Open-access "It is a fire in the sky": images, dreams, and transformations of warao shamanism during the covid-19 pandemic

Resumo:

Este artigo examina as transformações do xamanismo praticado pelos Warao durante a pandemia de covid-19, com ênfase nas imagens, percepções e interpretações deles sobre o evento. A análise concentra-se no ritual do najanamu e nos sonhos xamânicos, examinando os limites e as condições de possibilidade para a realização dessas práticas fora de seus territórios originários, especialmente diante da ausência de especialistas e de artefatos rituais. Ao abordar seus modos de vida, discuto as relações de poder que, historicamente, mantiveram com instituições religiosas e a incorporação de elementos cristãos às cosmologias indígenas. Com base em situações etnográficas, analiso como os Warao, em meio a deslocamentos constantes e às restrições impostas nos espaços de acolhimento, elaboraram estratégias de inovação e ressignificação ritual, que envolveram negociações interétnicas e o uso de tecnologias digitais.

Palavras-chave:
Warao; povos indígenas; regimes de (i)mobilidade; xamanismo; covid-19

Abstract:

This article examines the transformations in shamanism practiced by the Warao during the covid-19 pandemic, with an emphasis on their images, perceptions, and interpretations of the event. The analysis focuses on the najanamu ritual and shamanic dreams, examining the limits and conditions that make it possible to carry out these practices outside their ancestral territories, especially in the absence of specialists and ritual artifacts. In addressing their ways of life, I discuss the power relations they have historically maintained with religious institutions and the incorporation of Christian elements into indigenous cosmologies. Drawing on ethnographic data, I analyze how the Warao, amid constant displacement and restrictions imposed in their host communities, developed strategies for innovation and the reinterpretation of rituals that involved interethnic negotiations and the use of digital technologies.

Keywords:
Warao; indigenous peoples; regimes of (im)mobility; shamanism; covid-19

Resumen:

Este artículo analiza las transformaciones del chamanismo practicado por los warao durante la pandemia de covid-19, destacando sus imágenes, percepciones e interpretaciones en relación con el fenómeno. El análisis se centra en el ritual del najanamu y en los sueños chamánicos, examinando los límites y las condiciones de posibilidad para la realización de estas prácticas fuera de sus territorios de origen, especialmente ante la ausencia de especialistas y de artefactos rituales. Al abordar sus modos de vida, analizo las relaciones de poder que, históricamente, han mantenido con las instituciones religiosas y la incorporación de elementos cristianos en las cosmologías indígenas. A partir de situaciones etnográficas, analizo cómo los Warao, en medio de desplazamientos constantes y de las restricciones impuestas en los espacios de acogida, han elaborado estrategias de innovación y resignificación ritual, que han implicado negociaciones interétnicas y el uso de tecnologías digitales.

Palabras clave:
Warao; pueblos indígenas; regímenes de (in)movilidad; chamanismo; covid-19

Introduction1

At the northernmost end of South America, between the Orinoco Delta and the Amazon estuary, lies the Guianas macro-region, encompassing areas of eastern and southern Venezuela, Guyana, Suriname, French Guiana, and, in Brazil, the states of Amapá, northern Pará, Roraima, and parts of northern Amazonas.2 This is a territory traditionally occupied by Indigenous peoples belonging to the Cariban (or Karib) and Arawakan (or Arawak) language families, as well as the Yanomami and the Warao, who speak their own distinct languages and were therefore excluded from major comparative analyses of the region (Basso 1977; Rivière 1984; Gallois 2005). These groups maintain interethnic relations with other Indigenous peoples and non-Indigenous, sharing elements such as kinship ties, marriage practices, residence patterns, political organization, and shamanic practices, although significant internal variations exist.

Although the notion of the border does not necessarily form part of these peoples’ cosmologies, the impact of the delimitation and expansion of State borders has directly affected their territories (Oliveira 2016, 2021; Tardelli 2026). Historically, invasions driven by the exploitation of natural resources have contributed to the expulsion of several Indigenous peoples from Venezuela, forcing them to migrate to urban centers and, more recently, to other countries. In the case of the Warao, as well as the Taurepang, E’ñepa, Kariña, Wayuu, and other Indigenous peoples, this process intensified over the last decade, culminating in the displacement of more than 14,000 Indigenous people to Brazil, nearly 9,000 of whom belong to the Warao people.28

These displacements should not be understood solely as consequences of the recent context of hyperinflation, unemployment, shortages of food and medicine - exacerbated by the economic sanctions imposed by the United States - which led millions of people to leave Venezuela (Lezama 2020; Carroll 2013). Rather, they must be understood as part of a long-term historical process marked by critical events that shape forms of sociality and subjectivity (Das 1995, 2020). The displacement of the Warao is therefore embedded within a context of recurring forms of violence that transform Indigenous peoples’ experiences and ways of life (Rosa 2021a; Tardelli 2025a, 2025b, 2026). In this sense, the delimitation, closure, or expansion of state, agrarian, and extractive frontiers becomes central to the production of new territorialities and subjectivities, marked by tensions between belonging and exclusion.

The Warao’s trajectories to Brazil largely follow the routes taken by other Indigenous and non-Indigenous groups living under regimes of (im)mobility. Departing from their ancestral territories, they travel to the Venezuelan city of Santa Elena de Uairén, situated on the border with the Brazilian municipality of Pacaraima, in the northern state of Roraima. After entering Brazilian territory, they arrive mainly in Pacaraima, a municipality that includes the São Marcos Indigenous Land.4 The city constitutes one of the main points of arrival, hosting the headquarters of Operação Acolhida (Operation Welcome), a humanitarian response initiative established by the Brazilian government to address increased Venezuelan migration through a partnership with United Nations agencies and civil society organizations (Tardelli 2025a, 2025b).

Between February 2020 and June 2025, I worked as an anthropologist for an NGO and three UN agencies, assuming various roles, including those within Indigenous shelters (abrigo in Portuguese; refúgio in Spanish),5 associated with Operation Welcome’s acolhimento activities.6 At the time, there were two shelters exclusively designated for Indigenous peoples - in addition to more than ten facilities intended for non-Indigenous Venezuelans: Janokoida, in Pacaraima, and Pintolândia, in Boa Vista. Managed by UN agencies in partnership with non-governmental organizations, which also provided services related to education, healthcare, and hygiene, these spaces were additionally coordinated by military personnel from the Brazilian Army, who were responsible for food provision, security, and infrastructure, either directly or through contracts with outsourced companies.

Conceived as emergency and temporary structures, these shelters eventually became spaces of prolonged residence for many Warao, E’ñepa, and Kariña families due to the lack of alternatives. At the time of writing, some people have been living in these spaces for more than seven years. Elsewhere (Tardelli 2025a, 2025b), I analyze the different moralities and conflicts that emerged within these environments. Shelters established in other Brazilian states, although administered by local governments, reproduce a similar logic of control, neglect, and disregard for the sociocultural specificities and perspectives of these peoples (Rosa 2021a; Facundo & Santos 2024; Maréchal et al. 2020).

Created in 2018 during Michel Temer’s administration, Operação Acolhida was consolidated under Jair Bolsonaro’s government (Capdeville 2021; Tardelli 2023a) and underwent no substantial changes during Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s third administration, maintaining the Armed Forces - particularly the Army - in a central position. As I have argued elsewhere (Tardelli 2025a, 2025b), this initiative is situated within a broader context of increasing military presence in national politics since Brazil’s return to democracy7 and engages with a wider international trend of military involvement in humanitarian action (Fassin & Pandolfi 2010; Fassin 2016).

In 2020, the world was confronted with the COVID-19 pandemic, a disease caused by the coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2), whose clinical manifestations ranged from asymptomatic infections to more severe cases. In Brazil, by February 2025, more than 700,000 deaths had been confirmed (Guimarães, Passos, Antunes 2025). During the first and most dramatic years of the pandemic, then-president Jair Bolsonaro and his ministers reproduced discourses and omissions echoing patterns observed during the 1918 influenza pandemic (“Spanish flu”), when denial of the disease’s existence and the promotion of miraculous solutions to combat it became widespread (Schwarcz & Starling 2020). These actions led, in April 2021, to the establishment of a Comissão Parlamentar de Inquérito (CPI, Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry), which identified possible crimes of responsibility in the president’s management of the pandemic.8

For Indigenous peoples, the COVID-19 pandemic made explicit and reinforced inequalities, forms of discrimination, and historical challenges that have persisted since colonization. As Suliete Baré (2021) argues, the health crisis revealed the persistence of state practices and policies that can be understood as part of a genocidal process targeting Indigenous peoples in Brazil. Within this context, the increase in invasions of Indigenous territories, driven by illegal activities such as garimpo (illegal mining, especially gold extraction) and logging, intensified forms of violence affecting bodies, places, and ways of life, resulting in deaths, the spread of diseases, and environmental degradation.

The Articulação dos Povos Indígenas do Brasil (APIB, Articulation of Indigenous Peoples of Brazil) filed, in 2020, an Arguição de Descumprimento de Preceito Fundamental (ADPF) 7099 before the Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF, Federal Supreme Court of Brazil), seeking to ensure protective measures for Indigenous peoples amid escalating territorial invasions and the absence or inadequacy of state responses to address the health crisis. As a result, the STF issued a ruling ordering the adoption of emergency measures for territorial protection, actions to combat illegal mining, and the provision of healthcare assistance to Indigenous peoples (Terena 2022; Pataxó 2025).

In August 2021, APIB submitted a communication to the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague (Netherlands), alleging possible crimes of genocide and crimes against humanity committed against Indigenous peoples during Jair Bolsonaro’s government (APIB 2021). At the same time, given the limitations of official records and the underreporting of COVID-19 cases and deaths among Indigenous peoples, Indigenous organizations assumed a central role in producing, systematizing, and disseminating data on the spread of COVID-19 and its impacts among different peoples (Rosa 2021b). With the beginning of vaccination efforts, APIB mobilized for the inclusion of all Indigenous people - including refugees, migrants, those living in urban areas, and communities in territories that had not yet been officially recognized - in the National Operationalization Plan for COVID-19 Vaccination. In this process, Indigenous women played a fundamental role in demanding access to vaccines and conducting awareness campaigns focused on immunization (Rosa 2022).

The pandemic intensified the vulnerability of the Warao in different regions of Brazil. In Natal (Rio Grande do Norte), episodes of expulsion of Indigenous families were reported (Facundo & Santos 2024), while in Porto Alegre (Rio Grande do Sul), food insecurity worsened when Warao women were prevented from requesting donations in public spaces (Maréchal et al. 2020), a practice they have adopted in different locations. As Rosa et al. (2024) demonstrate in their analysis of shelters in Manaus (Amazonas), shamanism and Indigenous healing practices were largely disregarded in the planning and implementation of health actions, while sheltering arrangements intensified institutional control over Warao mobility and permanence in urban spaces.

My observations regarding the context of Roraima are quite similar. While the institutions involved in Operação Acolhida were developing a health protocol for shelters and establishing an isolation area, I observed that the Warao were developing their own care strategies, often guided by rationales distinct from those underlying institutional actions. Plant-based healing practices and shamans - the “Warao doctors” - were part of this repertoire, alongside other practices mobilized during the pandemic. At the same time, many families moved to other states, such as Amazonas, Pará, Mato Grosso, and the Federal District, carrying with them these experiences, which continued to guide their forms of care. This dynamic indicates that mobility was not merely a consequence of increased vulnerability but also a dimension of how the Warao responded to the health crisis. This scenario reveals the plurality of Warao therapeutic itineraries, highlighting the coexistence and combination of different forms of knowledge in response to critical situations.

Nevertheless, the performance of shamanic practices among the Warao faced significant challenges, whether due to the absence of specialists in certain communities or the difficulty of accessing the raw materials and artifacts required for rituals. Faced with these limitations, many families began moving throughout Brazilian territory in search of a wisiratu10 - whose role will be discussed below - or other specialists capable of addressing processes of illness and healing. Conversely, the closure of the Brazil-Venezuela border, imposed by the Brazilian government,11 further aggravated the situation by preventing numerous Indigenous families from reaching the country and leading some to resort to trochas, a term used by Venezuelan and other Latin American migrants to refer to informal cross-border routes that bypass official checkpoints.

Within this context, a series of photographs and videos of propitiatory rituals performed in different territories, especially in Venezuela, began circulating through Warao WhatsApp groups. Although geographically separated, the benevolent signs sent by Kanobo (“the grandfather spirit”) did not seem to be restricted to the communities that honored him during the najanamu (or nahanamu), a ceremony that Warao people describe as the “great feast” or “great dance,” but rather crossed borders and connected dispersed families. Likewise, Warao shamans’ dreams circulated among these groups, forming part of a collective narrative that reinforced and complemented interpretations of this event, always filtered through the lenses of their cosmology. Some of these dreams were even drawn by Mauricio Fiscal, a wisiratu living in Pacaraima. Dream experiences and visual records thus became intertwined in the production and circulation of knowledge during the pandemic.

To understand transformations in Warao shamanism, this article focuses on the imaginal representations produced by Warao people about the pandemic, emphasizing the performance of the najanamu and shamanic dreams. I analyze the limits and possibilities of carrying out this ritual outside their ancestral territories, amid ongoing displacement processes and contexts marked by the absence of ritual artifacts and specialists. I also examine how these challenges were addressed through negotiations, resignifications, and the incorporation of new resources, such as recorded videos shared through social media.

The article also discusses the power relations that some Warao communities have established with religious institutions, as well as transformations associated with missionary presence and Christian practices. I first present aspects of Warao life in their ancestral territories, focusing on cosmology and shamanic practices. Drawing on Warao interpretations and missionary records, including photographs, I then describe and analyze the najanamu ritual. Finally, I examine experiences shared with Warao people in Roraima, seeking to understand the strategies they developed to respond to the pandemic.

Life in the caños

Even when they lived in urban centers in Venezuela, the Warao families and communities who came to Brazil maintained as their primary reference the caños of the Orinoco Delta, river channels that connect the eastern region of the country to Venezuela’s largest river, whose name in Warao is wirinoko, meaning “the place where we paddle” (García-Castro 2006; Rosa 2021a). This connection with waterways is expressed in the ways they identify themselves: “people of the waters,” “people of the canoes,” or “people of the low coast” (waja = low coast, arao = people), expressing a historical and cosmological relationship with the delta’s marshy territory (García-Castro & Heinen 1999; Tardelli 2023b). Amid intertwined rivers and exuberant biodiversity, the Warao developed diverse forms of social organization grounded in a shared cultural identity, although marked by variations among communities and regions. Despite their relative isolation, they maintained interethnic relations with speakers of Karib and Arawak languages before Spanish colonization (Wilbert & Lafée-Wilbert 2009; García-Castro 2018).

In the caños, their houses were positioned facing the rivers and were called janoko, that is, “the place of the chinchorro,” where hammocks were hung for sleeping. The architectural model was based on the stilt-house construction system, common in areas with high rainfall levels. Dwellings were built on trunks or pillars, preventing them from being flooded or carried away by river currents. Lacking walls, the houses were covered with palm leaves. In the words of Teolinda Moraleda, a Warao leader with whom I have been in conversation since July 2020, the Warao lived upon the waters: “There is a lot of water. Our typical food was ocumo and fish, yuruma, the gusano of the moriche palm.12 Fishing and hunting. And planting. While we were planting, we were not hungry; food was never lacking. That was life in the caños.”13

Warao communities were organized into groupings known as janoko sebe (“sets of houses” or rancheira, in Spanish). Generally, these were small settlements, composed of approximately four to fifteen families connected through kinship ties. Authority within these communities was not centralized in a single individual; rather, each one was led by an elder who exercised local leadership. Communities were composed of extended families, exceeding the nuclear configuration of parents and children. It was common for a single residence to house between 30 and 100 individuals, depending on the size of the structure.

After marriage, newly formed couples would reside with the wife’s mother’s family or community, following the principle of matrilocality. Domestic organization was structured around an older couple, in which the man, father and father-in-law (aidamo or iramo) - guided his direct descendants and affinal relatives in economic activities, especially those related to obtaining food. The woman, in turn, as mother and mother-in-law (arani), was responsible for redistributing these food resources among members of the group. The oldest man within the extended domestic unit occupied a position of prestige and authority within this segmentary social organization and was often recognized as an aidamo, a category also translated as the “head” of the extended family (Lafée-Wilbert & Wilbert 2008; Diego 2008; García-Castro 2018; Rosa 2021a; Tardelli 2023b).

The authority of the aidamo was therefore grounded in kinship relations, especially in the father-in-law/son-in-law relationship. However, this form of political organization did not remain unaffected by relations established with external agents, although such contacts occurred unevenly among Warao communities and across different historical periods. In regions where missionary and state presence became more pronounced, especially from the 1920s onward, new forms of authority and political organization were introduced, coexisting with traditional structures. For instance, positions such as comisario, fiscal, and policía were created, apparently inspired by external models of administration and discipline. Some Warao told me that, to deal with certain situations, these authorities imposed punishments: if a woman had a relationship with another man, her hair could be cut; if a man assaulted a woman, he could be tied upside down (Tardelli 2023a).

These transformations were related, among other factors, to the activities of the Order of Friars Minor Capuchin (Capuchin Order), associated with the Franciscan tradition and approved in 1528 by Pope Clement VII, which played an important role in Catholic missions during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. According to Amoroso (2006), the Capuchins followed settlement models aligned with the universalizing project of the Catholic Church and informed by evolutionist conceptions regarding the incorporation of Indigenous peoples into Christian society. As Allard (2025) argues, in seeking to evangelize, civilize, and reorganize Warao communities, the Capuchins had to confront the limits and contradictions of their project in relation to the concrete conditions of the region. Although they intended to establish permanent settlements, transform Indigenous people into sedentary farmers, and impose a model of “civilized” life, missionaries were forced to adapt to the reality of the delta, characterized by wetlands, river mobility, extractive activities, trade, and intense cross-border exchanges.

A more detailed analysis of Capuchin missions among the Warao, which is the subject of an ongoing research project, will be left for another occasion. However, for this article’s argument, I would like to share an excerpt from a text written by Manuel A. Pulido Méndez, Venezuela’s ambassador to Peru, published in the journal Venezuela Misionera14 in August 1945. The diplomat reviewed the activities carried out by Franciscans in Venezuela - including the Capuchins - while praising the missionaries’ achievements:

Currently, Franciscan Missionaries in Venezuela carry out work of paramount importance in the regions of Delta Amacuro and the outermost portion of Guayana, known as the Gran Sabana. In the former, they are engaged in the catechization of the Guaraúnos15 and the Arawak tribes - a human substance intermingled like the silt and waters carried by the Orinoco, inhabiting the banks of the channels and estuaries across the vast expanse where the immense river carves its path toward the ocean (...). Given the nature of the terrain, man nearly vanishes within the Delta region, seemingly devoured by the teeming forces of nature. The indigenous population lives intimidated by witchcraft and the arrow. Acting as a balm, the Capuchin friars and sisters, with sublime selflessness, perform the exalted task of integrating them into Christianity and civilization upon this sun-scorched earth, for which San Francisco’s canticle seems to have been written. The educational process proves arduous. A fragment of human life dispersed among water, morichales, mangroves, and rubber plantations - where, until quite recently, the greed of rubber tappers (gomeros) escalated into a brutal and inexorable drama, throwing races, principles, and things into chaos - must inevitably constitute a difficult material for the missionary to shape; a matter to be drawn back from the dark and turbulent depths of instinct into the clear, elevated realms of spiritual life. To humanize space, to humanize man - herein lie the combined ideals of Christianity and the emerging field of Geopolitics (Méndez 1945:243, my translation).

The passage above demonstrates how colonial discourse and practice, which in my view continue to be reproduced in contemporary contexts (Tardelli 2023a), relegated the Warao and other Indigenous peoples to a condition of subalternity. A central aspect is the reinforcement of the nature/culture dichotomy, in which Indigenous peoples are associated with “savagery” and, consequently, with nature: at times described as a human substance mixed with mud and waters, and at others as victims of natural forces.

Because of Warao’s geographical location and the difficulties of navigation in the region, Europeans only began establishing a more intense presence in the caños from the eighteenth century onward, although sporadic contacts had already occurred in the sixteenth century (Tiapa 2007). Except for some incursions aimed at capturing Indigenous people for enslavement in the Spanish colonies of the Greater Antilles, the Warao remained less exposed to colonial incursions. This relative distance was partly related to European disinterest in occupying the lower delta, which was perceived as a hostile environment and poorly suited to colonial projects (Wilbert & Lafée-Wilbert 2009). As Tiapa (2007) argues, within the imaginary of conquest, nature was understood as an element capable of limiting or enabling territorial occupation; in the case of the delta inhabited by the Warao, colonizers predominantly perceived it as an inhospitable space, difficult for human settlement.

Although these lands continued to be regarded as difficult to access throughout the twentieth century, this perception was not enough to prevent the advance of missionaries. Beyond the challenge of mastering an environment considered hostile, missionaries also took upon themselves the task of transforming Warao ways of life, dispersed among waters and morichales,16 while acknowledging the complexity of such an undertaking (Allard 2025). In this context, the Capuchins embraced the project of incorporating the Warao both into Christianity and into what they called “civilization,” seeking to overcome what they identified as obstacles to evangelization, including fear of brujería and the arrow. Humanizing the space, humanizing the human being: this was the ideal that guided their actions.

The idea that the Warao needed to be “shaped” resonates with Viveiros de Castro’s (2024) analysis, which revisits the metaphors of marble and myrtle used by Father Antônio Vieira (1608-1697) to reflect on the challenges faced by Jesuits in their Catholic evangelization efforts among Indigenous peoples. For Vieira, Indigenous peoples supposedly displayed instability and indifference toward the Christian faith, being perceived as incapable of fully adhering to a doctrine or submitting to religious authority. However, considering the experiences of the Warao with whom I have interacted and my fieldwork observations, the “inconstancy” associated with processes of evangelization does not appear to result from a rejection of Christianity; rather, it is expressed through how Christian elements may be incorporated into Warao cosmology without necessarily implying the abandonment of shamanic practices and conceptions. Although the relationships established by the Warao with other Christian institutions and denominations - including Pentecostal and Neo-Pentecostal churches and Jehovah’s Witnesses - still require further investigation, an ethnographic episode allows us to reflect on some of these negotiations.

In October 2025, I observed, in a Warao WhatsApp group, a discussion involving different religious perspectives: a man from Teresina (Piauí), who had recently converted to a Protestant denomination - a phenomenon still relatively uncommon but which, according to Rosa (2021a), has been growing - began sharing proselytizing messages, prompting reactions from women in the group, who reminded him that this space was not intended for such purposes:

My religion is Catholic, 100 percent. The word of God is one and only. The word of God has always been present in our minds, in our knowledge, and in our hearts. Within the group, we see that each person has different knowledge to speak about and defend our religion. That is good; the belief is one because there is only one God. Sending only one liturgy is good; it makes people reflect a little, prevents them from straying from God’s path and from losing their faith, because we, who are believers, are God’s adopted children (...). However, within this group, there are several beliefs, and the group must respect them.

The statement above was made by an elderly woman living in Boa Vista, about whom, interestingly, years earlier, rumors had circulated attributing witchcraft practices to her - the veracity of such claims is irrelevant for this analysis. What matters here is her affirmation of the possibility of coexistence among different beliefs and forms of religious expression, as well as the ambiguity of her words: it is possible to share liturgical practices, but that is not the group's purpose; there is one God and one faith, but all beliefs deserve respect.

Geertz’s (2017) approach, which conceives religion as a cultural system, is useful for understanding Warao religious discourses and practices. According to the author, culture consists of historically transmitted patterns of meaning embodied in symbols, through which human beings communicate, preserve, and develop their knowledge and attitudes toward life. Sacred symbols, in this sense, synthesize a people’s ethos and worldview, articulating a particular way of life with a metaphysical order. Geertz emphasizes that the religious perspective constitutes only one among several ways of interpreting the world and that the boundaries between the religious, artistic, and political spheres may be blurred. Among the Warao, this distinction becomes even more complex, since different dimensions of social life and cosmology are articulated with one another, without necessarily corresponding to rigid classifications or fixed separations.

Warao shamanic perspectives

According to Brunelli (1996), although concrete aspects of existence, sociological features, and certain techniques for establishing contact with other beings are relevant for understanding the forms that shamanism takes in different societies, these particularities, considered together, do not constitute definitive criteria for determining what can or cannot be recognized as such. Calavia Sáez (2018), in reviewing the anthropological literature on shamanism in the Lowlands of South America, emphasizes that expecting a single and precise definition is illusory, since the term has been applied rather loosely to highly diverse realities. Thus, there is not one shamanism, but rather multiple shamanisms - diverse practices and specialists that manifest themselves in different ways according to each context.

I do not seek to define shamanism. Rather, for analytical purposes, and in dialogue with Barcelos Neto, Pérez Gil, and Ramos (2024), I argue that it is possible to identify certain recurring features, although they are not universal. Two are particularly salient in shamanic practice and thought. The first concerns the aesthetic dimension: although not everything that is aesthetically marked involves shamanic agency, the literature suggests that shamanic action is necessarily mediated through sensory forms - sounds, smells, textures, movements, and images - in which beauty and poetics play a central role. The second concerns the shaman’s transformative capacity. As a creator and transformer of worlds, the shaman mediates relations between humans and nonhumans in ways that have tangible effects (Barcelos Neto, Pérez Gil, and Ramos 2024).

As Sztutman (2005) highlights, the cosmologies of Indigenous peoples of the Guianas are populated by fierce enemies, agents responsible for illness, and metaphysical beings, even when these communities have already experienced strong influences from Christianity in its various forms. Although shamans may lose ground to pastors or doctors, contact and negotiation with these beings remain fundamental to the maintenance of social life, which continues to be subject to constant threats - from the possibility of the sky collapsing onto the earth to devastating epidemics.

Indeed, the Warao world is filled with beings that, for lack of a better term, we conventionally call “spirits.” They inhabit trees, forests, mountains, and rivers, and possess the ability to transform themselves into human and nonhuman forms. This includes the nabarao, who lives at the bottom of rivers and may consume people, showing a predilection for women during menstruation, a period when they avoid approaching rivers. From this perspective, Alcida Rita Ramos’s observation regarding the Sanumá, a Yanomami subgroup, is also applicable to the Warao, as well as to numerous Indigenous peoples of the South American lowlands: the familiarity they “demonstrate with the forest and their ease in navigating through it do not entirely conceal the air of mystery that emanates from it, filled as it is with material and immaterial beings over which they have little control” (Ramos 1990: 32).

Such a world is inhabited by a multiplicity of jebu or hebu (“spirits”), found in the air, forests, and rivers. These beings may cause illnesses and epidemics, bring misfortune in fishing and hunting, and are known as jebubitu a nonatuma, the assistants of the “Great Jebu” or “Great Spirit.” The jebu occupies a central place in Warao shamanism, referring to a powerful force that inhabits a wide range of beings and elements of the world, including trees and stones, and is closely associated with illness. To have jebu is to be ill. Illness results from the action of a jebu upon the body, producing sickness and daños - harmful afflictions caused by human or nonhuman agents - which may ultimately lead to death (Arellano 1986; Allard 2010; Sørhaug 2012; Rosa et al. 2024). Accordingly, when translated into Warao, the names of some diseases are accompanied by the term jebu (Tardelli 2021).

According to the missionary Lucas de Benllera (1979) - whose work I discuss in the following section - the “Great Spirit” is known by different names, each emphasizing a particular attribute: dijaguara (“the one who produces life”), wisiratu arotu (“the Lord of the Priests”), jito-are (“the one who lives above the supreme extremity”), kuai-mare (“the happy or blessed one who lives above”), jebubitu (“the Great Spirit”), and kanobo (“our grandfather”). Among the Warao with whom I have lived and conducted research, kanobo is by far the most frequently used designation. Although nobo literally means “grandfather,” the term has a broader meaning associated with old age, seniority, and leadership. Elders are referred to as nobo even when they do not have grandchildren. As noted above, these elders play a central role in the political organization of extended families. In this sense, kanobo can be understood as “our elder leader,” a figure whom ethnographic accounts describe as having a wife and family (Heinen 2009).

The jebu dwells in the heights, above the clouds, in a house called joebo. This celestial dwelling contains conucos (“small gardens”) and curiaras (“canoes”) that navigate the seas above. It is also inhabited by other celestial beings, such as the zamuros, Warao who transformed themselves into zamuro birds to descend to the earth (Benllera 1979). In addition, joebo is home to other types of jebu, or “assistant spirits,” including the masisikire and the kanaima. The former is represented as a small figure with twisted legs, appearing either as a man or a woman. I first learned about the masisikire in July 2020, when Jesus Norberio explained its characteristics to me.

Initially, the Warao living in the Janokoida shelter in Pacaraima collected firewood on weekends for cooking.17 Before long, however, many began to fall ill. Jesus explained that this was because certain spirits inhabit mountainous areas. He then told me about a young man who began suffering seizures after an encounter with a masisikire. According to his account, the young man had gone to the bathroom and, as he was leaving, saw a woman approaching him as if to embrace him. Frightened, he recognized her as a masisikire. Fearing the consequences of this encounter and following a disagreement with health professionals who insisted on transporting him by ambulance, he decided to travel to Manaus to seek treatment from a “Warao doctor.” The masisikire assumes either familiar or unfamiliar human forms, and those who encounter it may become mentally disturbed, with potentially fatal consequences.

Jesus Norberio: If a Warao man falls in love with a woman and has no contact with her, he begins to imagine things. Then, the spirit appears in the form of that woman, but it can be seen on his leg. If the spirit does that, it practically takes him away-it takes his soul. He doesn’t die right then and there, but he begins to grow ill until he dies that same day or that very night.

A second case involved an older man who sustained his family through the abundance of food produced in his gardens. One day, while searching for a new plot of land, he entered an area inhabited by spirits. Upon his return, a masisikire took on his appearance. According to Jesus, the affliction resulted from his failure to observe an important rule: one must not enter places that serve as dwelling sites for spirits. The same principle, he explained, accounted for the illnesses that affected the Warao who ventured into the surrounding hills to collect firewood in Pacaraima.

Jesus Norberio: He was cleaning when he heard a noise; he looked up and saw himself. He spoke and thought he was going crazy. He went home and didn’t say anything to his family. Over the weekend, a friend arrived from Tucupita, from the community of Araguabisi, where he used to live. The friend brought soda, bread, and cachaça. While they were drinking, he told him what had happened at work. He got drunk. The masisikiri had already taken his soul, and that very night he died.

The second spirit is called kanaima and is found among different peoples of the Guiana macro-region (Taylor 1996; Amaral 2019). Originating from mountainous regions, it appears as an aggressive being with both human and nonhuman characteristics, capable of killing. Among the Ingarikó, a people who inhabit the Raposa Serra do Sol Indigenous Land, located at the tripoint border between Brazil, Venezuela, and Guyana, and with whom I have conducted fieldwork, Amaral (2019) observed that kanaimë (or canaimé, in its Portuguese form) are frequently held responsible for most deaths, including those of Areruya prophets.18 She also demonstrates that historical accounts of kanaimë attacks and prophetic manifestations multiplied throughout the nineteenth century, a period immediately following the intensification of colonization in the lands occupied by the Kapon and Pemon.19

For the Warao, death is not always understood as a natural process, as it may be related to sorcery, as observed among some Yanomami subgroups (Ramos 1990; Taylor 1996; Kopenawa & Albert 2013; Limulja 2022). Malaise, pain, illness, and death may result from the action of a jebu, joa, or bajana. The latter two are associated with the practices of brujos, particularly the joarotu and bajanarotu, who employ these forces to cause harm.

The joarotu is a specialist in harmful practices who acts through the joa, or malevolent spell - a daño cast upon a victim in the form of pathogenic objects, such as stones and needles, which are inserted into the body. The joarotu can also remove the joa by massaging the parts of the body where these harmful substances have been introduced. The bajanarotu, on the other hand, is defined as the “arbitrator of the magic arrows” (Barral 1979:48). He acts through the bajana-a term that encompasses both the suction technique, literally translated as “the act of sucking or smoking,” and the physical object itself extracted from the patient’s body. Materially, the bajana takes the form of a small object that fits inside a closed hand, such as a piece of glass, a handful of hair, or some seeds.

In addition to the joarotu and the bajanarotu, the Warao recognizes a third specialist knowledgeable in illness and healing processes: the wisiratu. The term is frequently used to refer to the Warao “doctor,” “healer,” “brujo,” or shaman,20 in contrast to the joarotu and bajanarotu, who are regarded as “sorcerers.” The wisiratu communicates with kanobo through dreams. Upon waking in the morning, they typically share their dream experiences-a practice that extends even to those who do not hold this role. In this sense, as observed by Limulja (2022) among the Yanomami, the act of dreaming is distributed horizontally, even though it is not honed or controlled by everyone. Thus, the practice of recounting dreams, according to Langdon (1999), constitutes a communicative event integrated into narrative-and, in certain cases, performative-traditions. Dream activities, therefore, are not treated as illusions but as lived experiences that impact daily life, producing social and political effects (Kopenawa & Albert 2015; Limulja, 2022).

The wisiratu also communicates with kanobo through the maraca, an instrument widely used among various indigenous peoples of South America (Gallois 1996). This artifact is made from a fruit similar to a gourd, the interior of which is completely hollowed out, leaving only the shell, which hardens as it dries. Seeds or small stones (karekos) are inserted inside, along with a support rod that allows it to be handled in accordance with the rhythms specific to each ritual or festival. Some maracas are used exclusively in religious rituals - such as the najanamu - while others are used in festivities. The former are restricted to the wisiratu and other specialists. Another instrument used in this ritual is the esemoi, a type of flute made from cane or bamboo and played in a vertical position. Furthermore, like the joarotu, the wisiratu smokes the wina, a long cigarette (approximately half a meter in length) whose smoke is blown onto the body of the sick person and used during certain rituals.

The Warao devote considerable attention to caring for their sick, prioritizing the involvement of traditional healers in the early stages of the treatment process, before turning to the formal health care system. This approach does not constitute a rejection of biomedicine, but rather reflects their own epistemology regarding the process of illness and healing. In many cases, it is first necessary to “sacar el daño”-that is, to identify and treat the condition caused by the actions of human or non-human agents. According to this perspective, medication administered before this ritual procedure could “exacerbate” the illness, rather than restore the person to health (Rosa 2021a; Rosa et al. 2024). When no specialist is available nearby, Warao families may travel to other cities in search of one. In the absence of specialists in the area, the Warao travel to other urban centers to find them. When called upon, the wisiratu determines, through dreams, whether the condition is a “cosa de los warao” or an illness that requires biomedical treatment. If he is unable to resolve the condition, he himself suggests that the patient visit a health clinic or seek out another Indigenous specialist (Tardelli 2021; 2023a).

I understand that this distinction among specialists’ roles is related more to the distribution of knowledge and techniques than to rigid categories of specialists, since a single person may accumulate different forms of knowledge and practices. There is not enough space here to detail how someone becomes a joarotu, bajanarotu, or wisiratu, but I would note that such knowledge is not necessarily transmitted through hereditary lines. I met people whose path was revealed through a dream, while others became shamans after experiencing extreme situations, such as a near-death experience or the illness of someone close to them. I also encountered individuals who had undergone initiation rituals, which may or may not be successful. Although most of those I met were men, I heard accounts of women who also performed these roles.

In their ancestral territories, the Warao had spaces dedicated to shamanic practices, such as the jebu a janoko (“the house of the jebu”), a sacred ritual space. Unlike ordinary constructions, it was not open on all four sides, but instead had walls and doors, and was somewhat separated from other houses, sometimes located within the forest and away from public view. In this space, the wisiratu stored the sacred maraca, adorned with feathers, as well as other ritual instruments, such as sibu (“incense”) and aja (“tobacco”), which were used to prepare the wina (“cigarette”). Access to this space was restricted to others.

An episode narrated by Benllera (1979) illustrates both the sacredness of this space and the effects of Christian contact. Upon arriving in San Francisco de Guayo, Father Barral, a Capuchin missionary, selected a site for the foundation of a Catholic mission. To clear the area, he received assistance from young Warao who had been educated at the missions of Araguaimujo and San José Amacuro. During this process, however, they encountered a jebu a janoko, which they destroyed. For the Warao of that community, this act constituted an offense. Soon afterward, the jebu was believed to have become enraged and to have caused a severe influenza outbreak. To appease it, the wisiratu performed rituals for several nights.

A dance for kanobo

In missionary accounts, Indigenous perspectives appear subtly, always mediated by the interests of those who produced the records. As Montero (2006:15) argues, when considering the context in which these texts were produced and how they reconstruct oral cultures, it is possible to identify a “convergence of symbolic horizons” in the historical relations between Indigenous peoples and missionaries. The Indigenous peoples portrayed in these documents are not the same as those of the present; however, through a careful reading of what lies between the lines, it is possible to access ethnographic aspects and apprehend historical processes inscribed in these records.

Father Lucas de Benllera (Plácido Gutiérrez Gutiérrez) provides a good example. A Capuchin missionary, born in 1925 in León, Spain, he arrived in Venezuela in January 1952 and carried out missionary work in the lower Orinoco region (Pobladura 1976). He dedicated his doctoral dissertation to the Warao, focusing particularly on their religious manifestations (Benllera 1979). I first encountered his work in 2020, when Isidro, who lived in Pacaraima, lent me a copy. For him, this book was an important object, both because of his training as a teacher and because it contained information about “Warao culture”, in addition to being filled with images depicting life in the caños and Warao shamanic rituals, including the najanamu. It therefore served as a means of affirming identities and as an artifact of collective memory.

The missionary’s account of the Warao provides valuable details about their way of life, but it is permeated by prejudices, exoticization, and a skeptical stance toward their beliefs. Benllera (1979) points to difficulties in identifying a “true religion” among the Warao, attributing this to an alleged “primitivism” and to the absence of material elements such as pottery or writing. He is also struck by the absence of a direct relationship with a “Supreme Being,” classifying the Warao universe as an intricate labyrinth. Rather than recognizing the limits of his own interpretation, the missionary ultimately attributes to the Warao a “backward mentality” for seeking explanations in the world of jebu, figures that occupy a central place in their everyday concerns.

As Turner (2013) pointed out, ever since Lewis Henry Morgan, numerous anthropologists have sought to interpret religion using explanatory frameworks of a psychological or sociological nature. Although such approaches commonly disregarded the “supernatural” dimension, they recognized the central role of the religious phenomenon in the maintenance and transformation of social structures. This debate contributed to the development of criteria that established distinctions between “advanced” and “primitive” religions. However, Mary Douglas (2017) argues that magical practice, understood as a ritual to which an automatic effect is attributed, should not be taken as an indicator of “primitivism,” just as high ethical standards are not exclusive to religions considered “developed.” Despite the evolutionist assumptions that shaped his approach, Benllera acknowledges that the Warao perform multiple rituals and ceremonies, emphasizing the richness and complexity of their symbolic and religious experiences.

According to Geertz (2017), it is in ritual - that is, in behavior that has been consecrated by a group - that certainty emerges regarding the truth of religious ideas and the correctness of their orientations. It is in these ceremonial moments that beliefs, motivations generated by sacred symbols, and conceptions about how the world should come together and mutually sustain one another. In ritual, lived experience and imagined reality merge, connected through shared symbols, forming a single reality.

Among the Warao, rituals do not necessarily function as markers of chronological time. In the case of the najanamu, the moment of its performance is determined by kanobo, who communicates his will to the wisiratu through dreams and in accordance with the cycle of the moriche palm (Heinen & Lavandero 1973). As the Warao have explained to me, the najanamu is a great feast or “sacred dance” that lasts three days. Etymologically, the term means “container of the moriche palm shoot” (naja21 = “shoot of the moriche palm”; namu = “container”). This name refers to one of the initial stages of the ritual: the production, from moriche fiber, of a container in which the flour or starch of yuruma (“moriche bread”) is placed and offered to kanobo. The najanamu is therefore a propitiatory ritual, centered on this offering.

Figure 1.
Najanamu: “Container Made From the Moriche Palm Stalk”.

Upon arrival, they establish a camp, as the work may last for weeks, depending on the availability of palms. They move through the area in search of palms with abundant starch and cut them down with axes. The trunk is then opened, and the inner portion is removed, which is appreciated as food when fresh. The remaining leaves are used to produce different woven materials, especially hammocks. The second stage requires greater care: one side of the trunk is stripped away until the core is reached. Using picks, they carefully excavate this inner part, extracting the flour-like substance used to prepare yuruma bread22.

Both operations are carried out by men. Once the heart of the palm has been transformed into a thick flour, however, women are responsible for removing it from the trunk and transporting it in their biji, a round tray made of interwoven tirite fibers. They place the biji over a structure of sticks, beneath which a container is positioned. As they pour water over the flour while stirring and squeezing it, the starch drains into the container, where a mass gradually forms at the bottom. This mass is then removed, allowing the remaining water to drain away; it is subsequently dried and stored in baskets until the yuruma is finally prepared. Upon returning to their communities, they cannot consume yuruma until it has been ritually offered to kanobo.

Figure 2.
Warao Shaman During Healing Practice.

The wisiratu is responsible for organizing the preparations for the najanamu, mobilizing all members of the community in different activities, such as providing the fish to be consumed during the festive days, inviting neighboring communities, cleaning and arranging the place where the najanamu will take place (jojonoko), and producing the ritual instruments. Among these are maracas, botutos (flutes used exclusively in religious ceremonies), esemoi (“signaling whistle”), marakitas (used by men participating in the jabi sanuka dance), and jatabu (a support structure for ritual objects). They also prepare ornamental body paintings and the container known as najanamu - mentioned above - in which the yuruma is placed.

In the initial rite, the wisiratu places the flour in the najanamu, presenting the offering to kanobo. He chants, moves the maraca, and requests protection for the entire community. The wisiratu is recognized as holding the knowledge required to establish this communication and to use the appropriate words for the ritual. However, as Gersem Baniwa (2017) argues, ritual language is not restricted to verbal expression; it is also conveyed through gestures, dances, fasting, and symbolic offerings, which acquire a political-pedagogical dimension. According to Warao understandings, the presence of women or children at this moment could provoke a harmful response from the jebu, including the risk of death. The ritual also appears to be restricted to members of the community itself, excluding external visitors and men from other communities. After approximately two hours, the participants returned in single file and in complete silence.

Figure 3.
Warao Ceremonial Dance.

On the following day, women of greater prestige in the community are responsible for collecting the flour for the yuruma bread and preparing the fish intended for the celebration. These activities occupy much of the day, and at the end, the food is deposited in the najanamu. At night, the sacred jatabu dance begins, with the space prepared by men. They gather silently in the center of the plaza (jojonoko), where the jatabu serves as support for the ritual objects brought from the jebu house. The dokotu-arotu (“music director”) strikes the ground, announcing the beginning of the men’s painting ceremony, conducted by the wisiratu. A new signal then summons the women for the dance: they enter in a line and have their arms painted.23 After the paintings are completed, they go to the sanctuary to retrieve the objects and the decorated maraca of the wisiratu, which are placed at the center of the dance area on the jatabu. At this moment, women and children remain absent. The wisiratu carries a staff and wears various ornaments, which vary according to the ritual context, including bands, belts, and necklaces.

The dance begins. In silence, the wisiratu approaches the jatabu, looking toward the bundle and taking steps from the center to the right and from the right to the left. He is then given the large maraca (mari-mataro), which he plays while moving in a circle from left to right. Each step is accompanied by the sound of the maraca. The other men enter, forming a semicircle around the wisiratu. The musicians play their instruments. Finally, in procession, the container is returned to the jebu sanctuary.

The wisiratu remains at the site and begins playing a smaller maraca. One of the women appears before him. The men again begin to circle in semicircles around them, while the musicians perform. The woman begins to jump from left to right and from right to left, without leaving her position. The chorus of men then chants: “Eeeé, yún, yéee....!”, which, according to Benllera (1979), is a cry adopted in different Warao rituals. The woman leaves and is replaced by another woman, and the same procedure is repeated with other women. After all women have danced with the wisiratu, he begins removing his ornaments, which are successively used by other Indigenous participants, repeating the previous dance - one man and one woman. Finally, the wisiratu’s wife appears and begins wearing her husband’s adornments. All participants danced with her in the same way they danced with her husband.

Without claiming to cover every aspect of the complexity of the najanamu, it is worth noting that, in addition to the rites described, there are a number of other ceremonies held throughout the days dedicated to the ritual. Among them, the kua-mare stands out, directed toward children. In this ceremony, children remain inside a semicircle formed by adult men, who utter words requesting protection for the young ones. The celebration concludes with the marakitas dance (or jabi sanuka), when kanobo is invoked.

A fire in the sky

As soon as I arrived at Janokoida on August 6, 2020, probably around 7:30 a.m., Mauricio Fiscal waved at me and said that he needed to speak with me. At the time, I was working as the coordinator of that shelter. He told me that he wanted to share a dream he had had. It was related to the coronavirus. I invited him into the coordination office. I asked whether I could record the conversation. He agreed. He also showed me a notebook in which he had drawn images from the dream. During our conversation, Mauricio complemented the drawing, using images to illustrate what he was telling me; in fact, he was attempting to reproduce what his “protector” - he did not directly refer to kanobo - had communicated to him while he slept, while he was “traveling” upward.

Gabriel: How was the dream?

Mauricio: Brother, look. He indicated it to me: what is here, as he taught me from a book, he told me: this plague is coming this way, in 20 days it will arrive in the city. From today, count 20 days. And this plague that bites here, if someone dies within five minutes and after the body is buried, the body goes [inaudible] beneath the earth. And that will remain in the mountain, inside the body, when it is already dead. That is what he showed me. And here there is a map [showing me the drawing] ... that will enter the city. This is a road that comes from outside, and this is a road that goes into the city, a curve, and here there is another one, another one here, like a roundabout. The truck coming from outside will follow this way and enter. And the bus coming from here will meet the truck, the one coming from outside, and they will crash. And inside that truck will come the plague.

Gabriel: It will crash... so, will there be an accident?

Mauricio: An accident... And all the people around will die, everyone who is here (this is a house that is here inside). I do not know if it is Boa Vista or Manaus. Twenty days for it to reach the city.

Gabriel: And where does this truck come from?

Mauricio: The truck comes from outside. I do not know where it is from, but he showed me that it comes from a city...

Gabriel: Is it Pacaraima?

Mauricio: No. We must pay attention; we must count the days until we reach 20 days from today. A giant plague, he said.

Gabriel: The dream?

Mauricio: Yes. A giant and poisonous plague. Yes, brother, I will pay attention to this dream, and I also warn you. And I will try to find out so that we can locate it.

Gabriel: Mauricio, in the dream, is it Kanobo who speaks to you or is it another “spirit”?

Mauricio: The dream directly shows me what is going to happen.

Gabriel: But is it a “spirit” who speaks through the dream?

Mauricio: It is like my protector. But I think this message he is giving me comes from above; it is God who is sending me his message. Everything that is going to happen shows me in dreams.

Mauricio represented, through a drawing, a hill over which winged figures hovered, translating the “giant poisonous plague” - a direct reference to the coronavirus. Because he could not visualize precisely the form of the plague, he suggested that I search for images on the internet, which we did together. On another page, he drew a child and wrote beside it one of the symptoms (headache), pointing with arrows to where there would be a pathogenic object (stone), indicating that it was a daño.

Figure 4.
Representation of the pandemic.

In February 2021, after being hired by a UN agency to produce trilingual material on COVID-19 and Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs) with the Warao, I invited Mauricio to a workshop, where he shared his views on these diseases. On that occasion, he described the coronavirus as a rain of fire, a “fire in the sky”: those struck by it became ill, experienced fever, and suffered bodily pain. According to him, it was necessary to “wash hands and collect garbage.” To illustrate this, he drew a divided world: on one side were those who were contaminated; on the other, those who were not. The “believers” -those who believe in “God” - were on the side without illness. The virus, translated as jebu, was divided into two types: “killer” and “good”; both could inhabit our bodies. It was necessary to have “faith” in order not to have it. Thus, the term “God” acquires multiple meanings, not limited to the Christian God.

The image of the “fire in the sky” described by Mauricio should not be understood merely as an individual elaboration about COVID-19. During the pandemic, the Warao frequently recalled the cholera epidemic that affected several communities in the state of Delta Amacuro in the 1990s, leaving deep marks on their memories. Analogies between the two experiences appeared in memories of deaths, preventive measures, and forms of care mobilized in response to the diseases: “People could not touch each other; they had to wash their hands with chlorine. Many people died” (Tardelli 2023a:325). In this sense, interpretations of COVID-19 articulated present experiences with memories of previous epidemics, in which relations with external agents, biomedical practices, and different ways of understanding illness were also involved (Briggs & Mantini-Briggs 2003; Rosa 2021a; Tardelli 2023a).

The narratives shared by Mauricio and other Warao illustrate how this group interpreted the COVID-19 pandemic through the lenses of their own cosmology, which involves the adoption and re-elaboration of Christian elements, information (and misinformation) circulating through social networks, and biomedical practices. Although they have historically maintained relations with missionaries in some of their communities - as in Mauricio’s case - the relationships between Warao cosmologies and Christianity are not homogeneous. In certain contexts, Christian elements have been incorporated and re-signified, whereas in others, particularly in processes of conversion to some evangelical denominations, tensions and forms of rejection may emerge regarding traditional practices and forms of knowledge.

Thus, rather than a simple coexistence or acceptance of multiple perspectives, these relations involve negotiations, conflicts, and different forms of religious appropriation (Vilaça 2007, 2018; Leite 2018). As Capiberibe (2017) argues, encounters between Christianity and Indigenous cosmologies should not be understood as unilateral processes of replacement, but rather as fields of transformation, dispute, and the creation of new meanings, in accordance with the historical experiences and positions of the subjects involved.

Several months before my conversation with Mauricio, I was in a shelter in Boa Vista, where I worked as an anthropologist. I was talking with someone when I noticed an unusual movement: several people were leaving the shelter, visibly agitated. Together with a colleague, I decided to investigate the reason. In the square in front of the shelter, two families were involved in a confrontation. The scene revealed a dynamic structured around markers of generation and gender: on one side, the older women of each family faced each other; on the other, the older men and daughters also participated in the dispute. Although there were episodes of physical aggression - mainly pulling hair - verbal attacks predominated, especially among the women, who spoke in Warao. During the confrontation, mother and daughter performed coordinated movements while exposing parts of their bodies, such as their arms and thighs, without, however, undressing.

The conflict began after gossip circulated: a Venezuelan woman from outside the shelter told one of the Warao women that she had become ill because the husband of another woman had sent a daño against her. Until the pandemic, I had not witnessed accusations of brujería24, but they began to appear amid a set of tensions, especially between members of different families whose relationships were already marked by hostility, although they did not always escalate into physical confrontation. As Evans-Pritchard (2005) analyzed in relation to the Azande, accusations of this type frequently emerge in situations of interpersonal conflict: the “witch” tends to be someone with whom one has some form of disagreement, whether related to affective matters, debts, or other disputes. In the shelters, everyday coexistence in highly dense spaces, combined with cases of illness, contributed to intensifying these animosities, causing previous conflicts originating in Venezuela to be reactivated in the new context.

Conversely, hunger leads to physical weakness and, consequently, fosters disease and death-a frequent occurrence in Brazil. Paradoxically, even while away from their territories and constantly on the move, they continued to assert: “We have strong bodies.” At the height of the pandemic, few believed they had contracted the virus, even those exhibiting symptoms. The possibility of infection was linked to contact with “outsiders,” whether through Indigenous people visiting health facilities or strangers entering the shelters.

For Mauricio, the plague or “fire in the sky” would not reach the Warao, either because of the local topography and winds that would drive the disease away, or because of the rituals he had performed at the four cardinal points of the shelter - although he did not describe the procedures involved. I emphasize that this was not his first dream about the pandemic; his interpretation of this phenomenon was gradually constructed through each new dream experience. Moreover, Mauricio’s dreams were added to those of other wisiratu, and even to those of Indigenous people who were not specialists in these practices. Both he and other Warao maintained connections with wisiratu living in Venezuela or in other Brazilian states.

In Warao WhatsApp groups, institutional videos circulated, warning in their own language about ways of preventing COVID-19 infection, alongside fake news - from which none of us were immune - and audiovisual records from communities of origin, including scenes of calamity, funeral rites, and the performance of the najanamu. Some of these materials were shared with me; indeed, it was the first time I observed, even remotely, the najanamu being performed. According to reports, kanobo had instructed the wisiratu in those communities to carry out the ritual to protect their communities and relatives, and, apparently, this protection also extended to those living in Brazil. Paraphrasing Vilaça (2018:59) regarding the Wari’ relationship with photographs, it seems to me that the Warao appropriated images “not in their aspect of fixity, as a mirror of the world, but of transformation, of the projection of bodies into another world, which nonetheless brings us back to shamans and their alternative bodies.”

Figure 5.
Still Image From a Video of the Najanamu Being Performed in Venezuela.

The performance of the najanamu in Roraima encountered numerous challenges, especially in the shelters of Operação Acolhida. First, it depended on institutional authorization, which did not always allow practices not foreseen in the regulations governing these spaces, such as funeral rites, which were rarely authorized. Another obstacle was the limited knowledge of Pacaraima and its surroundings; although they were located within the São Marcos Indigenous Land, an area with extensive buriti groves, they did not know the exact location of the palms and were uncertain whether they had permission to collect them. It is worth remembering that the moriche palm is a central element of the najanamu, not to mention the other objects and spaces required for the ritual.

However, this did not prevent them from attempting to perform the ritual, even if inadequately. On June 17, 2020, while still working as an anthropologist at the Pintolândia shelter in Boa Vista, I experienced a situation that I consider relevant to share. At that time, the two Indigenous shelters in Roraima were managed by the Fraternity - International Humanitarian Federation, in partnership with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR). Although its members referred to themselves as missionaries, Fraternity was not an officially recognized Catholic religious community, such as religious brotherhoods or orders. Among them were “nuns,” “sisters,” and “friars,” all wearing garments like those of Catholic religious figures: habits and tunics. The missionaries promoted activities described as “recreational,” “spiritual,” and “cultural” within the shelters.

On that day, during the pandemic, two “sisters” who organized conversation circles about Warao stories and songs in a space reserved for handicraft production encouraged Indigenous women to perform the najanamu. They then dressed in their colorful traditional dresses, normally worn at festivals and dances. The handicraft space, with its wooden floor, was appropriated as a jojonoko, the symbolic center of the ritual space. In the absence of a jatabu - a structure made of two crossed poles that supports ritual objects - they improvised using an empty plastic soda bottle. Since there was no yuruma, they placed a small Warao basket on top of the bottle, with its opening turned downward. Only women participated; some men watched and recorded the scene on video, as did I. One of them took on the role of wisiratu, holding a small maraca, while others took turns dancing with her. The chants and sound of the maracas were frequently interrupted by laughter, especially among the younger women. The atmosphere resembled a simulation more than a traditional ceremony, almost like a game.

Figure 6.
Simulation of a Najanamu in an Indigenous Shelter.

At the end of the dance, the lighthearted atmosphere was quickly replaced by tension. Men and women expressed their dissatisfaction. Some elderly women reprimanded those who had participated in the attempted performance of the ritual. For them, the najanamu could not be treated as a joke, nor could it be performed in an improvised manner. One of the reasons was the absence of yuruma, an indispensable element for the performance of the ritual: without it, kanobo could feel offended and, instead of offering protection, cause epidemics. Moreover, only kanobo, through the mediation of a wisiratu, could determine the appropriate moment for carrying out the ritual, which had not been observed on that occasion. The use of the maraca outside the proper ritual context was also identified as a problem. Faced with the warnings of the elders, the women who had participated in the dance showed apprehension and agreed with the observations.

Some final reflections

Before concluding this article, I propose some reflections based on theories of ritual, a fundamental theme in Anthropology, initially devoted to the analysis of extraordinary religious phenomena but which, over time, came to encompass multiple events present in contemporary societies (Peirano 2002). According to Turner (2017), rituals are privileged loci for observing structural principles and moments of rupture, crisis, separation, and reintegration - non-rigid stages of what he called social drama, that is, conflictual processes that, while they may contribute to the restoration of social cohesion, also create opportunities for structural transformations and changes. It is a critical and creative moment, one that enables possibilities of transformation. As we have seen, the najanamu is performed both in situations of crisis, to appease the “spirits,” and in situations in which crises are anticipated - as the wisiratu is warned through dreams - being fundamental for restoring or preventing the rupture of order in its broadest sense: cultural, social, ecological, and cosmic.

Regarding ritual efficacy, Tambiah (2014) argues for the need to reconcile the structural properties of symbolic systems with the efficacy of symbols in bringing people together and regulating behavior. For him, magical language intensifies everyday language: it is performative and dramatized. The efficacy of ritual derives from its performative character, whether as a conventional act, an intense communicative performance, or a reference to shared values. This means that, in rituals, words (and gestures) are not merely symbolic expressions without consequences, as they have effects in the empirical world, provided that they are uttered by socially authorized subjects and within the appropriate context. In the situations described above, we observed that the najanamu performed by women at the request of the “sisters” did not achieve the effects expected of such rituals and could also produce undesirable consequences. Conversely, the performance of the najanamu in Venezuela, following local precepts, and the possibility of remote participation through videos seem to expand the ritual’s efficacy beyond national borders.

As Tambiah (2014) proposes, rather than starting from rigid definitions of rituals, anthropologists should identify what the groups under study themselves recognize as rituals. From this perspective, the author observes that these practices usually present certain recurring features, such as organization, collective participation, distinction from everyday activities, and connection to specific cosmologies that guide their performance. Peirano (2002), in turn, argues that rituals, as culturally elaborated symbolic systems of communication, constitute forms of thinking and acting endowed with social efficacy. More than merely reflecting a cosmological order, they condense and intensify aspects of social life, becoming privileged spaces for the production and renewal of shared meanings.

In this sense, I understand that rituals are not only guided by cosmologies but also contribute to their continuous re-elaboration, incorporating historical experiences and internal and external factors affecting groups. The data presented here show that Warao shamanism has undergone - and continues to undergo - profound transformations in response to different historical processes, among which stand out the invasions of their territories, successive epidemics, and the effects of state, extractive, bodily, and moral borders (Tardelli 2026). In my view, in light of Bonilla’s (2005:55) observations on the Paumari, the transformational shamanic power and the cunning of the Warao experts function as vital strategies for neutralizing and managing aggression from external agents that threaten their existence.

Pérez Gil (2024) emphasizes that, even in the face of colonial, missionary, and capitalist incursions over more than five centuries, shamanisms re-emerge, in diverse and strengthened forms, precisely where they seemed to have been eradicated. For the author, it is highly adaptable and dialogical, open to the incorporation of diverse practices, techniques, ideas, and agents, while simultaneously expanding and establishing new connections. From this perspective, although the constant displacement of the Warao imposes obstacles to the reproduction of their ways of life, they also encourage actions to confront these adversities, such as the use of social networks and audiovisual productions for the circulation of information, collective mobilization, and the reaffirmation of identity. Remote participation in rituals, such as the najanamu, constitutes one of these strategies of creativity and resistance. However, ethnographic data show that such innovations do not dispense with observing the principles that give meaning and efficacy to the ritual.

We are therefore faced with a structure of the conjuncture where meanings are in constant transformation through historical practice. Contrary to a “pessimistic” view, even in contexts of contact, the groups with whom we work possess agency and respond creatively to the advances of “development” and “progress” (Sahlins 1996). However, “sentimental pessimism” should not be replaced by “sentimental optimism,” at the risk of ignoring that power relations are historically asymmetrical and produce inequalities. The Warao have developed their own strategies to confront the pandemic and deal with regimes of (im)mobility and life outside their territories. This, however, does not exempt the State from its responsibility to guarantee their rights, including the provision of public policies suited to their cultural specificities, such as access to differentiated health services. After all, these processes unfold amid frequent episodes of violence and death, whose consequences often exceed the possibilities of intervention available to shamans.

References

  • ALARCON, Daniela Fernandes et al. (2022), “A gente precisa lutar de todas as formas”: povos indígenas e o enfrentamento da Covid-19 no Brasil São Paulo: Hucitec Editora/Abrasco.
  • ALLARD, Olivier. (2010), Morality and emotion in the dynamics of an Amerindian society (Warao, Orinoco Delta, Venezuela) Cambridge: Tese de Doutorado em Antropologia Social, University of Cambridge.
  • ALLARD, Olivier. (2025), « Évangéliser une terre inhabitable: les Capucins face au défi du Delta Amacuro (Venezuela, XXe siècle) ». Social Sciences and Missions, vol. 38, nº 1-2: 129-159.
  • AMARAL, Maria Virgínia Ramos. (2019), Os Ingarikó e a religião Areruya Rio de Janeiro: Tese de Doutorado em Antropologia Social: Museu Nacional/UFRJ.
  • AMOROSO, Marta. (2006), “A primeira missa: memória e xamanismo na Missão Capuchinha de Bacabal (Rio Tapajós 1872-82)”. In: P. Montero (org.). Deus na aldeia: missionários, índios e mediação cultural Rio de Janeiro: Globo.
  • ARELLANO, Fernando. (1986), Una introducción a la Venezuela prehispánica Caracas: Universidad Católica Andrés Bello.
  • ARTICULAÇÃO DOS POVOS INDÍGENAS DO BRASIL (APIB). (2021), International complaints dossier of Brazil’s Indigenous Peoples - 2021 Brasília: APIB.
  • BANIWA, Gersem José dos Santos Luciano. (2017), “Língua, educação e interculturalidade na perspectiva indígena”. Revista de Educação Pública, Cuiabá, vol. 26, nº 62/1: 295-310.
  • BARCELOS NETO, Aristoteles; PÉREZ GIL, Laura; RAMOS, Danilo Paiva. (2024), “Introdução: o xamã como criador e transformador de mundos”. In: A. Barcelos Neto; L. Pérez Gil; D. P. Ramos (org.). Xamanismos ameríndios: expressões sensíveis e ações cosmopolíticas São Paulo: Editora Hedra.
  • BARÉ, Suliete. (2021), “Território, luta e resistência: uma abordagem a partir da ciência dos povos indígenas”. In: M. Zelic; A. C. Zema; E. Moreira. Genocídio indígena e políticas integracionistas: demarcando a escrita no campo da memória São Paulo: Instituto de Políticas Relacionais.
  • BARRAL, Basilio de. (1979), Diccionario warao-castellano, castellano-warao Caracas [Universidad Católica Andrés Bello].
  • BASSO, Ellen B. (org.). (1977), Carib-speaking indians: culture, society, and language Anthropological Papers of the University of Arizona, nº 28. Tucson: The University of Arizona Press.
  • BENLLERA, Lucas de. (1979), Los Guaraos en la etnología y en la historia de las religiones Caracas: [s. n.].
  • BONILLA, Oiara. (2005), “O bom patrão e o inimigo voraz: predação e comércio na cosmologia Paumari”. Mana, Vol. 11, nº 1: 41-66.
  • BRIGGS, Charles L.; MANTINI-BRIGGS, Clara. (2003), Stories in the time of cholera: racial profiling during a medical nightmare Berkeley; Los Angeles; London: University of California Press.
  • BRUNELLI, Gilio. (1996), “Do xamanismo aos xamãs: estratégias Tupi-Mondé frente à sociedade envolvente”. In: E. Jean Matteson Langdon. Xamanismo no Brasil: novas perspectivas Florianópolis: Ed. da UFSC.
  • CAPDEVILLE, Júlia. (2021), Llegar, estar e salir: da Venezuela ao Brasil Brasília, DF: Dissertação de Mestrado em Antropologia Social, Universidade de Brasília.
  • CALAVIA SÁEZ, Óscar. (2018), “Xamanismo nas terras baixas: 1996-2016”. BIB - Revista Brasileira de Informação Bibliográfica em Ciências Sociais São Paulo, vol. 87, nº 3: 15-40.
  • CAPIBERIBE, Artionka. (2017), “A língua franca do suprassensível: sobre xamanismo, cristianismo e transformação”. Mana , vol. 23, nº 2: 311-340.
  • CARROLL, Rory. (2013), Comandante: a Venezuela de Hugo Chávez Rio de Janeiro: Intrínseca.
  • DAS, Veena. (1995), Critical events: an anthropological perspective on contemporary India New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
  • DAS, Veena. (2020), Vida e palavras: a violência e sua descida ao ordinário São Paulo: Editora Unifesp.
  • DIEGO, José Díaz. (2008), “El delta indígena: los Guaraúnos del Orinoco en la etnografía del obispo Turrado”. Espaço Ameríndio, Porto Alegre, vol. 2, nº 2: 152-177.
  • DOUGLAS, Mary. (2017), Pureza e perigo São Paulo: Perspectiva, 2ª ed.
  • EVANS-PRITCHARD, Edward Evan. (2005), Bruxaria, oráculos e magia entre os Azande Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar Ed.
  • FACUNDO, Ángela; SANTOS, Rita de Cássia Melo. (2024), “The commonplace period of expulsions: frameworks for Warao migrations during the COVID-19 pandemic in Natal, RN, and João Pessoa, PB”. Vibrant: Virtual Brazilian Anthropology, vol. 21: 1-32
  • FASSIN, Didier. (2016), La razón humanitaria: una historia moral del tiempo presente Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires: Prometeo Libros.
  • FASSIN, Didier; PANDOLFI, Mariella. (2010), “Introduction: military and humanitarian government in the age of intervention”. In: D. Fassin; M. Pandolfi (ed.). Contemporary states of emergency: the politics of military and humanitarian interventions New York: Zone Books.
  • GALLOIS, Dominique Tilkin. (1996), “Xamanismo waiãpi: nos caminhos invisíveis, a relação i-paie”. In: E. Jean Matteson Langdon. Xamanismo no Brasil: novas perspectivas . Florianópolis: Ed. da UFSC .
  • GALLOIS, Dominique Tilkin (org.). (2005), Redes de relações nas Guianas São Paulo: Associação Editorial Humanitas: Fapesp.
  • GARCÍA-CASTRO, Alvaro A. (2006), “Migración de indígenas Warao para formar barrios marginales en la periferia de las ciudades de Guayana, Venezuela”. In: F. Represa Pérez (coord.). De Quito a Burgos: migraciones y ciudadanías Burgos, España: Editorial Gran Vía.
  • GARCÍA-CASTRO, Alvaro A. (2018), “Los Warao en Brasil son refugiados, no inmigrantes. Cuestiones etnológicas y etnohistóricas”. Périplos: Revista de Estudos sobre Migrações, vol. 2, nº 2: 32-55.
  • GARCÍA-CASTRO, Alvaro; HEINEN, Dieter H. (1999), “Planificando el desastre ecológico: impacto del cierre del caño Manamo para las comunidades indígenas y criollas del Delta Occidental (Delta del Orinoco, Venezuela)”. Antropológica, nº 91: 31-56.
  • GEERTZ, Clifford. (2014), “A religião como sistema cultural”. In: C. Geertz. A interpretação das culturas. Rio de Janeiro: LTC.
  • HEINEN, Dieter H. (2009), The kanobo cult of the Warao Amerindians of the Central Orinoco Delta: the nahanamu sago ritual Berlin: Lit Verlag.
  • HEINEN, Dieter H.; LAVANDERO, Julio. (1973), “Computación del tiempo en dos subtribus warao”. Antropologica, nº 35: 3-24.
  • KOPENAWA, Davi; ALBERT, Bruce. (2015), A queda do céu: palavras de um xamã yanomami São Paulo: Companhia das Letras.
  • LAFÉE-WILBERT, Cecilia; WILBERT, Werner. (2008), La mujer Warao: de recolectora deltana a recolectora urbana Caracas: Fundación La Salle de Ciencias Naturales, Instituto Caribe de Antropología y Sociología.
  • LANGDON, Esther Jean. (1999), “Representações do poder xamanístico nas narrativas dos sonhos Siona”. Ilha, Florianópolis, nº 0: 35-56.
  • LEITE, Tainah Leite. (2018), “Mudando de ideia: cristianismo evangélico e festas de caxiri entre os Ninam do Alto Mucajaí”. Mana , vol. 24, nº 3: 216-246.
  • LEZAMA, Paula Vásquez. (2020), País fuera de servicio: Venezuela de Chávez a Maduro México: Siglo XXI.
  • LIMULJA, Hanna. (2022), O desejo dos outros: uma etnografia dos sonhos yanomami. São Paulo: UBU Editora.
  • MARÉCHAL, Clémentine; VELHO, Augusto Leal de Britto; RODRIGUES, Milena Weber; BUENO, Pietro. (2020), “Transformações sociais e (re)territorialização Warao no Brasil: a trajetória de uma família frente à pandemia de Covid-19”. Espaço Ameríndio , Porto Alegre, vol. 14, nº 2: 46-87.
  • MÉNDEZ, Manuel A. Pulido. (1945), “Los franciscanos en Venezuela”. Venezuela Misionera, año VII, nº 79: 241-244.
  • MONTERO, Paula. (2006), “Introdução - missionários, índios e mediação cultural”. In: P. Montero (org.). Deus na aldeia: missionários, índios e mediação cultural . Rio de Janeiro: Globo .
  • OLIVEIRA, João Pacheco de. (2016), O nascimento do Brasil e outros ensaios: “pacificação”, regime tutelar e formação de alteridades. Rio de Janeiro: Contra Capa.
  • OLIVEIRA, João Pacheco de. (2021), “A nação tutelada: uma interpretação a partir da fronteira”. Mana , vol. 27, nº 1: 1-31.
  • PATAXÓ, Samara. (2025), Povos indígenas e justiciabilidade: a advocacia indígena como estratégia para aldear direitos Rio de Janeiro: Lumen Juris.
  • PEIRANO, Mariza. (2002), “Rituais como estratégia analítica e abordagem etnográfica”. In: M. Peirano. O dito e o feito: ensaios de antropologia dos rituais Rio de Janeiro: Relume Dumará, Núcleo de Antropologia da Política/UFRJ.
  • PÉREZ GIL, Laura. (2024), “A pedra, o sopro e o ‘vegetal’”. In: A. Barcelos Neto ; L. P. Gil; D. P. Ramos (org.). Xamanismos ameríndios São Paulo: Hedra. p. 327-355.
  • POBLADURA, Fray Pacífico de. (1976), Herores: 50 años de trabajo y promoción humana León, España: Delegación de Propaganda de Misiones Capuchinas León.
  • RAMOS, Alcida Rita. (1990), Memórias Sanumá: espaço e tempo em uma sociedade yanomami São Paulo: Marco Zero; Brasília: Universidade de Brasília.
  • RIVIÈRE, Peter. (2001), O indivíduo e a sociedade na Guiana: um estudo comparativo da organização social ameríndia São Paulo: Editora da Universidade de São Paulo.
  • ROSA, Marlise. (2021a), A mobilidade Warao no Brasil e os modos de gestão de uma população em trânsito: reflexões a partir das experiências de Manaus-AM e de Belém-PA Rio de Janeiro: E-papers.
  • ROSA, Marlise. (2021b), “‘Isso é uma emergência!’: panorama da mobilização da Articulação dos Povos Indígenas do Brasil (APIB) para o enfrentamento da Covid-19”. Espaço Ameríndio , Porto Alegre, vol. 15, nº 2: 60-97.
  • ROSA, Marlise. (2022), “A campanha de vacinação contra a Covid-19 em povos indígenas: exclusões, mobilização social e protagonismo das mulheres indígenas”. In: D. F. Alarcon et al. (org.). “A gente precisa lutar de todas as formas”: povos indígenas e o enfrentamento da Covid-19 no Brasil . São Paulo: Hucitec.
  • ROSA, Marlise; TARDELLI, Gabriel; ROA, Sebastian. (2024), Os Warao no Brasil: contribuições da antropologia para a proteção de indígenas refugiados e migrantes Brasília, DF: Agência da ONU para Refugiados (ACNUR), 2ª ed.
  • ROSA, Marlise et al. (2024), “Práticas de autoatenção warao no enfrentamento à pandemia de COVID-19 em Manaus (Amazonas, Brasil)”. Anthropologica, vol. 52: 11-33.
  • SAHLINS, Marshall. (1997), “O ‘pessimismo sentimental’ e a experiência etnográfica: por que a cultura não é um ‘objeto’ em via de extinção (parte I)”. Mana , vol. 3, nº 1: 41-73.
  • SCHWARCZ, Lilia Moritz; STARLING, Heloisa Maria. (2020), A bailarina da morte: a gripe espanhola no Brasil São Paulo: Companhia das Letras .
  • SØRHAUG, Christian. (2012), Holding house in crazy waters: an exploration of householding practices among the Warao, Orinoco Delta, Venezuela Oslo: Unipub.
  • SZTUTMAN, Renato. (2005), “Sobre a ação xamânica”. In: D. T. Gallois. Redes de relações nas Guianas . São Paulo: Associação Editorial Humanitas/Fapesp.
  • TAMBIAH, Stanley Jeyaraja. (2014), Cultura, pensamento e ação social: uma perspectiva antropológica Petrópolis, RJ: Vozes.
  • TARDELLI, Gabriel. (2021), Yakera jakitane saba nonate/Para construir uma vida melhor: abordagens sobre saúde sexual e reprodutiva e enfrentamento da violência baseada em gênero com o povo Warao Brasília, DF: Fundo de Populações das Nações Unidas.
  • TARDELLI, Gabriel. (2023a), Entre o poder colonial e a razão humanitária: sobre modos de gestão da população Warao Brasília, DF: Tese de doutorado em Antropologia Social, Universidade de Brasília.
  • TARDELLI, Gabriel. (2023b), “Os caminhos dos Warao: configurações dos deslocamentos entre Venezuela, Brasil e Guiana”. Espaço Ameríndio , vol. 17, nº 1: 341-370.
  • TARDELLI, Gabriel (2025a), “Operation Welcome: an analysis of power relations between military personnel, humanitarian workers and indigenous peoples”. Vibrant: Virtual Brazilian Anthropology , nº 22: 15-44.
  • TARDELLI, Gabriel. (2025b), “The Warao at the crossroads: conflicts and moralities in the indigenous shelters of Roraima”. Anuário Antropológico, Brasília, DF, vol. 50: 1-23.
  • TARDELLI, Gabriel. (2026), “Exiled from their own lands: indigenist policies, oil, and colonial plunder in 20th century Venezuela”. The Journal of Latin American and Caribbean Anthropology, vol. 31, nº 2.
  • TAYLOR, Kenneth I. (1996), “A geografia dos espíritos: o xamanismo entre os Yanomami setentrionais”. In: E. Jean Matteson Langdon. Xamanismo no Brasil: novas perspectivas . Florianópolis: Ed. da UFSC.
  • TERENA, Luiz Eloy. (2022), Povos indígenas e o judiciário no contexto pandêmico: a ADPF 709 proposta pela articulação dos povos indígenas do Brasil Rio de Janeiro: Mórula.
  • TIAPA, Francisco. (2007), “Las relaciones interétnicas entre los Warao de la frontera noroccidental del Delta Orinoco durante la época colonial”. Trocadero, nº 19: 215-228.
  • TURNER, Victor W. (2013), O processo ritual: estrutura e antiestrutura Petrópolis, RJ: Vozes , 2ª ed.
  • VILAÇA, Aparecida. (2007), “Indivíduos celestes - cristianismo e parentesco em um grupo nativo da Amazônia”. Religião & Sociedade, Rio de Janeiro, vol. 27, nº 1: 11-23.
  • VILAÇA, Aparecida. (2018), Paletó e eu: memórias de meu pai indígena São Paulo: Todavia.
  • VIVEIROS DE CASTRO, Eduardo. (2024), “O mármore e a murta: sobre a inconstância da alma selvagem”. In: E. Viveiros de Castro. A inconstância da alma selvagem São Paulo: UBU.
  • WILBERT, Werner; LAFÉE-WILBERT, Ayala. (2009), “También somos gente. Cambio cultural paradigmático warao”. Anthropos, vol. 104, nº 2: 423-444.
  • ACNUR. Populações indígenas refugiadas e migrantes no Brasil Brasília: ACNUR, 2026. Disponível em: https://app.powerbi.com/view?r=eyJrIjoiMjlmNzdiODctYjMwZC00NjkzLWI0YzctY2VmZDdjYzJmMDQxIiwidCI6ImU1YzM3OTgxLTY2NjQtNDEzNC04YTBjLTY1NDNkMmFmODBiZSIsImMiOjh9 Acesso em: 07/07/2026.
    » https://app.powerbi.com/view?r=eyJrIjoiMjlmNzdiODctYjMwZC00NjkzLWI0YzctY2VmZDdjYzJmMDQxIiwidCI6ImU1YzM3OTgxLTY2NjQtNDEzNC04YTBjLTY1NDNkMmFmODBiZSIsImMiOjh9
  • GUIMARÃES, Cátia; PASSOS, Juliana; ANTUNES, André. (2025), “5 anos de Covid-19 no Brasil: um balanço do legado da maior crise sanitária da história do país”. Escola Politécnica de Saúde Joaquim Venâncio, Fiocruz, 25 fev. 2025. Disponível em: https://www.epsjv.fiocruz.br/noticias/reportagem/5-anos-de-covid-19-no-brasil Acesso em: 28 out. 2025.
    » https://www.epsjv.fiocruz.br/noticias/reportagem/5-anos-de-covid-19-no-brasil

1

This work results from the postdoctoral research conducted at the Departamento de Antropologia da Universidade de Brasília (DAN/UnB), with funding from the Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES), through a fellowship awarded under the Programa Institucional de Pós-Doutorado (PIPD). Part of the data analyzed here was collected during the period in which I was affiliated, as a visiting researcher, with the Departamento de Antropología Social y Psicología Social da Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Spain, under the supervision of Prof. Alberto Fidalgo Castro. I thank him for his hospitality and suggestions, as well as the other members of the Grupo de Investigación en Antropología, Medio Ambiente y Economía (GAME), especially Professors Paula Escribano and Laura Pérez Gil.

2

The Guianas constitute a historical and ethnographic region extending beyond contemporary national borders. In anthropological literature, the region is often approached as a cultural area characterized by long-standing interethnic relations, shared social institutions, and comparable cosmological frameworks, although marked by considerable internal diversity.

3

UNHCR, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. Indigenous refugee and migrant populations in Brazil. Brasília: UNHCR, 2026. Available at: https://app.powerbi.com/view?r=eyJrIjoiMjlmNzdiODctYjMwZC00NjkzLWI0YzctY2VmZDdjYzJmMDQxIiwidCI6ImU1YzM3OTgxLTY2NjQtNDEzNC04YTBjLTY1NDNkMmFmODBiZSIsImMiOjh9. Accessed: July 7, 2026.

4

Pacaraima is located within the São Marcos Indigenous Land, a territory traditionally occupied by the Macuxi, Taurepang, and Wapichana peoples. The presence of the municipal seat within this territory remains marked by legal controversies and land conflicts.

5

Part of the data analyzed in this article was developed from my professional experiences as an anthropologist, which have included, among other activities, coordinating an Indigenous shelter, training Indigenous leaders, contributing to the development of public policies, and providing consultancy services to produce bilingual publications on Indigenous health. Over the past six years, I have worked in different Brazilian states and in the Co-operative Republic of Guyana, conducting anthropological assessments of the situations faced by Warao families and communities. In parallel, I have carried out research with the Warao during my doctoral and postdoctoral studies, independently of my contractual affiliations.

6

Operação Acolhida is organized around three main pillars: (1) border management, (2) reception and shelter (acolhimento), and (3) voluntary relocation (interiorização). The first pillar involves the reception, identification, health screening, immunization, migration regularization, and triage of newly arrived migrants. The second pillar refers to reception and shelter, that is, the provision of accommodation for Venezuelans - including Indigenous people. The Portuguese term acolhimento has a range of connotations that extend beyond ‘receiving’ or even ‘welcoming’ to imply protection and care (offering shelter). The third pillar concerns the relocation of these individuals from the state of Roraima to other states in Brazil (Tardelli 2025a, 2025b).

7

Brazil’s redemocratization refers to the political process through which the country transitioned from the military dictatorship (1964-1985) to a democratic regime. This gradual process involved political reforms, the restoration of civil liberties, the return of direct elections, and the promulgation of the 1988 Federal Constitution, which established the legal and institutional foundations of Brazil’s contemporary democratic order.

8

Established in the Senate on April 27, at the initiative of Senator Randolfe Rodrigues (Rede-AP), the Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry (CPI) aimed to investigate both the actions and omissions of the federal government in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, as well as possible irregularities in the transfer of public funds to states and municipalities. After nearly six months of work, the senators presented the final report on October 21, 2021, recommending charges against 66 individuals and holding then-President Jair Bolsonaro accountable for nine crimes.

9

Arguição de Descumprimento de Preceito Fundamental (ADPF) is a constitutional legal mechanism in Brazil that allows the Supreme Federal Court to assess violations of fundamental constitutional principles. ADPF 709 addressed the protection of Indigenous peoples during the COVID-19 pandemic.

10

Warao terms may present spelling variations in the anthropological literature because of different transcription systems, authors’ orthographic choices, and, in some cases, linguistic variations among communities and regions. Thus, the same word may be recorded in different forms, such as wisiratu and wisidatu. In this work, I preserve, when appropriate, the spellings used by the sources and interlocutors.

11

The border was closed in March 2020, in the context of the measures adopted by the Brazilian government to contain the spread of COVID-19. The restriction was initially established by Interministerial Ordinance No. 120 of March 17, 2020, which temporarily restricted the entry of foreigners arriving from Venezuela into Brazilian territory.

12

Yuruma, gusano, and ocumo chino are foods consumed by the Warao people. Yuruma consists of a flour produced from the starch extracted from the inner tissues of the trunk of the buriti palm (Mauritia flexuosa). The term gusano refers to the insect larvae that inhabit the same palm species and are incorporated into Warao dietary practices. Ocumo chino (Xanthosoma sagittifolium), a tuber introduced into Warao territories through historical processes of exchange and contact, was subsequently incorporated into their dietary practices.

13

Throughout the article, interlocutors’ statements and other direct quotations are translated into English to facilitate readability.

14

Venezuela Misionera was founded in January 1939 by the Capuchin friar Cayetano de Carrocera (Álvaro Rabanal González, 1892-1971), who also served as its first director. Conceived as a publication to disseminate Catholic missionary activities and promote studies on Indigenous peoples of Venezuela, it was the first periodical in the country devoted to publishing research on Indigenous literature, ethnography, and linguistics produced by Capuchin missionaries.

15

Cartographic and bibliographic sources from the colonial period - even when produced retrospectively - used the spellings “Guaraos” or “Guaraúnos,” which represent Spanish adaptations of the word Warao.

16

A swamp or wetland ecosystem dominated by the moriche palm, found primarily in South America.

17

In some Operação Acolhida shelters, despite the provision of meals, wood-burning stoves were installed without necessarily involving prior consultation with the communities (Rosa, Tardelli, and Roa 2024). Although the Warao expressed a preference for preparing their own food, obtaining firewood to operate these stoves presented challenges, including the risk of extracting wood from environmentally protected areas.

18

Regarding the Areruya religion, see Amaral’s doctoral dissertation (2019).

19

Kapon and Pemon are two Indigenous ethnolinguistic groups of the Guiana Highlands, each encompassing different Indigenous peoples. Their ancestral territories are located mainly in the Guiana macro-region, particularly in the tri-border region of Brazil, Venezuela, and Guyana.

20

The term shaman is used here as an analytical translation of wisiratu. Although it shares some features with broader anthropological understandings of shamanism - particularly forms of mediation with nonhuman beings through dreams, healing practices, and specialized knowledge - the category wisiratu refers specifically to a Warao specialist and should not be understood as identical to the broader comparative concept of shaman.

21

According to Barral’s dictionary (1979:324), the root naja—which forms part of the ritual’s name—exhibits broad polysemy in the Warao language, spanning various semantic fields: a) material culture and the botany of the buriti (moriche) palm, referring to the “palm stalk or stem”—an essential raw material used to craft harpoon shafts, sails, fishing floats, and festive ornaments; b) weather phenomena, signifying “rain” (and appearing in expressions related to the end of the rains or to seasonal rains associated with local flora); c) anatomy, designating the “nape of the neck” or “neck tendons”; d) verb forms, functioning as the verb “to clean oneself” (or, in certain dialects, “to be afraid”); and e) morphological structures, serving as the past participle of the verb “to kill” (“killed” or “that which was killed”) or as a verbal suffix for the negative present tense.

22

Although the Warao and the literature use the term “torta de yuruma” in Spanish, we have opted here for “bread” due to its similarity to the expression “pan de moriche.” It is a dense, baked dough made from buriti starch, and its preparation process is similar to that of beiju or casabe made from cassava, which is common among various Amazonian peoples.

23

According to Benllera (1979), the ritual painting of participants is carried out with the aid of a wooden cylinder carved with geometric patterns and soaked in a pigment extracted from a plant fruit. The object is then rolled across the body, creating semicircular designs on the back and chest, which are subsequently complemented by horizontal lines connecting these marks.

24

Although derived from the colonial Christian lexicon, the category “brujería” (witchcraft, in English) has been reinterpreted by the Warao to reflect their own conceptions of the body, health, and illness. Far from the pejorative Western connotation, this concept encompasses the processes of illness and healing mediated by ritual specialists, the unleashing of daño (spiritual attacks), and the actions of non-human entities, such as the jebu.

Data Availability Declaration

Not applicable.

Editor-in-Chief:

Edilson Pereira

Guest Editor:

João Leal

Assistant Editor:

Lucas Bártolo

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    02 Oct 2026
  • Date of issue
    2026

History

  • Received
    31 Oct 2025
  • Accepted
    17 June 2026
location_on
Instituto de Estudos da Religião ISER - Av. Presidente Vargas, 502 / 16º andar, Centro , CEP 20071-000, Tel: (21) 2558-3764 - Rio de Janeiro - RJ - Brazil
E-mail: religiaoesociedade@iser.org.br
rss_feed Acompanhe os números deste periódico no seu leitor de RSS
Ir para o topo