ed. Lisboa: Edições, v. 70, n. 1, p. 223, 2004.
  • BARNES, R., ASHBOLT, N., ROSER, D., BROWN, P. Implementing sustainable water and sanitation projects in rural, developing communities. Waterlines, v. 33, n. 1, p. 71-88, 2014.
  • BOOTH, W.C.; COLOMB, G.G.; WILLIAMS, J.M. The craft of research. University of Chicago press, 2009.
  • BORGES PEDRO, J. P. Solução semicoletiva de tratamento de águas fecais e seu processo de apropriação em comunidade de área alagável da Amazônia. 2022. 201 f. Tese (Doutorado em Saneamento, Meio Ambiente e Recursos Hídricos). Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, MG, 2022.
  • BORGES PEDRO, J. P., OLIVEIRA, C. A., GOMES, M. C. R. L., CORRÊA, D. S., NASCIMENTO, A. C., VON SPERLING, M. O que motiva ribeirinhos rurais a adotarem sanitários? Achados da Amazônia Central. Revista Desenvolvimento e Meio Ambiente. 2023. V. 62, p. 727-741, 2023.
  • BRASIL. Ministério da Saúde. Fundação Nacional de Saúde. Programa Nacional de Saneamento Rural. Brasília: Funasa, 2019.
  • CÂMARA, R. H. Análise de Conteúdo: da teoria à prática em pesquisas sociais aplicadas às organizações. Revista Interinstitucional de Psicologia. v. 6, n. 2, p. 179-91, 2013.
  • CARROLL, J. Completing Design in Use: Closing the Appropriation Cycle. In: European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS), Anais [...], 2004.
  • DAGNINO, R. Tecnociência solidária: um manual estratégico. Marília, SP: Lutas Anticapital, 2019.
  • DAGNINO, R.; BRANDÃO, F. C.; NOVAES, H. T. Sobre o marco analítico-conceitual da tecnologia social. Tecnologia social: uma estratégia para o desenvolvimento. Rio de Janeiro: Fundação Banco do Brasil, p. 65-81, 2004.
  • DERY, F., BISUNG, E., DICKIN, S., DYER, M. Understanding empowerment in water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH): A scoping review. Journal of Water Sanitation and Hygiene for Development, v. 10, n.1, p. 5-15, 2020.
  • DOURISH, P. The Appropriation of Interactive Technologies: Some Lessons from Placeless Documents. Computer Supported Cooperative Work, v. 12, p. 465-490, 2003.
  • FIGUEROA, M. E.; KINCAID, D. L. Social, Cultural and Behavioral Correlates of Household Water Treatment and Storage. Baltimore: Center for Communication Programs, 2010.
  • FRANÇA FILHO, G. C. de. Inovação social e incubação tecnológica em economia solidária na fronteira de um outro paradigma em CT&I. In: UFRJ, E. (Ed.). Incubadoras tecnológicas de economia solidária: concepção, metodologia e avaliação. p. 213-234. Rio de Janeiro: Editora UFRJ, 2018.
  • FONSECA, R.; SERAFIM, M. A Tecnologia Social e seus arranjos institucionais. In: IG/UNICAMP (Ed.). Tecnologia social: ferramenta para construir outra sociedade. Campinas/SP: IG/UNICAMP, 2009. p. 139-153.
  • FUNDAÇÃO BANCO DO BRASIL. Elevated Community Septic System - Instituto de Desenvolvimento Sustentável Mamirauá. Rede Transforma - Banco de Tecnologias Sociais [Internet]. Fundação Banco do Brasil. 2021. Available on : https://transforma.fbb.org.br/tecnologiasocial/fossa-alta-comunitaria Accessed on : 28 ago. 2023
    » https://transforma.fbb.org.br/tecnologiasocial/fossa-alta-comunitaria
  • GALINDO, N; SILVA, W. T. L; NOVAES, A. P.; GODOY, L. A.; SOARES, M. T. S.; GALVANI F. Fossa Séptica Biodigestora.pdf. Vol. 1, Comunicado Técnico Embrapa. 2010. p. 32.
  • GÓMEZ, M. F.; SANCHES-PEREIRA, A.; SILVEIRA, S. Technology for Social Inclusion: the Case of Electricity Access in the Brazilian Amazon. Journal of Sustainable Development of Energy, Water and Environment Systems, v.1 n. 3, p. 237-259, 2013.
  • GHIMIRE, R. Acquiescence to acceptance: Community acceptance testing in water supply and sanitation. Water Practice and Technology, v. 10, n. 3, p. 595-600, 2015.
  • HAYASHI, M. C. P. I.; SOUSA, C. M. de; ROTHBERG, D. Apropriação social da ciência e da tecnologia: contribuições para uma agenda. Campina Grande: EDUEPB, 2011.
  • HIRAI, M., KELSEY, A., MATTSON, K., CRONIN, A. A., MUKERJI, S., GRAHAM, J.P. Determinants of toilet ownership among rural households in six eastern districts of Indonesia. Journal of Water, Sanitation and Hygiene for Development, v. 8, n. 3, p. 533-45, 2018.
  • INSTITUTO DE TECNOLOGIA SOCIAL. Caderno de Debate - Tecnologia Social no Brasil. 26. ed. São Paulo: Instituto de Tecnologia, 2004. 40 p.
  • JACKSON, M., STEWART, R. A., FIELDING, K. S., COCHRANE, J., BEAL, C. D. Collaborating for sustainable water and energy management: Assessment and categorisation of indigenous involvement in remote Australian communities. Sustainability (Switzerland), v. 11, n. 2, p.1-30, 2019.
  • JESUS, V. M. B. de; COSTA, A. B. Tecnologia social: breve referencial teórico e experiências ilustrativas. In: INSTITUTO PÓLIS E FUNDAÇÃO BANCO DO BRASIL (Ed.). Tecnologia Social & Políticas Públicas. p. 17-32. São Paulo: Instituto Pólis; Brasília: Fundação Banco do Brasil, 2013.
  • JORRITSMA, F.; FEDTKE, G.; ERGÜNSEL, A. Introducing Sustainable Sanitation in Kyrgyzstan: an Analysis of Success Factors and Barriers. Utrecht : WECF, 2009
  • KAZI, N. M. Sanitation Strategies and Technologies: Flood-prone and High Water Tables Areas of Bangladesh. Bangladesh: ITN-Bangladesh, 2003.
  • KHURTSIA, K. Inle Lake - Conservation and Rehabilitation - Stories From Myanmar. [S.l.] UNDP, 2015.
  • LIENERT, J., LARSEN, T. A. High acceptance of urine source separation in seven European countries: A review. Environmental Science and Technology, v. 44, p. 556-66, 2010.
  • LIMA, K. W. S. D., ANTUNES, J. L. F., SILVA, Z. P. D. Percepção dos gestores sobre o uso de indicadores nos serviços de saúde. Saúde e Sociedade, v. 24, p. 61-71, 2015.
  • MARINHO, P. A. S.; GONÇALVES, H. S. Práticas de empoderamento feminino na América Latina. Revista de Estudios Sociales, v. 56, p. 80-90, 2016.
  • MINAYO, M. C. de S. Pesquisa Social: teoria, método e criatividade. 21. Ed. Petrópolis: Editora Vozes; 2002.
  • MÓNICO, L. S., ALFERES, V. R., CASTRO, P.A., PARREIRA, P. M. A Observação Participante Enquanto Técnica De Investigação Qualitativa. Investigação Qualitativa em Ciências Sociais, v.3 n. 2, p. 724-33, 2017.
  • NASCIMENTO, A. C.; MOURA, E. A. F.; TEISSERENC, M. J. da S. A. Para além do sucesso técnico: rede sociotécnica em pequenas comunidades rurais amazônicas, Amazonas- Brasil. Novos Cadernos, v. 21, n. 1, p. 215-241, 2018.
  • NEU, V.; SOUZA DOS SANTOS, M. A.; FERRAZ MEYER, L. F. Banheiro ecológico ribeirinho: saneamento descentralizado para comunidades de várzea na Amazônia. Revista em Extensão, v. 15, n. 1, p. 28-44, 2016.
  • NUNES, J. A. O que se entende por cultura científica nas sociedades baseadas no conhecimento? (Universidade de Coimbra, Ed.) In: Conferência Prioridade à cultura científica, Coimbra. Anais [...] Coimbra: Universidade de Coimbra., 2004.
  • PENTEADO, I.M., DO NASCIMENTO, A.C.S., CORRÊA, D., MOURA, E.A.F., ZILLES, R., GOMES, M.C.R.L., PIRES, F.J., BRITO, O.S., DA SILVA, J.F., REIS, A.V. and SOUZA, A. Among people and artifacts: Actor-Network Theory and the adoption of solar ice machines in the Brazilian Amazon. Energy Research and Social Science, v. 53, p. 1-9, 2019.
  • PEREIRA, L. C. B.; FREITAS, C. C. G. Educação na tecnologia social: análise de experiências. Revista Tecnologia e Sociedade, v. 14, n. 30, p. 105-120, 2018.
  • RHEINLÄNDER, T., KERAITA, B., KONRADSEN, F., SAMUELSEN, H., DALSGAARD, A. Smell: An overlooked factor in sanitation promotion. Waterlines, v. 32, n. 2, p.106-12, 2013.
  • RIBEIRO, M. G.; FARIA, P. A.; DIAS, A. P. Educação e tecnologia social. In: EPSJV (Ed.). Técnico de vigilância em saúde: fundamentos: volume 2. Rio de Janeiro: EPSJV, 2017. p. 223-241.
  • RODRIGUES, E. B., LAPOLLI, F. R. ZONA DE RAÍZES: Experiência Vivenciada Numa Escola Rural No Município De Campos Novos/SC. In: ANAIS DOS RESUMOS VIII SIMPÓSIO BRASILEIRO DE ENGENHARIA AMBIENTAL, Curitiba. Anais [...]. Curitiba, 2015. p. 840-1.
  • RODRIGUES, I.; BARBIERI, J. C. A emergência da tecnologia social: revisitando o movimento da tecnologia apropriada como estratégia de desenvolvimento sustentável. Revista de Administração Pública, v. 42, n. 6, p. 1069-1094, 2008.
  • ROMA, E.; JEFFREY, P. Evaluation of community participation in the implementation of community-based sanitation systems: A case study from Indonesia. Water Science and Technology, v. 62, n. 5, p. 1028-1036, 2010.
  • SILVA, A. H., FOSSÁ, M. I. T. Análise de conteúdo: exemplo de aplicação da técnica para análise de dados qualitativos. Qualitas Revista Eletrônica, v. 16, n. 1, p.1-14, 2015.
  • SILVA, B. B., SALES, B., LANZA, A. C., HELLER, L., REZENDE, S. Water and sanitation are not gender-neutral: human rights in rural Brazilian communities. Water Policy, v. 22 n. 1, p. 102-20, 2020.
  • SOUSA, J. R. de; SANTOS, S. C. M. dos. Análise de conteúdo em pesquisa qualitativa: modo de pensar e de fazer. Pesquisa e Debate em Educação, v. 10, n. 2, p. 1396-1416, 2020.
  • TAM, T.N.T.P. Participation of women in rural water supply and sanitation projects: visible or invisible actors? The case of the sub-district of Maubara (Liquiçá, Timor-Leste). International Journal of Multidisciplinary Thought, v. 2, n. 4, p.149-170, 2012.
  • WALTER, S. A.; BACH, T. M. Adeus papel, marca-textos, tesoura e cola: inovando o processo de análise de conteúdo por meio do Atlas.ti. Administração: Ensino e Pesquisa, v. 16, n. 2, p. 275-308, 2015.

Correspondence

João Paulo Borges Pedro ✉ joaopaulo.pedro@hotmail.com

Correspondence

Cassio Augusto da Silva Oliveira ✉ cso.augusto@gmail.com

Correspondence

Isabel Campos Salles Figueiredo ✉ belzinhafigueiredo@gmail.com

Correspondence

Taína Martins Magalhães ✉ magalhaes.taina@gmail.com

Correspondence

Vania Neu ✉ bioneu@yahoo.com.br

Correspondence

Adriano Luiz Tonetti ✉ tonetti@unicamp.br

Correspondence

Marcos Von Sperling ✉ marcos@desa.ufmg.br

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    07 July 2025
  • Date of issue
    2025

History

  • Received
    11 Sept 2023
  • Accepted
    29 Dec 2024
location_on
ANPPAS - Revista Ambiente e Sociedade Anppas / Revista Ambiente e Sociedade - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
E-mail: revistaambienteesociedade@gmail.com
rss_feed Acompanhe os números deste periódico no seu leitor de RSS
Ir para o topo