Open-access Scope and effectiveness of public policies on patient safety in hospital institutions: an integrative review

Alcance y eficacia de las políticas públicas sobre seguridad del paciente en entornos hospitalarios: una revisión integradora

ABSTRACT

Objective:  to analyze scientific publications on the scope and effectiveness of public policies aimed at patient safety currently in place in hospital settings, with a focus on incident prevention.

Methods:  an integrative review was conducted in the Public MEDLINE and Latin American and Caribbean Health Sciences Literature databases to answer the following question: what is the scope and effectiveness of patient safety policies currently implemented in hospital settings for incident prevention? A total of 661 articles were identified, and after analysis, 26 were selected.

Results:  patient safety policies show variation in scope and effectiveness, influenced by organizational culture, leadership, and professional engagement. Effectiveness depends on infrastructure, adherence to protocols, and continuing education. Challenges persist, such as policy fragmentation and limited resources.

Final considerations:  implementation faces challenges, mainly highlighting the lack of adequate professional training.

Descriptors:
Hospitals; Health Policy; Public Health; Patient Safety, Health Policy; Planning and Management.

RESUMO

Objetivo:  analisar as publicações científicas sobre o alcance e a efetividade das políticas públicas direcionadas à segurança do paciente em vigor nos ambientes hospitalares, com foco na prevenção de incidentes.

Métodos:  realizou-se revisão integrativa nas bases de dados Public MEDLINE e Literatura Latino-Americana e do Caribe em Ciências da Saúde para responder à seguinte pergunta: qual é o alcance e a efetividade das políticas direcionadas à segurança do paciente em vigor nos ambientes hospitalares para a prevenção de incidentes? Foram encontrados 661 artigos e, após análise, 26 foram selecionados.

Resultados:  as políticas de segurança do paciente apresentam variação em alcance e efetividade, influenciadas pela cultura organizacional, pela liderança e pelo envolvimento dos profissionais. A efetividade depende de infraestrutura, adesão a protocolos e educação contínua. Desafios persistem, como fragmentação das políticas e recursos limitados.

Considerações finais:  a implementação enfrenta desafios, destacando-se, principalmente, a falta de treinamento adequado dos profissionais.

Descritores:
Hospitais; Política de Saúde; Saúde Pública; Segurança do Paciente; Políticas; Planejamento e Administração em Saúde.

RESUMEN

Objetivo:  analizar las publicaciones científicas sobre el alcance y la eficacia de las políticas públicas destinadas a la seguridad del paciente en entornos hospitalarios, centrándose en la prevención de incidentes.

Métodos:  se realizó una revisión integradora en las bases de datos Public MEDLINE y Literatura Latinoamericana y Caribeña en Ciencias de la Salud para responder a la siguiente pregunta: ¿cuál es el alcance y la efectividad de las políticas de seguridad del paciente implementadas en entornos hospitalarios para la prevención de incidentes? Se encontraron 661 artículos y, tras el análisis, se seleccionaron 26.

Resultados:  las políticas de seguridad del paciente varían en alcance y eficacia, influenciadas por la cultura organizacional, el liderazgo y la participación del personal. La eficacia depende de la infraestructura, el cumplimiento de los protocolos y la formación continua. Persisten desafíos como la fragmentación de las políticas y la escasez de recursos.

Consideraciones finales:  la implementación enfrenta desafíos, sobre todo la falta de capacitación adecuada para los profesionales.

Descriptores:
Hospitales; Política de Salud; Salud Pública; Seguridad del Paciente; Políticas; Planificación y Administración en Salud.

INTRODUCTION

The fundamental principle “Primum non nocere”, introduced by Hippocrates (460-370 BC), reflects early awareness regarding the possibility of harm resulting from medical practice. Throughout history, several leaders, such as Florence Nightingale, through the development of environmental theory; Ignaz Semmelweis, who introduced hand hygiene in healthcare services; and Avedis Donabedian, responsible for systematizing the pillars of quality, contributed to improving the quality of healthcare. However, the topic “patient safety” was not explicitly addressed at that time and only gained prominence in 1999 with the report “To Err is Human” from the Institute of Medicine (IOM), which revealed a high incidence of adverse events (AEs) in the United States, exceeding mortality associated with HIV, breast cancer, and motor vehicle accidents combined. Patient safety emerged as one of the pillars among the six attributes of quality of care - efficacy, efficiency, effectiveness, optimization, acceptability, legitimacy, and equity - gaining global relevance among patients, families, managers, and healthcare professionals, all seeking safe care(1,2).

Incidents related to healthcare, especially AEs resulting in patient harm, represent an important cause of morbidity and mortality in health systems. In response to this concern, the World Health Organization (WHO) established the World Alliance for Patient Safety, aiming to unify concepts and definitions regarding patient safety and propose measures to mitigate risks and reduce AEs(3).

In Brazil, the initiatives of the National Patient Safety Program (PNSP - Programa Nacional de Segurança do Paciente), created in April 2013 through Ordinance 529(4), are aligned with the objectives of the World Alliance and complement other health policies, aiming to strengthen care provided within healthcare networks. An example is Collegiate Board Resolution 36/2013 from the Brazilian Health Regulatory Agency (ANVISA - Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária)(5), which establishes fundamental guidelines to ensure patient safety in healthcare services. This includes measures such as mandatory implementation of Patient Safety Centers (NSPs - Núcleos de Segurança do Paciente) in healthcare services, AE reporting, and development of the Patient Safety Plan(3), in addition to Ordinance 2,095/2013, which approves Basic Patient Safety Protocols, such as pressure injury prevention and hand hygiene protocols(6).

Furthermore, WHO, in partnership with the Joint Commission International, established six international patient safety goals, adopted by the Ministry of Health as a reference for improving quality of care. These goals aim to: (1) correctly identify the patient; (2) improve effective communication; (3) improve safety in prescribing, using, and administering medications; (4) ensure correct-site, correct-procedure, and correct-patient surgeries; (5) perform effective hand hygiene; and (6) reduce the risk of falls and pressure injuries. The implementation of these goals serves as a practical guideline for healthcare services, guiding standardized actions aimed at preventing failures that may result in patient harm(7).

The need to ensure patient safety in hospital settings is a challenge, evidenced by the alarming increase in AE cases reported in Brazil over the years. According to the annual report on incidents/AEs related to healthcare released by ANVISA, between 2021 and 2024 there was a significant increase in the total number of AEs in healthcare services in Brazil, rising from 222,741 to 385,304. Even more concerning is the exponential increase in AEs occurring specifically in hospitals, which rose from approximately 210,000 in 2021 to 375,653 in 2024. These events include failures involving venous catheters, pressure injuries, patient identification failures, among others(8-11).

Although the numbers show an increase in the volume of notifications recorded in the national system, it is essential to recognize that such information does not directly represent the actual incidence of AEs in the country. National studies demonstrate that underreporting remains substantial, since several incidents internally documented by institutions are not recorded in official systems due to factors such as operational difficulties, platform instability, lack of professional knowledge regarding the reporting process, insufficient training, workload overload, and fear of accountability. In this regard, the growth in notifications over the years may be associated with the expansion of reporting culture and greater team engagement, and not necessarily with an increase in event occurrence. Therefore, the data should be interpreted cautiously, and it is necessary to complement them with methodologies capable of providing more accurate estimates regarding the actual magnitude of AEs in healthcare services(12).

The impact of public policies is evident, making an in-depth analysis of implemented initiatives essential in order to identify their contributions to the improvement or deterioration of patient safety, thereby guiding future strategies aimed at ensuring the protection and well-being of those seeking care. In Brazil, legislation includes instruments such as NSPs, care protocols, reporting systems, continuing professional education, patient and family participation, as well as audit and inspection mechanisms. However, promoting this culture still faces challenges, such as fear of consequences when reporting errors, lack of feedback from managers, and uncertainty regarding the effectiveness of reports in generating positive institutional changes(13,14).

This study becomes relevant in light of the significant increase in AEs within hospital institutions, making a more in-depth discussion on patient safety essential. Therefore, the importance of understanding how health policies may positively influence quality of care is highlighted. The analysis of these publications is not limited solely to individual nursing practice, but must also be considered within the context of institutional health policies. Nurses, as essential frontline care providers, play a key role in enabling and implementing these policies; however, for their performance to be effective, it is indispensable that they are supported by well-structured institutional guidelines and by an organizational culture committed to safety. Thus, critical analysis of these policies allows not only guidance for care planning and professional decision-making, but also supports institutional strategies for AE prevention, aiming at the continuous improvement of safety and quality of care provided.

OBJECTIVE

To analyze scientific publications on the scope and effectiveness of public policies aimed at patient safety currently implemented in hospital settings, with a focus on incident prevention.

METHODS

Ethical aspects

The study was conducted in accordance with national and international ethical guidelines. Ethical review and approval were waived because the research consisted of an integrative literature review, without direct involvement of human subjects or primary data collection. The analysis was based exclusively on previously published and publicly available articles, generating no risks to individuals and not requiring specific ethical consent.

The research protocol was registered in the Open Science Framework under DOI 10.17605/OSF.IO/P5DCS.

Study design

The study consists of an integrative literature review. This approach allows a comprehensive and interactive analysis of studies related to a specific topic, encompassing different types of research. The study was developed according to the six stages proposed by Souza et al.(15): 1. Identification of the topic and guiding question; 2. Establishment of inclusion and exclusion criteria; 3. Definition of the information to be extracted from the selected studies and their characterization; 4. Assessment of included studies; 5. Interpretation of results; and 6. Presentation of the review/knowledge synthesis(15,16).

Identification of the topic and guiding question

The methodology enables the synthesis of diverse knowledge to answer the guiding question, formulated using the acronyms P (Population), V (Variables), and O (Outcomes). This approach is essential to ensure methodological rigor and analytical focus in the integrative review, as it clearly defines the main elements of the study. By structuring the research question in this format, it was possible to accurately guide the search and selection of evidence, ensuring the inclusion only of studies directly related to the investigated topic. In the present review, the following elements were used: P (hospitals), V (patient safety policies), and O (incident prevention). The guiding question established was: what is the scope and effectiveness of patient safety policies currently implemented in hospital settings for incident prevention?

Establishment of inclusion and exclusion criteria

The search was limited to studies published in full-text and free-access formats, including articles and gray literature in Portuguese, English, and Spanish, without time restriction, aiming to capture a broader and more historical perspective. Studies addressing the impact of public health policies on patient safety in hospital settings were included, regardless of study design. Studies not directly related to the topic were excluded.

Study selection was conducted in May 2024 independently by two authors through consultations in the electronic databases Public MEDLINE (PubMed) and Latin American and Caribbean Health Sciences Literature (LILACS). The search strategy consisted of descriptors and their synonyms identified in the Health Sciences Descriptors and their English equivalents identified in the Medical Subject Headings, including “Health Policies”, “Patient Safety”, and “Hospitals”. The search strategies were adapted to each database according to their specificities, separated by the Boolean operators OR, to distinguish them, and AND, to associate them, as illustrated in Chart 1.

Chart 1
Search keys used in the databases

Several combinations of descriptors were tested, including the term “AE”; however, its inclusion reduced the sensitivity of the search and limited the retrieval of studies relevant to the review objective. Therefore, broader terms were chosen, as they showed better performance in identifying publications aligned with the review focus.

After the survey of scientific publications, the studies were organized in order to identify and exclude duplicates. Titles and abstracts were assessed according to the predefined inclusion criteria, excluding those duplicated across databases, not freely available, or outside the scope of the investigated topic. Both primary and secondary studies were included, as well as institutional documents related to the proposed topic.

Definition of information to be extracted from the selected studies and characterization

Relevant data were extracted from the selected studies into a Microsoft Excel® database to systematize the collected articles, using a standardized form based on the criteria established by Souza et al.(13), including information regarding study characteristics, such as journal, country, language, and year of publication, objectives, participants, interventions performed, main results, response to the guiding question, and conclusions relevant to the research question.

Assessment of included studies

The methodological assessment of included studies was conducted according to the hierarchical classification of levels of evidence proposed by Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt(17), which organizes study designs according to methodological strength and scientific rigor. In this hierarchy, level I studies correspond to systematic reviews or meta-analyses of randomized clinical trials; level II includes individual randomized clinical trials; level III refers to quasi-experimental studies; level IV encompasses cohort and case-control studies; level V includes systematic reviews of qualitative or descriptive research; level VI corresponds to qualitative, descriptive, or case series studies; and level VII comprises expert opinions and committee documents.

The adoption of this structure enabled a consistent assessment of the methodological robustness of the evidence present in the selected studies and their contribution to the integrative synthesis. Topic categorization was performed through thematic analysis, identifying patterns, similarities, divergences, or gaps among the selected studies for conducting the research discussion.

RESULTS

A total of 661 texts were identified, six in PubMed and 655 in LILACS, and after critical reading of titles and abstracts, 71 manuscripts were selected for full-text reading. After critical reading and considering methodological characteristics, thematic approach, and findings, the number of included studies was reduced to 26 articles in the final phase.

For presentation of the search and selection stages, the study selection flowchart adapted from the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses was used. Figure 1 describes the process performed for study identification, screening, eligibility, and inclusion according to the consulted databases.

Figure 1
Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses flowchart for study selection in the integrative review

The results were qualitatively synthesized, identifying the main publications that answered the study guiding question. After critical reading of the 71 articles and application of the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 26 comprised the final sample, 22 of which were found in the LILACS database and four in PubMed, considering their methodological characteristics, thematic approach, and findings.

The publications covered the period from 2008 to 2024, with emphasis on the year 2019, which presented five publications. The main origin of the selected publications consisted of articles originally published in English, corresponding to 53.84%. Publications in Portuguese represented 38.46%, while those in Spanish accounted for 7.69%. A summary of the selected articles is presented in Chart 2.

Chart 2
Distribution of publications according to author/year, title, country, methodological design, sample size, main results, and level of evidence

Concerning the level of evidence of the studies, one article with level I evidence was identified, none with level II, one with level III, nine with level IV, four with level V, three with level VI, and eight with level VII. These data indicate that most included studies presented observational, qualitative, or narrative review designs, such as descriptive, qualitative, cross-sectional cohort studies, or nonsystematic reviews, evidencing the predominance of methods with lower scientific robustness within the hierarchy of evidence.

DISCUSSION

Effectiveness, in the context of patient safety, refers not only to the implementation of protocols and practices, but also to their actual capacity to generate significant changes in care conditions, with measurable impact on reducing AEs. Therefore, it constitutes an impact assessment that considers both objective outcomes and qualitative and subjective transformations within the hospital environment(44,45). A greater number of publications was observed in 2019. This period was marked by the launch of the Global Patient Safety Challenge on Medication Safety in 2017(46) and the Global Patient Safety Action Plan in 2018(47), which mobilized researchers worldwide to publish evidence and experiences prior to their formal adoption in 2021. In 2019, the first World Patient Safety Day was also celebrated on September 17, established by WHO.

The critical aspects, best practices, and opportunities for improvement observed in health institutions regarding patient safety are discussed below.

Weaknesses in patient safety in health institutions

According to the obtained results, the patient safety culture in Latin American hospitals presents significant weaknesses. Although dimensions such as “organizational learning” and “teamwork within units” are positively perceived, other areas, such as “nonpunitive response to error” and “staffing”, receive less favorable assessments(38). The perception of a punitive environment, in which errors are associated with formal punishment, discourages open communication and contributes to AE underreporting. Therefore, the creation of a “blame-free” environment is essential to encourage open communication and error reporting(27). In Eastern Mediterranean hospitals, up to 18% of hospital admissions involved AEs, and 83% of these were preventable, according to WHO. The main cause was the lack of structured policies and a punitive culture, reinforcing the need for an environment based on trust and organizational learning(20).

These findings indicate that Latin American hospitals may have an underdeveloped safety culture. A South Korean study showed that, even with well-defined national policies, failures in organizational culture and workload overload hinder the application of safe practices in daily hospital routines. In Brazil, safety policies are still fragmented and concentrated in the South and Southeast regions, with greater presence of PNSP in competitive private services. A study conducted in three hospitals in Rio Grande do Norte, with different management models, demonstrated low adherence to safety practices even when guidelines were available, highlighting preventable risks and the need for structural and procedural improvements across all administrative spheres(22,23,28).

These findings suggest the need for training programs focused on communication, leadership, and teamwork, as well as health policies requiring annual safety culture assessments to identify and correct weaknesses. The studies emphasize the need for a more integrated and comprehensive approach to patient safety policies, highlighting the importance of continuous improvement strategies and equitable distribution of resources and initiatives(24,27,29,36).

Public policies and institutional patient safety culture

Patient safety policies vary significantly among countries and institutions. Studies highlight that, in Brazil, despite several initiatives, the lack of an institutionalized national quality policy represents a challenge. Hospital accreditation, promoted by the Brazilian Hospital Accreditation Manual and the National Accreditation Organization, is an important tool for quality assessment focused on patient safety, since hospitals with international accreditation tend to present a more robust patient safety culture. An international study also highlights that, despite advances in accreditation and protocols, implementation of safe practices remains uneven. Two decades after the To Err Is Human report, preventable events are still frequent, especially in contexts characterized by fragile organizational culture, low institutional accountability, and limited use of data for continuous learning(24,26,32).

In Europe, well-structured national policies are observed to be fundamental for articulating actions among the different levels of the health system, promoting better patient safety outcomes(21). Similarly, countries such as Lebanon and Jordan have also advanced in aspects such as quality, accreditation within national health plans, and investments in information systems. However, both in these countries and in Brazil, the absence of a clear and integrated national patient safety policy is still observed, resulting in fragmented legal measures and poorly defined responsibilities(25). In contrast, countries such as Chile demonstrate the importance of well-defined national policies, with multisectoral strategic plans integrating AE surveillance, knowledge management, and strengthening of institutional safety culture(18).

The creation of regulatory bodies is essential for patient safety, since they establish standards, guidelines, and requirements that ensure safe and high-quality care. However, implementation of these policies faces significant challenges, such as lack of leadership engagement and language barriers. In Brazil, a recent study showed that implementation of PNSP promoted advances in organizational structure and perception of safety culture. Nevertheless, difficulties remain in consolidating practices, especially in institutions with lower technical and managerial support, highlighting the need for institutional strengthening(37,43).

Results demonstrate that institutions in which hospital managers act as catalysts in knowledge creation promote multilevel interaction, i.e., they foster collaboration among different hierarchical levels and departments within the organization. In a health context, this multilevel interaction involves information exchange and coordination of efforts among senior management, middle managers, frontline professionals, and even patients. This integrated approach benefits clinical quality efforts by ensuring that patient safety policies are understood, implemented, and monitored effectively at all institutional levels. Hospital managers play a fundamental role in creating complementary enabling conditions by aligning national guidelines with frontline realities, establishing connecting roles, promoting shared understanding of quality, and implementing information tools(32,43).

Thus, it is understood that an organizational ethos focused on learning rather than blame transforms employees into agents of change in patient safety. Continuous training and education are essential to maintain a qualified workforce aware of patient safety issues. Practical and experiential learning opportunities are especially valuable in helping professionals understand the nature and diversity of patient safety problems. Administration and management should become more closely involved in activities related to patient safety, promoting a safe and motivating environment for professionals. The implementation of permanent education and continuous training programs is essential to improve the perception of safety climate and, consequently, the quality of care provided to patients(31,42).

Adverse events as indicators of the effectiveness of patient safety policies

Currently, hospitals face a greater number of AEs compared with other health institutions, including medication errors, incorrect diagnoses, and healthcare-associated infections (HAIs)(29,34). In a study conducted in large hospitals, the most frequently reported AEs were pressure injuries (88.9%), falls (77.8%), and medication errors (75%). This high incidence reinforces that, although risks are recognized, significant challenges still exist regarding prevention and full compliance with mandatory protocols(35).

However, most of these events are considered preventable and are related to quality of care and adherence to safe practices(32). A study conducted in 4,504 acute and emergency care hospitals in the United States indicated that, except for “failure to rescue” - defined as the inability to prevent death after a severe complication - patient safety indicators presented weak or even inverse correlations with other indicators, such as pressure injuries and HAIs. This raises concerns regarding the reliability of some indicators as effective tools for monitoring hospital safety(19).

Therefore, active involvement of managers in continuous quality improvement and in promoting a culture of safety within hospitals is crucial. Furthermore, it is essential that governments prioritize the implementation of more structured policies to improve healthcare resources. Promoting leadership education and multisectoral collaboration is equally important to improve patient safety(42,43).

A study conducted to explore the perspectives of international patient safety experts demonstrated that patient safety can be promoted through robust quality management frameworks, such as the biomedical ethics principles proposed by Beauchamp and Childress, the six international goals of the IOM, and the Triple Aim model from the Institute for Healthcare Improvement. These models emphasize the importance of principles such as autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, and justice, as well as the need for safe, effective, patient-centered, timely, efficient, and equitable care. Furthermore, the Triple Aim model focuses on improving the care experience, reducing per capita healthcare costs, and improving population health. Implementation of these practices requires effective collaboration among clinicians, administrators, and policymakers to ensure high-quality and safe care, reducing incident rates and improving patient outcomes(36).

Challenges in implementing and recommendations for improving patient safety policies

According to Akologo et al.(27), Karltun et al.(32), and Hatakeyama et al.(33), patient safety policies face significant implementation challenges, especially in hospitals, compromising their effectiveness. A common point among the studies is the lack of adequate training, as also highlighted by Oliveira et al.(30). In hospitals in the Gaza Strip, for example, although nurses’ attitudes toward patient safety were slightly positive (mean of 3.68 on a 5-point Likert scale), only 41.9% reported having received previous training on the topic. This evidences failures in integrating safety culture into educational programs, emphasizing the importance of strengthening hospital leadership in promoting this culture(28,40).

Furthermore, a study on regional perspectives of patient safety policies in the Middle East and Asia highlighted the importance of involving multiple stakeholders, including patients, in the development of these strategies. Among the main challenges identified were lack of training, the disconnect between education and clinical practice, and low awareness regarding the topic. On the other hand, opportunities were identified, such as strengthening leadership, encouraging a just culture, and improving incident reporting. These observations are reinforced by a WHO technical report (2015)(23), which, based on regional consultations, highlighted weaknesses in governance structures, the absence of reliable data, and low political priority as barriers to effective policy implementation. The document emphasizes the importance of leadership and professional engagement in consolidating an organizational culture focused on safety(23,43).

The need for a formal incident reporting structure within health institutions is highlighted. In a referral hospital in Mbarara, Southwestern Uganda, the absence of such a system hindered the recording of events such as medication, diagnostic, and procedural errors. Barriers such as fear of punishment, lack of knowledge, and absence of a dedicated incident management team were identified as the main obstacles. In contrast, a study conducted in Japan demonstrated that, when properly structured, reporting systems are used as continuous learning tools, promoting process improvements and strengthening safety culture. This reinforces that, in addition to recording failures, it is essential to transform collected data into practical actions and into a collaborative and nonpunitive environment(34,41).

It is concluded that aligning policies, organizations, and resources is essential to institutionalize improvements in health systems. WHO(22) reinforces this perspective by highlighting that safety policies reduce morbidity and generate positive fiscal impacts, although they still face low prioritization among decision-makers. Thus, the development of robust national policies is advocated, with strategic plans encompassing priorities, implementation guidelines, operational actions, and monitoring mechanisms. These policies should be developed with participation from multiple sectors, including communities, and aligned with the Brazilian National Health Plan. In this regard, the WHO Regional Strategy for Patient Safety in South-East Asia proposes six priority action areas: improving structural systems; assessing the nature and scale of AEs; ensuring a trained workforce aware of patient safety; preventing and controlling HAIs; improving implementation of global campaigns; and strengthening research capacity and promoting patient safety research. The document also highlights the importance of institutional commitment, intersectoral articulation, and adaptation of strategies to local needs(22,23,25).

Furthermore, it is essential to expand awareness regarding patient safety among professionals and users through educational campaigns and the development of specific leadership training. Inclusion of the topic in curricula and promotion of partnerships with the community strengthen this agenda(22). Complementing these observations, Isaac et al.(19) demonstrated variability in the effectiveness of patient safety policies, with better outcomes in certain hospital quality measures, although this association was not uniform across all examined indicators. This highlights the need for a careful approach in the assessment and implementation of safety policies, reinforcing the importance of coordination and strategic planning.

Study limitations

This study presents some limitations that should be considered when interpreting the results. First, fragmentation and diversity of sources may be pointed out, since variability in methodological designs and study contexts may hinder direct comparison of findings. Furthermore, most analyzed studies focus on developed countries and urbanized regions, which may limit the generalization of findings to settings with fewer resources and infrastructure.

In addition, exclusion of articles not freely available may have resulted in the loss of relevant studies accessible only through subscriptions or payment.

The effectiveness of patient safety policies is also influenced by cultural and organizational factors, which vary among different hospital contexts, making uniform application of a single policy across distinct realities difficult. Another limitation is the absence of primary data, since, as an integrative review based on secondary publications, the study depends on the quality and comprehensiveness of reported data, without the possibility of collecting new data to fill potential gaps.

Contributions to nursing, health, or public policy

For nursing, the findings reinforce the importance of continuing education and development of a safety culture that encourages error reporting and open communication, which are fundamental elements for improving clinical practice and reducing AEs.

In the health field, the study provides understanding regarding the need for adequate infrastructure and adherence to protocols that ensure safer and higher-quality care, highlighting the role of leadership and organizational culture in effective implementation of these policies.

For public policy, the study highlights the urgency of more integrated and equitable policies, with special attention to less favored regions. By identifying current gaps and challenges, it provides a basis for developing public policy strategies aimed at standardizing and strengthening patient safety practices, promoting greater effectiveness in health systems and benefiting the population as a whole.

Patient safety is a crucial component of healthcare quality. However, recent studies have highlighted several weaknesses that persist in health institutions, directly affecting effectiveness of care and patient safety. This study synthesizes the main findings from articles addressing patient safety culture in different regions, offering recommendations for continuous improvement in this field.

FINAL CONSIDERATIONS

The study reveals that patient safety policies in hospitals present variable scope and effectiveness, influenced by factors such as organizational culture, leadership, and team engagement. Effectiveness is directly related to available infrastructure, adherence to protocols, and investment in permanent education. Despite advances such as national plans and information systems, challenges persist, including policy fragmentation, resource scarcity, and weaknesses in preventing AEs, such as infections, falls, and medication errors. Initiatives such as PNSP are relevant, but still insufficient to significantly impact the reality of hospital services, especially in less developed regions.

The need for a collaborative and evidence-based approach is reinforced, enabling assessment and improvement of these policies, with focus on adaptation to local realities and alignment with international guidelines. It is expected that this study contributes to a critical understanding of the effects of public health policies on patient safety in hospital settings, providing relevant support for clinical practice, hospital management, and future research in the field.

AVAILABILITY OF DATA AND MATERIALS

The available research data is in the body of the article.

REFERENCES

Correspondence

Corresponding author: Flávia Shimeny Soares Cardoso, E-mail: flav.shimeny@gmail.com

EDITOR IN CHIEF:

Dulce Barbosa

ASSOCIATE EDITOR:

Alexandre Balsanelli

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    16 Nov 2026
  • Date of issue
    2026

History

  • Received
    14 Nov 2024
  • Accepted
    25 Apr 2026
location_on
Associação Brasileira de Enfermagem SGA Norte Quadra 603 Conj. "B" - Av. L2 Norte 70830-102 Brasília, DF, Brasil, Tel.: (55 61) 3226-0653, Fax: (55 61) 3225-4473 - Brasília - DF - Brazil
E-mail: reben@abennacional.org.br
rss_feed Stay informed of issues for this journal through your RSS reader
Go to top