ABSTRACT
This article analyzes the prescribed school curriculum for basic education in Brazil, focusing on the themes of gender, body, and sexuality between the years 1985 and 2022. From a methodological perspective, it is exploratory documentary research involving the collection, reading, and analysis of reference documents from educational policy. Based on the exploration of nine milestones, the central argument indicates the existence of advances and setbacks that cannot be understood out of context. This is because both Brazilian and international contexts help explain them, but also because the very dispute over the curriculum plays a role in shaping these contexts.
Keywords
Curriculum; Prescribed Curriculum; Gender; Body; Sexuality
RESUMO
Este texto analisa o currículo escolar prescrito para a educação básica no Brasil, com recorte nos temas gênero, corpo e sexualidade, entre os anos de 1985 e 2022. Do ponto de vista metodológico, trata-se de pesquisa documental exploratória, envolvendo o levantamento, a leitura e a análise de documentos de referência da política educacional. Com base na exploração de nove marcos, o argumento central indica a existência de avanços e de retrocessos que não podem ser compreendidos de forma descontextualizada. Isso porque os contextos brasileiro e internacional ajudam a explicá-los, mas, ao mesmo tempo, porque a própria disputa em torno do currículo atuaria engendrando os contextos.
Palavras-chave
Currículo; Currículo Prescrito; Gênero; Corpo; Sexualidade
Introduction
Scholars in the field of the sociology of the curriculum argue that what should be taught and learned in schools is situated within a field of disputes, whether economic, cultural, material, symbolic, social, pedagogical, or political. These are disputes that are sometimes highly active and explicit, and sometimes passive and implicit, yet equally operative (Ribeiro; Azevedo-Lopes, 2017). Located within a social arena (Popkewitz; Pereyra, 1992), such disputes may represent a fertile field for analysis. They help us understand how, when, why, under which conditions, and with which interests or intentions forms of knowledge are structured and set out in (and by) school curricular discourses. In this sense, curricula would not be merely the expression of a space occupied by those who (or that which) supposedly hold the power to teach, but rather a privileged space of knowledge and representation in which formative actions, educational projects, and public policies are made possible (or unfeasible).
This means that conflicts, narratives, representations, or resistances involving curricula can be analyzed in light of the collective social actions that establish teaching practices, that can underpin public educational policies, and that can produce ways of being2. First, because it is within them that the roots of these factors of/in dispute are found. Second, because it is within their fabric that the curriculum acquires and produces meaning. Finally, because the curricular text can enable an understanding of the trends and countertrends, the accommodations and resistances of the educational projects inscribed in the flows of historical movements.
In curriculum studies, there seems to be consensus regarding the existence of several different types of school curricula that may or may not interact with one another. According to Sacristán (2008), a curriculum may be understood in terms of its official status (prescribed curriculum), the exercise of its action (curriculum in practice), and the elements that make up a school subtext or the underlying meanings of intentions that are not explicit (hidden curriculum). Other researchers also mention the null curriculum (empty curriculum): the one that schools and education professionals simply eliminate from their plans and activities. A curriculum of absences (Moreira, 1997) that can be as formative as, or more formative than, that which manifests itself as presence.
It is worth emphasizing that, in the typology of school curricula, only the first of them is made explicit in the form of official documents (foundational frameworks, decrees, decree-laws, guidelines, laws, parameters, ordinances, etc.), being understood as an explicit and objective normative document, unlike other types of curricula that are also prescriptive, such as interpretive and subjective normative documents (circulars and official letters, for example) or guidance documents (schools’ internal documents and support texts, among others)3.
In this article, we analyze some of the explicit and objective normative documents of curricular policy that present precisely the prescribed curriculum for basic education in Brazil, with a specific focus on the themes of gender, body, and sexuality. For the purposes of analysis, we chose to adopt an interval bounded by two temporal markers: from the year 1985, the first year of the New Republic, which inaugurated Brazilian redemocratization after the Military Dictatorship; to the year 2022, the last year of the Jair Bolsonaro administration, a period known for producing various attacks on education and on human rights (HR) (Biroli et al., 2024). We address three questions: between 1985 and 2022, which disputes produced a prescribed curriculum on gender, body, and sexuality? Which advances or setbacks can be observed in school normative documents over these nearly four decades? And, ultimately, as a society, where would we stand with regard to what is prescribed to be taught in schools about gender, body, and sexuality?
In seeking to answer these questions, we designed as our methodological procedure the analysis of nine keys of reading that, as historical-social milestones, guided our investigation:
-
the Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil, known as the Citizen Constitution, promulgated in 1988;
-
the guidelines and bases of national education, established in 1996 through Law No. 9,394/96, called the National Education Guidelines and Bases Law (LDB-EN);
-
the National Curricular Parameters (PCN), established between 1997 and 20004;
-
the creation of the Department of Continuing Education, Literacy, and Diversity (Secad), within the organizational structure of the Ministry of Education (MEC), in 2004, later renamed the Department of Continuing Education, Literacy, Diversity, and Inclusion (Secadi);
-
the National Curricular Guidelines (DCN), established between 2009 and 20125;
-
the emergence of the School Without Party Movement (Mesp) and of conservative agendas engaged in a false crusade against a fabricated gender ideology6 from 2010 onward;
-
the approval of the National Education Plan (PNE), in 2014, through Law No. 13,005/14;
-
the institution of the National Common Curricular Base (BNCC) between 2017 and 20187 and;
-
the abolition of Secadi, in 2019, without the transfer of the vast majority of its competencies to another structure within the MEC.
An important note: the aim was not to analyze each of these milestones in detail. On the contrary, the effort sought to understand them as keys of reading capable of, amid historical flows, supporting an understanding of how the categories gender, body, and sexuality became fundamental pieces of the disputes in the field of the prescribed school curriculum. This article is, therefore, the result of exploratory documentary research. Its corpus was constructed from the collection, reading, and analysis of reference documents of educational policy between the years 1985 and 2022, listed at the end of the text.
As a summary of its argument, the article was structured into three sections. First, the work presents the historical movements related to the construction of the curriculum on gender, body, and sexuality in Brazil. Next, the curricular movements themselves are explored. Throughout these first two sections, we carry out an exercise of presenting and analyzing the data, thereby revealing partial results of the research8. And in the final section we present brief final considerations.
Historical movements
The period from 1985 to 2014 in Brazil was marked by what Ribeiro (2017) called the movement of three democratic agendas: that of democratization, led by the Brazilian Democratic Movement Party (PMDB); that of the stabilization of the economy, led by the Brazilian Social Democracy Party (PSDB); and that of social policies, led by the Workers' Party (PT). Articulated with the agendas of democratization and social policies, a growing process of institutionalization of policies for women developed. In 1985, still in the midst of the redemocratization process the country was undergoing, the National Council for Women's Rights (CNDM) was created, subordinated to the Ministry of Justice (MJ). The creation of the Secretariat for Women's Rights (Sedim), also linked to the MJ and incorporating the CNDM, dates from 2002, the last year of the Fernando Henrique Cardoso (FHC) administration. This body for managing policies specific to women would be abolished in 2003, at the very beginning of the first Lula administration, giving way to the National Secretariat of Policies for Women (SPM-BR). This secretariat initially enjoyed ministerial status and, in 2014, was elevated to the condition of a ministry (Amorim et al., 2024).
Between 2015 and 2022, the political history of Brazil, marked by a Coup in 2016 against President Dilma Rousseff and by the rise of the far right in 2018, brought Jair Bolsonaro to the Presidency of the Republic. Drawing on Ribeiro (2017), one may argue that this period was dominated by an antidemocratic agenda. As the author proposes regarding the 1985-2014 period, this is an agenda that emerges “[...] as demands of only a part of society, facing the disregard or even the rejection of most actors with decision-making power; [...] [and that took] time to take hold [...]” (Ribeiro, 2017, p. 58). However, while the democratic agendas were led by a particular political party and became State policies (Ribeiro, 2017), the antidemocratic agenda would be led by the far right and marked by the hollowing out of public policies.
Specifically in relation to policies for women, the years between 2015 and 2022 were years of deinstitutionalization and antifeminist occupation of the feminist structures of the State (Amorim et al., 2024; Cardoso et al., 2023). The national bodies underwent four changes in this period. Each administrative reform imposed a period of adaptation on the public apparatus, having, therefore, caused at least initially a negative impact on policies for women. When there are four changes over the course of four years, the adaptation period unfolds and is prolonged. In 2015, President Dilma merged the SPM-BR with other portfolios, creating the Ministry of Women, Racial Equality, Youth and Human Rights. This action perhaps indicates, today, the understanding of a first sign that the issue was losing ground on the governmental agenda9.
In 2016, when Michel Temer took power, the ministry was summarily abolished, and its competencies, except that of developing policies for young people, were transferred to the Ministry of Justice and Citizenship (MJC). Less than a year later, in 2017, Temer created the Ministry of Human Rights (MDH). Curiously, at that moment, the women's portfolio was not transferred to this new ministry, but rather to its Secretariat of Government (Segov-BR). Two years later, in 2019, Bolsonaro would assume the Presidency of the Republic, ordering the creation of the Ministry of Women, Family and Human Rights (Lobato et al., 2018; Amorim et al., 2024).
From 2016 onward, the change in the profile of the women in the upper echelons of the national women's policy bodies in Brazil indicated a project of antifeminist occupation of the feminist structures of the State. Feminists were replaced by antifeminists, such as Fátima Pelaes, who led the SPM-BR and the CNDM during the Temer years, and Damares Alves, who headed the Ministry of Women and the CNDM under the Bolsonaro administration. Both, evangelicals with conservative positions, marked a transformation that went beyond institutional changes, profoundly affecting State action. Although the CNDM and the SPM-BR are achievements of the feminist and women's movements, historically occupied and led by feminists, with the 2016 Coup, these spaces were taken over and came to be filled by antifeminists with the aim of propagating antifeminism (Amorim et al., 2024).
Within the context of the historical movements, it is necessary to point out at least four events from the international context, beginning with the highlight of two of them: the 3rd UN World Conference on Women, held in Nairobi in 1985, and the 4th UN World Conference on Women, held in Beijing in 1995. This international context impacted the governments of UN member countries, including Brazil and others, whose historical movements of the 1980s and 1990s still signaled engagement in the democratic opening and the overcoming of the adversities produced by the military dictatorships. Specifically, regarding the preparation of the 3rd Conference, the rapporteur of the organizing committee pointed out that, in the country, an activity for the promotion of women and the evaluation of medium-term plans would be “[...] as a class, to strengthen bodies that are being created10 so that the law is fulfilled, preventing women's rights from being disrespected” (Editorial...., 1985, n.p.). In addition, the organizing committee itself mentioned the need to evaluate the advances and difficulties faced by the countries, in order to achieve the objectives of the UN decade for women (Editorial..., 1985). Regarding the 4th Conference, in its declaration and platform for action, it was affirmed that
its [...] legacy [...] [would be] a set of strategic objectives – with the identification of the actions necessary to achieve them [...] a comprehensive guide to orient governments and society in improving the legal framework, in formulating policies, and in implementing programs to promote equality and to prevent discrimination
(UN, 1995, p. 149).
Two other international events were led by the Catholic Church through the dissemination of the so-called struggle against gender ideology, a term coined in the Holy See under the influence of Cardinal Ratzinger. After the International Conference on Population and Development, held by the UN in Cairo in 1994, which broadened the notion of women's sexual and reproductive health, the Catholic Church perceived feminist achievements as a defeat and feared that this would pave the way for the recognition of abortion as a right (Corrêa et al., 2018). In response, the following year, the Church mobilized Catholic intellectuals and activists for the Women's Conference in Beijing. Among other names, that of the conservative Dale O’Leary stood out, who wrote and disseminated materials critical of the concept of gender, such as the book The Gender Agenda, used as a reference for the notion of gender ideology (Paternote; Kuhar, 2018). Also in this context of resistance against feminist achievements, the First World Congress of Families was held in 1997, promoting the defense of the natural family; an intentionally discursive construction regarded as a fundamental pillar of society. Thus, the notion of gender ideology consolidated itself as a global political strategy of the Church, adopted by its co-partners in the same undertaking, the evangelical churches. In summary, Miguel (2015, n.p.) explains that gender ideology would be a term
coined by the conservative sectors of the Catholic Church, but also adopted by Protestant denominations, and put into effect in various countries around the world, among them Brazil, as a way of organizing opposition to advances [...] toward greater equality between the sexes and greater respect for gays and lesbians.
In Brazil, the one at the forefront against gender ideology in the educational field was Mesp. Founded in 2004 by Miguel Nagib, it presented itself as an initiative of parents and students who claimed to be concerned with a supposed political-ideological contamination of Brazilian schools (Amorim; Salej, 2016; Miguel, 2016). The movement systematically accused teachers of using their academic freedom to promote their own worldviews, under the justification of offering a critical view of reality (Silveira, 2019).
Although officially created in 2004, Nagib located the origin of his problem a year earlier, in 2003, when a history teacher at his daughter's school had allegedly compared Che Guevara to Saint Francis of Assisi, which he interpreted as an attempt at political indoctrination. With no response from the school, he gathered supporters and started the movement, seeking to expose what they considered to be the instrumentalization of teaching for ideological ends (Miguel, 2016; Silveira, 2019). Obviously, Mesp adopted a supposed neutrality in its action, arguing that teachers should avoid expressing opinions in the classroom (Frigotto, 2019; Miguel, 2016). For the group, the role of educating would fall solely and exclusively to the family and to religion. To the school would remain only the function of instructing, an action restricted to the transmission of a knowledge considered neutral, without addressing values or encouraging reflection on the student's social reality (Carvalho, 2019; Miguel, 2016; Silveira, 2019). This perspective, from the outset, has assumed that knowledge is something objective and detached from the teacher-student interaction, thus intentionally ignoring the formative role of a critical education (Miguel, 2016).
It is worth reinforcing that Mesp is part of an international movement that manifests itself in several countries, such as Australia, Canada, and the United States, through the encouragement of U.S. initiatives by conservative think tanks such as No Indocritnation, No Brainwashing, Creation Studies Institute, and Campus Watch, among others. These organizations monitor school content they consider biased and seek to combat what they perceive as political biases in education, especially in public education. Nagib openly declared that he was inspired by the U.S. group No Indocritnation, considered by him as an example of success in opposing school ideologization (Santos et al., 2021; Silveira, 2019).
Although created in 2004, Mesp remained relatively unknown during the two Lula administrations, gaining prominence only during the political crisis provoked to destabilize the Dilma government. It was during the so-called June Journeys of 2013 that Mesp strengthened itself as an influential voice in debates on education. Miguel (2016) points out that, when the movement was created, its denunciation of a supposed political-ideological contamination in the Brazilian educational system focused on the critique of Marxist indoctrination. However, from the 2010s onward, this narrative absorbed gender ideology, thus embracing a broader-spectrum conservative agenda. According to the author, “at the moment when ‘gender ideology’ overtakes ‘Marxist indoctrination,’ Mesp's discourse takes another turn. The defense of a ‘neutral’ education, which had been predominant until then, gives way to the notion of the primacy of the family over the school” (Miguel, 2016, p. 601). Since then, the movement has come to foster hate speech against the progressive political positions of teachers and school administrators and the inclusive proposals of public policies (Carvalho, 2019; Miguel, 2016; Santos et al., 2021).
Amorim and Salej (2016) point out that Mesp associates the term gender ideology with a supposed indoctrination process. Avowedly, the movement disregards the legitimacy of the concept of gender in order to, while attempting to deconstruct it semantically and politically, use it as a political strategy to mobilize conservative sectors. This approach removes the debate from the field of the social sciences and shifts it to the moral field, contributing to opposition to advances in gender equality and respect for sexual diversity. This strategic shift allowed Mesp to garner the support of certain religious groups, notably conservative ones, and to expand its political and social reach, influencing even the creation of different Bills (PL) at the municipal, state, and federal levels (Amorim; Salej, 2016; Frigotto, 2019; Miguel, 2016).
These Bills, disseminated nationally through model drafts, aim to restrict the discussion of the issues of gender, body, and sexuality in the classroom, keeping education in conformity with a biological sexual identity. Thus, their proponents aim, among other things, for example, to establish the need for formal parental authorization for the teaching of contents deemed moral or religious, and to require the posting of signs in schools indicating the duties of teachers, which aims to limit academic freedom in order to prevent what they consider an imposition of ideological values (Amorim; Salej, 2016; Barroso; Silva, 2020; Santos et al., 2021).
Curricular Movements
The 1988 Citizen Constitution assigned exclusively to the Union the authority to “legislate on the guidelines and bases of national education” and established that teaching should be provided based on the principles of the “freedom to learn, teach, research, and disseminate thought, art, and knowledge,” as well as of “pluralism of ideas and pedagogical conceptions” (Brasil, 1988, Art. 22, Sec. XXIV, Art. 206, Sec. II-III). Almost a decade later, the LDB-EN determined that education, “inspired by the principles of freedom and the ideas of human solidarity,” would have as its purpose “the full development of the learner, their preparation for the exercise of citizenship, and their qualification for work.” The Law further reinforced the constitutional text (Brasil, 1996, Art. 2, Art. 3, Sec. II-IV).
Taken together, these normative documents determined that Brazilian states and municipalities should formulate and establish their educational policies without usurping the Union's primary and prior authority, thus respecting the guidelines and bases of national education established by it. The possible need to supplement federal legislation, with a view to regulating local or regional interests, would not justify, for example, the prohibition of school contents, which could run counter to the prescription given by the Union. More than that: the education networks, schools (including private ones), religious entities, and even families do not have the right to decide on the content to be taught and learned in schools, that is, on the curriculum11.
From a curricular standpoint, in Brazil, three central normative documents were produced between the years 1985-2022: 1) the PCN, dating from the turn of the twentieth to the twenty-first century; 2) the DCN, dating from the late 2000s and early 2010s; and 3) the BNCC, dating from the end of the 2010s. Since the advent of the LDB, therefore, approximately every decade the country has produced a new normative school curriculum document, and all of them proposed cross-cutting themes in the curriculum. The PCN proposed six cross-cutting themes. The DCN, in turn, proposed an indeterminate number of thematic/guiding axes, organized by general themes. Finally, the BNCC proposed 15 contemporary, cross-cutting, and integrating themes. In the case of the PCN and the DCN, these were curricular recommendations, whereas in the case of the BNCC, it is a curricular determination, in which all 15 mentioned themes would be governed by specific rules (Brasil, 1997; 1998; 2000; 2009; 2010; 2012; 2013; 2017a; 2017b; 2017c; 2018).
In the PCN, specifically with regard to Elementary Education, six cross-cutting themes were proposed — ethics, the environment, health, cultural plurality, sexual orientation, and the relationship between work and consumption — which, because they constituted social issues assessed at the time as current and urgent, both in the national and international contexts, should be addressed in a continuous and integrated manner; that is, breaking with the logic of the isolated school subject. In this case, the treatment given to the theme by the official document, cross-cutting, indicated not only the urgency of the debates on sexuality in schools, already at that time, but also the very understanding that the matter could not be restricted exclusively to the areas of science or biology teaching (Brasil, 1997; 1998; 2000).
Regarding the theme of sexual orientation, within the scope of the PCN, three fundamental axes of teaching work were indicated by the document: 1) the human body; 2) gender relations; and 3) the prevention of Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STD), among them Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS) (Brasil, 1997; 1998). The initiative inaugurated, perhaps in an unprecedented way in the history of Brazilian school education, a genuine call for teachers of the different curricular components to assume, in their classes, the responsibility of working with sexual orientation.
The human body was presented as the matrix of sexuality. Within it, care for the body was advocated, with a view to promoting healthy habits and quality of life and health, including sexual orientation with the aim of conveying information and problematizing issues that would contribute to the responsible and pleasurable exercise of sexuality, as well as to the discernment of behaviors that require privacy and intimacy and the recognition of manifestations of sexuality that may be expressed in the school environment. The document emphasized the need for self-knowledge of one's own body and the extent to which this self-knowledge would be related to self-esteem and to the very use of one's own body, in the production and expression of ideas, but also, socially, in movements of overcoming and displacement. The body was therefore considered, beyond its biological dimension, in the understanding of difference and of the different and of respect for differences and for those who are different (Brasil, 1997; 1998).
Specifically with regard to the discussion of gender, the material argued that it should foster the recognition of gender inequality, which would be an important step in promoting equality and equity. This would make it possible to question and to make more flexible the rigid gendered social roles established for men and women in society (Brasil, 1997; 1998).
The school is therefore pointed out as the privileged locus of sexual orientation. This is because, on the one hand, the education it ensures would differ, in some cases, from that of the family, since it would necessarily make possible the discussion of various points of view, without the imposition of values and beliefs and, on the other hand, it is work carried out collectively, without a psychotherapeutic bias (Brasil, 1997; 1998). Carreira (2019) argues that the PCN, still under the FHC Government, represented an important step in the construction of a place for diversity in educational policies and that the creation of Secad/MEC, in 2004, already under the Lula Government, should be understood in the wake of the PCN, as an advance in this construction. With its advent, for the first time in the country's history, a place was granted in the structure of the State specifically intended for the approach to diversity in educational policies.
During Lula's first term in office, Secad was created with the aim of promoting educational policies aimed at groups historically excluded and marginalized in Brazil (Jakimiu, 2021; Taffarel; Carvalho, 2019). Its name was changed to Secadi during President Dilma's first term, in 2011, with the inclusion of the theme of inclusion, incorporating attributions previously linked to the Special Education Secretariat (Jakimiu, 2021). Secadi was the result of the struggles of social movements, such as those for education and for agrarian reform, which pressed for educational policies that would recognize inequalities historically silenced in the educational debate (Taffarel; Carvalho, 2019). In this way, its establishment represented a significant advance in guaranteeing the right to education for diversity, with a focus on reducing educational inequalities and on promoting social inclusion (Jakimiu, 2021). For Carreira (2019, p. 03-04):
The new secretariat came not only to articulate existing actions, but to promote programs and policies concerning indigenous school education, ethnic-racial diversity, gender equality and sexual diversity, youth and adult education, rural education, environmental education, and complementary educational actions.
Lázaro (2013), in turn, mentions an example that illustrates the importance of Secad/Secadi in promoting the discussion of gender and sexuality in schools in Brazil. This is an initiative in partnership with the SPM-BR, developed on the basis of the 1st National Conference on Policies for Women (CNPM), held in Brasília in 2004, and the 1st National Plan of Policies for Women (PNPM) of 2005. The course Gender and Diversity at School (GDE), focused on the training of basic education teachers and of students in undergraduate teaching programs, was developed in partnership with public universities and social movements, offered in a blended format, and trained thousands of professionals.
Regarding the DCN, the resolution of the National Education Council (CNE) that established them for Early Childhood Education determined that schools should fulfill their pedagogical and sociopolitical functions, “constructing new forms of sociability and of subjectivity committed to [...] the breaking of relations of domination [...] of gender [...]” (Brasil, 2009, Art. 7, Sec. V). The CNE resolution that established these same guidelines for Elementary Education, in turn, determined that
the curricular components and areas of knowledge must articulate their contents, based on the possibilities opened up by their frameworks, addressing broad and contemporary themes that affect human life on a global, regional, and local scale, as well as in the individual sphere. Themes such as [...] sexuality and gender [...] must permeate the development of the contents of the common national base and of the diversified part of the curriculum
(Brasil, 2010, Art. 16).
The same resolution would also determine that
it is incumbent upon the executive bodies of the education systems to produce and disseminate materials to support teaching work, which contribute to the elimination of discrimination, [...] sexism, homophobia, and other prejudices and which lead to the adoption of responsible and supportive behaviors in relation to others [...]
(Brasil, 2010, Art. 16, § 3o).
Finally, the CNE resolution that established the DCN for Secondary Education determined that
the political-pedagogical project of the school units [...] must consider [...] the valorization and promotion of human rights through themes relating to gender, gender identity, [...] sexual orientation [...], as well as practices that contribute to equality and to confronting all forms of prejudice, discrimination, and violence in all their forms
(Brasil, 2012, Art. 16, Sec. XV).
The word gender appears 34 times in the document published by Secad/Secadi, presenting the set of DCN established by the CNE specifically for youth and adult education, environmental education, HR education, special education, rural education, indigenous and quilombola school education, and for ethnic-racial relations. In 32 of them, that is, in their near-totality, its meaning refers to the socio-historical and cultural construction of feminine and masculine social roles. The word sexual or its radical sex- appears 23 times, making direct references to sexual orientation, sexual diversity, sexuality, sexuality education, sexual violence, and sexual abuse. Gender, body, and sexuality emerge in each of the specific DCN and, particularly, in the DCN concerning HR education. In this case, it is necessary to emphasize that they bear on the struggle against the inequalities, discriminations, stigmas, oppressions, and prejudices determined by gender identity and sexual orientation, insofar as they advocate that all people are subjects of rights12.
It is therefore undeniable that, according to the DCN, gender, body, and sexuality are part of the prescribed school curriculum for basic education. However, the number of thematic axes is indeterminate and depends on the choices of the subnational education system and of the school units, but also on teachers and students, in an attempt to break with fixed contents. Moreover, the guiding axes are, above all, methodological or of a background nature — for example, the social interactions and forms of play that constitute the guiding axes of Early Childhood Education (Brasil, 2009). There is, therefore, a great margin of maneuver in the implementation of the DCN and, consequently, doubts remain as to what extent and how gender, body, and sexuality were effectively addressed in the classroom.
The most recent document among the others, the BNCC was ratified between 2017 and 2018 and was to take effect in 2019, with progressive implementation, even though, since its formal establishment, it has faced opposing reactions and resistance from teachers, students, families, and educational establishments. In any case, the document sought to establish the essential learning that all Brazilian students should develop (Brasil, n.d.). Consulting the initial proposal and its processing, one observes an omission regarding the discussion of gender and a rather timid openness to the discussion on sexuality (Brasil, 2017a; 2017b; 2017c; 2018).
The word gender, in the sense of the socio-historical and cultural construction of the feminine and the masculine, appears only four times in the Draft opinion and draft resolution dealing with the BNCC. The radical sex-, in turn, is even less present in the document, appearing only twice (Brasil, 2017a). Gender emerges, first, when it is argued that the improvement of school performance should be committed to confronting social inequalities, among them that of gender (Brasil, 2017a, p. 14). Next, it is recorded that the cross-cutting themes are requirements of specific legislation and rules, and, in the case of gender and sexuality, it is necessary to consider Opinion CNE/CEB No. 11/2010 and Resolution CNE/CEB No. 7/2010 (Brasil, 2017a, p. 30). The word gender also arises to justify its absence in the BNCC:
The theme ‘gender’ was the object of much controversy during the public debates on the BNCC. In this sense, it is understood that the CNE must, in response to social demands, deepen the debates on this theme, and may subsequently issue guidelines for the treatment of the matter, considering the national curricular guidelines in force
(Brasil, 2017a, p. 30).
Finally, the document announces that the specific curricular guidelines would be postponed: “The CNE will issue specific guidelines on sexual orientation and gender identity” (Brasil, 2017a, p. 42). The draft of an opinion effectively gave rise to an opinion, Opinion CNE/CP No. 15/2017 (Brasil, 2017b). In both cases, both in the draft and in the opinion itself, the documents appear to be quite similar. However, a fine-grained analysis indicates the existence of at least two important differences: the first is that the opinion did not determine that the CNE could subsequently issue guidelines for addressing gender and sexuality in school, but that it should do so, considering the importance of the topic for “the development of values and attitudes of respect, tolerance of diversity, pluralism, and individual freedoms, in order to combat any form of prejudice, discrimination, and violence” (Brasil, 2017b, p. 30). The second difference between the documents centers on the fact that, in the opinion, there is a restriction by Counselor Antônio César Calligari regarding the exclusion of references to gender and sexual orientation in the BNCC:
I emphasize, however, my reservations: [...] the exclusion of the references to gender and sexual orientation, with the MEC and the majority of the CNE members ending up yielding to the pressures of the fundamentalist and ultraconservative militias that positioned themselves against the existence of these matters in the BNCC (I presented amendments for their reincorporation into the text, unfortunately rejected) [...]
(Brasil, 2017b, p. 45).
The resolution proposed by the CNE, ratified by the MEC, came to have force as a norm. It is interesting to note that, according to this resolution, sexual orientation and gender identity, as well as computing, were to constitute the object of subsequent specific guidelines (Brasil, 2017c). However, while the latter have already been published, those on sexual orientation and gender identity are still absent, several years later (Brasil, n.d.).
In the document annexed to the draft opinion and to the Opinion mentioned above, entitled Base Nacional Comum Curricular and produced by the MEC (Brasil, 2017a annex; 2017b annex), the word gender emerges 269 times in a total of 470 pages. However, in all of them, reference is made to a content of the languages (textual, discursive, and musical genres, inflection by gender, etc.). The radical sex-, in turn, emerges six times: to indicate that, in the final years of Elementary Education, themes related to human reproduction and sexuality should be addressed; to make explicit that students who are completing Elementary Education are expected to be able to act by protecting and promoting sexual health (twice); when the objects of knowledge of the Thematic Unit Life and Evolution of the Science Subject of the 8th grade are listed — reproductive mechanisms and sexuality; and when the skills of this thematic unit are listed (twice) (Brasil, 2017a annex; 2017b annex, p. 325, 341, 346, 347). It is worth citing the latter, considering that they may help to unveil part of the curriculum of gender, body, and sexuality:
[...] Compare different reproductive processes in plants and animals in relation to adaptive and evolutionary mechanisms. [...] Analyze and explain the transformations that occur during puberty considering the action of the sex hormones and of the nervous system. [...] Compare the mode of action and the efficacy of the various contraceptive methods and justify the need to share responsibility in the choice and use of the method most suited to preventing early and unwanted pregnancy and Socially Transmitted Diseases (STD). [...] Identify the main symptoms, modes of transmission, and treatment of some STD (with emphasis on AIDS), and discuss prevention strategies and methods. [...] Select arguments that demonstrate the multiple dimensions of human sexuality (biological, sociocultural, affective, and ethical)
(Brasil, 2017a annex; 2017b annex, p. 347).
With regard to the PNE, the central document of educational policies dating from 2014, as recorded by Brandão and Lopes (2018), the inclusion of the terms gender and sexual orientation gave rise to an intense debate, posing, from the outset, obstacles to its approval. For this reason, whereas the 1st PNE was in force until 2010, the 2nd only took effect in 2014, with a four-year delay, and the final text mentioned neither gender nor sexual orientation.
Some social and political segments vehemently disagreed that the themes of sexuality and gender should be dealt with in the public sphere, in spaces such as the school. They consider them matters of a private order, restricted to the family environment. Because they do not agree with the inclusion of what they call ‘gender ideology’ [...] they strongly opposed it, mobilizing efforts to block any advances in that direction
(Brandão; Lopes, 2018, p. 102-103).
It is worth recalling that, in 2011, the debate on gender and sexuality in Brazilian schools gained prominence with the controversy surrounding the teaching material of the School Without Homophobia Program, developed by the MEC, with the aim of combating LGBTphobia in the school environment. However, the negative reaction was intense, and the material was pejoratively nicknamed the Gay Kit by conservative sectors, as a strategy for promoting moral panic. The political pressure resulted in the withdrawal of the material from circulation on May 26, 2011 (Barroso; Silva, 2020). During that same period, the then federal deputy Jair Bolsonaro and ideological peers began a crusade against the MEC, framing the entire discussion on sexuality in schools as gender ideology (Silveira, 2019)13.
It was precisely in this context that the rhetoric of the Mesp came to emphasize the primacy of the family over the school, arguing that educational content could not run counter to its values. To this end, the movement began to encourage families to send extrajudicial notifications to schools, as a way of preventing teachers from addressing themes related to gender and sexuality (Miguel, 2016). This discourse was widely used in the mobilization against the inclusion of these agendas, both in the PNE and in the BNCC.
In 2014, during the discussions for the approval of the PNE, slogans such as indoctrination and gender ideology were widely used by conservative groups on social media, in order to press the political disputes over the curriculum. It was these pressures that culminated in the exclusion of guidelines that oriented the debate on gender and sexuality within the school. The previous PNE (2001-10) included strategies such as the analysis of textbooks to identify content discriminatory against women, Black people, and indigenous peoples, and people in situations of vulnerability, as well as the incorporation of discussions on cross-cutting themes in teacher training. However, the following PNE (2014-24) reduced these guidelines to a single strategy aimed at combating sexual violence, as a reflection of the influence of the movement that forcibly falsified a struggle against gender ideology and sought to suppress discussions on social markers of difference, such as gender, sexuality, race, religion, and generation (Barroso; Silva, 2020).
This clash also marked the drafting of the BNCC, begun in 2015 after the approval of the PNE. The process of constructing the document went through three versions: the first was made available for public consultation between September 2015 and March 2016; the second was published in April 2016; and the last, in April 2017, after the impeachment of President Dilma and already under the Michel Temer government. Owing to the discussions on the reform of Secondary Education, the definition of the guidelines for the treatment of gender and sexuality was postponed to 2018 and separated from the guidelines for Early Childhood Education and Elementary Education (Barroso; Silva, 2020). During Temer's transitional government and with Bolsonaro's proximity to the executive power, the Mesp became a privileged and direct interlocutor of the MEC, promoting a technicist and limited view of human development, especially in Early Childhood Education and Elementary Education (Miguel, 2016; Silveira, 2019). This influence became evident in the BNCC ratified in 2017, which excluded discussions on body, gender, and sexuality, replacing them with ethical principles and values and reinforcing a conservative and moralistic approach in education (Silveira, 2019). During the revisions of the BNCC, terms such as gender identity and sexual orientation were systematically eliminated, consolidating a narrative that privileges traditional values (Barroso; Silva, 2020; Santos et al., 2021). Not by chance, the extinction of Secadi occurred in 2019, during the government of Jair Bolsonaro, by means of Decree No. 9,465, which altered the administrative structure of the MEC (Jakimiu, 2021).
With the end of Secadi, the head of the Literacy Secretariat (Sealf) absorbed only a minuscule part of its competencies, with Carlos Nadalim, a central figure of the Mesp, occupying its leadership. The Secretary, known for his Catholic and Olavist orientations14, led changes in the National Textbook Program (PNLD) and in the BNCC. In 2013, he created the blog entitled “How to Educate Your Children,” promoting agendas such as homeschooling, the fight against the ideas of Paulo Freire, and the adoption of the controversial phonics method of literacy (Biroli et al., 2024). For the office of the Coordination of Teaching Materials, an activist of the Mesp, Sandra Ramos, was also appointed, “an evangelical of the Baptist Church who defines herself as ‘a fighter against the movement of gender ideology in textbooks’” (Biroli et al., 2024, p. 20).
The extinction of Secadi represented not only an administrative change but a significant setback in educational policies aimed at vulnerable populations, increasing the risk of school dropout and low achievement owing to the absence of inclusive public policies. It amounted to a failure to comply with the basic principles set forth in the Federal Constitution of 1988, which aim at the construction of a just and supportive society, in the pursuit of the eradication of poverty and marginalization and of the promotion of the well-being of all, without discrimination. It also infringed the principles of the LDB, such as equal access to school and permanence, respect for freedom and for ethnic-racial diversity; in addition to weakening the implementation of the PNE, which sought to eradicate illiteracy and overcome educational inequalities (Jakimiu, 2021).
As Taffarel and Carvalho (2019) argued, this extinction was aligned with a political context of setbacks in rights. Within this context lies the growth of the far right in the country and the interest of a resurgent neoliberal project fostered by the economic elites. This project, which since the 2016 Coup has stripped away social and labor rights, aggravated social inequalities, generating exploitation, unemployment, and hunger and expanding misery in the country. Sectors constitutionally protected by the Constitution, such as health and education, had public investments frozen, and public bodies such as schools, universities, and hospitals verged on insolvency. Constitutional Amendment No. 95/2016 contributed to the weakening of policies of inclusion and social justice, imposing on the whole of Brazilian society a fiscal regime that is even more perverse for the historically marginalized groups.
It is therefore to be assumed that the Mesp and other conservative far-right groups not only influenced the political discourse on education in Brazil, but also directly impacted the formulation of public policies by forcibly shaping the school curriculum in accordance with their ideological guidelines. Obviously, this flow contributed to the construction of a discourse that reaffirmed traditional conceptions of gender, body, and sexuality, excluding, even if momentarily, discussions about cultural and social diversity in the educational environment (Barroso; Silva, 2020; Miguel, 2016). Nevertheless, it must be noted that, if what is maintained, what is erased, and what is reinvented represent a constant dispute of educational interests in the field of the curriculum, the advances of the far right are not consolidated and were not produced without encountering resistance15.
Final Considerations
It is the existence of the Law that guarantees and establishes the recognition of the practices of teachers interested in the construction of a more egalitarian and inclusive history, endorsing and legitimizing practices that could not and should not be questioned by third parties [...] this means that if a professional act is performed under the aegis of a teacher, it should be carried out under the protection and with full support of the State: teachers are not enemy indoctrinators in society
(Cardoso, 2020, p. 249).
Considering the flexibility of subnational curricula and the margin of interpretation of the national guidelines, in addition to the recent advent of Law No. 14,986/24 (Brasil, 2024), which includes in the LDB the mandatory nature of approaches grounded in the experiences and perspectives of women in the curricular content of Elementary and Secondary Education, it is necessary to develop objective pedagogical guidelines on what to address in terms of body, gender, and sexuality in a progressive manner and how this should be done. These guidelines must be anchored in the normative frameworks in force and in the principles of human rights (HR), promoting educational practices of respect for diversity and the combating of violence (Amorim et al., 2025).
Notes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Availability of research data
the dataset supporting the results of this study is published in the article itself.
References
-
AMORIM, Marina Alves et al. Policy Brief Educação e Gênero Belo Horizonte: FJP, 2025. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/ylnlkk5a Acesso em: 17 set. 2025.
» https://tinyurl.com/ylnlkk5a -
AMORIM, Marina Alves; SALEJ, Ana Paula. O conservadorismo saiu do armário. Revista Ártemis, João Pessoa, v. 22, n. 1, p. 32-42, jul./dez. 2016. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2ajreq5n . Acesso em: 13 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/2ajreq5n -
AMORIM, Marina Alves; SALEJ, Ana Paula; MAIA, Maria Clara. As políticas para as mulheres no Brasil entre 2015 e 2019. Revista Ártemis, v. 38, n. 1, p. 46-66, 2024. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2ajreq5n . Acesso em: 13 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/2ajreq5n - BARROSO, João. Cultura, cultura escolar, cultura de escola 1. ed. São Paulo: UNESP/UNIVESP, 2012.
-
BARROSO, Ramon; SILVA, Lana. Gênero e sexualidade na educação brasileira em tempos de Movimento Escola Sem Partido. Revista Diversidade e Educação, v. 8, n. 1, p. 427-451, jan./jun. 2020. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2apt9ywz . Acesso em: 13 mar.25.
» https://tinyurl.com/2apt9ywz -
BIROLI, Flávia; TATAGIBA, Luciana; QUINTELA, Débora. Reações à igualdade de gênero e ocupação do Estado no governo Bolsonaro (2019-2022). Revista Opinião Pública, Campinas, v. 30, 2024, p. 1-32. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/22bacjmg . Acesso em: 13 mar.25.
» https://tinyurl.com/22bacjmg -
BRANDÃO, Elaine; LOPES, Rebecca. “Não é competência do professor ser sexólogo”. Civitas, v. 18, n. 1, p. 100-123, jan.-abr. 2018. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/26lw7pmb . Acesso em: 13 mar.25.
» https://tinyurl.com/26lw7pmb -
BRASIL. Base Nacional Comum Curricular (BNCC) Brasília: CNE, s.d. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/vlkw4tl Acesso em: 23 set.24.
» https://tinyurl.com/vlkw4tl -
BRASIL. Constituição da República Federativa do Brasil de 1988. Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, DF, 1988. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/onpt6dq . Acesso em: 13 set. 2024.
» https://tinyurl.com/onpt6dq -
BRASIL. Lei n. 9.394, de 20 de dezembro de 1996. Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, 1996. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2lx8cmmh Acesso em: 14 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/2lx8cmmh -
BRASIL. Parâmetros Curriculares Nacionais (1ª a 4ª Série) Brasília: MEC/SEF, 1997. 10 volumes. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/r5jm2s7 . Acesso em: 14 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/r5jm2s7 -
BRASIL. Parâmetros Curriculares Nacionais Brasília: MEC/SEF, 1998. 10 volumes. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2czvb9w3 . Acesso em: 14 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/2czvb9w3 -
BRASIL. Parâmetros Curriculares Nacionais para o Ensino Médio (PCNEM) Brasília: MEC, 2000. 8 volumes. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/26apvs2e . Acesso em: 20 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/26apvs2e -
BRASIL. Resolução nº 5, de 17 de dezembro de 2009. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/27x854m6 . Acesso em: 20 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/27x854m6 -
BRASIL. Resolução nº 7, de 14 de dezembro de 2010. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/rh3uo45 . Acesso em: 20 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/rh3uo45 -
BRASIL. Resolução nº 2, de 30 de janeiro de 2012. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/y6l3v5eo . Acesso em: 20 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/y6l3v5eo -
BRASIL. Diretrizes Curriculares Nacionais Brasília: CNE/MEC; Secadi/MEC, 2013. 480p. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/233uwfq7 . Acesso em: 20 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/233uwfq7 -
BRASIL. Base Nacional Comum Curricular Brasília: MEC, 2017a. 472p. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/6p9h3vzk Acesso em: 14 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/6p9h3vzk -
BRASIL. Minuta de parecer e projeto de resolução que trata da BNCC, de 7 de dezembro de 2017b. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/24g4mgvn . Acesso em: 23 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/24g4mgvn -
BRASIL. Resolução CNE/CP nº 2, de 22 de dezembro de 2017c. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/y8dy7ufd . Acesso em: 23 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/y8dy7ufd -
BRASIL. Base Nacional Comum Curricular Brasília: MEC, 2018. 600p. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/v6dzun5 . Acesso em: 23 mar. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/v6dzun5 -
CARDOSO, Frederico. O que é uma aula? Cadernos de Pesquisa, São Luís, v. 27, n. 01, p. 229-57, jan./mar. 2020. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/yser6can Acesso em: 17 set. 2025.
» https://tinyurl.com/yser6can -
CARDOSO, Frederico; AMORIM, Marina Alves; SULZ, Juliana. “Crise da masculinidade”. Revista FAEEBA: Educação e Contemporaneidade, v. 32, n. 72 (n. espec.), p. 97-115, out./dez. 2023. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/226xl8j4 . Acesso em: 13 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/226xl8j4 -
CARREIRA, Denise. A execução orçamentária das políticas de diversidade nos governos Lula e Dilma. Revista Brasileira de Educação, v. 24, e240010, 25 abr. 2019. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2dcu94d3 . Acesso em 17 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/2dcu94d3 - CARVALHO, Celso. O discurso de despolitização como meio de politização da educação. In: BATISTA, Eraldo; ORSO, Paulino; LUCENA, Carlos (Org.). Escola sem partido ou a escola da mordaça e do partido único a serviço do capital Uberlândia: Navegando Publicações, 2019. p. 49-68.
-
CORRÊA, Sonia; PATERNOTTE, David; KUHAR, Roman. The globalisation of anti-gender campaigns. IPS Journal, 31 maio de 2018. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/25798weh . Acesso em: 13 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/25798weh -
EDITORIAL: O Decênio 1975-1985 das Nações Unidas para a Mulher. Revista Brasileira de Enfermagem, v. 38, n. 1, p. 5–6, jan. 1985. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2yfhdtre . Acesso em: 13 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/2yfhdtre - FRIGOTTO, Gaudêncio. Prefácio. In: BATISTA, Eraldo; ORSO, Paulino; LUCENA, Carlos (Org.). Escola sem partido ou a escola da mordaça e do partido único a serviço do capital Uberlândia: Navegando Publicações, 2019. p. 1-10.
-
JAKIMIU, Vanessa. Extinção da SECADI. Revista de Estudos em Educação e Diversidade, v. 2, n. 3, p. 115-137, jan./mar. 2021. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/yufx5rbx Acesso em: 17 set. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/yufx5rbx -
LÁZARO, André Luiz. A Diversidade, a Diferença e a Experiência da Secad. Revista Retratos da Escola, v. 7, n. 13, p. 265-2013. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/25c4oe4l Acesso em: 17 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/25c4oe4l -
LOBATO, Ana Laura; REZENDE, Marcela; FONTOURA, Natália. Igualdade de Gênero. In: IPEA. Políticas Sociais: acompanhamento e análise Brasília: Ipea, 2018. p. i-xxviii. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2653hfht . Acesso em: 13 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/2653hfht -
MIGUEL, Luís Felipe. A criminalização do pensamento crítico. Blog Boitempo São Paulo: Boitempo, 2015. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/28b7hexr . Acesso em: 13 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/28b7hexr -
MIGUEL, Luís Felipe. Da “doutrinação marxista” à "ideologia de gênero". Revista Direito e Práxis, Rio de Janeiro, v. 7, n. 15, p. 590-621, 2016. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2ydcub4l . Acesso em: 13 mar.25.
» https://tinyurl.com/2ydcub4l - MOREIRA, Antônio Flávio (Org.). Currículo Campinas: Papirus, 1997.
-
ONU. Organização das Nações Unidas. Declaração e Plataforma de Ação da IV Conferência Mundial sobre a Mulher Pequim: ONU, 1995. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/y576vw56 . Acesso em: 13 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/y576vw56 -
PATERNOTTE, David; KUHAR, Roman. Disentangling and locating the “global right”. Politics and Governance, v. 6, n. 3, 2018. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2a3l27op . Acesso em: 13 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/2a3l27op - POPKEWITZ, Thomas; PEREYRA, Miguel. Práticas de reforma na formação de professores em oito países. In: NÓVOA, António; POPKEWITZ, Thomas S. (Org.). Reformas Educativas e Formação de Professores Lisboa: Educa, 1992. p. 11-40.
-
RIBEIRO, Renato Janine. A democracia vai crescer ou diminuir? In: VASCONCELOS, Álvaro (Org.). Brasil nas ondas do mundo Campina Grande/ PB; Coimbra: Editora da UFCG; Editora da Universidade de Coimbra, 2017. p. 53-69. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/2ysffvo2 . Acesso em: 13 set. 24.
» https://tinyurl.com/2ysffvo2 -
RIBEIRO, William; AZEVEDO-LOPES, Ronielle de. Conhecimento-investimento e Currículo Meritocrático. Currículo Sem Fronteiras, v. 17, n. 3, p. 659-677, set./dez. 2017. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/25bxdyeg . Acesso em: 13 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/25bxdyeg - SACRISTÁN, José. O Currículo 3. reimp. Trad. Ernani F. da Fonseca Rosa. Porto Alegre: Artmed, 2008.
-
SANTOS, Marina; MIESSE, Maria Carolina; CARVALHO, Fabiana. As questões de gênero e sexualidade e o Movimento Escola Sem Partido. Revista Diversidade e Educação, v. 9, n. Especial, p. 509-531, 2021. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/26oye4pz . Acesso em: 13 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/26oye4pz - SILVEIRA, Zuleide. Onda conservadora. In: BATISTA, Eraldo; ORSO, Paulino; LUCENA, Carlos (org.). Escola sem partido ou a escola da mordaça e do partido único a serviço do capital Uberlândia: Navegando Publicações, 2019. p. 17-48.
-
TAFFAREL, Celi; CARVALHO, Marize. A extinção da SECADI. Cadernos GPOSSHE On-line, Fortaleza, v. 2, n. 1, 2019. Disponível em: https://tinyurl.com/262n5o2u . Acesso em: 13 mar. 25.
» https://tinyurl.com/262n5o2u
