The effects of the changes in sample concentration on the NMR chemical shifts and on the selective and non-selective spin-lattice relaxation rates (R1S and R1NS) of the three isomers of nitrobenzaldeyde guanyl hydrazone (NBGH) pure and with bovine serum albumin (BSA) were measured in solution. The results wereused to determine the correlation times (tauc), showing that the degree of intermolecular drug-drug association varies with the nitro group position on the ring and that this degree of association interferes with the interaction of these drugs with BSA. The results suggest that the degree of drug-drug and drug-BSA association are related to the in vitro anti-Trypanosoma cruzi activity of these compounds.
intermolecular interactions; relaxation rates; correlation times; guanyl hydrazones
Os efeitos da variação da concentração da amostra nos valores de deslocamento químico e nas velocidades de relaxação spin-rede seletiva (R1S) enão seletiva (R1NS) foram medidos em solução para os três isômeros das guanil hidrazonas derivadas do nitrobenzaldeído (NBGH) puros e com a albumina do sorobovino (BSA). Os resultados foram usados para determinar o tempo de correlação (tauc), mostrando que o grau de interação intermolecular droga-droga varia com a posição do grupo nitro no anel aromático e que este grau de associação interfere na interação destas drogas com a BSA. Os resultados sugerem que o grau de interação droga-droga e droga-BSA estão relacionados com a atividade in vitro destas drogas contra o Trypanosoma cruzi.
Determination of Correlation Times from Selective and Non-Selective Spin-Lattice Relaxation Rates and their Use in Drug-Drug and Drug-Albumin Interaction Studies
Luzineide Wanderley Tinoco, and José Daniel Figueroa-Villar* * e-mail: email@example.com
Departamento de Química do Instituto Militar de Engenharia,
Praça General Tibúrcio, 80 - Urca, Rio de Janeiro - RJ, Brazil
Os efeitos da variação da concentração da amostra nos valores de deslocamento químico e nas velocidades de relaxação spin-rede seletiva (R1S) enão seletiva (R1NS) foram medidos em solução para os três isômeros das guanil hidrazonas derivadas do nitrobenzaldeído (NBGH) puros e com a albumina do sorobovino (BSA). Os resultados foram usados para determinar o tempo de correlação (tc), mostrando que o grau de interaçãointermolecular droga-droga varia com a posição do grupo nitro no anel aromático e que este grau de associação interfere na interação destas drogas com a BSA. Os resultados sugerem que o grau de interação droga-droga e droga-BSA estão relacionados com a atividade in vitro destas drogas contra o Trypanosoma cruzi.
The effects of the changes in sample concentration on the NMR chemical shifts and on the selective and non-selective spin-lattice relaxation rates (R1S and R1NS) of the three isomers of nitrobenzaldeyde guanyl hydrazone (NBGH) pure and with bovine serum albumin (BSA) were measured in solution. The results wereused to determine the correlation times (tc), showing that the degree of intermolecular drug-drug association varies with thenitro group position on the ring and that this degree of association interferes with the interaction of these drugs with BSA. The results suggest that the degree of drug-drug and drug-BSA association are related to the in vitro anti-Trypanosoma cruzi activity of these compounds.
Keywords: intermolecular interactions, relaxation rates, correlation times, guanyl hydrazones
Aromatic guanyl hydrazones are a new family of cationic compounds which we have shown to be potential candidates for the chemotherapy of Chagas disease1. This disease is third in the ranking of importance for the World Health Organization, and is responsible for about 45.000 deaths per year in South America. The transfusion of blood contaminated with T. cruzi is the second most important way of infection of this disease in endemic areas, and the only way of contagion in countries outside the endemic zone2,3. The probability of receiving a blood transfusion with blood contaminated with this protozoon can be as high as 2.19% in certain regions of South America4. Some guanyl hydrazones are able to eliminate the trypomastigote forms of Trypanosoma cruzi from contaminated blood in concentrations as low as 17 mM, making them good candidates for the prophylaxis of blood in blood banks in endemic areas1. The mechanism of action of these cationic antibiotics is still unknown, but it is believed that it may be related to their capacity to interact with either the cellular membrane or the DNA of the parasite5. In any case, it is clear that this interaction occurs through the cationic side chain. In order to determine if the guanyl hydrazones can be safely used in blood prophylaxis it necessary, among other studies, to determine the type and degree of their interaction with plasmatic proteins.
In our previous studies we showed, using non-selective T1 studies, that the guanyl hydrazones derived from nitrobenzaldeyde (NBGH - Fig. 1) interact with bovine serum albumin (BSA) with different affinities6. These compounds showed different activity depending on the isomer, for 2-nitrobenzaldehyde (2NBGH, ID50 87.5 mM), 3-nitrobenzaldehyde (3NBGH, ID50 182.6 mM) and 4-nitrobenzaldehyde (4NBGH, ID50 55.9 mM)1. Our initial hypothesis to explain this difference in activity was based on the possible different degrees of drug-drug association, which could affect the availability of the cationic side chain of the drug for interaction with the parasite. This hypothesis was also supported by molecular modeling studies6. In this work, selective and non selective spin-lattice relaxation rates measurements were used to study the intermolecular interactions between the NBGH and BSA and the importance of the self-association of the nitroguanyl hydrazones on their interaction with BSA and their in vitro activity.
The measurement of selective and non selective spin-lattice relaxation rates was suggested by Freeman et al to ascertain whether the relaxation mechanism is dipolar or other, such as chemical shift anisotropy or spin rotation7. The use of mono-, bi- and non selective spin-lattice relaxation rates have been applied to conformational studies of amino acids and peptides and in studies of interactions between small molecules with macromolecules8-14.
To study systems were there is fast conversion between the bound and free states, as is usually the case for the drug-macromolecule complexes, it have been demonstrated that selective spin-lattice relaxation rates (R1S) are more sensitive to the process than the non selective spin-lattice relaxation rates (R1NS)8-14.
In a multi-spin system the relaxation rate can be approximated by a sum of pairwise 1H-1H dipolar interactions, yielding an initial rate constant for the recovery of the Iz magnetization given by Eq. 112-15.
In this equation rijis the direct relaxation rate and sijis the cross relaxation term for a ij proton pair.
Selective excitation inverts only the magnetization of spin i while not perturbing all other spins (j ¹ i). Consequently, the cross-relaxation rates do not contribute to the initial recovery constant, which is now given by Eq. 212-15:
Some researchers have shown that R1 can be measured in the initial rate approximation with the 180° - t - 90° sequence provided that the 180° pulse is selective and that, in the extreme narrowing limit (wtc << 1 - were w is the Larmor frequency and tc is the correlation time) the R1NS / R1S ratio is 1.512-15.
The three nitroguanyl hydrazones used in this work were prepared by treatment of the respective nitrobenzaldehydes with aminoguanidine hydrochloride in refluxing ethanol containing a catalytic amount of HCl1. The solutions of the pure nitroguanyl hydrazones (13 mM, 25 mM, 50 mM and 75 mM) were prepared in acetate buffer 0.1 M in D2O with pD 4.75 at 20 °C. The solutions for the interaction studies were prepared by dissolving the respective NBGH until the desired concentration (13 mM, 25 mM, 50 mM and 75 mM) in a 7.25 x 10-5 M stock solution of BSA (98% - Aldrich Chemical Company). NMR measurements were carried out on a Varian Unity -300 (300 MHz) spectrometer at 37.0 ± 0.1 °C. Spin-lattice relaxation rates were measured with the inversion-recovery pulse sequence with the first relaxation delay varying from 12.0 s to 32.0 s, depending on the sample concentration, and the second delay from 12.5 ms to 32.0 s. Nine points were used for each measurement. For non selective measurements the 90° 1H pulse length was 16 ms with 58 dB transmitter power (attenuation of 5dB). For the selective experiments, the selective inversion pulse was achieved by replacement of the hard 180° pulse of the inversion-recovery sequence by a DANTE16 train consisting of 300 identical hard pulses of the same nutation angle (0.6°) separated by 0.0001 ms delays with the transmitter power adjusted to 30 dB (28 dB attenuation in relation to the non-selective pulse) to give a selective 180° 1H pulse length of 702.4 ms. All the reported relaxation rate results are the average of at the least three measurements. In all cases, the relative uncertainty was less than 20%, with most results having uncertainties lower than 10%. The absolute uncertainty of the R1NS / R1S ratios was calculated according to standard procedures17, and was always equal to or less than ± 0.1.
Results and Discussion
In order to determine the tendency to self association of the pure drugs, the selective and non-selective relaxation rates were measured in solutions with different concentrations for the three isomers. These data were then used to estimate the correlation times associated using Fig. 2, which can be plotted form Eqs. 1 and 2 assuming a constant distance for the ij dipolar interaction14. The results are summarized in Tables 1, 2 and 3.
The analysis of selective and non-selective relaxation rates values for the 13 mM and 25 mM solutions of pure 2NBGH (Table 1) show that the R1NS / R1S ratio for this compound is around 1.3. This value, for which wtc is very close to 1, is expected when the mechanism for relaxation is other than pure dipolar, and the molecule is outside the extreme narrowing region (wtc << 1), that is, its hydrogens present intermediate tc values, which are typical of medium size molecules (see Fig. 2). For the 50 and 75 mM samples, the values of the R1NS / R1S ratio are approximately 1.0. In this case, it is possible to say that the molecule is near the wtc@ 1 (wtc is slightly above 1) and that its hydrogens also present intermediate correlation time values, which are more elevated than those observed for the 13 mM and 25 mM concentrations. Since 2NBGH is a small molecule, these results could only be explained if there is drug-drug intermolecular association, with this interaction being favored at higher concentrations.
On the other hand, the results for 3NBGH, which are summarized in Table 2, show values for the R1NS / R1Sratio around 1.0 for the 13 and 25 mM solutions. According with Fig. 2, it is observed that this region corresponds to values of wtc of approximately 1, that is, the 3NBGH hydrogens present intermediate tc values, similar to the ones observed for the 50 mM and 75 mM solutions of 2NBGH. This fact suggests that, for 3NBGH, it would be possible to consider the existence of drug-drug intermolecular interactions even at lower 3NBGH concentrations. Interestingly, for concentrations above 25 mM it is observed that the values of the R1NS / R1S ratio are around 1.2, thus, according to Fig. 2 the values of tc would be smaller than for the 13 and 25 mM solutions. This result suggests that at higher concentrations the molecules of 3NBGH are more mobile than at lower concentrations. This is somehow surprising, as at higher concentrations it would be expected that the increase in solution viscosity and the greater possibility of drug-drug interaction should lead to greater values for the correlation time. This behavior of the 3NBGH is not well understood yet, but one feasible explanation for this phenomenon would be the possibility of shorter half-lives for the molecular aggregates of 3NBGH at higher concentrations. In fact, it seems plausible that at higher concentrations the greater number of drug-drug collisions would decrease the half-life of the molecular aggregates, as compared with the dilute solutions. This might be the case for systems where the drug-drug interaction is much stronger that the solvent-drug interaction, that is, for systems where it would be necessary the collision with a solute molecule to disrupt the aggregate.
For 4NBGH the average value of the R1NS / R1S ratio is around 1.3 for all the concentrations (see Table 3). This value corresponds to the wtc @ 1 region (Fig. 2) and suggests the occurrence of intermolecular drug-drug interactions. In any case, the results suggest that the affinity of 4NBGH for drug-drug intermolecular interaction is the lowest of the three isomers, in agreement with the highest overall R1NS / R1S ratio. It is also interesting to notice that, for this system, there are not detectable effects of the changes in concentration on the correlation time values.
In general, it can be observed that the three isomers differ greatly on their relaxation behavior at higher concentrations. Since this behavior is somehow anomalous, it seems more appropriate to compare the results of the three compounds at the lowest studied concentration, where the solution behavior is closer to ideality and the differences in the tendency to form molecular aggregates are more likely to be observed. The average R1NS / R1S ratio for all the hydrogens of each molecule in the 13 mM solutions (see Tables 1, 2 and 3) are 1.3, 0.8 and 1.3 for 2NBGH, 3NBGH and 4NBGH, respectively. From these results it is clear that 3NBGH displays the highest tendency to self aggregation (tc= 1.1 x 10-9), while the other two isomers show a lower potential for drug-drug interaction (tc = 3.7 x 10-10), where the tc values were calculated by interpolation of the plot shown in Fig. 2.
If the values of the R1NS / R1S ratio, which are used for the determination of the correlation times for the three isomers, are calculated as an average of the R1NS / R1S ratio of all the individual hydrogens at the four concentrations used (2NBGH = 1.2, 3NBGH = 1.1 and 4NBGH = 1.3), the results obtained for tc for the NBGH are 4.8 x 10-10 s, 5.3 x 10-10 s and 3.7 x 10-10 s for 2NBGH, 3NBGH and 4NBGH respectively. Since the correlation time is inversely proportional to the degree of molecular mobility, that is the smaller values of tc correspond to higher molecular mobility, it is possible to say that the intensity of drug-drug intermolecular interaction for the nitro guanyl hydrazones decrease in the order 3NBGH > 2NBGH > 4NBGH. This result, which shows the lowest molecular mobility or higher tendency for drug-drug interaction for 3NBGH, is in agreement with the results obtained with the relaxation measurements at the lowest concentration (13 mM). However, in this case, it seems that the ortho and para isomers do not display a similar behavior, with 4NBGH being the least likely to form molecular aggregates.
In the study of drug-BSA intermolecular interaction the analysis of selective and non-selective relaxation rates was carried out as for the pure drugs. The values of the R1NS / R1S ratio were evaluated for each NBGH isomer in 13 mM, 25 mM, 50 mM and 75 mM solutions in the presence of BSA (7.25 x 10-5 M). The results are shown in Tables 4, 5 and 6.
Initially, the analysis was carried out using only the average R1NS / R1S ratio for all the isomers at the 13 mM solutions. Then, the same procedure was carried out using the overall average values for all the hydrogens at all the different concentrations, as it was done for the pure drugs. For each case, the correlation times were determined from Fig. 2, and the results are summarized in Table 7.
For the 13 mM 2NBGH solution, the average value of the relaxation rate ratio in the presence of BSA is 0.6, which indicates that tc corresponds to 1.7 x 10-9 s. This tc value is significantly longer than the tcvalue for the pure drug (3.7 x 10-10 s). In fact it is possible to say that the molecule now presents long correlation times values, and that it is on the wtc >> 1 region. This result strongly suggests that 2NBGH is forming a complex with BSA. It is well known that BSA presents a correlation time of 3,8 x 10-8 s and that the small molecules present values of tc in the range of 10-10 s to 10-12 s.18 Clearly, because of the association with BSA, 2NBGH is showing a tc value proximal to the tc value of BSA. An identical conclusion is reached if the analysis is carried out using the overall average values of the R1NS / R1S ratio for 2NBGH. In this case, the data from Tables 4 and 7 show that the average of the values of R1NS / R1S ratio is 0.6 for the 13 mM and 25 mM 2NBGH solutions, and 0.1 for the 50 mM and 75 mM 2NBGH solutions. Both results, when evaluated on the plot of Fig. 2, show that the 2NBGH molecules in the presence of BSA are on the wtc >> 1 region, which is indicative of complex formation with BSA. These results also show that the increase in 2NBGH concentration facilitates the drug-BSA intermolecular interaction.
The results for 3NBGH in the presence of BSA, are summarized in Table 5. The analysis of the data obtained with the 13 mM solution affords an average value for the R1NS / R1Sratio of 0.7, which corresponds to tc = 1.4 x 10-9 s, which is slightly greater than tc for the pure drug (1.1 x 10-9 s). This value is indicative of a weaker drug-BSA interaction for 3NBGH. When the analysis is carried out for all the data, it is observed that the average R1NS / R1Sratio is 0.7 for all the concentrations. The value of the average overall R1NS/R1Sratio for the pure 3NBGH solutions is 1.1 (tc = 5.3 x 10-10), indicating that the increase in tc due to the presence of BSA for 3NBGH (0.9 x 10-9 s)is only about half of what it was observed for 2NBGH (2.0 x 10-9 s). With these results it is possible to conclude that 3NBGH interacts with BSA, but with lower affinity than 2NBGH.
The values of the R1NS/R1Sratio for 4NBGH with BSA are summarized in Table 6. It is possible to observe that the average ratio is 0.5 for the 13 to 50 mM solutions and 0.3 for the 75 mM solution. This values correspond to the wtc >> 1 region in Fig. 2. The average R1NS / R1Sratio values for the 13 mM solution, as well as for all other solutions is 0.5, which is significantly smaller than the value for the pure drug (1.3). The difference between the correlation time for pure 4NBGH (3.7 x x10-10 s) and the correlation time for the drug with BSA (2.3 x 10-9 s) is 1.9 x 10-9 s, showing that 4NBGH interacts with BSA with a similar affinity as 2NBGH.
Since the correlation time presents an inverse correlation with the degree of molecular mobility, it is possible to say that the intensity of drug-BSA intermolecular interaction for the nitro guanyl hydrazones decrease in the order 2NBGH > 4NBGH >> 3NBGH, suggesting that the 2NBGH have, for a short margin over 4NBGH, the greater affinity for BSA. However, if we calculate the tc (PURE)/ tc(BSA) ratio for each drug (Table 7), thus considering the effect of drug-drug intermolecular interaction, it can be observed that the lower tc(PURE)/ tc(BSA) ratio corresponds to 4NBGH, indicating that this drug has the lowest propensity for drug-drug interaction and the highest tendency for drug-BSA interaction. In this case, it is possible to say that the degree of drug-BSA intermolecular interactions decrease in the order 4NBGH > 2NBGH >> 3NBGH. Interestingly, this last result suggests that there is a correlation between the tcPURE/tcBSA ratio and the in vitro ID50 values, which follow the order 4NBGH > 2NBGH > 3NBGH.
Selective T1 measurements are very sensitive and convenient for the investigation of the binding of small molecules to macromolecules, allowing the calculation of the correlation times. Our results indicate that all the NBGH are able to establish intermolecular interactions with BSA, and that of the three isomers 4NBGH and 2NBGH present the highest affinity for this protein, with 4NBGH being the most affine. The meta isomer, 3NBGH, on the other hand is the drug with the highest tendency to drug-drug association, and the less affine to BSA. The analysis of the values of tcPURE/tcBSA ratio shows that as the self association tendency of the drugs increases, the tendency for drug-BSA association and the in vitro activity decreases. These results strongly favor the hypothesis that the mechanism of interaction of these compounds with T. cruzi is of electrostatic nature, and that it occurs through the guanidinium moiety. In this way, the different tendencies for self association in solution, which disfavors the interaction of the drugs with the parasite, would explain the in vitro activity differences between the three isomers.
We gratefully acknowledge the financial support given by PADCT/CNPq, the scholarship awarded by CNPq (J.D. Figueroa-Villar) and studentship awarded by CAPES (L.W. Tinoco).
Received: March 29, 1999
- 1.Messeder, J.C.; Tinoco, L.W.; Figueroa-Villar, J.D.; Souza, E.M.; Santa Rita, R.; De Castro, S.L. Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett 1995, 5, 24, 3079.
- 2.Chmunis, G. A. Transfusion 1991, 31, 547.
- 3.Hamerschlak, N.; Pasternak, J.; Amato Neto, V.; Carvalho, M.B.; Guerra, C.S.; Coscina, A.L. Rev. Soc. Bras. Med. Trop. 1997, 30, 205.
- 4.Center for Disease Control (CDC). Emerging Infectious Diseases 1998, 4, 1, 5.
- 5.Santos Filho, O.A.; Figueroa-Villar, J.D. Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 1997, 7, 13, 1797.
- 6.Tinoco, L.W.; Ph.D. Thesis 1998, Instituto Militar de Engenharia, RJ, Brazil.
- 7.Freeman, R. ; Hill, H.D.W.; Tomlinson, B.L.; Hall, L.D. J. Chem. Phys 1974, 61, 466.
- 8.Niccolai, N.; Miles, M.P.L.; Hehir, S.P.; Gibbons, W.A. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1978, 100, 20, 6528.
- 9.Gaggelli, E.; Gaggelli, N.; Maccotta, A.; Valensin, G. J. Magn. Reson. 1994, B 104, 9.
- 10.Gaggelli, E.; Gaggelli, N.; Maccotta, A.; Valensin, G. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 1994, 308, 1, 48.
- 11.Gaggelli, E.; Valensin, G.; Kushinir, T.; Navon, G. Magn. Reson. Chem 1992, 30, 61.
- 12.Camparini, B.; Gaggelli, E.; Marchettini, N.; Valensin, G. Biophys. J. 1985, 48, 247.
- 13.Valensin, G.; Kushinir, T.; Navon, G. J. Magn. Reson. 1982, 23.
- 14.Bonechi, C.; Donati, A.; Picchi, M.P.; Rossi, C.; Tiezzi, E. Colloids and Surfaces: A 1996, 115, 89.
- 15.Hall, L.D.; Hill, H.D.W. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1976, 98, 5, 1269.
- 16.Bodenhausen, G.; Freeman, R.; Morris, G.A. J. Magn. Reson 1976, 23, 171.
- 17.Harris, C.D. Quantitative Chemical Analysis; W. H. Freeman and Company; New York, 1996.
- 18.Wallach, D. J. Chem. Phys. 1967, 47, 5258.
Publication in this collection
21 June 2001
Date of issue
29 Mar 1999